O'keefe Foundation - 46 and 2 (Tool cover) REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!

[@aaronlane5000]

MUSICIANS: Drums / Curtis Moss Bass / AJ Allen Vocals / Kala Rose Lead Guitar / Chris DeYoung Rhythm Guitar / Jacob Boldman Piano / Olivia Martin Claves / Geoffrey Lewis Djembe / Jack Riley Bongos / Kane Jacobs

[@jonathanbouthillette753]

missed opportunity to make the video 46 minutes and 2 secondsn long

[@JDC701]

The little dude just killing it on drums is absolutely the highlight for me

[@DizzyD850]

Curtis is a beast

[@danielmcbride2375]

I can't say anything bad about these kids or the foundation. To take kids and teach them complex music and they do it well, better than some adults, is impressive beyond words. Props to the kids, teachers. Instructors, everyone involved. I'd be so much farther along in music had I been involved in a foundation like this.

[@ianfranks541]

I'm in Arlington, TX right now on a business trip. And I was having supper while watching this video. And a lady came up to me and said OMG!! DAVID HERETIC!! I LOVE HIS REACTIONS!" Haha thought that was really cool!

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Oh lord....it's spreading.....

[@ianfranks541]

@@THEDavidHeretic like a wild fire!

[@treysalazar7791]

Great performance. Kala Rose, same vocalist from the O'Keefe cover of "Sober".

[@karlbecker8775]

Thank you for supporting the cause! What they do with these kids is amazing!

[@chrispowers8339]

First reaction I’ve seen when someone caught the bass player going over the top-good eye!😉👍😂🙏🫡

[@kh-sp1sm]

I see Tool.. I click

[@cheezypoofkc673]

I've been watching this video about every other week or so for a while. The kids are amazing. The kid on the sticks playes drums on No More Tears and drops a drum stick without missing a beat. The drummer is the one that wanted O"Keefe to do the song. The singer is in some rocking music videos and I've heard she at one time had her own band.

[@smilie-pm9gb]

She sings in "Saving Escape" kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWTQeYSde9aiaMU

[@billyowen9800]

I honestly think that the piano added quite a bit to the feel of this version.

[@BluesDeville]

I do too. Piano gave a great contrast to the distorted guitars and bass.

[@PowderedToastMan420]

The kid playing the Claves is killing it. ✌️

[@sherlock595]

Kala Rose is going to be just fine, I've seen the Crazy Horse cover!

[@cfrancis325]

I don't blame you for going back. They were amazing.

[@brandonmcheyenehoward1077]

46 and 2 was not my go to tool song until I heard these kids do it. And now it’s one of my favs. This was a magical performance.

[@doolok]

Gotta do their Rammstein cover next....it will completely blow your mind.

[@arjantje7596]

You did the song I requested! Glad you liked it David!

[@vinograd74]

At last! A request for a song that is surely interesting for the Reviewer! Glad you have watched this!

[@PowderedToastMan420]

The future of Rock n Roll is in good hands. ✌️

[@stitch3163]

AJ Allen is the young man playing bass and Curtis Moss is the young man playing the drums. I agree, both were the standouts in this performance. Wishing them all the best in their future careers.

[@Somasteel]

update youtube.com/@KalaRose heres here stuff think drummers Barry....

[@wiseguerrero1]

They star on my eyes

[@thechefmechanic2484]

I've got lumps on my throat watching this cover.

[@jzeke1712]

The Okeefe cover of Iron Maiden’s Number of the Beast is by far their best cover, even though 46&2 is by far their most popular. The kid singing in Number of the Beast is incredible.

[@heyskipj]

Great that you mentioned the drummer. He was the one who brought the song to the foundation for the performance. I’ve also heard the singer has had some moderate post-foundation success. Great instinct by her using a falsetto there. Great choice.

[@brucenadeau5920]

yeah she was in a few bands I had read.

[@heyskipj]

@@brucenadeau5920 But any word on if that silky bass player kept going?

[@92ElDuderino]

Kala got her own band now called "Saving Escape".

[@stephaniegeer1691]

That's freaking awesome!! Great drumming skills on that kid!!😃also,he has fantastic taste in tunes!!🎶✌

[@stephanieallangarman5598]

After watching these AMAZING young artists…I believe they’ve made me research these bands that I had no knowledge of. Okeefe Music Foundation is SUPERB at supporting these youngsters with their individual musical abilities. Thank you for sharing your analysis and support. GREAT 👍🏽 CHOICE. Happy Holidays ❄️☃️🤍🙏🏽 2022’.

[@ericflaherty4668]

I've seen this multiple times and never caught that over hand slide the bass player did 😆

[@kevinstenger9758]

Gotta do Number of the Beast (Iron Maiden) by O'Keefe! Same bass player and drummer when they were a little younger. Also do I'm Broken(Pantera) from O'Keefe Music Foundation!

[@Somasteel]

looking for you now stay tuned!

[@armchairgravy8224]

I love a good cover song, and this is a great cover song.

[@MarkStettler]

I don't have the knowledge, skills & ability to dissect music like you, but I certainly appreciate your pro breakdown, and happy that a legit musician thinks this tune rocks too! Cheers!

[@Somasteel]

update kzbin.info/www/bejne/iaqWc56kic6cjtE Saving Escape features vocals Kala Rose Scarpinski ,Her bestie from O'keefe Charolette ( piano 46 an 2) on BASS and one of the Guitarists from O'keefe no idea about 2nd guit. Alex ,Drummer from their high school here performing weatherman live sound rec.quality not great...and she is been with Brad Manning recog.vocal coach!

[@rayyman6934]

These kids were still learning their craft as young musicians. They are not equal to professionals. They didn't have enough experience yet.

[@tylerpd52]

I've always like this version of 46 & 2 best

[@jan.toledo]

thanks

[@NoSmokingDogs]

You can't compare the two scores, the Tool score was for the song itself, this score was only for the performance.

[@hardcorechristopher9174]

Great job

[@eggstu]

Epic rant about the credits brother

[@Captain_Kirk116]

They definitely should've given these kids their due by mentioning their names in the credits. I noticed that this kid going beastmode on the drums uses Sabian cymbals and Pau from The Warning also uses Sabian, so I guess there's something about that brand that makes awesome drummers beat the crap out of them lol! Idk if I like this version more than the original but the piano was definitely a great addition to the song, very well done cover by all of them.

[@deadlyredly1]

What you say at the start is absolutely right mate. These kids (yes kids, but...) put a video out there - and they nailed it. They 100% need to be there for the negative as well as the positive. Credit (and dissing) where it is due.

[@paulalloyd8860]

Great reaction!!! I think you should still be teaching kids. You have a great passion for music and the kids feed off that. ❤

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I miss teaching, and I miss the kids....but I absolutely do not miss the politics.

[@paulalloyd8860]

Oh is that why you got so emotional reacting to Sound of Silence by Disturbed?

[@SergeSmirin]

hey man, you are the only one who noticed that move 13:25 ))))

[@AngelofSunday]

This is absolutely bananas! Brought tears to my eyes first time I saw it. Props to the parents of these kids! Metal lives on!!! Edit: pretty sure the kids do the videography- not necessarily the performers- and also- yessss the end is better than tool for sure. This same young lady also does pull me under by dream theater. Another absolute banger from O’Keefe. Please check that out!!!

[@Somasteel]

JOSH she names you as the one that helped her get confident.lol goodwork if your that josh cole she credits

[@jimioi8734]

I agree with the whole thing about if these kids want to be musicians they have to be able to take criticism, but this is also roughly a 10 year old girl singing vocal parts of an adult male so I think she killed it. It reminds me of the who's Tommy movie. It was all sang by other artists with different genders and vocal ranges all being sang based off of.what Roger Daltrey had already performed. They had to make it work, though. She killed it. They all killed it. BTW. I usually hate to hear kids sing.

[@Somasteel]

David it used to be in there think there May have BEEN an incident the Vocalist is Kayla Rose last name forgotten this was rec. when she was 14 she at 18 was fronting a band she is from cleveland this RECORDING engineer made her "electric" last verse after drum break rare everyone seeks that so Engineer Zach deserves KUDO's!!!

[@darrenjohanson3594]

An old saying is hard work will always beat talent

[@bsargent8935]

These kids make me feel lacking as a dad. Lol.

[@dsgp7835]

The use of a little ten year old girl wearing a rock angel t shirt singing Maynard lyrics is genius. Kala blows me away with her interpretation of Maynard. The whole band is awesome. Thanks for reacting to the O'keefe Music Fountain.

[@MsNewsted]

I recorded this to play in my car.. It sound way better on my speakers.. I know you got a nice system in you car.. give it a try :) They more tool and Dream theater.

[@shawnellerton7074]

The lead was 11, the rest of the band were between 13 and 16 except the one young man. Exceptional performance. And that drummer...beat them like they owed him money. :)

[@dariendudley941]

Dave ya gotta understand in this Era we live in now they give kids participation awards ho figure

[@BamaMatters11]

The kids names are in the description of the original video lol.

[@NoSmokingDogs]

Beat me to it.

[@zephyr835]

I didn't think I'd end up watching this in full, but that was fun. Pointing out things like the flat note is good, because it's something that can be improved, and it's not like it's a personal attack. Too much hand-waving means that inaccuracy essentially becomes the standard. I really like what she did, though, like with the flips and her overall tone. Combined with the rest of the song melodically, I was getting shades of Uninvited from Alanis Morissette. And yeah, the piano was a nice addition, and I love the breakdown with just that and the bass.

[@merlinnuffsaid5054]

I couldn't agree more. This was better than Tool's version of Tool's song, lol. I wonder if we were to switch roles for a bit and have Maynard sing with this band, I wonder how it would sound then and back then with those exact kids. I am not taking anything away from Kala at all, she was great, loved her but I like to see half n half with covers. Thanks for covering this reaction..

[@terrahawk1977]

Settle down this is a long one. I’ve listened to this loads of times it’s nuts good 👍👍

[@todddole4855]

Love it man. Constructive criticism. The greats in any business, listen to someone trying to help them.

[@mitchbuchannon6637]

Yuuussss

[@velvetboots]

It's better than the original song in my opinion. Listen to You Should Be Mine, they did, by Guns N Roses. I love No More Tears by Ozzy too. 46 and 2 definitely my favorite. Listen to the band with Okeefe's Foundation that does Pantera songs and Let The Bodies Hit The Floor. They are Already concert worthy!!🤯🤯🤯 Check out the Little girl and the musicians that cover Blood Letting.

[@maureenwagg5305]

Hey, you're so right. Constructive criticism is warranted. That's what the kids would want. They are fantastic for their ages. Check out their version of Crazy Horse by Black Label Society. Kala Rose is the singer and she's 11 in this video, I think. In the other video she's 18. Quite a change.

[@stanreaper3080]

A great cover! I always think I might like this version more, then I switch over to the original. Nah, not as good but still great! I do think the sound is fuller at the end, but the ending of the original, Adam's guitar just f-ing growls, along with Justin's thunderous tone. I don't get that from this ending.

[@arthurluis80]

Please, react to Europe - Ninja

[@CAGE497]

Their names were in the credits had ya let it roll

[@RaginKavu]

Great react. I always thought that this version was better than the original. That kind of treatment, of being held accountable and being treated as a professional was not the main factor, but it definitely contributed to the success of the girls of Babymetal.🤘🏻🦊🤘🏻 On another note, the singer is called Kala Rose. I've seen some recent videos of her and she's still nails it!

[@oscardiggs246]

I love the original, but something about this arrangement is even better. I think all of these kids have aged out of the program by now, this one is pretty old. Curtis Moss has his own channel where he does drum covers with the same fire seen here. Kala Rose sang on an OMF cover of Crazy Horse that you would probably like. It's a startling performance to see how she's grown as a singer and performer.

[@nitrodad5775]

I’ve listened to this a bunch of times before listening to the original and I must say I like OMF’s rendition much better than the original. Thanks for the review 👍

[@hayneshvac2]

Would I ridicule Maynard...not at all, especially if he were 11 years old...I don't expect the level of professionalism that Maynard's years of experience has brought from an 11 year old who is just starting...for someone who has had little experience, I feel in comparison to her peers, she is on top of her game, very talented, and has amazing potential to grow...The real question is, How good was Maynard at 11...that's the proper comparison.

[@randywenrick2393]

Curtis moss on drums

[@paulalloyd8860]

I think Maynard would be thrilled!!!

[@gable354]

🔥🔥🔥🔥🚒🚒🚒🔥🔥🧯🧯

[@colnixon8989]

Sounded perfect to me, but that's why I am not a professional musician.

[@Somasteel]

Kala rose scarpinski !

[@WhatAboutRC]

Moral of this video.. He says a statement at the first that some might see has a bit hard. Then spends the rest of the video trying to justify it. Either say it or dont... Those of us that get it will get it and you just make the rest of the video annoying, And those that dont, you arent going to say anything that they will change their mind to anyways.

[@shatteredstiks7392]

Maybe she's dealing with her of shadow of confidence with her voice as the song goes.

[@yanickmalard9635]

Hello David, I love your reactions and if you want to try another Tool cover, try this Lateralus cover, the guy is amazing kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXurm3-dq5Z4hpY

[@aedep]

I agree!

[@Covaids]

David unfortunately we live in a world now where everyone gets a participation trophy and criticism is frowned upon.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

And mediocrity is praised. I know, trust me I know. I miss the good old days.

[@StoneShards]

Vocalist reminds of Lacy Sturm...So, this is like, uh, "School of Rock", right! The O'Keefe Music Foundation is doing a good thing! At nine mins in, I'll guess we're headed for about 7.2...'cause it seems to me there's a certain something missing..."groove", perhaps...they're, "hard on the clock". I'm not familiar with Tool--do they swing the rhythm at all?...............drum roll........eight.five, eh? hmm...extra voices, ok; vocalist was flat once, ok, though not a check in the plus column; falsetto thin and weak, but sweetness, ok; bassist and drummer stole the show, ok, though guitarist's staccato wasn't staccato enough; last minute of song was really thick powerful intense aggressive--better than Tool! That was your review, Dave, which, for once, I found unpersuasive. Bound to happen, I'm sure! Good show, Dave!

[@1bossdj]

They're minors and the school might have reasons for not sharing kids' info.

[@TaverenTech]

Wait! what! treat kids like professional musicians... you don't think every child should get a trophy? I get frustrated when I try to teach my 6yr old about having to put in effort to succeed and he regurgitates the stuff they teach him in school... how its ok to make mistakes, everyone does it their own way... when they don't yet understand the realities of life. And the music industry is brutal. They'll cut a kids contract as fast as any adult.

[@rodneyespinoza2492]

I agree better than Tool!

[@dariendudley941]

OMF HAS A COVER CRY LITTLE SISTER BETTER THAN ORIGINAL

[@dariendudley941]

They also do 4 different versions of the pot

[@gabrielstratton1775]

They actually kept the kids names out by request from their parents for safety reasons

[@BamaMatters11]

If that was the case then why are their names in the description of the original video smh.

[@TheTurinturumbar]

It's not cruel and I'm sick of that view. It's time to call that dishonest bs out at every turn. It's short term mean to be long term kind as opposed to "it's hard being honest so I'll just set you up for a more massive reality check later". That's what's cruel but it's dishonest and cowardly to boot. I mean you're actually lying in order to be cruel by proxy.

[@michago8725]

Please do me a favour and keep your comments shorter. In the moment you're killing your own videos.

[@308lonegunman]

Tell me you're not a liberal without telling me you're not a liberal, lol... The no victim mentality speech about treating as pro's... Good sh*t...