Peel & Stick Tile: dollar store vs Amazon vs brand name... which is BEST?! | The DIY Mommy

[@monicaconstanza40]

Yes. I’m a strong believer in the saying “You get what you pay for”. Thank you for the review. I’m looking at backsplash options for our kitchen renovation, your review is helpful.

[@angelinacarraway3576]

Ty so much for an honest opinion I’m low income n so dang tired of wasting what lil money I hav bc some influencer wants to lie to me about an item they r reviewing jus so they can make $$ off of a good review n so u will use their affiliate link!!!!!!

[@theeluannesantos]

Same here. I only have a handful of influencers I trust, but I still read reviews on products and check the return policy

[@thediymommy]

Thanks for watching! I think it's extremely important to share honest opinions on products.

[@mnamous9823]

@@thediymommy Any updates on how that Amazon tile has held up?

[@doratiscareno5856]

JUDGE FOR YR SELF THE DOLLAR TREE ONES ARE JUST AWFUL AND AWFUL TO LOOK AT I WOULD NEVER PUT THEM UP ON MY WALL...ILL SPEND MORE FOR BETTER QUALITY 👏👍ONES THAT LOOK GOOD

[@doratiscareno5856]

@@thediymommy How did the Amazon Tiles work out for you...?

[@jonesyrn71]

I was watching this thinking... ugh... but no one knows cold.... then you said ALBERTA CANADA!!!! I'm in EDMONTON!!! Thank you so much xo

[@thediymommy]

Oh, I KNOW cold! HAHA!

[@elainerobertson7329]

You sure did a great job on all projects. Once again, quality counts.

[@VioletJoy]

Honestly, I was impressed with all of them. Of course depending on the situation, one would be more appropriate than another. But, if someone has an ugly wall and no money, the Dollar Tree tiles would be a huge improvement! It's a super cheap way to cover sins, add texture and give a clean look.

[@montanaelise23]

I agree! I am updating my apartment and I wanted something cheaper because I don’t know how long I’ll be there. As well, the dollar tree tiles seem like the easiest to remove

[@VioletJoy]

@@montanaelise23 How fun! I wish you could share an "after" pic! But, no can do on KZbin. Hope it works out. 🙂

[@weetzybat]

Sins😂

[@joslynperryelliott456]

As a newbie Peel and stick remodeler, very informative! Thank you

[@younyqworld]

I have been pondering to figure out which brand to use because I didn’t want to be bothered with the lifting so thank you for your honesty!

[@amypoole30]

I have just begun watching this but hands down Roomates from Amazon!!!!!! I did the mini subway tile white with grey grout! Very forgiving on horrible rental walls. 1 year no bubbling tons of repositioning got the info from another youtuber in Canada!

[@thediymommy]

Great to know; thank you!

[@mesongs3946]

Hi Amy is the brand roommates ? Looking to buy on amazon , except looking for the Moroccan style for my boho caravan makeover 🥰 Thanks

[@karennetherland2327]

Christina, thanks so much for doing this video. I have been wanted to put up a peel and stick backsplash but, I was hesitant because usually they don't work . So it's true, you get what you pay for. I totally guessed wrong. I thought for sure you'd shock us all and say the dollar store tile. Again, thanks.

[@bingersinger1517]

I’ve used several peel and stick products. I will always pay extra for the Smart Tiles. It is still holding in my Master bath. WalMart version has failed in bathroom 2!!

[@janbarriault4494]

was thinking about doing bathroom accent... good to know! thanks

[@patrickarchuleta9594]

You have to know what to use that will stick any tile for centuries.

[@Mary-jm5zm]

@@patrickarchuleta9594 what should we use?

[@sithakhounborinh5181]

lol

[@lumijasminasmr3583]

I love your honesty, calm nature and the effort you put in all your videos. ✨

[@joycesanderson7083]

We have Smart Tiles as our kitchen backsplash and years later they are still looking great. People think they are glass!! We are redoing out countertop and will definitely get Smart Tiles again. Quite a savings from glass type backsplash. 👍

[@JJAM60]

Sometimes its just best to spend the extra dollars for something that lasts longer. You can always cut back on other things to make up the difference.

[@lyn1991]

I used the Amazon pile and stick tile. I had issues of it not sticking and it was more difficult to put up than I thought. I used it in my bathroom, but it is pretty and I’ve had a lot of nice comments. I just use stick glue. It’s been up for about three years now, so I think I have glued my last edge.

[@annastavola7999]

Lyn, what kind of glue did you use?

[@doziercreations6209]

Probably a glue stick

[@victoriayoder7502]

I've used several brands in different homes, rooms, etc and I've had the same experience. 6 years after installing, my Smart Tiles still looked as good as when I put them up. Others I've used, not so much. I have a white hexagon ones in my kitchen currently from Amazon (slightly bigger than the ones you put up), and, although they look great, they started coming up in spots within several months of putting them up.

[@emilye709]

The dollar one looks so nice!

[@theeluannesantos]

I figured you get what you pay for when it comes to peel and stick. Thank you for this video and for always being honest in your videos. I’ve been subscribed for a while but don’t comment often. Now that I know how much it helps your channel I’ll leave more comments.

[@thediymommy]

Thanks; I appreciate it!

[@BT-502]

I just bought dollar tree peel and stick today, it looks great! I hope it works for a while

[@carolevans5285]

What about adding ur own adhesive to the cheaper ones, just a thought

[@RAIRADIO]

The glue gets very tight as time passes and very difficult to remove later. After leaning my lesson once, I only peel and stick the corners and not the whole sheet.

[@lesliebeacom4567]

@@carolevans5285 I agree. I use an adjustable spray adhesive that you can now find in hardware stores. Used to only find in art supply stores.

[@ginafriend1690]

I would have thought the most expensive. Adhesive is probably stronger.

[@janicehedley1006]

I bought my white subway tile from Rona. Expensive brand name. Package of 4 (12x12) for over $40.00. Put some tiles on months ago and noticed them peeling away and every so often I have to push the lifting. I applied the balance of the wall last week. For the older parts lifting, I added some glue to areas to stop the titles that lifting. Glad I won't be here in 10 years if pick and stick tiles need replacing. But they are beautiful over my counter and behind the stove looks great. Totally added beauty to my home.

[@lavernepuller3080]

Thank you so much for this video, your timing is perfect! I'm getting my tiny rental ready for the upcoming holidays, and Winter, by painting EVERYTHING brilliant white. But I couldn't decide one which peel'n stick tile to choose. Now I know, I just need to choose the pattern. Stay safe, and I'll see you in the next video!🤗

[@mfspataro]

Hi, It also depends on the quality of tiles that you're buying from amazon, I bought my tiles there, and it looks amazing!

[@dazem8]

do you remember what brand you got from amazon? I'm browsing 😃

[@Alicia-ig7cv]

Thanks for your honesty 🙂

[@maryoverton1126]

So happy I found you because Ive cleaned my wall thoroughly now waiting for them to dry then I'm putting up Tic Toc subway peel and stick! I'll post before and after

[@lorrainegatzke1048]

Thank you Christina, that was very informative and helpful. 💖👋🇿🇦

[@soffyabad]

Bad thing that not all of dollar store. worth even a dólar, I heard that is not the best to buy there, for example shampoo, microfiber towels, and so on, just cleaning products are good. Thanks for the honesty Kristina😊🤗

[@ketherwhale6126]

Smart tiles! I’ll have to remember that.

[@leamonroe-odette1997]

I guessed Amazon, so glad to know there is a difference!

[@kimbwf629]

They all look great but the quality difference seems to be in adhesive. I wonder if any product exists that would enhance the poorer quality tiles that would be reasonably priced and easy to apply? Otherwise buying the more expensive tiles may be the way to go. Great info!!

[@thediymommy]

I'm not too sure, but if I find anything I'll share!

[@dekaaden178]

I discovered you today n am binge watching your videos... love them

[@は私です彼の名前]

This product is a God Send for campers and RVs. It is crazy top me that folk try to use real tile and real wood in those RVs adding sooo much weight. This stuff looks just as good and way more practical for RVs.

[@thediymommy]

Totally agree with you!

[@lizdc1]

I have tic toc subway tiles with commercial adhesive in my camper. They were more $ but after about 18 months they are still perfect. Makes my kitchen look and feel like a kitchen in my small space. I also have the marble look contact paper you recommended for a table top we made. It is also still perfect.

[@thediymommy]

That's great!

[@catheyahannas3240]

I wonder if you take a hair dryer and activate the glue again on the places that are popping up if that might solve that problem?? I have had to do that with floor tiles.

[@marilynnschroeder4436]

It would have been nice to know how that expensive tile holds up over a stove/near heat.

[@saharvarona]

Thanks sooo much for this video!! Question: will these smart tiles work well in a bathroom with lots of moisture? I will be doing a renter-friendly reno when i move to canada and i am in search of good quality tiles for walls and floors!

[@thediymommy]

I think they'd be fine by a sink, but not around a tub or shower.

[@Kevin-sm8pn]

Omf. No. No. No. NO!

[@alive-awake]

Does it ruin the camper walls when you remove it, say you want to change the whole thing out?

[@leslietran1922]

Great video! Do you have videos how to put on your RV counter top and your RV walls? Hope there’s videos of it. Thank you so much for sharing your videos.

[@ChefBoiImHungry]

1 trick on any brand tile backsplash/floor.....use spray adhesive on the lift spots or for new install it will never lift! ;)

[@racemom777]

How about adding extra adhesive before installing? Perhaps it would devert the lifting.

[@olguiq1013]

Thank you Christina... Smart Tile it is!!!

[@amyyoung2804]

Looks great. Quick question..could I peel and stick tile over existing real tile? Appreciate your answer. Thanks much.

[@janetgushleff9983]

I’m consider peel and stick tiles for a backsplash in a small camper that I’m re-doing but I’m concerned about the heat and humidity since it will be left unattended during the week and I’m afraid the heat might play havoc on it. Any chance anyone has had this experience and what success or failure have you had? Thanks

[@belindaaguirre8181]

I’m so glad you did this video. Thank you.

[@2new2this]

Hey fellow Albertan! I'm curious as too how it will come off? Will it rip the layer below it or is there a product you recommend to remove said peel & stick tiles?

[@thediymommy]

You should just be able to gently peel it off. It's going to depend what's underneath, but if it's well cured paint, there shouldn't be much damage (if any).

[@allystanhope4431]

Hi! We removed some stick on tiles from our powder room that the previous owner installed and they did peel off paint and damage the dry wall paper. We had to patch it before we could paint. I supposed it would depend on the brand of sticky tiles as well.

[@mssixty3426]

My guess would be the brand name would hold up the best. Dollar store the least likely to last, based on other products I've bought at the Dollar Store. I haven't bought home hardware or decor items from Amazon. The problem where I live in the desert Southwest of the U.S. is high summer temps and dry heat, adhesives don't last.

[@gratitude1181]

I really appreciate your honesty it helped me a great deal 🌻 and thanks for sharing

[@allystanhope4431]

Be careful with any peel and stick tiles if you ever plan on removing them from the wall. The previous owners of my house put them in as a backsplash in the powder room and they came off easily but heavily damaged the walls/peeled off paint - and we were very careful taking them off.

[@thediymommy]

Yes, it's going to depend on the tile, the installation, and the wall as to how easy the tile will be to remove. Sorry you had to deal with that!

[@hayden47371]

I know your comment is a year old, but did you use a solvent with the adhesive when you were removing? Just curious for my future self!

[@allystanhope4431]

@@hayden47371 we did not, maybe that was our mistake, but the way people describe this material is you shouldn't need to. I don't know if it would have helped because i don't think it would have been able to get through the tile to the adhesive.

[@GailWhimsy]

Great comparison! Thank you so much for posting this.

[@Klutzy68]

This was very helpful. I didn’t even know dollar stores carried tiles. I was quite impressed with how your Smarttiles held up and went to their website. Unfortunately all they have is black, white and gray. I need color! Do you have any other recommendations?

[@bjwieland-doucet5917]

Good to know. Will check on other "name brands" here.

[@EdinaViensBreakthroughCoach]

Is this easily removable after a year ? I don't want mess up a rental property.

[@martinebangs6520]

Hi Christina....thanks for the update on your tiles...It's snowing up north in Ontario as of yesterday, it's not here yet in North Bay but it won't be long...ugh....Take care....stay safe...

[@gwenrowe2721]

Maybe I missed it . What was the verdict on t he tile we are waiting for?

[@nancybrewer4452]

Thanks 😊 so much for this video. I am adding backsplash in my kitchen and I really learned a lot today!!

[@BeautiflyyBargains]

I'm in Alberta Canada too. So happy to find your channel

[@bethhoppes6388]

Thank you for this info. We are getting ready to install a peel and stick tile in a home we are updating to sell. Hopefully it will turn out.

[@didthatreallyjust]

Why would u put something temporary up for someone who is paying a lot for something long term. I hope u let them know their tiles are peel and stick

[@bernadettep3293]

Its really good to know, I ordered some from Amazon and never installed them becuase somebody mentioned it will always peel off. So I bought very similar subway tiles ( I do like big one but its over my budget so this, small tiles still beautiful and affordable from Home depot)

[@lysalange4550]

Thanks for the heads up. I’d rather pay more & have it last longer.

[@Qui7422]

I'm a renter is this removable without damage.

[@sarahholland2600]

Yes, it peels off easily. If it's a little stubborn a hairdryer makes the adhesive soft & you're good to remove tricky corner bits etc.

[@montana5398]

If there’s any sticky residue you can use goo gone to remove it! I’ve just peeled it off but I’ve also used a steamer to remove it before!

[@anthrogeekPF]

Great info, thanks! One thing no one ever addresses is what you do to cap off the tile at the ends of each row. Do you put some type of trim there to finish off the edges?

[@thediymommy]

Some manufacturers have matching trim, or you can use a plastic or metal trim from the hardware store.

[@nancyflemming5632]

I picked up Dollarama metallic tiles for my boler trailer. They are thicker than the regular peel and stick, it will be a permanent fix. Do you think I will need additional adhesive for them to stay stuck ? I picked the Smart Tile as probably holding up the best. thank you.

[@marimurphy3856]

Pound one's. ❤

[@kristyhelkaa2841]

Thanks for the rating!

[@sylvienormand1291]

Do you have a spray product to recommend to spray my glass panels on my balcony for more privacy ? I used a spray in a bathroom window once but inside. I wish to do the same with the right product outside now. I also live in Canada (Québec) with very cold temperatures. Thanks

[@Lotusblume.8]

My biggest worry would be how easy they are to remove and what does the wall look like after? I don’t want to have a damaged wall that’s going to be a pain to renovate to give back to the landlord.

[@thediymommy]

It really depends on your wall and the type of tiles. Definitely do a test patch.

[@stphill79]

Thank you so much for your review of the peel and stick tiles. I will check out smart tiles. I just saw this video come up in my suggested videos.

[@Chicago48]

Hi there, Enjoy this vid. I also have some dollar store tile that I put on my wall. And like you, it's starting to lift and so I'm going to replace it with a better brand.

[@janem3575]

Hi, thanks for the comparison. I've heard the dollar store peel n stick doesn't remove cleanly. Does the Snart Tile remove cleanly? I am in a rental, so that's important.

[@janedough2492]

Where did you get the first subway tile? Where can I buy them?

[@debbieconroy6230]

Hi can you use peel and stick tiles on a bathroom wall that has been previously decorated with ‘wet wall’ material?

[@brendabenitez7359]

Peel and stick wall can only be used to what surface?

[@maraimacarvalho]

Very useful info,thanks so much😁 Muito obrigada 🇧🇷😁

[@conniebridges6885]

You need to put some silicon or some e6000 on each corner before install. Hey it's dollarama & quite inexpensive, so it's worth it just for a little extra manual coverage on all corners!

[@grogweedwalker]

What peel and stick dd you use for cabinet renovation? Do you mean instead of painting?

[@vivian5517]

Have you used some from Hobby Lobby? I like the way it looks what they have there but no idea how it would hold up

[@svetlanaermilina6091]

I love your kitchen curtains! Where did you buy those?

[@mom2blessings_sadie]

Are you installing this over tiles??? Ty

[@amayranihinojosa5490]

I'm gonna guess brand name when it comes to sticking good and lasting long

[@michaelrobinson4677]

Great job, I live in Michigan, not quite as cold!! Lol Gonna try, thank you!

[@rachelfriesen9260]

Hi Christina, can you place the Smart tiles right over top of existing old tiles? Thanks for the video.

[@thediymommy]

You usually can!

[@ussalac]

Have you tried StickGoo tiles? They're amazing! The sheets are thicker, and the adhesion is very strong. We redid our fireplace over the natural stone (not a super smooth surface) and are very happy with the results!

[@thediymommy]

I have not! I'll check them out - thanks!

[@aileenalejandro7064]

That's what I used too. It looked very realistic. It is pricier than others but it is worth it

[@kmolley8054]

I purchased StickGoo also $175 , so glad to see this comment. I haven't installed them yet.

[@ussalac]

@@kmolley8054 that seems a little pricey. I was getting it at $4-6/sheet off Amazon. Each sheet was 12×12, so it's generally larger than most others as well.

[@debs179]

Can you put these over existing ceramic tiles

[@jmecass]

Can you put peel and stick over existing tile and grout?

[@leynaabbey]

The third tile was also a different shape, so the installation will be different in how the pieces match up.

[@kellyhampton1000]

I'm going to home depot for mine. I figured I'd get better quality

[@bethminer2222]

Does it destroy your wall if you want to change it as year or so down the road??

[@allystanhope4431]

It can. We just removed some from our powder room and they peeled off paint and damaged the dry wall paper in some spots. We didn’t install them so I don’t know what brand they were but from other comments it sounds like some come off easier than others.

[@thediymommy]

Yes, it's going to depend on the tile, the installation, and the wall as to how easy the tile will be to remove.

[@janetwilliams782]

Thanku for the great information..I said the expensive one was the best cause u pay for what u get....tyfs♡

[@thediymommy]

Good Guess!

[@memphis4525]

Can you please tell me if I can stick this over very old dark cranberry wallpaper ? I am using a light tile

[@cutiepiepdxo]

Oh my gosh! I live in the same province as you. I freakin love your work. I watch your videos and never do any of it because I'm so not crafty 🤦‍♀️ I'll have to call you one day for help haha

[@katianasimon]

I saw a smart tiles at home depot. Is it the same one? Or do they only sale it online on their website? Thank you.

[@nadjamorozov6128]

Thank you for the update on the tiles!!! I enjoy watching your videos ;) planning to paint my camper kitchen cabinets and got a question.. was your kitchen (in the latest camper u renovated) part wood and part vinyl covered? And you sanded it and used the behr WATER BASED primer and it worked really great??? Just worried about the vinyl part..

[@thediymommy]

Yes, I used the primer on everything!

[@nadjamorozov6128]

@@thediymommy thank you so much!

[@323azteca]

Any updates on the amazon tile during winter?

[@personalpersonal9202]

4:50 - Would you mind telling me where you purchased your curtains from? I love them!

[@thediymommy]

Thank you! I made them :) The DIY Roman Shade is actually one of my most popular posts on Pinterest - LOL! You can get step by step directions here, a list of what you'll you need to make them and a link to the video tutorial: thediymommy.com/sew-a-diy-roman-shade/

[@jojobean5382]

Would adding caulk make the tile stick better or would that mess up the adhesive?

[@thediymommy]

I'm not sure; I've never tried!

[@antoinettegoodson7167]

Just wondering if you can use peel and stick tiles over your existing ceramic tiles?

[@thediymommy]

I think you can on most!

[@joanahenderson9747]

Can I stick these to existing tile backsplash tile in my kitchen?

[@saharvarona]

Yay! Canadian dollars means you from canadaaaaa which is where i will beeeeee

[@shawnise311]

She said they were in Alberta in the beginning in the camper. ☺️

[@jennifer0074]

can we use these stick tiles for bathroom too ??

[@shannonbeattie1732]

I have some dollar store tile in our new to us travel trailer that was installed by the previous owners that I want to replace. Is hard to remove it? Anything I need to do to make it easier or not wreck anything?

[@judykleeman7197]

I would guess just like wallpaper, steaming helps to loosen the adhesive and cause less damage.

[@getlowpapoose]

I’m late to the video and less than a minute in lol but you are stunning!!

[@girlonaswing9439]

I was wrong, okay smart tile it is. Thank you