Thermapen One Review | Best BBQ thermometer (but should you upgrade?) Thermapen One Vs Thermapen MK4

[@BabyBackManiac]

✅🔴 Buy the Thermapen One www.thermoworks.com/thermapen-one?tw=BABYBACKMANIAC ✅✅ Thermoworks Smoke x4 tinyurl.com/tyo8x5r ✅✅ Cheaper Alternative tinyurl.com/y6tlgse6 tinyurl.com/yxc525qj

[@rayguest565]

Hay Justin I watch a lot of your videos what part of Texas do you live in? Would like to meet you sometime.

[@TROYCOOKS]

Wonderful review Justin! Very informative and funny. Miss ya brother!!!!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Love you buddy. Thanks for watching!

[@ehelf2356]

Thanks for making this video. I decided to get the Mk4 until I saw the Thermapen One is on sale! I'm excited to see that you're posting new videos again. Keep up the great work!

[@jamesbraden5353]

You sold me! Just ordered mine using your link in Tennessee Orange. Will take a couple weeks longer to get it, but hey, I will be one of the first in the country to have that color. As always, great job Justin!

[@iliketurtles536]

My question going into this video was "whats the difference?" and you addressed it in this video perfectly.

[@BabyBackManiac]

I'm glad it helped.

[@jeremylane6824]

Thanks Justin! I’ll stick with my MK4 for now, by the time my bbq is ready to temp, the beers have slowed down my vision where I wouldn’t know the difference. Appreciate the review. Keep up the good work!

[@bradhelfrich6602]

😆 🤣

[@brianshenk6912]

Dude! We all know what you talkin bout! 👏

[@SJCOOKS]

Getting the mk4 at a discounted close out price seems to be something nobody is talking about. I am considering purchasing a 2nd mk4 as backup or to at some point gift.

[@BabyBackManiac]

I would have mentioned it if I had known. I was under the impression at the time I filmed this it was going away the day this came out. They will be gone soon though so grab the 4 while you can if you want to save a few bucks.

[@richardg4817]

@@BabyBackManiac I bought the Mk4 for my son for his birthday recently. Was a great deal at $69.99

[@BabyBackManiac]

@@richardg4817 Absolutely!

[@SmokyRibsBBQ]

Awesome review Justin! I totally agree that the ThermoWorks Thermapen is the very best investment you can make if your serious about BBQ and want dead on accuracy that you can trust. I will probably end up getting the Thermapen One just because it is the best instant read out there right now!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah, Rus, it's so crazy how good they have gotten. Thanks for watching, my friend.

[@brucewayne9699]

You're right, though it's a great investment for anyone serious about cooking in general, not just BBQ.

[@SmokinJoesPitBBQ]

Good stuff Justin. Very thorough review.👍

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks, bud. I actually put some time into planning this one. I think it helped keep my rambling to a minimum. (*he says after posting a 16 minute video about a thermometer. lol)

[@richardg4817]

Geez, I just got the e-mail from them yesterday and you have one! Lucky you. I love my Mk4 and won’t upgrade. My wife even uses it when she bakes bread. So versatile. For those that want the new one, be a good person and give your old one away. Someone will love you for it.

[@cristrivera]

True👍

[@benross303]

Great comparison. I've been using the MK4 for about 2 yrs. Just bought my son the One & Smoke for Xmas for his new off-set, but as you said the adult in me will continue w/the MK4 for myself. UNLESS my boy starts cooking better BBQ than me:)

[@cookaerialphotography9143]

I was just thinking about purchasing a insta thermometer since I got a green egg for Father's Day. The KZbin algorithm is clairvoyant. Just purchased. Thanks for the thorough review.

[@KM-ex1rr]

Thanks for the integrity of your review. I have the OG Thermapen from 15 years ago and still love it. No reason to upgrade yet.

[@LumberjackPa]

SO FREAKING REAL! You make it easy to trust your word. You're the real deal. Thanks for sharing.

[@BabyBackManiac]

This is one of my favorite comments today, LumberjackPa! Thank you for the kind words.

[@AbsoluteFidelity]

Without watching the vid and just by the specs alone I would certainly go for the upgrade. Faster response times and a smaller margin error are always a step in the right direction. Upgrade, UPGRADE EVERYTHING!

[@nhrabandit]

Was about to buy a 4 when I stumbled upon this video. Thanks for the review.

[@cyberbeer65]

Good in-depth review, Justin. I will buy the Thermapen One when and if my Mk4 gives out.

[@BabyBackManiac]

The only "problem" is that thing is never going to die on you. lol.

[@DavidRamseyIII]

SOB! I just bought a mk4. It’s soo good though. Way more accurate than the MEATER and doesn’t leave a subway tunnel sized hole. Cool review

[@TheMueslikrieger]

Same for me.

[@bry120]

Put that on ebay or Amazon

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks for watching, Jacob. The Mk4 is so good, man. I woudn't sweat it.

[@nateg452]

I don't even remember how I got subscribed to you, but this was a really good review, great job man.

[@mikeoreilly4020]

Justin, I don't know how you do it. 16 minutes on a Thermapen, and the whole thing was entertaining. Great job. Now, if only I could lose my Mk. 4.

[@BabyBackManiac]

😂 thx Mike!

[@gosman949]

I have a Thermapen that is at least 10-12 years old. Had to send it in once for a free repair. Now the battery door is broken but a piece of tape and it is still going strong.

[@cmdub420]

Picked up a MK4 while it was on discount and it has become the best tool ive ever gotten for the kitchen and bbq! cant believe I went all these years without a good thermometer.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah they’re fantastic

[@bobroberts5074]

I still have the original Thermapen my wife bought for me in 2014 because I wasn't going to spend the $99. Best money she ever spent. Still going strong and dead nits accurate.

[@Digital.Done.Right.]

Excellent review Justin. I've got the MK4 and will not upgrade. Your review was extremely clear and exciting to see the company moving forward with their products.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Glad it was helpful!

[@PeterGregg]

Awesome! Now I want one lol 😎 Wonderful video and working it with those camera angles - big thumbs up 👍👍

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks buddy. I actually pulled out all my fast glass for this one. I need more practice with it.

[@Viewtoagrill]

Looks like a great product and a great company Justin. Instant.. means instant... and it seems like Thermoworks did a great job with this upgrade. Take care!

[@BabyBackManiac]

They really did. Thanks for watching, Johnny

[@GallaghersGrub]

Wow! Thanks for this review. Take my money.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Any time, man. Take care.

[@Edward135i]

If you're going to upgrade your thermapen, get the Thermapen IR, it combines the thermapen Mk4 with a IR gun in one unit, I use mine constantly for everything when I'm cooking.

[@Chris-wp3ew]

I saw the ad for the new one and my OCD kicked in... Despite already having a Mk 4 and the Mk 4 with the infrared sensor... I was about to order it.. and like you said, the adult kicked in.. Why? The MK 4 is fantastic. I'll stick with it until one of the Mk 4's fails (and I've never had one fail or even need a battery). Thank you for the honest review.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah you may be "stuck" with the mark 4 for a long time. It's a darn good thermometer. Congratulations on being an adult. ;-) Thanks for watching

[@CompleteCarnivore]

Awesome review. I never had the MK4 but got the ONE and it is amazing. Hopefully I will have a review up in the next day or two.

[@BabyBackManiac]

You are going to love it!

[@TomVoyageuk]

Thanks for making this video, it’s exactly what I was looking for! 👍

[@BabyBackManiac]

Great to hear!

[@sammcgovern8540]

Great information! Excellent video as always! Since you don’t need that MK4 I will gladly take it off your hands😃

[@ManCaveMeals]

Nice review... i am gonna pick one of these up just so I can have one :)

[@BabyBackManiac]

lol. I know, right. They do good work. Thanks for watching, John.

[@Pap1961]

I bought the MK4 2 years ago and love it. I just bought my wife a One, it arrived yesterday. As soon as I got my hands on the new One, I had an excuse to upgrade: My MK4 warranty has expired! Thanks for the info.

[@theqshedbackyardbbq]

Leave it to Justin to create a beautifully produced and highly informative video about a relatively simple barbecue tool! Great job and congrats on breaking the 100K sub barrier brother!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks man. I just try to make them watchable. Anything beyond that is bonus. lol Have a great rest of your week

[@gusm2752]

Great timing. Just ordered one a few days ago , being delivered today. As soon as I placed the order I got the add on the new model. Figures. I’m sure the Mk 4 will do just fine And 40 bucks cheaper.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah man you're set for years to come. Thanks for watching

[@PostalBarbecue]

Great review man. I think what you said at the end is great. I have the mk4 and it is a bad beast! I know that I will upgrade to the ONE once I need to but I am one of those guys uses things until they are lost or broken. Haha. That ONE however if you are looking for a first thermoworks would be what I would choose in a heart beat. Really you can’t go wrong with anything from them!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah man. It's one of the few companies I can recommend and not worry that it's going to come back on me. They're just so good at what they do and they stand behind their products. Have a great rest of your weekend buddy

[@mitchhaunn8400]

Hey Justin, this is a good review. Ironically this past Thursday I purchased the MK4 due to it being 30% off LOL. Thanks for the video! Cheers brother!

[@BabyBackManiac]

And you got a heckuva deal!

[@4-6-3DP]

I just read a Wash Post food Section article today about frying perfect chicken at home. The author mentioned Thermapen. They have a big fan base!

[@robertdewalt8711]

Thank you Justin, currently I use MK4 and last year I bought a MK4 for my Mother.

[@SidebandSamurai]

I really love your channel. Your reviews and presentations are just like your thermo pen you just reviewed. They get better and better. There is such a polish and shine that I am always looking forward to what you say. Thanks for your hard work. Maybe you should buy a bunch of instant read thermometers and test them. Using this pen you just reviewed as the gold standard.

[@MrStoutfool]

I’ve been eyeballing this for a long time. Don’t really care the price, because I’ve already purchased $100 of broken /non functioning temp devices. I still have them sitting around..like they might work? Lol! Thanks for the videos! Cheers!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah, totally. It's the "cheapest hammer is the most expensive" theory. The 5 year warranty is a nice change this time around but it's probably a pretty safe bet on their part. They are made so well.

[@salavalos]

I just received the notification today about the 1 and you have it already! Great video, thank you for sharing!

[@Roy-BBQn]

Thanks for the video. 👍🏼👏🏼 Love my themapen IR. Won’t buy the new one till I want to gift the older. Then I’ll need a NEW thermaworks. Also Love the Smoke for my long cooks. Thermaworks is AWESOME!!!

[@apparaoapparao]

I’m very frugal, but the Thermapen is a luxurious, robust mechanical work of art that is a joy to use and well worth the price. They do go on sale or buy two get one free every once in a while.

[@greengoosehobbies]

Great review, I want to order one and I’ll definitely use your link when I do!

[@mathewramage4194]

I appreciate your honest opinion especially for not pushing the product

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks man. I try.

[@mathewramage4194]

You're welcome. I watched the pellet grill review you did for under $500 that video helped me in making my decision on which pit boss to buy. I ended up with the 600 pro. I'm new to all this and I'm having a blast. Everything I have smoked so far has turned better than expected

[@michaelbsmith7810]

I love my MK4 that I have owned about 4 years. I also have 3 dots and 3 Chef Alarms. What do I think of ThermoWorks? They make quality products! It will be awhile before I buy a new one. I know where to call when I am ready for an upgrade as I just wouldn’t buy from anyone else.

[@ericousleyjr9119]

Great review Justin! I think the MK4 is absolutely perfect. With that said I’m still gonna buy the new one 😬 Cheers🍻

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks for watching.

[@mittelfruh]

I'm awaiting my order of this therm up here in Canada, sometime in July. I've got the Classic, so thought what the heck, I'll finally upgrade ;-) Would you happen to know, if the low light sensor will still work with the silicone boot on it? I'm a brewer, so lots of steam in the environment. Nice review by the way! Cheerz

[@iskato914six]

That's the one for me! great video :) will get this model for sure. Thanks!

[@ItsRyanTurley]

I agree brother! The Thermapen MK4 is the single best investment I’ve ever made in my barbecue journey. I absolutely love this tool, & would highly recommend... Cheers!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Couldn't agree more!

[@hoodnibor]

Thanks Justin, just order it. Good to see you on Hobo live chat earlier this morning. Buy things at 3 o'clock in the morning, have to love the internet.

[@BabyBackManiac]

lol. Thanks for coming back to the channel. Have a great week.

[@JustCookingwiththeGuys]

Nice review, Justin. I’m gonna check em out.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks man. Have a great weekend.

[@DeadBrokeBBQ]

I have always loved my MK4!! I got the Thermapen One I can't agree with you more, how did they make it even better!?!? It is the most used accessory I have ever purchased and has helped me on every cook since I got my MK4 but now he goes to the bench warmer spot while I break in the One!! #1 for me is the display is so much easier to see!! Great video Justin!!!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks buddy. Appreciate you watching.

[@davidb9547]

Love my pen don't know how I got buy without it. Works great so I'll keep it. That said if I already didn't have one, I'd buy the new one just because of the long warranty. Thanks Justin. ✌🤟🖖

[@95SLE]

TY Justin. I am looking to replace my instant read thermometer and will go with the Thermapen 1. Right now I am waiting for it to go on to a Black Friday sale from Thermoworks. Right now the Thermoworks Black Friday sales have me buying too much. LOL And you are spot on about the customer service.

[@seankillian4601]

Great review. I'm doing it. Will look great next to my Mk4

[@victorbenner539]

So first off Justin it's always good to see your vids. Next up,you're timing couldn't be any better. My grandfather started teaching me how to grill when I was 5. That was about 57 years ago. Why do I say this? Because we didn't have instaread thermometers back then so learned the hard way meaning I don't use them for steaks,chicken parts,etc. But dammed if they aren't wonderful for roasts,briskets, turkeys, etc. And I recently decided if I can justify a crazy ass propane flamethrower for lighting my fires ( yes it is the grill gun of witch I speak) I might as well as break down and finally get a thermopen. So thanks to you I'll not mess around and place my order for the new one. Thanks. Now back to the grill gun. I wonder just how fast you can toast a marshmallow ? FIRE 🔥🔥🔥😄👍

[@lennyrubio6824]

Appreciate the honest review, purchased one using your affiliate link this morning

[@mikewalker1081]

Thanks for a good review of the Thermapen One, just subscribed to your channel and used your affiliate link to order through, I figure, if you take the time and energy to do all that, you should get a little juice from the company. Looking forward to checking out your other vids. Cheers.

[@jefferywebster4150]

Enjoyed the review Justin but I gotta say that I see no practical difference. I mean... if you need to slow it down to 25% to see a difference then there is no difference.

[@peterlubke8231]

It looks great. But I’m extremely happy with my InkBird that already has all the waterproof features of the new Thermopen. Are you going to be posting new vids more often than you have been?

[@peppers6037]

Do grilled brisket tacos (the best) 1.) Slice raw brisket thin 2.) Season with season all or lawrys 3.) Grill on high heat (watch for flare up's because of high fat content) 4.) Using a clever chop meat (because of toughness) 5.) Serve on grilled corn tortilla (chopped onion, cilantro, lime, and salsa opcional) Creamy green salsa (most people think it has avocado but its a lie) 1.) Grill 5 jalapenos 2 serranos 2 cloves of garlic and a 1/4 onion 2.) Once charred blend everything together 3.) Crucial step slowly drizzle canola oil while blending to emulsify (if oil seperates stop and remove excess oil and reblend) 4.) Add salt to taste (even though it has a lot of peppers it is not a very spicy salsa. Really creamy in texture)

[@RandyBachmeier]

I have bought a half dozen of these…not for me…but for friends. They are unmatched in quality and performance.

[@Anteater23]

You buy expensive gifts!

[@RandyBachmeier]

@@Anteater23 Just paying it forward.

[@mikebowerstv]

I may have to give them another shot. I haven’t had luck with the Thermapen I have, but I purchased it over 7 years ago. Might be time to try again.

[@BabyBackManiac]

I honestly think you'll be very happy with it, Mike.

[@gazzidgebbqs1209]

You do know Mrs Baby Back maniac watches your videos and you can never throw anything out of the window to get a new one again! I absolutely love Thermopens, they just work each and every time flawlessly. Buy one, cook a chicken breast to temp, you'll never have tasted a chicken breast like it

[@PartyUpLive]

LOVE my MK4. If it ever breaks I'll upgrade but I think it will last a long time because it seems to be very well made. I bought my sister their DASH Thermometer and it has worked great. When my cheaper wireless smoking thermometer dies I'll be looking at the SMOKE.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Yeah they make great products. The price tag isn't cheap but I still think it's a great value for what you get..

[@YesItsMario]

Good review Justin Mk4 is $69 close out price, makes it a hard decision.

[@danielrowe2174]

I just bought a thermal pen MK4 yesterday for close in out price at $69.00. The One was listed at $109.00 before tax. I decided to get a thermal pen because my buddy has one and also my next grill thermometer probe sleeve came off. It was cheap and it was time to get a high quality product.

[@phil6012]

A common problem with the older style is the battery compartment cover has a tendency to break in half through the screw hole. New design resolves that issue. Don't drop and don't over tighten that screw on the older version!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Noted. Thanks, Phil.

[@donniem6191]

My wallet hates me but I’m a guy that has to have the latest and greatest so I’ll end up buying it

[@BabyBackManiac]

Lol. You'll love it.

[@tonysid3563]

Love my MK4! Wanted to get the MK4 with the built in IR, but will wait for them to add IR to the new ONE.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks for watching, Tony

[@tonysid3563]

@@BabyBackManiac Hooked up with you from "T-Roy". Figure anyone he's got respect for gotta have some good she-it! I know you have deserved cred from being up front about Thermoworks. Will be checking out your other advice/experience. Thanks for what you do and share Bro!

[@msreneethebarber]

*_New here fam_* ! Great video and very informative. 💈💈💈

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks and Welcome aboard!

[@darringuiter]

I would love for you to do another review. I’m hearing nothing but great things about the new Franklin BBQ pits. But I’m interested in your comparison between that and the lone star grille smokers.

[@rayguest565]

Great review Justin. I have an old thermapen and a mk4 love them both.

[@DrLumpyDMus]

I have a $14 temp pen from Amazon. Every feature discussed/advertised regarding the Thermapen(s) is present on my cheap pen except one. It does not rotate the temp display as you change the thermometer body aspect. Fourteen dollars. I've been using it for over a decade.

[@tedz.]

Love my MK4, no regrets or wishes. That said, Thermoworks (if you're listening) might want to consider a trade in offer. Functionally, the new One is no different than the MK4. It's just all the functionality is a little bit better. As far as the warranty goes, they probably realize that even the MK4 can be covered for 5 years given the known durability. If I thought I was only going to get 2 years out of my MK4, I wouldn't have bought it. Justin - Thanks for the frank and honest review.

[@thomasgates7852]

The Mk4 is currently $30 off on their website so I just ordered one!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Nice! Great deal!

[@grantsdad177]

The mk4 closeout for $69 is a great price I was thinking about buying a few for gifts

[@gotcheese9163]

Absolutely love everything from thermoworks. Of course I’m going to buy it and already have the mk4 and the original. Take my money!

[@wilkiesbbqnc]

Great review Justin going to pick up another MK4 at close out price.Thanks 😀

[@MrFowl]

Have you tried the version with an IR thermometer built in? I really want that one.

[@BbqMikeG]

It’s great to use on cast iron. Dutch oven cooking got more manageable.

[@BabyBackManiac]

I have a IR gun already so I haven't tried the built in one.

[@gambit1001]

3rd! Thumbs up brother, thanks for the vid!

[@BabyBackManiac]

No problem 👍Thanks for watching.

[@LoveLynetteTan]

Thanks for making this video. So appreciate the detailed explanation, cheers!

[@joyceandmichaellarimore7230]

Good Show - Convinced me to skip the incredible MK4 Sale($69) and spring for the One($105) - A Happy Purchase!

[@BabyBackManiac]

Glad to hear it!

[@engineerncook6138]

Great review. I'm a long time Thermoworks fan and upgraded to the Mk4 from a Classic a few years after it was released. Undecided if I'll upgrade again but I may gift my Mk4 to a friend or relative if I do (better than "accidentally" dropping it onto a 700 deg F grill). Excellent comparison showing what I will get if I do upgrade. 5 year warrantee is a plus. I had a Thermoworks timer fail after 25 months of modest use, it had a 24 month warrantee. UPDATE: After two years of use, everything you say is true. I can barely see that The ONE is faster than the Mk4 when plunging into an ice bath, but it is always about 1 second or a tad more. Thermopop 2 is a budget and slower alternative from the same folks. Not ruining one prime rib easily pays for a Thermapen.

[@BigLewBBQ]

I agree the MK4 is excellent, the ONE is better excellence.

[@BabyBackManiac]

So true, Big Lew! Still praying for you every week, man.

[@BigLewBBQ]

@@BabyBackManiac Thanks, I still need it.

[@jimfromri]

Love your sense of humor…and my MK4!

[@mdboatbum]

I want my Babyback, Babyback, maniac back!! Hope all is well. Miss seeing your videos.

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks. Working on it.

[@johnknapp6328]

Is there a reason you would pay over a hundred dollars for those as to some you can get on Amazon for 10.00 mine has lasted for over 3 yrs and I really like it. Thanks for the demonstration but to expensive for this guy.

[@Dive-Bar-Casanova]

Amazon Prime $10 delivered and they work great.

[@illiniwood]

Reason:=Long term pin point accuracy. If the Chinese ballpark temp reading you're getting with yours works for you, then at ten bucks every three years, it will forever keep you money ahead by a small margin.

[@gosman949]

dont blame us if your steaks of burned rather than medium rare!

[@justplanefred]

If you didn't have either would you but the Mk4 for $69 or save up and get the"One" for $105? My dash is getting a little frustrating...

[@jshoutx]

Wasnt there a Thermapen before the Mk4? I have one but it doesn't rotate, uses disc-type batteries and it doesn't have the light sensor. If so, how does mine compare to the ones you have? Your thoughts?

[@ScottysBackYardBBQ]

great review .. i may upgrade now

[@BabyBackManiac]

Thanks Scotty. Have a great rest of your weekend

[@208414]

I have a Thermapen Classic and I decided to preorder the One. I think it will be a nice upgrade.

[@theunchartedtrucker1113]

You have owned many many different grills. What are your favorite or top 3 favorites that you have used. Thanks

[@dwaynewladyka577]

That's a very good looking thermometer. It's a crucial thing to have when preparing things like poultry. Cheers! ✌️

[@BabyBackManiac]

Totally agree!

[@dwaynewladyka577]

@@BabyBackManiac Basically, you get what you pay for. Quality is well worth it. Cheers!

[@truthseeker1328]

Thanks Justin for your thorough evaluation of both Termapens but especially for your honesty about the new one versus the old and not playing the drama queen that everyone has to buy one or you're bbq experiences will be ruined for life.

[@TheFishingfool25]

As I said on their Instagram post, if they offered this in a camo version, like they have before, I would be all over it. Even though both myself and my lady have the MK4 lol. I bought her the Red and I have the Blue, but I want a camo version!

[@BabyBackManiac]

But but but...How would you find it. lol (sorry, dumb dad joke.) Yeah that would be cool. Also the American flag one.

[@TheFishingfool25]

@@BabyBackManiac lol. I agree with the flag version as well. I like that they have different colors, but some patterns would be fun.

[@photasticimages9258]

Great review! I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE my Mk4 and probably won't be upgrading anytime soon. That said, I just gave my sister a Thermapen One for Christmas and she LOVES it as much as I love my Mk4. You really can't go wrong with either!