The True Story of Kitty Genovese | The Witness | FULL MOVIE | True Crime Documentary (2017)

[@rachelleisland]

Heartwrenching yet beautifully told Bill. Thank you for sharing your family, your life and beautiful Kitty with us.💜

[@FidgetyGuy]

Liberal-minded (76.8%) New Yorkers were woke before it was a word. To let a black man have his way with a woman and do nothing is about as woke as you can get.

[@nighthawktt]

Agree ⚘

[@braeutchen41]

Your sister is beautiful, Mr Genovese......I want to take this innocuous place and moment to thank you for your service to our country. I have lived my entire life in peace, raised children who didn't have to go to war and now my grandchildren are in their 30s. Thank you. Many of my friends went to war and didn't come home. I'm glad u cane home to your loved ones. And I hope you have found the Peace that passes understanding. 💔💝

[@Mpirefilms]

The footage of her dancing is everything! I love her personality. She should have been an actress.

[@carolynholland291]

Bill your commitment to finding out the truth about your sister’s murder was so courageous and a loving testament to the beauty and value of her life. Thank goodness you discovered she was comforted in her last moments by a loving friend. Your investigation revealed a beautiful, vibrant, life loving, love giving sister, daughter and friend who left a huge hole in so many lives. I also felt compassion for the murderer’s son who reiterated stories fabricated to try and explain, and lessen the terrible stigma, of having a father whose inexplicable actions had scarred his life and family too. Moseley left so many victims. I was relieved to read he had died in jail and never was released. The film is a timely reminder of the harm that can be done by journalists who let a “good” story get in the way of the truth. All the best Bill. Kitty would definitely want you to move on although she will always be journeying with you. Thank you for the film.

[@Gina19876]

You can never move on from such a heinous death.

[@gertiedinwiddie9437]

John5:28,29

[@chimi1924]

😊

[@juliomarques6741]

Kitty’s poor dog, whom she loved, being abandoned by her family and dumped out, after traveling and searching to find their home is heartbreaking! That detail broke my heart. That would not be what she wanted

[@stellabella310]

To the entire Genovese Family, Thank you for this bittersweet documentary! I could remember my mother telling me about Kitty's murder when I was about 9 or 10 years old! I cannot believe it has been almost 60 years! Times were so different then! You showed us Kitty in the flesh! She was a beautiful woman who truly loved life! This documentary is filled with every emotion....today and always I wish you love! Kitty would love her nieces and nephews and their babies! xo

[@molliemae6855]

It happened in 1964. It was 59 years ago.

[@jp-a1a729]

The monster’s son blames Kitty and seemed upset because the publicity of case keeps him from being paroled. He was sentenced to DEATH, that was overturned to LIFE, there should be NO chance of parole, EVER. I hope that monster rots in hell for for eternity. Also, I’m curious to know if he was charged with the murder of the other woman he raped and murdered.

[@stellabella310]

@@jp-a1a729 I really didn't care for him either! His arrogance came through when Bill interviewed him!

[@January.]

Being "beautiful and loving life" is irrelevant. She was a human being. Period.

[@jeannetaylor2217]

Amen to that! 💕🙏🙏

[@thursoberwick1948]

Wasn't aware of this case before (I'm not from US.) I'm aware Moseley's son is in an odd position, but his justification for his father was utterly wrong.

[@cynthiaschmidt2726]

That man should live in shame for what he said to the woman his father killed brother. Disgusting and despicable. He could have said he believed his father had changed WITHOUT blaming her or her family.

[@thursoberwick1948]

@@cynthiaschmidt2726 I agree. Even if she had used some racial slur, as the son said, that was not a justification for what happened. It was hardly a hit and run attack. The son just kept trying to deflect.

[@KimF1]

@@thursoberwick1948 - Plus, he wouldn’t admit the other woman his father killed was black. He didn’t wanna hear it, because that destroyed his “race card” nonsense.

[@thursoberwick1948]

@@KimF1 I can understand someone being conflicted by the fact his father had done such a thing, but the son clearly has issues he needs to address in himself. I agree with you.

[@theswordoftruth-dn9yc]

If only it was a sister of "that" Genovese crime family! Mosely wouldn't have made it to trial! The news media would have had a whole different story going on, if any, at least not the twisted one they did manipulate to sell papers, and to write a book!! Wow! And, I think the cops needed a cover for not responding faster! There were some holes there. Phone calls not logged on the call sheet! So then the papers blame the residents for not calling the cops, when in reality, at least three had called, only to be rushed off the line, saying it was called in already. Wow!

[@farinshore8900]

I learned how alone i am in 1979, as a victim of violent crime. There were about 20 witnesses - none attempted to help me. I have been haunted by this all of my life.

[@rifulce]

Cómo sucedió?

[@aprylrittenhouse4562]

I'm so very sorrrry.❤

[@sharonazar1]

This fact was an awakening to me.....I'm so sorry you were a victim....

[@ednaamck3831]

Yes, it is a fact that just because a person is part of a “people” out and about does not equate to “people”. coming to the aid of a person in crisis. I am sorry you were victimized with no one coming to help you.😔

[@elizabethcurcio9044]

So very sorry that u still carry that horrible event w/ u .

[@laurieowens8510]

He should never be paroled. He has never accepted responsibility for what he did to that poor woman. And, even to this day, he’s making up wild stories about how he was only the driver. There was never any mention of a car by the witnesses. Clearly, it’s just another lie he is using to try and make himself look better. He’s a sadistic murderer. I can’t believe his son is trying to get Kitty’s brother to “forgive” him and help get him paroled. A shameful family at best.

[@leverne7386]

Google him. He passed away in 2016.

[@jacquelineredstone4487]

when the son pulled out the race card and the "mob" shiiiiiit omg that pissed me off

[@AABB-bm9kk]

@@jacquelineredstone4487 That was very disappointing. That son really bought into “blame the victim” ?? - And for this case ?? - And thought the victim’s brother should buy into it, too?? 🤢 “Move on”?? Gross.

[@cynthiaschmidt2726]

@@jacquelineredstone4487 worse part is our current society is feeding into this narrative that black people are always the victim and always a victim of the evil white man. It doesn’t help at all to never make people accept responsibility for their actions.

[@elizabethjarvie6077]

He should have gotten the death penalty anyway! 🤷

[@lissaajz]

Thank you Filmrise for posting this. Hope Bill and his family is doing well.

[@January.]

*are doing well

[@byunniq9060]

​@@January. 🤡

[@lindawall6833]

​Fascinating... I hope Bill finds some peace after researching and presenting this story...🙏🙏🧡🧡

[@sharonb.7867]

So heartbreaking, but so deserving of the brother Bill to tell his sister's story as he uncover new details. Bill did an amazing job!‐-

[@cilverleaf8111]

I agree Bill ❤ heartbreaking story

[@pibly7784]

Good documentary. 👍 It goes beyond what everyone thought they knew about the murder according to the NYT article that failed to investigate further and get more eye and auditory witness interviews.

[@anno-podcasteditor2597]

That part with the actress screaming… that broke my heart… and for sure Bill’s did, too…

[@martietomlinson3986]

How could anyone ignore those screams ? How could anyone go back to bed? How sad! 😢

[@theswordoftruth-dn9yc]

Yes! That really gets the stomach churning. Gut wrenching! How sad for Bill.

[@musiclover1958]

@@martietomlinson3986 No one ignored the screams! Did you watch the documentary? EVERYONE CALLED THE COPS!

[@evilangel2918]

​@@martietomlinson3986@musiclover1958 neither of you watched it🤦🏽‍♀️😂 no, not *everyone* called the cops- many ppl heard something & thought they heard a drunk couple arguing, could not see anything when they looked out, & did not realize what was actually happening, so they didn't call. but there were also many ppl who *did* call🙄 both of y'all should try actually listening to a/o watching it, before commenting 🤡

[@corrinaosborne9390]

I cannot imagine his longing for reasoning when there's none .One of saddest stories ever.

[@jeannetaylor2217]

This is terribly sad. I absolutely understand your pre suit for answers in your sister’s murder case 😢 My sister was murdered in 1978. We have NEVER found anything out as to who murdered her. My ALMOST 96 year old father still waits to know who murdered his precious daughter. She was 28 yrs old when she died and would have been 73 yrs old this July, 2023. I’ve been the one pursuing her murder all these years with no help from police, sheriff etc. I am now 68 yrs old and feel EXACTLY Like you 💕🙏🙏

[@LisaSmith3663]

I hope you find some answers.

[@jeannetaylor2217]

@@LisaSmith3663 thank you so much 💕🙏🙏

[@MrRJMGREEN]

If you do not mind, could you please tell me the details about your sister's murder? I am horrified you are receiving no help from police.

[@maceylabinsky6737]

What's her name? Find articles post pictures record videos telling her story...it will spread ...please bring awareness..don't doubt yourself..this could be your sign ! 💕 Extremely sorry for your loss ..that pain is unimaginable..sending lots of love your way

[@TexasHoldem-p9q]

I wish you some peace💕💕 My father who served 20 years in the military and a Vietnam Vet was murdered in 2002 I had to let go and trust that the universe would handle it along with karma. That’s the only way I sleep at night.

[@KARKLUKY]

What a gentle wonderful human being Mr. Genovese. This is one of the most heartbreaking stories I have seen ...and the sensitive way it was filmed!!! Thank you for sharing and Bill, I hope you found the peace you well deserve ♥

[@sj-art]

Wow the son is a piece of work. Let's blame everyone except the convicted murderer. I mean I can understand wanting to cling to the memories you had from before, but I'm sorry, you don't believe and don't try to make excuses for someone like that.

[@wisecoconut5]

Your comment is so strange. I heard no "blame" but curiosity. Why didn't anyone call the police? It is a fair question but more difficult to answer so long after the event. May you never be faced with the same question.

[@Dondillilochevrolet]

I think he means the son of the murderer. I was confused too haha until I read it a few times.

[@darkforest7736]

yeah, I agree. I understand his defensiveness because admitting to his father's actions would probably shatter him. Him as a minister, I'm sure he's been fighting his own demons. It's definitely a struggle for unrelated people like us to not empathize with his reactions, but I can see why he's reacting in that way. Bill was already very contained in his emotions, and I find that very respectable.

[@coolohiobreeze2037]

Thank you Bill, for making this Documentary. It is a wonderful, sensitive, heart wrenching tribute to your dear Sister, Kitty and I will remember this always. I do remember reading about it so, so many years ago. But, it stayed in my mind, because I was so utterly horrified. May you find the inner peace you and your family are looking for. I am thinking Kitty is in such a much better place at this point in time. Also, thank you for your Service to us, in the United States. You have been through so very much.

[@DoUntoOthersAsUWouldHaveDone2U]

I have watched this. It is an amazing, thoughtful, heart wrenching documentary, and leaves the viewer with a heavy heart, I won’t lie. If only 1 person……just 1, could have been proactive when they heard her screams. A true exploration of societal disregarding & remaining silent by fear, instead of proactive actions being driven by courage.

[@lowerclassbrats77]

If I recall correctly in this documentary made by her brother. He determines that more than likely nobody could hear her screams, that's why nobody intervened.

[@thursoberwick1948]

@@lowerclassbrats77 Partly. I think he says the media tried to blame the neighbours but he points out the event would be brief. He also implies that the police were not helpful.

[@tigq1430]

Mr. Farrah said maybe why some of them heard & didn't do anything, many were survivors of the holocaust. Makes complete sense.

[@thursoberwick1948]

@@tigq1430 And yet I hear of this happening where people have no such excuse. I think the truth is that either many did not wish to get involved or thought it was an argunent not a murder.

[@elizabethjarvie6077]

@@lowerclassbrats77 MANY people DID hear her screams...did you miss all the interviews & testimony of the people saying they heard her screaming? I think he said many of them heard it but did not see it.

[@shespeaks1971]

Oh my God the ending to this documentary when he has the actress act out his sisters screams from when she was stabbed brought me to tears.

[@zxy78267]

Me, too!

[@patriciabarajas7925]

It was quite powerful

[@monicaenriquez8643]

Thank you for highlighting your beautiful sister’s life!

[@angelalejzerowicz9670]

WOW what an unbelievable story it had me captivated to the very end. I think we all have that one loss that hits so differently from any other it stays with us changes the way we see/feel about the world around us & the loss is so profound it never heals. You honored your sister memory wonderfully thank you for sharing your experience with us

[@suzannetracy1005]

This story is one I’ve never heard of before. This was so beautifully done. My largest take away from this isn’t only about the crime. What touched me most Was what an amazing amazing family Kitty was a huge part of and still is. Gentle tears streamed down my face at the reenactment. God rest her soul ❤ Thanks for the insane amount of work this must have taken you Bill.

[@anitafrail8435]

One of the best documentaries I have seen in a long time. Read and heard some things about this case but never the truth until now.

[@lisamarierosso2713]

Wow her brother is incredible 👏

[@Wildrover82]

Powerful and sad story. I'm sure Kitty would be proud of her brother.

[@tbobbiej7776]

I give Bill much respect for the devotion in finding out what happened in this tragedy. My condolences to Kitty's family.

[@tennispals]

We know what happend, Winston Moseley rapped and killed Kitty. Mr. Moseley died on March 28, 2016. Hopefully, he is still burning in hell.

[@rowanbowyer6560]

I have the distinct impression the “criminal” Mosley has manipulated his son as well as many around him, his son really needs help to openly, honestly, factually learn about ALL his criminal behaviour. To understand his father’s impact on this family and the other family who was raped and murdered in a torturous manner, he really needs to know all of it, that would be an incredibly difficult confrontation to process.

[@mariabarco7226]

Let’s hope he sees the entire film!

[@tonithenightowl1836]

An incredibly well done documentary, my utmost respect to William and his family. I was 11 when this happened and it shocked a nation. I'm thankful for learning more than the media side of this horrifically, tragic event. William's tenacity is amazing and admirable. He dug deep to find the truth no matter how painful. I hope the family has found closure.

[@January.]

*My utmost respect for

[@cwaterstreet1]

Wonderfully detailed and beautiful, from another filmmaker

[@carolyngarcia6292]

The most terrifying thing about this crime is that it can still happen today. I hope you’re resting in peace Kitty and the Genovese family live their lives out in peace

[@carlalalanne7311]

Heartbreaking I’ve learned of her story in college ironically at Fordham University. I felt bad then and still now. I can’t believe his son so disrespectful pretending to be a man of God with no empathy no apologies for his father’s action. He should never get out of prison. The son is in denial. His father is a monster an animal. He has escaped from jail only to commit more crimes. I can’t believe that he thinks he should be paroled. The apple don’t fall far from the tree. Hope the family, Bill find peace and you will see your sister again in the afterlife. May she Rest In Peace.

[@kimberlygabaldon3260]

Many thanks to Bill. When he was talking to Hattie, and she said that she was told, "We've already got the calls," maybe it didn't end up in the call log because the dispatch didn't even take her name. Kitty sounded like so much fun. It's a shame that she's not still around. 💔⚘ So it sounds like Moseley was a serial killer, caught early. Who knows how many more he would have killed, over the years, if he hadn't been caught.

[@debraperkins4448]

Don't forget Him being a Rapist as Well!!

[@kevinkiso4579]

Gdmn. That hit me like a train. I cried at the end. A fifty seven year old man in watching this documentary alone in my downtown Seattle high rise. She was so beautiful. I went back and watched how Kitty moved and smiled in the old film footage. 🌹

[@tundrawomansays694]

You have so much compassion and heart, sir. Thanks.

[@damn0705]

I was shocked when murderer’s son Steven came to talk to to Bill and tried to justify his father’s actions and turning the guilt on Kitty… and he’s a reverend for god sakes.

[@Stella_In_Real_Life]

Right? Much denial here. He needs to start asking the right questions to his father. The fact he didn't even know of the other woman's death remains highly confusing.... I see a wounded little boy. Still bitter his Dad was taken. The stories groomed in his own mind is a safety blanket. Which, is understandable. However..... he needs to accept the truth so he too, can be free.

[@Estoverax]

He’s a piece of crap for trying to make it into a racial issue

[@maybebaby9211]

Having worked as a 911 call taker, I can say it is hard to understand how so many people could have just rolled over after hearing that and gone back to sleep. Even the recreation sent chills down my spine. The murderer doesn’t ever deserve to breathe one breath of air on the outside of prison. Lying monster. What a toll her murder must have taken on her parents. I know they would be so proud of her brother for telling her story.❤

[@musiclover1958]

Did you watch this documentary? Everyone called the cops!

[@Enrique-nv3lc]

​@@musiclover1958Some people call the cops, not everyone.

[@christinabernat6709]

THANK YOU BILL FOR THIS SUPERB DOC'Y. IT SHOULD BE SEEN BY ALL, and STUDIED FOR THE NEXT 50 YEARS - at least - N COURSES! You gave much peace by doing this not only to yourself, Kitty, all the families involved, etc, but also to millions of us who were not only naturally upset by this violent event - BUT ALSO UNNECESSARILY OVERWHELMED FOR THE WRONG REASONS through compromised journalism about this event. This should be seen everywhere by everyone. SUPERB QUALITY. Cudos to all involved in making this. And soooo beautiful to watch, because the superb quality of this raises this to a work of art as well. JUST SUPERB.

[@klaytonvonkluge4905]

When that actress screamed, the largest part of my inner soul froze with terror .... Wow. Holy mother of fear - From the onset of this film, I tried to put myself in the shoes of someone who heard or saw something, and I honestly can't say what I would have done; I'm not really a brave soul, but I'm not a coward , neither ... The only ones who can say is those who experienced everything first hand. . Thank you for your bravery , Mr. Genovese, Both overseas in defense of the US, and to put together such a detailed, honest , scientifically and meticulously documented account of what you went through.

[@stephaniek1076]

Beautiful and heartfelt, insightful comment. Thank you!

[@cecillec2331]

That killer should never be paroled. His dishonesty/changing story which is self-serving is enough reason not to trust this man. The son truly did not fall far from the tree. There was nothing coming from him that deserves his wanting to be called a "reverend". While trying to give a lecture on forgiveness, he came across arrogant and actually angry, practically blaming the Genovese family/the notoriety of Kitty's story for his father's continuing incarceration. He also had the audacity to bring up the Genovese crime family, for what, to put the Genovese family on the same despicable level as his father? In my mind anyone walking around with the title "reverend" would be oozing humility, compassion, and love, not arrogance, defensiveness, and umbrage. I am just watching this from my computer screen and this "reverend's" negative vibe is so palpable. My heart goes out to the Genovese family, especially to Bill. I think this is the end of the road. Stop looking for goodness where there is none. You have a wonderful, loving family, immerse yourself in that.

[@Estoverax]

Totally agree

[@tamigreene2709]

I would be enraged if he said "I hope we can all put this behind us and move on from here" to me!!!

[@mariabarco7226]

Yes, nasty man. Son of an evil father. He will be roasting in Hell!

[@n.c.467]

What a beautiful testimony of brotherly love. Kitty's senseless murder interrupted and ended not only her life but also the special relationship she was building with her young brother, WIlliam. He has dedicated so much of his life to making sure her life story and her death story are accurate and honor her memory. His obvious true love for her extends beyond this life and into the next. Well done, William.

[@conversations1250]

Bill's expressive face was incredibly moving. I felt I could hear the story bit by bit without words. Grew up knowing the Kitty Genevese story, but not the person, like a faceless thing that happened. This changes it forever.

[@Kns567]

This film was well done and revealing. I learned about this case in high school. I was struck by the irony of the one lady asking Kitty’s brother: can I help you? Across the driveway and he accepted. I thought: wow! all these years later did she think she would give assistance to Kitty’s brother?? and she got the chance. It was a sweet exchange. I also see how back then some residents were villainized. Very unfortunate and not fair. My condolences to the Genovese family and RIP Kitty 🙏

[@LaureenLusby]

So terribly sad. A truly worthy documentary. I can understand where you were coming from Bill, if you had been left wounded in that paddy field you would have met a similar end. You had that spiritual tie with your sister. I am a baby boomer & saw my friends & family go to Vietnam. As a nurse I know the sort of suffering endured by many of those who served. When we remember ANZAC Day, in Australia, I always have a prayer for the USA service men & women too. God bless you & your family. Kitty would be proud of you.

[@honeydutch97]

Excellent documentary! My heart goes out to your family! 😢😢

[@ronrosfoster]

Wow! That killer’s son is sickly defensive! All he was saying was all just garbage. Wow! Easy to say to move on! Despicable person! Worst! These people should not be with other people. So sickening!!!

[@angelalejzerowicz9670]

Right. Saying Kitty was using racial slurs (which I don’t believe is true at all!) as if that excuses his Dads actions of murdering this woman

[@alarahillton1343]

And he was stereotyping that Genovese meant that all people w that name are mafia!!!! The apple didn’t fall far from the tree. They’re both crazy.

[@jp-a1a729]

He blamed Kitty. Disgusting. And to think he’s a reverend!

[@robertmoriarty925]

Then his Dad’s letter tried to blame it on an Italian guy. Something he never seemed to mention in 50 years.

[@kimberlyhood4095]

​@@jp-a1a729 they're usually the first to cast stones in their glass houses. I don't think much of the one's willing to coddle killers even if they're family. You own your crimes and sins because your victims are gone, their burdens have been laid down by your hands.

[@alisonbyrne9353]

I’m literally crying watching Bill watching the reenactment of his sister’s screams. Bill, you are the strongest man I have ever seen. Kitty would be proud of the man you became. I hope you and your family find some peace and comfort. I’m so happy that she wasn’t alone when she passed.

[@beverlyflores]

Absolutely I just balled my eyes out 😢

[@Glitter6804]

God bless her brave brother- he's giving her justice in the only way he can- by telling her true story! God Bless Kitty! Always help people don't be part of the bystander effect!

[@JoyDogDivaCat]

Thank you for this documentary about your sister, Kitty. I remember when this happened. I was a child, age 14, that was when parents watched the news every night and if you were a child, you were just there. I recall it reported as a young woman being stabbed multiple times on a street and she was screaming for help and no one helped, that there were 38 witnesses who heard her and did nothing. I hadn't heard about the friend who helped her, Sophia. I'm glad she was there for her. I believe your sister is always with you, Bill. May you find and know peace.

[@kimberlyhood4095]

I remember the first time I watched this and the reenactment of that night,her screams went through me like ice. I don't care how scared you are, if you can sit there and do nothing that's a lot to say about you. I'm glad he went there and talked to those people,got the truth. The media and cops has done a great injustice to Kitty's family and the people that were there for Kitty that night.

[@anitastodolak9882]

I just watched this and what COMPLETELY BOGGLES MY MIND IS HOW CAN YOU HEAR SCEAMS LIKE THAT AND NOT DO ANYTHING! Even though it was a reactment of the sceams it SENT CHILLS UP MY SPINE!

[@madisona3907]

Thank you for the touching, well-made story of a spirited young woman and a loving devoted baby brother. Your love has touched my heart. God bless you and yours.

[@jamieurban1419]

That was beautiful thank you Bill for setting the record straight I'm so sorry to hear that happened to your sister, but I am proud of you for making this film for people to truly understand some of the events that took place. I absolutely love how you showed us who your sister truly was.

[@juliedziura]

Thank you for posting it. Bill’s story is so touching.

[@lim-limdunn5655]

Sad that after 50 years, the murderer still would not accept responsibility, still trying to deflect & deny wrong doing, while his preacher son feels that his father should have/could have been paroled. Shame on the family, especially coming from a man of God.

[@Bornwikd]

I know typical

[@kathleenmckeithen118]

I was in the 10th grade in high school in 1964 and living with my parents in a tiny, very rural town called Orange Springs, FL. We were worlds away from NYC in so many ways but Kitty's murder and the reports of neighbors just looking on and doing nothing to help her shocked us to our toes. We could not fathom that your sister was not helped when she needed help so badly. One of the reasons I have never wished to even visit NYC was the impression all of that had on me when I was 15. Bill, my heart goes out to you and your family and I appreciate your sharing this with us. I think your following this through to the end was the right thing to do and, also, honored Kitty in a way that needed to be done for her memory, for you and for your whole family. I am so glad her friend, Sophie, was there for her and that you were able to talk to her. ♥ Kathleen

[@tammyangel3862]

What a wonderfully done documentary! I was so captivated, as if I were there with Bill, as if I could picture it all, or part of the family. So sorry for Bill and the family for the loss of Kitty.

[@rio-wi1el]

so breathtakingly sad that this monster robbed this lovely family of so much. my heart goes out to them. I hope watching this will remind us to always reach out and help when we think somebody is in harms way.

[@debbieblack9120]

I remember this story in a class in high school....I never forgot, it made such an impact on my life. I swore to never turn my back on anyone in harms way. And I have become a better person because of Kitty's tragic death. She has a place in history....if not to teach society to care for one another. I hope there have been many others that were touched in the same way.

[@felicehappy]

Thank you so much for uploading this, have been trying to find this documentary for over a year. A very important story to tell. So many tragedies, not least the newspaper article and how it affected the family. What's more the true story was so much more important to tell. If you here screams and you are not sure what it is, investigate in a safe way. Or call the police. Don't assume anything when someone's life could be at risk.

[@celineleeuwe1206]

It's ( journalism) often not about the facts but about what sells

[@robertforrest7956]

Most Excellent.... Hope you get all the answers you need. 🕯️

[@delib636]

Such a well made documentary 👏 Sorry you didn't get the closer you needed 😢 Pray 🙏 She was an amazing woman. Keep all her lovely memories ALIVE 😇

[@January.]

*closure

[@josephprovencher6345]

How can you say you saw or heard a woman screaming "save me save me" and not be frightened by it?

[@thursoberwick1948]

More likely most of them just heard someone shouting which is a common occurrence in cities especially when the pubs close. That's one explanation I can think of. Folk nearby maybe didn't have that excuse.

[@josephprovencher6345]

@Thurso Berwick I agree about the ones close by had no excuse ESPECIALLY the elevator guy 💔

[@thursoberwick1948]

@@josephprovencher6345 He had no excuse. The ones further away would. I've stayed in urban areas from time to time and there is a lot of noise. Occasionally shouts and screams off in the distance and drunken fights. I find one tunes them out... many of them are not as bad as what happened here. Some people may have simply had TV/radio on, or been cooking/showering etc.

[@carolw1624]

What I got out of this regarding the witnesses is that the truth of the matter is not really known. One said she called the police who said they got the calls already. Also, I heard that many occupants had numbers tatoed on their wrist which suggest prisoners of war survivors. Screaming and doing nothing would be ingrained into them. Who knows. It is a tragedy but I am glad the killer was caught fairly quickly.

[@megami.x]

@@carolw1624 I agree, touching story about a brother’s journey of grief, but it’s not a true crime documentary imo

[@thisisme3238]

One of the most moving documentaries I have ever seen ... thanks for making us aware of what happened to Kitty.

[@barbaraheed3509]

This is a very powerful story for certain. I almost fell off my chair when the preacher asked if you where part of the mafia family Genovies family. Unreal !!! I also must say that the young lady that portraid your sister did a fantastic job too. The entire thing came together for me at that point and I truly do not understand why knowone came to her rescue or call for police. I can't remember if 911 was around back then. But ,Bill....thank you so much for making this film as I know it must have been very difficult to do. Kitty will now always be remembered in our hearts and souls. Now you children and grandkids will know her too.

[@evelynchew9590]

I saw on another video that 911 arose as part of the response to this case. Apparently at the time to call the police, you needed either a direct phone number to the station, or wait on the operator to connect you...

[@violetg7315]

I learned this case in Psychology class. “The case is often cited as the basis for what is known as the bystander effect in social psychology, whereby individuals fail to aid in emergency situations when others are present.”

[@January.]

*psychology class: "The case is...

[@zxy78267]

@@January. I didn't even notice that you didn't put the word "class" in the sentence. I understood what you were saying anyway. I think our brains fill in the blanks. I wanted to be a psychologist when I was young. My life took a different path, but I've always stayed interested in psychology.

[@swaglord3076]

Heart warming and heart breaking at the same time. Thank you for sharing your story❤❤❤

[@minnietrout814]

At first it seemed to be a gross, shocking and hideous display of apathy. I remember reading about it and hearing the tv news about it all those many years ago and feeling shocked and appalled, though at the time I didn’t even have the words that could identify how I was feeling. I was just a child at the time. It was inconceivable to me. Unbelievable, really. It left me with the impression that people in NYC were weird and uncaring. Later on I heard about the “bystander effect.” I believe Kitty’s death made a huge impact on me. I vowed to never turn my back or ignore anyone in a similar position. I suppose from a sociological standpoint it’s probably one of the first things in the news that ever really impacted me (besides the assassination of JFK) and left a lasting impression although it was more than 1500 miles away.

[@danielaharcarufkova]

This was the best documentary I have seen in my life. It held me interested untill the very end.

[@cece9145]

It is a powerful, moving story. I am much like this brother whom is dedicated to telling his sister's story. Some of us are inherently wired to seek out stories and truths. I am one of those people, and that is why I find the path of the journey of this incredible story profoundly brave and honorable.

[@gillianstapleton8566]

The son seemed really manipulative.. a whole load of word salad. 2 murders his dad was well on the road to being a serial killer .. he should never be released.

[@mariabarco7226]

He’s dead, thank God!

[@Linda-pw8gx]

I am so sorry for the Genovese family, what a horrible horrible crime, may kitty always be in peace🙏💕

[@peppiholliday4525]

Excellent coverage of this. I am so surprised that I never heard about this as I listened to quite a few crime videos and podcasts but this was one exceptional and I wish that her brother would have been able to have her for a lifetime. Bless you and your family

[@blackgold3508]

When the actress did the SCREAM...I started to cry! Terrifying!😳😳😳

[@cheryltravis8616]

Me too and I had to hold my ears as I could feel myself shrinking inside 🙍🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️😭

[@Over60sowhat]

Wow! The film from Kitty's High School was spectacular! I really feel like I got to know her!!

[@wobby1268]

Me, too. It did such a wonderful job of making her come alive for all of us who only knew her as a name, a victim, a "syndrome."

[@thomaswayne4240]

Thankful to find this hmong channel for the suitable voice, true crime cases, sister you got the perfect voice for truce crime stories imo..

[@happytrails699]

This is why I believe in the death penalty. These people should just be taken off the planet.

[@elizabethjarvie6077]

Thank you!

[@mariebroyles6874]

me too

[@johnq.random1496]

How about 'swift' death penalty. No sitting on death row for 18+ years

[@Wildrover82]

If I could believe in the infallibility of the justice system, I could believe in the death penalty, but I know better than that...

[@rc1983]

Agree! I wish that death penalty in it's worst - beheading!

[@LindaCasey]

This documentary was brilliantly done and has answered many of my questions. Thank you Bill (etal) 🕊

[@giulianakerim1670]

Heartbreaking , but sadly the police covered up for not answering the call on time ! 😢

[@wenavandermerwe6407]

Beautifully done. What a tragedy. Also have sympathy for the children of the murderer who had to endure the taunting at school. People can be so extremely cruel and callous.

[@katiix]

2:34 It didn't frighten or shock her?! 😳 You know you live in a bad area if someone says the sound of a woman screaming for help doesn't frighten or shock them. 🤦‍♀️

[@kathylynch9732]

I don't understand why no one helped her. Why no one ran down into the street to defend her. But then I didn't grow up in that time period or that dangerous city. I grew up in a small southern town. Everyone knew everyone. I have to say that when the woman reenacted the scream, I felt it. For just a moment, I was his sister, alone on that street, crying out for help. I hope the murderer never gets out.

[@mariabarco7226]

He’s rotting in Hell the freak!

[@elizabethfrederick2434]

this is a story that moves a person. who knows what really happened but may we learn to take care of each other.

[@January.]

There are millions of people in this country suffering right in front of our eyes every day.

[@chrisv.4071]

Thankyou for sharing this horrific tragedy I know it was very difficult for you to do !!!

[@mariafarrugia1192]

I lost faith in human kind long ago..I DONT REGRET IT...RIP KITTY... YOU HAVE A LOVING BROTHER..

[@January.]

*humankind

[@jomama5186]

She looked like a lovely person. So sad. My heart aches for her and her family and friends. 🧡🙏🏻

[@Starfire6280]

Even after Vietnam, her brother Bill is a true soldier, a valient hero for Kitty, keeping her light shining on... ✨ 🕊️

[@renata8979]

In the end it doesn't really matter if there were 38 or 108 or just 8, it matters that not one person stepped out and "got involved". Just like no one got involved when in broad daylight a 12-year-old girl tried to break free from Ted Bundy and everyone dismissed it as "a family matter".

[@DeeJay_78]

God bless that poor girl. I pray she knew her dear friend and neighbour was holding her as she passed. I studied this case for my psychology degree and was so deeply fascinated and shocked to my core by it. If only ...... God rest your soul Kitty x

[@dbentleyto95]

I am personally so happy that Bill was able to see this all the way through. It was fitting that he found peace and was able to celebrate Kitty's life. Indeed, just as poignant is the yarn of the story brought about some change in reporting crime. Even today, there are people who turn away, but all help starts with one. Bill seems like such a brave, gentle man, and I thank him for sharing his amazing journey. It's hard to say if the truth was found as truth has so many facets to each person.

[@aprylrittenhouse4562]

She was in the wrong place at the wrong time, just like that other poor woman. I was attacked with a knife behind a bar ten yrs ago. Someone interrupting the attack by just taking out the garbage saved my life. I'll never know exactly how she felt. But I came close

[@flightlessemu1]

RIP Kitty. 💜 Bill the re-enactment of your sister's murder was extremely chilling and very sad, it was also gutsy and brave. I'm sure Kitty would be proud of your efforts to find out the real truth of what happened to her. I also think she'd probably understand your "need" to hold the re-enactment of her last moments. It is my hope for you that you can now enjoy the rest of your life. I wish for you and your family only happiness and love. Thank you for sharing Kitty's story with us all. No longer screaming or in pain, she's surrounded by Angels - as indeed she is one of them now. All the Best to you Bill. Much Love from Australia.💟💕💕

[@Splash99]

Not getting closure has got to be gut wrenching. Thank you for bringing Kitty to life!

[@January.]

*gut-wrenching

[@karenstieglitz3443]

I think in many ways Bill did get some closure... People did call the police. A gentleman shouted out for Moseley to get out of there. Kitty was out of some people's range of vision, so they assumed she got home safely. Her friend did respond to her calls and was with her when she died. Yes, some people should have done more, absolutely. Had the first gentleman called immediately, things would have turned out differently. And perhaps the police did not respond as quickly as they should have to those people that did call. Holocaust survivors met with such a test a mere 20 years later would understandably not seek involvement -- a tragically coincidental effect of historical timing. But it certainly wasn't as bleak a picture as the Times made it out to be. Shame on them. And obviously Moseley wasn't representative of most of us. He was a deranged, delusional psychopath. KZbin is filled with stories of how people have stepped up to the plate to defend strangers in need. There are heroes among us, and I think all of these uncovered truths needed to be heard by Bill.

[@Stella-jq9up]

Yes you said it right. Abhorrent that the reporters were interested in the " story " not in the trueth..Look where that's lead us!! In my opinion nowadays people view reporters as invasive, truth exaggerating, scandals mongers, not worth the time of day.

[@elizabethjarvie6077]

Well yes journalism isn't to be trusted 100%

[@January.]

*the story, not the truth. *invasive, truth exaggerating scandal mongers not worth the time of day.

[@January.]

@@elizabethjarvie6077 What percent is it to be trusted?

[@alysononoahu8702]

I've called 911 a number of times, to help family, friends, and strangers ❤❤❤❤THANK YOU KITTY❤

[@peggybreidenbach8703]

I remember when this happened. How horrible it was. We trusted & believed what media reported, many still do. I've learned since that media can not be trusted. How they manipulate reporting of stories. So it does not surprise me how this was reported & so full of untruths. I applaud you for your determination to find the truth & share it with the world. Not many have that determination & strength. Thank you for sharing your journey & story.

[@KimChung1970Saigon]

One of “Boat People " from Saigon. I would like to thank you so much for your " humankind service in South Vietnam which 5 allies soldier protected us in South Vietnamese in horrible war zone . ". & my parent also lost a son, I lost a younger brother at age 22 who service in Navy. Welcome Home sir. So very sorry for your order sister Kitty Genovese story. May her rest in peace. 💜 Again thank you for your service. God bless your family.

[@yehmen29]

As Jim Caviezel's character says in Person of Interest: 'At the end of the day we are all alone and no one is coming to save us'.

[@Stella_In_Real_Life]

What a beautiful testament for Kitty's courage and that of her family. I applaud Bills persistence. I hope he knows how impactful it is for all of us. We will all carry Kitty with us when we encounter people requiring immediate assistance. Everyone matters. Kitty's life made a difference. This piece is closure. ❤ Her voice was heard.

[@katjagolden893]

We studied this in a psychology class when I was in college

[@hurricaneheather1420]

Oh yea I was wondering why it was so familiar. Thank you kindly

[@itsjenga]

This was a thoughtful and enlightening documentary. Whether it was 8 or 38, the message is still the same that someone would have called for help. I hope the family has found some peace.