I can’t believe all this happened from a simple hunch me and pixel had. All this is so insane. Thanks for covering it and bringing it to light
@miss-socio-btpe2 ай бұрын
Hi Spence! A big thanks from my side to both you and Pixel for bringing all this to light :) Keep up the good work!
@Husain5XG3 ай бұрын
Galactic crows: the guy who regrets his decision, and is sorry for it. AjbGames: the guy who carelessly handle the situation. The modeler: the guy who didn't regret his actions, and was less sorry for it than he should've been.
@ajbgamesstudio3 ай бұрын
Galactic Crows really cared about the situation he helped me a lot in this situation and I still trust him because he is a good man
@SwaggyG_21023 ай бұрын
God, I love online niche drama such as this. At a time when everyone is getting outed for being sex pests, I do enjoy the smaller things such as this.
@WildFox-h1u3 ай бұрын
Something that gets me about the modelers statement is that they claimed that the teeth were the only things used, when they basically raised the entire model, down to the body and the bow.
@GalacticCrows3 ай бұрын
Well, I assume the fact I did a mistake, of course without realization, I have never thought it would go that far. Lesson learned, I’ll be more careful with whatever I buy and who I buy from. That’s for sure! If y’all wondering me and AJB are in good terms, and always were during this situation. Thank you for the video! I genuinely cared about all parties involved!
@Timazoree3 ай бұрын
Actually a W response
@ajbgamesstudio3 ай бұрын
We made mistakes bro and we learnt from it , Keep going my brother ❤
@lydiagalantmotherf3 ай бұрын
That really sucks for you as well, screw that modeller, hope you won't get crap for something that isn't even really your fault to begin with
@ajbgamesstudio3 ай бұрын
@@lydiagalantmotherf I will try my best to never be in situation like that and I'm sorry that my english is kinda bad because I'm not native english and I found problems to communicate with people
@lydiagalantmotherf3 ай бұрын
@@ajbgamesstudio... I mean, I didn't mean you regardless, but best of wishes, English can be hard to learn. And hey, as long as you try to improve and try to deal with things better, like not immediately assuming all criticism comes from a bad place, I'm sure you'll improve overall, hope you won't get tangled up in anymore problems and stuff, have a nice day! ^^
@Kerminator173 ай бұрын
Well that was quick. Uhyeah barely beat you to the punch lol
@Th3Badd3st3 ай бұрын
cuz that goddamn purple dog didnt interview every single person involved over the last 24 hours 😭(i luv him tho /lh)
@kitsunemusicisfire3 ай бұрын
"So causing trouble over something small like this wouldn't be cool, in my opinion." Honey, you violated copyright laws to steal models from a game (which was made by what was still an indie studio at the time), sold it for $150 despite doing very little work with it, risked their integrity and brand for a quick buck, asked to stay anonymous because you KNOW it's wrong and you KNOW no one would ever work with you if they knew, and then have the audacity to try to guilt trip someone covering the subject and pretend like it's no big deal? Jesus Christ.
@bumble_bbgun3 ай бұрын
I appreciate you giving out your statements, don’t sugarcoat nothing, and defending the Indie Mascot Horror Space. Hearing you so passionately talk about how much you hate the modelers mentality because you have genuine love for the devs in it is really cool to see. And you speaking your mind instead of giving an unbiased “this is how it happened” stance is awesome. Thank you
@theSilentSmile3 ай бұрын
It's kind of crazy how absolutely no one evolved in this ever for one second looked at sparky, from 2022 until now, in the development process of Bokkie, and never ever thought "erm that kinda looks like huggy wuggy".
@enderkatze61293 ай бұрын
Colour threw 'em off
@supersmashseandx19913 ай бұрын
At least they didn't steal the knockout box
@ajbgamesstudio3 ай бұрын
Thank you for this video and thanks to all the people who helped me in this situation , I didn't know that the Model is copyrighted and also Paul ( GalacticCrows ) He didn't know either , we made a mistake and we learnt from it , I will never repeat this mistake , as the new projects I will make everything from scratch to avoid problems like that , thank you so much for the video again ❤
@neoqwerty2 ай бұрын
Make sure that if you DO need to get a model from somewhere, you either DIRECTLY commission it (so you know who you're working with and can check if they have a bad reputation and have the option to look around for price estimates, never trust a middle-man, not even if it's from your publisher) or you buy it from a professional marketplace (where it's rare to find stolen content). As an older (amateur) dev who's been working around with various kinds of art for going on 20 years, doing everything yourself isn't always possible. And sometimes doing everything yourself will stop your projects from being released. Best of luck with your game projects going forward!
@karrahklinger25733 ай бұрын
part of me is morbidly hoping that the modeler will out themself with an angry post of some sort on Twitter. Like, Baddest choosing to keep them anon. and they proceed to out themself with a hissy fit. That would just sort of feel fitting to me... I'm a hobbyist blender modeler and self-taught. I'm self-concious about my models but consider them okay, and they're MUCH better than any clumsily sculpted Garten of BanBan, but I would NEVER charge that much, even for a much more visually appealing model. I think models from professionals who know what they're doing could go for that much or even more, but this wasn't really a case of a professional or an innocent freelancer... I wouldn't care what website it came from, modifying a model rip and selling it for 150$ is very gross in any circumstance, and at least Garten of BanBan made their own models from scratch (albeit poorly).
@KatAlystsStage3 ай бұрын
Extremely appreciative of your points here. People definitely made mistakes, but there's hope for all of them to grow from this if they choose to put in the work. Copyright law and theft are really serious issues, thank goodness someone is looking out for the indie scene. I'm not a game developer, but I am an independent artist, and it is so, so important that we take the time to learn about things like open source and creative commons 0. I'm constantly sharing open source software options for drawing programs with younger folks, because I've been there, sometimes you need something that's free and legal to use to get started. It's really unfortunate when stuff like this happens. earlier in the summer, someone took to twitter with concerns that the cutout model for Bendy and the Dark Revival was actually using stolen fan art, and I have never seen theMeatly be so quick to acknowledge and try to correct something. He was vigilant about clearing the air and making it right, and that spoke volumes. If one of the more well-known devs of the indie space can recognize when they've messed up, then so can more folks. I genuinely hope this modeller gets their act together, it would be a shame for them to carry on this way and tarnish their relationships in the creative world. Here's hoping for a brighter future.
@CalamitasCalliope3 ай бұрын
If this situation was brought to court for whatever reason, it would be likely that a lot of this could fall under the innocent infringer defense. The Bokkie dev is the most obvious example of this, i highly doubt any court would charge him. Galactic Crows *could* probably be charged since they are the ones who sold the model and they still have a working relationship with the modeler. But if it was brought to court they could throw him under the bus to save their asses and possibly reduce the money lost. And i highly doubt that defense would work for the modeler. He could try to use that defense due to the misunderstanding, but it's highly likely he would receive at least a partial charge
@peanutpeanutpeanutpeanut3 ай бұрын
bokkie 2: revenge of the copyright
@Leader73533 ай бұрын
the modeler and everything he made before and after is definitely something that should be looked into. This does not seem to be a one time thing kind of situation, they would have produced more than one model for other people. Who knows what else he worked on that might have similar copyrighted work? Sure, this might have been a one time thing he did during his free time while he had another bigger job to work on and put barely any work into because it was not his actual job. He did not actually take this whole 'created for a indie game' seriously (have seen this attitude in some modelers). But that is if I give him complete benefit of the doubt. This is not something to just bring to the public, but to past employers
@Based_Enjoyer3 ай бұрын
Missed opportunity to title the video "The true story of the Banbanned Mascot Horror game" smh
@king_poyo643 ай бұрын
I read it like that at first before getting a double take.
@britanimations20023 ай бұрын
If you're commissioned with actual money to make a model, I still don't think you should be looking for the basis in the first place. That should only be done if there's no formal commission and if the model will not be used in a commercial setting, otherwise too many risks legally
@tibby45033 ай бұрын
And we're already back.
@anonshrimp82992 ай бұрын
That modler better feel lucky. If I did something that bad and my whole identity was in your hands. I would be utterly grateful. I genuinely do not think this Modler understands the gravity of the situation.
@ghoulthedamned3 ай бұрын
I love how this story has basically been a tennis match between you and Uhyeah, videos being made one right after the other from each other's side of the cort sorta speak....idk I hope someone understands what I'm trying to say it's like...1AM as I'm watching this instead of sleeping...
@neoqwerty2 ай бұрын
I hope you went to sleep and next time remember the comments section won't just disappear on you, sleep is important!!!
@wyattsaum2722 ай бұрын
So basically nobody is “innocent” but it’s all basically the “modeler’s” fault (and the guy who put the huggy model on sketch fab to begin with) While the darker muzy being cancelled is fair I’m a bit curious how it would’ve been darker exactly. gore? flesh? corpses? Damn my curiosity
@e1iteyoshi9982 ай бұрын
Imo there is no way i think this freelancer is gonna change his ways. The only reason i see why he ended up chasing his tone was cause he got caught.
@katoatoato3 ай бұрын
Lmao, just finished UhYeah's vid and this dropped. Good timing.
@elliotsturtplus3403 ай бұрын
Gonna be honest I wanna say you have got more patience when it comes to people being ignorant if it were me I would’ve exposed this modeller most likely for everyone’s safety if he’s going to get devs in trouble and not take any accountability then he shouldn’t even be a indie dev
@Pyrotrainthing3 ай бұрын
"Hmm yes today I will sell this model someone made for me to my friend"
@RookelCookel3 ай бұрын
Round 2! Let’s go!
@sydneyb23782 ай бұрын
Why didn't AJB just say from the beginning that he didn't make the model? That's the part I don't understand.
@Snaily_Man3 ай бұрын
Well, did not expect this situation to take route like this
@portyfcraft18123 ай бұрын
I love how the Huggy from the thumbnail is from a gmod nextbot
@sboy20442 ай бұрын
5:27
@enderkatze61293 ай бұрын
I do not understand why the dev reacted the way he did
@Lovelymamas222 ай бұрын
5:27 eeeeyyyyyy thanks for the shout out bro this model was literally just a random shitpost lol
@liamramos12853 ай бұрын
A day already? That was fast.
@enderkatze61293 ай бұрын
The long awaited sequel
@samhill90893 ай бұрын
YES YOU USED KZbin HEROICLY thank you for sharing this or i might be in danger so a big thanks to you and your team!
@joel91043 ай бұрын
Good lord you work fast. I feel so conflicted with all the people in this situation, Galactic Crows I think is someone who made a real genuine mistake and is probably the most innocent person here. Although I do feel sympathy for AJB games, I am struggling to forgive him for his actions online especially because of how one of these unnecessarily put one of my freinds in the crossfire here (Isaac will know who I mean, I'm sure a lot of people here can guess) but at the same time nothing bad has happened to them because of it yet and they seem to be brushing it off as a joke. This modeller is someone I don't know how I feel about though, they could be a bad person attempting to try and save face but also could just be an idiot who misspoke. Truth be told, this whole thing just made me more interested to see what Galactic Crows and AJB Games make in the future. Even though his actions on twitter were terrible, the fact he was willing to die on this hill for a random mascot horror project makes me believe that he genuinely cares about what he is making. Excellent video btw, I don't really have too much to say about it but just wanted to let you know I enjoyed it.
@neoqwerty2 ай бұрын
In the end honestly if that modeler can't understand people on sketchfab lie about what's free and doesn't understand his work's license makes him DIRECTLY RESPONSIBLE for how it's used? He shouldn't be selling anything yet. Creative Commons literally is about control over how your work is used. a CC0 waives all legal rights and sends it to public domain. A CC BY requests use only with credits. A CC NC means your work can't be used in commercial works. A CC SA means that other people can only use your work if they also use the exact same license you used. The BY, NC, and SA tags can be combined to make the rest of the CC licenses. Applying a CC0 doesn't magically make him immune to legal responsibility for character copyright infringement (and might actually violate a previous license if the work he took it from was Share-Alike or Attribution, and meanwhile if it was NonCommercial he violated that license by selling the work).
@SolaireHighwind2 ай бұрын
It's wild that people who were in the mascot horror sphere apparently didn't recognize a part from one of the most well known mascot horror characters.
@Crystal_Dylan3 ай бұрын
Legit thought this was a reupload for a second
@bonniebluebellaextras2 ай бұрын
Well- time to see who spills the beans on who the “modeler” is. Seriously no one who fucks up this badly should be held anonymous when it’s getting into serious legal issues. For someone who does not take responsibility, that cocky demeanor should not be rug swept
@ringer13243 ай бұрын
Very serious situation we need to get the whitehouse involved. Bokkie is a matter of National security.
@EagleMadness3 ай бұрын
It awful that the modeler put these people into this position, but the one thing is for sure is that its hard to trust people, and its a great idea to hire a professional 3d artist I've also made a remodeling of the characters to make them a little more different than the ones certainly
@GigasGMX2 ай бұрын
I’m pretty sure Copyright infringement is a purely Civil matter and therefore not a “crime”.
@alexy7203 ай бұрын
TH3BADD3ST LIST3NS TO PORT3R ROBINSON!?!?!?! I alr3dy lov3d th3m but this just puts th3m in my top thr33 CC's
@Th3Badd3st3 ай бұрын
Smile is my album of the year rn!
@alexy7203 ай бұрын
@@Th3Badd3st OMG REALLY? What's your favorite song in it? My fav song in it (besides the first three that came out before the full album came out) is "Is There Really No Happiness". But besides that, my favorite from the album has to be "Cheerleader" which is closely followed by "Knock Yourself out XD"
@Th3Badd3st3 ай бұрын
@@alexy720 i think it’s Cheerleader but Knock Yourself Out XD, Mona Lisa, and Cheerleader are all competitors for #1 to me.
@ThirdyMeowy2 ай бұрын
omg yesss!!! i think "easier to love you" is my favorite followed by "knock yourself out XD" !!!
@laggingfr3 ай бұрын
That was quick
@cyboyentertainment923 ай бұрын
What a disaster. Thanks for sharing this video!
@Seakobra3 ай бұрын
well then
@mememachine54172 ай бұрын
11:11 Your honor, in my defense, I'm an indie dev- I work out of passion with very little money, so you causing trouble with my """supposed theft, scam, and crime""" isn't very cool in my opinion, so I'd prefer if I wasn't charged, thanks
@hiiamdorte2 ай бұрын
it not only happening to this game many games like in silence etc
@sworddev57983 ай бұрын
yjis is why i work cheep my stuff targets new devs so mess like this doesn't happen
@sunfastrose3 ай бұрын
Galactic crows lost money in selling the model?
@squibbled3 ай бұрын
Part 3 gonna totally happen tomorrow /j But yeah, if you see a model anywhere that isn't yours to begin with, don't put it in your works, kids! (if kids even read this)
@redmaskofficial64192 ай бұрын
jesus dude, if i could contact ajb and make models for free and make sure this does not happen again like damn
@coasterthekid88672 ай бұрын
I agree that exposing wrongdoings in the community is very important, which is why it’s very disappointing that we don’t know who this person is. It’s very much a double edged sword, because if you release the name, your credibility goes down as a journalist, but if you don’t release the name then you’re allowing them to continue doing whatever essentially free from any real accountability.
@mushymeow61023 ай бұрын
Wow that was a fast part 2.Im still surprised I haven’t been banned from KZbin for being racist/j
@ringer13242 ай бұрын
10:04 based discord profile pic
@SheepRunner3 ай бұрын
Man i hope this goes on the news lmao
@Theofficialguidetonothing2 ай бұрын
Rank every fnaf by lore
@vil83742 ай бұрын
I can understand maybe usain it free model to jump off. Of but make sure it's actually legal and also that website needs to crack down on that bullshit.
@JoshuaReyes-fg2zh2 ай бұрын
Says they haven't copied why does the bunnys mouth and body kinda look like huggys
@emperordalek1023 ай бұрын
Someone needs to get the commentary community on this. Such as mutahar and optimus and keemstar.
@Jocka-v6f3 ай бұрын
Im also early and i like your content!
@trhayden13 ай бұрын
Who loves th3badd3st
@angryworkatapizzaplacesound3 ай бұрын
ag
@TheGameplayCat2 ай бұрын
calling a "indie game dev"its a shame
@alternatequartz72243 ай бұрын
Wow I’m early
@TheFazzyDude3 ай бұрын
Same
@Julian-xt9fe3 ай бұрын
Claim your under one day ticket here (not comment begging) 👇