Can I bake BETTER cookies than Crumbl Cookies?

[@TheIcingArtist]

What's your FAVORITE cookie flavor of all time??? I Bake With Love + Anxiety Tee out NOW (limited time)!! theicingartist.shop/products/i-bake-with-love-anxiety-tee

[@UniquelyPenny]

I love that the T-Shirt suggestion made it to a real thing! ❤️❤️

[@Bithiah71]

My all-time favorite cookies are thick, rich brown butter chocolate chip cookies! But anything with chocolate is scrumptious!

[@Gunther_goat34]

Keylime pie, and Aggie Blue mint

[@laurenschenck5355]

Chocolate mint chip ❤mint ❤

[@philoctetes_wordsworth]

Brown butter chocolate chip with toasted pecans.😛😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥🫶🏻🫶🏻💋🇺🇸🌸

[@emilyramsey1380]

just wanted to let you know that the crumble cookies are slightly undercooked. so you didn’t do anything wrong! :)

[@TheIcingArtist]

That's what I was thinking! That's how they get them so chewy!

[@michelleramsey4302]

faxxxx.....waste of money...

[@Bonnies-Lasses]

I enjoyed them better the second day after I bought them. But I wasn't impressed enough to buy them again.

[@Lynastia-TheS1lly]

​@Bonnies-Lasses right? I don't get the hype. I thought they were too dry. I guess that's why they named it crumbl?? Cause it was just a crumbly mess!

[@luvyourcurls9756]

Slightly lol they taste raw I dislike them lol

[@Kaylee_eeee]

Kevin raising the cookies in victory was my favorite moment in any video I think 😂

[@meeeshacat]

I really loved seeing the clips of you panicking a little and looking up the recipes! It felt very relatable to my baking experience 😅I'm glad you had the right ones!

[@TheIcingArtist]

I'm glad I had the right ones too!!! It took so long to find the right copycat recipes, shop for all the ingredients and prep everything!

[@celester.812]

I CANNOT with Archie, he makes me laugh all the time with his head on the couch 😂😂

[@geelizz]

I don't think I have ever gotten a box of crumble where the cookies were fully baked. And I love a crunchy edge on my cookies so I had to give up on the pink box lol yours look so much better!!!

[@karagordo1991]

I know this comment has nothing to do with the cookies, but I find it absolutely adorable and so cute how Archie always wants to get permission to climb up on the couch as I know some people don’t like their dog hopping on the couch so for him to ask for permission as a dog. He is absolutely so intelligent and just such a sweetie. 😍

[@locaxmoca3482]

This is exactly what I said !! ❤ 🥹

[@karagordo1991]

@@locaxmoca3482 it just melts my heart every time he does it 🥹

[@KairaPaul]

Your cookies looked amazing!! But I must say, Archie stole the show❤ he’s an absolute cutie ☺️

[@xaviersaenz1375]

I'm absolutely loving your Subscribe cut out, the way you're squeezing it in at random times is the absolute most funniest thing to me, I'm so grateful I've been subbed to you😂💜

[@annalaser5583]

You need to do the same thing but with Little Debbie treats.

[@jamaiyahbryant2200]

Oh I can't wait to see

[@naturaldyer]

please I am trying to make dupes to change my dad over from so many packaged treats

[@hadiy101]

YASSSS

[@Kihei209]

I love the little aside comments & special touches added during the video editing. The video content is fantastic, but the side comments, tangent remarks, sunglasses on Laurie, mini videos, etc., elevate the content even more & gives me the giggles!!! Love it 😂😊

[@momoj9574]

i don’t love crumbl cookies cuz i find them too sweet. i feel like yours are probably better based on how you described the flavor differences

[@TheIcingArtist]

Ya I'm not a 'pour a pound of sugar into all my baked goods' kind of girl lol!

[@cassandraanderson3314]

Agreed. I tried them for the first time a few nights ago and I do not understand the hype around them. I was disappointed that there wasn't anything special about the combination of flavors, because they are too sweet and lack depth of flavor.

[@Hephzibah16]

I have a sister that worked at a Krumbl. One time she brought some home to share. I was very disappointed! The texture and flavors were blah. I think there were one or two that were nice. But that's a lot to pay for a disappointing cookie!

[@hoodpriestessphilosophy]

And four dollars for a cookie will never really be my thing.

[@hoodpriestessphilosophy]

@@cassandraanderson3314 and then they get crazy and throw out strange combos just to be cutting edge and trendy.

[@jamifitz]

I love how honest you were about your honest opinions and not just saying yours were better. I enjoy crumbl cookies too but when my daughter worked there for a while she would bring home the left over cookies that didn't get sold at the end of close and I ended up tired of them. Lol

[@TheIcingArtist]

I'll always be real with you!! Everything was very similar with those few changes (except the topping for the lemon cookie, I need to figure out some more stuff for that), but their brownie cookie aint got nothing on mine lol!

[@Panndia]

Kevin just killin it as the comedic relief

[@Gia-j1e]

@1:08 I love how excited you got realizing they messed up 😂

[@chefash8769]

As a former GM for crumble you put your chocolate chips intoo late so they don't mix in properly you have to put them in when you still have white flour visible and it's Ghirardelli chocolate chips The peanut butter chocolate chip is the peanut butter recipe with peanut butter chips and chocolate chips in it once again Ghirardelli . Berries and cream has pulverized berry powder and berry emulsion. Crumbl only uses emulsions.

[@Bonadea28]

Why do they only use emulsions? Aren't chunks of (dried) berries tastier?

[@andreabenitez7874]

Is it true that they use Betty Crocker cake mix for the cookies?

[@tiernyjasmine8678]

@@andreabenitez7874 i highly doubt that

[@user-vq2wk3kr9r]

Crumbl Cookies are *waayyy* too sweet- like, so sweet that they legit make me feel sick. I'll stick to making my own dark chocolate chip cookies

[@malloryoates8580]

same. i wont buy them anymore

[@user-yy4dh6ob2f]

Archie is the true star of this video 🤣 I love your videos!

[@thegenob]

What a fun experiment! I love the texture of Crumbl's cookies but have struggled to find a flavor of theirs that I actually enjoy. Most of them just are so sickly sweet that I never get much flavor past the sugar. I'll have to look up some of those copycats to make Crumbl cookies at home that actually taste good!

[@NozomiAvii]

I'm so glad you got another vid out, I've just been rewatching your old videos

[@TheIcingArtist]

Sorry it took so long! We try for every other friday morning, but this one took a bit longer to do and to get the t-shirt ready to launch!

[@NozomiAvii]

@@TheIcingArtist Omg I can't believe you replied to me feels like a celebrity acknowledging me haha but no don't be sorry your content is genuinely just so entertaining to watch, I truly appreciate both your and Kevin's work! Keep it up and wishing you best!

[@DeadHeadMakeup]

I love your videos and especially when Kevin captures your sweet pup, he had me cracking up... I've never ate crumble cookie.

[@rryoder1]

I do not like crumbl cookies. I’m sure yours will be better! 😋

[@TheIcingArtist]

Oh my Brownie batter was SOOO much better!!

[@carrieann5714]

My thoughts exactly!

[@boopdoop2251]

Me too tbh!

[@ScarlettOcean92]

I mean, if they taste nearly identical, you probably wouldn't like hers LOOL

[@MakeSomething]

This is so fun! ❤ Awesome meeting you at VidSummit!

[@lkf8799]

The panic in the beginning was very entertaining 😁 Poor Archie 😅 The Elsa and Lion King edit cracked me up 😂

[@simplesimply3753]

0:28 the panic with the shirt is just ❤

[@kweenofturtles]

I love your videos, you have such a sweet and bubbly personality ❤️❤️

[@manishagoswami2023]

That wall-e reference was hilarious 😂😂 love you guys ❤

[@TheIcingArtist]

that's my favorite Pixar movie! 😍

[@Clarky1951]

I just started hearing about Crumbl cookies. I wouldn’t like the chocolate chip because I don’t like a ton of chocolate chips in my cookie. All your cookies came out great. You’re brownie and lemon cookies looked and sounded delicious. I’d definitely be making my own for sure. I mean $30 for 6 cookies…I’m too cheap to pay that!! 🤪

[@TheIcingArtist]

Getting expensive treats is a nice treat. BUT there's nothing like making your own from home and making the recipes exactly what you want them to be!

[@Clarky1951]

@@TheIcingArtist Yes, buying for an occasional treat is fine. But like you say, baking from scratch at home yields just as good a cookie. Of course, if you’re not a baker…..then ya gotta pay the price. 🥰

[@abschmidt131]

I found this video while trying to use the same chocolate chip cookie recipe you did bc the way they ask you to put the dough on the cookie sheet is SO confusing!!! Im so glad Im not the only one thoroughly confused by their instructions and that it worked out just rolling it like any normal recipe!!!

[@sandynaylor3621]

I have a friend who works there, they use a boxed mix.

[@TheIcingArtist]

STOPPPP!!! Really???

[@SleepyHead76]

@@TheIcingArtistthey had a video taken from outside the window and there were Betty Crocker cake mixes on the counter! 😂

[@sandynaylor3621]

@@TheIcingArtist so I'm positive that you can make better cookies!! As long as you're making them from scratch, and you don't burn them, you win! 🎉💖

[@avaglaza1953]

I worked at Crumbl and we in fact do not use boxed mix at my location. But you did great replicating them considering our Crumbl process is quite unnecessarily elaborate

[@bini_latte13]

@@SleepyHead76 it's probably for their cake series not for cookies!

[@ijakejobs7006]

I didn’t expect to like these kinda videos: I don’t even know this brand, I don’t feel anything for baking. But this came on my feed and it is so fun to watch this!!

[@huggledemon32]

I’d love to see a follow up video on Laurie trying to bake the cookies with the “little changes” she mentioned and see how identical she can get them, or maybe even take a new weeks recipes from “crumble cookies” and try and come up with her own copycat recipes, and seeing how identical she can get them herself with out searching for other people specific copycat recipes. Like if she just finds out the names of the cookies and goes from there- eg how would Laurie envision a “lemon pie” cookie JUST from the name etc

[@Leena79]

I need to try the churro cookies. For some reason, I've been loving cinnamon cookies recently. The lemon pie cookie looks amazing, too.

[@perfectlyimperfect2368]

Snickerdoodle cookies are very yummy and easy to make if you're wanting a cinnamon sugar cookie.

[@Leena79]

@@perfectlyimperfect2368 I've made them, way too often! 😄

[@Lelo_GothicMaiden]

My pup always asks for approval too! Lol 😂 the “I don’t know why you need permission, you live here ya know?!” I felt that lol 😂

[@hannypressley343]

Archie is such a good boy.. N how sweet wanting to b every room u guys go in ❤❤❤❤

[@MindfulMya]

Omg the shirt reflect the mood today! That mini anxiety attack moment in the beginning 😅story of my life!

[@TheIcingArtist]

it's 2023, we're learning to embrace our anxiety!

[@viktorias.4643]

Omg, you guys crack me up. I laughed so hard and the ripping the ball in half and putting it back together. As a pastry chef myself I’ve come across some pretty confusing instructions at times 🤣🤣🤣

[@faeriesandrainbows]

Kevin coming out of Crumbl had me 🤣🤣🤣

[@logangb]

I’m here for the Archie content as much as the baking content 🥺

[@ffiontill5924]

I’m in the UK and don’t have crumbl but gosh do I want to try them so bad! Im super excited for the Halloween/ fall and festive season videos and recipes. The winter is always my favourite time to bake and try new recipes❤️🎄👻

[@JesusAlways1st]

You should start your own cookie business in the U.K. I bet it will be a delicious success! ❤😊

[@Gunther_goat34]

So I live where the first crumble opened up back when they only sold chocolate chip and sugar, cookies and thinking to my self that’s a cute idea but I don’t think it’s going to make it, boy was I wrong. My favorites are the Keylime pie and Aggie blue mint cookies.

[@TheIcingArtist]

Omg I didn't know Crumbl started out so small! That's so interesting

[@adventuresinbrowntown5592]

Wow I had no idea they were so small that’s cool! We have one 2 minutes away from our house and went every Friday until we tried all of them lol 😂 Mint brownie and waffle are my favorites

[@laurenschenck5355]

Archie is so cute and most sweetest dog ever ❤

[@katmak4551]

i would have loved to see your own takes on each of these flavours too! own recipes own design etc.

[@heidifinke8998]

For the chocolate chip put it in a ball, tair it in half put it side by side so both the rough ends are on top and kinda smooth the sides down so its one cookie. Another way we did it was take a chunk off the top and shove it on the bottom so that rough top was still there. Ps. No longer work at crumbl and it sucked when i did

[@katrinaskidmore9443]

I just recently made the oreo crumbl copycat. Since I first tried crumbl I have felt like the were too much with the frosting. I think the lemon pie and the berries and cream might have changed my mind BUT the oreo one's that I made 100% did not need the frosting. Half of them I left unfrosted and enjoyed.

[@Dedda616]

I always find it interesting that I never love their full on chocolate or brownie cookies, they are just too bitter or taste like too much cocoa. I end up loving all the non chocolate cookies they have. I need to try the churro cookie you made for sure! Looks amazing!

[@rbbjacob]

i used to work at crumbl a year ago, this was so interesting to watch haha

[@tjyb1502]

Ugh. Now I'm craving cookies.... but those look cakey. I like a cookie with a bit of crunch on the outside and chew on the inside. Not fussy at all... 😊

[@ritav793]

I actually like crumbl cookies so i enjoyed this and i agree that sometimes some of their cookies are too sweet! I usually share them with my teen kids. I also don't buy them often because they are expensive.

[@thenodiggardener]

That was a groovy change from the cakes, and perhaps you should theme this with other things, but I don't know what. I wish my dog had half the manners that Archie has. Truth is, she's just a heathen lol

[@Aninram1985]

I LOVED this video!! Please please make this an ongoing series, we NEED more cookies in our lives! ❤❤🍪😋

[@laughingalltheway8399]

I love this! I love Crumbl, but their cookies are almost all over-sweet to me so I am picky about which ones I get. The semi-sweet chocolate chunk is the best chocolate chip cookie I've ever had.

[@rqmennn]

Our pie cookies we do in fact cook in special trays. Also the technique for pulling apart cookies to leave a raw edge is to have the raw edges facing up next to each other and ball it around the edges until it’s uniform with fingerprints only on the sides and bottom. It’s only for aesthetic reasons as far as I’m aware.

[@bexybites]

As someone who can't buy crumbl cookies over here, it was fascinating to hear more about them and for you to recreate them! Your cookies looked yummy!!! (also I 100% want that t-shirt but you don't ship to the Netherlands 😭 maybe one day~) 💕💕

[@juliavaoitamaevamareko4661]

Lucky girl! 💐👏🏽for trying all those cookies! If I were to release my own 🍪lineup it would definitely be as follows: ⭐️Dark Chocolate Chip w/ Roasted Walnuts⭐️Granola ⭐️ Black Koko Samoa Peanut Butter Cup⭐️Berries Whte Chocolate Cheesecake ⭐️Milk Chocolate Chunk

[@HannahCoziCorner]

I'm surprised there's so many people in the comments that don't like crumbl cookies😭,it's definitely my favorite place to get cookies lol

[@Andy_Tx]

Whatever brand hair dye you're using is AMAZING

[@TheIcingArtist]

Thanks!! Either Artic Fox or Manic Panic, love them both!

[@logiccloud9373]

Crumbl cookies added a location to my city recently in Canada. Idk if it was the flavours we got that week but they tasted raw, undercooked and I hated them. Didint seem worth the money at all

[@Bithiah71]

The peanut butter chocolate chip link leads to a cocoa cookie recipe. Please may I have the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip recipe? They all look so delicious! 🍪

[@TheIcingArtist]

It's updated now!

[@Bithiah71]

@@TheIcingArtist Thank you!🤗🍪

[@darlenemackamul7008]

Was at Crumbl yesterday. They weigh out cookie dough, then roll to perfect circle for at least a minute. The size and density makes them the perfect cookie. I bought four monster cookies. So good.

[@kavithashaj2051]

Please make another video where you make the necessary adjustments to compare and contrast again. I think you can make better than theirs! ❤😊

[@robbie-the-bee]

idk if you'd ever do this again, but the technique for some of the cookies is natural balling! (i work at crumbl lol.) you ball it up, kind of rip open the middle, and rotate the cookie with your hands until it forms a ball, leaving the top untouched. idk if that makes ANY sense but im pretty sure there's a tutorial somewhere LOL

[@karenheston8599]

I love you and your channel! Happy baking!

[@ashleycameron2497]

I bet that brownie batter tastes real good😊

[@TheIcingArtist]

it was soooo yummy!!!

[@Tdwghfdh]

can we just talk about how nice her living room is and i bet her cookies are wayyyy better then theirs house tour pls😊💗

[@sukiumi]

i love to bake to help manage my anxiety, please bring these shirts back sometime! I must have it!

[@bethbrennan3021]

You should do another making my childhood snacks into a gorma dessert

[@emmaharper14]

The gif inserts were hilarious, you guys always make me laugh

[@Kayla-dy9pf]

Archie is so polite

[@totallyawesome7768]

Hi, are you sure you linked the right recipe for the peanut butter and chocolate chip cookies? Thanks for the video :)

[@TheIcingArtist]

I don't know what happened there, but the link is fixed now! cookingwithkarli.com/crumbl-copycat-ultimate-peanut-butter-cookies/

[@totallyawesome7768]

@@TheIcingArtist thank you very much!

[@andilengundze7604]

Love this idea

[@angelalejeune1508]

Wanted to say I absolutely love your videos. You and Kevin do such a wonderful job. Keep up the great work. God bless. 🥰🥰🥰

[@Soulspiritlife7]

Yes you can. I believe you can 💗

[@katieakin1091]

I like Crumbl Cookies, but I haven't had too many of them, and I can't eat a whole cookie; they make me feel sick (I think it's because of how sweet they are)

[@user-fb4sb1zi8g]

I clicked so fast! Love Crumble so much! Gonna have to try this to see how much like them they are.

[@bethbrennan3021]

Also I love your videos sooooooo much and their so for you inspired me and my sister to make a cake

[@yanamargolin5167]

At 3:31 when you gave up and said "ah" you sounded like Neytiri from Avatar when she gives up and says "ahh"

[@kerriemaxwell7950]

Loved all the little clips throughout felt like such a relaxed video. Except now I want cookies 😂

[@duallove6909]

Never tried these cookies. But as I’ve noticed, every time something goes viral and people queue in long line for it, turns out to be over rated “ imo”. You know which chocolate chip cookie is great for me?, surprisingly Starbucks's milk chocolate chip cookie is SO good!

[@LovingGodLovingOthers]

My fav chocolate chip cookie is from chick fila, so underrated lol they serve it warm and melty🤤

[@duallove6909]

@@LovingGodLovingOthers that sounds good! 🤩

[@JayofallTrades]

Recreations makes it be easier for someone to replicate them from home on a budget or be able to substitute for gluten, sugar, nut free ect. They still look so good. I would think maybe freezedried or dehydrated fruit like when you make a fruitcake cookie would keep it from being so moist and underbaked.

[@katiacleroux7376]

Thank you for this, it's actually perfect timing as we're starting our Christmas cookie doughs next week to throw in the freezer ❤!

[@twinmaddy1043]

Aww my dog does the exact same thing as Archie 😂 the puts her head on the couch and just waits there. Also I love your channel!

[@laurenschenck5355]

Archie needs to have his own KZbin channel and instagram ❤

[@CordeiSyd]

I have wanted to try crumbl for so long but there's none near me in the states and non in Canada .

[@jopalm5756]

At Crumbl they rip the top off of the dough ball so it makes a lumpy top on the choc. Chip. Each one has 5oz of dough.

[@gracewhaley3945]

The last frame Kevin stopped the video on is just wonderful 😂❤

[@adodson111]

Archies so cute!!

[@dramaticstrawlk3195]

Hi I love you cookies! 😍 They look delicious!

[@TheIcingArtist]

They were super tasty!

[@chicolovesmariah]

I love your videos. They always give me good ideas.

[@zainabnasir8753]

I really loved this video and would love more cookies videos in future ❤

[@vinitamaharaj5738]

Thanks for making this into 1 episode and not 6! We appreciate all the hard work that goes into creating each video.

[@user-fb4sb1zi8g]

Archie is so cute!

[@kristinxox]

I think it depends on the taste buds however, I would always choose a homemade cookie over a store-bought cookie- that means bakeries too. There’s just something about making cookies in your home. That just automatically makes them taste amazing

[@potatoo_oos]

You should do a real or cake with sideserf cake studios!

[@HeavenLeeMadeOnEtsy]

if you let the crumble cookies sit out over night they seem to get crunchier. I've been on a crumbl cookie kick so this earned you a sub. lol

[@hannahnohlgren989]

Curious question; First time commenting on your videos but have you ever tried baking with Butterfly Pea? It's these flowers with a strong blue pigmentation. I use them for tea as when you use acids (lemon/lime juice for example) the blue tea turns violet. I think you can buy it as powder and concentration as well, I use the natural flowers for tea. It is a super cool transformation and I have seen How to Drink use them in cocktails. But could you use them in baking for that beautiful blue look? Would a buttercream made with the flowers on the outside of a cake change color if you spray it with lemon juice?! That would be a wow factor in a cake. To just present it and then go 'But wait-' and sprits it with a spray bottle and the colors starts changing?! I hope you see this or if your other fans know you've done this before. Stay safe everyone!

[@adee_j]

Loved this 😂 great job Laurie they look delicious ✨️

[@CopperBooom]

The Archie content! I’m 100% here for that sweet little buddy ❤❤❤

[@blissbillo9603]

"it's Pavlov's fault" cracked me up 😆

[@laurenschenck5355]

I love cookie crumble yours looks amazing Laurie ❤