'Hindus reformed themselves, why isn't Muslim community reforming itself?'- Shehla Rashid

[@rajaramakutty9088]

Neelam asked a question on Muslims/Gaza but no question asked on Hindus/Bangladesh. Print is slanting way left.

[@satyanarayanamysore1962]

Beware of Taquia

[@Native_Guyy]

There's no settlers in Bangladesh like in Palestine lol

[@vp-lv6yk]

​@@Native_Guyyso? Hindus are being targeted in Bangladesh and it's our neighborhood unlike Palestine

[@adityabhattacharyya600]

Print is left wing media - it’s a known fact. Only thing is it’s not far left unlike the rest.

[@edres7563]

@@Native_Guyy yeah there are millions of arab settlers in palestine. They migrated into the region during the British mandate period, from countries like egypt, in order to take advantage of better economic development and condtitions at the time. You just need to check out their surnames and you will see where they were originally from. The arab leaders openly admit to this on arab tv channels, but pretend otherwise when peddling their dishonest propaganda that only the western naive fools and islamic sycophants in india fall for. Most of the so called palestinians are arabs from egypt. Heck, even egypt was overrun by islamic imperialism and arab settler colonialism 1400 years ago, and the native Coptic christians and minorities of that land have been suffering and living in fear in their own homeland, ever since. The entire middle east and north africa is arab settler colonies since the brutal imperialist islamic conquests in the first millennium CE, when arabs burst out of their native arabian peninsula, high islamic fanaticism borne out of a desert culture of raiding and looting, and invaded and settled everywhere they could get their hands on. While we go on and on about white european christian colonialism, no one wants to breathe word to acknowledge the brown middle eastern islamic colonialism! The hypocrisy is breathtaking!

[@daljeet140177]

It’s surprising that the reporter is only talking Muslim Muslim

[@manohar_ivu-7]

😂😂 because the topic is about person who have islamic name(authors book title says her motive ), having islamic name doesn't make one ready for entering to jannah. This comment is funny.| I don't believe in extremism in whole, community dek ke nahi support karni chahiye par dharm dekh ke verify kar sakthey

[@muralichundi]

I am aghast. Why wud there be reservations for Muslims? They ruled India for a good 1000 years. Got 2 separate countries post partition but now want reservations in India. First you have to acknowledge this fact before saying I want something

[@vishnumohannair8506]

She is not saying that is the solution just that is A solution. Only that the Muslims in being a vote bank for one party has lost their bargaining power for better life for themselves.

[@muralichundi]

@ the very fact that she says congress didn’t give Muslims reservations itself is bothersome. It kinda reflects her thought process which I have problem with.

[@VijAl-s6b]

And there are 57 muslim countries hindus are in minority we are very much divided

[@Logic78600]

Get your quota in porkistan Get lost terrorists and traitors

[@KalaTharanga]

Very Well said,

[@sbaskaran7638]

Appreciate her trajectory. Let many from Muslim community join her for the good of community & Nation.

[@kaiser95116]

Really hindutva gobar terrorist??

[@s-qc9ns]

Owaisi should learn from her.

[@kaiser95116]

@s-qc9ns , really hindutva gobar terrorist

[@Bhaibhavb]

Allah says in quran Quran 9:73 O Prophet! Struggle against the disbelievers and the hypocrites, and be firm with them. Hell will be their home. What an evil destination! Quran 9:123- O believers! Fight the disbelievers around you and let them find firmness in you. And know that Allah is with those mindful ˹of Him˺. Quran 47:35 -- So do not weaken and call for peace while you are superior; and Allah is with you and will never deprive you of [the reward of] your deeds. Sunan an-Nasa'i 3097 "Whoever dies without having fought or thought of fighting, he dies on one of the branches of hypocrisy." Love love love❤❤❤

[@mohamedali2858]

What are the good privileges that the muslim community in India will gain, which they were previously deprived of according to your opinion ⁉️

[@coolandy1979]

Dear Print, Let me ask you a fundamental question: Are Hindus not discriminated by other religious groups especially Muslims? If you are not aware about it then you need to go and walk in the bylanes of Indian villages and small towns and you'd undestand. The social discrimination and bias which different religious groups have for one another has always existed in India in particular and globally in general. However, the burden and the stigma is borne largely by the majority groups everywhere and that's what irks the majority groups. The support which you see to the neo-nationalists and so called right winged political outfits the world over is an expression of this feeling of resentment.

[@sramay123]

muslims if they find a muslim shop they go there only this is how they are brainwashed and their belief is the "superior" one. secondly you will not find a hindu shop in waqf /mosque complexes.

[@mohdshariq5814]

Can you give one or two examples of discrimination face by Hindus in muslims area in india??

[@locus1289]

It depends on who hold power and control.

[@shivam00668]

​@@mohdshariq5814 अरे कश्मीर से लेकर बंगाल तक , कैराना से लेकर कासगंज तक जहां मुस्लिम संख्या बढ़ गयी वहां हिन्दूओ को घर छोड़ भागने पर मजबूर होना पड़ रहा, हिन्दू शोभायात्रा निकाले तो बम और पत्थर मारे जाते है, हमारे मन्दिर तोड़ मस्जिद बना डाली गई और हम कोर्ट से न्याय मांगे तो दंगा करके हिन्दुओ को मारा जा रहा

[@mallukittens177]

​@@mohdshariq5814 bro what ? Islam itself says those who belive in polytheism are muslims enemies. And everyone knows how much hatred Islam has against himdus. And those who strictly belive in islam hate hindus so much.

[@sb5224]

The journalist is classic example of a left liberal trying to 'tell' an educated muslim woman like Shehla, how she should think and respond to issues. Shehla raises a very pertinent question - Is she not a muslim? Are muslims and their perceptions going to be defined by Sunni males? I also agree with her views on Stereotypes existing for a reason. As an Indian male, I have to make sure I am respectful of women because of negative stereotype of Indian men in the west. And that exists because Indian men act in a certain derogatory way. We have to change the perception by positivity.

[@rajeshmehta3921]

In Mumbai , a society of 100 Muslim and 1 single Hindu just see how Hindu faces discrimination.

[@curious_one1156]

how ?

[@Samrat794]

I live in the gulf. Come here and see how Hindus are treated and how Muslims are treated in companies where Hindus are their bosses.

[@thiruvetti]

@@curious_one1156 In a Mumbai society the Muslims have taken over the ground floor and converted it into a dargah within a society! This is how Muslims create fitna and fasad where every they go

[@thiruvetti]

@@Samrat794 Because they are moving away from Islamic law. MBS is the primary example. Everything he is doing is moving away from islamic laws. First learn something before blindly supporting them for ur salary! Also can u go and convert a Muslim women to Hinduism in Qatar and have a legal Hindu marriage??

[@bossbrawler3900]

@@Samrat794 Gulfs are not following eeslam. If they did then they would not hire you at first place.

[@Maharana.Pratap1597]

😂😂😂 oh man , anyone notice thier is no single muslim comment .

[@s-qc9ns]

Cannot tolerate pragmatism 😅

[@FidaHussain-v1e8o]

Maybe you are blind enough, but I saw a lot

[@adilceo1]

Read again.

[@ZubairAhmad-bo5zi]

Are bhai isko kashmir mai kutta tk nhi pochta.. 😂.. Tumhe nhi pata ye kon hai.... Pehle anti-india stance tha iska.. Ab halat dekh kr party badl di isne 😂.. Ye paiso k ghulam hote hai.. Kbi udhar kbi idhar..

[@ahmadsabeel6576]

Read again

[@starky2000]

Islam in majority- sharia law Islam in minority - secularism😂😂 that's hypocrisy for u😂, there are more than 50 Islamic countries, How many of them follow secularism🤔🤔🤔

[@budding4708]

Classic misinformation.Can you name any Muslim country where Hindus are continuously hounded or for that matter even christians or jews.Thats the real deal.Forget the labels

[@Maharana.Pratap1597]

Absolutely true

[@rrao7963]

​@@Maharana.Pratap1597there quran changes according to situations

[@DilshadAlam-gr4qt]

Tujhe political rights chahiye ya economic rights..kya Islamic countries me neta bn na chahta h kya and jis islamic countries me Sharia law h vha Hindus most safe economically ...do research...

[@Maharana.Pratap1597]

@@DilshadAlam-gr4qt krli researcher bhai Pakistan m hindu bahut safe m , Bangladesh m bahut safe h hna is level pH safe h ki hindus community ki population decrease hoke 1-2% k as pas agye hogi ... 2nd thing tu mujhe ye bata Arab countries m kitne hindus temple h ?

[@benjamindsouza6736]

This girl is surely gonna change stereotypes about Muslims. It's so inspiring how comfortable & positive she is about being a Muslim in India. Barring a few stray incidents, Muslims & other minorities in India enjoy a far greater degree of freedom & prosperity in India than their counterparts in Pakistan or Bangladesh.

[@FuriousFlash-l4k]

The Incidents you mentioned aren't few actually

[@AnarchistDoc]

Few 😂😂😂

[@sudipbhattacharjee9]

​@@FuriousFlash-l4kplease leave you got your portion during partition now leave

[@benjamindsouza6736]

@@AnarchistDoc Here in Goa the Christian community enjoys a great degree of freedom & we have always lived in harmony with the Hindus & others....& if you do your research you'll find that's true for Indian Christians in general, apart from the backlash we sometimes see against Christian sects that go around enticing people to convert, often using dubious means.

[@benjamindsouza6736]

@@FuriousFlash-l4k In Goa where I live the Christians that were converted by the colonialists/Roman Catholic church have been traditionally living in harmony with Hindus. This is generally true for India as a whole, & the backlash against Christians has been largely related to the Western sponsored evangelical sects that indulge in conversion, mostly of tribals, often using dubious means.

[@surfaceoftheoesj]

In your 20s you are confrontational. Well said Sheila

[@sudip_curiousmind]

Neelam madam BJP didn't win in Kashmir because muslims never have nor will vote for BJP no matter whatever BJP does for them, simple. Shehla couldn't have said it.

[@shawaizalikhan5970]

Lol you are pretending that BJP's voters vote for them for the development they are doing. Its because of the villification of Muslims that you vote for the BJP. If tomorrow Muslims start voting for the BJP, and BJP acknowledges this shift in voting pattern, I can guarantee you wont vote for the BJP. BJP is the Hindutva Version of the Congress and Congress is somewhat centrist version of the BJP. ALL PARTIES IN THIS COUNTRY are the same. BJP knows its voters are voting for them merely because of the hate or fear of Muslims. Its as simple as that!

[@nv9991]

@@shawaizalikhan5970 Have Deenis en-mass ever voted for BJP candidates across the state/nation? As they did for Shivsena or SP or Congress ..etc Without that, your If and but scenarios are just imaginary. Islam teaches Muslims to never live happily as a minority in Darul-e-Harb lands.

[@shawaizalikhan5970]

yes actually the Shia Muslims did vote for the BJP in Lucknow and surrounding regions for a long time because of Atal Sahab and then Lalji Tandon. But now they are also in the same boat as other Muslims,

[@thenun8595]

What BJP have done for muslim except spreading hate. Muslim also don't need to vote against BJP.

[@webseries324]

Oh wow they are getting free ration getting benefit of pm awas Yojana and they crying mila kya hai 😂😂 itni problem hai to free schemes ka benefit kyun uthate ho​@@thenun8595

[@PahadiPanda]

Hamid Ansari was the Vice President and also a Muslim. Later, he claimed that there is discrimination against Muslims in India.

[@Logic78600]

He is a 🐽

[@alani3992]

He was not talking about himself, just like Murmu does not mean segregation is not a reality. But saffronists can't think of this.

[@GayathriK-re7wt]

​​@@alani3992Ok , then leave the saffronist country.....

[@alani3992]

@@GayathriK-re7wt Typical saffron animal reaction. Can't even address the issue like basic human behavior..

[@sanskarpathak9521]

​@@alani3992 Green will soon fade away in this saffron River 😅😅😅😂..... subcontinent converts are really a pain in the ass 😫 ...... even Arabians are way nicer than these ... illiterate idiots .... whether Islam ends or not but these idiots lineage would surely end if their attitude towards world doesn't changes .....

[@cooldjk]

She’s one of those rare persons whose thoughts resonate with mine. Just thought of her as another leftist argumentative person,but her discussions in the last few news outlet really changed my view.And also the fact that we need to stop being protesting and instead provide solutions is what’s lacking in a great amount.The same thought was discussed by our external affairs minister in an ORF interview as to how India and China differs. The fact that an Indian Arab Spring moment was also quite apt coz the changes over years is quite visible and also the fact that being a proud Muslim is quite easy than being a proud Hindu. The secular thread that unites us is quite unique and both religions should try to keep their religion to themselves and dedicate themselves towards nation building. The same thought was made by famed pakistani travel writer salman rashid over how religion took precedence in our neighbouring country and look what status it brought them. Looking forward to her book

[@sanket_narode]

She is optimistic & rational, yet she looks through a filter that's why she is unable acknowledge ground reality

[@dreamsofadaffodil650]

Im a BJP voter, Modiji Yogiji admirer for their leadership and nation building. Also, I openly criticized them and the party for 2020 farmer's stand, female Olympians' mishandling and such other issues. Criticism is good and essential for a democracy, particularly I have the right to criticize the government, particularly, when i have voted in it's favor. What bad is organized propaganda, against a person and regime, based on vested interests and fake narratives. Modi government is the need of the hours.

[@curious_one1156]

Modi govt does not deliver. Nothing has changed bacuse this govt, like every other, has no incentive to make systemic fundamental changes. This govt just has a great formula for winning elections. And both of us know what it is. Hatred of muslims. I am sure you hate them too.

[@thiruvetti]

The 2020 farmers stand was fake. Read what the Supreme court appointed panel said about new farm laws. 85 % of Farmer organizations in india said it was good.

[@Admin-yp2rr]

Farmers law was best thing for farmers till date. Unfortunately government pulled back

[@bossbrawler3900]

Now German shepherd also said Farmer bill was good. This is the sad thing you people don't realize that BJP always think betterment of the people & country. Because they want to stay in power for a long time so they want to rule a better country unlike opposition who are fighting between eachother for power

[@hrp4566]

I was also a liberal like her. But understood there isn't any liberty over there. Its a gand of hypocrites and attension seekers.

[@s-qc9ns]

Same❤

[@Arpit-t8w]

Me too

[@NerdCentral_]

Being liberal means you should criticize all ideologies that re rigid and undemocratic

[@hrp4566]

@@NerdCentral_ then you become rigid and undemocratic eventually in the process

[@thomasthomasphilp4393]

She can become one of the great leaders in Kashmir. Let Kashmiris at the extreme North have same life like Keralites at the extreme South. We are one nation.

[@vishnumohannair8506]

Note to Print - These questions have been asked to Sheila by Mojo. Try to interview her from a different perspective.

[@shankerram6076]

Print has its own agenda. You know that.

[@appajirao]

Future Chief Minister of J&K. It's a pleasure watching Shaila Rashid transform from a confrontationist critic to a solution seeking reformist. Best wishes to Shaila in whatever she choses to pursue. 😊

[@samikshagoyal7707]

No! Future CM of J&K is Shagun Parihar❤ Intelligent, compassionate and a victim of islamic terror 😢

[@s-qc9ns]

Huge respect to this woman! True Bhartiya Nationalist mahila ❤ When we Indians are one, No-one can break us.

[@truthislogical]

Looking at the current situation one can easily predict that India will eventually disintegrate

[@soldier3514]

😂😂😂😂

[@rajunivask]

Hats off to Shehla ji. The interviewer seems hell bent on devaluing her.. and she was always one step ahead in taking higher ground. Discrimination is there.at multiple levels.. she is on point when she says... if you want to progress, don't have to take recourse to discrimination for their failure..

[@rafeeq_sultana]

I read her book, my experiences in life are not different from hers. My upbringing was in a neighborhood that were majority Muslims. Now I live in a community that is majority Hindus, the experience is very different. Better roads, better transport facilities, regular municipal water supply, malls and shopping complexes are close by, the list goes on. The quality of life is better For deprived Muslims (who form the majority in our religion), it is actually a struggle for better life which unfortunately took a religious color, there are several forces to polarize the situation making it complicated

[@RAMESH-js9lc]

It is not about fortune. It is a matter of choice. Muslims want a better quality of life but that should also be Islamic. So you see many refugees fleeing from Islamic countries to europe and having settled in there are now pitching for implementation of Sharia. No wonder the world is wary of the Islamist.

[@creativebureau-t6f]

If the majority are the reason behind your backwardness then why you lot are soooooo backward in the countries where you are in majority. Let's take the three countries your ancestors carved out from India for example. Why are you living in dark ages over there. Please stop playing the card of Al taquiya.

[@the_class_apart]

Accept the fact the Muslim as an Ideology is an regressive one. Bearing more children than you can sustain, stealing public property or destroying them, Girl marriage at the age of 14 is taking you down. Put a hindu in a muslim area and he will be shredded into pieces in no time. I have seen average muslim fellas always thinking about sex. Sex with hindu girls, sex with their own sisters, daughters nothing else comes to their minds. As a jamat, muslims keep mazab first instead of humanity and country first. Thus regression is self imposed.

[@nandeeswarareddysivaiahgar2121]

Look at in that area how many houses occupied roads by extending their houses ..how many mosques extending into roads..For all these issues root cause is having more childrens.

[@the_class_apart]

@@nandeeswarareddysivaiahgar2121 their population is exploding more than they can ever sustain. Then they expect better living conditions

[@krishnakumar_ka]

The history of Christianity also shows that. Now MBS is doing it in Saudi Arabia. Hopefully rays are there in India too. Indonesia will be a role model for Indian Muslims. They respect their ancestors and their culture.

[@kaiser95116]

Really hindutva gobar terrorist??

[@alani3992]

The West separated Religion-&-State, and thats how we got the modern world.

[@ZakiAkmal-m8v]

​@@alani3992We will accept secularism but not a single bit of hinduism in politics

[@3008venky]

​@@ZakiAkmal-m8v yeah.. take Universal civil code (basic principle of secularism) then demand for secular cover.

[@AnarchistDoc]

​@@3008venkyExtend it to all including TRIBALS and then talk about UCC

[@god__particle__]

Loved to see transformation in Shehla Rashid! A product of JNU will always have a sharp mind but to use that mind towards constructive activism is pragmatism. She's so correct..in 20s we're rebellious & confrontational but in our 30s we should be problem solvers.. that's true maturity. Need minds like her in politics asap. All the best @ShehlaRashid

[@madhabchandrapradhan2522]

Sohela your point of view is inspiring. The clarity of your thoughts is amazing. God bless you for a bright political future.👏👏👏

[@amrtadas5539]

The reporter try desperately to bring back her anti India anti Hindu anti Modi stance. But Sheila is honest and smart enough to understand it and answer brilliant

[@kggupta6685]

Very enlightened lady. Balanced views. Girl interviewing has asked all questions,, trying her best to provoke Shaila Rasheed. Interesting interaction . 👍👍👍

[@pallaviindia306]

Current views of Shehla is amazing n great , girl have reached the path of maturity 👍

[@JohnZoot]

Dear Ms Pandey Why are you constantly trying to promote The Narrative of discrimination against Muslims? It seems no interview is complete without the mention of this discrimination at least a few times. Do you also bring up discrimination when interviewing women and other minorities? To be even handed should you not ask your Muslim guests how about some questionable Behavior by some Muslims? Pattharbazi, blocking of Roads,defying the police, not sending their girls to school and the general subjugated status of women in Muslim Society etc. Is that not part of good journalism? Part of the reason media is losing its credibility is journalists yourself

[@PS-ug7nm]

_Amreeka ki Dalal hai BC_ - the Meme

[@sanjeevbhattacharjee1936]

Why should religion , at all be given any space in our democracy n an identity …religion should be personal choices and not displayed on one’s shoulder n fight over religious dominance in polity n society..…the anchor was unnecessarily fishing in troubles waters n sounded quite pathetic ..our journalists need to shoulder the responsibility of National Interest n Security n try make Indians more cohesive n not be divisive and try to divide us on perceived fault lines …Shehla Rashid has been outstanding n admire her candid views n her clarity of thought is commendable

[@subhajitghosh3391]

Religion has always been a part of our identity....

[@shankerram6076]

@@subhajitghosh3391 Keep that identity to yourself. I have my own identity too.

[@FidaHussain-v1e8o]

I appreciate your point and truly respect your concern for the society. But my point of view is somehow different. I think religion becomes problematic when it incites hate among people and creates divisions like the hindutva, far right christians, wahabist muslims. But if it is a source of self discipline and conscience building, it is far more effective than human conscience in building a moral being. Imagine a leader who truly believes in God and the day of accountability when he would pay for all his good and bad deeds, that would be best. But in the current scenario, when religious intolerance has shaded every positive aspect of it, it seems imaginary.

[@RAMESH-js9lc]

@@FidaHussain-v1e8o. It is your figment of imagination. Qur‘an is full of hate for the kafir. Not so with other religions which are older than Islam.

[@euphoria6681]

​@@FidaHussain-v1e8oYou are either a muslim or an Indian first , you can't take both together

[@artsmohan]

Finally i hear sensible talk frm a muslim girl. Communities shud self reform like hindus did. Its high time muslim communities wisdom grows as well, in terms of reform of society.

[@Sandip_RoYY]

This episode felt extremely disappointing, not because of Sheila, but due to the interviewer’s approach. For the love of good content, please focus on discussing the book itself instead of fixating solely on the country’s political climate. The interviewer didn’t even touch upon the role models highlighted in the book, which are such a key aspect. Interviews like those by Karan Thapar in TheWire or Kitaabwala in 'The Lallantop' set a far better standard-this episode pales in comparison. It seems as though the interviewer hasn’t even read the book, which makes it appear unprepared and superficial.

[@shankerram6076]

The interviewer has her agenda to complete. She has NOT read the book. A very good attempt by Shehla.

[@navneetmishra1309]

The Print is anti India.

[@PS-ug7nm]

Exactly she sounded like Andhbhakt of Rogi Media

[@TravisBickleTaxi]

This is one of those interviews where the guest is a moderate and the host is an extremist!

[@iamyou8994]

13:52 Isn't it funny how Parsis, Jews, Jains, Sikhs, Buddhists etc never complaint of discrimination in India? What's their number in India? They must be majority I guess. And Islam being an organised religion is actually the largest religion in India where hindus being Individualistic (and not necessarily religious) are the real minority. Every hindu represents a completely independent set of thinking and lifestyle which comes to with his/her life. The unity or cooperation among hindus is only due to absolute hypocrisy of Islamist and Christian abrahamics.

[@vijaygarikipati6087]

Smart, thoughtful, and introspective lady. She is still a convert, her ancestors did convert or forced converts like most. For some unknown reasons south Asian Muslims struggle to accept that fact.

[@tabishumaransari]

I don't think most Indian Muslims deny the fact that their ancestors (20 generations ago) might have been Hindu, and before that Buddhist, and before that indigenous (Indus Valley non-Aryans), and before that hunter gatherers. It doesn't matter. Our recent ancestors chose monotheism and dignity and freedom from caste and untouchability, and that's what we live by.

[@defaulterjangid5975]

@@tabishumaransari wow a muttalman spreading his narrative. at least read latest books which deny aryan invasion theory. and freedon from caste then why some of your community beg for reservation what about pasmanda chuslim

[@vijaygarikipati6087]

@@tabishumaransari Not true. Most believe they have Moghul/arab ancestry. Good luck with Ahamadiya, Suni/Shia, Mojahirs, Druze, Alexis,….and it’s legal. Ashraf's will not marry into a dalit convert. In fact they look down upon them. Everyone knows how Owaisi treats Dalit converts around him. At least Hindus have made it illegal as noted by this learned lady. REFORM! South Asian Muslims need to understand their roots. Look at Indonesia for guidance. BTW, Hinduism prevailed much before Buddha avatar. Also, Vedic practice existed in IVC as evidenced by several artifacts like Pashupati seal and others. It does not need a western “scholar” to validate it.

[@ZakiAkmal-m8v]

​@@vijaygarikipati6087Why do we need to follow our ancestors way of living and culture we have choosen Islam and we are proud of it diversity is a good thing difference is the part of nature

[@vijaygarikipati6087]

@@ZakiAkmal-m8v Sure. But most tow the kaffir, ummah line. Therein lies the fault line.

[@upscAspirant_IAS]

Solutions do not come from confrontation they come from cooperation :)

[@vinaydhopeshwarkar4567]

Indian Muslims says they are Ruling class for 800 years, so why they need Reservation. Again they say Muslims has no Caste System, hence Reservation is not applicable to Muslims. Muslims in Bharat must be treated the way Aurangazeb, Tipu treated Hindus

[@Trickkystar121]

Go watch dhruv rathee video on Aurangzeb and shivaji u will understand the truth

[@PS-ug7nm]

​@@Trickkystar121Why the fuck would any one wanna watch that propagandist ... I prefer Nitish Rajput

[@thenun8595]

You are no one to decide how should be muslim get treated. Aurangjeb alamgir and tipu sultan will always our hero. 😂😂

[@Arpit-t8w]

​@@thenun8595 then do not play victim card please converted I have no issue On you worshipping them but then if we take action don't cry

[@theworldscience1170]

​@@thenun8595ready for treated like hero❤

[@mohamedali2858]

Most recent Muslim oppression is reported from BJP states, where chief ministers have, contrary to their constitutional oaths, deployed dog whistles against Muslims and attempted to scare or shame Hindus into backing their party. In Madhya Pradesh, new chief minister Mohan Yadav said he opposed bulldozer sanskriti but allowed or ordered officials to continue demolition of Muslim homes - for allegedly finding beef in their refrigerators, for rioting. An Adivasi constable who refused to hand over a Muslim accused of “hurting religious sentiments” to Hindu fundamentalists was, instead of being commended, transferred.

[@amardatta4471]

There is a natural law that says "What goes up must come down", in other words "Your deeds of today will come back and haunt you and your off-springs to come in the future".

[@mohamedali2858]

@ Does the natural law you mentioned apply to those who are rising now, and is their downfall inevitable? In other words, is their actions today will come back to haunt them and their children in the future⁉️

[@amardatta4471]

@@mohamedali2858 Short answer is "Yes" - deeds on an individual basis will be restricted to the individual alone. However, the same does not hold true when deeds are against humanity or section of a society then the humanity or section of the society will face the consequences (negative) of their predecessor's deeds. Here, deeds and their consequences will depend on if they are positive (respect for humanity) & negative (inhuman).

[@mohamedali2858]

@@amardatta4471 Your concise answer of "yes" is a guarantee of the continuity of the natural law you mentioned, and this is satisfactory to me because the only constant is change, and I would add to that👇 The oppression of individuals against one another can be addressed through law and a fair, disciplined judiciary; however, the oppression of authority is more pervasive, beyond the capacity to counteract and halt, and it heralds ruin.

[@amardatta4471]

@@mohamedali2858 Laws of nature have very little to do with human input or interventions - like Newton's 3rd law of motion "Every action has equal and opposite reaction", and it specifically deals with the physical world or nature. Long before Newton's laws of Motion came Shri. Krishna said the same thing but meant for the Universe and its effects on inhabitants, particularly the human beings. Your say " ....because.....constant is change......" Not sure what you meant by it. Instead of the word "Constant" shouldn't it be "variable"? Then it makes sense to me. As far as "...disciplined Judiciary.." is concerned my comment is that wherever human beings are involved justice rendered is called "Natural Justice" and not same as laws of nature. Human biases, likes, dislikes, mind-set, politics, etc., influence the outcome or verdicts.

[@dharinidevadiga1681]

Sensible narrative from Sehla Rashid. Can't say the same thing for questions from anchor

[@amardatta4471]

Discrimination based on religion, skin color, race, etc., exists every where and every society in the word no matter what. It's a reality in life, and it will remain as long as humanity exists. On thing I want to ask the people belonging to "Peaceful Community" as to why other religious communities living in India for much longer than "Peaceful Community" do not feel the same.

[@s.m.tanvir7580]

Ever tried to ask anyone from dalit/OBC from your same religious community?

[@crazyjester993]

@@s.m.tanvir7580 yes

[@s.m.tanvir7580]

@@crazyjester993 , great to know. And? They said what?

[@crazyjester993]

@@s.m.tanvir7580 they r fine

[@loveearthly]

​@@s.m.tanvir7580you mean the pasmandas?

[@wisdomchase]

So Shehla Rashid has been turned around, or so it seems. I think she still just stands for Muslim exceptionalism and appeasement politics. But as the Muslim community begins to develop more thinkers like her, questioning Congress and the "secular" parties for not delivering for Muslims, we will see just how quickly the likes of Congress and other parties shut down their "Mohabbat ka Dukaan" and "Karwaan-e-Mohabbat".

[@daljeet140177]

Unfortunately for this interviewer journalism means keep cornering her and not talk in alignment with her thoughts.

[@Thinker-l4e7h]

Neelam, shane on you for not talking about the sufferings of Hindus, Christians and Buddhists in Bangladesh. Boycott Print if she doesn’t apologize.

[@punterjake]

Well Done Shaila

[@pramod6898]

40:29 ‘Shehla Rashid-“I’m afraid to get married (because as a Muslim woman she doesn’t has equal marriage rights). Shehla Rashid, madam please don’t be afraid of getting married; you may choose from a lot of suitable boys from the Hindu community. You’re welcome to embrace Sanatan culture and Dharm.

[@hrp4566]

Anchor want to become new figure of Anti national Journalism.

[@pugnator_1]

Atrocities are faced majorly by Hindu's across the history but still survived and Contributed to the society instead of Playing Victim that comes from the core idiology of the Religion. Goverment can subsidize goods and Provide Reservations upto a limit but in this rapid increase of Globalization across the world you're left to be pity and failed individual/country.

[@CatastropheGOD]

This is not the print....this is the victim card channel

[@vinaybellave6498]

Wow! Impressed with the maturity of the guest!! Kudos. Wish host was less biased. She was almost feeding the guest such exaggerated views...certainly did not sound neutral. Love the print for the balance. This host did not measure up to its standards.

[@kumartolani5641]

Batenge to Katenge is "Reverse Social Engineering" as compared to Social Engineering done by the adversary.

[@aftabansari2010able]

Ch000tiye ऐसा कब हुआ जब हिन्दू यहां ही कटे?? और जो भी सरकार बनाया, वो सब हिन्दू ही था

[@ganapatibhat2161]

She is very clever! Volitionally slipped from tricky questions!

[@uk2261]

All hindus united...time to open gurukul university for all hindus including brahmans and dalits to learn hindu vedas sitting side by side to become hindu priest or poojari in all temples

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

First learn how moguls finished crores of our people through Talwar and took our mahilas like rundis

[@Trickkystar121]

⁠@@Johnny-pi1vkyea keep barking lies ..learn the real history from proper people not from sanghis

[@nitin2696]

Her answer: " In 30s I want to sell my book.. In 20s I was showing my true color"

[@DCM2463]

How can you say Hindus have reformed themselves when there is still caste system and prejudice?

[@jai6196]

More and More Hindus consider Caste discrimination as bad. The Hindu women are much more empowered than Muslim women. No society is perfect or free from all sorts of prejudice but Hindu society has is changing and reforming over time.

[@ravindra7791]

Because Hindus have accepted Hinduism needs to change and changed laws. For eg Hindu marriage act was modified in 50s to ensure one man has one wife. Reservations were enshrined since independence. Can we all move to a uniform civil code which is decided by people who live in this century ? On the other hand Muslims didn't even repeal triple talaq which the BJP had to do to liberate Muslim women. Pakistan and Bangladesh have long ago got rid of it but to the eternal shame of Congress it has kept Muslims backward and trapped in medieval laws.

[@hedwig6643]

Btw caste is given by brits not us

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

The caste system dates back to 1000s of years and the Brits only ruled India for 400yrs. They exploited an already existent system to usurp control for the divide and rule policy. The caste system made sure we remained divided over silly reasons, all the Brits had to do was maintain that and rule over us. Please stop making excuses, acknowledge the problem so you may work on it. If you remain in denial you'll never work on it.

[@defaulterjangid5975]

@@ravindra7791 well said

[@pe1145]

Reporter is trying to push her agenda of appeasement politics.

[@somnathpal7252]

Bang on!

[@RandomGuy2421]

Appreciate the unifying attitude and reasoning of this Lady. We need more young people like her.

[@s-qc9ns]

Yes

[@jahangeerahmad5589]

Everyone needs to read this must read book to get a rationsl answer for several queries.

[@shehla_shora]

Thank you!

[@simple-eastner]

Sarkari Musalman: A Muslim from Hindustan, who love their Sarkar (not Government, but also the party in power). No one can clearly say what in therir hearts-mind, whether they love-worship ruler(s) or Allah, so we still call them Muslim.

[@thenun8595]

Then pakistani hindu should also love their government. 😂😂

[@ZubairAhmad-bo5zi]

Who is she 😂😂😂.. Nobody cares about her in kashmir.. If she had fought elections she wouldn't had scored even 2 digit votes 😂😂😂.. She is chameleon.. Before 2019 she used to be pro-seperatist, but now she has changed her colors.. She is opportunistic 😅

[@3008venky]

so who cares about you? when rajarammohan rai started taking reforms, He was not popular obv. People will get there after some time.

[@ZubairAhmad-bo5zi]

@@3008venky 😀😀 hahaha how dare you compare her with revolutionary rajarammohan.. She is chameleon,we have seen her changing colors many times.. She is not trustworthy at all...She is opportunistic & nothing else

[@venkateshnatarajan2941]

As a Indian muslin why you should care about what's happening to Palestinians

[@thenun8595]

Why shouldn't we care about Palestinian people. Hindu can pray for Trump win who can't avoid one day without beef. Why Hindu have so much obsession for netanyahyu he is circumcised as well what you people are making fun everyday.

[@logicalindian9227]

Being an ambedkarite atheist I do not accept miss Rashid . Right wing bjp govt is most ruthless despotic towards dalits , minorities etc . She talks about education but ignores commercialization of education . Victims of lynching are mostly dalits , minorities

[@kaushiksahu5646]

Victims of lyn*chings are mostly muslims. You must be a Jay bhim member who is intentionally lying to create hatred for BJP among Dalits.

[@kaushiksahu5646]

Victims of lyn*chings are mostly muslims. You must be a Jay bhim member who is intentionally lying to create hat**red for BJP among Dalits.

[@loveearthly]

You are probably from the Jai Meem army.

[@worldcitizen3519]

After getting reservation you talk rubbish Please don't take any reservation Making such statements are dividing India Atrocities was done on everyone as India was in dark stage for thousands of years If it was done today will support you It's not there hence you can't use this card

[@s-qc9ns]

All your life is base on communist mindset. Communism always fails. Even communist China had to accept capitalism for country's growth.

[@prabhasingh7961]

Ms.Shehla Rashid is really an intellectual person it's not easy to confront and reform your own notions and ideology and continuously evolving as a person.

[@celestialbeing295]

Itna 180 degree turn politics me kam dekhne ko milta hai😂. Full koshish ho rhi BJP ko join krne ki

[@shashikalanarayan585]

AT LAST!!! She realised wisdom 😊

[@Bhaibhavb]

This is what islam teaches ☪️ Quran 47:35 -- So do not weaken and call for peace while you are superior; and Allah is with you and will never deprive you of [the reward of] your deeds.

[@sunnykhan-ie4jb]

It means that you are going to win ,so don't give up .

[@taramisu]

Koran Surah 9:5 Either it is contradictory or it's not very peaceful you decide.

[@riyazgauri3402]

She has lost all my respect.

[@renejoseph6455]

@@riyazgauri3402 like we have lost for all Muslims in India

[@s-qc9ns]

​@@renejoseph6455But I respect Nationalist Muslims❤.

[@rizwanhussain645]

She never had any respect to begin with.

[@hemendrapatel6865]

Very level headed and highly positive...Muslim community needs such leaders...

[@atulkanji]

Brilliant logical replies by Sheela ! Respect!

[@ttdadvisory7061]

Hope many more Muslim sisters will get empowerment for the community's development and social reforms like Shehla Rashid. United India is the best!

[@1991kpp]

The interview was highly pragmatic, and I would like to commend Sheila Rashid for her impressive transition from a leftist rebel to a practical and conciliatory activist. This approach is more likely to resonate with society, making her contributions more impactful. Kudos to her for this commendable evolution!

[@vappalajaiprakash3590]

Muslim Voter is not emotional Voter. Muslim Voter is Allah voter

[@Souvik-v7v]

😅😂

[@FuriousFlash-l4k]

Earlier the people who used to call her anti national, today those same people are calling her nationalist... Logic left the chat

[@tvm73827]

Incredibly articulate, mature and intelligent guest. Unfortunately can’t say the same about the interviewer. Does Shekhar Gupta not do performance management of his staff? Funders please take note.

[@Thinker-l4e7h]

@shefalivaidya Has Print been talking about release of Mahatma Chinmoy Das who is leading a peaceful march for the right to life for Hindus, Buddhists and Christians? If not, boycott Print.

[@IMK1947]

Bucky converted to Winter soldier via Prison programming

[@kamranahsan4495]

Chamchi, she knows how to survive under bjp.

[@AnonymousAntony-o8q]

Its not that the Hindus reformed themselves and Muslims failed to reform themselves. It has always been the fight between the lower caste and the upper caste. Socio economic discriminations are all pervasive, and yet collectively ignored. It is the upper castes that have benefited at the cost of lower caste people's misfortune. The Muslims are mostly lower caste Hindus, and lack the wherewithal to self organize and progress, just like the lower caste Hindus in India do. The tussle is not between the Hindus and the Muslims, the tussle is actually between the lower caste (Hindus and Muslims) and the upper caste. The lower caste can change their religion, but not their caste, the plight of the Pakistan is a testimony to this fact, feudalism/casteism is rampant in Pakistan. The lower caste has not only been hammered from millennia of oppression(both observable and unobservable, quantifiable and unquantifiable), and has failed to revive itself because of its inability to unite, collaborate and cooperate among themselves.

[@KaushikMajumdarKopiteForever]

The Print only want to talk about “Muslim” discrimination and every other discrimination is non existent! Kudos Shehla Rashid for coming on a platform that’s so against her positive messaging and taking her position to people who don’t agree with her. I’m buying her book!

[@jailorgbn7817]

Aapne meri baat kar di,true words,❤

[@devangerdthori3757]

I feel the largest "minority " group is extremely lucky...that there are no reprisals ... ..as often happens ..on news of oppression & fake news ...in the neighbouring countries.....A feather in the cap for the majority population in India...and the maturity of its people

[@akashmendon7850]

This is the Guide book to how to be Left media.. Look at her the questions.. Muslim Muslim Muslim.. she acts like they are the minorities in India😂seriously they must be 20+Croes now

[@thareja12]

Amazing interview! Both the interviewer and the guest were great.

[@ThePrintIndia]

Thank you for watching!

[@lovepeacehatewar9818]

Life is Long, Running from Teen, Students, Colleges, Young Ages Where We were living in JHOSH, HOT BLOOD, Believed In What we Hear, See At First WITHOUT Research, Without Knowing Actual. But when year and years Past we Gratully get Matured and Change, we able to know What where Wrong, what is Wrong, and what is Right, So Life meh Ache ke Liye Change Hona Acha hai, Sheila Rashid ko👏🏻🙌🏻👍🏻 sfbeng 🙏🏻

[@surajgurav]

Winner mindset vs Loser mindset. Very positive conversation

[@Bhaibhavb]

This is what islam teaches ☪️ Sunan an-Nasa'i 3097 "Whoever dies without having fought or thought of fighting, he dies on one of the branches of hypocrisy."

[@Malik-lh4jh]

Lindu hatemonger

[@doncorleone3901]

So what should we do now?

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

If you don't war monger you are a hypocrite? What does that even mean?

[@Bhaibhavb]

@@NidzShah-ps6kr Means always stay in action mode. Wherever you find any disbeliever/nonmuslim thn udhar hee nipta dene ka as is mentioned in holy holy quran.

[@Bhaibhavb]

@@NidzShah-ps6kr Means always stay in action mode. Wherever you find any disbeliever/nonmuslim thn udhar hee nipta dene ka as is mentioned in holy holy quran.

[@daljeet140177]

I don’t like this reporter. She is not good for journalism culture

[@rayrwyr]

There is large amount of very serious systematic discrimination against Hindus in India.

[@RavitejNarayan]

Good to hear that she is talking about reforming islam which is much needed right now.

[@jio0rJine2]

Actually the world needs reformation,the world order is being changed in a wrong direction, ISLAM is not a man-made religion (this is the belief of muslims)...

[@jio0rJine2]

And one more thing, Prophet Muhammad is the last prophet of Islam (he is not a founder) ,thats it.

[@taramisu]

They'd call it blasphemy and attack her. Women already have no status in islam.

[@manjarisheel2275]

Shehla’s model is the classic model of placing all the responsibility of changing the world on the individual citizen. Instead of holding truth to power.

[@atorbGk]

That is an empowered women.

[@SulaimanBeary-ci7xz]

Sheila is right ,muslims should change for the better themselves instead of complaining.

[@devinderchauhan2652]

Muslims are having their golden period period in Indian cricket. No cricket commentary is complete w/o Irfan and Kaif. Right now Muslims are captains of Indian senior women's and men's Jr hockey team. Nikhat is top level boxer. Zeeshan Ali is long time manager of Indian Tennis team. Number of Muslim TV anchors is pretty high. Khan's in Bollywood need no introduction. This Yr 51 Muslims cracked Civil Services exam. Rebel Kashmiri IAS officer Faisal was reinstated. More Muslims are getting Padma awards. Modi's outreach to Muslim countries is world known. There is not even an iota of discrimination against Muslims in governance and delivery of large number of Modi's welfare schemes. Haj pilgrimage has been made better. Muslim religious and political leaders have thoroughly misused freedom of speech in abusing Modi infinite times and yet Modi doesn't retaliate. Kamlesh, Krishan, Kanaihya were subjected to 'sir tan se juda' and to escape it Nupur has to spend rest of her life in hiding. Who threw out Hindus from Kashmir? Islamist have mastered the art of collecting stones and attacking Hindu religious processions. Azan is communal utterance and yet it goes on. Modi made Gujarat communal violence free during his tenure. So has Yogi with few rare exception. The list goes on. There is no mob lynching of Muslims. Some Hindus who are deeply emotional about cows and have volunteered to stop it's smuggling have attacked cow smugglers some of whom were innocent. So don't say Muslims have been attacked. Say cow smugglers have been attacked. Quote one example where BJP, particularly it's central and state leadership is involved in this violence. Look at the kind of freedom Muslims are enjoying in Bengal. The list is endless. The problem is Muslims and their non-Muslim appeased don't want to be truthful and factual about the exact issue. Muslims are enjoying parallel constitution by way of Sharia but cunningly selectively as for the criminal part (tit for tat justice) they want to enjoy the Indian constitution. Madrasa teachings are highly communal and unpatriotic. Muslims do not know co-existence. Violence (mentally, verbally and physically) is the only tool they believe in sorting out differences and problems. They show trans order pan Islamic ummah patriotism. They protest if a Muslim terrorist is killed by non-Muslims in some other part of the planet. They were 9% in 1947. Today they are more than 15% and this demographic shift is terrorising non-Muslims. Who has stopped Muslims from progressing? They neither want to do hard work nor introspection. They have given nothing positive to the world. Shehla is a are exception.

[@thenun8595]

What you people give to the world language of hate. City of [e-mail] tax caste discrimination. It was Britishers who make you what you are today. 😂😂😂

[@saksham_srv]

Her thoughts are flowing like water.

[@reardelt]

It's not discrimination that the Indian parliament didn't have more than 11% of women. 95% of brick layers are men. She won't raise her voice on that. Also, Can you tell me why majority of nurses are female?

[@alishahrustum655]

It means she is more intelligent then the judges of supreme court 😅😅

[@dileepsreevatsav2502]

Being a khattar hindu 🕉...i respect shehla Rashid s views ❤❤❤ but shame on this provocative journalist .....

[@puneetsingh6602]

Change the interviewer please,such stupid selection of questions Disappointed with Print

[@rashmipawar1688]

Shehla aap ne bahot aachi bate kahi hai Good 👍