Another amazing episode? "Andor" Episode 9 (Spoiler Review-cap)

[@ARBLACKx]

Imagine if Obi-Wan had Andor's writers and episode count

[@chasehedges6775]

It would be soooo good.

[@chasehedges6775]

Same with Book Of Boba Fett

[@donkeysaurusrex7881]

And a story that wasn’t built to break canon and characters whose story allowed for new events to be inserted. This is why a story about a character makes a lot more sense than one about a character like Obi Wan with a well fleshed out backstory.

[@VonJay]

Girlroy wouldn't touch characters he had no part in creating. that and he doesn't like using force users. He didn't even like Star Wars when he took the Rogue One job. I think that Disney needs to just hire grounded writers. People who don't like Sci Fi all that much and are just good about making realistic relationships and desires. Then the sci fi would be like icing on the cake. But yeah I agree with Gilroy in that there's this cognitive dissonance involved whenever one writer takes over for characters they didn't create. I think Disney should just make that a rule. Hire grounded writers, let them create their own characters and striking character driven views, give them several projects for those characters, and possibly if its outside of the Empire era, let them make striking culturally driven views on architecture, vehicle design, weaponry, etc.

[@jayhernandez5508]

@@VonJay Hmm 🤔, maybe.. I argue that the problem with BoBF, Kenobi, even the sequels is that they're hiring writers and show runners that don't live and breathe SW. People that know the story in and out, instead hiring who's hot and trendy at the moment

[@azure4527]

"Never more than 12" might as well have been Han Solo swooping in to save Luke from Vader. It was such a punch the air moment.

[@Matt-bg5wg]

100% agree. Such a great moment to end the episode on

[@jamesmurray8572]

yuuup

[@Dan-Payne]

Two full episodes of total bleak helplessness for one line that gives us hope. It’s Star Wars at its core.

[@leafgreensniper13]

I gave an audible chuckle when he said that. The character finally had enough motivation to change, great writing.

[@ellicel]

Andy Serkis was absolutely brilliant! Throughout the episode you see layers of his character: how he cares for the older guy, his desperate need to hold on to the idea that if he just plays along he’ll eventually get to go home, his self-doubt when he begins to suspect he’s been wrong, and finally his acceptance and resolve when he sees that there’s no way out unless they can fight their way out. Serkis was able to convey so much in such few moments. Casting decisions in this show have been stellar, selecting amazing talent to portray lynchpin characters.

[@IanM92]

@The Rotten💯 He’s not above them in any way and is just as expendable as the rest of them.

[@tech-no-logictech9743]

Agree regarding the casting...except Vel.🙈

[@quanganhvu6791]

​@The Rotten💯 like Andor said: they don't need to care

[@quanganhvu6791]

@The Rotten💯 nah if you watched the episode, Andor was trying to get info from Serkis' character saying those in charge really don't care what they do or say since they can just zap the floor twice a day. Both the episode's name "Nobody's listening" well as overarching philosophy of Andor is that the Empire is so full of itself and considers everyone else beneath them that it really doesn't pay attention as the rebellion is slowly infiltrating their ranks and getting stronger. Back to your point about isolating Serkis' character, while in real life it would be the case, in the context of the show it makes sense

[@peddlerofbombast6982]

Galen Erso designed the Narkina 5 Imperial Factory Facility, with the help of Director Krennic.

[@johnosullivan1480]

Dr. Gorst has a casual joyful almost childlike enthusiasm when talking about the torture device...it is absolutely chilling ...and brilliantly acted!

[@VonJay]

Space Kevorkian. He had me at "hello" btw.

[@GSFBlade]

loved his little wave.

[@scooble]

Everything about the Empire has such a strong and consistent Nazi vibe about it, from their entitled arrogance, fetishization with order and inhumane experimentation. All clear examples of evil without the need for evil space magic.

[@godking]

Good news everybody !!

[@javiervidal366]

@@godking awesome reference!

[@natedgreat1298]

This is the bleakest star wars I've seen on-screen and I'm here for it. Everything, in the prison and out, felt dark and foreboding. Andy Serkis was AMAZING this episode, loved to see his transition as well. Can't wait for next week!

[@VonJay]

I think they do a great balance. Its bleak but not the bleakest thing I've seen, but yes the bleakest in Star Wars though it doesn't really feel like it if it makes sense. I feel like they mastered the tone, made it as smooth as they can given the obstacles the empire puts well meaning people into.

[@natedgreat1298]

@@VonJay Agreed.

[@Wackaz]

I'm so thankful there are fans giving this fantastic show love. This is truly brilliant television, methodical and patient, respecting the maturity and intelligence of the viewer in a Gilligan fashion - quite easily the best and most exciting Star Wars project we've had since the 2015 - 2017 Star Wars period.

[@retsz]

This show has done something i thought was impossible: it made me care about Cassian Andor. My expectations for this series going in were pretty low but I've been pleasantly surprised at how good it is. The empire is actually menacing and kinda scary now. You did good with this one, Disney.

[@chasehedges6775]

They really have done a wonderful job with this character and his story before Rogue One.

[@ellicel]

I think even though this contains Andor’s story, I see it more as an ensemble show. It’s been wonderful to see how even minor characters have great story arcs or have a huge impact in the context of the fledgling rebellion. I was not expecting that at all.

[@VonJay]

Did you not like Rogue One? When I heard Gilroy would return with this I was all in. When it comes to Star Wars or any other material out there, I pay attention to the writer and sometimes director. Better way to manage expectations in my opinion.

[@VonJay]

@@ellicel I don't get why Disney likes naming shows after characters. I think it's part of their research group's found request from fan posts, in that "this move has great characters.'' And they're just humoring fans with the titles. I find it really annoying personally.

[@retsz]

@@VonJay i thought rogue one was great. I still think it's the best movie Disney star wars has made. I just didn't really care about andor. I just assumed this show would be a lazy cash grab to bring in more Disney+ subs. I'm happy to say i was wrong. I genuinely appreciate the different take on the franchise, and a new addition to the star wars roster that i actually like that wasn't mando.

[@hardcase-69]

A show with very little action, yet still has you on the edge of your seat, leaving you wanting more. It's so engaging.

[@RuggerDez]

Suspense. It’s not action. But just as entertaining if not more.

[@danielvanveen2960]

If you have a (gun)fight in star wars, do you actually worry something could go wrong? I hardly do. This show keeps you on your toes. Much more engaging imo.

[@subsume7904]

@@RuggerDez yeah that fight scene on Ferrix, the one where they shot at each other with blasters and people died, yeah that wasn't action at alllll right?

[@wannabemexican]

"Never more than twelve" is likely one of the best final lines in a TV episode that I have ever seen. It is such a pay off. The entire episode has been building towards this moment. This show is the first in a long time that make me so nervous watching it that I don't look at my phone. It is absolutely enthrawling and I agree that it is some of the best television ever made.

[@javiervidal366]

It was a perfect line! Such great writing, directing, and characters.

[@mydreaminorbit9297]

"Never more than 12" that line was so well earned it gave me chills. Throughout the episode we see Kino go from company man to I'm going to burn this place down. Superb performance by Andy Serkis.

[@bowenhorne0616]

I love how this episode took Kino from being so obsessively fixated on maintaining order and not jeopardizing his sentence to being fully on board with the escape plan. And at no point did it feel rushed, it was completely natural and just felt right. And Andy Serkis unsurprisingly plays it perfectly. Also the most terrifying thing about the doctor telling Bix about the torture is just how casual he was, like it’s just another day in the office for him. Everything in this show is just brilliant.

[@MustafaAlmosawi]

Shades of Zuckerberg showing off Meta 😂

[@PrincessFionaYT]

It definitely didn’t feel rushed. Nothing in this show feels rushed. That’s the problem. This show has a very niche appeal. It only appeals to the most diehard Star Wars fans that are still left that are willing to linger excessively on the smallest of details. This is not gonna capture you a large audience.

[@bowenhorne0616]

@@PrincessFionaYT I think you’re mistaking rushing with brisk pacing. Rushing is a development issue, pacing isn’t. Even putting that aside this episode is hardly what I’d call slow. And great, it should appeal to the fans first, worry about drawing in the larger audience second. That’s been the one of the major issues with Disney Star Wars from the start.

[@PrincessFionaYT]

@Bowen I agree but this show is not appealing to the fans. That’s the problem. Is it is it is appealing to a very small subset of really die hard core fans. The word is been out for nine weeks and it still hasn’t been able to gain an audience even amongst the fan base, much less normal people. It’s already seen a 68% drop in it’s initial audience which was already the lowest for any Star Wars show in history. That’s why the show has already been canceled and season two will be a cut down and delayed season. They’ve already announced that it’s the final season and it’s now been pushed back to 2024. There will be no season three. And they’re going to take away the wrong lessons from this. And we’re never going to get a show like this again with thoughtful writing and real dialogue. Because they were going to blame the failure of the show on the things that everybody likes about it.

[@SultanOfAwesomeness]

Easily the most tense and distressing episode in the series so far. A little detail that I really loved was how Bix’s screaming actually transitions very well into the high pitched whining and whirring of machinery as we’re shifted back to Andor in prison. The scenes with Cirril’s mother are absolutely brilliant as well; it’s a really nice portrayal of how parental manipulation unfortunately works. The way she switches between chastising and belittling him; insinuating that he’s a failure who doesn’t care, to praising Cirril for his ‘promotion’ is absolutely something that happens irl. I feel pretty sorry for the person who’s personal experience they’re probably drawing on in order to make it so convincing.

[@josecardenas2902]

Also loved the nod to A New Hope. When the torture room door closes, the camera pans down and to the left to the walk of the imperial guy just as when Vader shows the torture droid to Leia.

[@Oldstalk]

Thank you Tony Gilroy. Thank you everyone involved in this project, actors, technicians, musicians, everyone !! Everything in this show is damn phenomenal. There is so much love and care put into this project. It reminds me of series such as Better call saul. The people behind it actually care.

[@ellicel]

I’ve also compared it to BCS in describing it to others! It’s one of those rare prequels that actually makes you appreciate the original story more and doesn’t retcon things just because the writers don’t know how to add to the existing world or story. I’m loving it!

[@lukedevlin5948]

It’s so nice to have good dialogue in a Star Wars show, I thought we were doomed to cringe but this show makes you enjoy just watching conversations

[@VonJay]

I've been saying it for so long, this is the closest thing to Better Call Saul. If only Kennedy would hire the BCS and Breaking Bad duo (one of them used to work on the x-files). I would love to see what they come up with.

[@MaxRamos8]

There's a scene in the prison where they use a high pitch sound to freeze the people, it hurt me too and I had to lower the volume!!! Cool and not cool at the same time

[@ellicel]

We need webisodes, “Meals with Syril and His Mother.” I could watch a million of those! 😂 Also, dying to know: What’s in his private box? His sketches of Dedra? Pieces for his Tie Fighter Lego set? His daily affirmations journal? WHAT’S IN THE BOOOOX?!

[@eyeheartsushi2212]

😂😂😂😂

[@MustafaAlmosawi]

It’s private, he has ways of knowing. That simple throw away line said so much about how twisted and horrible the relationship is.

[@Michael20]

The syril and mom scenes are so funny and relatable

[@thatoneradicalizedprussian225]

Definitely his sketches of Dedra

[@sonofjack6286]

Sketches of Dedra, he seems a little bit attracted to her. I just hope he gets a job at ISB under her command, he'd probably be a lot happier.

[@YegRon]

Really hoping Tony Gilroy is given more opportunities to make Star Wars. The acting, dialogue and cinematography are all on point, and everything is so incredibly tense, despite the lack of action. Agreed, this is the best show on television.

[@VonJay]

I personally believe he should be in charge of hiring other grounded writers who aren't into sci fi that much, and be given the chance to construct the look and feel of a different era

[@shugaroony]

He doesn't want to do that, so don't think thats whats going to happen.

[@YegRon]

@@shugaroony he was talking about a third season of Andor when only two seasons were approved, I’m not so sure we should assume we know what he wants.

[@bitchoflivingblah]

I just rewatch Rogue One when I have a Star Wars itch - Gareth Edwards and Tony Gilroy's masterpiece. Unfortunately we're going to have to get through a Taika Wahtiti episode and perhaps some more Rian Johnson efforts before any chance of seeing another director.

[@VonJay]

@@bitchoflivingblah i really don’t get Taika’s appeal. Can’t believe he’s getting a Star Wars film before Chris Nolan

[@Felix-sb5wp]

I planned on making a bowl of ice cream for myself halfway through the episode, but before I remembered the episode was over lol. They keep getting better, the revelation at the end was amazing.

[@andyb1653]

That ending gave me chills.

[@chasehedges6775]

@@andyb1653 Same.

[@atomicboxstudios]

Honestly, this series should be used as a benchmark for other future Star Wars stories. The world building, character development, subtle nuances that all tie together to build arc's in the story until they reach their explosive climax, is what keeps me anticipating each new episode. My only regret will be having to wait well over a year till the next installment of episodes that eventually lead to the doorstep of Rogue One. However, it will be worth it.

[@MCsCreations]

The feeling from this episode is... Eternal claustrophobia. It's amazing how well they're showing the worst part of the Empire... Which is something without a good side. That tells you something!

[@BlackhaloZ]

"claustrophobia" Exactly my take-away. From the torture, to Syril eating breakfast, to him accosting Deadra to the entire prison, just overpowering, but so damn good.

[@MCsCreations]

@@BlackhaloZ Exactly!

[@CaptainLore]

I wish every writer who worked on Star Wars had the same level of care and dedication the writers, directors, and actors have in this show. Everything is good. Every character feels real. The story is building so well. It is just phenomenal.

[@JoRoq1]

Andor was not written to fulfill a personal agenda. It was written to be a good story with good characters. That is the true difference.

[@BlackhaloZ]

In all the interviews with the other show-runners, they seem to treat it like a joke. Like, "this isn't a real show, it's just Star Wars." The same vibe I get from Rings of Power. In contrast, Andor clearly takes it seriously. One would hope, that with a billion dollar property, the owners would expect the same level of care from all.

[@jamiemunn9200]

Actually, Tony is not really a fan of Star Wars. He is a very competent producer, and unlike a lot of writers nowadays. Respects the lore.

[@Hanakin-Sidewalker]

Andy Serkis brings so much to the table. The scene where he was quelling the rumors about Level 2 in the bridge was so brilliantly acted. The casting and dialogue has been phenomenal thus far!

[@ellicel]

OMG, yes! I know everyone is reacting to the last line of the episode, but the scene you referenced was so good it gave me chills. He starts out shouting to the others but by the end his voice lowers gradually and he’s speaking to himself, trying to keep himself from panic, trying to comfort himself. Wow. So well done.

[@MonstersNotUnderTheBed]

As he yelled out directions, he was trying to convince himself even as terror overtook his face.

[@danielvanveen2960]

Let’s hope his character survives some more episodes.

[@RasKetchum]

I have to comment on the fact that the opening music gets more epic each week. I was really pumped when this week's episode was starting!

[@simonyesh]

This episode was fantastic. The Empire was portrayed in such a sinister way. I actually felt dread when Bix was being tortured.

[@leefchapman]

I'd pick the tense slow burn of Andor blowing my mind at face value than an episode of Frog Lady taking a bath whilst we're wondering who and what Grogu is and it never paying off.

[@twit7380]

This had been said before by multiple people but it’s worth saying it again. Andor is finally giving us an Empire worthy of fear and respect. No longer are storm troopers blind buffoons. I also “like” that the torture sequences are not simply beatings. The Sith and by extension Palpatine’s Empire, is so scary because they mess with the mind and spirit as much or even more than the body

[@Wackaz]

I'm so thankful there are fans giving this fantastic show love. This is truly brilliant television, methodical and patient, respecting the maturity and intelligence of the viewer in a Gilligan fashion - quite easily the best and most exciting Star Wars project we've had since the 2015 - 2017 Star Wars period.

[@PrincessFionaYT]

That’s the problem. All of the fans giving that show love are pretty much here on this channel. This show has failed to garner any kind of an audience whatsoever and it’s likely, not through its own fault necessarily, going to be responsible that you’re never going to see content like this again. Had this show come on the heels of stunning successes, things would’ve been very different. But this show was too little too late and I believe the executives are going to take away the very wrong impressions from the show’s abysmal performance.

[@brianomdahl8377]

…wait, Disney MISUNDERSTANDING the audience and fan base?? NO WAY!

[@SirDenzington89]

I also really like this show. It might be the best thing Disney Star Wars has created even though I love the Mandalorian. One thing that is one of the stand out feature of the show is that the Empire is scary and competent again. Thats something I’ve been waiting for

[@ellicel]

For me (as relatively new to SW), the difference has been that my love The Mandalorian didn’t lead to a deeper love for this universe. Watching Andor has me watching a variety of YT commentary channels, wanting to learn so much more about the books and the animated series. Because the show does such a great job with the world building and writing, I can’t wait to learn more about it. Before I was content not having watched the prequels since I knew the basic plot and didn’t feel I needed to have a deeper understanding in order to get the gist of the current content. With Andor, you don’t NEED to have a deep knowledge, but I can see how much more rewarding it would be. Plus, it just got me excited to WANT more!

[@darthtroller]

@@ellicel I agree, Mando doesn't go as deep as it should have, such a shame cuz Mandalorians have a LOT of lore and history

[@Сайтамен]

@@darthtroller And it's generally not well written.

[@BlackhaloZ]

Not just scary, but makes the case that the Empire is deserving of destruction.

[@dimebag505]

This show just keeps getting better and better, you can see Andy Serkis character actually cares about the other inmates and when the older inmate died you could see how it impacted him, was such a brilliant scene

[@jetblast190]

Andy Serkis shines in this episode. The writing and directing allows him to peel back the layers of the onion and explore Kino’s character. Supervisor Dedra Meero also steals the screen during her scenes. She’s gone from an ISB agent unsure of herself who I was rooting to a full-on intimidating ISB agent with a clear plan for achieving her goals. Gaining the support of Major Partagaz was all she needed. I literally felt Bix’s terror during her “interview.” The darkness explored in this episode ranks up there with Anakin/Vader’s youngling scene in ROTS…except that Andor affords more time for the audience to experience and imagine what that torture must be like…it sat with me.

[@ellicel]

The interrogation scene reminded me of the beginning of Inglorious Bastards, where the villain is so casual but the stakes and the threat are so high. Slowly the tension of the scene builds and builds until you just can’t stand it. Of course even though people complain about the show being slow, I don’t think this would land as hard as it does if we hadn’t gotten to know Bix in the previous episodes.

[@jetblast190]

@@ellicel Good analogy, and it definitely wouldn’t have worked without the time spent to develop Bix, particularly in those first 3 episodes. But I feel that way about all the characters…Andor simply wouldn’t work if the writers hadn’t taken the time needed to create layered and nuanced characters.

[@rostyslavukrwin]

Compare Dedra script and acting with Third Sister from Obi One. Dedra is clever and scary. She is to be feared... And the Third Sister? She's like a parody of a villain...

[@jetblast190]

@@rostyslavukrwin Night and day difference.

[@Scratchmane]

This series is absolutely thrilling. I'm not even close to missing The Force, it's users or large scale action. The characthers the suspense is grabbing me like nobody's business. It's AWESOME 🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@LumVaughan]

It was interesting to see how Cassian is slowly becoming the 'alpha male' of his group of prisoners and beginning to take charge. The prisoners are starting to come together and even Kino Loy is beginning to look at Andor as the leader. It was good to see the prisoners plotting and preparing for an escape and that dynamic conflicting with their hope to be released after a specific number of shifts. Ulaf's failing health and the other prisoners' concern for him was touching, especially coming from Cassian who has been rather cold-hearted in much of the series. Syril somehow reminds me of Norman Bates; he is a man on the edge, I fully expect him to murder his mother and stalk Dedra (whom he clearly has developed some strange reverence for) until ISB guards kill him. You can sense his sanity wavering in and out and a dormant rage waiting to come out.

[@Arezoo298195]

Yeah Syril is headed for some giant breakdown. During that scene with Dedra I half expected him to kneel and beg to worship!😂

[@LumVaughan]

@@Arezoo298195 He could be the wildcard in the whole thing -- Dedra figures out everything with the rebels, is about to expose them and out of no where (after a few more episodes of shown interactions between them) Syril appears and kills her with a blaster for rejecting him. It would be something you didn't see coming and really bring out the human and psychological aspect of living in that universe. Syril cracks and Dedra was so focused on proving herself that she didn't see she was in danger.

[@Arezoo298195]

@@LumVaughan Sounds dramatic!

[@javiervidal366]

@@LumVaughan or Syril and Dedra have a psycho kid; the one that later helps builds that abysmal laser planet.

[@LumVaughan]

@@javiervidal366 You know, you could almost see that -- General Hux has that same pale, pasty look that Dedra has!

[@decay79]

Serkis is incredible, you can see every emotion on his face in these scenes, from doubt, hatred, sadness and all the way to the realization, the hopelessness of it all.. Such a brillian actor.

[@multipass113]

I have an inkling (from the tone of this show) that Dedra might be eventually thwarted by her own assistant Heert(?) whose laser focus and efficiency has been shown gradually through each episode.

[@CantankerousDave]

He did seem to want to get noticed by the boss in that meeting.

[@darthtroller]

That would be a good reveal, the seeds are there but are hidden well enough

[@JoRoq1]

I had that thought, too. And if we get there the wonderful twist should be that he is great at procedure and recalling pertinent information, but has no instincts like Dedra to actually put random pieces together. He needs someone else to give his focus and efficiency a direction. In taking Dedra down, he unwittingly opens the cracks that allow the Rebel Alliance to be forged when Dedra was on the cusp of uncovering the key players.

[@westwardstar1686]

​@@JoRoq1I really like that idea. If he were to step in it would have to be at Dedras lowest point. Which appears to be the Ferrix Riots. Could very well happen.

[@sirrickardjameses]

My favorite episode so far. I've been a prisoner and there's nothing more terrifying than the idea of never getting out or not knowing when

[@54tisfaction]

Let's not forget Christopher Fairbank who plays Ulaf in a way that was totally convincing. His health deteriorated from a cramping hand, to being confused and irritable, to clearly having some sort of physical episode and finally collapsing. I was wondering weather this was a planned ruse to create an opportunity for escape, or if this was going to put a wrench in what was planned. Damned right that this is a show that would be a stellar show regardless of it taking place in the Star Wars universe or the real world. It is all anyone could have hoped for.

[@enriquesalvador9904]

We barely knew Ulaf but the sadness I felt during his death scene hurt more than any thing I've seen in Star Wars lately.

[@damianrahmann4453]

Every episode brings something different. Right down to the opening score amping up. Dedra is the villain we can love to hate - so good in her role!!

[@rostyslavukrwin]

Compare with Third Sister from Obi One......

[@ProdCritic]

Some people say Andor doesnt "feel" like SW. They're right. Andor is not only expanding what SW can be, it is *ELEVATING* it. IMO Andor is one of the best prestige TV Dramas of the past few years. This matters because for better or worse, SW has always been consistent but so long as it exists in a box it will always be limited in quality & scope. To clarify, not everything should be this. But Andor expands the traditional audience of SW, and it will attract better talent to help make better SW content as a whole.

[@darthtroller]

For me it does feel like Star Wars, the type we've seen in Rogue One and ROTS and some parts of TCW and it's diving deep into that aspect

[@istari0]

Another awesome episode! It just goes to show what good actors can do when they have good writing to work with. Andy Serkis was phenomenal as we watched him start listening to Cassian and have his doubts about getting out of the prison grow to the point where he has signed on to the prison break plan. Dedra continues to shine as am increasingly scary antagonist. That early line about them excited about this new technique the doctor had come up with for interrogating (i.e., torturing) prisoners was chilling. Anyone else notice that when the Mothma's are gathered around the dinner table, Mon sits at the head of the table while her husband and daughter sit across from one another down at the other end?

[@lanaz375]

Hope they keep the creative team for Andor together. They really are doing great stuff.

[@eltorpedelocho2984]

“A long time ago…” an empire slowly took over the galaxy and this shows how masterfully it did it. It’s like looking at the gears inside of a well-made watch: we’re all familiar with the glitz of Lucas’ IP, but I like that Andor is breaking it down for us to see how it operates. After this series is over I’m going to want to rewatch, not only R1, but the OT (esp. ESB), knowing that the ruthlessness of the Empire extends well beyond our main antagonists of Palpatine and Vader.

[@Cheesehead_Caleb]

Wow this show is AMAZING. I would even say that it's nearly as good as shows like Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul at this point.

[@Oldstalk]

Not YET imo, but it's reaaaaally not that far

[@darthtroller]

@@Oldstalk agreed

[@javiervidal366]

Right up there, perhaps Breaking bad at the top but this one a close second.

[@federov100]

Andor is growing a following who prefer science fiction over fantasy, whose imagination has been captured by a universe that’s been fleshed out enough to feel almost real, but to date fans that have been frustrated that its potential is squandered by being portrayed fantastically.

[@StraightOtohGunga]

Star Wars is a perfect mix of the 2, the problem is that The story line and the things that happen still need to make sense within the world. People have no problem with force powers and all of this, it just needs to be consistent

[@drp1bb856]

It has the trappings of a Luceno book brought to tv. I’ve said before I wanted to dislike this show, but its been great so far. I’m glad we aren’t just seeing rebels planning to attack something and repeat. EDIT- I’ve always wanted to see a day to day show of the Empire.

[@thorskywalker]

It's like a good EU book on screen. Never thought I'd ever see anything like it.

[@jamesgrieves2669]

@@thorskywalker And we do have to specify a *good* EU book. Disney Star Wars imo isn't any worse than the EU in terms of having a lot of dross but a few great gems.

[@KingCobraLolcow]

Serkis was fantastic. This show is soo great than in every episode you could see a different character shine. Even if they aren't the main character you are just invested with them. Everybody in this show has a meaning to them!

[@adscomics]

Kino Loy I think may be my favorite part of this episode. I really liked see him become a much more interesting character that isn't simply a hard-ass. Even in the last episode, he never seemed unreasonable. It definitely came across to me that his time in the prison is almost up, and he just doesn't want anything to go wrong while he's still there. Excited to see what happens next week.

[@RampidWarthogStudios]

I pray they do shows like this every so often. Didn’t need to be every show. But please keep up content like this

[@JoRoq1]

In style and tone, yes, there should be variety. But the quality and care put into the show by the entire production is what we should be getting every time.

[@RampidWarthogStudios]

@@JoRoq1 without a doubt. That’s all I’ve been asking from Disney.. if they need to pump out fewer shows to make it happen then so be it.

[@Urielization]

Honestly Syril has some durasteel balls in stalking a ISB agent and than trying to grab her arm.

[@Peter-id9wh]

Like everyone else, I’m floored by how good this show is. The issue people have of “nothing happens” I usually take to mean there aren’t jumpy cuts or lens flares or over-the-top explosions… all of this known as the key jangling to keep us from noticing the lack of story or coherent scripting/character development. Andor doesn’t need those because there are actual professionals writing, acting, directing and producing this show. The thing that drives me crazy is that legacy characters don’t get the same respect. They hand those characters to unproven talent (no offense Deborah Chow - you did what you could to make Obi-Wan look good) but take great care with Disney era characters. Oh well. At least we have this show to rewatch. I can’t wait to binge it all at once after the run is completed. Can’t wait to see what season 2 brings!

[@JumboH]

I think it’s also interesting to add that like all the prisoners don’t feel like criminals or thugs they feel like normal people

[@braedenworden6694]

Genuinely my favourite show in a long time. It mixes gripping, adult level themes and ideas that require you to think hard with Star Wars. Its epic

[@MedalionDS9]

There was a line by Dedra that was ironic where she says "The worst thing you can do, is bore me" and how audiences won't give the show a chance because they are "bored" by it.

[@Matt-bg5wg]

I think the viewership for Andor is actually pretty good. There was initially a misreporting of the numbers which everyone quickly jumped on and screamed “see no one is watching” which was soon rectified.

[@anthonybrown4726]

im baffled how anyone could be bored by this show lol

[@NameNotAChannel]

@@anthonybrown4726 I am quite bored by this entire show so far. One problem is that it is a prequel, so we know what happens to Andor. Another, is that very little actually happens. What little is happening, is based around Andor, who I think very much deserves to be in prison, so I'm not rooting for his escape, as he is a murderer, while the most interesting parts are based around imperial characters who I am NOT rooting for their success in destroying the rebellion. The background stuff going on with Mon Mothma is boring. I know she becomes someone important in the rebellion, so she's going to survive all this... I don't "fear" her getting caught in these money laundering shennanigans, as her being deposed from her senate seat would just push her more into her eventual role in the rebellion... Plus, their "humanizing" of the imperials in that first heist scenario just rubbed me the wrong way. I don't want to sympathize with the evil empire. It doesn't add layers of grey, it just paints the rebellion in a worse light.

[@javiervidal366]

@@NameNotAChannel the nuanced take about the rebels and the empire is one aspect that I love about the series. It's not a fairy tale about the good guys vs the bad guys. We can see how the empire has real people living real lives (in an obviously make believe world). That people are disillusioned from the empire and join the rebels. That the rebels do things that lead to death, torture, and oppression (actions by Luthen). One of the best written stories I've seen in a long time, with great character development, and top notch acting.

[@NameNotAChannel]

@@javiervidal366 Well, the nuance is one of the things I hate most about the series, given the nature of the source material. It's like people who think "grey jedi" could be "a thing" in the star wars universe... I must just shake my head and sigh.

[@naotohex]

Im so happy I decided to watch this series. I really wasn't going to because almost everything under Disney Star Wars has been awful, but this show is just so good that I am super excited for each episode each week.

[@themanipulator1]

Couldn't agree more, I'm watching with delight as it unfolds , only frustrating thing is seeing the potential of star wars and the potential we've missed in recent shows and particularly Obi Wan. That reveal at the end was brilliant.

[@dereklopez9060]

"How many Guards on each level? " "Never more than 12." The acting in this show is top notch. Andy Serkis honestly stole this episode.

[@EikeSky]

I watched this episode from my phone, and the cheer that came out of me completely involuntarily when Circus said that, the tone, the pace. Absolute perfection in a series. So good!

[@nessa5759]

Omg this was an amazing episode!!! I love Andy Serkis! His character is so multidimensional and relatable! I just love this whole episode- it’s my favorite so far!

[@flatline8580]

I like how there's been a bit of a theme that ties back into Rogue One, "Do you think anybody's listening?" "I do. Someone's out there." There's the whole waiting in the transmission tower for contact with Luthen. And a couple times in the prison arc we have Cassian cry out that there's nobody listening. It's a small thing, but it's a show full of small, thoughtful things.

[@darkside6526]

This episode was so well written. I actually felt a since of dread when the prisoners found out that an entire level was fried. Things like this show just how brutal the Empire was and why so many people began to stand up against them.

[@liningtheclouds]

I said the identical thing to my wife after watching it last night it's a great show period regardless of being set in the star wars universe we are both fans since 1978 so it's wonderful to go back to that era of star wars I assume that's why there has been low viewership it's simply for more mature audiences. I haven't heard anyone say it's bad really so I think it's a case of those who watch it like it spread the word.

[@chrispy1398]

I don't think this show is getting nearly the praise it deserves. Almost every episode ends and I realize I've been tensed up, leaning forward into the screen the same way I used to get sucked into the movies as a kid. And now I walk that wonderful tightrope of not wanting to wait for next week's episode but also not wanting it come to an end. I feel like Star Wars has kind of gone the way of The Walking Dead. You know, they get kill off Carl, then get rid of Rick and you wonder "Where is the show going to go from here? Isn't this where it should end? Just end it already!" It just kept going on and on. But then, like magic (new writers and show runners didn't hurt, but...) there was actually room to let the other characters grow and work with challenges. It gave the show new life. And so I see this happening outside of the Skywalkers in Star Wars. Not everything has to come directly back to Darth Vader or Luke or Leia or Han or Maul... I imagine somebody spit-balling the idea, what if Han Solo's in the prison with Andor? And was thusly thrown out of the writers room and sent down to work on Book of Boba Fett where that kind of random crap was tolerated. This has been a good move on Disney's part, make a new character, show us why we should care about him/her, don't ride coattails, don't shoehorn. Proof read, edit well, and tell a story.

[@corne-mlg1847]

In my opinion you are as spot on as ever, amazing breakdown. Truly amazing content! I love the show, and of course as any other human, I love people seeing the same as I do, and agree with what I think, although I welcome any scepticism or disagreements. But screenwriting, details, acting, characters, story developments may be the best I’ve seen in a while. Hats off to Tony Gilroy and the team that produced this, and all the amazing actor performances so far!

[@aaronbertram2342]

Thanks for your reviews. As important as it is to criticize the lackluster programs that Disney has produced, it is just as important to play up shows that have been really well done. I hope more people will come around and support this show. It has been outstanding so far.

[@tsiever]

Syril also gets rewarded by his mom after hearing about his promotion with her giving him more cereal. And the prisoners get rewarded in the prison with food.

[@danielvanveen2960]

I wonder whether the food is something like soylent green…

[@ChrisParlett]

Looking forward to watching Rogue One again after these seasons with all the extra layers.

[@ellicel]

It’s a rare prequel that can actually make you enjoy the original more, but if this level of quality continues, that’s exactly what Andor will achieve.

[@ChrisParlett]

@@ellicel Exactly.

[@glyph2011]

Serkis is bringing his A game as always. He stood out in the UK’s “Channel 4” show “Streetwise” back in the 80’s. Always thought he’d go far. Andor is a fantastic TV show. One of the best things I’ve seen in years and certainly the best Star Wars Show. This episode also proves it’s most DEFINITELY not for children.

[@eatmorenachos]

Andor is amazing because it has DEPTH. Mandalorian and Boba Fett are indeed fun. Obi Wan has the feel of the original trilogy. Andor stands out from all of them. Great writing, acting and these characters aren't just cutouts reading lines. You get a sense that these are real people. This recent episode was intense.

[@freshofbreathair1476]

This show has to be creating a lot of buzz and accumulating viewers as it goes along. It’s cool to have thought provoking parallels to the real world, interesting story arcs and crescendos along the way.

[@JoRoq1]

Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be happening. A massive number of potential viewers have just completely tuned out because Disney. Many others never got past the "boredom" of the first episode. In tone and style, it is not a show for everyone. It doesn't have the high fantasy space opera feel of the original trilogy, particularly by not having any element of the Force openly presented at all (let alone Jedi or Inquisitors). And for those who honestly just don't care for the type of show Andor is, that's ok. The problem is the people who are just assuming it is yet another subpar Disney production; who just want to see everything Disney Star Wars burn in the vain belief that Disney would sell and someone else would rebuild the franchise; or who only want Jedi, Sith, lightsabers, and explosions. They are not willing to give the show its chance and are unwilling or undiscerning enough to recognize the quality of the storytelling and world building it presents.

[@AA-Ashley]

This is my favorite serious show of all time now. I love it so much.

[@ledanoir1239]

Andy Serkins is amazing at emotions, wether he is a possesed hobbit or not.

[@Huppy1234567]

7:50 syrils mom " i prepare two meals for you a day" as she pours cereal and milk lol

[@LordDigby]

I just want to offer up praise for Andy Serkis, too. I think he's considered a 'character actor", which usually doesn't garner a lot of praise, in comparison to lead actors. Saying that, he is one of the strongest presences in the series, and cuts through the role of Kino like a lightsaber through butter(corn). He really is a brilliant actor, when you consider all the roles he's taken on. And, Kino is pretty much a simply a normal, human...person (as opposed to Gollum, Snoke, the merc in the MCA, etc.).

[@MaximilienRobespierre1]

As someone who follows British politics I saw many parallels between the Empire and the recent activities of the British for example in Northern Ireland. In the 1970s following the beginning of 'the troubles' internment without trial was used as a tool, where entire streets had the young men lifted and thrown in jail under suspicion of association with the IRA. The hooded men were a group of individuals who were tortured using experimental methods similar to those of the show. I don't know it the parallel is deliberate but is certainly is stark. I wonder show that deserves awards.

[@byzantium72]

It was really telling when the med-tech told the guard that he needed a cart and a trolley and the guard said it was already on its way. They knew before they even got there that they weren't saving the poor guy.

[@cye58]

Here a thought Thor the capture of Cassian could be the best thing that could have happened to him. Because he disappeared with literally nobody knows where he's is, and where he's at he's not who he is. When he escapes he can really be a phantom because of the time that's passed since he's been gone. He can use his position of stealth to carry out future missions. 👁️

[@mrcat3493]

Andor keeps delivering! This episode was terrific, they spent just enough time with each story to be fully invested and without leaving the viewer disappointed. Also, the ruthless and power of the Empire shown in this episode makes them absolutely terrifying. The Dedra/Bix interrogation was intense.

[@dwaynecuster]

Best stuff since Rogue One. Love Andy Serkis!! And I really feel Mon Mothma's dilemma and heartfelt struggle. Genevieve O'Reilly gives the character so much depth. Mon feels like she's truly a character out on an island by herself.

[@papabull8993]

Andor is a test of critics to me. It shines a light the critics that are evaluating a show for its content as opposed to those that are hating it because it is a Disney product. While I didn't finish Obi Wan, and dropped Mando after the first season, this show is amazing in it's plot and character development.

[@TimTam_3]

Another absolutely fantastic episode. The layers of this show is insane. The acting, writing, direction, cinematography, the editing, the score. All absolutely fantastic. As someone who wants to go into the film industry, I find this show so awesome and the depth that this show has is crazy. I love the show. I also wish we could see more aliens. That’s the only nitpick for me

[@MichaelDeNicola]

This is honestly some of the best television I've ever seen. It's shocking that this isn't what everyone's talking about

[@-AtomsPhere-]

There’s nothing to talk about…it’s just been a continuous course of slow buildup…when it reaches its climax I have a feeling people will be talking. But right now? I’m not surprised.

[@ondrejmaceska6196]

@@-AtomsPhere- and yet this comment is under a video which talks about it for 20 minutes

[@MedalionDS9]

I don't see Dedra softening to Syril.. I think on some level she realizes how much of a loser he is and pities him, and that locking him up now would be no pleasure to her... but she will do it if she has to. I joked last week that Syril was gonna turn into a Serial killer (sounds like Syril) and then he shows up stalking her and creeping her out and talking like a complete stalker simp

[@rsdillbot3646]

Serial killer Syril Khan

[@MedalionDS9]

@@rsdillbot3646 Exactly... Syril loves cereal and is a serial killer. This show loves their pun names.

[@marksandor9391]

This ultimately feels like a great show that just happens to be set in the Star Wars universe

[@davidparmly8828]

We seem enthralled with Andy Serkis for lots of reasons, but the Oscar/Emmy needs to go to Denise Gough for this episode. She was as menacing as any monster I have seen on screen anywhere. If you don't shudder when she delivers the "I suppose not." line of dialog, you're not paying attention. Denise's eyebrows should get a Best Supporting Actress Oscar as well. The subtlety of their movements was like watching a ballet.

[@turkishjade8873]

I agree with you 100% but I am an English major, the writing and acting, it actually has depth, Love it. FINALLY GOOD STAR WARS

[@colonel_angus]

Excellent summary, Thor. I love this show and each week I’m reminded of why. I totally agree with you and Andy Serkis was the standout of this episode. You could see the doubt creep in earlier in the episode and slowly build. Awesome! Looking forward hear what Sailor Naboo has to say!

[@Justatackit]

Ceril mother is only in his head she's been dead for a long time now and he's just having visions of her because he's losing his mind!

[@jamesdixon2917]

That was one of the BEST endings I've seen for a middle episode.

[@inkedvader813]

Another amazing episode, performances were flawless. This shop is a step up for writing in Star Wars, makes me want a Jedi's story told the same way. But also this show has been adding so much to the world of Star Wars, I mean we have been to more new planets in Andor than all three other Disney plus shows combined and we are likely to see one or two more before this season even completes. Also correct me if I am wrong but the big Alien that one character brought along as muscle was a Selkoth from KOTOR, Ferrix seems to be a mostly human world where as Niamos seemed much more diverse, I think it kinda of explains the lack of alien presence.

[@MedalionDS9]

I wouldn't call this an amazing ep... just another ep of consistent storytelling and excellent tension building. This ep felt very deliberate in drawing out the interrogation of Bix, ramping tension...the fear of interrogation before it begins, and the realization from Cassian shit is going down, nobody is getting out alive, and Syril is kinda becoming obsessed but in a sad... and unhealthy way. Vel being related to Mothma's makes it now less likely Vel is related to Luthen. That poor old guy, you knew he was most likely gonna die before the arc ended... he was looking worse for wear as the ep went on.

[@Rich_H_1972]

The pay off from earlier of those last two lines was brilliant. Said all you needed to know about where this was now heading.

[@marvelousmikereviews]

I agree this is another tremendously written episode. The depth of the subtext of the characters and actions of the Empire expresses the very theme of George Lucas in his early films. The original Star Wars and his first feature "THX 1138". Though Star Wars was a light hearted space opera, with serious messaging sprinkled in, as expressed on a few other channels the dark tones of "THX 1138" warnings against tyranny is expressively similar in Andor. "Absolute power corrupts, absolutely." Andor is a great example and there are very few examples in today's entertainment landscape of "showing not telling" the audience. Enjoyed your review. 6 stars, lol.

[@GSFBlade]

I've noticed that in most scenes with more than two people, most of the actors are given dialogue, (if it feels natural). Most shows would just limit the dialogue to the main characters, but here the background characters often get to weigh in as well.

[@paulyb2405]

I thought it was a brilliantly acted scene by Joshua James (Dr Gorst). He sold it well. The way in which he spoke about the source of the sounds. How they was discovered, how they were then tweaked a little and what the results are. Dr Gorst seemed proud, menacing and riding the line between genius and madness. I think it's good that we don't actually hear the sounds. Leaving it to the viewers imagination is far better. Probably Star Wars most chilling scene ever. Using the screams of children being massacred as a means of psychological torture. It all adds depth to the storytelling. An Empire that commits genocide,land clearing, locks people up in show trials, slave labour and now torture. No wonder a rebellion forms..

[@sonofjack6286]

I felt sorry for Ulaf, the poor guy probably had some family waiting for him. I feel sorry for the doc too, he's probably seen a good few of his brothers go out in a similar way, so he doesn't want to get attached.

[@spartan117zm]

Yes - I had picked up on that too, when he says he didn’t want to know his name - that tells me a lot about just how many fellow inmates he’s had to put down.

[@StraightOtohGunga]

I also wonder if the constant electrical shocks is what ended up causing his decline in health, or even a sort of poisoning by design to ensure he never makes it to his last shift

[@overload81]

​@@StraightOtohGunga nah, it was probably just the curse of johnny gobbs.

[@Droidsbane]

Honestly if a show makes you want more of it (which seems to be the case for most people that have been talking about it) then you know the show's good

[@eane4762]

Obi-wan was about destroying another hero of ours. This show is true SW and it is wonderfully written. Tremendous character development and an excellent, dramatic and action packed storyline. I enjoyed the classic old cinema tricks used as we see in the headset placed on Bix and the door being closed leaving the horror to our own imagination as well as the camera pan to the boots walking by, we see this in the OG SW movies, love it! Disney got this right, Rogue one saves the day. AGAIN.

[@unitruth]

Amazing episode and series. If and when a force sensitive or Force user shows up it will have an even larger wow impact.

[@sessions1617]

This show has been the best star wars made. It’s set a new bar. The depth in every scene has been insane.

[@FreeReel1]

I watch a lot of SW KZbinrs and you’re one of the few that are really praising it. I’m glad there’s someone of the same mind as me haha

[@drmaxwellandminecddp1116]

“Never more than 12.” One of my favorite Star Wars quotes right now. If I watch Age of Ultron or Black Panther again I will probably take some appreciation for Andy Serkis. The sequels too but I had completely forgotten he played Snoke.

[@Kowkarot]

One of my favorite parts of the episode, is the little reference to A New Hope during the torture scene. The scene was really graphic and scary, and thanks to the reference, those feeling will also be there with us when we see it happen to Leia. Our imagination as to what exactly happens to her will go far beyond, because now we have a better grasp on what the Empire is willing to do with their torture methods. This is how you strengthen the universe of Star Wars.

[@aryap2797]

What's great about this show is that it could literally fit by itself without the context of the larger Star Wars universe. It's not relying on legacy characters or mentions of legacy characters to keep views (hell there is like 1 mention of the Emperor.) I think it does an amazing job of showing the nitty gritty of the formation of the rebellion and how the populace really helped accelerate the downfall of the empire.

[@holyfreak8]

Just finished watching the chapter. I like how they show "the banality of evil". Theese are not monssters making bad things, it really shows how normal people can make the worst things.

[@holyfreak8]

@CastilloPérez men and women

[@shugaroony]

They are the Nazi's we have to remember. And ordinary soldiers and people in that organisation went along and did truly evil things, it wasn't just the SS. This is echoed here. Whilst none of these imps are Darth Sidious or Vader, they are truly forged in their beliefs.