This is what's left of women's lives in Afghanistan | DW News

[@dominicdmello7531]

It isn't the world that abandoned the women. It is the afghan men who have. Especially those in the afghan army and police who walked away instead of fighting the taliban

[@maseehwardak6055]

We had no choice, taliban are afghans, it's the first time in the region's history where the illiterate rural population took control of the nation. Urban educated population is extremely small and stands no chance against the villagers if they choose to fight, and years of war sparked the rural people to fight and takeover. Afghanistan will recover but it will take a very long time. Fighting against the taliban is almost like fighting the entire nation, America knew this, that's why they left. And afghan women, especially those in the villages don't really know what a free life is like, so they don't talk about it. In the cities, people are going to neighboring countries or other countries for education.

[@itsme-sq5rd]

@@dominicdmello7531 women are strong and independent. They can get their freedom.

[@Yeahyeah-r7p]

@@maseehwardak6055thank you for explaining

[@Yeahyeah-r7p]

@@maseehwardak6055 oh dear I can’t imagine. Come to the west if you can, there’s help for you.

[@Sukunasenpai-p4n]

@@itsme-sq5rdfreedom from who who is the enemy of women

[@samlatooni]

This tribe will always be in the stone age.....

[@emptyhad2571]

Even woman in the Stone Age were more free than this.

[@alphaff9939]

Not tribe but Islam

[@SadanandaSadananda-rm3jp]

Islam, Taliban sharia is protecting women's, they have no rape reported. Mashallah

[@Cedawood]

​@@alphaff9939 PRECISELY!

[@phoque121]

Before Islam, the predominant religions in Afghanistan were Hinduism and Buddhism. Can you imagine? I think they would be doing better now...

[@labahadihamimi7128]

Everybody gave up on these poor women .A country ruled by bearded misogynists

[@AnUpo17]

Misogyny is an under statement

[@anasttau9908]

They are the ones who have to fight for their rights. The more you help them the less they will fight.

[@Bozewani]

I taught myself Pashto to define hose women it's a violation on cedaw

[@Bozewani]

Mna raza Pashto farassa metash Afghanistan

[@patrickd8770]

I was there in 2010 with the US Army and helped build a lot of schools for girls around the country. We all were afraid this would happen but it's just heartbreaking to see. hopefully it made some impact or inspired them to what could be. Unimaginable this is happening in 2024.

[@reberi]

I am very sorry that you had to live through the nightmare of 2010. It made me so angry when they had to abandon the mission and let Taliban take over in 2021. So much bloodshed for nothing. I can't imagine how the soldiers who served in Afghanistan must have felt when they heard about that. But thank you for you positive take on that. I hope you are right. Though I am concerned about what the lady in the hijab said, and I see this as well. Afghanistan will become a major security threat to the western world. I am in active service, and I don't want another Afghan war.

[@026585]

If you had the chance to talk to the locals,do you have any insights on why this paticualr branch of islamism(or regional culture) is so adamant to keep women invisible?

[@joseprakashfrancis4114]

It dosen't work that way, the fact is religon is not suitable for the time??

[@celebratingsoundzzz3387]

The current situation sounds bad, but at least you can take some comfort in knowing you did provide valuable assistance to people in Afghanistan who were able to study at the schools you built. Today, there are probably many Afghan woman who are at least able to read and understand math who would not otherwise have those skills. You helped them in the long term.

[@MarciaMatthews]

An educated woman can teach her children to read. This reminds me of the old south, when it was a crime to teach a slave.

[@silenceofpotato674]

10:24 woman, this is the true Islam. How long are u gonna deny that? This is the problem. Nothing else. This is the problem why u guys are suffering all around the globe. Either u r denying the truth or u didn’t study your religion. I mean study. Not to listen from scholars. Check the references by yourself. Accept the truth. 'Islam' is the problem.

[@20SG20]

💯🎯

[@salvatoresikilacci8460]

Primitive Men culture!! Afghan Women and Children you will one day taste true freedom.

[@asraalisultani4594]

The people who choose peace instead of freedom, they will lose both of them 😢

[@DaGabbaGangsta]

True that !!!!!!

[@mikenogozones]

For everyone who cheered on the Taliban especially the keyboard warriors, is this what you support?

[@smitprmr]

Apart from Pakistan, nobody cheered Taliban. Pakistan because they share common religion with them.

[@niloyahmed7765]

​@@smitprmrBangladeshis too

[@dotmarceo]

Are women happy where you are? Be concerned about that. Afghanistan is sovereign. Remember that, colonist.

[@smitprmr]

@@niloyahmed7765 Yea I have seen many Bangladesh G-hadis here in NY. They are pro Palestinians aswell.

[@mikenogozones]

@@smitprmr You’d be amazed on how many pro Taliban comments I see especially on Twitter.

[@Ivanka-yr9vl]

Absolutely tragic for the women living there

[@sidali2590]

Shame on the Taliban they treat women as second class citizens thanks for covering this DW

[@NikhatKing]

Why DW dont cover Gaza situation. Afghan women are dying without food. Gaza women and children died without food, and so called liberals are shut there mouth. This woman Don,t said any word of Gaza situation. West planted this woman

[@SpicyPlur]

​@@NikhatKing​ and what would you want them to say? That we should "free" Palestinians from Hamas the same way we talk about the Talaban? That Palestinians have the right to kidnap and torture anyone in Isreal? That both are examples of evil Islam? Your logic indicates that you are too young to even know what a liberal is. If she is talking about the Talaban why would she talk about Hamas. If you are talking about an issue you do a deep dive into that topic, not a general glaze over all topic. 🤡

[@miifi1825]

​@@NikhatKing Because this is a program of women under the talibans. There are other videos of g aza. I have seen masses of them so it should be easy for you to find. Not EVERY video needs to be about g aza.

[@Catnyp2828]

The palestinians chose to put Hamas in charge. Want to stand up for them? Go there and see if you can change their ideology!😂 @NikhatKing

[@youtubeconnollyfamily]

@@NikhatKing why not cover the women in Israel who were kidnapped or murdered?

[@mbrown6837]

The plight of the women in Afghanistan is due to their own religion. Their Quran permits men to treat the women and girls, in the manner that they are being treated today. What is being suggested that the world do about their situation?

[@HumanbeingonfloatingEarth]

What can we do. 😢 Devastating for these ladies

[@mbrown6837]

@@HumanbeingonfloatingEarth There are areas in the world where women are starving. At least they seem to have enough to eat.

[@Kelektroid]

Exactly! Afghanistan shows Islams endgame. They are responsible for it themselves. The world, with which she means the west, has our own issues to deal with.

[@Kelektroid]

​@@mbrown6837North Korea comes to mind.

[@misfitm1457]

@@mbrown6837 they'd probably rather stave than this, I know I would

[@asraalisultani4594]

I'm from Afghanistan, I've lost my freedom, my education and now I'm just disappointed 😢I get depressed

[@ammiiskander7372]

yes and corruption is low people are more safer and justice system is efficient in the previous government it was the opposite exactly so what is wrong and right is highly subjective you should have done a movement like taliban and fighten for justice to all people you would surprised by how many men would have joined and supported you if you provided them with what the taliban did so next don't blame taliban blame yourself for your selfishness and how you cared only about yourself most of these problems did not bother you because you as a woman it will rarely affect you the other side have seen it the other way and choosed the taliban see history is full of such scenarios it is an unfortuante reality

[@maseehwardak6055]

آنلاين درس خوانده برو، انشاالله مکاتب باز خاد شد.

[@asraalisultani4594]

@@maseehwardak6055 I've completed my school, I was at university 🥺💔 but I couldn't complete

[@asraalisultani4594]

@@ammiiskander7372 اصلا خودت میفهمی چه پیچ پیچ میکنی ؟ فکر کنم اول باید ادبیات ته قوی کنی ، بعد نظر بدی

[@maseehwardak6055]

@@ammiiskander7372 لوده دا چيشي دې ليکلي، ښځو حقونه خوړل شوي، دا يو واقعيت دى.

[@RIANAVENTER]

If I had to live there I'd rather not live - that's no life.

[@Mooon123-b9o]

@@RIANAVENTER and it’s been three years that we are living in this prison 🖤

[@mamabear-x7u]

I support you. I rather go down as a free woman than to bend a knee to babarism

[@RIANAVENTER]

@@Mooon123-b9o 🫂

[@Jennyxx-ie5jw]

I was with guys from there and it waa the worst experiences ever

[@itsme-sq5rd]

@@RIANAVENTER it's your perception.

[@helpanimals-]

THEY let this happen. The taliban rode in on bicycles, BICYCLES!! and the people let this happen. They received training from the US forces and didn't want to fight for their country. Now they pay the consequences for a very long time. Afghanistan is a failed country

[@creativeaarts4023]

What if they are happy with Taliban.. Just showing some different face.. Else they would have done something if they had problems with Taliban long back..

[@vibeit8304]

Afghanistan is living in the stone age era because talibani men feel comfortable with that. Seems like these mens life goal is to be an extremely overprotective parent of women!

[@dotmarceo]

Are women happy in the USA? or in Germany? No!

[@vibeit8304]

@@dotmarceo who are you?representative of all the women in USA & Germany?

[@dotmarceo]

@@vibeit8304 Is that a yes?

[@happyvalleyroses8145]

@@dotmarceohappier.

[@userq38x]

​@@dotmarceo women are much happier in the West, yes.

[@natashahaselton6710]

And the UK gov wants to bring that life to UK. Australia too. This sadly will be our future if people don’t wake up n rise up.

[@SusanaXpeace2u]

yeh, the blinkered naivety makes me so angry and fearful

[@jenn9579]

Women there have always been slaves. So very sad.

[@infidelheretic923]

Not always.

[@MarkOmega.]

We could help them, but they lie to us.. so we choose to leave them in their miserable veiled lives

[@dt6esdff413]

@@infidelheretic923 fact, the only time when us stationed there. now back to square one

[@nama796]

Iam not slave 😒

[@smitprmr]

They got 11 long years to quit their religion and accept modernisation. But they didnt. So now let them suffer their own faith.

[@planesandbikes7353]

This is why it infuriates me to hear people say the US and the West wasted their effort and resources in Afghanistan. This is just not the case. They turned Afghanistan into a semi-free society for a full 2 decades. 20 years of girls in schools and women in the workplace. A whole generation who got to grow up with real lives. The tragedy is the West pulling out of Afghanistan abandoning 20 million women in that Taliban-run nation turned back 5 centuries once again.

[@seanbrennan9188]

Sounds like you're suggesting colonizing them is the answer. I thought that was Western imperialism.

[@Tribuneoftheplebs]

​@@seanbrennan9188 exactly. The women of Afghanistan must do for themselves just like western women did. They do not need us to colonize them

[@ASmithee67]

Is it the job of the West to force its culture/values on the local natives?

[@oakridgemall-8jl2h9f]

@@seanbrennan9188 The West learned that from the Meccans and Medinans.

[@oakridgemall-8jl2h9f]

@@Tribuneoftheplebs That's easier said than done . . . *Qur'an 4:34* “Men are in charge of women by what Allah has given one over the other. So righteous women are devoutly obedient. But those from whom you fear arrogance - advise them; forsake them in bed; and b___t them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand.” *Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 72, Hadith 715* "Aisha said, 'I have not seen any woman suffering as much as the Believing women. Look! Her skin is greener than her clothes!'" *Sahih al-Bukhari 7:137* "We got female captives in the war booty, and we used to do _coitus interruptus_ with them." *Quran 2:282* And get two witnesses out of your own _men._ And if there are not two men (available), then a man and *TWO* women. *Qur'an 65:1, 4* "When divorcing women, know their waiting period. For women past the age of menstruation, their waiting period is 3 months - and those who have _NOT_ menstruated yet as well."

[@erinbyrnes5921]

Its sad how Afghans didn't fight to protect their freedom.

[@oakridgemall-8jl2h9f]

*Qur'an 4:59* “O believers! Obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority” *Qur'an 8:20* Believers! Obey Allah and His Messenger and do not turn away from him". *Qur'an 5:101* “O believers! Do not ask about any matter which may disturb you.” *Qur'an 3:151* “We will cast t_____r into the hearts of those who deny the Truth" *Qur'an 8:13* “Whoever defies Allah and His Messenger, ˹know that˺ Allah is severe in punishment.” *Qur'an 5:33* “Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) and cause mischief is that they be k___ or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides”

[@maseehwardak6055]

Becuase most of us don't know what freedom is. The few that do have no power.

[@Sukunasenpai-p4n]

@@maseehwardak6055why you hate women

[@seanbrennan9188]

Maybe next time they're given the opportunity to fight for their freedom. They won't drop their weapons and run.

[@sergersgerhersh6594]

It's not the rest of the world's responsibility to save Afghanistan from its own fundamentalist views. They'll have to sort out their own problems for once. If Afghans didn't fight to protect their freedoms in 2022 from the Taliban, then why should we?

[@justinlucas]

Free Afghanistan 🇦🇫

[@sianais]

From who? Itself?

[@paperclipismybias]

@@sianais fr.... like people love it there ig..... nobody's protesting or saying anything .

[@sadeddinmus]

Islam az its finest.

[@jennifervan75]

Religion at it's finest

[@SusanaXpeace2u]

@@jennifervan75 don't be naive Jennifer. Islam is a political ideology.

[@redgoddess]

These women need to stand up. No one is coming to save them. They have to save themselves in any way they can.

[@ShifaYusufzai]

Why not applicable in Palestine and Lebanon?

[@mamabear-x7u]

​@@ShifaYusufzai because this post is about Afghan women . Lebanon or Palestine women or any other countries for that matter can do the same . If they choose to. Coz nobody is coming to save them.

[@maseehwardak6055]

Reality is limited to many afghans, they don't know what freedom is, how can they stand up for themselves. You need to put yourself in afghan woman's shoes to know this.

[@sidali2590]

If the women stand or speak out the evil Taliban will come after them

[@zdrekyria]

Its not as easy as it seems

[@johnmartin17t]

I wonder what will Queers for Palestine think about this?.

[@Mateomartinez-u1z]

true

[@ZaydAliKhan]

who are queers?

[@mikenogozones]

Their silence is deafening

[@jibril2950]

I'm gay,but I always laugh when I see those queers for Palestine😂😂😂,what could be going on in their minds?I wonder

[@neneklampir6664]

Or the ones who yell "Islamophobia"

[@sophiawilson8696]

Their men fail them!

[@Jennyxx-ie5jw]

We need Jesus Christ ☦ we're in spiritual warfare

[@spaceballs44]

Definitely!!!!

[@armlovesmetal1036]

Yeah right LOL. Religion ruins advancements for women. They need freedom, rights, critical thinking - NOT religion.

[@4lyfMotorhead]

To people saying it was not worth spending billions of dollars a year to make sure women do not live like slaves are giant pos. Funny how they are also the ones most religios while immediately having no issue puting a price on human life.

[@Tribuneoftheplebs]

Do you know how women got rights in the west? The economy booming leads to demand for more labour and womens rights. Stop sanctioning Afghanistan if you want women to have rights 🤔

[@oakridgemall-8jl2h9f]

Really . . . *Qur'an 4:59* “O believers! Obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority” *Qur'an 8:12* "I shall cast t____r into the hearts of disbelievers, so strike them upon the necks" *Qur'an 9:111* “Allah has indeed purchased from the believers their lives and wealth in exchange for Paradise. They fight in the cause of Allah and k__ or be k____.” *Qur'an 9:29* "Fight against those who do not believe in Allāh or in the Last Day." *Qur'an 2:216* "Fighting is obligatory for you ˹believers˺. Allah knows and you do not." *Qur'an 3:151* “We will cast t_____r into the hearts of those who have denied the Truth" *Qur'an 9:123* “Believers! Fight against the disbelievers who are near to you; and let them find harshness in you. Know that Allah is with the God-fearing. O ye who believe!” *Qur'an 47:4* “So when you meet those who disbelieve, strike their necks until, when you have inflicted slau _______ upon them, then secure their bonds, and either confer favor afterwards or ransom them until the war lays down its burdens. That is the command. And those who are k______ in the cause of Allah . . . never will He waste their deeds.”

[@mathking2890]

This is their religion. Don't impose your values on them

[@BluePlanet-m7h]

​@@mathking2890Just like Islam don't impose their Terrorism.....I mean "Values" on others Right ?

[@heathervandewalle8954]

It is always worth trying to help a country or an individual struggling. Because we can not be sure if the help will make the difference in their lives that saves them and they deserve that chance. But at some point, with that country or individual, in time it becomes their responsibility to further build on the help they received to improve their own lives. If you help a drug addict get clean, support them for a time, provide training and counseling you want things to be better for them. But if they return to bad ways, and even worse ways once you let go of their hand a little, that is on them. Look up the story "The Bridge" by Edwin Friedman. This powerful story holds true in global situations as well as individual ones.

[@paquitoignacio3449]

I feel sorry for the women in Afghanistan, the lose all their rights unbearable suffering for the rest of their life

[@spaceballs44]

These women in Afghanistan would be in a better situation in an American Prison.

[@aasiyapowell875]

She is fluent but she doesn't say anything specific nor new. She is not talking about the problem of orphans and widows, nor the problem of health problems due to early marriage or too many children. Nor the problem of said children roaming the streets unsupervised and vulnerable. When all Afghans resolve to solve these problems, the country's burdens will lift up.

[@scaderiascaderia7209]

All this questions are included in the topic they discuss. They just underlying

[@nenasiek]

The amount of trolls in the comments are sick, this is a real problem and ppl are suffering.

[@dotmarceo]

Do you want to rescue them with missiles? Hasn't that been tried already? Always seeking to control others from the outside with your morals.

[@ls-l1518]

Don't call people who disagree with you, trolls. You are gaslighting. You are the troll actually. No respect for others.

[@j.peaceo1031]

You cannot force a people to choose democracy. The Taliban retook power because the Afghan peopl writ large want this rule. As much as anyone would want to help these oppressed people, nobody can until the PEOPLE have had enough and rise up themselves.

[@ASmithee67]

I understand all the restrictions on women in Afghan society, and the lack of opportunities for all Afghans. BUT... the Afghan people welcomed the Taliban into the leadership of their country. The majority of Afghanis happily dropped all opposition and celebrated the Taliban back. Now they have to live with their decision.

[@ammiiskander7372]

that's because taliban provided justice and order and safety you do not understand what does it mean to live in a jungle and see people commiting murders and paying bribes and they get away easily

[@Wizreader2828]

Where is your evidence to say most Afghans welcomed the Taliban? Put the link in this chat.

[@shauncameron8390]

@@Wizreader2828 Most as in those who don't live in the capital.

[@marjetka01]

Watching this makes me sick.

[@irsinium]

They re fighting to implement this savagery in Europe too. What a dizgrace to see women arguing to wear these bags ...

[@joseprakashfrancis4114]

It is not just the Afganees , The majorty of them lives in the stone age. They want to bring the concept to liberal society.

[@silentblackhole]

After twenty years of trying to support a free and open Afghanistan, America had to leave. The withdrawal was a complete and utter disaster and a mess, but they Couldn't stay forever. The amount of money been poured into Afghanistan was incredible, and it was not been dare I say, appreciated or used effectively by the people of Afghanistan. Many countries tried to help build Afghanistan but let's focus just on The United States. The US roughly spent $2 billion dollars EVERY WEEK FOR 21 YEARS!!! That's insane. If Afghanistan couldn't work with that level of support then I don't know how they'll ever have a chance to work. Too many people in Afghanistan didn't want the free and open country the world was offering them. The majority of the army was an absolute joke. It was hard enough getting them to come on the days and times they were meant to be there, let alone do anything effective. That would be constantly be high on opium. The military of Afghanistan is the reason why it collapsed instantly. I feel very sorry for the people who did care about the country that put in the effort that tried to build something, but the majority of the people did not buy into this dream and therefore the country has defaulted back to this barbaric way of running a country. Overall, the majority of the men of Afghanistan have let down not only their country themselves, but their women. How can people go from treating women with respect to not ingest the case of a year or two? People don't change that. quickly like that It seems that the respect wasn't always there. Then in the first place, and it was only been supported by force of the International Coalition at the end of a gun saying that women had these rights and everyone. supported it then, but without Authorities with morals.

[@splinterbyrd]

I suspect Afghan women would be - at least to an extent - better off than they are now if America had never got involved in the first place.

[@zambisabianus8245]

This is what islam teaches,, Afghanistan is the only country that has implemented it successfully... that's islam, it's not about Afghanistan as country

[@tvismyonlyfriend]

Encouragement is what these women need not modesty

[@spaceballs44]

Access to firearms and weapons.

[@kirav2536]

When I was in Sankt-Petersburg in late eighties we had a lot of students from Afghanistan. among them many women. They were smart, vibrant, happy, independent people. I am always wondering what happened to those women. They are in their 50th now.

[@Teresa-ui2cn]

If the men are jobless then why aren't they defending their families and fighting against the Taliban? Didn't the United States stay over there for years to teach the men how to fight the Taliban?

[@lukelucy1980]

I appreciate this Excellent Conversation.

[@Thisscandinavian]

the taliban promised peace, women's rights,food and end to poverty honestly none of these happened but they took women's rights and threw em in the trash pretty badly more so than the others

[@diazvirdani1059]

*Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Yemen, Libya, South Sudan, Haiti. under interim government.* fast election new government.

[@dianalee-me7gl]

"The world has abandoned them" ... This is not the right statement.. US tried to help for over 20 years but if the mindset doesn't change at the grassroot level, the world can't help them

[@EyeofSekhmet]

Coming to a western country near you, or your's.

[@lorylovechan8362]

Im Luck Born in Philippines 🇵🇭 A Free Country

[@losenikromah7802]

We can't want better for them than they want for themselves.

[@Ben-Israelreports]

Good point!

[@misfitm1457]

Well we already know most want to live normally

[@SusanaXpeace2u]

They must be SO depressed, and betrayed.

[@brendatroy2843]

ALL WOMEN, YOUNG AND OLD ALL SHOULD BE EVACUATED TO SOMEWHERE SAFE AWAY FROM POLITICAL AND RELIGIOUS PROSECUTION

[@Darkurge666]

Don't care. They didn't fight for their freedom. They wanted taliban. Their land their problem.

[@anty_07]

Exactly

[@Vineeth..v]

Exactly, see gazan suffer bc of haaamas, they let H rule them.

[@AbdulHannan-or8ql]

Why not applicable in Palestine?

[@planesandbikes7353]

The Afghans did not 'want Taliban.' They just did not seem to have the want of freedom enough to fight for it. The Taliban wanted power more enthusiastically than the population wanted a liberal democracy.

[@charles___]

@@planesandbikes7353 In other words they're weak and a portion of their population supports taliban more than democracy

[@ArjunSehgalDigital]

3 years ago US fled Afghanistan. Since then the situation has become grave and Afghanistan has gone back decades.

[@Catnyp2828]

Fled??We were there for 20 yrs!! Give us a FN break!

[@ArjunSehgalDigital]

@@Catnyp2828 you did not need to be there, you did not need to create taliban, you were there for 20 years to fund your arms and ammunition businesses not for any humanitarian needs.

[@loriar1027]

@@ArjunSehgalDigital Initially we were there bc of Osama Bin Laden.

[@ArjunSehgalDigital]

@@loriar1027 And who created them?

[@ArjunSehgalDigital]

​@@Catnyp2828 And who created them?

[@scottthorson11]

Aaah... the Garden of allah...

[@sayedsadnamsakey9140]

also u r welcome American style of alphabet world. both are extreme in opposite direction . that is why u need balance

[@brianchu3317]

I’m not surprised that women’s rights have totally regressed back to the dark ages. But changes must be done within. The US experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan have taught us that we in the west cannot build democracies from the outside. The people got to want it really bad and be willing to sacrifice whatever to achieve their goals.

[@sianais]

They were doing better in the dark ages. The scary part about all this is that it's recent. It's devolution.

[@talking2388]

Islam is peace? Right ?

[@Ie4s]

Islam is Taliban? Wow

[@aasiyapowell875]

Islam means acquiescence to the will of God. Therin is peace if one is not being oppressed by an outside source.

[@talking2388]

@@aasiyapowell875 Wonder what WOMEN think about his that lives in Islam countries?

[@TandMroaming]

Such a waste of intelligent women in a place that needs some intelligent policy to rebuild their country. What a horrible place it must be.

[@zdrekyria]

Its sad to know their in this position. Talibans need to resign, illiterate Afghans need to be educated properly on the consequences of their actions each time they choose to control their nation by imprisoning the opposite sex. This is completely heartbreaking

[@esthermarcen7587]

Not only we forgot, we have now youtubers and pseudo jounalist traveling to afganistsng and saying how wonderful all is there, of course are all men from countrues as Finland, Ireland that have no interest in helping, so low and sad

[@cantbesure0714]

I've watched these youtubers, they need to stop putting money in the hands of the Taliban. It's very sad, as many of the people there seem wonderful, they have heart. However tourism like this needs to stop because like the ones going to North Korea, they can't possibly show the actuality of what is happening there.

[@themessenger6560]

America trained their military for 20 yrs and they did not fight the Taliban at U.S departure. If the people will come together in Afghanistan as one people the Taliban will listen or be force out by the people.

[@carlosvillegas6113]

A de ser deprimente vivir en un país como este

[@kamrunnissathambi9416]

Ladies you should fight this dreaded taliban

[@Logic_55]

Because women are stunning and brave, right?

[@misfitm1457]

@@Logic_55 that's trans, not women

[@LeslieLaverdiere-ph5ok]

So incredibly sad 😥

[@Suz3439]

And statistically, it's the Afghan men fleeing their country leaving these poor women to their fate 😢

[@lindsaymcpherson4744]

It isn't the world that abandoned them this is the true teachings of Islam being enforced ,read how the kayran describes women

[@jijok1382]

Islam means equality and peace like Pakistan iran afganistan Nigeria somaliya Sudan libiya Yemen Iraq labanon Bangladesh etc 🎉🎉😂😂😂😂

[@qazifabiahoq2053]

Lebanon is better off , research about them! They don’t strictly follow that

[@MarciaMatthews]

Thank you, Marie, great interview with Nargis Nehan.

[@Whet-wb9jt]

They're literally hostage!!!!!

[@cageybee7221]

this will be israel if the keyboard warriors online get their way.

[@Catnyp2828]

The Afghan women only wished they had it that good! Women are respected in Israel! They can worship , Drive cars, go to school, vote, sing and serve in the military and don't get covered from head to toe! It's called a democratic state and it's the only one in the region. I can see why Islam hates it so much 😂

[@milanjgmilanjg]

it is strange!!! people who escaped from afghanistan wants sharia law in the countries in which they went into.

[@Mooon123-b9o]

No human basic rights for us 💔

[@Sukunasenpai-p4n]

Who took them

[@loriar1027]

@@Sukunasenpai-p4n Taliban men

[@Sukunasenpai-p4n]

@@loriar1027 men yes

[@JulieAnneJones-i1v]

Neanderthal men, in a biblical country. The land time forgot.

[@louisefrezell]

The Taliban has done this to this poor country! Terrorist Islam has done this to these oppressed people! God have mercy on them! And rid them of Evil.

[@gibbongood3281]

"Anymore" she says, even though it's been this way for centuries if not thousands of years

[@jeanettediss6640]

They are being treated as modern day slaves. Its time the world took note.😢😢

[@ls-l1518]

The Afghans themselves must revolt. The young men must save their country, in stead of fleeing here, creating havoc. The world has forgotten us. Sorry, we have our own countries to take care of. We are very tired of yours.

[@rabiazeb9051]

I dont understand one thing, US attack on Afghanistan in 2001 and been there for 20 years, and i didnt find anything they changed in the 20 years and the most funny thing was their over night withdraw, i dont understand what they did in these 20 years? they went there to destroy alqaida but what? the situation for normal people was worse then and now even more, only common people suffer, common people died on the name of terrorist, common people suffered from both side whether its taliban or US

[@qazifabiahoq2053]

Exactly !!!!

[@karz12]

The situation in Iran is even worse.

[@20SG20]

What is happening?

[@razmohammad423]

Ghaza also there no school Left 😢

[@sandybeach3576]

That's what Europe is in for 😅

[@Mateomartinez-u1z]

😢

[@prometheusr]

No.

[@theotherohlourdespadua1131]

As if Europe wasn't the lead exporter of that during the days of empire. The society in my country is freer compared to the society these Europeans introduced to us as "superior"...

[@pixie_sparkle74]

Not going to happen.

[@NikhatKing]

Oh, 😂yes what afghan women said of Ghaza there is no school left for studying, and about 16000 children died of bombardment. This is human behaviour. Dual face of West came here.

[@Catnyp2828]

If Hamas wouldn't selfishly store their weapons in schools and mosques! Gaza was handed over to Hamas by the palestinians and still supports them. GTH.

[@Thunderbolt_5]

Free Afghan women

[@BluePlanet-m7h]

Didn't Majority of those Afghani women themselves said that they want Sharia Law in their country ? 😅

[@Rubybutterfly666-k6g]

These women gave up on themselves wheres their fire to live and breath free it seems your only right is to go to jail. I will leave you with a quote from Patrick Henry GIVE ME LIBERTY OR DEATH

[@sarasata]

We shouldn't force our ways on other cultures/peoples. Let them be.

[@i77777]

Then Talibans should not use the US military vehicles and weapons as well. That’s not their culture, right?

[@oneconcept7032]

@@i77777 Why did they invade their country in the first place using a false claim? Trash

[@itsme-sq5rd]

​@@i77777technology is not culture.

[@feefee2]

I agree. But in this vid it seems like the women have a culture they don't want being forced on them

[@itsme-sq5rd]

@@feefee2 they don't have.

[@2935441]

Too bad, when they had a chance to stand up and be counted, they continued the same old ways. Notice that Ms Nehan still covers her head. When you are liberated, you throw off your shackles. Before the war in Afghanistan, I had many women friends who would cry in their beer for the women in Afghanistan, the minute we went into Afghanistan they were suddenly quiet. Don't make that mistake. Don't commit someone else's child to a military confrontation unless you are willing to commit your own. No luxury beliefs please.

[@misfitm1457]

There is no draft in America

[@captainnemo8072]

I hope the women have a social life among themselves.

[@spaceballs44]

I’m sure not.

[@Suz3439]

They aren't even allowed to sing, so what do you think?

[@KingTaupCreatives]

Hypocrisy of Westrn Media strikes again😅

[@zdrekyria]

Afghan Women hold on, Hope & Help is closer than you think ❤

[@Mzenith]

Quran outcomes

[@enockjanna916]

Its there culture and it doesn't mean that's new from western they born with it so don't change them to became western and Europe they're even not Africans

[@vanessaabbas2309]

It's wild to think that your fate is determined by your geological place of birth. These poor women. I wish they knew how strong they are. Those men have to eat and sleep at some point... you know where the knives and toxic ingredients are. May you all know just how powerful you are.

[@misfitm1457]

The thing is, it's not their Husbands etc it's the Taliban, who always have patrols and don't sleep anywhere a random person could get to them

[@angelarutherford1840]

Support 💜

[@debrakelly4505]

So sad- what a way to live! I cannot imagine being cloaked “head to toe” in oppressive heat! Thanks, Joe!

[@starlarose2216]

Thank the founding fathers who fought and died for the idea of all men being created equal in the image of God and free to live his ways (aka ten commandments)

[@NikhatKing]

Shame on you said you are advanced society. There were lakh people died in Bengal femine and winston Churchill said is Gandhi died and lakh people killed because he

[@loriar1027]

President Biden is not to blame for the backwards ideology of the Taliban. 🙄 Get a grip.

[@maurien655]

They are the mothers, I wonder why they can't raise them to be different

[@jennifervan75]

Because they get influenced by the violent men around them

[@JuliaBarna]

Yet Europe is right behind them.

[@Margot-t8s]

A very, very long time ago, in Greece, already a civil place, a woman called Lisistrata, unsatisfied because of men's behaviour, suggested that women should begin a strike. This strike took place in bedrooms. In the end, women were listened to. Come on, Afgani sisters !

[@dominicdmello7531]

An army and police who were trained and equipped for 10 years.

[@BernardGosselin-y8q]

Somethings wrong with the way you educate yourself on the situation of the woman from the start . Husband and son don’t respect or love their society… no future for that society !

[@OnlineMD]

The first 12 minutes is just endless repetition of the same message. Sorry but I had to say it. Anyhow, the people of Afghanistan knew all about the Taliban from previous exposure. And yet, the government was so horribly corrupt eating up American money so the Afghan armed forces, poorly paid or often unpaid, gave up and abandoned the armed forces in droves. They must have thought that the Taliban would take better care of them. Also, the people distrusted the Americans. Perhaps they thought that the Taliban would bring in Islam in its pure form. Well, this is what it turned out to be.

[@vsharan2k]

the point is who are really to answer for their status, who ran away after sowing instability from Pakistan, who transformed that otherwise progressive society, into a fundamental-islam mine field for their communities...the same remorseless social-engagements were executed a while earlier in Bangladesh...unfeeling and manipulative acts!

[@qazifabiahoq2053]

No I don’t want this for my country back home 😢 don’t want Bangladesh to turn like Afghanistan

[@That_kind_of_orc]

Seems like women are enjoying islam :-)

[@maseehwardak6055]

They don't even know what it is. 70% of afghans don't even know what it is.

[@spaceballs44]

Are they outside celebrating and talking to people? Not listening to the new law where they can’t talk to people.