Top 10 ALL TIME Modern Comic Books - Overstreet 48th Edition 2018

[@LWOP710]

Found a Batman Adventures #12 for $125 had a soft crease down the middle no color break... got it pressed and graded it came back a 9.6 CGC....

[@brianhood4555]

I bought a Walking Dead #1 right off the rack...It’s the only issue I have...Boo Hoo for me!!

[@brianhood4555]

#19

[@Ecwfan]

I just discovered this channel , so I subbed it. I have Preacher #1 , Walking Dead #19 , Walking Dead #2 and Batman Adventures 12. Sadly I don't have any of Bone's 1st prints lol. Even back years ago when I searched before it became a huge deal finding a 1st print of Bone single issues was hard. I'm shocked that 1st appearance of Deadpool or Venom isn't cracking this top 10.

[@masterbuilder2856]

Love the list. And I just have to say, Bone, The Goon, and Chew are what comics are all about. No tv shows, no movies, no "options," and yet they're all on this list. Just solid writing and story telling. Awesome....!!!!

[@diesel6796]

Master Builder Chew is in the process of being an animated series, and Goon has been optioned for years. There is test footage on KZbin that looked incredible

[@masterbuilder2856]

@@diesel6796 Oh. I was not aware of that. Thanks for the heads up. Looking up The Goon right now....!!!

[@diesel6796]

Master Builder my pleasure my friend. The Goon looked great, and Chew has been on hold since Robin Williams passing.

[@zolo120mil]

Great video and episode Tom, Jeff and Ryan!! Love to hear your conversations on comics!! Ryan for some comedy and when Jeff talks you listen and stop what you are doing listening to a great wealth of knowledge!!

[@goldenageguru]

zolo120mil thanks so much, we have a great time when we all get together to chat comic topics. Really appreciate the comment and the time you take in watching out content.

[@johnscomicswithkids]

My favorite is probably Bone. Good stuff. Not a huge Kirkman fan but I respect his hustle.

[@Eparker09]

Jeff has me cracking up right now. Y'all are gonna have to coin that time "Go find a bathroom". My favorite was the black and white print of Spawn

[@joshuasanders9710]

So glad to see all the independent love on the list. The only one I have is Invincible but hopefully in the near future I'll be able to add a couple more from the list to not collection. Great videos guys, as usual.

[@bronzeagebroski9647]

You guys are amazing, i consider myself to be pretty comic knowledgeable but watching your show ive learned and discovered so much. Thanks ALOT Guys. Much Love, Chris!!

[@bronzeagebroski9647]

Ps im loving the SPAWN black and white #1 and that Lethal Protector

[@goldenageguru]

SuperSoldierComics so glad you are finding our videos so helpful and informative. We really try to bring the best information we can. Thanks again and geek responsibly.

[@nightbringer99]

Preacher would have to be my favourite from this list. My older cousin handed me down the first trade (I was almost definitely too young for it), and that is 100% what got me into comics. It's still on my shelf, and when he visited last Christmas he was surprised I still had it!

[@doctorviz00]

I really want to check out Goon, I've enjoyed Hillbilly. Thanks for another great video.

[@joeyxsolo]

More great content! I didn’t even know there was a black cover of that venom lethal protector.

[@silver-ageddave2849]

I unknowingly paid 5 cents for a Batman Adv. 12 a couple years ago, it was mixed/hidden within a large collection I bought so great surprise to find a year or so later when I actually worked thru the boxes...true story! I’ll pick Batman Adv. 12. Great video as usual. Silver

[@drbradictech]

Great show! Walking Dead #1 is my favorite from the list.

[@DLoCollects]

My favorite on this list has to be Walking Dead 19. It’s my favorite character on the show/book. She is so badass

[@Goat99]

Very surprised that Edge of Spider-verse #2 was not in top 10. (first Spider-Gwen appearance.)

[@chrishammond6320]

Love the show guys awesome I tune in to everything you guys do!!! But my favorite on the list is the adventures of Batman #12 first appearance of Harley great book actually saving money to try and get it!! Thanks guys love the pod cast keep up the great content!!!!

[@DEMONJIM]

Chew is hands down my favorite of the list. Fantastic writing, great concept, awesome art, and Poyo. Bone comes in 2nd for me as I find it very charming.

[@michaeljones9594]

Spawn #1 black and white Venom: Lethal Protector #1 black Are my picks for the top 10, great vid as always!

[@drkwngdukisback5873]

Great job, love all the content you guys put out, love all the knowledge you guys drop, great list but my favorite is the spawn variant from the bad boy of comics(todd), spawn changed the industry, it had the comic,movie, n cartoon.

[@chriscooper9290]

I think chew has the most opportunity for growth, amazing story, tons of content for a tv show

[@kevinhenson1286]

Goon #1 for sure. I was on hiatus from collecting when these came out but I got my first introduction to Eric Powell's work in The Goon: Once Upon a Hard Time then again when Big Man Plans came out. I was fortunate to be able to meet him at a signing he was doing near Nashville at a local shop and he mentioned that he too was a Tennessee native from nearby Lebanon. I got several signatures along with an unexpected sketch on the cover of Big Man Plans.

[@arzola2]

Great list and show. The venom black cover n bone 1 I use to have

[@travisdecheno5670]

Good stuff guys!! My favorite has to be Preacher #1 even though I still have nightmares about trading TWO copies for a few MTG booster packs back in 1998, hahaha...keep it up boys!!

[@howlettcorps5996]

Great list!

[@not.jack.sparrow334]

Out of the comics on this list I have to say my fave is Venom Lethal Protector #1. Keep up the great content!

[@N8DGR8]

Haha, @ Jeff. I do the same thing with Bone. Every time I find it I think it’s “the one. “

[@batcavecomics4499]

Great list guys. I'll have to go with Lethal Protector Black error. Thanks for sharing.

[@QueBall]

was a big fan of the black and white spawn #1, the error print of venom: lethal protector #1, & TWD #1

[@michaeljglocks1402]

Bone #1 so stoked to see this on the list ! Love the channel ❤️

[@paulmilton5935]

Great video chaps thank you!, My favourite is The Walking Dead #1

[@popcultureotaku3761]

My favorite on the list is definitely batman adventures 12, but that black and white Spawn cover was epic!

[@Mr.Persia958]

Great video Tom, been hunting for that black n white spawn in the wild for awhile now. Definitely a favorite 🤘🏼

[@DocStrange30]

I think my fav is that venom lethal protector. Great run, and that black cover is no jokey!

[@spyderpaul314]

My favorite on this list is Venom Lethal Protector

[@jamesgallegos2803]

Thanks for this list....going out to search my local shops now!

[@collectiblepaper6555]

Another solid vid. My favorite from this list is Batman Adventures #12.

[@jr_nerdlife]

Can't wait for the copper, bronze, silver etc. Gonna be fun to see which book made the list & which ones should have but didn't. I expected NYX 3 to make the modern list, but didn't.

[@popfuntoplay]

Bone #1 would be my favorite, I have purchased dozens of the later printings I still hoping to find that 1st print in a dollar bin.

[@wardb900]

Batman adventures 12 is one I still have on my list to buy, it’s my top comic you guys covered in the list. Great content as always!

[@JPBudgetCollecting]

Nice list. Must own Batman adventures 12, but no NYX #3? Surprised that wasn’t on the list.

[@xero37]

Jason P Budget Collecting yeah I watched this expecting NYX #3

[@Stampede215]

That's a strong list!! I have a Batman Adventures 12 9.8 CGC. I don't care if the price goes up or down, the book is staying with me!! lol Great video as always fellas!! Can't wait for more top ten lists!!!

[@pokey699666]

My Favorite is Chew #1 or Venom Lethal Protector #1. I have a Venom Lethal Pro #1 CGC 9.8. (Not black cover) and I just completed my Chew collection last week. My #1 is a 4th Print CGC SS Guillory 9.8 . and #2 is 2nd print. The rest are first prints. :) THanks for the Cool Videos. Im about to follow the link to the Venom Lethal Protector Videos you guys did. :)

[@barrysheets9454]

VERY pleased to get a black bag 15th Anniversary TWD #19 in my very first Mystery Mail Call in December! Also loved the Seanan McGuire signed Spider Gwen Ghost Spider #2 variant! Great, great books! More of a bronze/copper collector, but loving me some minty Moderns!

[@djderkey]

I’ve had a cgc chew 1 9.8 for years now. It’s definitely one of my favorite books I’ve read in a long time.

[@bretthessart63]

Wish I would’ve jumped on the Walking Dead comic bandwagon back in the day, it just happened to come out at a time that I wasn’t collecting that much. Glad to see Chew on the list. Good stuff, can’t wait to see the Silver and Golden Age Top 10 lists.

[@JamesLewis-iv3ll]

Chew 1 , I was at SDCC talking to Rob & John about the book they had issue 1 at there table for $50 , I didn’t pull trigger grab issue 2 that just came out. Walk the floor for about 10 minutes, walked about to the booth they sold the last copy

[@timmeyer9191]

Great video everyone. I think this series will be very cool. Have you thought about doing a top ten of books that had the biggest drops (in %) for each era? With the ebb and flow of prices, getting great investments when they're on the down tick might be something people would be interested in.

[@unrulysimian3897]

Yup, good idea. Hope Tom & Co. read this.

[@snizzlepop4641]

Pretty much on par for what I thought would be on there...for me...Invincible #1 is my pick. Loved the whole series and look forward to the possibility of a show....Snizzle out...

[@bigofgcu4265]

My favorite is the one you are giving away, The Walking Dead #19!!! Super hopeful for the show to curve back up with Michonne and crew taking center stage!

[@Boricua1796]

My favorite from the list is Venom! I agree with Ryan on The Walking Dead.... it's not my favorite either but only because Zombies creep me out!

[@90mfcomics]

Batman Adventures 12 was my favorite on the list, great video!!!

[@tree_fingers]

With all the indie heat on this list, I was surprised not to see Saga #1

[@thatoldcomicsmell56]

Oh, to go back in time. I remember seeing Preacher #1 and Walking Dead #1 in my LCS way back in the day. Like , they cost $50-100 back in the day. I passed on Preacher and thought zombies were stupid. (You'd have to grow up watching cheesy 70's&80's horror movies to understand). I did have some early issues of Bone. No idea what I done with them. Probably sold it for nothing. I'd have to say Spawn would be my favorite. I was collecting in the pre-Image heyday, and remember how McFarlane and Lee's highly detailed styles were game changers.

[@baxterleclair]

I have Bone 4-10 (and upwards) in 1st Print. 1-3 are signed 2nd Prints. One advantage to being old I guess

[@doomedhuh]

I have the regular red Venom #1 and regular Spawn #1

[@QueBall]

doomed huh same here!

[@jr_nerdlife]

If either or both are news stand covers (with the barcode) then you're doing just fine, if not they're pretty average unfortunately

[@UndeadMousey]

My favourite modern comic has to be Walking Dead 001. I had been collecting walking dead comics since issue 002 but never had a number 001. Then one day whilst visiting a car boot sale I found one in a box of comics. I paid £20 (GBP) and immediately sent the issue off for cgc grading. It returned a few months later a 9.4 Very happy. I now own a complete set through to present with every issue from 007 signed by artist Charlie Adlard. (With a few Kirkman and Moore signature scattered about) Still holding out on the Blind Bag issue 19 pencil sketch edition 🤞

[@burleycardboard]

Good list! My favorite from the list is Batman Adventures 12.

[@DarthBleak]

I wish I could go back in time when I had or could get a hold of these titles again. I loved Bone and some of those awesome indie titles!

[@venredjtn]

Awesome Comics!!!!! It's hard to say that Walking Dead #1 isn't my favorite, but I'll go with Bone #1 for my daughter. I think that is the first comic series that she got into. Geek Resposibly

[@sactosanctorumcomics5395]

My favorite from Modern is definitely Walking Dead. I took a long break from comics and when I discovered Walking Dead last year, I absolutely demolished the trades and have begun to collect the singles.

[@ownerofthewhitesudan9288]

Would have to be walking dead 1 and 19 cause both were game changers in the comic industry and this series is what got me into comics.

[@nerdycouch]

so many great books...that Spawn cover is awesome..I also like the Venom cover. Huge fan of Venom

[@JoseCastillo-ps7hn]

I have to say venom and spawn hits my list you guys are doing great

[@jesselundberg7264]

Really like the look of that Spawn cover.

[@carlosl9826]

Prediction: #1 of all time....Turok 1

[@theretrosavage3337]

Well played carlos..well played

[@badzsculptures3755]

DarkHawk #1

[@carlosl9826]

@@badzsculptures3755 It might be if there's a surprise move to make him part of the new Guardians of the Galaxy

[@nerdtopiapodcast5278]

Hell. Yes.

[@dannybailes3948]

Hey guys. Love this channel. What do you guys think about Spiderman 2099 #1 toybiz variant? Seems to be going up a good bit

[@antoniosantiago2166]

Jim Lee, Marc Silvestri and Scott Williams are to town this weekend, any tips on what I should get signed? Already know I’m getting Batman damned signed by Jim Lee, but what else, mostly have Image books from these guys.

[@cryptthantoz782]

Spawn is my favorite wish I had more spawn stuff

[@BamaLynx]

Venom Lethal Protector #1...I don’t have the black cover, but that book was the first comic I ever bought when I was a kid so it holds a lot of sentimental value

[@coppaaa9972]

You guys are solid. For real. Thanks.

[@goldenageguru]

mike no Mike, your solid. 😁 Thanks for the kinds words, really appreciate the support. Geek responsibly my friend.

[@MrLuckycharms23]

Invincible #1. Love the Ryan Ottley art, and darker take on the super genre.

[@Tomurow]

Boooooone! My favourite! 💪🏻❤️🤓. I used to search for Bone stuff like crazy back in my early years of collecting. So-much-so that, even to this day, I still have very vivid dreams about finding that 1st print of issue #1! 🙄

[@jesuso2307]

Bone #1 read it as a kid and fell in love with books :-))

[@no-name4u]

My favorite is Batman adventures 12! I use to have that as a kid and I am bummed out that I don’t as an adult.

[@renegaderene4560]

hay Tom i like watching your True Firsts videos and i just found Absolute Vertigo preview and Wolverine #80 for a dollar each at the swamp meet...keep those videos coming

[@tonymiles273]

Would have loved to have picked up a walking dead 1 but somehow missed this one and didn't discover the book until a comic shop owner handed me the first trade and said: "Take this home and read it,if you don't like it bring it back if you do then you can pay me for it." Shout out to Arlene owner of "The comic shop" in Oswego NY.

[@enob1359]

Invincible 1 and Preacher 1 are definitely my favorites

[@joshdhogan]

I would have to say that Walking Dead 19 is my favorite on the list only because it’s the one on the list I have. I would love to get the other TWD books some day.

[@AdrianM91]

My favorite would have to be Walking Dead #1. Got into collecting because of the walking dead show so It only makes sense that that is one of my personal grails

[@imj3688]

My guess is that Chew, Bone and Batman Adventures have the best long term legs on this list. Batman Adventures has become a staple collecting key, the likes of Iron Man #55, Batman #232 and Journey Into Mystery #85; and the book is a desirable slab even as low as a 7.0. Chew garnered interest upon release but has simmered for a while. Even so, it wasn't incredibly over printed and is an original, over the top idea that will be supported on the secondary market if only for it's cult status even if it never pops beyond where it's at now. Bone has had a nice, slow burn from the beginning - a book that we all knew about since day one, but no one bought when first released. Everyone 35 - 50 probably remembers the Hero Illustrated Bone Special, but now can't readily go back and satiate their curiosity because the 1st print of the book is impossible to find. And once this becomes a quality animation, the property will permeate pop culture and that book will further become a solid long-term bet. Comparing the two only on a comic publication level, Bone #1 is the immediate successor to an Eastman & Laird's TMNT #1 first printing.

[@goldenageguru]

John B. Comerford I feel the same in many of your points.

[@eoneillmor]

Any chance of getting a mystery mail call in the UK and Ireland? 🙏

[@josuemuniz3115]

Batman adventures 12! I mean who doesn’t love Batman The Animated Series? 👀

[@rustin9034]

I really liked the bone cover I’d never seen it before but look pretty cool.

[@oldwolf65]

I have to say that the preacher #1 would be my favorite of the top 10. Reason.... it’s the only one I own on the list. Lol. Keep geeking responsively

[@kcsnipes]

My fav top 10 from this list is the batgirl Harley issue just for how iconic it is ! I'm not sure I own any of these sadly, wait I'm mistaken I do own the 1st invincible !

[@seesawcollectibles6452]

I would love to own Bone someday. I read the story to my eldest daughter and I will do so with my youngest very soon. Great vid guys!

[@tylermcdonnell5391]

I always forget about the spawn cover

[@berightbackproductions6464]

Cool list

[@SociallyTriggered]

I have a Bone #1 1st print which I bought when it came out. Now it sells for about $2k.

[@mondricuskelly2581]

I’d have to say spawn #1 is my fav only because it made me want to be an illustrator.

[@nathanielmcdonough4120]

Walking Dead #1 is my favorite choice on this list. Love the show, of course it has its ups and downs but I still really enjoy it.

[@dwaynern1972]

I have never seen that Spawn cover it is sick!! Now I must find one to buy lol.

[@barbariankungfu]

1 out if 10 isnt bad when your 1 is towards the top. Can't wait to see the next video

[@traphousezombie8003]

The walking dead is my favorite because it got me into now being a collector and im now at the comic shop regularly..and buying other comics and I wouldn't have done that if it wasnt for the walking dea..so pick me for the giveway.I wasnt able to get a #19 blindbag.

[@nobodynoone7271]

I missed out on a complete run of spawn 1-100 with the black and white spawn 1 for so cheap earlier in the year. I was a fool. Great looking book.

[@DavisComicFinds]

I got to go with Batman Adventures 12. I flipped a copy last year, but the proceeds went to my ASM collection. Only issue 1 to go!

[@goldenageguru]

Davis Comic Finds fantastic accomplishment. Can’t wait to hear when you finish your run.

[@mariotonyferrer7917]

OK, so my favorite on this list is Walking Dead #19. That cover is probably the most iconic moment in the series. Along with one of the best characters of the series.

[@goldenageguru]

Mario Ferrer 100% agree with you. Thanks for the contribution to the comments Mario. 👍

[@johngrundy896]

Preacher #1 for sure but I'm also a big walking dead fan.

[@dadaustin4570]

LOL. “Go find a bathroom and start reading”

[@nighttigercomics7323]

I definitely choose Bone as favorite. It was really a fun read. Great video as always. Out of curiosity who does your editing?