Bottle Dungeons - History's Most BRUTAL Execution Method?

[@niteshades_promise]

and this nyc apartment is $2500 a month.😂🍻

[@ACollectionOfBookmarks]

Original walls, open concept

[@Crackpidgeonextreme]

Antique fixtures

[@angelripper_420]

Lmao bruh 🤣 💀

[@undertow2142]

For the first month. Then normal rent is $5000.

[@-John-Doe-]

2500 is a steal

[@Sacred-ENL]

The cruelty that man is capable of inflicting on another is bonkers

[@thomask4978]

I'm pretty sure it is still happening right now somewhere on this planet.

[@Sacred-ENL]

@@thomask4978 it always is somewhere at some point. Very sad. I pray they find God

[@fredtaylor9792]

"Bonkers"... Thank you. Truly, and without ANY sarcasm here, thank you for not saying it's "wild" or "crazy".

[@squiremuldoon5462]

All creatures on earth have such capabilities.

[@INFINITY-oe4is]

Greed is a strong emotion unfortunately!

[@mitchellcox1912]

Never surrender and you won't be killed slowly.

[@Zazinikki]

Exactly my thoughts

[@thisismyyoutubename1214]

Don't get captured either. That one is harder to accomplish than simply not surrending

[@blackjackvods649]

​@@thisismyyoutubename1214 fight to the last, they can't take you if you don't stop

[@pfcaraujo]

Death before dishonor

[@budisutanto5987]

​@@thisismyyoutubename1214Don't get captured alive. Easier when bomb invented, dynamite, grenade, artileri shell, etc

[@bwhog]

Apparently one of these was discovered after being hidden for centuries and within it were found the remains of dozens of prisoners.

[@nocturnalrecluse1216]

Source?

[@cliffklimas8324]

@@nocturnalrecluse1216do your own research you 🤡

[@RS-xq6je]

​@@nocturnalrecluse1216YT comments don't require a source they are already fact

[@stompieandsuzie]

​@@RS-xq6jeThere was the case of a Japanese soldier that was found inside one and released after several years inside, and he thought WW2 was still on

[@RS-xq6je]

@@stompieandsuzie I've heard of the Japanese pilot marooned on that island for decades but not of this one thanks. The tube deleted my original comment can't remember what I wrote 😆

[@aqueousone]

Visited Warwick castle in the 90’s and saw this very chamber…. Had nightmares about it right up until recent years. Thanks for the reminder.

[@CodyHomes]

Are you okay?

[@RS-xq6je]

​@@CodyHomes extensive amounts of therapy and an emotional support caterpillar

[@CodyHomes]

@@aqueousone it's on the way.

[@Zazinikki]

So hard to imagine that humans are able to do such cruelty to each other

[@thePavuk]

You would be surprised what peopple do to people nowdays. Isis, mexican cartels, africa.... Medieval people were amateurs.

[@Zazinikki]

@@thePavuk I‘m not necessarily surprised. Though it is still incomprehensible to me, people who are able to this, no matter what circumstances influenced them before, are possessed with pure evil. Or in other words lucifers minions.

[@smellykat6481]

This isn’t even the worst of it, this is mediocre compared to some others…

[@riftvallance2087]

I don't think it's fair to indict all of humanity for this. These are the machinations of the ruling 1 percent, a special kind of insane depravity born from centuries of inbreeding .

[@andrewhooper7603]

People don't aspire to be kings because they want to hand out candy.

[@royshashibrock3990]

I saw one of these in a castle in the Neckar Valley region of Germany when I was stationed in that area with US Army - mid to late 1980s. I cannot remember the name of the castle. The dungeon contained an iron grate fashioned like a bed, and resting upon it was a skeleton. The skeleton looked real, but who knows.

[@borstenpinsel]

Neckar is a big river. Never been in the castle myself but perhaps Burg Teck (on top of a mountain near Kirchheim unter Teck (named after the castle)) rings a bell? 😊

[@royshashibrock3990]

@@borstenpinsel Not certain, but the word Kirchheim does ring a bell...

[@teutonalex]

This sounds a lot like the skeleton down in one of the towers in Hornberg castle. Your description sounds dead on.

[@glueguygreen420]

Lots of shit like that was still around in the 80's..

[@Squee7e]

​@@glueguygreen420you mean in the 1780s? because in the 1980s only the castles remained but nothing there was used anymore apart from some people living in them or them being made a museum..

[@TheLepke2011]

I read once that some of these would have a spike at the bottom, so if you were "lucky", you'd land on that and die either immediately, or at least more quickly. If you missed the spike, then you would slowly starve.

[@tentaclesmod]

Why do people always thing that someone trapped will slowly die of hunger? Unless there's a source of water, they would die significantly faster from dehydration. People can survive over a month without eating but only around three days without water.

[@LetsTalkAboutPrepping]

​@@tentaclesmod I think many people use "starve" rather than "dehydrate to death" simply because there's a very long tradition of simply calling it starving to death regardless of what sustenance you lack. Today we call starving "food deprivation", but generally it was just the deprivation of sustenance, with the withholding of water being a modulator to extend the suffering

[@cosmiclounge]

The idea that the human body cannot last for more than three days without exogenous water is a myth.

[@noimnotarobotcanubeleiveit7024]

​@@tentaclesmod rubbish. I have gone days without water. You are thinking of desert

[@joostdriesens3984]

Some of these rooms, for instance the Warwick castle it is not certain they were dungeons, but perhaps part of a sewer system or latrine.

[@janverbanck]

Correct. Some have even been revealed as being just a kind of silo's for provisions, even water wells. There are very few written testimonies concerning people actually being thrown in.

[@EliChristman]

That was my initial thought when they described the rooms. I thought it looked like a latrine.

[@riftvallance2087]

​@@janverbanckAlthough I could see why you wouldn't want to keep written records of this.

[@hafirenggayuda]

Tbf, I think some people would use this to torture someone. "Oh nice, a latrine with dungeon below it"

[@danle7022]

Lol, a latrine and dungeon, nice

[@AntoineWilliams7118]

Looks like a medieval latrine. Maybe they were used as both purposes simultaneously

[@youteacher78]

My thoughts exactly. Many supposed medieval torture stuff is just made up nonsense. And "evil prison cell" goes so much harder than poopchamber. 😂 Also the reason you find dead people in those things is simple: castle got sacked during a war. Loads of dead people everywhere. What do you do? Chuck 'm in the latrine. Problem solved.

[@3lullabies]

The horrors men invent. Wretched!

[@earthwormscrawl]

Standard punishment at my Catholic elementary school in the mid-1960's.

[@SCVM__]

"Stop it, Get Some Help" (Micheal Jordan)

[@joekeegan-yc4nm]

Ah from Australia eh.

[@nocturnalrecluse1216]

​@@SCVM__😂

[@larsatkinson6491]

It puts the lotion on its skin..

[@Tempusverum]

“Or it gets the hose again!”

[@jamegumb7298]

It lacks some oomph.

[@larsatkinson6491]

How does it feel to be so beautiful? ​@@jamegumb7298

[@BucolicLife]

Ed Gein would be proud.

[@BucolicLife]

@@larsatkinson6491 That house now serves as a museum for the movie right?

[@zadeify9596]

Who needs hell when you got shit like this?

[@jasonwarren9279]

This looks insane. But... Honestly, I'll occasionally see some nightmare news story involving something terrible someone has done to a child, and then I understand.

[@Kj16V]

"Society was so much better before video games and social media." *Society before video games and social media:*

[@chrism9493]

You skipped a few hundred years which were the Goldilocks zone for the human timeline.

[@Kj16V]

@@chrism9493 Which, the few hundred years with holy crusades, imperial conquest, transatlantic slavery, and world wars? 😂

[@chrism9493]

@@Kj16V imperial conquest is the oldest practice of humanity that still exists in disguised form. But I’m talking about the period after the Renaissance and before Napoleon invented modern warfare.

[@mattjewett4473]

Well, I'm planning on cold sweat nightmares tonight.

[@tjgelliott]

"Barbarian" a Chieftain who lives in a wooden house at the end of the street, walks down that's street and people follow voluntarily. "Civilised" someone living in a stone fortress with a gang of thugs who subjugates the surrounding people with torture.

[@VoidHalo]

This is almost as bad as being walled in. Which I think would make a great topic. It's a very unique form of imprisonment/execution.

[@rodnstaff33]

Yep. Equally lobotomizing.

[@glen9303]

Just needed a lick of paint and a few pictures on the wall 😂

[@sonofloki-wn3vj]

Am dumb or do I remember in the original robin hood tales that he was rescued from an oubliette? For some reason I recall that but maybe not.

[@bio-plasmictoad5311]

You can't get out, but people up top could lower rope.

[@redfox9446]

It was mentioned in one of Robinhood's tales. If I recall he was imprisoned in the one located in Nottinghamshire castle, which also served as a jail. The details are hazy, but that's what I recall.

[@rammbostein]

The first time i ever heard of an oubliette was in the movie "First Knight"

[@garycallihan4206]

I recall a lot of things.

[@venomousgas3300]

@@rammbostein Mine was in Labyrinth, lol.

[@BartSliggers]

I wonder if there was any chance of escape, as the narrator does not even mentions this once.

[@user-up5ld4pj7w]

I was held by the Taliban in a dungeon luckily rescued by Colonel Bear Girls. We dug through the wall with our hands as the one window led to a courtyard overseen by the guards. The cruelty of the place can hardly be comprehended. A small room with a grilled opening on one side through which the prisoner was pushed leading to an identical room save for the missing door.

[@Biyn_acc2]

Did they feed you?

[@southern_merican]

that's terrifying! also they probly were used as urinals too for the staff while someone was in there 😮

[@slimjohn2090]

Humanity is awesome

[@Xtopher822]

I saw one of these in a Swiss castle. Very dark spiritual energy there.

[@H33t3Speaks]

It's evil, through the screen.

[@ianmclaughlin8987]

How about some of the castles that hung people in those cages, sometimes below the wall toilet, not sure of the proper name of the wall sewage port, but that is just a terrible way to die. These bottle dungeons of course were worse then the cage on the wall, but, the way unfortunate people perish has always amazed me.

[@sethprice241]

The cage is called a gibbet. The practice known as gibbeting.

[@herlocksholmes9369]

There is video about gibbets on the same channel from just a few weeks ago.

[@ianmclaughlin8987]

@@herlocksholmes9369 thanks, I will check it out

[@ianmclaughlin8987]

@@sethprice241 Gibbets were not fun, if I had a choice between a gibbet or the bottle dungeon, I would take the gibbit.

[@robbyjay8119]

Looks cozy..

[@SKIDMARKBROWN]

Back before technology ruined humanity.

[@k956upg]

Funny thing I recognised that hole in Warwick castle immediately..been down in that dungeon alon twice on quest days…vey cool on hot days & scratched markings on the walls…no sense of anything spiritually or sense of danger tough..

[@r3gret2079]

What a fascinating video! Thanks for sharing!

[@Mark-sd4hv]

These weren't torture devices. That was made up for tourism when old torture devices became a draw.

[@FloatingOer]

I thought it said "battle dungeon" at first and got really excited 😅

[@akosszuper1824]

Lucky you! I can't stop laughing every time he says butt(h)ole dungeons....😂😂😂

[@mastermill79]

Oubliette is such a pretty word for such an ugly thing. The juxtaposition is fingerlicking good.

[@wintersun398]

1:44 does anyone know where this is located or is just a concept drawing

[@ThePrimebeef]

word is that shit was thrown into the hole too, via buckets.

[@Calvin_OBlenis]

At least they had something to eat.

[@mrskunk4732]

​@@Calvin_OBlenisyou have to pay for this nowadays

[@michaelschwegel2986]

Hence, the term "shit hole" was coined😂

[@NickyDekker89]

Considering all the different torture techniques and devices that were used this one is still relatively comfortable lol

[@whatfreedom7]

Can’t help but wonder if they flood this thing to drown you. The way it’s made looks like it could hold water up above the metal top. Looks like a water well opening. Then there is the part on the side that looks like something travels through into the main part.

[@oftin_wong]

Imagination running wild

[@computerbiscuit]

Some of these just look like water cisterns.

[@David_Avidmind]

Thank God we have TV now!

[@bojangles2492]

That wall may as well be a ladder for your typical rock climber.

[@DraconisWyrm]

take a shot every time you hear "no escape"

[@NickGurrFromEurope]

Imma add this to my air bnb trip

[@DropB]

Immurement was also at least equally cruel. Especially when the imprisoned was kept alive.

[@yongyea4147]

3:29 I'm patiently waiting for you to turn on your phones light

[@kennycarter5682]

If one has a litrine, how is the latrine emptied??

[@garycallihan4206]

Molecules of dung dry out and arise as fecal particulate as in a wind tunnel.

[@toddkes5890]

Thin tunnel going to the outside.

[@Barrythebomb]

I like IRON MAIDEN The evil that men do

[@KiithNaabal]

Is this written by an AI, they repeated themselves 20x.

[@peetsnort]

As long as bluebottle flies could get in their maggots would eat everything. But the smell would have ruined the entire castle. So it needs another explanation

[@cornpopandhisbadboys2438]

Was this written by an ai? The script kinda just kept repeating itself.

[@F0wlPlay]

Just call them what they are: 'oubliette' sounds WAY cooler than 'Bottle Dungeon', and they're literally the same thing.

[@jcwoodman5285]

Happy thoughts 😊

[@jameseadie7145]

Saw the one at St Andrews

[@MaharlikaAWA]

Parkour guy could get out over time.

[@KuroNekoExMachina]

You know... the "good old days". /s

[@peternystrom921]

Have they ever found human remains in them? Im kind of skeptic tbh

[@andrewhooper7603]

Really helps contextualize why the so called "reign of terror" was necessary in response to the excesses of an absolute monarch.

[@GM_Joe]

Interesting that you put the reign of terror in quotes and said that it was necessary. The reign of terror didn't start until after the king and queen had already been disposed and executed along with most of the government. The government's successes definitely got their just deserts. The reign of terror took place following that when the revolution turned on itself and started killing their own. A little history goes a long way

[@axel8406]

You can end up with horrors like these without an absolute monarchy. Look at the horrors of communism and socialism for example. Or you could look at the French terror when the French persecuted religious people by the thousands.

[@spambot_gpt7]

@@axel8406 Those are all examples of unaccountable power. I'd argue that with a monarch, you at least know who to blame and there's a chance of things getting better with each succession. With a socialist power structure, decisions are opaque and change is unlikely.

[@andrewhooper7603]

@@axel8406 the heckin wholesome religious folks who were carrying water for the absolutists?

[@thehim2990]

Sponge bob and Patrick were thrown into one of these when they went to prison

[@francisseguna3004]

Hmm this is interesting.

[@Paul-vk6ed]

These people are sick

[@indica8510]

Looks like to store alcohol or grain.

[@mariuszmoraw3571]

...you know what.... take me to chopping block instead.

[@karndorbad6536]

We need to bring this back

[@marthvader14]

How did they get prisoners out again?

[@AsaTrenchard1865]

...said the supreme optimist 👍

[@NickyDekker89]

It's a one-way trip mate.

[@Jones-xx2gc]

Grim or what. Hideous way to go.

[@emiltuverot9978]

My apartment is smaller😂

[@Rexini_Kobalt]

mfw you realize the first bottle dungeon was probably just a cistern 😬😬

[@Tuck-Shop]

Dual purpose

[@perrymalito]

Backpacker Ben

[@Sorrus-B4lyfe]

… how da fuq would they make this back then.

[@DelfinoGarza77]

Yuk, that people did that

[@Dang3rMouSe]

Terrifying

[@cmcowen5888]

And prisoners complaining about prisons today they got it super easy and very good living conditions in comparison

[@jasperzanovich2504]

Not sure about most brutal since some miserable being came up with boating.

[@PhazonSouffle]

Get In The PIT

[@googleaccount-zf7yd]

...I saw caged eye

[@AfroAtze]

Not as bad as scaphism though.

[@killkrazy9913]

Ah yes perfect for certain... individuals...in Congress 🤔

[@mynameismynameis666]

is that the western values, traditions and culture the rightwing always refers to?

[@chriskennedy7534]

The species that claims to be made in god image

[@anonimoqualquer5503]

yeah the greeks belive in that remember what the Greek gods did daily? exactly

[@chriskennedy7534]

@@anonimoqualquer5503 Greek gods did the same as the other gods humans have invented, absolutely nothing, because they aren't real.

[@charlottedowling2241]

The thing about this the horrible people that inflicted this on there people are now in a worse place ,and will never escape their tormentors.

[@armageddonready4071]

Not if they ate the cookie and drank the juice. All is forgiven after that right?

[@SmallSpoonBrigade]

@@armageddonready4071 TBH, it wouldn't surprise me if the only people that go to hell are the religious faithful. Not that I personally believe that anything happens after you die.

[@user-qe1qt7pk8m]

@@armageddonready4071 No.

[@shoobidyboop8634]

Doesn't look so bad.

[@johnassal5838]

Can you imagine the rent on that space in this market

[@mukfay]

Months!!? Why would you drink water!? Why not just stop drinking water if you knew that you were going to spend the rest of your life there?

[@Universal_Craftsman]

It's not that easy, if you are thirsty enough you will drink everything, at some point survival instinct kicks in. Why can't people lose weight? Just eat less or nothing for some time. It's easier said than done.

[@mukfay]

@Universal_Craftsman You shouldn't tell me what I would do. You don't know what I would do. Some people probably did. Of course, it's not easy. I would find a way rather than suffer for months.

[@Tuck-Shop]

​@@mukfaydeeds, not words.

[@mukfay]

@Tuck-Shop I don't know what you mean by that in this context. For all we know, a lot of people probably did kill themselves by dying of thirst. People are capable of amazing feats of will. It's been proven over and over.

[@Tuck-Shop]

@@mukfay You talk big.

[@Frommerman]

Someone built this. They built this, then went home and lived the rest of their life. Maybe they thought themselves a fine stonemason and decent person, but they built this. Villainy lies not in crowns, but in the hands of those who enable them.

[@jamesofallthings3684]

All your videos say "HiStOrYsMoStBrUtAlExEcUtIoNMeThOd??!!??"

[@antherthalmhersser7239]

Misread this as "battle" dungeons. Needless to say, I am disappointed.

[@toxicgracie3772]

😂

[@YenzQu]

I know it sounds far less interesting, but these are just ordinary cisterns. 🤓

[@garycallihan4206]

Just a microcosm of the River Seine.

[@AsaTrenchard1865]

Or perhaps dual-use items.

[@borincod]

Was it really called blyat' ??

[@gmadman7]

We are a truly evil species. To be able to do such horrible things to one another.

[@user-qe1qt7pk8m]

Maybe someday you'll actually find "history's most brutal execution method"... 😂

[@wintersun398]

everything is BRUTAL lol

[@southern_merican]

which is?

[@user-qe1qt7pk8m]

@southern_merican Don't know but this guy has been searching for years...

[@anonydun82fgoog35]

@@southern_merican Marriage?

[@nutbastard]

Look up Scaphism aka The Boats.

[@getoffyoubassandletsfish8565]

Wow it’s bigger than my house! 760 square foot…..

[@kimlatta4053]

🙏🙏🙏

[@devinblack2628]

Jesus was this script written by an ai?

[@stompieandsuzie]

Yes, and read by one using a British accent

[@travispeterson5359]

They got room for Obama, Hillary and Harris in there? Asking for a friend.

[@warrenleezy]

Room for Trump and Giuliani actually 😅😂😅

[@EHellKnight]

Why does someone always have to start a stupid American political flame war in every comment section?

[@williamsistrunk504]

Because they aren't content to learn new things, they have to sound off on their political ideology

[@Travis-bl4gx]

​@warrenleezy yes, imprison the person who start 0 wars and ended many (Trump), cheer on the person that had 7 ongoing wars at one time (Obama/Hillary) 👍 good job you fascist

[@HansZarkovPhD]

And people think jesus suffered. He only had a bad weekend.

[@Joseb9-gq8pe]

Discusting

[@corneliussulla9963]

Spam trash

[@The_Deaf_Aussie]

How many times must you repeat the same fucking sentences in this video?

[@DT-wp4hk]

The ones in concentration camps went in a humaner way. So called good Christian medevil times and monarchs who claim to be divine. Sure.

[@SCVM__]

"Stop it, Get Some Help" (Micheal Jordan)

[@DT-wp4hk]

@@SCVM__ ffs. Study some history.

[@SCVM__]

@@DT-wp4hk Go wave Your Palestinian Flag

[@DT-wp4hk]

@@SCVM__ what has that to do with you being what you are?

[@SCVM__]

@@DT-wp4hk Coincidentally My History Professor was a Witness to the 1972 Munich Olympics Attack. Looked right into their eyes as they passed by. You are obviously the Low information, intolerant woke Activist. You Both Downplayed the Holocaust and chastised Christians who were actually fighting back against "Colonization"

[@serijas737]

Ah yes, supporting Palestine is communist wrong-think. Got'cha.

[@chrishartley4776]

Yawn

[@Bay0Wulf]

Not to say its NOT Brutal but in a time period where brutality was a casual occurrence and often used for Public Entertainment / Examples, this was not as bad as it seems. Today’s Penal Systems fail because they are lacking in Toughness &/or Brutality.