Things You Only Notice In Starship Troopers As An Adult

  Рет қаралды 2,035,315

Looper

Looper

Күн бұрын

A satirical slap in Heinlein's face, a love triangle that doesn't exist, and a seriously gutting "happy" ending. Maybe the bugs were the real heroes after all.
#StarshipTroopers #SciFi #Satire
Paul's movie vs. Robert's novel | 0:00
Nazi imagery | 1:17
Carmen | 2:08
Gender-neutral showers | 3:08
Lacks racial diversity (but that's the point) | 4:00
An inside job | 5:08
Good bugs | 6:18
Rico's teachers | 7:24
An unhappy ending | 8:10
Read full article: www.looper.com/346401/things-...

Пікірлер: 6 000
@Looper
@Looper Жыл бұрын
What was your impression of the "Starship Troopers" movie when you first saw it?
@twilightgardenspresentatio6384
@twilightgardenspresentatio6384 Жыл бұрын
I loved the gender equality and saw it immediately.
@LastBastian
@LastBastian Жыл бұрын
@@twilightgardenspresentatio6384 I loved the bewbs and noticed them immediately
@jonathanmarkoff4469
@jonathanmarkoff4469 Жыл бұрын
@@LastBastian Mine was that this isn't what Heinlein wrote, but it's a very photogenic movie.
@mochasmiley9743
@mochasmiley9743 Жыл бұрын
Loved it
@mookz34
@mookz34 Жыл бұрын
In the book, there was a third race "the skinnies" that changed allegiance from the humans to the bugs.
@pelmeni_va
@pelmeni_va 2 ай бұрын
Bug propaganda.
@shijaschka
@shijaschka Ай бұрын
Smells like treason against SUPER EARTH
@JosephDickson
@JosephDickson Ай бұрын
Looper has been reported to the Ministry of Truth.
@Scorponox93
@Scorponox93 Ай бұрын
@waximax
@waximax Ай бұрын
you made me cry of laughter xD
@krzysztofkaruzo6899
@krzysztofkaruzo6899 26 күн бұрын
good bug is a dead bug
@marscaleb
@marscaleb 3 ай бұрын
The year Starship Troopers came out, MST3K did a special about the Oscars. After poking fun at the frontrunners for Oscar nominations for half an hour, the last punchline of the show was a throw-away joke about Starship Troopers. And yet, here we are 25 years later, and people are STILL talking about Starship Troopers. Nobody even cares about The English Patient.
@donnietobasco4526
@donnietobasco4526 Ай бұрын
That is a very specific reference lol
@TheSteakStyles
@TheSteakStyles Ай бұрын
Googled "the English patient" after reading this... Can honestly say I don't even remember that film being advertised.
@marscaleb
@marscaleb Ай бұрын
@@TheSteakStyles I only remember a joke in Seinfeld about someone saying they didn't like the movie and then everyone turning on them for not liking it. Also I just double-checked, and I got the year wrong; the 1997 Oscars were for the movies that came out in 1996, so the Oscar winner that Starship Troopers "competed" against was Titanic. Even saying that though, I still hear more people talk about Starship Troopers today than Titanic, especially since most of what I hear about Titanic are parodies and jokes rather than the meaningful content behind it. Oh and Starship Troopers was nominated for best visual effects, but lost to Titanic. Also Jurassic Park the Lost World, but it just goes to show that Oscars are more about Hollywood circle-jerking than meaningful acknowledgement.
@Barefoot433
@Barefoot433 24 күн бұрын
Nah, not exactly. See it as such if you like.
@LukewarmEnthusiast
@LukewarmEnthusiast 21 күн бұрын
Thanks in no small part to Helldivers 2!
@DrSarcasmable
@DrSarcasmable 3 ай бұрын
Fun bit of trivia: Movie props are expensive, so if they aren't too famous or iconic (lightsabers, ruby red slippers, etc.), they tend to end up in warehouses until needed for another film or show. If you are a fan of Firefly, you might note some familiar armor on the Alliance military.
@enjoythestruggle
@enjoythestruggle 3 ай бұрын
Federation*
@nokh3382
@nokh3382 2 ай бұрын
Now that you mention it, I did notice some similarities between the two but originally I thought it was just a coincidence.
@Maxihzb
@Maxihzb 2 ай бұрын
Also in power rangers Lost galaxy they used this same armor
@matthewedwards123
@matthewedwards123 Ай бұрын
I remember the infantry armor and weapons made a comeback in a Power Ranger episode. I believe it was the Power Ranger Space season.
@griffvaldez
@griffvaldez Ай бұрын
Not only that but the reason they have the oversized silly looking assault rifles is that they were going to have the power armour in the movie. they made the power armour scaled rifles with no scope because helmet camera link. Then, low on budget, commissioned cheap helmets and flak vests instead of the originally intended armor.
@Lechuga1815
@Lechuga1815 3 ай бұрын
At the end Rico yells "come on you apes you wanna live forever". It's a haunting scene because it's a direct quote from Ironside's character who is reenlisted and dies in combat. This paints a haunting future as the cycle of death and war for these soldiers starts over and over again.
@rogerlynch5279
@rogerlynch5279 2 ай бұрын
KERLS, DO YOU WANT TO LIVE FOREVER - Quote of FREDERICK THE GREAT in the Batlle of Kunersdorf ( Seven Year´s War )
@williamfox6826
@williamfox6826 2 ай бұрын
Marine Corps Sgt. Maj. Dan Daly said something very similar in WW1. “Come on, you sons of bitches, do you want to live forever?”
@boomsayer5169
@boomsayer5169 2 ай бұрын
There's a deeper layer to that line. It's also saying that the only way for a mortal human to live forever is to be remembered through heroic deeds/a glorious sacrifice. It's a way to get them to risk their lives with less hesitation. But the reason *Rico* says it is to cement Radchek's legacy and pass on his teachings to the new Roughnecks.
@hunteralderman4867
@hunteralderman4867 Ай бұрын
I felt that too, but I think when you remember the novel is actually a bildungsroman it is part of showing him turning from boy to man, which is kinda wholesome? But yes, that only really just adds to the hauntingness if you see it as him growing up to take his place in the grinder. Though again in the book the soldiers are all super elite as opposed to the human wave nonsense in the film, so it isn't a grinder in the book.
@ziggrrauglurr
@ziggrrauglurr Ай бұрын
The novel was also satirical, but it in a different way, it continuously exalted the militaristic system while at the same time showing you all the cracks it had, if Verhoeven actually thought the book was prowar he didn't understood it. Ironside's character (Rasczak) line, is repeated by Rico because at the end of the movie the system has processed him and spit another Rasczak. In the book you see Rico's father "seeing the light" and enlisting, at all points you see the system grinding up people and remaking them into usable pawns (kinda like the military dies to soldiers)
@greghelm843
@greghelm843 Жыл бұрын
The best bit about the kids squashing the bugs is when it cuts to the mum and she's maniacally laughing and clapping
@DarknessIsThePath
@DarknessIsThePath Жыл бұрын
lmao
@WolfPriest_Leon
@WolfPriest_Leon Жыл бұрын
Probably it is not their mum, but their teacher, and it makes it ever more grim.
@paulgrove1407
@paulgrove1407 Жыл бұрын
Reminds me of the one photo of Trump kissing a woman's baby at a Rally.
@amac9245
@amac9245 Жыл бұрын
Kamala Harris anyone?
@Mike_294
@Mike_294 Жыл бұрын
@@paulgrove1407 or Biden trying to do the same thing, but the kid's parent pulled her away from him.
@PhilipNorthcutt
@PhilipNorthcutt 4 ай бұрын
I was an extra in that scene where they run into the ships. We ran ALL day. They filmed it at a hangar at LAX and had huge green screens in the background. The gear was hot and heavy, but it was still a kind of cool experience.
@karstenengelmann925
@karstenengelmann925 4 ай бұрын
cool! Glad you had that experience in life!
@AremStefaniaK
@AremStefaniaK 4 ай бұрын
How many bugs did you kill!
@eciekoc
@eciekoc 4 ай бұрын
You did your part!
@Kameleonic
@Kameleonic 4 ай бұрын
Thank you for your service;)
@Make_Canada_Trudeau-Less-Again
@Make_Canada_Trudeau-Less-Again 4 ай бұрын
I checked......and they have no record of you on the set........would you like to know more!
@sundowner8639
@sundowner8639 Ай бұрын
i keep seeing people talk about the meteor as a false flag and there's no proof that the bugs can launch them. But noone ever mentions the part of the movie where we literally see a meteor launched at the fleet as they approach the homeworld. Sure it could be a conincidence, and it's the only instance in the movie we see it actually happen outside of the propeganda, but i think intentionally clipping it out while saying "the only evidence is propeganda" is dishonest.
@donfolstar
@donfolstar 3 күн бұрын
How fast is that meteor traveling and how far is that planet, or any bug, from Earth?
@sbaltys
@sbaltys 4 ай бұрын
i hate when i click on a thumbnail then realize its looper
@christopher8659
@christopher8659 Ай бұрын
Why?
@sbaltys
@sbaltys Ай бұрын
@@christopher8659 their content is shallow, derivative, and obviously just taken from other better channels.
@bobjibbers7521
@bobjibbers7521 Ай бұрын
I see what you mean now... a very mid take on this film.
@Nsinger998
@Nsinger998 4 ай бұрын
8:09 - In the novel, The recruiter was far worse off, Described as barely human. Later, Rico finds him in the officer's bar looking normal and healthy. The recruiter explains that he removes his prosthetics while recruiting to make sure those who enlist know what they're in for and scare away those too weak to handle service.
@yxcdeb
@yxcdeb 4 ай бұрын
Yep, it was explicitly for transparancy, which is why its so annoying that Veerhoven bastardised almost every part of the novel's philosophy into a simplistic nazi parody. As much as I love this film, Veerhoven is the student who didnt understand the lesson, but speaks as if the smartest man in the room. To me, this is a perfect example of loving the art, but hating the artist.
@notsocrates9529
@notsocrates9529 4 ай бұрын
@@yxcdeb He inadvertently made fascism look appealing and reasonable.
@royhill5202
@royhill5202 4 ай бұрын
@@yxcdeb I love the book and the movie for completely different reasons. Heinlein was a Naval Academy grad. He felt that service to something greater than oneself was the greatest thing one could achieve. Starship Troopers was written to show that. One could contrast that to Harry Harrison's Bill, the Galactic Hero. Harrison wrote BTGH as a counterpoint to Starship Troopers and Asimov's Foundation series. I love the movie because it does show that Ultranationalism can lead to Fascism. In the DVD movie commentary, both Veerhoven and Neumeier specifically talk about how neither one of them actually read the book.
@SubtotalStar850-uh8pg
@SubtotalStar850-uh8pg 4 ай бұрын
@@notsocrates9529 When you have people do so for Communism, Dictatorships, and Monarchs it only makes sense people would do the same for Fascism, they're all equally flawed ideologies which take good ideas to drastic extremes with no thought for the individual
@kukenballe7063
@kukenballe7063 4 ай бұрын
" what their in for" they're*
@grimkupid8478
@grimkupid8478 Жыл бұрын
only thing missing out of this was "would you like to know more?" between every point lol Love this movie, and book,
@toddbloss
@toddbloss Жыл бұрын
"would you like to know more" and "I'd buy that for a dollar" are catch phrases that have stuck in my head for over 20 years.
@edbrackin
@edbrackin Жыл бұрын
Very witty.
@elmurdoc
@elmurdoc Жыл бұрын
I'm doing my part, are you? 😂😂
@cmasterson
@cmasterson Жыл бұрын
I just typed this. This was definitely a missed opportunity by the channel. Like all the research just to miss it.
@patrickdoane7
@patrickdoane7 Жыл бұрын
Why yes! Yes I would like to know more 😅😂
@onosendai2323
@onosendai2323 Ай бұрын
I grew up during comunist regime and we had a thing called TV speaker - it was a person who talked before the movie and whose purpose was to explain to us how we should understand the movie we are about to see. This reminded me about it a lot.
@Pico52
@Pico52 Ай бұрын
Reminds me of the Chinese version of Fight Club where before the buildings blow up at the end it cuts away to say the police took care of everything and the main character went to a mental care facility and recovered from his illness. lol Can't have the authorities look like they aren't all-powerful and all-knowing, I guess.
@BBanzaj
@BBanzaj 2 ай бұрын
ah yes, totalitarian, where you can leave the boot camp at any time and you are even told several times to do so, where a general is able and willing to leave his rank because he knew he fucked up, where media is so unrestricted that you can literaly have a live stream from the landing at normandy (or its equivalent in this universe)
@gggggggge4379
@gggggggge4379 Ай бұрын
the novice interpretation of youtubers has been spreading to the masses of young people who think they have it figured out.
@cattysplat
@cattysplat Ай бұрын
When you control people's mind by controlling the society, the people will enforce others to do what their masters will.
@PrimusGladius
@PrimusGladius Ай бұрын
A pedantic criticism that nevertheless cuts at the quality of the review. Many people use authoritarian and totalitarian interchangeably even though there are important distinctions between them as you point out.
@QoMSoL
@QoMSoL Ай бұрын
@@PrimusGladius and that is not the only bad use of terms the authors of this vid are vaguely familiar with. I mean come on, how does it even come to you to say "utopian faschist society"? Dystopian, n'est-ce pas? I'd say it's an overall disappointing video with a pile of very wrong and silly conclusions. Obviously drawn by a person entirely unfamiliar with concepts of war, political structures or even just military service.
@jamieterhark
@jamieterhark Ай бұрын
He tries to make it seem like everything about the humans is wrong and the bugs are innocents defending themselves. One line that proves it is false is when they join their new unit and ask the female officer about her combat experience. She says Zegema Beach which is the vacation planet Rico’s father wanted to take him. Defending by attacking a resort? There is no good or bad in this title. More about two opposing forces colliding. War, military, politics and everything connected to them is usually marred in the grey area. That’s where the fascist satire comes in. There are some things about the society that makes sense and others that have you laughing or shaking your head because it’s absurd or blatantly wrong.
@Susumagoo9
@Susumagoo9 Жыл бұрын
The scene where the queen bug sucks the brain out of that guys head like a Capri Sun. Traumatized me as a child.
@kanoreese1253
@kanoreese1253 Жыл бұрын
Lmaox10! You're comment had me rolling!
@evancrum6811
@evancrum6811 Жыл бұрын
Same!!!!
@TheFlutecart
@TheFlutecart Жыл бұрын
Don't worry! That bug would starve to death around the likes of you folks! - LOL!
@jamesmcstein6758
@jamesmcstein6758 Жыл бұрын
Michael Ironside 'They sucked his brains out!' Awsome scene lol
@evancrum6811
@evancrum6811 Жыл бұрын
@@jamesmcstein6758 It's delivered so well and so campy
@okami36
@okami36 11 ай бұрын
I saw this in the theater as a young man. A theater on Ft. Knox, and most of the other seats were taken by other young men who were in basic training. Made the movie far more interesting and amusing. Especially during the shower scene, when some young recruit jumped up down front. He started pointing at the screen and hollering, "Sarge! Sarge! Why don't we get that?"
@360entertainment2
@360entertainment2 11 ай бұрын
Funny story, years ago at Fort Hood there was a barracks snafu where some young guy got paired as a roommate with a young female troop. Both had just come out of Basic Training, didn’t know that wasn’t normal, and shared a room for a few months until they had their first big inspection. The Leadership had a field day and tore the dude a new one but again he didn’t know better, in fact he actually mentioned Starship Troopers during his defense. Not sure if the female troop got in trouble! 😂
@davealmighty9638
@davealmighty9638 11 ай бұрын
Never heard of trips to a movie theater during basic training. 🤔🤔
@slaytanic921
@slaytanic921 11 ай бұрын
@@davealmighty9638I had one in boot camp in fall 2009 in the Marine Corps. It was thanksgiving and they let us watch “300” on base theater MCRD San Diego.
@ciolake4136
@ciolake4136 9 ай бұрын
Why doesn't anyone talk about how Dizzy is openly refusing to take "no" for an answer, repeatedly stalks a guy who is dating someone else, and after he refuses to dance with her, she even physically pulls him into a dance position against his will? and stalks him from school all the way to the army? when i saw it in the theater as a 13year old girl, i was so embarrassed for Dizzy.
@CharlieBravoTango
@CharlieBravoTango 9 ай бұрын
​@slaytanic921 in 2005, when going through basic training, we somehow managed to pass barracks inspection for the first time in front while our CO was doing the inspection. This had been the first time I'd seen the movie at 20 since watching it when it came out at 11 or 12. To us, it was juts getting hyped about our ongoing training. Somehow, the director made an awesome movie trying to satire facism and knowing a bit more about the works its is based from, there is a part of me that believes there should be a difference between civilians and citizens.
@nebulous6660
@nebulous6660 Ай бұрын
This analysis is full of errors. Here's just a few points: 1. Paul Verhoeven did not read the book, he put it down after reading a few pages. 2. This is not an authoritarian state. An authoritarian state does not afford it’s citizens civil liberties or political rights. 3. Accusing the film of lacking diversity is silly as the soldiers are highly diverse & the highest military leader is a black woman. 4. There is absolutely zero indication in the film that the Buenos Aires attack was a false flag operation. The best you can do is point to people’s “speculations”. That’s simply inserting things that aren’t in the film. 5. You say the treatment of the brain bug at the end illustrates just how "victimized" the bugs are while completely ignoring how the brain bug treated two unarmed prisoners of war. Not to mention how the bugs treated a Mormon settlement on a planet that the bugs were not indigenous to either. 6. The bugs are an aggressive colonizing species that are spreading through the system so confrontation with them is inevitable. Obviously they are not interested in a live-and-let-live philosophy evidenced by what they did to the Mormon settlers (not a single weapon was shown in the carnage). The Federation at the very least creates quarantine zones to avoid contact with the bugs which is what a let-live policy would entail. Ultimately it's not the audience's fault for not seeing Verhoeven's "hidden brilliance". It's his fault. He did not make an effective satire of fascism. Fascism is not even depicted in the society he showed. Using German uniforms does not add any substance to the argument.
@hays0939
@hays0939 Ай бұрын
it feels like the person here is justifying as humans as "genociders" and making the bugs "good???" lol
@nebulous6660
@nebulous6660 Ай бұрын
@@hays0939 pretty much
@skellytonium8160
@skellytonium8160 Ай бұрын
Exactly right, Verhoeven simply failed in his goal, and now he's mad that people are "misinterpreting" his work. How about the fact that Rico's parents are rich despite being non-citizens, and that he could've picked any other line of work as a non-citizen and lived in affluence. Or the fact that being rich afforded him no special benefits in the army, which is an incredible showcase of meritocracy that doesn't even exist in our "democratic" and free society. If he wanted to show that the bugs were a non-threat or that the meteor was the military's doing, he sure did a poor job at that, since the former is clearly not a true and the latter is pure speculation. He could've made society far less fair and impoverished, the military more shady and corrupt, and the bugs more "innocent", but he failed at all of those things and that's his fault.
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
I'd give this a like, except you said something about "Verhoeven's hidden brilliance". He was not brilliant at all. He was jealous, and small.
@nebulous6660
@nebulous6660 Ай бұрын
@@garymelchisky2880 that was sarcasm
@Veldazandtea
@Veldazandtea 4 ай бұрын
"Where citizens aren't aware of what's going on." Just like real life then.
@retropulpmonkey
@retropulpmonkey Ай бұрын
That's... that's the... yes. correct. Well done.
@Koranthus
@Koranthus Ай бұрын
arguably with the exception of the asteroid bit (which could have been a natural disaster, you never actually find out what happened), their citizens are more informed of the war effort and what is going on than real life.
@Jiraki_the_Wingless
@Jiraki_the_Wingless 24 күн бұрын
@@retropulpmonkey They got there eventually.
@Andy-Mesa
@Andy-Mesa 10 ай бұрын
This is the first time I've ever seen anyone refer to Jake Busey as a heartthrob.
@Nevyn515
@Nevyn515 5 ай бұрын
That was autocorrect, it was meant to be heart attack looking for a place to happen.
@apanickedseagull
@apanickedseagull 4 ай бұрын
Tall Has money 2/2 for things women want.
@marquesekj
@marquesekj 4 ай бұрын
​@@apanickedseagull still missing the most important ingredient to being a heartthrob...GOOD LOOKS
@apanickedseagull
@apanickedseagull 4 ай бұрын
@@marquesekj At a certain level of income good looks for a man is irrelevant.
@Stoigniew666
@Stoigniew666 4 ай бұрын
@@apanickedseagull then maygbe it's a wallet-throb?
@samg5463
@samg5463 Жыл бұрын
Starship troopers is a bit tongue in cheek but it’s also a pretty accurate portrayal of military life. Signing up for the wrong reasons, love troubles, making friends with people you’d have never thought you would, and getting to play with explosives. The only thing it’s missing is a caffeine and alcohol abuse.
@murky5101
@murky5101 11 ай бұрын
yep, as i take a sip right now. My thoughts exactally.
@cthatcher11482
@cthatcher11482 11 ай бұрын
Don't forget the tobacco use too
@kirby89000
@kirby89000 11 ай бұрын
Don't forget the over excessive use of hot sauce
@Grimmwoldds
@Grimmwoldds 11 ай бұрын
@@kirby89000 And the inscrutinable semi-mystic ritual ceremonies.
@TheIRONSTAG
@TheIRONSTAG 11 ай бұрын
AND NICOTINE
@fluffernutter6633
@fluffernutter6633 2 ай бұрын
Things you only notice in Starship Troopers if you're ignorant of the film's origins*
@MrShadowpanther3
@MrShadowpanther3 4 ай бұрын
When I first saw the previews in the theater, the scene where the bugs are rushing the remote compound they were in is reminiscent of a scene from the book "Armor" by John Steakley I was STOKED They might make that into a movie (and I think it would be an awesome movie). Still enjoyed Starship Troopers and went back to get the book and was shocked at how literally different they are. The movie took the Title, some character names, and a few background ideas, and then sprinted in a different direction.
@seanconley903
@seanconley903 4 ай бұрын
TOTALLY!!!! MAKE ARMOR Damnit!!!!
@VladTheImploded
@VladTheImploded 4 ай бұрын
Armor was so good. I loved the similarities too.
@akilgour13
@akilgour13 2 ай бұрын
Armor is a great book.
@ryanhenderson8908
@ryanhenderson8908 2 ай бұрын
I remember reading that book as a kid. I honestly don't remember much but I do think it has a major twist in it that easily works in a book (because you can't see the characters) but I don't know would be particularly easy to pull off in a movie. I remember enjoying it very much though and if they could properly adapt it I would definitely watch it.
@MrShadowpanther3
@MrShadowpanther3 2 ай бұрын
@@ryanhenderson8908I have read the book multiple times now. I think it is still in print. Yes, there was a twist near the end realizing who stood in front of them because he was the ONLY person in the universe who could have stepped into the suit and it responded to him.
@orionred2489
@orionred2489 Жыл бұрын
Please know that there are deleted scenes of her Fleet guy erasing messages from Rico. He really was a snake that let her think Rico had discarded her.
@mikehenrys
@mikehenrys Жыл бұрын
I never knew that. It seemed that she had just dumped Rico because she was so enamored with eventually captaining her own ship.
@alisterfolson
@alisterfolson Жыл бұрын
@@mikehenrys the more you know...
@kkmardigrce
@kkmardigrce Жыл бұрын
Thank you for this, makes her far more likeable.
@moonscar119
@moonscar119 Жыл бұрын
@@kkmardigrce do you want to know more?
@AnalystPrime
@AnalystPrime Жыл бұрын
Too bad they deleted that, I think showing that the other guy is a creep trying to get into her pants and she never finds out would have worked well. Or, after the guy has a heroic death scene defending her from the bugs Rico mentions she must have been too busy to answer his messages so she checks her message history and finds out he was gaslighting her. Instead of stupid love triangle BS show that the the kind of psycho perv the internet tries to claim is some ugly fat guy living in their mom's basement is actually perfectly normal looking and can get into a high position in this system.
@johnparadox9429
@johnparadox9429 Жыл бұрын
One point from the book that was left out [to make it a satire of militarism] was that a person didn't have to be in the military to gain citizenship [which Heinlein noted in a later article]. Working in any government offices [such as the Peace Corps in our system] would allow citizenship, as the concept was to make the potential Citizen aware of the need to keep others in mind, and be willing to give up your own desire to "get all you can at others' loss".
@jeffjwatts
@jeffjwatts Жыл бұрын
The movie deliberately left out a lot from the book. Indeed, the book famously has a line where someone says, " The arachnids aren't bugs, bugs don't build starships." Because in the book, the arachnids were intelligent and built starships and other machinery.
@jv-lk7bc
@jv-lk7bc Жыл бұрын
@MF Nickster *thats* the part that annoyed you? smh
@Numl0k
@Numl0k Жыл бұрын
@@jv-lk7bc He said "that's ONE thing" that annoyed him, directly implying that there are others. But I guess I wouldn't expect solid reading comprehension from people that use "smh".
@kirgan1000
@kirgan1000 Жыл бұрын
and they have the exampel of the blind man who counting the legs of a centipede.
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
The two biggest themes in the book are discipline and putting the needs of others ahead of your own, but every character in the movie has a selfish desire for joining the military.
@MattDunlapCO
@MattDunlapCO 4 ай бұрын
"some key changes" should read "nothing from the book made it into the screenplay". The movie is good but has no relation to the book. Heinlein's book is foundational SciFi and deserved to actually be put on screen.
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
I agree an actual adaptation of the book deserves to be put on screen, because this movie is not an adaptation of the book. However, the movie is both bad and does have relation to the book, if you can call twisting the philosophy completely around to try to discredit the author being a relation
@Hazardteam
@Hazardteam 4 ай бұрын
It's perfect. I was read the interview with the creator in those days when this movie launched. He said the same. He also said, he had try to explain the movie to the guy who played Rico, but that guy isn't understood, because he's never saw any similar to the na71s and the bolsheviks. The only part what i missing from your video, that part, what was the most important one, the speach what represented the whole movie logic. That short speach in the classroom. But the 2 youngster "activity" pushed up from our eyes, the "philosophy" behind that future earth regime. Congratulation! Excellent review, thank You🙂(And sorry for my bad english, i never learned)
@shieldwallofdragons
@shieldwallofdragons Жыл бұрын
The thing about the novel that the movie was unable to capture was the use of the mobile infantry suits. His was one of the first Sci-fi works that went into detail about the power suits...how they could see in the dark, had individual radar, enhanced the user speed and strength. Real groundbreaking stuff for 1959. The movie didn't have either the budget or technology to depict that...which is a real shame.
@johnpatz8395
@johnpatz8395 Жыл бұрын
Yeah, i was sad when I realized it wouldn’t have the mobile infantry suits, nor would they drop via the pods, both of which were covered extensively in the book. Hopefully at some point a skilled director will remake the movie and include the suits drop pods.
@Tanstaaflitis
@Tanstaaflitis Жыл бұрын
@@johnpatz8395 Both the anime spin off movies and the animated Roughneck Chronicles depict the powered suits.
@sonicslv6132
@sonicslv6132 Жыл бұрын
@@johnpatz8395 You should look into the sequels, except ST2, which is trash. On the sequels they got a lot more of the mecha stuffs. ST4 and ST5 is actually japanese animation but still continuing the story of Rico who now already become a badass. What they lost is of course the intentional sarcasm of Verhoven.
@FunningRast
@FunningRast Жыл бұрын
The thing about the novel was that it was completely raped by Verhoeven to make the movie.
@wightrat1207
@wightrat1207 Жыл бұрын
Wasn't the mobile infantry suits partly an inspiration for the 40k Space Marines?
@stupidchatpodcast4599
@stupidchatpodcast4599 Жыл бұрын
I think an important thing to mention is the dialogue. When Rico was a private in a squad, the squad leader was voicing the very same lines that Rico finds himself saying when he becomes of that role, which truly hint and show the transformation.
@mikehunntt5338
@mikehunntt5338 Жыл бұрын
The skit was takin from a officer and a gentleman
@Bootyhunter70
@Bootyhunter70 9 ай бұрын
transformation or indoctrination?
@stupidchatpodcast4599
@stupidchatpodcast4599 9 ай бұрын
@@Bootyhunter70 in this case transformation, indoctrination typically comes with the basic training and first deployment, which is what we see, causing patriotism to take over.
@technofilejr3401
@technofilejr3401 7 ай бұрын
I think you missed the main point, Rico knows he is putting on an act for the fresh recruits. Before he addresses the new troopers he asks Ace Levy “Give ‘em a little of the old man?” The old man meaning the late Lt. Jean Rasczak who used the very same words to them. Ask any drill sergeant and they will admit part of their demeanor is partly acting mean while trying to teach vital skills.
@masterofthedeathwing2839
@masterofthedeathwing2839 5 ай бұрын
i think the idea was that the leader of the roughnecks was a character, so when you become the leader, you take on the character. its like the regalia of a particular unit. how standards and banners are passed down through time in a unit, but in this instance, the banners and standards being passed down, were the character of the leader of the unit.
@bloodfire1989
@bloodfire1989 Ай бұрын
The inside job bit is wrong though and can easily be debunked by the scene of the asteroid taking out the comms deck of the Roger Young (The ship that Carmen serves on). The reason that scene exists is so that you draw a logical conclusion that the same asteroid that hit the Roger Young is the same one that decimates Buenos Aires and because the Roger Young couldn't communicate this back to Earth it comes as a surprise attack against the planet.
@CorvusBelli01
@CorvusBelli01 Ай бұрын
The Bugs can knock small asteroids out of their orbital path in a limited scale, but that doesn't mean they can aim an asteroid at a moving target (the Earth) hundreds of light years away. The actual reason that scene exists is so that you can see how "the Bugs can move asteroids, therefore they could have launched an asteroid at Earth from hundreds of lightyears away" is a deeply spurious argument. The asteoid that hit the Roger Young did so in another star system; even if you imagine it's the nearest star sytem to our own (which is only 4 lightyears distance), that's still over 38 trillion kilometres away. Even if the asteroid was travelling at 100,000 kilometres per hour, it'd still have taken that asteroid 43,200 years to get to Earth. In order for the Bugs to have intentionally targeted Earth with the asteroid that hit Buenos Aires, they'd have had to calculate the speed and trajectory of the asteroid (as well as the movement of the Earth, and the robit of our star sytem around galactic central point, and every major potential gravitational body in the asteroid's path) hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of years in advance, meaning they'd have had to do so long before humans evolved. The distances involved, and the comparatively slow speed an asteroid moves at, mean that it's all-but-impossible for the Bugs to have launched the asteroid attack on Earth.
@raidolato
@raidolato Ай бұрын
@@CorvusBelli01 Cosmic distances and time do not count in this film. After all, people went to the planet of bugs and did not age at all.
@ofgreyhairwaifu4089
@ofgreyhairwaifu4089 Ай бұрын
@@CorvusBelli01 I away find this argument pretty funny. So you see the asteroid changing trajectory or where it came from and go "AHA - bugs couldn't predict that!". Despite neither bugs nor humans having a set way of FTL travel. Despite the trajectory change needing to be calculated by the "inside job" people. To think that you would have to willingly ignore things that are openly provided in the movie and then go "well you need to read between what you've read between the lines!!!". The actual answer is that Verhoeven didn't care about physics, distance and space travel enough to even consider those things and it shows.
@CorvusBelli01
@CorvusBelli01 Ай бұрын
@@raidolato Because they have ships capable of travelling at FTL speeds, which they would need to have to have established interstellar human colonies in a reasonable timeframe. That solves that problem pretty handily, and is a very common sci-fi staple.
@CorvusBelli01
@CorvusBelli01 Ай бұрын
​@@ofgreyhairwaifu4089 "So you see the asteroid changing trajectory or where it came from and go "AHA - bugs couldn't predict that!"." The difference between changing the trajectory of an asteroid to hit "a stationary target within a few hundred kilometres", versus hitting "a moving target a few hundred LIGHTYEARS away", is vast. So vast, in fact, that comparing the two is ridiculous. "Despite the trajectory change needing to be calculated by the "inside job" people" They'd be using an asteroid from within our solar system, which would be a VASTLY simpler set of calculations, and depending on how they move the asteroid (thrusters attached to the asteroid, for example) they can even alter as necessary during it's flight to hit Earth. "The Bugs launched an asteroid at Earth" is the films equivalent to the Gleiwitz incident, or the Reichstag fire. The fact that you hear the fascist governments convenient justification for their war and think "yup, sure, seems totally reasonable to me, it's not like fascists ever lie to achieve their goals, and that's totally not a major theme of the movie" is pretty amusing.
@imrekalman9044
@imrekalman9044 4 ай бұрын
I watched it when it was new, then read the novel, later watched two sequels. All I remember is that movie-Daisy's big death scene was a single page in chapter one. Something about Mobile Infantry doesn't leave people behind, and then at the end of the page it casually mentioned private whoever dying on the way back.
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
"Flores died on the way up." I think that's an exact quote from the book, but I haven't read it in a decade. Still, the movie used it, more proof that Verhoeven or someone read the book, even they they twisted it beyond recognition. That quote, by the way, was its own paragraph in the book, to emphasize it. It was not casual in any way.
@imrekalman9044
@imrekalman9044 Ай бұрын
@@garymelchisky2880 Ugh, I read it in high school, late 90's. Some details are missing, to put it mildly. 😁
@narm_greyrunner
@narm_greyrunner 5 ай бұрын
Starship Troopers is one of the few things where the book and the movie have nothing to do with each other and I love both.
@SaraMorgan-ym6ue
@SaraMorgan-ym6ue 4 ай бұрын
yeah they are two totally different story's but they each are great in their own right.😃
@unrealzman68
@unrealzman68 4 ай бұрын
It smelled false flaggy, but the bugs are also an aggressive species, so they probably did it or were planning it.
@ThatGuy-bz2in
@ThatGuy-bz2in 4 ай бұрын
@@unrealzman68 The movie doesn't really show them as aggressive. They are definitely violent, but we only see them do that where humans are invading their territory. Other than the asteroid hitting earth, we never see them attack outside their own territory. And if the asteroid is a false flag, then they have only acted defensively.
@canadiangopher4443
@canadiangopher4443 4 ай бұрын
@@ThatGuy-bz2in i don't believe the bugs really can send asteroids to the earth, and even if they could why would they, what do they gain? they don't have space travel, its not like they are gonna invade the earth for its resources or anything. As far as their actions when the infantry show up, what does a hive of bees do when you disturb their hive? does that make bees a terrible and aggressive species?
@ThatGuy-bz2in
@ThatGuy-bz2in 4 ай бұрын
@@canadiangopher4443 you're kinda just repeating my point back to me. The previous comment was that they were aggressive. My comment was that we only really see them defending their own territory. The only aggressive action was the attack on earth, which we never really see any evidence of them having done.
@invaderjpq
@invaderjpq Жыл бұрын
The war lasted so long that Starship Troopers turned into Ender's Game.
@HolyMateria
@HolyMateria Жыл бұрын
Amazing comment.
@KageNoTora74
@KageNoTora74 Жыл бұрын
Orson Scott Card reference for the win.
@joescott778
@joescott778 Жыл бұрын
@@KageNoTora74 Good writer, trash human.
@timhenley3602
@timhenley3602 Жыл бұрын
I see what you did there...👍🏽
@twilightgardenspresentatio6384
@twilightgardenspresentatio6384 Жыл бұрын
I love the comparison but where are the Pigs!
@allaboutboats
@allaboutboats 3 ай бұрын
The part where commentator explains his theory of the bug asteroid that hits Buenes Aires was some sort of "false flag" operation (similar to the pretense the Nazis used to justify their invasion of Poland in 1939) meant to incite anger and bloodthirsty revenge was completely lost on me! Is that what Paul Verhoven said he meant? Is the commentator pulling this "fact" out of his nether regions? Or is this something that we all should have realized (but didn't) from the master movie directors clues? If that was the message he was layin down, I sure as hell wasn't pickin it up! Maybe it was a SECRET message that we were supposed to figure out. What BS either way. I was pulling for the humans!
@JonaRosalinaRose
@JonaRosalinaRose 2 ай бұрын
given the massive defense ring meant to shoot asteroids out of the sky was a thing and it just happened to miss one kinda supports the idea that it was a false flag.
@allaboutboats
@allaboutboats 2 ай бұрын
@@JonaRosalinaRose So you are saying you figured out the secret message? Or were you pulling for the bugs?
@kirgan1000
@kirgan1000 Ай бұрын
@@JonaRosalinaRose Not how the movie jump in time, to confuse the matter. They have the defense ring LATER in the war, not then the first strike happen.
@fredmtucker
@fredmtucker 10 күн бұрын
So glad someone took the time and finally focused on the lack of diversity of bugs in this film. I had that same thought back when I first saw this movie! I feel so much more secure and included now.
@ronaldp7573
@ronaldp7573 5 ай бұрын
I was in an airborne unit and we kept a copy of Starship Troopers at the front desk of our barracks. Since we all had 24 hour duty at the desk at some point, we all read it. No one knows who left the book there, but it was almost a relic to us.
@thurin84
@thurin84 4 ай бұрын
what a fitting tribute to heinlein. he wrote the book to "celebrate the poor bloody infantryman" afterall.
@royhill5202
@royhill5202 4 ай бұрын
I read it in the 80's when the Navy had it on the Petty Officer Reading List.
@69BTony
@69BTony 3 ай бұрын
I liked the lessons of the Sgt, sometimes it is better just to shut up. If you are worth a shit, your Sgt will take care of you. As a retired SNCO I fought for my troops every day. I won some...
@TheCaptainbeefylog
@TheCaptainbeefylog 3 ай бұрын
I couldn't tell you how many units I've seen around the world that had a copy of it somewhere. That and Kiplings Barrack Room Ballads.
@nobodynothing00000
@nobodynothing00000 2 ай бұрын
cool story bro. I was with meal team 69 at the Battle of Waterloo.
@Guildguy457
@Guildguy457 Жыл бұрын
The premise of the conflict is that Missionaries went against advice and settled on an Arachnid planet. That can be unpacked in so many ways.
@stephenlreed
@stephenlreed Жыл бұрын
Oh and how many times have intrepid Mormons settled in very inhospitable places? Heinlein knew.
@dalephillips7576
@dalephillips7576 Жыл бұрын
Ask Mesoamerica of the 16-17th Century
@drbuckley1
@drbuckley1 Жыл бұрын
The Mormons provoked many Indian wars, and counted on the U. S. Army to come to their rescue. The film is also a satire of Manifest Destiny, and how Indians were viewed as "bugs."
@JohnDoe-wt9ek
@JohnDoe-wt9ek Жыл бұрын
@@drbuckley1 The Bugs were portrayed more akin to the Communists of the Cold War.
@09daniscool
@09daniscool Жыл бұрын
@John Doe I see the bugs as basically any enemy of a nationalistic state. In order to commit genocide you must turn the enemy into something subhuman, into vermin, into bugs. And what do we do with vermin? We must exterminate them. We see this in many ethnic cleansings - the dehumanizing of the enemy.
@bluskies1000
@bluskies1000 4 ай бұрын
I loved the novel as a 9 year old kid. Survival advice by Heinlein I read as a child (things his sister taught him he said :-) helped me several times in real life. I read it as a sort of anti war/war is survival story- Recruiters tried to discourage you, worked at displaying the horrors of war. BTW The Bugs started the war by dropping asteroids on colonized planets. They did it more than once. I disliked the movie as a adult. I still remember the novel version as the real story, the movie a sort of low budget, shallow knockoff I don't care to re watch (it's painful). But hey, others like it. Maybe I would have liked it better if I had not read the book,
@MelkiBes
@MelkiBes 4 ай бұрын
Whenever you separate the book and the movie as two completely unrelated things, which have the same name by mistake - it settles out just fine. The only thing that spoils it - that Paul Verhoeven got the book all wrong.
@james.network
@james.network 3 ай бұрын
The question is whether the bugs launching the asteroids was fabricated the whole time in order to manufacture the conflict... it is as likely the humans set it up.
@anotherbloodyhypocrite960
@anotherbloodyhypocrite960 3 ай бұрын
"they started the war by dropping asteroids on colonized planets" Two things. 1. Why are we trusting the fascist governments words on how things went down and 2. If those planets had been "colonized" then that suggests it was the humans that started it!
@Inucroft
@Inucroft 3 ай бұрын
@@MelkiBes Naw, he got the themes right. It was a pro fascist thesis dressed up as a fiction story
@MelkiBes
@MelkiBes 3 ай бұрын
@@Inucroft you got it all wrong, too
@taurianferguson
@taurianferguson 4 ай бұрын
I loved this movie and every spin-off that came from it. That it was anti-war totally flew over my head. Large bugs are easy to fear and kill without remorse. I never questioned them striking first. This movie sparked a love of sci-fi infantry novels to this day.
@maciejrozanski154
@maciejrozanski154 3 ай бұрын
Original novel was more interesting, the problem was communication and understunding, most bugs were not individuals but mindless drones, so when they killed colonists they considered it to be not so bad morally action because they assumed humans are similiar in nature, only brain bugs were sentient and were communicating in so alien way both species just couldnt engage in diplomacy, point of sending infantry in the first place was just to capture brain bug, research it not kill it and establish diplomacy to stop war without exterminating them, it is clear that humanity is stronger in later part of conflict but choses not to destroy the bugs and sacrifice many soldiers just for a chance of diplomatic solution.
@taurianferguson
@taurianferguson 3 ай бұрын
@@maciejrozanski154 sounds similar to Enders Game when you say it like that.
@maciejrozanski154
@maciejrozanski154 3 ай бұрын
@@taurianferguson Enders game might have been inspired by it to some extend, i do not know tho.
@69BTony
@69BTony 3 ай бұрын
Anti-war? He picked a bad premise for anti-war, aliens eradicating humans. Anti-war is a suicidal choice. He did such a great job of satirically making fun of the military, I made a career of it, as did my son and my daughter. Well done on anti-military.
@maciejrozanski154
@maciejrozanski154 3 ай бұрын
@@69BTony Just a concept of Enders game seems to be inspired by it, Heinleins original story was not anti war nor anti military, treated it as extension of politics in situation when there is no other option and promoted idea of measured response and negotiatons, i believe Heinlein was serving in the navy himself. I think he was kind a guy like Kennedy to some extend, Kennedy also served in military and was a patriot yet was one of the few that opposed being draggad into wars and military conflicts by his adivsors, generals and CIA. But yeah i got into politics, i also did not liked realy anti war theme in Enders Game where situation was so extreme and it was matter of survival, still a good novel, ive also read sequels to this book but those were not as good.
@pygmytyrantking3153
@pygmytyrantking3153 Жыл бұрын
A scene that I think gets overlooked often is the cafeteria scene. If you pay attention to the background you'll see the trainers watching the argument with Rico and he showed that he was better at commanding/being an "Alfa male", that's when he is given command over a training squad. I always thought that was super good environmental storytelling. I was also surprised at the amount of people that thought the movie was pro-war instead of satirical
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
I think Douglas Adams' legendary quote comes in to play here. "anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job.” But really it's "it is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it." that makes the difference. Yes Rico is gunning for squad leader, it's not his desire to get the job that gets him the job, it's his ability to lead and put others before him that really pushes him to the forefront.
@thisfool89
@thisfool89 Жыл бұрын
"I was also surprised at the amount of people who thought it was pro war instead of satirical " never underestimate how incredibly stupid a massive chunk of society is.
@mandomavicus3616
@mandomavicus3616 Жыл бұрын
I think it also goes back to the class teachings at the beginning being very fascist in ideology where it's very survival of the fittest. Zim didn't stop him butting in line because he saw it as a show of strength and if no one stops him it's seen as weakness on their part. Bully society.
@RobDaCajun
@RobDaCajun Жыл бұрын
Verhoven never read the book. Just skimmed it to tell his antifascist message. Heinlein’s novel is actually quite prescient on how social scientists mess everything up. Take our current clown world as an example. Unfortunately in the real world we won’t have veterans coming to save us from ourselves.
@TheGiltanas
@TheGiltanas Жыл бұрын
@@thisfool89 Actualy its also incredible how badly the director understands the original book. I like the movie. But the book is not nazi propaganda. There is a lot of pretty strong thoughts. And mainly its about free vote rights as people does not think about greater good when they vote, but about them selves. That only if you need to earn the right for vote, you can put the countly and future above your own interrests.
@Wetworks_Arclight
@Wetworks_Arclight Жыл бұрын
Dizzy was better for Rico than Carmen. She loved him selflessly and wholeheartedly. Carmen was all about prioritizing herself as an individual, whereas Dizzy was a team player- she supported Rico 100% to where his success was her success, too. Dizzy earned her place with Rico. Carmen just showed up when it was convenient.
@martyschriver
@martyschriver Жыл бұрын
But Carmen was prettier
@arphod
@arphod Жыл бұрын
@@martyschriver I'd take Diz any day.
@deementia6796
@deementia6796 Жыл бұрын
@@arphod Same here.
@vynnyn5489
@vynnyn5489 Жыл бұрын
Always thought Dizzy was hotter, prettier, more...yeah. Never got why Rico was into fish-faced Carmen, an "upper-class pretty" girl w/ daddy issues who reminds me of a bass I once caught... and when she said "I love you" to Rico she sounded like she swallowed a turd. IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN CARMEN WHO DIED!
@Wetworks_Arclight
@Wetworks_Arclight Жыл бұрын
@@martyschriver Well, that's an entirely subjective opinion. Objectively speaking, Carmen behaved like a basic bitch. Unlike Dizzy, however, SHE was a ride-or-die... literally 💯
@SamJac55
@SamJac55 2 ай бұрын
As someone who was in the military a lot of this resonated with me. Some was negative as was mentioned in this review but very much was actually a positive reflection as well. I always loved this movie in how "grey" it was.
@DaRuckus
@DaRuckus Ай бұрын
The asteroid was not an inside job. you literally posted the scene right before the ship is hit by an asteroid hit off course by the bugs..
@hazelryner8778
@hazelryner8778 Жыл бұрын
My biggest thing as an adult is how impressionable Rico was. He was constantly taking pieces from everyone. Others felt defined and knew what they wanted, Rico was the opposite.
@phoenixamaranth
@phoenixamaranth Жыл бұрын
Pretty much how youth actually are
@climatepurification
@climatepurification Жыл бұрын
Its his leadership type, assimilating the best qualities of those he meets into his own character (usually making a better leader). Anybody that claims to know themselves after only experiencing high school is delusional. Real experiences amongst adults in a larger venue are required to develop an actual sense of self.
@jakubkolacek6813
@jakubkolacek6813 Жыл бұрын
@@climatepurification THIS. Yes. Anyone who finished high school or coledge and think that he is complete ,,human" is soo wrong.
@oldscorp
@oldscorp Жыл бұрын
Rico was dumb and unexceptional. His friends were not. But Rico was wise, so he constantly took pieces from everyone. It's why he grows and becomes a leader and saves the day. Also, I don't really believe that his friends didn't take pieces from others too. His smart friend who became a psychic was not reading his own books in college, but what others people wrote. If people lack the humility and wisdom to actually learn from others, they grow up to be all "personality" and no brains. An empty brain is a useless brain, regardless of how fast or cool it may think it is.
@Snugggg
@Snugggg Жыл бұрын
theres nothing wrong with that though right? RIGHT?
@rightwingsafetysquad9872
@rightwingsafetysquad9872 Жыл бұрын
The Starship Troopers movie wasn't even about the book. The only scene taken directly from the book was the classroom. Otherwise they just borrowed character names and aesthetics. The working title of the script was Bug Hunt.
@aramessurrinam6120
@aramessurrinam6120 4 ай бұрын
there are much more references in that movie that are ignored here. E.g. the scene where Rico motivate his soldiers by: "...do you want to live forever?" is a reference to a german WW II movie and novel called "Dogs, do you wanna live forever?" referring to the call out of the german officer calling for the last attack i the ruins in stalingrad. "Hunde wollt ihr ewig leben" check it out
@Backonos
@Backonos 2 ай бұрын
its not, it is a quote in the book.
@akilgour13
@akilgour13 2 ай бұрын
Taken from a true incident in WW 1 during the fighting in Belleau Wood by Gunnery Sgt. Dan Daly of the USMC. " Come on you sob's do you want to live forever ?"
@Nekroleinchen
@Nekroleinchen Ай бұрын
that quote comes from a prussian king, not from ww2
@del1000005
@del1000005 2 ай бұрын
The movie was most definitely a critique of neo-fascism/Naziism, but the book was anything but. Heinlin wrote his novel in 1959 with WWII fresh in people's memories. The novel explored the dangers of "unfettered" democracy against Russian and Chinese totalitarin communism. Heinlin expressed concerns that an unfettered democracy where people could vote without earning the right through merit (military service or somethign similar) would fall to the communist tide. The concern was that people had come to believe that the right to vote equated to the ability to get whatever you wanted without work or effort. Moreover, while the right to vote was limited to those who earned it through merit, all other citizens retained their rights (freedom of speech, freedom of religion, etc.). The novel was hardly fascist, and, arguably, was not "pro war" (there are very few combat depiction in the novel, and during the invasion of the "Skinnies", efforts were taken not to harm civilians). It was simply about the benefits of a meritocracy over what he perceived was a major weakness in Western Philosophy.
@ziggrrauglurr
@ziggrrauglurr Ай бұрын
Hard Agree, . Heinlein always prized critical thinking and merits, so he didn't directly wrote the critics of a militarized state, he wants the reader to realize what's happening. He was in the Navy, he knows where all the cracks where on the system....
@PMunkS
@PMunkS 4 ай бұрын
3:30 "The main group of recruits discuss their reasons for enlisting in the military..." While arguably not a member of the main group, one uncredited female recruit in this scene states that she enlisted so that she might (be permitted or licensed to) have babies.
@69BTony
@69BTony 4 ай бұрын
We should totally adapt this system.
@CanadianTehGamer
@CanadianTehGamer 3 ай бұрын
@@69BTony Tell me you've not read the book without telling me you haven't read the book.
@69BTony
@69BTony 3 ай бұрын
Well Canadia, The book and the movie are nothing alike. I like both independently. Has Trudy made having balls illegal yet?@@CanadianTehGamer
@CanadianTehGamer
@CanadianTehGamer 3 ай бұрын
@@69BTony Why don't you come over and ask him yourself?
@69BTony
@69BTony 3 ай бұрын
It is a bit of a hike, I live in the free state of Florida. Just kidding about Trudy, look at the mumbling stumbler we have fake in charge.@@CanadianTehGamer
@freddymedina-ui7mm
@freddymedina-ui7mm 10 ай бұрын
As a south American Latino, the fact that Rico was a blue eyed blonde was pretty accurate
@VikingTeddy
@VikingTeddy 6 ай бұрын
They're spesifically *Argentinian* blondes, And everyone should know who's descendants blond, blue eyed Argentinians are. Oh, and it wasn't "hinted" that it "might" have been a false flag attack on Buenos Aires. It's blatantly made clear that it was the government, unless you are ready to believe that the bugs somehow predicted the future, sent an asteroid billions of years ago, and managed to calculate every variable on the slow interstellar trajectory of the rock. There's a lot to unpack in the film, it would take a much longer video to go through it all. One if my favorite movies.
@pog428
@pog428 5 ай бұрын
But it's feasible is it not? Isn't there quite a few in Argentina with German lineage?
@freddymedina-ui7mm
@freddymedina-ui7mm 5 ай бұрын
@@pog428 if you tell me to picture an average argentinian, he would be white and blonde. Or just white.
@VikingTeddy
@VikingTeddy 5 ай бұрын
@@pog428 That's the whole point, it's hinting they're descendants of nazis.
@raymondfellers9430
@raymondfellers9430 5 ай бұрын
@@pog428 And Italian. Many Europeans immigrated to South America.
@Psuedo-Nim
@Psuedo-Nim Ай бұрын
Sadly Verhoeven was incapable of understanding the novel. There's nothing ion the movie that suggest the bugs were set up: in fact, Carmen's ship encounter an Asteroid coming from Klendathu towards earth. the bugs are shown targeting fast moving spaceships in orbit form the surface. The bugs are not misunderstood.
@nauroticdax
@nauroticdax 22 күн бұрын
Fun fact about the shower scene, the cast felt the same way as you described "that it was just to incite thirst" and to a certain extent it was so they told the director that they would only do that scene if he would appear in it with them in the final cut...which he does
@nprbiz
@nprbiz Жыл бұрын
This movie was an amazing feat. To be so amazingly campy but still be so idealistically committed.
@mikehenrys
@mikehenrys Жыл бұрын
It did not reflect a Nazi-like system, because there was no one being taken away in the middle of the night, like the Gestappo did in Germany during the war. Nothing like concentration camps, was even hinted at.
@darklelouchg8505
@darklelouchg8505 Жыл бұрын
I would respectfully suggest, "The Politics of Starship Troopers" here on youtube. It has a good comparison of book vs movie and shows where many of the points presented above, aren't supported by the text.
@ML-dk7bf
@ML-dk7bf Жыл бұрын
@@mikehenrys Also the Sky Marshall who F**ked up, took responsibility and resigned, for a more competent leader. In a Nazi or Commie system, the leaders never take responsibility, they just keep sending more men to the grinder until the system falls apart, or they win.
@mikehenrys
@mikehenrys Жыл бұрын
@@ML-dk7bf Good point. Thanks.
@christianboehlefeld5168
@christianboehlefeld5168 Жыл бұрын
And that campiness is why so many people missed that it was supposed to be satire.
@stevewilliamson7521
@stevewilliamson7521 5 ай бұрын
I read the book "Starship Troopers" while I was serving in the infantry in Vietnam in 1967. Neither I nor anyone I knew over there that read it (The USO provide us with paper backs which we passed around) saw it as anything other than an anti-war novel.
@BRYANMTRUNNELL
@BRYANMTRUNNELL 5 ай бұрын
yeah, the book seemed libertarian, and sort of leaned on the fact that democracy ended up breaking down because people eventually just voted themselves to have ice cream, and had no skin in the game. Changes when you put your name on the dotted line, and have a better appreciation for freedoms.
@WaltherLeopold
@WaltherLeopold 5 ай бұрын
@@BRYANMTRUNNELL damn that's a really, really good summary of the philosophy of starship troopers
@briantoplessbar4685
@briantoplessbar4685 5 ай бұрын
That’s what I thought also. Calling it fascists is way overkill. You can say dystopian or authoritarian I guess
@M.A.Hutton
@M.A.Hutton 5 ай бұрын
That’s interesting. While I had read it along before this, it was actually part of the required reading for the army officers basic infantry course when I went through it in the late 80s. The army doesn’t view it as being anti-war. No, don’t get me wrong, I’m not disagreeing with your interpretation of the book. I can absolutely see how you’re coming at it with that viewpoint and I think it’s totally legitimate. I think one of the things that make this book great is, it can be viewed from a lot of different angles, and held up to illustrate various points of view.
@damianwozniak3798
@damianwozniak3798 5 ай бұрын
Yep when u think how that system work and have conclusions. :) First i think it was a shity movie class-B sci-fi. But afthere i watched it, the movie is great. AND why they were angry about starship troopers ? Not bcs is was gloryfing nazis systems but bcs it was look almost like United States. 🤣
@hankscorpio6111
@hankscorpio6111 4 ай бұрын
This is one of my all time favorite movies. I know it's a B movie but I really like it, and I've read the book too. Heinlein wrote several good books imo.
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
Heinlein wrote lots of good books. This movie was a terrible adaptation of one of his best.
@Luckmann
@Luckmann 2 ай бұрын
No, I noticed this as a teen when the film came out, and it's part of what makes Starship Troopers as great as it is.
@dirtyjrice
@dirtyjrice Жыл бұрын
Starship Troopers was amazing when I watched it as a kid, it's still just as amazing now. Just relax and enjoy the awesomeness that it is.
@theonlyzeek
@theonlyzeek Жыл бұрын
It still holds up to this day
Жыл бұрын
I used to watch The Roughnecks animation with my friends.
@slactweak
@slactweak Жыл бұрын
@Cencalsbest THANK YOU! Nowadays it's psychobabble this and "it REALLY means" that. What ever happened to just enjoying a good movie for pure entertainment value.
@mrman991
@mrman991 Жыл бұрын
@@IRMentat I love how people like you see a satire of fascism and unironically go "ooo, that please"
@darioburstin2418
@darioburstin2418 Жыл бұрын
@@IRMentat So... blindingly following commands to kill other beings for reasons unknown is good merit and personal responsibility???
@golddee2040
@golddee2040 Жыл бұрын
"Put your hand on that wall!" "The enemy cannot push a button if you disable his hand. Medic!!!" The best part of the whole damn movie.
@bobbyboyd4737
@bobbyboyd4737 Жыл бұрын
"Fresh meat for the grinder." This is not a statement about how the authorities feel about the recruits. It's just a statement of fact.
@chrisn6369
@chrisn6369 Жыл бұрын
Lmao I have to agree! You knew it was coming, but it was done so damn well you had to laugh.
@nemak89
@nemak89 Жыл бұрын
Always loved that scene, especially since you can see so many holes in that wall showing there is always that one recruit being a smartass xD.
@jamesespinosa690
@jamesespinosa690 Жыл бұрын
@@bobbyboyd4737 Yeh, it's as if these people have never met or spoken too or read about soldiers at any point in their lives. Good soldiers tend to be pretty stoic and masculine. And masculine men tend to talk like this.
@eriolduterion8855
@eriolduterion8855 Жыл бұрын
@@bobbyboyd4737 This was the veteran (in the book, with visible disabling wounds [missing legs]) whose job it was to eliminate those people (like Johnny), who had no clue as to why they wanted to join, and or were doing it for a "lark", or to run away from home, etc.
@ziggrrauglurr
@ziggrrauglurr Ай бұрын
The novel was also satirical, but it in a different way, it continuously exalted the militaristic system while at the same time showing you all the cracks it had, if Verhoeven actually thought the book was prowar he didn't understood it. Ironside's character (Rasczak) line "Come on you apes, do you want to live forever?", is repeated by Rico because at the end of the movie the system has processed him and spit another Rasczak. In the book you see Rico's father "seeing the light" and enlisting, at all points you see the system grinding up people and remaking them into usable pawns (kinda like the military dies to soldiers). Heinlein always prized THINKING, so he didn't directly wrote the critics of a militarized state, he wants the reader to realize what's happening. He was in the Navy, he knows where all the cracks where on the system....
@nyengster
@nyengster 3 ай бұрын
I have feeling that In america the showerscene was a shock, here in Denmark, we didnt even notice it :P
@thenoisyninja
@thenoisyninja 2 ай бұрын
The characters don’t even register the nudity themselves. They’re not above flirting and making crude jokes but the whole scene is just everyone having a normal conversation.
@MrCommentmaster
@MrCommentmaster Жыл бұрын
After being deployed with NATO-OTAN forces, the co-ed shower scene is only unusual for Americans. Many other countries deploy entirely co-ed in living quarters and showers. It was a bit shocking for me at first seeing a Gorgeous blonde Sweed step out of the shower in front of me, introducing herself, but I soon realized it really wasn’t that big a deal. Only prudish Americans think it’s outrageous, and my wife.
@mbryson2899
@mbryson2899 Жыл бұрын
So true. My better half and I were mistaken for foreigners by foreigners at a swingers club because we were so relaxed about nudity (we were stunned to find _so_ many skin-shy people there). We were both born and raised in the U.S. but somehow we missed the memo about nudity being shameful and wrong.
@dianapennepacker6854
@dianapennepacker6854 Жыл бұрын
Personally I just don't want to see anyone naked. Also hate being naked myself as I feel vulnerable physically. Don't need to see some saggy smelly balls, hanging vag lips, or the brown void. Breasts are okay but don't get mad if my eye catches them. They are there and distracting.
@kevinwebster7868
@kevinwebster7868 Жыл бұрын
Ya r/quityourbullshit
@agpc0529
@agpc0529 Жыл бұрын
Lol and my wife
@JohnDoe-wt9ek
@JohnDoe-wt9ek Жыл бұрын
I can just sense the SHARP cases sky rocketing because someone "eye raped" someone in the co-ed showers...
@kennetherhabor5543
@kennetherhabor5543 4 ай бұрын
I remember stumbling on this movie in the early 2000s. I was hesitant to see it but watched it just to pass the time. Turned out to be one of the best movies I have ever seen. A true classic!
@SaraMorgan-ym6ue
@SaraMorgan-ym6ue 3 ай бұрын
did you do your part and kill a few bugs?
@kennetherhabor5543
@kennetherhabor5543 3 ай бұрын
@@SaraMorgan-ym6ueOh, I did kill a few roaches.😁
@ChannelMath
@ChannelMath 2 күн бұрын
It's strongly suggested that the government picked a fight with the bug civilization. Like, "we were just colonizing their part of the galaxy, when suddenly they attacked!" Reminds me of a lot of Hasbara. I wonder if that was also a subtext
@mitchellcampbell4754
@mitchellcampbell4754 4 ай бұрын
The book is great and the movie is great. They are completely different things.
@Volcarion
@Volcarion 4 ай бұрын
Someone pointed out that, despite the enemy having a distinctly different silhouette and body structure from a human, the MI continue to use human shaped targets, and human-on-human scrimmages. Almost like fighting xenos is an afterthought
@bunnywithakeyboard7628
@bunnywithakeyboard7628 4 ай бұрын
NGL I figured that was the prop makers just being lazy
@AlexZebol
@AlexZebol 4 ай бұрын
Or because bugs were a new unknown threat and one can't foresee anything like this. Much easier to use known silhouettes.
@nekodesigner
@nekodesigner 4 ай бұрын
i guess if you are desensitized to shoot a fellow human, you will shoot pretty much anything
@dmitryivanov9026
@dmitryivanov9026 4 ай бұрын
At one point of the film they speak about making war with other humans.
@LDJ757
@LDJ757 4 ай бұрын
Idk if it was retconned in the movie, but the book has other alien species like "the Skinnies" who are initially allied with the Arachnids until the end of the book.
@themorningsky2632
@themorningsky2632 Жыл бұрын
I watched this movie when I was 10, so I didn't care about any of those hidden messages. I just enjoyed soldiers shooting monsters.
@krilc
@krilc 10 ай бұрын
@@wylderwatkins667 Bro he was 10 what do you want from him?
@DoxxoRoxxo
@DoxxoRoxxo 10 ай бұрын
@@wylderwatkins667 sir this is a youtube video comment section
@johnsteel5347
@johnsteel5347 5 ай бұрын
Calm down Rico
@alexanderbenkendorf688
@alexanderbenkendorf688 5 ай бұрын
Mee to. My son however who's 10 immedately told me it's a movie about space nazis, who bombed their own city & invaded the bugs.. so those hints are pretty obvious to today's generation.
@kedabro1957
@kedabro1957 4 ай бұрын
​@@alexanderbenkendorf688 Every time I hear somebody claim the internet is making us dumber, I roll my eyes. Because I keep meeting kids like your son. I am truly terrified of how useless I am going to be when I get old.
@JC-mn8kb
@JC-mn8kb 22 сағат бұрын
Holy shit, that was Blanche?!?!
@Heroselohim
@Heroselohim 2 ай бұрын
Thanks to this amazing movie we can now enjoy Helldivers 2, but... I'll probably watch this movie again, seems that it has a deeper message, and requires a rewatch as an adult. Great video BTW !
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
Read the book again.
@JohnDoe-og2bt
@JohnDoe-og2bt Жыл бұрын
On the B.A. event, thats the astroid that took out the communication on Carmen's ship, the only one that could've given proper warning of its existence. The asteroids are also how they spread planet to planet so they DO have the ability to make those calculations.
@thepcfd
@thepcfd Жыл бұрын
letc be hones here, Carmen rly hate comunication arrays.
@ballisticwaffles
@ballisticwaffles 11 ай бұрын
Its not so much the calculations as much the time involved. That Asteroid would have had to be shot a factor of time longer than the existence of humanity as a sentient organism in order to bridge the vastness of space to smite Buenos Ares. The Average speed of an asteroid is is about 12 miles per second, or a blistering 43200 miles an hour. To reach Proxima Centauri, a meagre 4.246 lights years from our sun, traveling at the speed listed above, it would take approximately 66812 Years. With what is presented in the film if that Asteroid was going at any appreciable FTL speeds than Carmen's ship would never have been seen again, let alone be able to see the asteroid at all. The Bugs could not have done Buenos Ares.
@GeordiLaForgery
@GeordiLaForgery 11 ай бұрын
​@@ballisticwaffles A good excuse is a logical excuse. 👍
@LucasEckhart
@LucasEckhart 11 ай бұрын
⁠​⁠@@ballisticwaffles I would assume that that there is some sort of wormhole or hyperspace tunnel that allows the asteroid to travel to the solar system in a drastically faster rate. Perhaps the bug is capable of using wormhole as means of interstellar travel? You know, the film mentioned that humans also use similar technology (hyperspace travel).
@masterworm1
@masterworm1 11 ай бұрын
@@LucasEckhart No, there's no wormhole, the bugs are just that, bugs. There's nothing special about them other than they exist at the other end of the galaxy from Earth. That's part of the brilliant satirism of the movie. It's the humans that are the invasive species, the colonizers, and the eradicators. The facist utopia only exists as long as there is an enemy to fight.
@EtherasFox
@EtherasFox 4 ай бұрын
"The book's main character is a Filipino man named 'Juan'" ..... WHAT? XD CORRECTION: No, its Johnny Rico, same character. Juan is just Spanish for John. They're from Buenos Ares. Argentina. A Spanish-speaking country. So it makes sense for Johnny's dad, for example, to call him "Juan". However, Argentina is also very Germanic, and is where many Nazis fled after WW2. Hence the abundance of chiseled German-looking folks. Sorry Looper, you got this completely wrong. I've probably read the book 30 times. Its one of my favorites. Rico is not Filipino.
@David-kn2il
@David-kn2il Жыл бұрын
Never once thought that the Bugs didn't send the asteroid and don't know anyone that has said that beyond this video
@rockymountainkitchen7834
@rockymountainkitchen7834 Жыл бұрын
You're right, the movie even shows a giant bug shoot something out of his ass out to space to knock an asteroid towards earth.
@jeffjwatts
@jeffjwatts Жыл бұрын
"Never once thought that the Bugs didn't send the asteroid and don't know anyone that has said that beyond this video" The Bug sent the asteroid in the movie and bombed Buenos Aires in the book. It's clearly shown. People trying to make it into some kind of Red Flag event are just making up a scenario to fit their own mental mood.
@FunningRast
@FunningRast Жыл бұрын
It’s a fanfic theory. This guy just plagiarized from the fandom wiki and other random sites. No way he actually watched the movie or read the book from what he’s saying about them.
@eoinoconnell185
@eoinoconnell185 Жыл бұрын
@@rockymountainkitchen7834 Exactly. They showed the bug doing it. Although the geometry of it landing on Earth would make it slightly less believable. But the humans were the baddies without a doubt.
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
@@FunningRast exactly. It's fanfic and it's a more modern theory playing on all the false flag talk from the conspiracy theory crowd. This is just a projection of modern politics onto the movie. I've seen this movie way too many times and I never once got the idea humans staged the attack. The farthest I would go is to call it a Pearl Harbor theory where government saw the attack coming and chose not to react knowing it would incite the masses. With how we track asteroids moving today, it's highly unlikely that any future society would be blindsided by an asteroid attack like this. Opportunistic isn't the same as a false flag.
@choboutube
@choboutube Жыл бұрын
Even as a kid, I knew it was meant to be tongue in cheek. Still a good 'fun' movie to watch though. Or rather, that aspect of it, made it a better movie. More depth and substance as it were.
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
It's crazy how kids like us caught on to that, but critics panned it as being pro-nazi and all that. If a 10 year old can watch it and understand it's more than a mindless action flick, how come the critics couldn't? I think they were just jaded by the gratuitous nature of all his films. I've watched his stuff before this one. Flesh+Blood, Robocop, Total Recall, Basic Instinct, and Showgirls are all very pointed and dive much deeper than surface level. I do find it very interesting that Robocop is a very deep philosophical movie, Total Recall is a solid adaptation of a PKD story that toys with the idea of fake reality, and then this is only looked at on a surface level. It doesn't make sense.
@ML-dk7bf
@ML-dk7bf Жыл бұрын
And the special effects still look good today.
@Rybo-Senpai
@Rybo-Senpai 4 ай бұрын
there's a slight inaccuracy, when they mention "officers uniforms" that's not quite exactly right, the Military in Starship Troopers is sub divided, like most armed forces, you have the Fleet who acts as the Navy, the Marines who are, well the Army and Marines and then you have the Intelligence Corp (Neil Patrick Harris's chara is in Military intelligence). Military Intelligence in the movie is seen as a fast track to Officer-ship as mentioned by the Recruiter stating "next time i see you i'll be saluting you" and at the end where NPH Chara is a Colonel, its Uniform specifically is different from the Marines/Fleet Uniform in that it is more reminiscent of the Gestapo and SS, where as Fleet and Marine Uniforms are more grey, the Marines and the Fleet need officers just as much, and if i remember correctly, by the end of the first movie, Rico is a Lieutenant, yet is still wearing the same kit and uniform of other enlisted personnel in the Marines. long story short, only the Intelligence Corps dress like Nazi's, the other divisions of the armed forces don't
@mediapark101
@mediapark101 4 ай бұрын
The only thing I really noticed as an adult that I missed when I first watched the movie was how much the brain bug's mouth parts resemble a....um....much like the face huggers in Aliens also resemble a.....both having long protrusions emanating that spell their own particular form of bad news but the brain bug has added....errrr.... all glooped around ....but I guess that's for another video.
@Suicoo
@Suicoo 2 ай бұрын
isn't there also one of these "find out more"-snippets, where they insert some machinery in the brain bug's mouth with a censor-bar above it?
@fletchfuller2246
@fletchfuller2246 5 ай бұрын
When I was in the military, we loved this movie. Apparently, the director's "slap in the face" was lost on us. We saw it as satire but fun. We wanted to be Rico.
@Tony_Cardoza
@Tony_Cardoza 4 ай бұрын
Paul verhoven stinks, thats why. He's a leftist pig.
@bramvanduijn8086
@bramvanduijn8086 4 ай бұрын
That's the thing about fascism: It is so infectious, that you can't easily teach people about it without accidentally triggering another fascist uprising. At least in nationalist cultures. It has been tried again and again. Robber cave, Third Wave, etc. Lots of teachers that think they should teach kids about fascism and accidentally re-creating it.
@BryceByerley
@BryceByerley 4 ай бұрын
Truth...Verhoeven tried to ruin Heinlien's work and only succeeded in making the MI even more cool.
@Tony_Cardoza
@Tony_Cardoza 4 ай бұрын
@@BryceByerley Agreed!
@BryceByerley
@BryceByerley 4 ай бұрын
@@Tony_Cardoza what's even more impressive is that he made them cool WITHOUT the power armor. When they added the power armor back in, it made them even better.
@fety0101
@fety0101 Жыл бұрын
I didn't take the scene with the Brain bug as suggesting that the Arachnids were victimized. More like a smart vicious creature feeling fear after being captured by the creatures who's brains its been sucking out. Not fear of a conquering humankind but fear of retaliation
@templar1115
@templar1115 5 ай бұрын
yeah I was about to say that. thats the same goddamn bug that sucked out their brains, called false SOS signals and generally fed false info to the federation so they can slaughter dozens of thousands of infantry... also its made pretty clear in the movies that the rocks were definitely launched by the bugs, as far as I remember there are zero hints about it being fake, and also they keep launching more asteroids after... this video is overall complete bull in my opinion
@crappymeal
@crappymeal 5 ай бұрын
Maybe it had to suck brains to protect it's own kind
@jacksonblack9408
@jacksonblack9408 4 ай бұрын
Same. It was more a juxtaposition between the "good guys", and a celebration that they had found a way to inspire fear in their opponent. That fear could be inspired. That the creatures they had dedicated themselves to killing weren't just unfeeling robots, but actually had a 'person' behind them that could be tortured. Kind of reminds me of the newspapers when Bin Laden was killed. Just felt a bit..off
@szeddezs
@szeddezs 4 ай бұрын
Humanity struck first, the bugs were defending themselves. Have you not watched the movie?
@elmariachi227
@elmariachi227 4 ай бұрын
The 'victory' scene is one of the most hollow and damning victory scenes ever. The hollow victory is that they made one bug scared. That's all you accomplished? After sending hundreds of thousands of men to die in a war of colonization? That's all you accomplished? The damning part of the victory is that even though they know bugs have feelings, too, it will not stop their colonization or genocide attempts.
@Chippaization
@Chippaization Ай бұрын
5:08 the "inside job" yet the bugs launched 2 other asteroids to our solar systems. The first hitting mars and them all dying on impact( we headed to klendathu a drop party was attacked and they set up the quarantine zone) the 3rd the luna base took out which was headed to cape town. Queens themselves are smart enough to know to commit suicide instead of being caputred, in Invasion it was smart enough to know how to hijack a human ship head it straight to earth and use to destroy other human ships, in Chronicles the queens are smart enough to use decoy ships and produce bugs that can cloak into human, Hell the movies has a almost planetary size god bug...quickly killed, but probably could to some crazy feats of power. Also the timeline doesn't match up with a lot of things....firstly zander leaves te same time as everyone else, but is a flight instructor when carmen hits flight school. rico and carmen both ship out at the same yet jumps right into flight school and rico is still at the start of basic for generic infantry? there are tons of inconsistencies, but bugs are more dangerous that people think...thankfully also less scary than in the novels Pseudo-Arachnids
@darahdoyle3176
@darahdoyle3176 4 ай бұрын
This was an awesome movie when it came out, I loved it. I admit the themes behind it went totally over my head at the time though. I had no idea and was enjoying it purely as a sci-fi action movie. Brainless action. The adverts throughout did irk me at the time, like my brain was trying to tell me something, but i squashed it all down with popcorn and exploding bugs and soldier being eviscerated. ST was a bit of a flop if I remember correctly, but I loved it.
@ShooterMcGottem
@ShooterMcGottem Жыл бұрын
Starship Troopers was the first R rated movie I ever watched (5 years old when it came out in 1997) and my dad let us kids watch it to my moms disapproval. It made me want to join the Marine Corps (which I later did) and it also made me fall in love with Denise Richards only to realize when I was an adult she was the real villain lol. Dizzy was the real one. That being said the movie was so impactful to me that I didn't even think to read the book until I had already served in the Marines and honestly I'm glad it worked that way. It gave me a much better appreciation for the military themes in the book and a much better understanding of the leadership lessons/political opinions expressed in the book. The book and movie only share the title, SOME names (Diz was a guy who died in the first couple chapters) and the general plot of killing bugs in space but that's pretty much where the similarities end. The book does not promote fascism as Paul Verohoven thought. He self admittedly didn't read past the first chapter of the book and was scorned growing up in a Nazi occupied country.
@diltzm
@diltzm Жыл бұрын
Rah
@Anonymous-rn7fp
@Anonymous-rn7fp Жыл бұрын
Thank you for your service solider!
@ShooterMcGottem
@ShooterMcGottem Жыл бұрын
@@diltzm rah!
@ShooterMcGottem
@ShooterMcGottem Жыл бұрын
@@Anonymous-rn7fp I'm a Marine but thank you!
@captmoroni
@captmoroni Жыл бұрын
The part where Sgt. Zim answers why they train with knives when nukes are available is so much better presented in the book. No ridiculous "cannot push a button if you disable his hand" quip. He explained that war is violence for a purpose, and excessive violence is counterproductive. Spank children to correct behavior, but don't beat them. It also was a call back to the opening chapter where the Mobile Infantry conducted a raid on another planet, destroying a few factories, some other buildings, all to show the native population that the MI can attack them with impunity, and to convince them to obey. The Feds wanted compliance, not extermination.
@JacquesduPlessis11
@JacquesduPlessis11 Жыл бұрын
So sad how few people have read this masterpiece. It really is fantastic. I am glad that the movie has gained more and more popularity in my life though.
@NickC84
@NickC84 Жыл бұрын
I picked up the book on a whim walking through Walmart with my mom in 1997, I was 13 at the time. It was a tie in semi promotional thing for the movie (the book cover had the movie poster on it). The book was totally Heinlein's classic though. I took it home and was absolutely enthralled, it introduced me to so many new ideas and on top of that introduced me to Heinlein as an author. It's STILL one of my favorite books of all time. Needless to say, I had my dad take me to the movie when it was released. I think that was the first time in my life I had a "this is nothing like the book...." moment. To this day I'm still not a big fan of it. I can see the popcorn movie appeal, but it always just reminds me of my disappointment at 13.
@shawnperry5991
@shawnperry5991 Жыл бұрын
I was fortunate to see the movie when it came out and to read the novel this year. Both are amazing in their own rights. The novel is much more than fascist jingoism.
@furiouskaiser9914
@furiouskaiser9914 Жыл бұрын
Listening to an audiobook of it now. Never read it before. Came across my KZbin feed yesterday spontaneously.
@shawnperry5991
@shawnperry5991 Жыл бұрын
@@furiouskaiser9914 Actually, I listened to an unabridged audiobook, not read the novel. I don't know why I wrote it that way. The reader was excellent. Look up the ship names and historical references; it's with it!
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
Both are masterpieces in their own right. The movie is wonderful, but I hate the legacy it left for the book. The book is wonderful and not fascist at all. There is some element of authoritarianism to it, but the reason for the switch to a more authoritarian government is the utter lack of discipline in society as well as a general selfish nature to individuals. It's 2023 and Heinlein's dystopian future that led to the regime is largely playing out. We have Dr. Spock's book to thank for not disciplining kids. We have government officials using their station for personal gain. I could go on. The service requirement to vote and be politically active is two fold. It requires both discipline and that you to put the wellbeing of others before yourself. Basically it's a way to weed out the self-serving and the corrupt. It's spelled out that you can live comfortably in a nice society without ever having to serve and the distinction between the two is minimal. I hate how Verhoven twisted this idea that service and discipline are just the machine breaking and remolding you into an obedient tool. Instead of it being a test to see who is fit to lead, it's perverted to be a form of control. And I know Heinlein gets a lot of crap, but the ideas here are not far off from Douglas Adams who is essentially the polar opposite of Heinlein politically. Adams wrote "it is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it." This then gets summarized to "anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job." We have a lot to learn from the old authors still.
@alexlevesconte7216
@alexlevesconte7216 2 ай бұрын
one of the greatest movies of all time, i still go back and watch it at least once a year at some point. i just wish the sequels stood up to the master craft of the first.
@Mesterlovesz74
@Mesterlovesz74 3 ай бұрын
I jsut run into this now, Starship Troopers was/is my favorite movie I got a poster still (I am 49), hanging on my wall. We can put the idea in the film in perspective, or just enjoy a careless 1,5 hours in our lifes, rooting for the soldiers to beat the crap out of evil aliens. Sometimes, you do not have to look behind the curtain, or you will live a depressive, joyless life...my 2 cents...
@Timotheus157
@Timotheus157 Жыл бұрын
Troopers = Superior warriors defending the superior society by destroying the alien invader bugs. Bugs = Anything and everything that stands in the way of the perfect, superior society. Loved the whole concept and action of the movie 100%! "The only good bug is a dead bug!" So true...so true...lol.
@fxsantazo
@fxsantazo Жыл бұрын
the bug meteor was legit. you're planting ideas
@AlIguana
@AlIguana Жыл бұрын
well, maaaaaybe. It's true that the bugs almost wiped out the human fleet in orbit by throwing big rocks up in the sky, but throwing a huge asteroid million of miles across space with a precise trajectory to hit earth? nah, that seems very doubtful. even if they could calculate it or have "space bugs" that could fly into space and do it. which (as far as we know) they don't. So yeah, it was the humans.
@benjamintherogue2421
@benjamintherogue2421 Жыл бұрын
@@AlIguana No, it wasn't. It was actually the bugs. In both the books and the movies it was canonically the bugs. They just maximized the incident to get everyone rolling in the direction of the bugs to fight them. Not that wasn't unjustified. The bugs were sending a continuous stream of rocks at Earth. That's what hits the ship partway through the movie. A rock on the way to Earth from the bugs.
@yodieyuh6077
@yodieyuh6077 Жыл бұрын
​@@AlIguana We know they colonized multiple planets in multiple star systems. They have some form of interstellar travel. Explain the mechanism that allows humans to travel across the galaxy in his or days using the informal in the film. Explain the mechanisms that allow humans to implant thoughts into a ferret.
@ChrisWiggins1
@ChrisWiggins1 2 ай бұрын
I didn't pick up on any of this watching it, and still not sure if I can draw the same connections as presented here. I just watched it again 2 days ago, so fairly fresh.
@garudanathanael5257
@garudanathanael5257 2 ай бұрын
Thank you for doing your part covering about this hidden gem movie.
@tanukismokingweed
@tanukismokingweed 2 ай бұрын
"Hidden Gem" It's one of the most renowned science fiction movies that still gets regular discussion to this very day?
@gronthgronth2628
@gronthgronth2628 4 ай бұрын
About the disfigurement part, i think Verhoeven left out one crucial thing. In the book, the recruitment officer that is missing limbs is later seen with fully functional bionic prosthethics. He also says that the "disabled" thing is just a part of the shtick they came up in the higher up for propaganda reason, and that the prosthethics make him even more capable in some fields than regular limbs.
@edwardteague3276
@edwardteague3276 4 ай бұрын
Very much so! In the boom, he doesn't wear his prosthetics as a way to dissuade half-hearted thrill seekers from joining the MI. That way, they get even less washout and more willing, less doe-eyed recruits. It is an incredibly important scene, like many of the books scenes, that were cut in favor of the director's attempt at propoganda.
@Galeanthropist
@Galeanthropist 4 ай бұрын
The whole point of it was discouragement. Every bit during your enlistment if you weren't fighting forces was to make it as onerous as possible. You had to WANT to be a citizen so much that you were willing to make great sacrifices.
@peteh3313
@peteh3313 4 ай бұрын
It was also to make recruits think twice before signing up, clearly signalled in the book.
@thurin84
@thurin84 4 ай бұрын
they came up with it to dissuade people from volunteering. does that sound in any way fascist to you?
@hamiller666
@hamiller666 4 ай бұрын
Verhoeven left all those parts about the "benevolent authoritarian government" out on purpose. He wanted a satire about how normal, likeable or even "good" people would fall for a fascist system and AFAIK it was pure studio interference that the movie was turned into an adaption of Heinlein's book in the first place. Verhoeven supposedly hated the book and just took some names and a few scenes he could fit into his original concept.
@thomasbetina7259
@thomasbetina7259 Жыл бұрын
Saw the movie countless times back in the days and i still love it. It's an underrated masterpiece.
@Vares65
@Vares65 4 ай бұрын
You really should read the book then. The movie strips out soooo much. In the book the Terrans are fighting TWO alien races, not just one.
@doobiez2
@doobiez2 4 ай бұрын
Or is you're short on time, watch Roughnecks : Starship Troopers Chronicles, a brilliant series.
@crinolynneendymion8755
@crinolynneendymion8755 4 ай бұрын
Ok, now make a vid paralleling Ender's Game with Starship Troopers.
@user-ji7nf4nc3o
@user-ji7nf4nc3o 3 ай бұрын
Шикарная боевая фантастика! Столько лет прошло, но до сих пор достойно смотрится!!!
@JayOnzs03
@JayOnzs03 Жыл бұрын
I'll always love this movie. RICO! YOU KNOW WHAT TO DO!
@gullyfoyle3253
@gullyfoyle3253 Жыл бұрын
This is really good, thank-you. I met CasparVan Dien not long after ST was released. He was very nice, a dedicated, hardworking, actor who emphasized the importance of research to my theater students. I remember him quite fondly.
@greva2904
@greva2904 Жыл бұрын
I liked him too. Shame his movie career never really took off
@carsilk2492
@carsilk2492 Жыл бұрын
@@greva2904 I like to imagine that by staying out of the Hollywood spotlight, some of these great actors are afforded a more peaceful life
@hornmonk3zit
@hornmonk3zit Жыл бұрын
@@carsilk2492 Yeah what I've heard is that he lives a pretty quiet life with his family taking occasional roles. Basically a standard middle class living driving his kids to school, taking the trash out, watching TV, etc. No mansions, butlers, or magical alien doomsday cults needed like the rest of Hollywood. Pretty cool way to live honestly.
@AkiSan0
@AkiSan0 4 ай бұрын
holy cow is that some mental gymnastics. nothing less expected from this pog channel
@4rtifex
@4rtifex 3 ай бұрын
Lots of incorrect info. Verhoven "grew up" in post war era. While he was born during the war, it ended when he was a babe. The government is not "military run" if anything its run by veterans, who are by definition not in the military. But that overlooks that military service is only ONE way to earn the franchise. Any service to society qualifies you, and no one is excluded if they choose to serve. The military service is dissuaded, and seen as the lower path. Could go on, but its nitpiks.
@FZMello
@FZMello Жыл бұрын
Apparently all the themes involving personal responsibility flew completely over Vanderhoover's head, because of course they did.
@riffbw
@riffbw Жыл бұрын
Service was a litmus test for discipline and being willing to serve others was just too hard of a concept. But let's not forget the famous Douglas Adams quote "it is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it." that is talking about that same thing from the opposite end of the political spectrum to Heinlein. The premise is simple that those least likely to want authority are the most suited to be given authority. George Washington falls in this category. Instead, he made all the recruits have selfish desires for wanting to serve and depicted the "carrot on a string" model of recruitment. They can exploit people that want something bad enough they'll die for it. For what it's worth, I think Rico in the movie becomes more of what Heinlein was looking for after the attack on BA. It becomes more about others than himself. He's got nothing left, so why not make sure nobody else suffers like he does. It's still very shallow, but it's the closest the movie came to the book's intentions.
@vynnyn5489
@vynnyn5489 Жыл бұрын
...but it wasn't his fault!! (sorry, had to!! :))
@PersonalityMalfunction
@PersonalityMalfunction Жыл бұрын
It's a sad indictment on modern values that what is clearly a meritocracy is immediately labelled 'fascist'.
@S3Cs4uN8
@S3Cs4uN8 Жыл бұрын
@@PersonalityMalfunction It falls a bit short of being a true Meritocracy, there likely wouldn't a Citizen/Civilian divide if it was one.
@snuffeldjuret
@snuffeldjuret Жыл бұрын
@@PersonalityMalfunction bingo
@GingerSnape46
@GingerSnape46 Жыл бұрын
Whenever I play Half Life 2, and it's time for the Strider battle at the Nexus building, I always yell "Do you want to live forever?". This was one of my dad's favorite movies. He loved movies with explosions and lots of gunplay, and I take after him. Love this stuff!
@johnnycampbell3422
@johnnycampbell3422 Жыл бұрын
Do you want to live forever? What does that mean to you? Do you want to die (now as opposed to an old man in bed), or do you want to be in history and songs for great deeds?
@GingerSnape46
@GingerSnape46 Жыл бұрын
@@johnnycampbell3422 I know where you're coming from, and while I can appreciate the philosophy that you're talking about, I actually say it because they say it in the movie
@johnnycampbell3422
@johnnycampbell3422 Жыл бұрын
@@GingerSnape46 Daniel daily said the quote in WW1 during a battle leading his men to attack. I have found how someone views the meaning says a lot.
@patrickkenyon2326
@patrickkenyon2326 Жыл бұрын
The line that stuck with me was, " Do the best of someone better"
@jarrodbright5231
@jarrodbright5231 Жыл бұрын
Well the line "Do you want to live forever" was more famous to me from Conan the Barbarian and I used it in multiple D&D campaigns over the years.
@moseshamlett3887
@moseshamlett3887 Ай бұрын
Oh my God. I didn't realize for my entire adult life that that was Garry Busey's son. Until now. Wow. The resemblance is uncanny. How did I never see that before.
@immortalghost443
@immortalghost443 2 ай бұрын
As an Adult whenever I see the first flim, I immediately see Micheal Ironside as the Legendary Sam Fisher, irony is that back then Sam Fisher as a character was a Spy, today that same character even though played by a diffrent voice actor but still sounds like Micheal Ironside is a trainer for Rainbow Six Operators in Rainbow Six Siege...
@davestar4718
@davestar4718 Жыл бұрын
Imagine calling Jake Busey a 90s heart throb 😂
@MyDogmatix
@MyDogmatix 6 ай бұрын
Ya, he has teeth that would be the envy of any zombie.
@albertchurchill4845
@albertchurchill4845 4 ай бұрын
He was a serial killer in The Frighteners.
@SellavinAtoms
@SellavinAtoms Жыл бұрын
25 years later you can't beat a classic
@DRHucke
@DRHucke Ай бұрын
I didn't suspect the 'false flag' aspect of the Buenos Aires attack until a few years later, watching the DVD at home. (On a smaller screen. It's easier to pick apart a movie at home). You start by asking, "Wait a minute. How does an asteroid get hurled hundreds of light-years across the Milky Way to strike a precise target such as the planet Earth? Can the arachnids make them move faster than light? That doesn't make sense." "The asteroid appears in the Solar System near where Carmen's ship is orbiting Jupiter. Why didn't anyone notice before then? It just is suddenly ... THERE." At the same time, I loved this movie. It's so much fun and nonsense, with plenty of over-the-top, quotable lines. "Everybody works. No one quits. If you don't do your job, I'll shoot you!"
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
"Wait a minute. How does an asteroid get hurled hundreds of light-years across the Milky Way to strike a precise target such as the planet Earth?" Because of a bad filmmaker.....
@lolololololo97
@lolololololo97 Ай бұрын
If we had the system in starship troopers that would be infinitely preferable to what we have now
@garymelchisky2880
@garymelchisky2880 Ай бұрын
Very much so. If people had to earn the right to vote, none of the western countries would be in the horrible shape they are now.
@TfMG539
@TfMG539 Жыл бұрын
You do realize that this movie was meant for adults, lol
@SuperJbunt
@SuperJbunt Жыл бұрын
Yet most of us in the comments saw it as kids
@infernas
@infernas Жыл бұрын
@@SuperJbunt indeed lol
@twistedspike69
@twistedspike69 Жыл бұрын
@@SuperJbunt totally busted it out for my 11 year old this last month!
@toga20000
@toga20000 Жыл бұрын
Yeah i was 10 roughly when this came out Yes I saw it lol
@wildlifewarrior2670
@wildlifewarrior2670 Жыл бұрын
What was the LOL
Sci-Fi Movies People Still Don't Understand
21:23
Looper
Рет қаралды 636 М.
STAR WARS De-Infantilized (It Works)
27:05
Beghast
Рет қаралды 2 МЛН
Normal vs Smokers !! 😱😱😱
00:12
Tibo InShape
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
Зу-зу Күлпәш. Стоп. (1-бөлім)
52:33
ASTANATV Movie
Рет қаралды 767 М.
Starship Troopers - Deceptively Smart Satire
10:21
The Critical Drinker
Рет қаралды 2,6 МЛН
How Sicario Fools its Audience
11:27
Film Thought Project
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
The Making of Futurama was a Sh*t Show (Part 1)
21:06
It Was A Sh*t Show
Рет қаралды 488 М.
Why we all need subtitles now
10:43
Vox
Рет қаралды 12 МЛН
The Untold Truth Of The Mummy
12:24
Looper
Рет қаралды 483 М.
The Worst Movies Of 2024 So Far
11:47
Looper
Рет қаралды 29 М.
Firearms Expert Reacts To Helldivers 2’s Guns
21:35
GameSpot
Рет қаралды 990 М.
The Real Stars and Scale of Sci-fi
35:16
The Overview Effect
Рет қаралды 2,5 МЛН
Falling Down was PROPAGANDA
44:02
The Barking Years
Рет қаралды 884 М.
Amazing Magic Trick Failed ❌😱 #shorts #magic #viral #funny  #trending
0:14
Shadab entertainment
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
Цыганка пристает к посетителям фудкорта
0:16
Новостной Гусь
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
Jack drinks Yujiro’s protein! 👹 @GFuelEnergy #yujirohanma
0:42
The Logan Chitwood
Рет қаралды 20 МЛН
Saito09 funny video 😂😂😂 #shorts
0:16
Saito
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
ОНАСИ КРИБ ҚОЛДИ 😨
0:15
BOBUR ALI
Рет қаралды 2,7 МЛН
ПИЛОНИДАЛЬНАЯ киста 😱 #Shorts
0:24
ФАКТОГРАФ
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН