All-Time Top 10 Premier League Wingers RANKED! | The Club Debate

Join The Club’s official Super 6 mini-league now using the code CLUB23: super6.skyspor...
Full season competition T&CS:
Listen to the FULL PODCAST here: open.spotify.c...
Join The Club
Linktree - linktr.ee/thec...
TikTok - / theclublivetiktok
Twitter - / theclublivetw
Instagram - / theclubliveinsta
Follow the lads on social 📱
Adam McKola
KZbin: / @adammckola
Twitter - / adammckola
Instagram - / adammckola
TikTok - / adammckola_
Rory Jennings
KZbin: / @roryjenningsfootball
Twitter - / chelsearory
Instagram - / chelsearory
TikTok - / chelsearory
Buvey
KZbin: / @buvey
Twitter - / lawrence_bury
Instagram - / buvey_
TikTok - / buvey_

[@lawrencebaker1811]

If salah hugging the touchline 90% of the game doesnt classify as a winger then hell, I know nothing about football.

[@roueljeremy8074]

I’m like wtf u mean u don’t have Salah

[@83hudini]

the older style wingers, that Rory refers to, were covering the whole wing, meaning including the defensive part of the game. Salah very rarely goes back to help and that 1 of the main reasons Trent is so exposed. Football was different pre 4-3-3 era

[@levicoker8937]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@83hudini wtf are you yappin about. Salah tracks back. His work rate off the ball is arguably better than every winger on this list.

[@camerondavies8442]

@@83hudini what a yapper from 2017-2022 all u heard was the work rate of MSF gegenpressing the ball suffocating teams u melt

[@tempname4039]

Salah plays a lot more like a wide attacker than a traditional winger imo, each to his own I guess.

[@R0ddy111]

Rory disasterclass as usual

[@jamnewt7338]

Horrendous opinions based on disgusting bias

[@AlexZouhehe]

Horrible but mad fun tbf.

[@tempname4039]

You prob wouldn't watch if he wasn't on the show though.

[@michaelrowell7798]

He is all over the place with his list. Got no idea what he was doing

[@drSvensen]

This time it's understandable and he is well aware he is wrong so I don't hold it against him.

[@cww3833]

salah hugs the touchline all game, hes the most clear winger iv seen. he's actually so prolific from the wing that people are just deciding he must be a striker, never seen a player get so much hate for no reason

[@hyywe240]

His first 4 years with firmino as a false 9, he and mane were basically strikers. Saying that, Rory has had a stinker

[@apt9238]

It’s the new systems in football. On paper and on the eye you’ll find Salah on those wing positions but ask Klopp who his strikers were in that team. He’d say Mane and Salah. Salah especially was taking more shots per game than anyone in that Liverpool team. Edit: angles of attack changed so that Firmino in the false 9 was a facilitator to let Salah (and Mane) strike from zones in which he could do most damage.

[@Robert-ks5ix]

People like this will do a top ten strikers list then say Salah isn't a striker as well. They're just bitter rivals who have all had to bow down to the Egyptian King at some point.

[@adambassuni6084]

@@apt9238 ask klopp who his striker was and he'd say firmino not the 2 wingers lmao what

[@apt9238]

@@adambassuni6084 who was taking more shots per game at Liverpool during that period? It was all by design, Firmino would occupy that central spot of the field but in terms of striking the ball towards goal that was Salah. Of course there’s games where Firmino would score but if he was the ‘striker’ than barely getting over 15 goals in a season was pretty poor from him

[@TG-it8zt]

Salah is a touchline winger, his heat map for every season at Liverpool is right on the touchline and exactly the same as you'd expect from Robben, Mahrez etc

[@nascimentoarantes]

There’s a song about that, Mo Salah cutting from right wing.

[@madeupstory9510]

I think that it's the perception that he has too many goals for a winger. It is completely false, but I think that this is the logic behind.

[@Un-informed-genius]

Mo Salah, Mo Salah, running down the……

[@Chidi_jc]

No

[@Do27gg]

He’s just too good so rival fans want to not put him in the list

[@SSUSA]

Went unnoticed but Buvey saying “Rory’s got Puskas in his list!” was gold. 🤣

[@dmbdajoker616]

Yes I cam to say this. I had to pause it I was gutted no one heard it 😂😂

[@euanmeade9023]

also adams joke that what i call wingers 90s addition haha

[@ancientknight9805]

Mane got disrespected massively. Look at his numbers 111 goals 38 assist in the prem . The disrespect is real

[@JNM781]

Problem is back in the day there was Left Midfielders and Not wingers

[@walshknwsbest]

Son also getting disrespected. The whole argument of him not having done anything worthwhile in the league simply because he hasn’t won a trophy is redundant. Is Harry Kane not allowed be in the top 10 strikers in the league as he never won anything. ? Such a stupid argument.

[@joshg2603]

No pens, also

[@ul.biggit217]

​@@walshknwsbestspiderman wannabe😴 he will never win anything at that disney plus club

[@walshknwsbest]

@@ul.biggit217 got nothing to do with winning something you numpty. It’s about the best players in a position that play or played in the premier league. Going by your metric Anthony martial is better than Kane as Kane never won anything with spurs. Use your head if you can

[@tomdixon5563]

The fact sadio mane isn't on any of their top 10 but damian bloody duff did is absolute criminal!!

[@Do27gg]

Idk how people can watch this channel

[@jackyoung7097]

Rory was correct. Mane and Salah were not wingers. They are missing Gillespie, Lennon, Stuart Ripley, Chris Waddle, out and out wingers who’s job is to deliver the ball to the forwards.

[@Do27gg]

@@jackyoung7097 reading the first sentence of your comment already makes it waffle ngl

[@garymaidman625]

Simply because Duff won more trophies, not because he is a better player.

[@supreme_zeeyus]

@@jackyoung7097a winger is a position not a role, your point is incorrect

[@Harryyy2121]

Salah is one there’s no doubt it’s only because the bias against Liverpool. Salah will never get the respect he deserves it’s a joke he’s one of the all time prem greats

[@ul.biggit217]

He never done itinthe barclays tho

[@alexwarren9730]

hes not better as a footballer compared to a lot of players on that list. mahrez, bale, hazard, ronaldo are all above for me. its no all about goals you know. he goes missing in a lot of games and scores when its 3-0 4-0 a lot of times. no way hes a better footballer than some people im sorry but youre wrong.

[@endinako9364]

League wise Salah is the biggest game player (70 g/a Vs big 6) Salah is a better footballer than Mahrez and hazard only because doesn't do skills is getting disrespected

[@alexwarren9730]

@@endinako9364 the way you can’t form sentences kind of doesn’t support your claim. It makes no sense what you just said. “Salah is a better footballer because of his goals and assists” literally the least important part of being a winger lad. Technically nowhere near hazard or mahrez. They’re better players.

[@endinako9364]

@@alexwarren9730 doku has more technique than Salah so now even doku is better?

[@sandgrounder]

John Barnes is one of the best wingers Liverpool have ever had.

[@shedzproductions8262]

Best years before premier league

[@LukeStarkilla]

Barnes centre mid in the premier era and not a bad passer/facilitator for Liverpool world class winger from '87-'91 in the old 1st Division

[@wb2463]

Yeah, Barnes was a class winger and a better player than a lot of players mentioned in this video but that was mostly before the premier league.

[@KremBananTV]

Barnes would be #1 on this list, had they not made it PL only.

[@sandgrounder]

He played over two hundred premier league games but yeah, he is more well known for playing in the old first division I suppose.

[@doublerr8325]

Buvey having Mahrez & Bale ahead of Salah was so expected 😂

[@Idur88]

Bale was better than salah.

[@leew-qh7dx]

Hahaha bale scored 42 league goals in 6 seasons at spurs. Salah in 6 seasons has 139 league goals. And that’s not including the 10 he has this season so far. I’m sorry I even had to do that to you.

[@Idur88]

@@leew-qh7dx bale was a top 15 fullback in the prem during the Barclays era, then had the most mesmerising season of any winger in pl history in his final year then became most expensive player.At real he had higher scoring seasons than salah has ever had and that was playing next to cr7 and KB. Salah is one dimensional and can’t do half of what bale could do.Even scoring, which is salahs main game. Also lead Wales to EURO 2016 Semi final which they would have won if Ramsey wasn’t suspended.

[@leew-qh7dx]

@@Idur88 now I know your a complete idiot. It’s ranked in THE PREM! You have to look at what bale done in England not Spain, not for his country. You talking about, salah can’t score goals? I’ve literally just proven to you how many more goals salah has scored in the same time. Salah is clearly the Prems best ever winger, tell me what did bale win whilst at spurs? Becides his 21 goals in that “mesmerising season” Salah scored 23 an you all said he had a shite season 😂🤫

[@alexischristou3266]

@@Idur88 Literally the definition of a tribal fan that cant comprehend logic. Here let me give you some cold hard facts. Gareth Bale's final season in the premier league: 33 games/21 goals Mo Salah's first season in the premier league as a Liverpool player: 36 games/32 goals....not bad for a one dimension player right? The numbers do not lie, end of story.

[@ntobekongcobo5081]

I rate Damien Duff but Rory having him in 8th while John Barnes is 9th is borderline sacrilegious 😂

[@josephcole8046]

I think it's because it's Premier League top 10, and his best years were before 1992. Didn't he also play in central midfield a lot during the Premier League era section of his career?

[@garymaidman625]

Top 10 Premier League wingers, John Barnes is not a top 10 Premier League winger. By the time the Premier League came around, Barnes was transitioning into CM.

[@maxwatkins7032]

Salah doesn’t make winger lists or striker lists, they just hate he’s so good so make stuff up to remove him

[@wb2463]

It's mad that only one of them had Mane on his list. The guy was amazing for Liverpool, won every club competition with us and was one the best LWs in the world at his peak. He was instrumental in our first Premier League trophy, holds the record for the fastest ever Premier League hat trick from his time at Southampton, has PL golden boot, was in the PFA team of the year for four of his 6 seasons at Liverpool, and was certainly a better player than Sterling and probably Mahrez too (no disrespect to either of those players, they're both amazing and have ridiculously large PL trophy numbers, it's just that Mane was better imo)

[@hyywe240]

Nobody had alexis sanchez either did they?

[@sib1930]

​@@hyywe240Because he doesn't deserve to be there

[@hyywe240]

@sib1930 Probably played 100 games less than mane in the prem so I get you saying that but better goal and assist contribution per game and he carried that arsenal attack for a couple seasons. Prem player of the year 2015. Be tough to leave him out for me

[@sm6996.]

Sadio Mane best player in the world

[@Prime1Wunna]

Not better than mahrez… that one Leicester season alone is one the craziest thing rvt

[@markwebb7576]

If anyone is interested, here is a list of wingers and their best 5 PL seasons by combined goals + assists. I know there is more to this debate than pure stats, but it is what it is. Salah 168 Ronaldo 122 Mahrez 116 Son 116 Hazard 116 Sterling 111 Mane 102 Beckham 100 Pires 96 Giggs 96 Sanchez 94 Bale 79 Walcott 77 Mata 77 Solano 76 McManaman 75 Kewell 71 Downing 69 Anderton 68 Nani 65 Duff 64 Barmby 64 Kanchelskis 64 Merson 61 Ljungberg 60 Ginola 58 Barnes 52 Lennon 50 Wright-Phil 48 Cole 47 Sharpe 44 Overmars 44 (only 3 seasons) Robben 31 (only 3 seasons)

[@joemakepeace6652]

what a surprise, no one even comes close to salah, most disrespected player of all time

[@thecro2060]

Ronaldo's numbers like this are actually very impressive considering he did all of that before he even hit 24, and looking at the guys he's beaten out on this list who were all in their prime, dude was otherworldly

[@MrBlynam]

Forgot about Zaha - 63

[@markwebb7576]

@@thecro2060 absolutely. For context, Ronaldo's and Messi's 5 year peaks in Spain are: Ronaldo: 259, Messi: 283

[@markwebb7576]

@@MrBlynam great shout. I tried to include those mentioned in the video plus a few others. Those are good numbers.

[@Bomberman60001]

Salah walks this list let's be real guy is the best winger of the premier league era and its not close

[@101notfound17]

Ain’t better than cr7 argue with a wall

[@TheBenj30]

@@101notfound17 Considering it's a Premier League list, he absolutely is better than Ronaldo and you just need to compare records for that - he is undoubtedly better than Ronaldo in the Premier League.

[@101notfound17]

@@TheBenj30 idc about the stats the fact is Ronaldo has won 3 prem titles ,a ballon dor ,a European golden boot ,two times player of the season,pfa player and young player of the season twice ,getting into ballon dor top 3 thrice ,winning a ucl ,ucl top scorer,2times ucl finals ,3 times ucl semis ,ucl player,uefa best ,fifa world player of the year 3 times in the fifa world xi ,4 times in uefa best xi all that being as a traditional winger not as an inverted forward like salah

[@TheBenj30]

@@101notfound17 Of course you don't care about the stats, if you did it would make your opinion completely baseless - and what you said wasn't a fact. Salah is vastly better of a player in the Premier League.

[@LordSeth-hf8ew]

based on what then lol you dont like facts you just using your own bias?@@TheBenj30

[@ob1slam]

Salah and Mane is incredibly disrespected. I understand bias will always come in to play, but just because they don't want to give credit to Liverpool, they down play everything those 2 players have done.

[@Do27gg]

Liverpool players will always be underrated for some reason, maybe because they’re African or not from traditional footballing countries

[@Deathmare235]

@@Do27ggeven that’s kinda bs since mahrez, a Muslim African gets respect even maybe more than he deserves, seems like a Liverpool bias

[@Do27gg]

@@Deathmare235 yeah true, even Trent, vvd etc don’t get their flowers. Suarez only got his respect once he moved to barcalona as well

[@alexwarren9730]

theyre just not as good as the very BEST the premier league have ever seen, if anything people like you overrate them and put them on bale or hazards level. just watch them play, they dont come close to the level that hazard, ronaldo, bale reached. they FULLY carried teams at times, salah and mane are part of an integrated system where they do their job very very well and contribute to the team massively. they dont shine as being the standouts in that liverpool team. firmino was as good as both of them.

[@WaniZame]

The disrespect to Salah and Mane from this panel.

[@joepoppleton7614]

Isn’t it crazy how a United fan, an Arsenal fan, a City fan, a Spurs fan and a Chelsea fan are disrespecting Liverpool wingers, it’s almost like they’ve got nobody to argue against them 😂

[@Romulan85]

They’re arguably one and two as well.

[@LFC-mr6yb]

If Liverpool won the covid cup where 30 out of the 38 games was played with fans. What is City’s title called where 0 games were played in front of fans?

[@PyroMiniYak]

Even if Liverpool had lost all their remaining games they still would’ve won the league. They were so dominant that year the league was already over by the time the pandemic started

[@oufc90]

That comment triggered you good 😅 honestly though I feel for you, I mean imagine finally winning it and not being able to properly celebrate… you must’ve been gutted. Maybe you’ll get a chance this season though good luck

[@randy2152]

Always the victim.

[@Robert-ks5ix]

​@@randy2152aways a bad nonce like randy2152

[@revoksfn7354]

City sell more tickets than Liverpool let's not even get started on season tickets we absolutely embarrass you

[@jakebarlowemotionaltherapist]

1. Mohamed Salah 2. Cristiano Ronaldo 3. Eden Hazard 4. Ryan Giggs 5. Gareth Bale 6. Robert Pires 7. Sadio Mane 8. David Beckham 9. Riyad Mahrez 10. Heung-Min Son

[@Pinhead___Larry]

Good list, I might swap Mane and Bale in terms of thinking soley what they did in the prem, but Bale defo had the best prem season of the two. Mane gets forgotten nowadays after the last two seasons at Bayern and now Saudi. But the penultimate season before leaving he was seen as better than Salah ... granted Salah had a slow season by his standards. I am Liverpool fan so there's bias, but it is hard not to put CR7 at the top. If Salah wins another PL for Liverpool then I think hes the undisputable no 1, atm its tough between the two

[@skgsinc1833]

Bale is above Hazard

[@Logicsupersedes]

The winger in the tradional sense is very much salah. Rory talking out of his arse again. He's talking about the old days when they were just RM and LM that played further out wide. Salah is in every sense of the word a winger, as is son. Rory has this habit of just pulling stuff out of his arse to try and make himself sound clever. It's so dumb it confuses people and they just ignore it.

[@michaellorenteshyllon4748]

Salah was a inside forward mate for the majority of his time at Liverpool. Stopped when Nunez joined

[@Festus034]

@@michaellorenteshyllon4748 his role is an inside forward his position is a winger two different things

[@thierryhenry674]

CristianoRonaldo, Giggs, Mahrez, Sane, Grealish, Sterling, Robben, JoeCole, Salah, Son, Hleb, Nasri, Arshavin, Sanchez

[@mass9504]

@@michaellorenteshyllon4748 he was not. his heat map every season is the same as every other traditional winger in Prem history

[@brettervonkanada6102]

Rory calls himself a pundit but doesn't understand the difference between position and a role 💀💀

[@wakantanka802]

RACISM, I'm calling it..If Salah wasn't Arab and a Muslim they would have obviously put him at number 1...Salah Most goals and assists on the wing in the PL anyway you mix it, far better than Ronaldo on the "WING" and Ronaldo hit his peak at Real Madrid not the PL!!!...Disgraceful, and I'm far from a Liverpool supporter...

[@roamingwildcampers2745]

Mad debate, look at the stats. Salah is far ahead, goals and assists...

[@jordandavis3867]

1) Salah (2nd Best all time foreign player in the Prem after Henry for me) 2)Christiano Ronaldo 3) Eden Hazard 4) Beckham 5) Giggs 6)Mahrez 7)Robert Pirez 8) Sadio Mane 9)Gareth Bale 10) Ginola *If we were talking in English football John Barnes would be top 5 but sadly not in the Prem.

[@bennrangphet9246]

Best list I’ve seen tbh mate

[@nascimentoarantes]

I’ll have Pires at 4

[@darrenpearson8451]

A human with a brain. 👍

[@jordandavis3867]

@@nascimentoarantes from a purely technical standpoint he's top 4 to 5, but impact has to be taken into consideration and the others before him in my list have had much bigger impact in either their contributions to trophies won for their club or individual achievements. Pires' style shaped the Salahs and Hazards of this world but they had either individual or team achievements that surpassed what he achieved.

[@pantrywarriors9577]

Ronaldo isn’t top 5.

[@MCBigz1]

This list was made before viewing the opinions in this video and I stand by it 💯 1. Salah 2. Ronaldo 3. Beckham 4. Hazard 5. Sterling 6. Giggs 7. Son 8. Mane 9. Mahrez 10. Pires 11. Sanchez 12. Bale Mix the eye test with the stats if you don’t agree 🤙 All-Time PREMIER LEAGUE Wingers…

[@nascimentoarantes]

Pires and Hazard are top 4.

[@ChorltonOutlaw]

You can’t have Sterling before Giggs

[@charliehancox6165]

Hazard was MILES better than Beckham, as was Bale.

[@MCBigz1]

@@charliehancox6165 Becks did it for 7/8 years - 142 goal contributions in 265 appearances 🔥👌 All-Time PREMIER LEAGUE Wingers…

[@MCBigz1]

@@ChorltonOutlaw Sterling hit double figures for goals 5 seasons in a row - whereas Giggs, only achieved double figures for goals 1 season in his whole 21 seasons in the Prem. This was the deciding factor for me but admittedly, it was close between the 2 players 🤝

[@NathII7752]

Salah Ronaldo Giggs Hazard Beckham Robben Mane Bale Mahrez Sterling The correct list in order

[@Do27gg]

I’d put giggs lower but other than that spot on

[@brandonmboya729]

I'd swap a certain ballorn dor winner and salah

[@skgsinc1833]

Hazard last

[@Tray23232]

Son above Robben

[@NathII7752]

@@Tray23232 True I dunno why I didn't put son 😅

[@elchapomaxman8456]

If salah isn’t no.1. You guys are all delusional, the best winger this country has ever seen by a mile. The stats don’t lie.

[@roamingwildcampers2745]

It's because Salah is an Arab, not a European...Hate to say it but Football Racism and Favoritism to a guy who had his best years at Real Madrid...

[@virtualcity721]

Salah is the greatest winger in the EPL of all time followed by Hazard, Bale and CR7

[@thierryhenry674]

Not Hazard and Bale. They are not tricky or tekky enough. Robben, JoeCole and Son are a lot more flashy and silky on the ball.

[@jamnewt7338]

I’d put Son above Bale

[@jamnewt7338]

@@thierryhenry674no Hazard? Your fucking nuts! That guy would jog through entire teams with the ball. Closest thing the prem ever got to Messi

[@vidalgutierrez9542]

@@thierryhenry674u are… dumb?

[@prodbymbrewer8002]

@@thierryhenry674hazard wasn’t tricky?? Are u mentally well?

[@filly8105]

The undisputed top 3 should be Salah Ronaldo and Hazard, honestly don't mind what order you have it in (because personal bias will come into play)

[@83hudini]

Giggs with 13 PLs has to be in a top 3. 24 years as a player, 23 of them as a starter for the dominating club. Incredible consistency. Just by sheer numbers he deserves a top 3.

[@abyysabyys]

Beckham was much better than Hazard so not undisputed at all, infact even gigs would be in there. Classic anyone but united crowd out in full force.

[@abdih5488]

@@abyysabyyswas Beckham the best player in a title winning team? Even top 3? Ahaha

[@abyysabyys]

@@abdih5488 Yes, comfortably? scored or assisted every winning goal at tne end of the season ffs.

[@Jared7628]

@@83hudini giggs is not top 10 be fr

[@alexischristou3266]

Salah is clearly the best winger in the premier league of all time, the maths do not lie. With C Ronaldo closely tucked up behind him and im putting Salah ahead because hes been in the premier league for 7 years and has been just freakishly consistent in scoring goals and assisting season to season, his numbers are absolutely stagerring for a winger.

[@scottishjp5082]

if going by numbers maybe but going by talent in my opinion no chance. Ronaldo lituarly carried united to a champions league title and premier league titles, they use to call it the ronaldo show also ronaldo has smashed so many records in the prem. Id rather than Ronaldo or Freddie Ljunberg on my right personally over salah. Ronaldo as a prem all time great he wasnt in the league long but id say it depends what you class as a good winger, is it someone who creates more chances than score or is it someone who scores more than they create? As becham was a fantastic right sided midfielder winger what ever didnt score as much but created more than salah probably has

[@alexischristou3266]

@@scottishjp5082 There is no maybe when it comes to numbers the maths never lie. You can rationalize any player you like to be the best winger but the facts and numbers are also applicable in Salah's case and the fact is nobody in premier league history has been this consistent for almost 7 years straight as a winger. You dont need to take my word for it just google it yourelf. You are not this insanely consistent if you are not talented. I just find the disrespect that Salah gets despite his achievements stagger me no end.

[@thecalrichards]

Well it’s a good thing stats aren’t the be all and end all isn’t it Coz if you watched both like I did it’s very clear Ronaldo was the better player in every aspect

[@alexischristou3266]

@@thecalrichards Its like im talking to brick walls here, were talking about just the premier league here not Ronaldos career as a whole and its clear that Salahs career in the premier league is superior both in terms of numbers and achievments compared to Ronaldos career just in the premier league.

[@LordSeth-hf8ew]

ronaldos best season in the prem clears salahs @@alexischristou3266

[@Stoicstruggle]

Salah #1. Sickening how low he is

[@marwanhisham233]

No he's not

[@alfronzocragimo-spicerini3828]

Salah is 1st for me not a Liverpool fan but he’s incredible

[@stephenrosca]

Some of these shouts are outrageous. Son above Salah😭😭😭😭 Mahrez above Salah. Salah is the best prem winger of all time and will finish as the best as well

[@michaelrowell7798]

No he is not. Giggs is

[@Ky-tz4pf]

@@michaelrowell7798giggs could never lace salah’s boots

[@Abdullah-t9c8f]

Salah for me he’s now the best player of all time in the league.

[@tomgriffiths2272]

Robben played 3 seasons at Chelsea and played and averaged 22 appearances a year, absolutely absurd shout.

[@arnfinson]

My top 10 1. Salah 2. Ronaldo 3. Beckham 4. Ginola 5. Giggs 6. Pires 7. Bale 8. Mahrez 9. Sterling 10. Hazard Honourable mentions: Son, Mane, Robben, Aaron Lennon & Theo Walcott

[@connortarrant4531]

Stinks

[@SamuelMills-ez4jo]

Great list. Hazard should be top 5

[@apt9238]

Today I learned Pires is criminally underrated. Spent 6 years in the Prem and in 3 of those he was in the TOTY competing with Giggsy for that left midfield spot. Won the FWA POTY in the 01/02 season too.

[@kevinsimpson-dw6vu]

Pires in the 2001/02 season was as good as it gets. Amazing season even accounting for his injury near the end.

[@ElDragow]

Ronaldo aswel, people like Rory say he didn’t do it long enough even tho he was 6 years in the league. Won 3 prem as the best player. Win every individual award in England possible. Etc… His Madrid prime was simply so good that people forget how good United Ronaldo was. If things had gone different he would have won 3 bdors in the prem and 3ucls.

[@Owenthomas1991]

Salah scoring 30 goals a season for 6 to 7 years straight. These boys are mad

[@saqib3055]

If it’s just the Premier league then salah has to be first,salahs first season was better then ronaldos treble season

[@mr4713]

@@saqib3055no it wasn’t Ronaldo was way better than that guy😂

[@saqib3055]

@@mr4713 not a chance,maybe when it came to doing stepovers but salahs first season was the best individual season from any winger

[@garywillmett8236]

Salah with more goals and over half the assist of beckham starts on wing for over 6 years and not a great winger 😮

[@TrentAlexanderArnold66LFC]

Salah is that good they won’t class him as a winger 😂 he’s the best ever

[@Abdullah-t9c8f]

To be honest, I consider him the best player of all time in PL

[@ZikalolLPL]

@@Abdullah-t9c8f thats outrageous

[@um931]

Salah is best winger PL history. Over Giggs or anyone else.

[@edenjorginho8604]

🤣🤣🤣

[@tomparle1508]

Easily

[@tomparle1508]

@@edenjorginho8604you can’t make a single decent argument to say he isn’t

[@cloudadwesley1610]

​@@tomparle1508Well, Salah is technically an inside forward rather than a winger, so... that statement is already wrong.

[@mikeyL575]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Daniel_ss4]

1. Salah 2. Ronaldo 3. Giggs 4. Hazard 5. Pires From an arsenal fan

[@brettervonkanada6102]

No matter what their style was, it's about how well they played from the LW/RW or LM/RM position. Some players were playmakers from the wing like Beckham, some were inside forwards like Salah but their position was winger so they all count. Mine is: 1 Ronaldo (it's just insane to argue about this) 2 Salah (no explanation needed) 3 Giggs (no explanation needed) 4 Mahrez (2016 alone would get him + he was crucial for City) 5 Hazard (just sensational) 6 Beckham (very special kind of winger, his style of play has never been replicated) 7 Bale (just sensational) 8 Sterling (great stats + longevity) 9 Son (incredible stats) 10 Mane (incredible stats) 11 Pires as honorable mention, he was amazing but the wingers that came after just have insane stats. Can't leave out people with 100 + GA. It's football, so goal contributions always count for more.

[@Kebabhunden]

hazard ahead of mahrez = perfect list

[@brettervonkanada6102]

​@@Kebabhunden Maybe. I know Mahrez wasn't as important for City as Hazard was for Chelsea. I put him there because of that one season, which may not be logical but for me is the greatest ever performance in PL from any player. He was the main man of the biggest underdog story I've seen since 2004 Euros.

[@Deathmare235]

@@brettervonkanada6102I love mahrez but he’s not better than hazard, that’s like putting vardy in top 10 pl strikers of all time

[@ajayagath5976]

1. Salah 2. CR7 3. Bale 4. Mane 5. Maherz 6. Hazard 7. Sterling 8. Son 9. Pires 10. Beckham

[@chrisg27]

The fact some of them didn't even have Hazard in the top 5 is unbelievable.

[@danmaher1862]

I can’t believe the only Chelsea fan on the panel put him 7th????

[@michaelrowell7798]

He would be 5th for me, he had 2 ordinary seasons (injury affected), but his talent was undeniable. Chelsea was title competing whenever he was on the pitch, injury free.

[@nascimentoarantes]

It is ridiculous and full of unsubstantiated bias.

[@skgsinc1833]

Overrated bum

[@Deathmare235]

@@michaelrowell7798other than bale, Ronaldo and Salah who’s better

[@alexharris6481]

This has to be the full time lineup going forward. Great Dynamic.

[@Obligated4]

How is salah not first? I thought he would be for sure 😂

[@Luke-jd7rf]

Because he’s not anywhere near ronaldo

[@trashed4005]

Rory did this on the SDS PL Striker top 10 as well. Said Salah wasn't a Winger but a Striker just because he scores goals and they said they all had Salah in their Winger list. I'm sure he's just doing this to be a contrarian at this point.

[@sk00p]

I see Salah as a' RF not RW.

[@Deathmare235]

No that was akinfenwa

[@jordy6144-d9t]

@@Deathmare235 I mean Akinfenwa did it aswell, but this comment is about Rory on SDS. So what's the point in bringing that up?

[@tempname4039]

The show is much better with him on it though, if everyone agreed, it would be v boring.

[@jordy6144-d9t]

He's doing it, because that's his opinion. He doesn't just change it and swing with the majority, like a sheep. Some people still have their own stances, you know... And I would actually agree, when it comes to Salah atleast. He's an inverted forward moreso than a winger.

[@Hyto1892]

Number one is Salah he's a winger simple

[@sethdaniel1115]

Salah > Cristiano in the prem

[@marwanhisham233]

Ronaldo won a bllon dor douchbag

[@mrcasino7051]

I hate the point of ‘They didn’t win trophies’ if that was the case Kane isn’t in the top 50 premier league strikers.. Trophies play a part but it’s not the be all and end all

[@TheAgeRating]

Salah end of debate

[@Young1Fendy]

Salah is the greatest premier league winger of all time, period.

[@yester9037]

Giggs was never a top 3 player on his team, when players like Hazard and Salah were the best players in the league.

[@Withcare11]

Not sure about this. Giggs, Scholes, Keane and Beckham is a pretty tough group to separate. All best in class at the time.

[@Deathmare235]

@@Withcare11giggs is easily the worst out of them

[@JKnight23]

Salah and then 9 others.

[@Hyto1892]

Salah is above Ronaldo for wingers

[@jamespace5429]

Anyone with Hazard and Salah outside the top5 are unserious. Hazard at 9, Son at 3. cmon

[@baileystewart391]

These city mugs 😂

[@mattsilliman1237]

Robben had 15 goals in 3 years.....an amazing player no doubt, one of the best wingers in world football all time, but not a top 10 winger int he premier league IMO.

[@nickbarrett2698]

the disrespect on salah is real with them lot - flav even had son above him . they also kept on giving excuses for not having a player in or higher , then using opposite reasoning for picking a player - 1 minute cant pick because wasnt in the prem for long enpough , then picking 1 that was in prem for not very long . they should have been given 10 players & told to put in order

[@filly8105]

Haven't watched it but Salah better be 1st (minimum 2nd)

[@ay-ui6bt]

sick winger salah is …

[@eurwvhu]

he’s the best, should be 1st

[@robbie1238]

@ay-ui6bt yes he is one of the best wingers ever

[@KeepItLevel]

Buvey had him in 6th place disrespect or what , hopefully Salah steam rolls city on the weekend

[@hyywe240]

Pires Sanchez Mane Sterling Beckham Bale Giggs Hazard Ronaldo Salah

[@bradley4706]

The disrespect to Hazard is crazy. I’m genuinely shocked.

[@tevildo45]

He’s overrated

[@ss-kg8hh]

better than sterling @@tevildo45

[@bradley4706]

@@tevildo45 the man was directly involved in 50% of all chelsea goals in the season we secured top 4 and best arsenal to win the europa league final. None of the players they mentioned could do what Hazard did to West Ham in his goal there. Not even Ronaldo did that. He scored in different ways but he couldn’t do that.

[@areyoudeadman]

Hazard can’t tie Ronaldo’s boots kid. Ronaldo could do everything and better than anyone else. Don’t compare the two it’s embarrassing

[@bradley4706]

@@areyoudeadman well you are wrong. You can lick his asshole later, people who actually understand football are talking, so go play in the corner or something.

[@wilshere1998]

Salah is no.1

[@scottbarkley496]

SALAH is clear

[@Do27gg]

Haven’t even watched this yet and I know most of these idiots will say Salah isn’t a winger but still classify hazard as a winger or son.

[@robbie1238]

Haven't watched it but salah better be top 2

[@edenjorginho8604]

🤣🤣🤣

[@robbie1238]

@@edenjorginho8604 whats funny about that?

[@mirkys130]

@@Dontmatter433if Salah retired tomorrow he would be top 2 so why not just give it not

[@robbie1238]

@Dontmatter433 yes they can what are you on salah already has bettered 95 percent of premier league wingers

[@Dontmatter433]

@@mirkys130 That was irony man😂😂Ofc salah is top 2

[@leeperryjr.v_v5299]

The Liverpool disrespect is so obvious. Barnes had everything, literally everything. Free kicks, left footed but equally as good on the right, power, pace and finishing. Fine he was past his prime when the prem came about but he was so versatile he moved into central midfield for the betterment of the team. If this panel weren’t so biased towards their own club Salah should easily be top two.

[@Harryyy2121]

Salah is top easy

[@elliothavik4697]

Salah is number one now come on

[@christopherwilliams4404]

SALAH ACTUALLY STANDS ON THE WING its like you don't watch the games at all. Look at his position and average position rory....

[@SucculentCh1neseMeal]

A table of woeful takes - good job lads

[@zombievikinggaming4258]

Damien Duff and what he did for Blackburn, Chelsea, Ireland, before his injuries ravaged run at Newcastle, was beyond Aaron Lennon. Go look up Duff vs Spain.

[@BirdLives7]

Mckola outdid himself saying Beckham was a much better player than Debruyne 🤡

[@jaysmith2858]

Beckham is one of the most overrated players of all time, if not the actual most overrated.

[@decdeckers]

Disrespect on Sadio Mane’s name!

[@gavbailey4363]

Salary is No.1, end of. The stats bare that out.

[@sam8893]

He won’t be mentioned too much, but Marc Overmars was absolutely electric to watch. As a Chelsea fan, my top 3 would be Hazard, Salah and Ronaldo if we’re talking all time.

[@ZimaBlue1225]

Is it me, or is Rory becoming increasingly more and more of an absolute Bellend!

[@jaysmith2858]

That's what happens when you start working for TalkSport.

[@luckyigbomor4088]

Damien Duff was awesome.

[@Labtiger69]

Rory not ever taking a single sip of his Guinness irks me so much more than it should 😂

[@danmaher1862]

Hazard anything lower than 5th is outrageous, especially from Rory

[@skgsinc1833]

He's last

[@scottlaquis5564]

What am I watching. Man put son in 3 and buvey put mahrez in 3 both above salah. This is an absolute disasterclass

[@abdullahiumar1273]

Someone should please ask rory if ronald koeman was a striker, since he also scored his goals centrally. I want to see something

[@Hyto1892]

Buvey the COVID cup was the year after when City won the league the big fucking dope

[@alexbrown975]

As a kid growing up in the 90s. We would have Prem players come to training and do q and A's. All the defenders would say Giggs and Ginola were the hardest wingers to play against. So for me they are the 2 best from that era. Then in the more modern era it was Ronaldo, Bale, Hazard and Salah. I think Saka could eventually make the list if he continues to develop and maintain his current form. Mahrez could of made the list but Guardiola didn't play him enough.

[@sib1930]

Mcmanaman in the 90s as well

[@alexbrown975]

@@sib1930 absolutely! Can't believe I forgot about him.

[@jayfe86]

"Now that's What I call Wingers 1998" might be the funniest thing ever said on this podcast

[@lewisward7956]

A Liverpool fan on the panel would be nice

[@Deathmare235]

Wasn’t the black guy a Liverpool fan?

[@oliverdowntonbent5333]

10: Bale 9: Heung min son 8: raheem Sterling 7: Robert Pires 6: David Beckham 5: Sadio mane 4: Ryan giggs 3: Eden Hazard 2: salah 1: ronaldo Only correct list

[@KremBananTV]

The Club needs to try to get Ian Wright or someone from that period to educate them on players like Barnes, Beardsley, Le Tissier, David Rocastle and so on.

[@fivestarman5130]

In fairness Barnes, Rocastle and Beardsley both peaked in the First Division era and none of the lads would be old enough to remember them

[@KremBananTV]

@@fivestarman5130 That's why they should get someone on the show and educate the lads :)

[@josh23992]

Ronaldo Salah Bale Mahrez Hazard Giggs Beckham Mane Son Pires In no particular order

[@JamesLimb]

Salah's arguably top 3. Look at his stats and consistency over the time

[@joe-mh1vu]

No arguably. Definitely and probably number one

[@lawrencebaker1811]

Arguably? Should be inarguable.

[@HK-do7bf]

The same ones arguing about Salah not winning enough titles are the same ones who put kane up there as top 3 strikers ever in prem without a title 😂

[@onetwo8847]

These lot couid do a "Top 10 English attacking mids in Prem history" list and half these absolute fools would start screaming "what trophy did Le Tissier ever win??"

[@jaysmith2858]

According to them and that criteria for picking a player, they'd have Darren Fletcher over Steven Gerrard. 🤦

[@fivestarman5130]

No way Buvey ranked Salah at 6th because he only won a single Premier League and then puts Gareth Bale 2nd😭😭😭

[@jaysmith2858]

If you're looking for intelligence, logic and common sense, you're not going to find any emanating from the mouth of Buvey.

[@lewisepicfootycontent5934]

Buvey salah would have 3 prems if he wasn’t up against 115ffp charges

[@Me-gs3uu]

1. Eden Hazard 2. David Ginola 3. Riyad Mahrez 4. Marc Overmars 5. Robert Pires 6. Alexis Sanchez 7. Gareth Bale 8. Cristiano Ronaldo 9. Ryan Giggs 10. Steve McManaman

[@stewiegriffinfan123]

but ronaldo literally meets all of rorys criteria on what a winger was played in a 442 and still bagged over 20 goals in 3 consecutive seasons

[@inquisitorsneed2]

He was played on the right of a front 3

[@stewiegriffinfan123]

@@inquisitorsneed2 man utd under fergie never played with a front 3 it was always 442 him and giggs/nani on the wings with rooney and tevez/berbatov up front

[@conorseanmurtagh9963]

I caught that from Adam “Rory releasing Now that’s what I call wingers” joke…….incredible 😂😂

[@brudbruh]

Hazard 9th!?!?!?!?

[@trenddyy3462]

Son over Salah is crazy from the tottenham fan.

[@edenjorginho8604]

hazard first and its not close

[@Daniel_ss4]

Hazard is the best dribbler but overall winger salah all day every day

[@edenjorginho8604]

@@Daniel_ss4salah better goal scorer that’s it

[@MemphisGoar]

​@@edenjorginho8604and goals win matches. It's the hardest things to do in football. Hope you didn't get the memo 😅

[@AusSpurs]

I would go: 1. Salah 2. Ronaldo 3. Bale 4. Hazard 5. Giggs 6. Mahrez 7. Son 8. Pires 9. Beckham 10. Mane

[@k17nopasi]

The disrespect to John Barnes is unbelievable. Top 5 wingers across the entirety of top tier English football history

[@nateb8282]

Haha good one

[@Callumh1113]

Load of rubbish

[@Robert-ks5ix]

​@@nateb8282clearly never seen him play

[@sib1930]

​@@nateb8282It's true tho. Cry about it