What If Qui Gon Jinn Continued To TRAIN Obi Wan As A Force Ghost

[@Damariobros]

The glitched bit at 0:08 is "Our Story Begins" for those wondering

[@lunar3055]

Thanks man I was confused by the plot later on after the glitch

[@supremegodemperorpalpatine4872]

And the Jedi I admired most, Met up with Darth Maul and now he's toast. Well I'm still here and he's a ghost. I guess... I'll train... This boy.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Best song ever

[@darthnexus9570]

Stopped the CD I was playing to play this video...😂😂😂

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Love it

[@noah-os5ev]

What cd was it?

[@lowesgameing2003]

​@@noah-os5ev the DK rap

[@lego_minifig]

@@lowesgameing2003ah yes, the best CD

[@Notconceitedjustbetterthanyou]

Nobody asked or cares

[@craiglanedjtripwire]

The idea of dooku framing shmi is an awesome piece of lore even if this is just fan fiction! Well done!

[@sasquatchredman2608]

What if the Jedi were better at communicating their thoughts and feelings? I feel like a lot of the problems that plagued Anakin could have been dealt with if they had been more direct in communicating with him.

[@RFDN0]

That was one of the major problems the Jedi had, which is why they weren't balanced.

[@thedelta4258]

Council: [giving order] Obi-Wan, channelling his inner Qui-Gon: Nah, we're gonna do this

[@nfinity1421]

Thank you for this story! While I had heard of the approach of the abduction of Anakin's mother was arranged instead of random, it was rare and I had no idea where it came from. Thank you for sharing its source and its masterful weaving it in the story. I also loved how you stressed the differences between helping the people, and helping the Republic as well as how Qui Gon had a learning curve to his ability to appear before Obi Wan. All in all another great story I will want to revisit, thank you again for it.

[@bigmanhelper]

In my mind, I consider this video the new course of "The Phantom Menace" and "Attack of the Clones". No need for "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" or "Revenge of the Sith". Great job, as always!

[@markstark1007]

*IDEA:* What If Dagan Gera joined Cal Kestis and fought against the Empire as a Jedi?

[@luisceragarcia2872]

Good what-if story to write about

[@markstark1007]

​@@luisceragarcia2872Thanks.👍

[@RedDragonForce2]

The fact that the idea of Shmi wielding a Lightsaber and killing a family is both outrageous and believable depending on who knows Shmi. Those that know her know she would never do this, not only in skill, but also in personality and choice. Those that don’t know, know that powerful Force Users wield Lightsabers so being told this isn’t too unbelievable. Gotta love a universe where the Force Exists and Laser Swords are a thing one can believe a woman of Shmi’s age can murder an innocent family in cold blood.

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

See now this is how it should be , more proactive Jedi actually making moves & not completely being about this “will of the force” sh*t 😆👏🏾‼️ Great idea & keep the stories up man 🔥.

[@bobafett1313]

I’m glad they cut the line out, I think the Force itself giving Anakin visions rather than all his visions being manipulation by Sidious is better and it also shows the Tuskens have tribes that are evil or do evil things. It also gives Anakin justification for killing the Tuskens rather than him being completely evil in that moment.

[@bizmasterTheSlav]

The force itself aided humanity in settling the galaxy, so the force definitely preferred humans over tuskens.

[@djlego1591]

Personally, I feel like the best version of this kind of thing would be the force giving Anakin the visions of his mother, Sidious finding out about it, then manipulating Anakin with the visions of Padme

[@GrumpyEngineerND]

This is a great idea for a video. I've been watching a variety of star wars 'what if' videos for years, and I haven't been this excited for one in a while.

[@Achuidian179]

I love how you did the part of Revenge of the Sith novel with Dooku hiring the Tuskens. More over, I love how the Clone army was used to ensure the stability of the Republic as is their original purpose. Day 29 What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@dragonblast417]

Darth Talon? A man of culture I see ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@Achuidian179]

@@dragonblast417 thank you

[@noahsibahi-jackson8757]

These what ifs are a work of art!

[@GamingDrummer89]

From the stories so far I've listened to that involve Qui-Gon's influence remaining in the picture, it seems like he was literally the one missing ingredient that could have completely saved the Galaxy from years of corruption under Sidious. I also don't think I've ever seen both Dooku AND Sidious get overwhelmed and destroyed as thoroughly and as quickly as they did in this scenario.

[@Alexrocks2024]

That was a super cool What If. It was wholesome and smart for the Jedi . Tusken Raider are smarter than they look.

[@derrickmabry5803]

The fact that obi wan wasn't a Jedi master for that recording is worthy of order 66 by itself but great vid keep it up man

[@BigWynne]

One of your more well written stories, thanks for another banger .

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

so the Star Wars Galaxy Force ghost Qui-Gon Jinn training Anakin Skywalker and Kenobi sounds fair and logical great one for real also please tell me my friend please have you gotten my comments and requests from the commentary and the last video

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Yup!

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

@@thestarwarsgalaxy then the Star Wars Galaxy my friend my man my brother please tell me when can we expect to see what if Anakin Skywalker went to both the wellspring of life & ahch to Birth place of the midichlorians and first Jedi Temple along with Yoda in the Clone Wars season 6 followed by many what ifs followed by what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself

[@DarthnightKing]

What a twist and great work

[@SaturnBlade]

I honestly believe since Obi Wan is the only other Jedi that sensed the darkness early in the first movie he'd be more willing then 10 years after the fact. Yet I did enjoy this. What if please keep up the good work.

[@hobogaming1632]

i love these what ifs they are amazing top tier content here keep on keeping on

[@westube3493]

I guess Maul spends the rest of his life as a weird mechanical spider in a trash hole

[@UnravelingofLathine]

I really liked 16:26 with the Ysalamiri (had to google how to spell it, I wasn’t sure how to begin to XD). That’d actually be pretty cool vibing around Palpatine but he’s completely force powerless. Go take a chess board or something and see if he’ll play.

[@DakotaManchester]

I remember a comment from someone that said what if mace windu survived, but was carbonized boutht by Jabba and was found many years later by luke skywalker. So please do this one i like it.

[@andydaniels3029]

Video idea: what if Palpatine used Sith arcane knowledge and alchemy instead of microchips to issue Order 66 to the clones.

[@alex52043]

The jedi would sense it and order 66 would fail.

[@andydaniels3029]

@@alex52043 One would think so, but the Jedi also didn’t sense their impending demise when the Temple was marched on, nor did they notice anything about Palpatine’s leanings towards the dark side until it was too late, even with Sith artifacts in his own office.

[@andrewmah2962]

The balance of the Force is in danger. Anakin is in danger. The galaxy is in danger. MY EVENING IS IN DANGER!

[@MortonMcCastle]

It's not over yet. Anakin still has training to do and a destiny to fulfill. Sidious and Tyrannus may be gone, but Maul and Savage are still alive.

[@GamingDrummer89]

Sidious and Dooku were FAR above Maul and Savage in power, though, even though the latter two were no joke. I'm sure Anakin and Obi-Wan would take them out easily once they got stronger. Heck, if Anakin got near Sidious' or Yoda's power (which he was destined to far surpass at some point), he could probably just fight them both at once with two sabers and take them out on his own.

[@bluex7delta]

But Maul was growing in power. Hideous even called him a rival. So without videos there... maul would grow in power and have the nightsisters there too

[@GamingDrummer89]

@@bluex7delta Yes, he was growing in power, but technically so were the Jedi.

[@3767jack]

I really like this channel. I found it a few days ago. It reminds me a lot of Star Wars theory before he was cringe and toxic. Definitely going to be binge watching all of your content the next few months

[@fenneclord9581]

What if obiwan reasoned with maul before he killed satine that sidious is who he should blame for taking him away from talzin causing his suffering

[@stever3832]

I would love to see a devil's advocate video for Palpatine - what if he had good reason to do everything he did?

[@dragonblast417]

Hey man I've been watching a lot of your videos for a while now and I noticed that you really love having Anakin pull his masters from falling. He did it when Qui-gon was falling from their fight with Sidious, Obi-wan with their fight with Sidious, Kitfisto and Windu with their fight with Sidious, and Yoda with......well you get it. I'm not complaining or anything just fun thing I noticed. Reminds me of Cal Kestus saving his friend in Fallen Order

[@Yan-uz7gv]

Discovered the channel not a long time ago, really love your what if video, keep up the good work !!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thank you so much!

[@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis]

Very nicely done!

[@kewlrob2]

Thanks!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Well thank you!!!

[@LivingInTheLifeOfChrist]

This was cool and I love this man and god will use you if you let him I was very happy to see this

[@Hiddenus1]

For some reason the moment when Qui Gon wakes up in Force Realm I imagined him waking up same way as Gandalf did xD

[@CaptainHarlock-sx6xk]

What if Vader made Tarkin use the Death Star on tatooine?

[@eddiethepothos2648]

He does hate sand that much but why stop at tatooine all sand planets should be destroyed

[@destructiveraider]

One of my favorite ones so far, keep up the good work!

[@leeolson9466]

And also, that obi wan saw how happy Anakin was with padme and said “maybe satine is still around?” Later years maul arrives with savage vs obi, Anakin, and ahsoka.

[@agentchris1482]

Playing the FF7 rebirth demo junon part while listening to this.

[@oscarjacquot]

What if Abeloth emerged during the Clone Wars and took over the body of either: Barriss Offee, Darth Maul, Darth Sideous, Count Dooku or General Grevious?

[@djlego1591]

An incredibly powerful force being like Abeloth possessing Grievous would be a super cool concept

[@reeceemms1643]

here are my ideas carried over day two of asking. would love to see number 2, number 5, number 6, or number 9 What if Padme Amadala was enslaved during the Clone wars? What if Cal and Merrin had a daughter? What if the Ones survived? What if Luke Skywalker fell in love? (weather this is Mara Jade or an Original character I don't really mind) What if during Han's rescue Luke and all that were able to save Han but Leia was unable to kill Jabba and was left behind? What if Luke and Leia found out they were twins earlier? What if Padme was arranged to marry for the Republic during the clone wars? What if Leia chose to finish her Jedi training? What if Din Djaran and Bo-Catan fell in love during Mando season 3 and became joint rulers of Mandalor? Merry Christmas

[@Knight_Raider27]

I am 100% sure that you and Pente are the same person 🤣 you both sound so similar it’s freaky

[@PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay]

I imagine this as a plot twist, plot twist would be they are twins that sound extremely similar but not too similar

[@overanDownUnder]

That’s such an interesting concept rabbit hole to go down. Really enjoying just listening to your theories at work. Earned a new sub man. Thanks.

[@seyacosmoprowertheseedrian2757]

What if General Grevious switched sides during the Clone Wars? For essence, from what I believe Grevious' armour has implants into his brain and it keeps him in that constant state of hatred. Although this is very unlikely, what if those implants wore off and it allowed Grevious to think more freely?

[@fumkioyuki8457]

Saw this weeks ago now saw it now and wonder why did I not watch this previously

[@drewhutchison3115]

The Jedi Council are a terrible influence. Luke is not wrong about them, as in The Last Jedi, he explained their hypocrisy and hubris and that they allowed the Sith to rise, create the Empire and wipe them out effectively.

[@kennykiller]

16:30 So just a politician then?:D

[@rodey6416]

What If Anakin Skywalker accidentally time-traveled to the past due to hyperspace malfunction.

[@brucetharpe762]

The Space Gulag DELIVERS!

[@Dobbsey34]

Great story, thanks

[@cronag4172]

What if Dooku blinded Anakin, instead of taking his arm?

[@lego_minifig]

Going by JoJo logic he would only become more powerful

[@cronag4172]

@@lego_minifigyou could say he have “Unlimited power!”

[@oisinm332]

Ysalimiri do not drain the force they create an area of influence around themselves and in that area a force user is cut off from the force. They repel it around themselves in a bubble.

[@Ellerion2]

FINALLY something that isn't just Sidious being the star wars version of Q.

[@alex52043]

Palpatine wouldn't be so blatant on a long distance communication.

[@PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay]

He didn't know he would be caught plus Dooku knows that Palpatine and Sidious are the same person, why do you think Dooku was genuinely shocked when Palpatine told Anakin to "Kill him, kill him now", he also stopped Dooku from revealing to Anakin who Palpatine really was in that film. Plus remember in Attack of the Clones, Dooku did tell Obi-Wan this: "What-if I was to tell you that the dark Lord of the Sith controls the Republic" something along those lines

[@justinhansen9355]

Please do what if the nightsisters adopted a baby boy to be their protector and how it impacted during the droid invasion

[@spider-deku4479]

What if Cal Kestis trained Luke Skywalker during Episode 5 and 6.

[@Tamamo-no-Bae]

I feel like Sidious gave up way too easily here. He'd have some kind of contingency plan, but otherwise good story!

[@rodgerscott8808]

What if Anakin was trained by al'sharad hett? The tusken Jedi.

[@VestedUTuber]

Problem: A'sharad Hett was himself still a padawan when Anakin first came to the order. He was actually knighted only a couple years before Anakin. _Sharad_ Hett, A'sharad Hett's father, might work though.

[@rodgerscott8808]

@@VestedUTuber true, I sometimes forget those names are interchanged because of disney and their cherry picking the real canon.

[@dianesinger9729]

I liked this story well done

[@thestørmcrier2024]

What if after his arrest the Jedi began to talk with palpatine trying to learn more about the sith and why he chose the dark side? Ultimately winding up partially redeeming Sheev.

[@obi-wankeknobi8413]

The ninth video of the campaign: I wonder what you could cook up with this idea - "What if Anakin died in the Battle of Coruscant ?". I was personally interested in seeing what would happen if Anakin crashed into a munitions crate or something, dying in the cockpit of his crashed fighter. How would that affect Obi-Wan and Sidious's plans ? Maybe Dooku could finally convince Obi-Wan to join him, or something else. Perhaps with Dooku arrested, the Jedi order would believe him and stop Palpatine, either killing him or arresting him. For the Jedi, the prophecy of the Chosen One would turn out to have been wrong, but in reality, Anakin not living to join Sidious would've probably been a better fate for the galaxy. Alternatively, Sidious could perhaps still salvage the situation, making his empire stronger. I think it could be another 2 part episode

[@chesskinge4627]

What if the SDF 3 (Robotech) made its way into the Star Wars Galaxy? Clone Wars has a lot of potential as I would love to see Alpha and Beta veritechs go up against the separatists. The SDF's main gun would be a game changer. Max and Miria's younger daughter might be a prize Sidious would want given her powers. Can a song bring peace to the galaxy or does the Empire rise even faster? What if the Republic found Eternia? Do the jedi help new allies to succeed or does Greyskull fall to a Sidious/Skeletor alliance? Who will gain the strength, the power to become Masters of the Universe!!! What if GI Joe (a real American Hero) joined the Republic against the Separatists? Does the Bad Batch become even better under Sgt. Slaughter's training? How do the Separatists fair against the Republic's elite fighting force? GI Joe the Republic's elite fighting force brought together to fight the Separatists, an organization determined to rule the galaxy! “He never gives up, he'll stay 'til the fights done!” GI Joe a real Republic hero! Yo! Joe!

[@thuvuvan2304]

"save his mother" really changed the course of galactic history

[@chaosinorder9685]

What if the Jedi didn’t forbid attachment? I think that would’ve made a massive difference.

[@fleetmastermichael]

I think stopping the clone wars stop a lot of the potential this had

[@irruption4770]

What if the Jedi had Therapists

[@robertvanostrand]

I paused my game to watch this. This guy's writing is top tier.

[@zackcross7190]

What if Mace Windu found Anakin on Tatooine?

[@PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay]

Now that I wanna see, maybe he can see that the Jedi aren't doing what they should do and he decides to train Anakin as his next student and tells the Jedi Council what he saw on Tatooine

[@bigwsly]

What if anakin led a slave rebellion and led the cis as a gray Jedi

[@HeyShotgun]

You should write a part 2 where dukoo didn’t die and then dukoo executed order 66

[@vnep5743]

What if Anakin went all Voldemort on the other Padawans. What if the Jedi got to the future Darth Maul and/or his brother before they were fully turned?

[@lordofpain3476]

What if Qui-Gon appeared to and trained Plo Koon and Cin Dralig instead of wasting his time with Yoda and Obi-Wan ? What if Qui-Gon came to Anakin as a force ghost and continued to train him instead of yoda and blowme-wan ?

[@john98765333]

I was kind of hoping Quigon and Obi wan would confront Dooku, lol

[@jshaw71-2]

I was just wondering about this, thanks for doing it as a what if, it's a good question yo ask in story form, I'm not sure?about them going yo tython but otherwise a good story

[@saintbooker7]

I listen to this when i wanna relax

[@CommanderAlien18]

What if Anikan betrayed the Jedi and the Chancellor

[@Mech299]

Title's a bit misleading, but it's still a good story :)

[@PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay]

How so?

[@eric-ty3yn]

That was good

[@firelioness363]

What if Quai Jin Survived and able to train Anakin .... He did choose him as his new Padawan learner ...

[@CPUReddragon24]

what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him

[@PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay]

I think PPSW did that story, it's pretty good

[@bradkleinert5605]

What if there was a money exchange on Tatooine? In the story, the trio of Qui-Gon, Padme and Jar-Jar find Anakin, embark on the Pod Race storyline and then, just as the race is about to start, Jar Jar finds a money exchange so, now not only do they get the parts they need, but as Qui Gon goes to take Anakin from Shmi, Padme shows up and tells them the Queen was able to locate a money exchange and get enough local money to buy Shmi from Watto.

[@BadMedic]

This story while good, completely lacks a reason for Anakin to be “the choosen one.” He didn’t bring any balance to the force at all

[@AyminAlhumdi-ly6fu]

MY EVENINGS IN DANGER

[@padmeSkywalker]

This is going to sound crazy but What if Star Wars was told from a different point of view? the entire trilogy was told in a different perspective, one far more horrifying and psychologically disturbing. Every character is the same but it’s twisted. Perhaps the Jedi’s are truly kidnappers that takes children from their parents and disappear like Peter Pan. Perhaps palpatine is like Captain Hook trying to save the innocence and Anakin is realizing the true nature of the Jedi. Perhaps the suppose children Anakin kills are not true kids but they are a changing that can shapeshift into kids and he has to kill all of them otherwise they’ll take control of the senate and the entire galaxy.

[@Starwarsforlife-fx3uc]

In the end you said if anikin killed his mother... Lol

[@MoxJet629]

No new content until 7:35

[@LivingInTheLifeOfChrist]

God bless you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@3liwho571]

Listening to this while cutting grass

[@arthurwhite7134]

What if Revan was reborn as Anakin Skywalker. Revan ( redeemed)

[@shadowfast541]

What if anakin dies in the episode jedi crash and at the end of the war ahsoka becomes the emperor's apprentice?

[@RobertVistal-jp2cw]

Now that I think about it, the jedi for centuries thought force users to bottle up their emotions, their attachments, and that was wrong. Letting go of their emotions that they couldn't control was OK, but being constantly getting told as 'advice' to let go overtime felt more like bottling up their emotions. This felt suffocating and isolating. That was the mistake of the jedi fundamentally. Letting attachments and emotion in could've saved the jedi

[@TenkoBerry]

This this was Good 👍

[@TenkoBerry]

Still Quite Good

[@MakenzieDuckett]

Day 19 of asking what if Vader used bor gullet to torture leia for I formation

[@PilgrimSonnet]

Wait a min, I remember seeing a video like this… did you reupload?

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

No I did not. Probably something similar.

[@CanisMythson]

The only issue I see with this one is... Now how does Anakin bring balance to the Force? Or is the assumption that in this story, Obi Wan was the Chosen One and nobody knew it?

[@jovontahelm5229]

The only thing I can think of is that sidious master is still alive, potentially meaning he might find another apprentice

[@felps_4500]

​@@jovontahelm5229Now that you said it, Darth Plagueis is indeed alive in this continuity

[@michaelthompson3567]

Please part 2!

[@gyularacz7237]

What if Obi-Wan trained Katoonie after Anakin?