The True Face of the Taliban | ARTE.tv Documentary

[@artetvdocumentary]

Watch next 😮 Mexico: The Cartels Switch to Fentanyl I ARTE Documentary kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJjUln56i9mCl7c

[@rodrigoalmanza66]

@ricardo-2022; Right, it's the West's Double Standard.

[@procommenter5094]

Yup, I totally agree with you, the west biggest shame and beginning of ending started from Afghanistan...it's the true that they are fighting against with such a double standard illusiinal journalism!

[@aburovsen5942]

Salam Aleykum və Rehmetullahir və berekatuh Taliban ☝️🤲🤗🌹💓

[@AdilKhan-i4w4j]

Why you ever made a video on manipur incidence.....girls forcefully naked by mob and march naked in street....I know you will never make a video.

[@artetvdocumentary]

We have forwarded your suggestion to our editorial team.

[@rominalizada7365]

I remember going to Afghanistan a year before Taliban take over and in Kabul we couldn’t go outside after sundown because thieves would kill and take our money, couldn’t use our phone outside, couldn’t tell anyone that we are coming from the US , in my own country . Surprisedly I went back after Taliban take over and everything was opposite , we were out until 11 , 12 o’clock at night , no problem at all …

[@Travelwithshafiq]

that's right but unfortanatly the propoganda that is going on even me i tought that the taliban were very diffrent but when i see them now i wish that they were in the past 20 years then Afghanistan would be in much better level

[@asadmughal5484]

west only have propaganda to show an islamic govt in bad sense they dont want that there is any islamic govt in the world

[@clarkporter1340]

Then y don't we see more ppl from Afghanistan online since d Taliban took over? Is dat Afghans(especially d women) don't like d Internet?

[@rominalizada7365]

@@clarkporter1340 Thanks to their western friends do you know how much it cost to use internet? People use internet to study online classes, those who can afford, not to use onlyfans lol or propaganda KZbin videos

[@Val_kyriee]

Go back and stay there then.

[@Sultan-gr5tk]

They totally misinterpreted the words of the Imam in madrassa at 9:56. He wasn't even talking about conquering and martyrdom. He was talking about Ijtehad, which means deriving rules for various matters based on Quran, and Sunnah, ...

[@ghrbaa6727]

Yes. The way they lie straight to your face is abhorrent.

[@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1]

BMA I was feeling they are lieing about things! Though I do not understand the language!! Hvr it's nothing new, this is how hypocrites operate & amongst the Americans there are some biggest hypocrites!!!

[@AteequllahGhaznawi]

Exactly!!!!!!!!💕

[@JuicyTobacco]

Basing rules on religions and archaic books is brainwashing, so kinda a conquer of the minds. So not really a misinterpretation

[@Azamat-eq2rq]

Not even surprised, it's expected . These piece of junk journalists have only come to spread another lies about Islam.

[@cityclips8479]

Bombing the country for 20 years and expect them to like you 😂

[@wmasculinity]

Fact hahahahah

[@stokism2353]

They should give binladen to us if they really want save their millions of people .

[@zoybean]

@@stokism2353 They said they would give Osama if the US offered evidence of Osama's involvement. USA's response was "We know he's guilty." Osama was never even on the FBI's wanted list for 9/11, they never mentioned it.

[@Ron-Lfc10-163]

True story that

[@RahilKhan-io8bz]

@@stokism2353 Bin laden is funded by US to fight against Russia . Binladen was a paer of US network of terror . Bush must be punished in ICC . But hahaha ICC wil punish Bush noway

[@haronsamim7711]

OMG I can’t believe how they mistranslated a lot of stuff. The teacher in Madarasa was taking about the day of judgement and they were translating cutting hands off.

[@artetvdocumentary]

Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!

[@mohdyousuf2796]

It's cut off video in between..use your common sense

[@CumaBisaHayabusa]

dont worry we muslim from SEA support afganistan❤❤

[@wasiahmed6176]

​@@artetvdocumentary😂 good try you propagandists

[@ziaulhoque5988]

We Muslim and wise people understand very well. This is West media propaganda about Islam. Russia, American killed soo many afgan children, women that is not issue. Still Israel is killing philistine infant kidd no need to mention addult. There is no issue for west media. Hipocracy of west.

[@raza3378]

10:33 He said "yamal qiyamah" That means the day of judgement Translation says "These direction must be followed"

[@havetrustissue8975]

After Taliban take over poppy production reduced by 99.9% in Afghanistan where 80% of total world production were produced before Taliban take over. And 95% of Europe's heroin were supplied from Afghanistan which is now totally stopped. This simple action alone should be applauded and recognized and Europeans should be grateful to Afghan to save their future generation. But you concern about film, drama. freedom for nakedness etc.!

[@Goodmorning-oj5mn]

Наркотики как поставляли так и поставляют

[@itxmfahadkhan]

Freedom for Nakedness 😂

[@badbassnine]

They probably make this neagtive propaganda because they don't want independent countries in charge of themselves and messing up the Western governments continued war of drugs which is a joke that just makes governments money and makes us loads of junkies through legal or illegal drugs..

[@thegreatest1176]

how about al qaed's leader??

[@Ali-fc1bv]

@@thegreatest1176dead. At an al zawahri was killed.

[@MinhazulArefinAbtahi]

They totally misinterpreted the words of the Imam in madrassa at 9:56. He wasn't even talking about conquering and martyrdom. He was talking about Ijtehad, which means deriving rules and Jurisprudence for various real life matters based on Quran, and Sunnah. The imam in Madarasa was also talking about the day of judgement and they were translating as cutting hands off.| Such hatred and biasness!!

[@aimanmarzuqi4804]

Wait really? I wish I understood the language. Then I would know if that is true or not.

[@zaki0938]

​@@aimanmarzuqi4804they admitted they mistranslated

[@alidurrani4645]

Exactly, I am a pashtun myself and i was shocked to see the translation lol such blatent lies.

[@mixstuff3d]

You proved that the Taliban`s point of view about western media is right 😂

[@zzzz9513]

Exactly, when you listen to the journalist you feel there is fanatic dogmatic terrorism taking place

[@odeysoomaaliyeed]

Pure propaganda 😅

[@AAT786]

It's not about Western or Eastern media. The truth is that the Taliban is a racist and terrorist group which now oppresses and kills Afghans. No single country is willing to recognize these terrorists and human rights violators, not even their Arab supporters. That speaks for itself.

[@carlojimeneztrader]

Right!? Hahaha the irony

[@Sultan-gr5tk]

@@carlojimeneztrader Even the background music lol

[@mohammada1562]

As a journalist I should say it is a journalistic sin to get your report influenced by your own opinion or that of your media outlet vested interest. Unfortunately we see these type of reports from majority of Western journalist, which is clearly disgusting and disgraceful to the profession of journalism.

[@nashriaelmoda8414]

Lets not expect fairness from westerners media.

[@bogdanbogdan3462]

Gimme a break, those are savage dictators with no respect for basic human rights,

[@bogdan6768]

​@@bogdanbogdan3462But i am totally disgusted by the western brainwashing news. "Everybody must think like this, otherwise you are old fashioned "

[@TBfilms657]

I can agree in principle but I have to askl you, where are you a journalist? And also they clearly try to stage a show for the journalists and she is not even allowed to enter some buildnings being a woman so they have no sympathy from me

[@guineanguy5406]

dear @mohammada1562 i agree with ur opinion. im about to go to afghanistan myself to get an unbiased neutral view. if ur interested id like to talk to you

[@molwelang]

Taliban actually handling the situation much better than I expected 🙏

[@zenlob]

bc this is the first channel that shows who the taliban really are

[@odd_shoes]

Except children are starving to death and girls being sold to paedophiles and rapists.

[@Jason-fg9wn]

@@zenlob That is a lie :)

[@phoenixrising8640]

@Jason-fg9wn no matter how much u troll and lie...majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government now. We don't care whether u accept this or not. We hated u foreign invader terrorists. We are happy that u were sent running by our Taliban and we are now safe, at peace, free and ruled by our own. As much as u wish for regime change, just remember, that Taliban will always win and have majority support...history repeated itself and will always repeat itself in Afghanistan. Afghanistan is not a US colony, state or playground, nor is it your house where u have a say so go to hell, your time is up foreign invader terrorist. We hated u foreign invader terrorists and are sick of your interfering...oh, and don't bother accusing me of being a Talib, I'm just am ordinary Afghan civilian.

[@guydreamr]

They can't even keep the lights on.

[@moeorya309]

Lots of mistakes in the translation: e.g. 10: 08- 10:13. The teacher is saying as long as there is suffering (caused by an issue/even) there can be ijtihad (meaning... analysis and a diligent judgment on the issue). The word Ijtehad is used for new ruling to address contemporary issues that arise in society.

[@Lonesome__Dove]

We need public punishment in the USA. Crime is out of control and we are just getting softer on crime. I support public punishment 100%.

[@franciscouderq1100]

…..eh eh, the “Dove” has spoken.

[@ashikislam8370]

iraq, syria and libya destroyed by your country. can you destroy saudi? i f you do. your time will end. saudi arab following sharia law. which is follow afghansitan

[@mahnoorimran2470]

Human rights will catch you on your ideas

[@Lspixel]

That is why we say and repeat Islam and Sharia for all, when a person kills another person, he should be publicly executed, when a person rapes a girl, he should be publicly flogged or death sentence depend on cases , When the sentence is carried out publicly, everyone who tries to commit a crime will thinks twice before he does it. sadly most islamic countries not apply Sharia Whoever talks about human rights tell him what happens if someone kills one of your family , sure he will demand the death sentence

[@RomansMentalHealthAssociation]

@@mahnoorimran2470 morals are subjective

[@VillageSimpleLife]

Afghanistan is the safest place on earth after Taliban take over, I have visited multiple time they are very nice people and their hospitality is on another level. And don't listen to media what they are saying. Media is calling them Terrorist because they protect their country against invaders that's the only issue. ( And in this video their translation of many words is totally wrong they are not even saying that what you are showing on screen)

[@memritvdeutsch7526]

So why don't you and all the Afghans go there and stay?

[@VillageSimpleLife]

I am not Afghani, I am Pakistani and i visited Afghanistan about 10 times and spend months there, and will visit soon again in coming month.

[@memritvdeutsch7526]

Ah, you live in Pakistan? Which country is more safe and peaceful? Pakistan or Afghanistan?

[@VillageSimpleLife]

@@memritvdeutsch7526 Afghanistan is more safe and peaceful than Pakistan.

[@kbyvillepika3741]

Stop bullshiting! Every Friday there used to be a terrorist attack by the ISIS khorsan on Shia minorities right after their takeover. And they didn't close down universities after indecent acts! They closed even all-girl schools because they believe that in pashtun traditions, once a girl reaches puberty, she should be immediately married off without consent through coercion. They can't publicly utter many of their perverted beliefs because the world would consider them even worser than they already are. This is a regime that celebrates suicide bombers.

[@slickperspective]

Wow, okay. Why hasn't there been a documentary about "The True Face of the US Government"? I'm a content editor for a company I work with. People must know that documentary videos like this are usually HEAVILY edited, especially for "agenda" purposes.

[@carlosdangerfield9477]

Did you also talk about crippling sanctions and freezing of afghan assets?

[@thegreatest1176]

and they didnt talk about that 40 million per week from infidels

[@carlosdangerfield9477]

@@thegreatest1176 Thank god, you believe it.

[@asharahmad1068]

​@@thegreatest1176ya first impose sanctions then freeze their 7 billion dollars then send foreign aid to show that you care😂

[@yt98833]

That asset is actually aid money of US and other countries. That does not belong to the Taliban in first space.

[@Omer1996E.C]

@@yt98833 you don't have evidence for what you're saying, this is Afghan money from their central bank don't lie we're tired of you

[@sarfrajansari166]

You were not there for honest reporting, You went to show everybody Negativity about them.

[@JuicyTobacco]

Like there is anything positive about them..

[@rominalizada7365]

@@JuicyTobacco If you lie and misinterpret , add extra words and leave some parts out is kinda fishy and someone with brain 🧠 should come to conclusion that they are not telling you the truth

[@JuicyTobacco]

@@rominalizada7365 I agree with you, but i was aiming more about what positive things can religious extremist bring? We cannot properly progress as society as long as religion has it's fingers in politics and public opinion.

[@m60tsabra24]

​@JuicyTobacco if this is extremistm I don't know what is Iran

[@JuicyTobacco]

@@m60tsabra24 Even stronger one, but extremism or not, religion shouldn't have any place in public opinion and governing.

[@thatsgoodmoney3485]

These comments bring my faith in humanity back, thank you everyone for being critical and not believing everything they put out

[@scottgleeson4905]

So, do you work for Tehran, Kabul or Moscow?

[@vernonrev6642]

She's not a journalist. She's a critic.

[@Destroyruss]

Yes. Taliban is good. Much more Heroin, much more Gras, woman in cage. Well done

[@Travelwithshafiq]

@@Destroyruss heroin is banned in Afghanistan again it was alowed before the the taliban took over the power in 2021 and in 1996 till 2021 it was banned it was a huge business for the Nato soldiers narcotics

[@lungsfull]

@@Destroyrusshow delusional can you be

[@jeeefthegreat7555]

Hope you're living there and enjoying the fruits of all of the Taliban's great work.

[@Val_kyriee]

So go and live in kandahar then. You can comment from there about how you live islamic fanatics 😂

[@muhammadisoul]

The Amarat e Islami Afghanistan is true sign of justice, peace and fighting for the right. May Allah almighty bless them always and help them in promoting true picture of Islam throughout the world.

[@Jason-fg9wn]

No. No.

[@phoenixrising8640]

@Jason-fg9wn Yes. As long as we feel this way...u, a foreigner has no right to dictate to us Afghans. Majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government now. It was you foreign invader terrorists we hated.

[@veerainhegde9375]

But it's citizens will be malnourished and poor forever. Taliban will never be able replicate a successful society in the modern era.

[@Goodmorning-oj5mn]

Да проклянет их Всевышний 😂

[@Jason-fg9wn]

Same group who says "God is great" before blowing themselves up, setting off an IEDs, and while they're shooting RPG's. The taliban in afghanistan are actually satanist who use the name of God in vain while committing sin. Their God is the devil.

[@puenoune9316]

As a former warrior. I wish nothing but Peace and Harmony to Afghanistan.

[@KgVgv]

Former warrior??😂😂😂😂

[@khalilkhud1623]

The peace and harmony not only in Afghanistan will be but every Muslim countries only if America leaves us alone

[@14vsoplot]

@@KgVgvhe was probably a soldier dumbass

[@nstnst8007]

@@khalilkhud1623 ah yes the so called peace you know what yes i hope the west leaves you guys so, so we can see what that peace looks like my guess pure dogshit

[@Timtam99]

@@khalilkhud1623 why not let the women speak?

[@proofofmyexistence2352]

I think that Afghanistan's economy is suffering because of foreign sanctions not because of the Taliban. The Taliban is not some foreign or Alien group. It's made up of Afghans who stood up to resist foreign occupation. The fought the Americans like their fathers fought the Soviets. It doesn't matter if it's the Americans or the Soviets or the British. For us all of them were foreign powers trying to enslave us. We resisted all of them and we were victorious. So far the Taliban government has proved to be capable. The crime rate has been falling down since they came in power. It's gotten more safer. Also drug addicts have disappeared from the streets. I believe that Afghanistan has great potential. We have a young population and large mineral resources especially of lithium. The only thing we lacked was stability and a strong government. Democracy won't work everywhere especially in Afghanistan. Now we have a strong and a stable Government. I think our government should follow the example of Vietnam. Just like Afghanistan, Vietnam was also invaded and destroyed by the US. However, today Vietnam has one of the fastest growing economies in the World.

[@cityclips8479]

True

[@akhan6778]

Well said brother Ma'sha'Allah 👏🏼

[@Sekaisansen]

As long as there are people in power who want to cut the hands because of stealing something we will remain as low and stoneage like as we are

[@mohsenarafath]

❤❤❤

[@problem4643]

LOL Taliban is proxy of Super Powers. They are like a toy. USA can use them against Iran and vice versa. Day is not far when you people will go back to your homeland.

[@Dudenier]

Afghans have decided they prefer this government. Western countries should keep out of it unless you want to fight another 20 years of war

[@Freefiretube123]

Afghans didn't choose, CIA put them for their next move and they are temporary

[@clarkporter1340]

​@asahitoki3228defeat u say but 🇺🇸keeps carrying out air strikes in Afghanistan at will

[@Azzam_Alqudsi]

@@clarkporter1340 and youre proud of that? you're proud of OUR tax money funding the opium war overseas and sending our boys to fight in war made by capitalists.

[@cccbb89767]

No issues with leaving this country like it is.. but please explain why afghans are fleeing to Europe… we didn’t ask them to come here. Obviously they don’t like the talibans and they want a change in your country. Take care of that and show that you are capable running a country. Otherwise you failed.

[@alemir1975]

Afghans did not decide this! All these bushmen leaders have been trained in the USA and it was time for them to go back to that poor country to make life a hell for the people!!!

[@ChadBrahh]

The thing I admire about the Taliban is public punishment. You don't need to follow a law book that has a bail system written by some liberal 100 years ago. You punish criminals and keep your country safe. When people know there will be consequences, they behave. Something I wish India would adopt someday.

[@Omer1996E.C]

@aqeel-3771 didn't you hear it? It's mostly religious with some culture laws, nothing else. Previous Country laws were called international laws, they don't exist now

[@Sniperboy5551]

Something I wish we would adopt here in the US. It would be nice to reduce our prison population, by any means necessary.

[@ananyasingh6719]

Its amazing how women are stoned to death for apparent cheating and how they thing that a crime like domestic violence doesn’t exist.

[@Omer1996E.C]

@@ananyasingh6719 lol, even men are stoned to death And this rule only works only if 4 people saw you having sex (and with evidence) and only if you're already married. This rule is very rarely applied

[@LarryVasquez82]

How do you find 4 witnesses when you're abused lol. Women's voice already worth 1/2 in islamic court, and now she should find 4 witnesses of her abuse. It's sad to see women who born in such vile region. No right for education, to work, just to be sold/married of to some creep and serve till the rest of her life. It's crazy to see people (usually men) who defend the barbaric way of thinking. Do you guys don't have mother? Sister? Daughter? How could you guys be so heartless and justify treating women as 2nd class citizen?

[@MushtaqqAhmed]

Making of this video itself speaks volumes about how safe and sound Afghanistan has become now.

[@Oblivisci........]

They made videos like this before top, remember?

[@adventuregemssydney2219]

As someone who knows this place intimately, and its people, this documentary did it's absolute best to portray them in their own light. The propaganda undertones are significant, but won't be picked up by the average viewer who is neutral.. They failed to mention the state of chaos and lawlessness the taliban reigned in, and that people can now live in peace and harmonyy. And you complained about not being given a fair chance to film and ask the questions you like. Well that is specifically because of this reason, your whole aim was misrepresentation and propaganda. You don't deserve a fair interview. Don't give any ground to liars, they will manipulate your honesty against you. The taliban's suspicions about your intentions were 100% spot on.

[@jaktaboss4414]

You right

[@akhan6778]

Well said 💯💯👏🏼

[@kharnyrasool6501]

💯 % 👍

[@Sekaisansen]

They can live in Peace ok not so many suicide bombs by IS anymore, but please if u really know this place there is millions starving right now women are worthless again kids are at home (Girls) no work no nothing, before there was work economy prospered Little By little. What is so Good about one-ethnic leaders? Yes they do Good things and deeds too, BUT they arent optimal good leaders. Lost senseless faces, fake religious, still being controlled by pakistan. Ofc the west uses propaganda to make islam bad, but if taliban are the real public figure for islam, no one wanna be muslim.

[@odd_shoes]

They may live in peace (no/less crime), but A LOT of children are starving to death or getting sold to be married by men three times their age. I wouldn't call that the usual/west's definition of peace and harmony.

[@beniadam6028]

4:13 He said "I have no right give my opinion." Means that Law is above my personal opinions. And there you start playing emotional music, like seriously!!!

[@y.6948]

it's media.. I can only imagine how much editing this went through just to try to make the afghan people look bad, and they failed. The media is truly the mouth of the devil

[@alilodhi2039]

Play with ur barin aka CNN lol

[@cityclips8479]

😂😂😂 Fr

[@Thigamabob]

Its music, you don't need to cry over it.

[@beniadam6028]

@@Thigamabob makes me laugh instead

[@ab_-pk9xe]

the translation of the part where he talks about women is very wrong--most probably intentionally.

[@usmansultanzai8963]

I agree

[@mdhasiburrahman8806]

Propaganda man they always try to put propaganda on Islamic things.

[@phoenixrising8640]

This is normal for them

[@KnowledgeFactory800]

Just like Andrew Tate says (they film 8 hours and then take out only five minutes to make me look bad) they’ve played with translation, editing and added voiceover to Somehow demonise Taliban but people are starting to realise how biased mainstream media is

[@uncle___ben]

So what does he actually say?

[@asim-gandu-phenchod]

When are you going to make a documentary on the war crimes committed by NATO, US and Australia?

[@thegreatest1176]

after they finish the documentray of suic1de attacks and terr0rism by tolib

[@มะสารีนัน]

😅😅😅

[@Oblivisci........]

Yeah because the Taliban have always been innocent and just, huh? 😂

[@Lonesome__Dove]

Are the people happy? Are they provided for? Thats all i care about....I support any country that honors its traditions and values. Aftwr decades of attacks from western countries i can understand anger. And their women seem to be very valued and protected. Western ideology isn't all its cracked up to be....its actually quite disgusting at this point. I hope the people of Afghanistan are happy, truly. That is all.

[@Thigamabob]

All are "happy" trust me.

[@MrvelvetviruS]

You better be happy...

[@Bambino2440]

@@why66_77Women in the west are a slave to their own vanity and male approval

[@Islamunitedpeople]

A true muslim is happy and peaceful. We invited you to study islam.. :)

[@yt98833]

​@@Islamunitedpeopleignorance is bliss for most of them.

[@luqmankhilji1]

30% of the Video in which Pashto speaking and English translation are not matching.

[@cityclips8479]

Women - poverty- any small bad things will be shown as big issues- welcome to western media 😊

[@Lonesome__Dove]

Meanwhile the women in America are miserable single and being replaced by men in skirts.

[@MC-ng2gp]

Uh no, women are allowed to work and go to school in civilized countries.

[@truthboom]

yes because, Women can't control money their own right, their own freedom, treated like slave with no freedom is call small bad things

[@asharahmad1068]

​@@truthboomand what do you mean by freedom? If you mean immoral things then keep it to yourself. We saw what your freedom did and now you ppl have onlyfans😂

[@truthboom]

@@thedictationofallah How does that contradict my statement, Wife got dowry(Mahr) Money Once in a lifetime and the rest the husband controls the money. Why would he take a penny from the wife after divorce when all the money is at the husband. Which part am i lying?

[@khansaiful115]

Love to the brothers and sisters of Afghanistan, I pray that Allah will strengthen the Taliban, inshallah, Afghanistan is a very beautiful country, only the western world spreads fake news to defame Muslims. Love to Afghanistan from Bangladesh.

[@phoenixrising8640]

Thank u Brother. Come and visit.

[@akhan6778]

Aameen 🤲🏼 in'sha'Allah

[@Jason-fg9wn]

Incredible how you show love to one country and completely shit on another with lies. And you claim to pray? Where is the truth in you?

[@phoenixrising8640]

@@Jason-fg9wn he is telling the truth. All facts in what he said. Why are u so bitter? U beat u fair and square.

[@Jason-fg9wn]

@@phoenixrising8640 You are no one to define the truth. I am not bitter at all, liar. Screw your head on properly.

[@stephenmachipi9708]

I'm not privy to the Taliban's operations except what I was told by Western Media. But knowing how the West deal with those who do not take instructions from them, I'm interested in learning about the true Taliban.

[@shershah3827]

@@hasinarian6711no maybe u are Muslim but not frome Afghanistan my family lives there and they had never seen a government wich do the work what other governments sud have done it they are working on everything straight up so keep ur advice to ur self and never talk shit about my country and the women education they are working on it they are building new schools wich the western media will never tell u so never believ those devils western media

[@Thigamabob]

The truth is that taliban is as violent as isis. I'm telling you as someone who isn't from a western country.

[@shahzebahmedkhan2313]

@@hasinarian6711 You're saying this as someone completely uneducated about your own religion. Also Would dare call the Barbaric Americans as Civilised? I dare you to even say so

[@حسينمحمد-غ1ص3ع]

True Taliban is word of God. Islam that is how we were living since 1400 years ago the question is why US tried to invade to Afghanistan?

[@Adam-wz6hz]

Afghanistan is what it is because of Islam.Sometimes what is good for is difficult to swallow. Take medicine for example. It's taste is often unpleasant but it succeed in giving relief.As outsiders westerners see the Taliban as an oppressive regime.But they are delivering what society needs ie peace,stability and reduced crime rate. It works for them because the overwhelming majority are Muslim. For us who are western orientated to derive benefit from the Islamic way of life we have to take a step to liberate ourselves from the desire to slavishly fulfil our impulses. If we accept this the the doors are open to a better life.Otherwise our desire to be free will be the thing that will forget enslave us. Good luck

[@nabilaferoz5937]

No one can add or delete any thing too Shariah as all muslims believes, learn and practice the Book of Alla'h Al Quran through the sunnah of our beloved prophet Mohammed PBUH, since childhood in formal schools and at home everyday.

[@odd_shoes]

"In formal schools..." unless you are a girl.

[@m60tsabra24]

​@@odd_shoesYou lack average knowledge

[@Thigamabob]

@@m60tsabra24 Yes, there is no "protecting women", you enslave them. In the west, you make fools out of them. Both 2 extremes.

[@Robert-mw5tp]

@@odd_shoes. You have understanding of a zombie.

[@lurdkatmin3298]

@@odd_shoes Girls have never been banned from religious schools, only secular UN propaganda schools

[@arsalanahmadws]

Finally NATO and American terrorists' are out, Taliban defended their land like nobody! Prosperity to Afghanistan.

[@curiouscat5229]

It really seems safe. May peace prevail in Afghanistan.

[@kodvavi150]

​@@hasinarian6711Afghan feminists*

[@asharahmad1068]

​@@kodvavi150pseudo western feminists

[@S5ugarfr33]

What do you mean? IT IS safe. Damn, you guys WISHED it wasn’t safe. Jealousy at its peak cos you ain’t got a country rich in resources 🤣🤣🤣

[@qawali2207]

For me it's the most important thing, that they defeated nato America indian Pakistani Russian army. They are brilliant. They are bosses.

[@AAT786]

That was not the terrorist Taliban. They only killed Afghans.

[@relaxg1727]

😂

[@AmericaButcherofHumanity]

No, Gandhi is

[@Jason-fg9wn]

Go back to school and get a refund.

[@witchilich]

There was no Indian army in Afghanistan.

[@ismailamiri8650]

Women’s in Afghanistan are just simply happier than women’s in Europe and America. Present government in Afghanistan is just a gift from Allah to all muslima umma alhamdulillah

[@Thigamabob]

Yeah all the unhappy women can't speak up or else 😂

[@ismailamiri8650]

@@Thigamabob fine, for those women we have mental health support to help

[@thegreatest1176]

thyere soo happy living in home prison hahah

[@humzahardy1212]

​@@thegreatest1176 and the western women are also trapped in homes making disgusting only fans.

[@Bob-zs3ro]

I did not type the word don't. So who did????????????????????

[@tolgai.altunova5858]

After this documentary, I will plan to travel to this beautyful country. Because I will feel safe.

[@Jason-fg9wn]

Pure delusion.

[@realgamer5636]

@@Jason-fg9wn yeah, invading a foreign country and bombing the innocent while targeting their freedom fighters in the name of "liberation" is the opposite of delusion. you westerns are the responsibility of the most world troubles, from Vietnam to palestine, palestine to iraq, iraq to syria, syria to Afghanistan. if you did not invade or colonize the world, there would not be such troubles.it's easy to judge sitting behind a monitor, and tha'ts what you're doing.

[@ziaulhoque5988]

I possible i also want to migrate to Afghanistan.

[@Jason-fg9wn]

@@ziaulhoque5988 No one cares 🙂 Instead of talking about it, go; Move there. And see the taliban for the evil incarnated group they are. You should put north korea as your plan B for when the taliban ultimately come to take what you've got.

[@ismailzulfiqar9554]

Islam is best and you will find a new life , come out of the devil tricks which is made by west💚

[@VICTORIOUSAFGHANS227]

THIS IS THE LAND OF THE BRAVE ❤

[@rob9528]

Land of the slaves.

[@phoenixrising8640]

@@rob9528 nah, all the US and NATO foreign invader terrorists slaves and traitors ran away...now we are free of any slaves and independent. We true Afghans are slaves to no one.

[@ArifIbnSayed3]

@@rob9528 the slaves who fxcked US, NATO, USSR.🤣 But you liberal people act like puppet 😃

[@rob9528]

@@phoenixrising8640 You are slaves to islam and your allah.

[@Jamuna-Atma]

And men with small dicks who have to treat women as less than.

[@sarayfernandez-sf3kv]

Afghanistan is a beautiful country with beautiful peoples long life to Afghanistan and he's people!

[@Jamuna-Atma]

It's not he's

[@borntorebel333]

@@Jamuna-Atma - it just proves that was one of the Taliban commenting and he didn't even know how to spell his lies, lol

[@Saifullahkhan10024]

@@borntorebel333 what lies some taliban can speak better than you after all some taliban worked with Americans as spy of talibans

[@borntorebel333]

@@Saifullahkhan10024 hush, even your Quran tells you to lie to your wives, unbelievers and the enemy!!!! The true God said ''thou shall not lie'' full stop, no special occasions, lol You are liars and your next stop is hell for all of you....

[@Jamuna-Atma]

@@borntorebel333 exactly. And saying something about crocodile tears in one of the comments. No intelligence whatsoever.

[@rominalizada7365]

90 percent of the translation was wrong , leaving some parts out, adding things extra…

[@artetvdocumentary]

Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!

[@beleiver12]

@@artetvdocumentary then please correct them otherwise people could be misguided

[@paintingwithterrie5171]

That's because our American media does nothing but lies, lies, lies! Biden family is being brought up on treason for taking millions from international governments to stuff in their own pockets at the expense of my American people. Justice will be served soon. Keep watching for it.

[@paintingwithterrie5171]

​@artetvdocumentary that's another lie lolol. Media does nothing but lie and you know exactly what you're doing!

[@rominalizada7365]

@@beleiver12 You think they are going to fix it ? 😂 don’t be a kid

[@jijafaizi]

ARTE: You went all the way to the Afghanistan to document and tell lies to the world about Afghanistan? It's very shameful. Let me be honest with you, Afghanistan is secure, united and moving forward. Afghanistan people wants the western world not to interfere in our internal affairs because currently our wounds are healing. Peace! ❤️

[@thegreatest1176]

go khordi lowda, talib is a terr0rist takfiri group that massacred 10000s of people

[@marianabashirullah1391]

What about female education n progress

[@jijafaizi]

@@marianabashirullah1391 some opened and some opening.

[@naqibkhan4071]

​@@marianabashirullah1391women education will start as well when the have worked on mechanism, they don't want intimate scenes taking place in the name of education and in universities.

[@folegionnaire4404]

I’m a Brazilian revert Alhamdulillah, if only the west could wake up with the snap of a finger and realise that when these guys say the hijab etc really is there to protect women they mean it.

[@emmanuelsilvestre7956]

😂😂😂

[@emmanuelsilvestre7956]

Go and move there 😂

[@folegionnaire4404]

@@emmanuelsilvestre7956 maybe, moving to a whole new country isn’t something you do instantly, I’ve been thinking moving to Saudi or Malaysia but I’ll visit them all before I decide.

[@Thigamabob]

@@folegionnaire4404 Better get out of brazil before your people try to wage jihad over there also.

[@osamamahmoud2493]

​@@folegionnaire4404God bless you man and welcome to Islam my brother 🎉

[@slowliving2041]

Lady, one hand cut punishment done in public will deter 1000 thieves wannabe from executing their criminal act. The cheapest, the most effective method for gov to maintain order, no need for prison and all expenses associated with it.

[@proofofmyexistence2352]

Thanks to that the crime rate has fallen drastically especially in big cities like Kabul and Kandahar.

[@truthboom]

It doesn't apply to the top elite branch who control the country. Crime? No proof haha Crime proof? Buried it

[@vidasarwari]

Taliban already have built a new schools for girls. There is also was problem with acts of terrorism in girls schools with non taliban organization ISIS-K(2021,2022). Were created women police forces and created a new work spaces for women engineers. Excuse my english

[@zaidsyed8187]

The issue isn't whether schools are being built. Plenty of universities already exist. It's simply that the supreme leader is even more radical than most of the Taliban officials that want women's education since he does not and will not allow it. Also, even when they open up their schools, they're not gonna be teaching liberal arts or STEM. They might teach a little math and a little elementary science, but they'll only really teach shariah as they do at their madrasahs currently for men.

[@phoenixrising8640]

@zaidsyed8187 stop talking nonesence. They know what these things need to be taught in Afghanistan and will be taught for our female doctors, nurses, teachers etc to be able to do their jobs.

[@courierton9217]

Who you to talk about their woman. They will take care of their woman. Piss of

[@truthboom]

Nonsense. They were spreading poison on school for girls

[@Timtam99]

@@phoenixrising8640 the point of segregated schools is to teach different things. Otherwise, why segregate the men from the women? All schools aren't equal, its likely that these girls schools will only teach them basic stem, arts and politics while the majority of teachings is going to be radicalized brainwashing.

[@moeasmal2071]

May Allah swt accept the Taliban and grant Afghanistan aafiyah

[@AnthonySmith-hl2pq]

Ameen

[@majumahkamanzi5448]

not while women are still living in fear and are oppressed!

[@moeasmal2071]

@@majumahkamanzi5448 This world is temporary. Why trade the eternal life for a little of this temporary world. The West have confused you with the meaning of oppression

[@majumahkamanzi5448]

@@moeasmal2071 ok, if thats how you see injustice than ok

[@Omer1996E.C]

@@majumahkamanzi5448 yes, leave us alone, you have problem with our mindset? Keep your human law in your country, we have absolute rule of law

[@Buhamad-l5n]

"The True Face of the Western Media" Me after watching this documentary!

[@قدرتمند-ز8غ]

Since the day the Taliban came, the economy has collapsed, 90% of people are unemployed and have no food to eat, former soldiers are tortured, imprisoned and even executed. No one is allowed to go to school or university. Protesting women are arrested and imprisoned and raped in prison. Cultures and languages ​​are being destroyed and the genocide continues. They destroy non-Pashtun tribes, expel them, take their lands and houses by force and give them as gifts to Pashtuns………more others and everyone was silent🤐🤐

[@wmasculinity]

Ohhh really This is from ur pokect but Where were you in old government Lol. God exposed of ur fake propagandas

[@princessanineveh]

You should upload videos of the schools, universities, and market places built by the westerners in 20 years of not an invasion of a foreign country. Should be an easy task.

[@ixiixiixiixiixi]

@@princessaninevehare you claiming that nato and USA did not build infrastructure in Afghan? There’s plenty of evidence fool

[@clovenshield3067]

“The economy collapsed” yes because the US tax payer was bankrolling their economy for 20 years when Karzai and Ghani was in charge

[@natrajm324]

Such a biased documentary. Journalism has to be unbiased.

[@Azzam_Alqudsi]

this isnt journalism, it's Western reporting

[@concernedhomosapien9807]

@@Azzam_Alqudsi Its a shithole, whether its West, East, North or South reporting it.

[@mueenkhan2294]

It yellow journalism

[@user-nu4um2gr3d]

The Taliban beat America, so why do Americans live so much more comfortable as Taliban or Afghans? Please Explain.

[@Dominicn123]

@@user-nu4um2gr3dLmao when they did ever beat America?! Because I remember how America beat the taliban’s ass so hard two decades ago that they ran off with their tail between their legs!!! And then America was able to occupy and help build Afghanistan for two decades, and then when America left the other year, the Taliban came running back to power. Not once did the Taliban EVER pose a threat to American occupation 😂😂😂😂 And to answer your question of why Americans can live much more comfortably: it’s because America moves forward and a progressive lifestyle, while the Taliban has ruined Afghanistan because they try to live like how people did 400 years ago……they allow a book that was written thousands of years ago dictate life in the modern day, and they don’t even know who the true author was!! 😂😂😂

[@gauravtejpal8901]

Love to the Afghan people 💕 May they prosper 🙏

[@truthboom]

You meant Afghan *Man* Woman is not allowed to prosper in Afghan 💀 Parents treat their children as tools

[@yt98833]

If you keep half of your population under walking tent...how can your prosper.

[@มะสารีนัน]

❤❤❤😊😊😊

[@mrcelebrityfactsofficial]

Ma shaa Allah, crime has decreased during the Taliban regime, and justice prevails. Only that, the education system for girls is in progress. I believe this is for their benefit. Hopefully, the Taliban government will continue to adhere to Sharia Laws. In shaa Allah, this country will prosper as an example of implementing the laws of Allah for the betterment of mankind. Sending love from the Philippines. :-)

[@skrizwanullah4366]

13:12 good approach by students ♥️♥️♥️

[@barqodahabiya7483]

I'm happy for our Muslim brothers

[@Oblivisci........]

Not Muslim sisters though, right? 😂

[@yashaofsauga]

"afghanistan's future seems to be weaker than ever" is the sentence that she chooses to communicate at the very end of this video which thus legitimizes all of the apprehension they had about her presence there white women need to be concerned about the future of their own societies and whether or not they will exist as a species in 30 years.

[@rougeslushie2956]

Those poor Afghan women. Men ruin everything.

[@proofofmyexistence2352]

Lol yes the birth rate is falling rapidly and the Western Governments are doing nothing to increase it. In fact they're doing the opposite by supporting abortion and career obsessed women.

[@NahintheW]

based

[@Thigamabob]

To be fair, both sides are clowns.

[@jahangirsamtio8690]

True

[@sarfrazkhan1300]

The childrens treated you the way you deserved 👏

[@ahmedxaziz2960]

Why the orientalist music in the background and why the spooky sounds when a government official is interviewed. Does this also happen when they interview putin, Biden or other officials

[@youtubehodol3989]

based people from based country

[@ziggyc3004]

Those who fail to remember history are doomed to repeat it.

[@yokul8886]

This is not new footage. This footage is at least 1 year old and was already published here before.

[@hussainchaser1661]

I LOVE YOU AFGHANISTAN & PAKISTAN. Both countries Sacrificed a lot. Wish you all the very very best AFGHAN.

[@Oblivisci........]

Yeah, they sacrificed their own people for their own gain. Pakistan and slavery go hand in hand.

[@rowshansharjil]

Ow my brothers may Allah glory your reign. May there be peace , may Allah make Afghanistan self sufficient, may Allah make the land of Afghan fertile. May Allah helps to keep that land in Sharia.

[@Sultan-gr5tk]

Wow. Many mistranslations and deliberate misconstructions throughout the video.

[@artetvdocumentary]

Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!

[@capitaljustice7324]

after invading for 20 years and introduced foolish culture,drugs feminism , mass murders now “they don’t like us coming hear “ 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@common-sense99]

but its stupid teaching hate to children.its damaging your future prospects.

[@kiadav9529]

@@common-sense99 lol killed their family and friend and ask not to hate them, your logic is implacable i say

[@common-sense99]

@@kiadav9529 read mandela's story.i did not say 'love them' but hate and revenge will get you to your doom.

[@kiadav9529]

@@common-sense99 easier said when it`s not your family 6 under

[@common-sense99]

@@kiadav9529 india did not get here sitting and hating british and islamic invaders. or israel is not fighting germany now.

[@rominalizada7365]

I recommend you guys to watch ( Afghanistan the great game ) part 1 and part 2 , you’ll understand fully what’s going on in that country and why we are here today .

[@akhan6778]

subhanAllah watched them videos, 👏🏼👏🏼 some people even after seeing and knowing the truth about the Taliban and the propaganda against Taliban they still want to hate on Taliban, maybe it's because they were victorious against their countries, but they don't see how their countries mistreated the afghans just to take opium drugs in their own countries to destroy their own people because they wanted to fill their own pockets with money, but they don't see how Taliban were actually trying to get rid of drugs and all Poppy fields but Unfortunately the Taliban still get a bad name because of the western media propaganda!!

[@HistoryOfRevolutions]

Taliban are warriors who defeated the American Invaders. Alhamdulillah

[@humzahardy1212]

Not just Americans the NATO.

[@reginaangell5327]

It was Allah, subhannahu wa t'aala who defeated them. He allows or disallows. He defeats it provides victory. Death in fighting for his way is martyrdom where he is saying I'm satisfied with your efforts and sacrifices for me.

[@words1983]

Western world vandalized Afghanistan for decades and now they are talking about Justice 😂

[@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman]

bad translations don't help

[@syed_saif_aljamal]

Why don't you ask Israel about their open killing of Palestinians.

[@thomasalmond3311]

LONG LIVE ISRAEL🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱!!!.

[@busyraj]

what's with Toyota and war torn country anyway?

[@brando8086]

Super reliable vehicles

[@ΧριστίναΜαγουλα-β1ξ]

@@brando8086 Exactly 👍

[@hayamkhan3841]

Translation is wrong😂what media is that

[@artetvdocumentary]

Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!

[@jalilullahIshaqzai]

This is very carefully mistranslated to put words in the talibans mouth like at 10:15 the guys says where there is a challenge will be a solution but they translating it “ where there is a challenge there will be martyrs “ 🤦‍♂️

[@artetvdocumentary]

Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations

[@rominalizada7365]

I know I saw that too , man these people are so racist and against afghans they bomb innocent civilians for 20 years but couldn’t destroy us , they don’t even want us to breathe , but they come and talk about women’s rights lol it’s really funny

[@jalilullahIshaqzai]

@@artetvdocumentary as long as it was not done out of ill intentions then absolutely no problem 👍

[@AwfulDog1]

If that post is correct it is a pretty big mistranslation. Not sure why it would be so different to what was alleged to have been said.

[@paulmcgorian5712]

Well thats enough of that . What a mess .

[@lifegamerpro4033]

It's a propaganda video with prejudice narrative.... Not a documentary

[@smashville7303]

spent 15 months in Jalabad been to every FOB and bagram hundreds of times while I was in country its a beautiful country you can still see cold war era equipment in the country preserved as if the war was yesterday got hit by suicde bombers while I was there also. I loved my time in afghanistan it was a different beast fighting the taliban then when I was in iraq. Hoooooooah shout out to all my battle buddies who served.

[@TheRedMenaceUK]

You take pride as an invader?

[@mianuvoletta690]

It's like a glimpse into the Middle Ages. Every religion, every culture, every civilization has made some kind of progress - only these are not capable of it. It just annoys me that they are creeping into our civilization. Stay in those dumps of yours and don't take advantage of a civilization that has worked hard. I don't understand why we don't ban these primitives from our countries.

[@samfadi8716]

😂😂😂 you got a wild imagination, and child like thinking of the world. I am here to educate you so worry not. What makes you think that everyone wants to be like you? Or assimilate and borrow your ideas, culture etc.. You are not to be blamed, it's not your fault but the fault of the public education system that has brainwashed you for years into being a good ol slave smart enough for the slave task, dumb enough to be aware of what's moral and immoral. Countries like Afghanistan believes in the laws of God, where the western values and beliefs are man made laws and materialism worship. In conclusion, you are in no position to decide who should, do what, where and how. The days of white supremacy and their propaganda is over.

[@zenlob]

I mean, if you're doing crime whilst the Taliban are in power, you have balls of steel.

[@abdulhafiidh9728]

😂😂😂

[@mohammadsamyee3340]

Why you’re saying the future of Afghanistan is bleaker,we think the future will be better but takes time

[@abdulghani8269]

TThank you ARTE tv Docu..

[@mikidias]

Afghanistan Zindabad 🇦🇫

[@auggievu2972]

Taliban took over Afghanistan in one week ....Russia could learn a lesson.....so could Ukraine lol

[@Azzam_Alqudsi]

you mean the US took Afganistan in one week and the Taliban took 20 years to take it back

[@reginaangell5327]

You know why 15 students [Talibs] took 21 rifles and went out to take over the country don't you? Bad people defiled a woman, then murdered her, left her naked in Mullah Omar's masjid. He had to defend her honor and avenge what was done to her because they protect women.

[@hardsurface6277]

🏳️⚔️🦁.. long live the Emirate

[@Thigamabob]

White flag stands for surrending.

[@ardayilmaz8757]

​@@Thigamabobsurrendering is one of your tactics, not of ours

[@hardsurface6277]

@@Thigamabob white flag 🏳️ stands for purity of our religion Alhamdulliah

[@Thigamabob]

@@ardayilmaz8757 We never fought your war, americans did. Religious s**cide would be a more suitable term for you.

[@Thigamabob]

@@hardsurface6277 There is no "purity" in your religion, it is literally created by a pdffile muhammed who deflowered someone who was still playing with dolls.

[@yuhanayaacob4021]

Let them handle their own country. Only the people of that country know what is good for them to be safe. After years of occupation, they deserve all the happiness in the world. 💗💗💗

[@shahid8545]

Afghanistan will prosper in shaa Allah!

[@justhustle4979]

His voice is very convincing I would be surprised if he slapped a mosquito, he can easily convince me to quit internet

[@battlements7649]

It's crazy because that's about as convincing as it is for all of the other mass copy-cut clones of Md's this earth is producing. They're all for it. If you really look at every single man we saw in this entire documentary- they did not deviate more than maybe 10%, as far as personality, character and demeanor is concerned, from one another. So as such, they are all convinced. Easily. It's a very dangerous thing to have very large populations of either idiots and or no personalities or what I call, blanks.

[@abdulbasitkhan7448]

That Stronghold crusader game's sound in the background gives some real different vibes 😂❤

exactly what i thought

[@byronmorales4706]

Im a 40 year old man from a little country called Guatemala, I just want to say I wish peace for the World, for countries to stop fighting each other it's a waste of time. One love.

[@thomasalmond3311]

🇬🇹🇬🇹🇬🇹!!!.

[@Agent_0267]

Alhamdolillah. Allah blessed Afghanistan with Taliban.

[@มะสารีนัน]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@rehmanhizbullah9445]

The fact that you mentioned that no minister has visited the TV station makes no sense, why would they visit the news station? The news is made to talk about the political situation, they are not obligated for the ministers/govenment entity visits. Nor are they in anyway owing some sort of explanations, they will run the country and the news channels will broadcast the decision, that's it.

[@malikjon7619]

They can’t let them succeed as it will show a working model of sharia based society succeeding. But, these talibs are very determined people. That’s for sure. The rest of the world is suffering from uncertainty and futile issues like gender identity 😂

[@2009jadeorchid]

the west is dying the whole gender identity shows the personal weakness and narcissism

[@mycammedia]

I'm not surprised they don't like you at the madrassa - I don't either. Who is the financial backer for this 'documentary' - there is plenty of fair coverage of this issue from honest and professional journalists.

[@lifegamerpro4033]

Shame on producer of this propaganda film ...

[@ghulammujtaba5931]

I am also Muslim. and education from garrison lahore .my opinion about young pretty girls education is they have seperate university in every demanding area . Jews have money if jews really cares about women literacy rate in Afghanistan and then they should made university many many there and seperate schools from 4th to 10th class for females why not ? I read in co education in lahore . In one class boys attention divided on pretty girls rather then education. On the hand if not co . Focus remaining

[@cityclips8479]

Believe me This is not reality of Afghanistan 😂

[@Hanny-l1t]

Who are you Maasai???😒

[@cityclips8479]

@@Hanny-l1t why u Wanne know ?

[@zrolyn6367]

Not the best place on earth but way better than any major city in the US.

[@FVQ365]

Wow us is turning into a shithole

[@drrydog]

look at these 7ft ceilings in these trashy buildings lmfao.. This people group is broke AF, no lie

[@catalina1968]

How many Jews and Christians are allowed to worship in Afghanistan?

[@budgetking2591]

These poor women

[@maksudurrahman2414]

Poor women are yours. Not theirs. 🤡

[@akhlaqali1139]

I agree poor western women oppressed under liberalism

[@FATHOLLYWOODB123]

"Explosions happen even in American dance clubs" the last one to happen in America was done by a Islamic extremist subscribing to a similar philosophy as the Taliban! Someone teach them that hahaha

[@princessanineveh]

Yeah the taliban should adopt the fantasy WMD philosophy as a war pretext.