What Mojang DIDN'T Say In Their New Creaking Snapshot

[@tristanshaltz2769]

I'm just imagining some guy in the air port, walking to his flight, and he hears: "99.9% of house fires happen to people who aren't subscribed"

[@Planetmango48]

Hmmmm...

[@toycat]

It's a public safety campaign, really

[@LordPorkshire]

@@toycatHow’s your day, Toycat?

[@toycat]

Very tired lol

[@KaibamanYT]

@@toycathope you enjoy your trip in Qatar. Just be careful. Tensions are very high in this region especially with the west.

[@jacobrutzke691]

1:47 actually hanging moss does have a use. When it is hanging of of pale leaves or pale logs it will occasionally emit sounds. Thats how the custom sounds work in the pale garden, they come from blocks not the biome settings.

[@jamwrightiam]

something people need to stop ignoring. this is very useful for datapacks + map makers

[@Phoenix-vz8ji]

Wait actual? Also which blocks do what ?

[@jacobrutzke691]

@@Phoenix-vz8ji I believe it's just the hanging moss and the creaking heart, with the hanging moss only making noise if it's on a pale log or leaf. I don't believe there are anymore but I could be wrong.

[@jacobrutzke691]

@@Phoenix-vz8ji oh and hanging moss makes most of the unique normal sounds in the biome, while the creaking heart makes the more creepy ones.

[@Planetmango48]

Oh cool.

[@lautrec4150]

Ibxtoycat exploring a real world realm

[@Lilboy20-rm1wr]

😂😂😂

[@NR.gamer241]

Then what the hell is he?💀

[@Lilboy20-rm1wr]

@@NR.gamer241 they call him cat and A hat 😆😆😆

[@Planetmango48]

Yes.

[@venator-fb7yy]

​@@NR.gamer241high energy wandering villager (doesn't barter but gives information similar to a cartographer)

[@bobojo6447]

Pale trees should be taller, and fog should be added. If they’re going to go scary, go really scary!

[@wariodude128]

ooOOOoooh, I like the idea of adding fog. Maybe only during a storm though, to give it something unique to see while there.

[@ythegamerita]

Also make the eyes visible even with fog

[@milkycolaaa]

I’ve noticed there is kind of fog in a way, the pale garden’s sky is white rather than blue :]

[@mikimus839]

like warden's effect, but pale

[@tycho25]

An extra difficult and rare Pale Mansion full of creaking hearts would be a game changer for the biome I think

[@hakim9602]

i have a question, why is the creaking hostile

[@alexcole9325]

​@@hakim9602Because they're just puppets of the Creaking Hearts, which are canonically just evil.

[@odin-gamingandwrestling7141]

it could have pretty good loot too. slightly better than woodland mansion loot, with a unique armor trim and music disc. maybe even a new goat horn.

[@MarionFR]

Of course, I agree

[@ked49]

It would need to be smaller.

[@oliverphoenix1563]

What Mojang NEEDS to do is add 2-5 Pale/white flowers. Creepy flowers would be amazing, and they should make the torch light emit light while they’re at it.

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

I’ve been saying this sibce it was announced, but the pale garen needs white pumpkins because story mode was a thing and that would be a cool reference, especially if a mansion spawns there. some of them could even spawn carved or as white jack o lanterns because spooky.

[@SEAF_Democracy_Officer]

@@Grand-Theft-Autismholy snap yes, absolutely would love white pumpkins

[@Fishfanplayz]

MAKE IT A FEAR GARDEN

[@Tomfoolery-of5gp]

Creakings spawned from spawn eggs act differently than ones spawned by the heart. The ones from spawn eggs can be killed in one hit. The ones from the heart cannot. Bringing an iron golem in the pale garden won't do anything.

[@RustyhairedAlp9575]

It would be really funny if someone tried though

[@sparkz5884]

Yeah, the Warden can't kill the Creaking so you could use it as bait to keep the Warden away from you.

[@rodomify7681]

@@sparkz5884 I've tried it myself and it's actually kinda weird, since the creaking can take knockback from the warden while you're not looking at it. If the warden manages to push the creaking far away enough from the heart it'll die and the heart will spawn another one.

[@randomperson8375]

dang, now you have me thinking about a "Pale Mansion" variant structure that has a bunch of Creaking Hearts mixed in with the logs and is filled to the brim with Creakings instead of pillagers. And of course it would be overgrown and filled with pale moss/vines/leaves/etc to obscure your vision.

[@Dr._Lemongrab]

Maybe it could be a different structure altogether, the "Haunted Mansion" with a bunch more structure specific enemies lurking around. The woodland mansion has Evokers and Vindicators, perhaps the haunted mansion would have some form of spooky undead enemies.

[@mrdino5273]

I think calling it a manor would be cool

[@MasonAlex-f9p]

I'm sending this idea to Mojang

[@Yoskio]

@@MasonAlex-f9pthey don’t care

[@MasonAlex-f9p]

@@Yoskio they care more than they did an update or 2 ago

[@Xwight.]

I almost lose my faith with this community until i watched this video and read the comments. Glad there are still people who grateful and hyped for this next update. These comments also giving feedbacks in such a polite and good way which made me feel better.

[@tinand69420]

it's always the ones complaining that are the loudest.

[@crangejo]

For real. The people complaining don't even play the game more often than not, they just are helplessly terminally online and easily manipulable by social media

[@el-verdadero_mordecai-456]

​@@crangejothose are the ones that say "the mc community is too complacent" while being annoying themselves

[@-desertpackrat]

My only real complaints are, it should be lighter gray colored if it's a "pale" garden, and it should be called a pale forest, not a garden, since... There's kind of nothing here that meets the definition of a garden, especially as gardens are man made and maintained areas, not wild biomes in nature, but if they insist on calling a wild forest a garden for some strange reason, they should at least add flowers I guess. It would still be a forest to me though. Essentially it's like having a biome with grass and cows and calling it "the Farm biome" when farms are human-maintained and not a natural area. As a plant nerd, that makes me facepalm. And also wish the creaking dropped some item. I won't really have any reason to interact with them. It's fine, I'll just ignore them, but I'm not wasting my weapon durability fighting mobs with no drops 😂

[@Xwight.]

@@-desertpackrat I don't really know the lore behind that name but if there's nothing specific, i do agree with you with the name "Pale Forest" About the creaking not dropping anything, it would be pretty good if it drop anything when killed but the thing is, Naturally spawned Creaking is not killable which is pretty pointless if they add the loot from killing it. Funny that you mentioned "im not wasting my weapon durability" when the real way to kill the creaking is by breaking its heart which doeant require any sword durability loss. Also you can actually obtain the heart which is something we can obtain from the creaking. "Its not killable, but its obtainable"

[@elwisuntemp7199]

It seems like everyone else went “Ooh Toycat’s in Singapore” but he was actually in a desert biome

[@Pebbleguy]

>Be person in airport >Overhear some British dude enthusiastically yapping about snapshots, Minecraft, and something called the Pale Garden

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

> He starts saying that 99% of house fires happen to people who aren’t subscribed

[@crazychicken8290]

@@Grand-Theft-Autism lol

[@masahirosakurai64]

A sneaky little detail I found about the creaking in my playtests that I don't think was mentioned in the changelog is that illager mobs are afraid of the creaking and prioritize running away from them over attacking the player, like piglins with zombified piglins.

[@who_has_atzomboi]

i think it would be really cool if they make the pale garden foggy and make it more of a gradual transition so you're walking across the roof of a dark forest and you start noticing the leaves becoming paler and the fog getting thicker and then you find yourself in this creepy pale garden and it would just be so much more natural and immersive that way

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

the sky turns grey in them though. they don’t need fog, they said the vines already obstruct your view enough, like mojang said, and it will always be dark during creaking encounters. also fog is a really generic horror trope they don’t really need to add.

[@ShrekOwO]

@@Grand-Theft-Autism Just bring torches or night vision and all those "obstructions" will be useless. Who cares if fog is a "generic horror trope" isn't the creaking that acts like weeping angel also generic? Fog would add a much better atmosphere to the biome, and fog can also be added to swamps too. Its not hard to add fog..

[@RedEarthOfficial]

3:50 WHAT!? 💀

[@Bakedbeans780]

I bet they have had so many conversations on skibby toilet lore 🤤🤤🤤

[@lasticflace1416]

💀

[@Bobbybats4295]

💀💀💀

[@deleted-something]

Kinda cool that they did made the pale garden as a dark oak variation, while it contrasts a lot with dark oak, it is a neat idea

[@pepsienjoyer17]

Not really, pretty lazy

[@fiblz5443]

@@pepsienjoyer17 that means birch forest is lazy lol

[@jacobrutzke691]

​@@pepsienjoyer17get off your high horse. They've literally already added what they promised for the drop like 5 days later.

[@justanothercommentercarryo8367]

seeing this comment after all the "I hate that the pale garden is a dark oak variation" comments reminds me of how impossible it is for this community to be satisfied with anything. Not a hate comment to the op, just a lamentation.

[@aguyontheinternet8436]

@@fiblz5443 I mean... I wouldn't exactly disagree

[@UltraVegito-1995]

Last chance to look at me Steve -Creaking

[@AnonymousAnonymous-zp6lu]

Creeper: Has Hss Steve: AAHH- 💥💣

[@moodstorm7]

@@AnonymousAnonymous-zp6lu*steve walks out of room and eats cooked beef*

[@FilmBucket]

It would be pretty cool for a Woodland Mansion to generate all withered and broken in Pale Gardens, maybe even with some Creaking Hearts inside as though the Illagers were ran out by an infestation of Creaking. Also, I'd love to see some tall pale trees to add to the claustrophobia!

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

it would be more claustrophobic with shorter trees because you would feel more enclosed and trapped in.

[@FilmBucket]

@@Grand-Theft-Autism true, but the larger trees could make you feel like a small part of something you arent meant to be a part of. ig claustrophobia isnt the right way to describe that.

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

@@FilmBucket yeah, that would actually be scarier, but on the other hand feeling trapped does evoke a few more feelings of fear than being insignificant. Maybe they could have tall trees mixed in with the shorter ones, or maybe a giant underground system of roots that connects to every tree, which could also explain where the creaking hearts come from, so if you investigate, you realise it’s much more significant than you first thought, and maybe they could all lead to one really spooky structure, like the ancient city, and there could be loads of spooky ghost mobs and there could also be white pumpkins in the biome and some of them could spawn carved and oh my god this update is going to be amazing (sorry for waffling on for so long, it’s just whenever I get excited my autism just keeps going on about some specific special interest lol )

[@DamagedPotential]

They should add cobwebs around the pale garden biome. It'll add to the creepiness factor. Also, the player should be able to strip the Creaking Heart to reveal a stripped pale oak log version. That should make it look nicer when it's attached to such logs!

[@kindaparadoxical5631]

Along with the webs it would be cool to have a spider variant called like the “Pale Spider” which is white and when it bites you it gives you blindness which helps the creaking attack you

[@ked49]

If you strip the log it should double the range.

[@digitalfantasies4570]

The thing I was wondering is how the creaking reacts to wolves. Do the dogs attack the creaking when you hit them? Does the creaking hit back against the dogs when you look away or does it just continue to target you? Does the creaking target other mobs when you aren't looking? Like if you spawn a warden would a natural generated creaking attack and kill the warden when you don't look?

[@jacobrutzke691]

The creaking will only ever agro on the player. Maybe if something could deal damage to it, it could agro but maybe not. It is interesting to note that every hostile mob is scared of the creaking tho(the warden being a exception).

[@Dev2009_2]

​@@jacobrutzke691 woah i did not know that

[@flinnyskylie1506]

good 𝗾𝘂𝗲𝘀𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 tho, For me i think the dogs wont react to it thinking that its also a tree 😅 ʲᵘˢᵗ ᵍᵘᵉˢˢⁱⁿ'

[@dreg651]

dont bring a golem naturally spawning creaking cant be killed and take no damage, then only way to get rid of them is if when they disappear in the day or break the block they spawned from, ones spawned from eggs have health because they have no source block

[@jennyevef]

in regards to the mansion, illagers actually flee from the creaking, even though it isnt hostile to them from what i can tell so its likely that if theres a structure in the pale garden it'd be something new

[@Feu_Ghost]

They do ? Damn that's really cool !

[@Roma_Romanee-Conti]

No that's mostly because pale garden is a variation of dark oak forrest where the woodland mansion is

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

@@Roma_Romanee-Conti the trees being similar to dark oak could very well be a placeholder though, as the pale gardens don’t have mushrooms like the dark forest does. I think if it was meant to be a variant it would have been called the pale forest, not gardens.

[@frank9966]

@@Grand-Theft-Autism it is a varient: EVERY pale garden spawns next to a dark oak Forrest

[@typervader]

3:30 YOU WERE STARING AT HIM OF COURSE HE DIDNT DO ANYTHING. He litrely doesnt move if you stare at him bro

[@sweetnsoursis]

Did you not watch literally 10 seconds after...?

[@typervader]

@@sweetnsoursis I did

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

yes but you still can’t kill it in survival usually, so it probably has the same behaviour as when you are in creative when its not spawned by a heart.

[@Chilliestbean13]

Glad you were able to make this and how you’re enjoying your day!!!

[@Chilliestbean13]

*hope. I’m failing at spelling today for sure.

[@craftxgamez]

Just edit your comment

[@Chilliestbean13]

@@craftxgamez when I hit edit nothing changes and I cannot actually edit. It’s like the fake thermostats that make you feel in control but don’t actually do anything except I can tell much sooner. Probably my browser’s fault. Or Warner Brothers. Who can say? Anyway I can only choose to delete, add a comment to correct or cringe.

[@kadenblanch6482]

I think the pale garden should have trail ruins spawn in it (yeah I know it’s a ‘useless’ structure). Not only would it make a rarer structure slightly more common, it would be a good way to spice both up a bit. It could even fit in lore wise, like the forest was corrupted, and everyone left; kinda like the ancient cities. I imagine archaeological digs would be much more exciting if you had to worry about angry forest spirits.

[@LandonEmma]

Bros risking his plane flight to make a video for us

[@Hadeks_Marow]

So, hot take, I think "The Creeking" would ACTUALLY serve a point if they had "bonemeal feet" where it bonemeals the ground around where they walk. This would have SOOO much application to it. It would also coincidently have the effect of making the "pale" spread when walking on pale moss since bonemealing moss causes moss to spread.

[@Lumberjack_king]

I completely agree

[@theplayer_]

Mojang's rule is not to have any dynamic affects in the game that can affect your world on a block level so the bone mealing thing while being cool would be bad for players who wouldn't want a mob you can spawn anytime with the creeking heart affect your built blocks or generation/decorations

[@MORE_BEANS_PLZ]

It should be limited tho if not prepared for a good chunk of your world to be a a boring re skin biome

[@STEALTH-ct5kc]

Yeah!, but instead of bonemealing it would just turn the grass or dirt it stands on into pale grass, and spawns trees

[@codymartin5747]

@@theplayer_im not super for this idea i think itd be weird but as for mojang not adding dynamic affects what about the endermen moving blocks then

[@ELCAyoutube]

They should make the trees almost, but not quite as tall as jungle trees and they should also add fog and make abandoned villages spawn there

[@Biggi19]

I think the reason why this snapshot isn’t in bedrock yet is because it’s easy to update Java than it is in bedrock, since several companies(Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, Apple, Android) have issues with certification and eventually making all the releases line up well so the bedrock previews come out in every platform

[@parkerredeker5216]

Everyone else: Oh new snapshot! Me: The cool air port was used in the 2004 tv show version of Battlestar Galactica

[@fldom4610]

what does that have to do with anything?

[@josephrowlee]

Fun fact: Creakings spawned from Creaking Hearts will not be damaged or killed by Iron Golems or The Warden

[@fazbrogaming7776]

I have a theory for the Pale garden. As we know theres been this long standing theory that there was a race of ancient builders that existed before the minecraft player, they escaped the Overworld after creating the Wither. What if the Pale Garden is a direct result of the wither’s destruction? Its possible what the pale garden was once a regular forest but after the withers attacks it became infected with the wither sickness and became what we see it as today.

[@newtechnoblade]

That's a cool fanfiction bud.

[@chriscofer6780]

​@@newtechnobladecry

[@SEAF_Democracy_Officer]

@@newtechnobladeit’s called a theory, not a fan fiction, genius.

[@ked49]

@@newtechnobladefan fiction is making a story using characters you are a fan of. Based on that, playing Minecraft is making fan fiction as you make the story using the characters/world. What they did is present a theory.

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

wouldn’t the biome be black and withered if that happened? also in that theory the wither followed the builders into the ancient city, but they spawn under mountains, so it wouldn’t make much sense that the biome above it isn’t corrupted whereas a biome it doesn’t spawn under does. Still, interesting theory, I just don’t think it makes much sense with the lore we already have.

[@crazedweasel6087]

What's interesting about this 3:00 is that they literally told us in the "live" (but not really live) that we could use the creaking to protect our base as long as we the player put the heart down. Now the fact that they don't act like iron golems sucks why tell us to put a hostile mob in our base if it's not going to do anything like attack other hostile mobs and still attack the player I hope it's just a bug or something that will be fixed when the released version comes out. If not I don't see any other reason other than to "scare your friends" ( Which I don't have ) to bring one of the hearts to your base and spawn a creaking.

[@blueberryf1nch969]

There's still a good few months left before the release, so they may add this feature later. I'd love an ent friend.

[@puzzlegal17]

Also, it's linked to its heart. You could place it strategically so there's a safe path to your base, but the creaking defended other ways in.

[@dlp404]

5:33 sleeper agent activated

[@supercat765]

wait... could you use a creaking to distract a warden? The mob that cant die to normal damage and constantly makes noise, vs the mob that goes after noise. So could a creaking be a method of exploring the deep dark? (i am not saying a good one just a possible one)

[@minewrecked5775]

Honestly, if they added Woodland Mansions in the Pale Garden... It would make sense for it to be abandoned with a bunch of creaking hearts in the walls, some overgrowth and damage too. But they would have to make The Creaking more dangerous first.

[@That_OneGuy46]

I feel like the creaking vs warden questions (+ iron golem one) wasn't answered well, as you've used creative mode creaking, you should check to see if they can kill natural creakings, or if it'll just trigger the creaking heart link

[@chewy99.]

Birch is going to see a big dip in use lol

[@Platypus_Gaming_1]

Missed opportunity with the cherry blossom leaves to turn white similar to the “Snow Fountain” Weeping Cherry tree

[@darth3911]

Suggest it to the devs then and they might add it.

[@MyconidMushFungi44]

For a pale woodland mansion, the cobblestone could be replaced with Deepslate, creaking hearts could be embedded into secret rooms so creakings will be more challenging to overcome, and in addition there could be a ancient city located below every pale mansion with a semi-mineshaft/trial chamber between the mansion and the city so when your finnished with looting the mansion, you can then move on to the mineshaft/chamber, then city

[@darth3911]

That would definitely improve the worth of seeking out the mansions.

[@MyconidMushFungi44]

mojang, hire me, "i can make reality whatever i want it to be"

[@Shojiki64]

watching people walking past him and giving him weird looks is golden

[@pizzaman5344]

Really would like if they added an ambient weather overhaul. Fog would be an excellent idea for the pale garden. Torrential rainstorms, sandstorms and blizzards would be cool additions to add to the atmosphere.

[@The_pig_cult]

Dude that place is horrifying I played it And got scared

[@kolkagaming1234]

Maybe I recommend if you bring some armour. And if the Leaves get in the way of the Creaking Heart use shears as they can Tear through All Leave blocks. And feel free to enchant your Shears with Unbreaking alongside efficiency.

[@dougsvoboda6091]

@@kolkagaming1234 A hoe is better for leaf blocks than shears. Same enchantments with way more durability.

[@kolkagaming1234]

@@dougsvoboda6091Oh. Are you sure Hoes can break Leaves Fast enough without the Efficiency Enchantment? My Diamond Hoe has Efficiency 5 & it Tears Apart Leaves. But with Shears you can take the Pale Leaves without Silk Touch though.

[@dontgivetwothwips3615]

A Rapunzel like tower in the middle of a pale forest with a special item, like rope, a non-craftable but multi use component for items like a grappling hook or something.

[@evanmcnemar5241]

💯

[@epicthief]

Creaking Woodland Mansion would be wild, they could have the Pillagers experimenting with the Heart, a way to show players what can be done with it

[@dhakman8765]

I feel like it was a missed opportunity to not add a Structure to this biome. As now there is no reason to go to the pale garden because the creaking hearts don’t benefit you at all. If they don’t add a reason to go to the biome then in a Few Years everyone will just forget it. At Least Make the Creaking that spawns out of the heart able to attack hostile mobs so that you can use it to be another protection to villages

[@Cat_Conqueror]

Wood

[@therealslimweegee]

About the last point; the Creaking does scare off Illagers, so there is a use for it in defending villages from raids.

[@arandomcreatureontheinternet15]

i mean the thing isn't like finished yet, they still could add a structure or something i imagine they at least have a couple more things planned for the pale garden

[@dougsvoboda6091]

I don't think it really needs a structure as much as others do. The cherry grove only offers pink wood and a new pink flower and people are fine with that. Pale Garden adds white wood and an interesting aesthetic to set up a base in.

[@arandomcreatureontheinternet15]

@@dougsvoboda6091 yeah it'd feel kinda odd to have a structure imo but like i do think it needs a reason to go there at night

[@Alabenson]

I'd make woodland mansions that spawn in pale gardens abandoned, like the abandoned villages. It would add to the creepy atmosphere and you can add unique mobs to it later.

[@sirjamesfancy]

Crazy how much Toycat travels. I've never been on a train or plane.

[@crazychicken8290]

bro go travel explore

[@sirjamesfancy]

@@crazychicken8290 Costs moneeeey

[@devbadge]

The amount of weird looks he was getting while recording in public was hilarious. Just look at the lady at 00:17

[@EldritchDoodler4828]

I think if they put the garden in the middle of a Dark Oak forest would be really cool- a biome that’s hidden away from the rest of the world They could also add some kind of clearing with a body of water to the biome, would help break up the biome a bit

[@olibuckpokefan]

I hope they make it so the creaking will attack anything that is not looking at it or something like that like how it attacked the villagers in Minecraft live

[@olibuckpokefan]

And since the warden is blind they would be enemies

[@youraveragenerds]

I think they definitely need an reason to go there, like a unique drop or something other than the freaking heart

[@darth3911]

They heard feedback and are working on it. Hopefully they add more unique mobs for the biome. Maybe new illagers and a pale creeper or something.

[@thecrustycaptain1934]

My main issue with the creaking is how weak it is like there’s no threat and it’s not gonna kill me if I look away to break the heart

[@robertgardiner7709]

Three things: 1. The dark oak accents on the Pale Woodland Mansion actually look cool, I sort of hope Mojang will do the same if it's included. 2. Maybe replace the Pale Woodland Mansion's Evoker spawns with a new Illager type? Maybe something like "The Pale Druid", The fangs are re-flavored as thorns and it can summon Creaking instead of vexes? Maybe even a new drop for this super rare mini-boss? 3. Add an alternate biome-skin for the other illager mobs inside the mansion, Would be kind of neat if they made it look like The Creaking Heart has somehow possessed them or that these specific illagers have formed a cult to worship it.

[@remysummerb]

My longboi arrived today!

[@NekoEko]

I kinda like the ides of the pale garden being similar to a virus, spreading through a dark oak forest (not actually getting larger in game but giving the appearance of it) so that any structure that would have spawned in the dark oak is actually a deserted run down version of it since it was build before the pale garden got to it

[@darth3911]

It’s better as a plain hunted forest. Skulk makes a much better virus biome.

[@maucraft119]

imagine a pale abandoned mansion, like abandoned villages but white

[@mtrujillo9221]

I instantly got where you’re at you’re at the Singapore airport. Oh your in the middle East I thought you’re in Singapore

[@joemamaenjoyer5262]

I think a cool idea could be to make woodland mansions that spawn in pale gardens have a small chance to be run-down and abandoned, with some of the logs that make up the structure replaced with creaking hearts.

[@ArayaRetta]

The mangrove tree looks sick af in the new biome

[@TigerLiu-HIM9528]

Just imagine being in the same airport as Toycat at that same time, how cool would that be!!! And also, you are so good, working so hard for each video, I love them ❤

[@mantisr818]

Illagers are afraid of creakings, so you'd need an abandoned Mention

[@TiagoMonteiroArt]

Thank you, Harrison and Andrew, for this video! :)

[@KevinKolpack]

Interesting that you bring up the woodland mansions, because they made it so all the illager mobs run away from creakings.

[@netherwarrior6113]

My question is could this be used for look based redstone. Having a creaking spawn in a room with a pressure plate and some water, and the creaking will run towards the player onto the pressure plate. This could be very cool for some Halloween builds of stuff moving when you look away

[@swankierSpy2658]

7:55 it says it’s a variation of the dark oak forest in the changelog

[@joelwong1239]

0:40 Jewel changi airport Singapore

[@Capamike]

I agree with the woodland mansion variant! I also think that adding fog into the biome would be great

[@santohyj422]

Btw the entity ID for naturally spawned creaking is creaking_transient. You cannot summon them (‘/summon creaking_transient’ is an invalid command), but you can put the ID for a selector argument (e.g. ‘/tp @s @n[type=creaking_transient]’).

[@Restless-Crow]

There are people wanting the Creaking to do more damage. Can you imagine going into a Pale Garden, and there are multiple attacking you doing 3 or more hearts of damage.

[@IrisThatOneGothMf]

the creaking is inmune to lava, the wood should be immune to fire

[@nikolifrancis9629]

Real ones remember his old let’s play Xbox 360 videos. 11 years ago😢…..

[@edenwayne8407]

I think the name pale garden doesn't fit it very well, because it's definitely more of a forest rather than a garden. A garden just sounds more man-made. But who knows, that might be a lore thing.

[@beaniefamily]

Yeah, I thought the biome was gonna have a whole bunch of grey-ish flowers growing in it lol

[@beppis-vr3qr]

The lore sounds like a cheap excuse not to work.

[@edenwayne8407]

@@beppis-vr3qr I mean if it is really man made, I think mojang would have to add more clues to that, like abandoned structures. Which would be more work than just a natural biome.

[@modeushelltaker4076]

Yea Exactly The Better Name Would be: Corruption Forest!

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

⁠@@beppis-vr3qr “cheap excuse not to work” - says the child who has never worked in their life. You can’t just saying “mOjYaNg dOn’T dO aNyThInG aHyUhYuHhYuH 🤓” just to try sound cool and edgy, despite mojang announcing a new update, whilst also saying there will be more updates more often than ever before down the line. Life isn’t as easy as just having an idea and then instantly being able to bring that idea to life right away. Don’t worry, you’ll learn that someday. Maybe around the time you reach your 12th birthday.

[@RogerMollet]

You might want to leave there soon, otherwise you might get kidnapped by the two fighting groups.

[@vicentearnabal]

??? He's nowhere near palestine or any other place with 'two fighting groups'. He's in Qatar

[@yee8332]

Only concern might be the return flights back being rerouted or delayed, but seemingly no war issues happening in Qatar

[@lunaticcultist3764]

@@vicentearnabal I'm slow and thought he meant the warding and the creakings

[@iamamogus7702]

Qatar Airport - DOH

[@sylokthedefiled7650]

Really wish theyd put a garden temple and some unique flowers in the pale garden, since there's nothing that makes the biome a garden.

[@Portal_Master547]

This place is a biome. It has no reason to be there other than what it already has. It's like asking why go to the savanna, or the dark oak forest. For its resources.

[@stargazer-elite]

Imagine having a pale garden version of the woodland mansion that’s basically just a color shifted version but abandoned that would be pretty neat but I think that might be asking for too much. It’s just an idea to throw out there.

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

it would be cool if they had creaking hearts in the walls as well as other Ghost Type mobs.

[@peixeesquisitomk]

Things that should come to the Drop - glowing or emissive flora for the pale garden. -Fake creaking: they are more like a block that can sometimes generate at night, that are there just to trick the player -Albino trees: Some trees in every biome have a veryyy small chance of being made of pale blocks instead of the normal ones and have a creaking heart, but again, very tiny chance Retinal Scabner: redstone that can only be activated if the player looks at it, maybe even if a mob does. It can also be reversed (only activated when not being looked at) -Creaking Drop: maybe the mob drops it's head or maybe a special rod item that can be used to craft a new gear, just like the breeze drops its rod to make the mace? -more ambient animals, like birds -owls that scare the creaking or have some type of interaction with the mob. Or it lands only at trees that have creaking hearts

[@AkadTheFox]

What if it always rained in those? Making it so fires would be instantly removed.

[@Moon-cz5ze]

its like nobody watched the aftershow and get surprised that information wasnt talked about when it literally was in the aftershow

[@nintendoswitchbrit4201]

The Creaking that you get from spawn eggs and the summon command are different from the Creaking that are spawned from the heart

[@outregis]

I'll say this again, even though it barely has any relation to the video, but Woodland Mansions should get an update to it's structure to work like Trial Chambers, with Illagers instead of the other mobs. It would breathe new life into the structure AND give them a reason to look for over just repurposing it into your own base.

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

i don’t really agree with the idea of illagers coming out of spawners though, considering how they’re like sentient beings and all. They could still add new illager-related mobs similar to ravagers and vexes though I guess.

[@fungusdingus6813]

Was excited for toycat stream rebuilding a whole woodland mansion with spooky wood. Then realized he was in one the whole time!

[@SkyHighCity]

If other wood types look different in the pale forest (yes, I said forest on purpose) then what does the pale oak look like in other biomes?

[@Grand-Theft-Autism]

all the wood is the same, it’s just leaf types, grass and water that change colour between biomes.

[@SkyHighCity]

@@Grand-Theft-Autism yeah I’m wondering what the color of the vines moss and leaves would look like

[@Shinikyu_xX]

Add Frogs/Fireflies to the Pale Gardens and make a spawned* (by the player) Creaking attacked mobs not looking at it. Thatd be way cooler as u could build a forest around ur base that’s infested with Creaking that wont attack you

[@themissamandabeth]

Bored with more grey blocks but happy for true white wood

[@anglespoggle]

Toycat, even in the worst recording conditions, your videos absolutely brighten my day. I wish to be half as good at what you do one day, you’re truly an inspiration.

[@RogerMollet]

Also, the azelea tree would look cool, I doubt it would change color.

[@gruchogaemer8692]

I'm actually excited for this drop ngl

[@Gamelorian]

"I'm in the Middle East, which I hear is the hot place to be right now" 😂😭

[@somespeciesofpenguin]

statistically speaking, the number of housefires happening to SUBSCRIBERS has multiplied by more than 1,900,000 since the channel was created !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Helldiver-710]

Ye BTW spawned creakings die in one punch and the ones that spawn from hearts are the only invincible ones until the heart is destroyed

[@JuhoSprite]

Mojang did you dirty with the timing💀

[@reneegarafola7248]

I love the fact that Minecraft is so passionate and puts so much effort in to these updates me personally I really really like the pale wood probably going to be my favorite wood tbh it just looks so good and I love the idea of having to fight of the creaking in order to get the wood it’s like there trying to protect it and it makes it a little fun to collect it because we have a challenge to get it and that makes me happy this is a very unique update in my opinion and I can’t wait to see what they make next also w video i love your videos they dont take 10 years and they get to the point but love the video and your channel you give me joy in your videos

[@edwardm2445]

Does the creeking float like a BOAT? Its wood afterall

[@somaricraftbros6283]

Bro in the new dimension, life

[@lilwheezer6694]

Idea: when it turns to day instead of just despairing the eyes should go colorless and they stand perfectly still like trees

[@MewlingWolf]

thank you harrison for burning down a forest for me

[@HarrisonGray]

Np :)

[@the_phantom_cat7912]

It's also very much worth mentioning that any creakings thar are spawned by the spawn egg have one hp, and any spawned by a heart are unlikable, except by breaking the heart or the /kill command (though they quickly respawn if killed by commands), meaning golems aren't going to do anything in a real situation

[@dustymcwari4468]

The way summoned Creakings die so easily compared to naturally spawned ones reminds me of Tubba Blubba from Paper Mario, who's invincible while his heart is hidden away somewhere else, but becomes pretty easy to defeat once his heart is back inside his body