TMC MP Saugata Roy vs FM Nirmala Sitharaman | "You're Not a Trained Economist" | Budget Discussion

[@selvaperia8512]

Wow....what an excellent and clear cut speech and truth about FM! He has slapped her terribly.

[@k.m.pandiank.m.pandian6077]

Slavery abolished long ago in America. But today faithfully followed by Nirmoolanayagi, a worthless lady functioning as minister (Back door entrant). Shameless creature acting as if she is the elected member of Parliament. 🤔🤣🤣🤣

[@kaderamer7837]

Nirmala who is not a economist😛😛😛😜selected minister not a elected 😮😮😮😅😅😅😊

[@GurujothiD]

She is not a finance minister but a Tax minister. We pay 30% tax and what service the govt is giving?

[@peterjohn3673]

Why were you born? To pay tax 😭 Why are you growing? To pay tax 😭 Why are you studying? To pay tax 😭 why do you work ? To pay tax 😭 Why are you a family man? To pay tax 😭 Why are you dying? To pay tax 😭

[@narendhiranpandurangan684]

We pay 50 percent bhai. U forgot the gst we pay for every product we buy

[@jeganathajeganatha6834]

சூப்பரா கேட்டர் ஐயா அவர்கள் நிர்மலாவுக்கு நல்லா செருப்பு அடி பதில் சூப்பர்

[@selvane9819]

Roy Sir....they're not ashamed....they have one agenda....Adani Ambani as a bankers of bjp

[@selvane9819]

Nor she

[@mohamednazar2539]

நீ இன்னாவேனாலும் சொல்லு.நாங்க திருந்த மாட்டோம்.

[@jeyabalan6334]

Wow excellent speech. Fact ofcourse

[@bravain2010]

Super...❤

[@arulmaryarockiyasamy2751]

Super iya🎉🎉🎉

[@rahuls9886]

Bed sheet போட்ட பேட்ஜெட் v காட்டி ஜெயிச்சோம்... இல்லை நிக்காம படுது பதவி வங்கி இருக்கோம்...

[@jeyabalan6334]

Super.fact fact

[@ctholkapiyan]

Adani and Ambani have purchased almost all BJP MP’s to raise their voices vehemently whenever any remarks are made against Adani and Ambani by opposition leaders in the Parliament.

[@shamugapriyasundarrajan6515]

It's becoming so difficult for middle class people like us to manage expenses... Prices are high but salary hike is not there... One side people are spending so much money lavishly for marriage.. Please bring a balance... Poor and middle class are affected badly

[@karthikeyansrinivasan2621]

Reduce your expenses.Save first.Then spend.

[@matte67]

Does this Country need a FM

[@bloggernatzm9295]

Do we have one now?🤣🤣🤣

[@vikramp1248]

Superb very 👉

[@sathishkumar-tr6bt]

Wow nice 🔥🔥🔥

[@r.m.9702]

Well experienced clear speech. No one can have this much courage to say straight to Nimmi,that she is zero as FM.

[@aje06]

Election la avala first jeikka sollunga

[@baskarr9480]

Super speak sir

[@Ashwinmena705]

Super sir

[@babuprabhakaran9422]

God only can save this country

[@lifestyle3750]

🎉

[@maranmicro]

Good for MP Saugata ji that FM was there. But bad day for her 😂😂😂

[@rajgeneviveveena2437]

Hats off

[@sja505]

Exdellent slap....she is not a 3:19 trained economists...

[@jayakumara7395]

A B Budget?😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 Super

[@DeiveegamS-om5ml]

Fm didn't know basic logic my humble request to PM sir kindly change the fm

[@sja505]

India should n must protest to change UNFIT FM ..

[@uthumanansari2328]

Not only FM… the entire Ministry including PM!

[@johnbritto8413]

Her attitude my goodness.

[@francisprasad2171]

Horrible

[@sashtia5239]

Pathetic

[@kuralovien5524]

Manmohan Singh trained economist thana? Aprm en UPA 1 and 2 period la inflation double digit? Moderate growth? IMF , World Bank warning la india la irunthuthu?

[@babum9282]

He did not collect gst.

[@kuralovien5524]

@@babum9282 no he just drafted the bill and couldn't get it passed at both houses due to lack of clear majority in both lol.. you do know that GST bill was drafted during congress period and BJP simply just implemented it right? Even P. Chidambaram was only critical of the way BJP implemented the GST, not the GST by itself.. ahh why am I even telling you this,,, you're probably just another dumbass who watches fake videos and whatsapp forwards and think he knows shit lol

[@kuralovien5524]

@@babum9282 and how is that relevant to double digit inflations under his rule? And you do know that GST was drafted under Manmohan Singh right? And BJP simply implemented it... Because congress didn't have enough majority in both houses to pass the law

[@NK-vn1fo]

Semma! Look at her face 😂

[@benjaminfdaniel]

Oh my

[@brksk4309]

A witch has some compassion.😅

[@morganhepzibha3151]

Manmohan Singh is a great genius. Someone like him should be born from now on. But nirmala seetharaman is a negative term for genius

[@MJANSI-vz6mp]

Porulatharam padithathane therium anna eppadiketutinga

[@semaeasy]

Honorable Ex Cm Dr. Manmohan Singh and Honourable Ex Finance Minister Dr. Chidambaram are geniuses and they were very humble and kind, and Nirmala is the most arrogant minister without any sympathy and empathy, she is the nation's shame.

[@kmpskmps2435]

பொருளாதாரம் தெரிந்தால் நிம்மி மாமியை நிதி அமைச்சராக போடுவாங்களா??😅😅😅😅😅 அதுவும் மூன்று முறை😅😅😅😅

[@stephenkj6799]

Very correct speach TMC MP 👍👌👌👌

[@hari-rv2jj]

He literally tarnished her 😅😂🤣, not a trained economist 😅😂🤣

[@Billybutcher-n1q]

1:17 😂😂😂

[@Sankar-yi4ge]

Correctly said old psrlimentarian

[@perumalk27]

Most poorest budget

[@bloggernatzm9295]

4:42 Bangam 🤣🤣🤣

[@lilzakki16]

as we have proper elections for everything. THE FM SHOULD BE A QUALIFIED IN THAT FIELD. NOT SOMEONE WHO COOKS AND EATS HALWA OVER THE TAXES OF MIDDLE CLASS.

[@ishwaryaam7560]

He literally demands a Writ of Certiorari

[@josephamaldoss8570]

நிர்மலா இதுக்கு மேல நீ இருக்கணுமா?

[@rahuls9886]

வூற ஓத்து பதவி வாங்கி இருக்கேன். போடா

[@thangapandian7444]

Any body can easily put tax on people,a good economist should reduce the burden of poor people by reducing the tax,

[@JayaChandran-e1d]

Educational-'Medical--TRANSPORT??(BUDGET-'FINANCE??,,

[@SVS75ify]

FM just read prepared by someone and all the budget are prepared by PMO office bearers like TV Somanathan and others

[@gunaseharanvenkatesan3042]

You people are the last to comment about FM 's knowledge in economics. Her husband is crying about this for a quite long time. Who else is competent than her husband.😊

[@UshaBalaji-uv7wq]

Hit nail at the head, she is not fit to be FM

[@jacobcheriyan]

If only our FM had any shade of humility, she would have checked with experts before presenting the budget. What more can be expected if she is subservient to PMO?

[@matte67]

FM is Selected not Elected by the People this is the biggest problem because FM doesn't reach the common man. She doesn't understand their needs and wants. The problem is with the PM who selected her as FM . A Chaiwala selects a Sales woman

[@rohithgovindaraj1318]

You only want Freebies😂, no one can Match your needs sadly lol, The budget must Oppress one of the three classes and For The Politics it needs to be the middle class it won't change even if congress win , congress and its allies are just using this for political benefits if they get the Chance they would also do this😢 sorry it's reality

[@vkdevan2011]

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SHOULD BE NEXT PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA NOT NARENDRA MODI - மூல கெட்ட மோடி

[@rajashekarrajashekar6417]

அவரை விட்டால் யாரும் அவர் கட்சி யில் இல்லை யோ நிதி நீதி.🤔🤔😮😭😔

[@k.m.pandiank.m.pandian6077]

Everything is artificial in this modi government. Fooling the people by AI, but what modi and his coterie forgot is that Indian people have original intelligence and are not artificial.🤔🙏🤣🤣

[@NMuralidharan-qq8hf]

Ok whether the Parliament would be allowed to function?

[@solomonrajsolomonraj8676]

U r fentastic speech TMC MP sir..😂😂😂😂

[@s.palkarasumathavi]

Batget worst entru koorum muttalgal nalla batget eppadi vendum entru kuravendum

[@gnanavelu632]

Amazing analysis about budgets and its benifits for nation, states and our citizens. I dont think nobody can expain in detail as you did Sir. Thank you Sir and i appreciate your effort and most valuable time. I wish and pray god to bless with good health to you and ALL. OM SAI RAM.

[@vengaivenu6817]

Nirmala madam opposite party illatha apo... Enna pechi pesininga, onion en ivlo cost nu last time keta nasngo onion sapdrathu illa neengalum sapdathingo... Vilai kuraiyum ithuva answer??? Shame.... Now opposition party asking lot of question give the answer madam......

[@BrindhaBaskar]

We want execution of social stratification in every subject with six sigma probability distribution sampling test type. Report as number in standard deviation gives how much Congress deviated from their ideology social stratification during standard committee report giving importance to every caste, custom, social equality, each subject, etc

[@sambhasivamjagadishan9563]

Madam have no experience about the financial subject. Who ever it may be. Only the parson no the Indian economical subject. So he know vary well. Have a experience about the financial. Because he served as governor of R.B.I.

[@ArmyofGodTV1]

நீங்கள் என்ன வேண்டுமானாலும் பேசங்க எனக்கு அதைப்பற்றி கவலையில்லை என்று அந்த அம்மா உட்கார்ந்துடு இருக்கு...

[@rahuls9886]

மானம் கெட்ட ஒழான்

[@sambhasivamjagadishan9563]

Try to bring back blac money fro. Switze bank amount. India never face any financial problem. And no need to cut the I.t. most of the parliament members are all corepathi. They may not bother to I.t Only the problem of middle class people. Madam givne middle class people middle finger. Vary worst budget. Past 2019 onwards I t slab may not changed. Unable pay th18. Months D.A. arrears for central government employee. During the covid period.

[@ArunKumar-sl7rv]

Extraordinary slap 😂

[@jammygalaxy]

TN government should not allow any single person from bihar inside the state

[@ShanmugaSundaram-pf7el]

சவுக்கடி கொடுத்தது போல் இருக்கும் சம்பந்தப்பட்டவளுக்கு.

[@ytadltspv]

adharkellaam soodu soranai vaendum - inga no soodu no soranai no vetkam no manasaatchi

[@shrestaassociates4063]

Not modi ka guarantee but pm....thank god...

[@jaffmartin1862]

BJP has collected Electoral boand from those are didn't paid incomtax & didn't showing his full property & income 😅😅😅😅😅

[@mageshg2058]

Manmohan singh m

[@sipderman3788]

Tmc mp are you saying that your people obtaining g degrees are useless. Only Oxford n havard are the best. From which university degree are you holding.

[@shaunbird8051]

Nice talk.This budget is made only for the benefit of Adanis & Ambanis.

[@SekerN-hm3zm]

அது. ஓரு. பெரிக்கி

[@gopalaswamybalasubramaniam1435]

This Budget is octopomus . Suck all money from wage earners in the name of Tax salary. DA pension House rents capital gain interest on savings . Nothing left . And these politicians enjoy all subsidery. No income tax Flight travel pension if they are Mp for few hours .we should work for 30 years to get pension . Congress was better Chidambaram was atleast sparing house rent and interest capital gain .BJP taxing is like leech .

[@dr.vsethuramalingam9197]

Purely economic aspects of speech. He may be an economist.

[@shanmugamthiagarajah9174]

Nirmala Sitharaman though unqualified as a fit person to be holding the Portfolio of the post of Finance Minister, she is highly qualified to head nodding to both Modhiji & Amirthaji. Because like a Learning Institution the Indian Parliament is ruled exclusively by a headmaster Modhi & Asst Headmaster Amirthaji. Nirmala Seetharaman is yes Sir Chaprasi. Other than that she doesn’t know ABC of finance or bullshit. Shame!!!

[@bharmf]

இதை கேட்டு உயிரோட இருப்பானுங்க 😂😂😂.. மானமுள்ள தமிழன் இருக்க மாட்டான்..

[@rahuls9886]

வூற ஓத்த மாமி நிம்மி make up களையும் வரை.. வெட்கம் இல்லை..

[@natarajanannamalai4720]

How pity. Our fm is from Tamil Nadu and our GodM oiasrely on FM who doesn't know economic

[@ChennaIWelcomeYou]

TMC's prescription of development of the state and its people are two fold. Daily lottery and monthly doles for party cadre wherever from Bengal, even across the border! Sourcing is by illegal taxes not forming part of GST from business and enterprise and whoever is with deep packers. For supplemtal income bash India in foreign and digital media. Nowadays that is a big earner. Unfortunately that is NOT the prescription of GOI and most of the progressive states. Mamta led TMC is regressing Bengal (she includes Bangladesh in election time) beyond redemption. Work culture is non-existent there. Expecting gifts and doles and subsistence living is accepted as a fate. This was the case of our planners headed by two Sardars and our PC - all three with highest education and were never elected as they were far far away from the people for whom they were planning. PC was never selected or elected from TN except once by a dubious whisker of a few hundred votes.. That tells you the truth about him. Hon.PM changed all that diffidence in the planning process with the help of Niti Aayog's and we returned to normalcy and in spite of Covid devastation growing at a very fast pace not even dreamt of before by the Congress regime of 70 years.. That is why they are talking out of context and about IN EQUALITY. IN - put in the hard work EQUALITY can be expected but it is in God's domain not always guaranteed. Ambanis worked and are working their socks off for several decades and along the way , have made lakhs of people crorepatis and tens of lakhs of people millionaire and still doing it today. They PUT IN the Hard work They have achieved EQUALITY with billionaires the world over. So do not compare ourselves with them and suffer. We can only think for today and accordingly our work for the day is weak and lacks confidence. Oh TMC , Raga, Kerala ! THINK! why you are talking about the INEQUALITY all the time. Because you are bankrupt in planning ahead. You can only think of today. Whereas Hon PM can think decades ahead like LKY of Singapore. That is why Hon FM and others in the cabinet happily follow his guidelines. The current budget oozes confidence in their consistent policies and procedures.. above all they are corruption free. This is Unlike the COTERIE of Congress Era which reluctantly trudged along with diffidence and corruption ruled It is an innate quality you will not get in any University. More so from Harvard, Oxford etc. Manmohan Singh and PC are two great examples of that. Oh TMC wallah, do not put down the FM's qualification vis a vis PC and the Oxford educated Sardar. One was corrupt ; one closed his eyes on corruption ; and never understood what the people needed as they were far removed from reality. Election can give you that strength. If you are riding along you may not get that strength. Do not ride along Mamta as she is depriving her State of all the programs of Hon PM. History will show them in their true light of how their tenure regressed India by decades , even if they continue to score in debates and dupe gullible people with their takes on any matter of national importance.

[@anniejoseph8363]

Roy Sir its true FM has no knowledge of economy shes the teleprinter of PM hope this Govt is removed

[@kris.s6346]

Wow ur g8, she is fooling all u guys.

[@Deenabandhu-v9y]

Sorry for the ignorance. Is there something called G8? Kindly enlighten me . Thanks.

[@vasanthim2531]

Ayya ஊறுகாய் மாமி நோட் ஃபிட் ஃபார் financial மினிஸ்டர்.இந்தியா economic total demaged

[@SivakamagowriMurugan]

ஜெயிக்கம

[@ganapathisamykrish5633]

A. Finance minister must well known well versed in economics but this FM knows only how to prepare pickles. She.has zeero. Knowledge in economics but. She acts as. She were great international economist she is. Unable. To answer properly to the opponent's. Questions she is shouting arrogantly

[@rajadunu8038]

Aama periya porulathara nibunar nayee.

[@muthukumarr655]

What daring comments... Only an honest man can speak like this. Tamil Nadu people deprived of elected MPs like Abhishek banarjee, Saugata Rai ms. Moitra.

[@kalaiselvansel1156]

She is not a Finance Minister. She is a Follow Modi Minister. What can you expect from her? She doent take onion. That is why her face is like a onion.

[@rahuls9886]

ஓழு போட்ட bad get

[@bakthanramachandran9877]

Ivanuga velai ithuthaan

[@Nomad97249]

Copy paste minister

[@rahuls9886]

வூருக்காய் தடவுங்க அவ கூதியில வூருக்காய் பேட்ஜெட்

[@rahuls9886]

மூஞ்சில வுட்டு அடிங்க மூத்திரதை.. மூக்குல அடிங்க

[@c.karolinlice4656]

Worst budget

[@rajkumardavid1965]

Awesome speech. Congratulations and hats off to you sir. Whatever good we say, it will fall in deaf ears of Nirmala as she doesn't consume garlic and onion. Perhaps she stopped buying tomatoes too, so she has no knowledge of soaring prices of common domestic provision needs. She's born with golden spoon for not having the need to stand in an election and prove herself but elected one like governors, do she's just a puppet in the hands of Modi and Amit shah. People should be educated to see through their empty promises on paper alone. Untill then these kind of power hungry , persons having care my foot attitude will thrive. God save this country

[@madhun718]

Worst budget of the century

[@kalaiselvansel1156]

Horrible Finance Minister. Look at her face. So angry.

[@dharmanayyan3021]

நீர் மலா

[@jahirhussain6490]

சரியான speech கிழி கிழி கிழி 🤣🤣🤣

[@rahuls9886]

கூதி யை பிடிச்சி கிழிச்சா கூட ஒன்னும் வொரைக்காது

[@chandraa8502]

Already FM has lost all her dignity. That's why she shouts with atrocity and anger. But when she leaves the ministry no one will honour her as a human. She will shed tears for her actions now.

[@panneerselvam3962]

Nirmala knows very well to tell lies. Back door entry nirmala. Unfit to FM .

[@vijayakrishnamurthy2044]

Was chidambaram economist?? A lawyer had any connection to economics and home ministry ....failed in Mumbai attack culprits of Pakistan ....what he did for the country ...sold our money printing mechine to Pakistan etc....tmc leader can't solve sandeshkali women problem ,her mp critized our fm, who gave seven times budget and saved our country during corona period. Now the nasty creatures elected by people not speaking about people's welfare etc...but criticism about a woman fm....due to jealous ....can't tolerate that a woman in higher post ...

[@Attitudezero884]

Emnada sanghi romba katharre😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Deenabandhu-v9y]

Vijayakrishnamurthy, you have just been identified as one among who has,have and had exploited, oppressed and belittled the native people of this land, of whome you people are foreigner.

[@vijayakrishnamurthy2044]

@@Deenabandhu-v9y The language you have written is full of mistakes and no sentence formation. Better try tamil language. Had, has, have belittled ...in ques....what are these...??.Dravidia English😀 Learned well.

[@RuthulArunachalam4401]

Even though she doesn't know economics, she knows it

[@Siva-jl9mi]

She is unfit for finance minister.

[@ayubansary2196]

Correct Speech