Tribal People Learn about The Solar System Part 02

[@TRYBALS]

To be honest, I don't feel I should feature more such videos on this channel. It's disheartening to see all your hardwork bearing no results. I do respect Abdul's viewpoint but the reason why we started the space series was Parvati. She doesn't seem to be interested in it to me. I can't say for sure but I do have a way to find it out. I'll prepare for two or three different topics next time. One from the space series, secondly a music and a random one (either funny or of historical or cultural value). The choice would be left upon them.

[@I-didnt-ask-you]

I am enjoying these videos. People need a lot of time especially if they are older to change their minds on something they've believed to be true all their life. I think the video had an error, it said the rings were 1 Kilometer thick or 62 miles, but I think they meant 100 Kilometers, as 1 Kilometers is less than a mile I think.

[@TRYBALS]

I'm happy that you are enjoying but I'm losing the motivation to run this channel these days.

[@I-didnt-ask-you]

@@TRYBALS Don't give up. Be patient, you can try different things to keep them interested and then come back to the topic. I always enjoy listening to Niel Degrasse Tyson, he has a great way of explaining things. Perhaps one of his videos can help in the future?

[@johnthompson6374]

Please show them The Deep Field View. Where the darkest piece of sky can hide 1000's of separate galaxies behind a grain of sand held at arms length. Earth at night would be interesting as well. Peace/JT

[@TRYBALS]

@@I-didnt-ask-you I'm afraid they'll forget everything if we take a time off from such subjects.

[@Az777]

Even if the participants don't retain (or believe) everything, it's for sure they'll never look at the night sky the same way again. I appreciate the time you've spent on this series, especially with Parvati. I've also learned new things by watching. Thanks for such a great channel!

[@TRYBALS]

Thank you ❤️

[@alphagt62]

It’s a lot to digest. Give them some time to think on it. Then come back with smaller pieces, and answer any questions they may think of. Diagrams do wonders for giving someone a sense of size and shape, but actual photos are the most interesting. You want Parvati’s attention, show some actual photos of these planets, stars and galaxies. They always fascinate me!

[@SovereignThrone]

It would be cool to bring maybe a telescope and look at some of the planets they learned about with their own eyes.

[@marklar7551]

@@TRYBALS , also realize that those of us in the USA had to study these things year after year in school. Most do not remember a large portion of whet they were taught after the final exam. Merely exposing the group to these things is interesting to watch. I think it might be prudent to expose all of us to the history of the region for what it has done to influence the planet to modern times from centuries ago. Science, mathematics, music, and culture.

[@VACIO666]

Parvati showed that she was interested, but gravitational force, the Milky Way, planetary orbit, rotation? Too many complex concepts that overwhelm anyone and make them lose interest. He need to slow down, explaining everything with several simple examples. You can't show a differential equation if people don't know how to add or subtract, you have to start with the basics, the Earth, the water cycle, how the sun affects life, the tides, why do we have an atmosphere?, the layers of the earth, why does the earth rotate?, gravity and its effects. They need to know the bases of science in an orderly way so that knowledge helps to understand another more complex one. I have said that the job of teacher or educator is one of the most important jobs that exist. All the best.

[@OzymandiasKaboom]

I know others already said this, but I repeat: this is very ambitious, and you all deserve respect for taking on such a project. On other channels similar to yours, they do not try to explain so much to the people. It's more just putting them in front of a screen and asking them to react. This is very popular it seems, but it doesn't help the people to really understand the material, and so it doesn't have much substance, in my view. You are the only one I know who tries to really explain and make sense of things for the team, and that is a great credit to you!

[@nicolasjungblut7874]

100% on this. Other channels are about "reacting to McDonald's" or "reacting to donuts". Those are too shallow. You are really doing something that's having an impact on their lifes. This is really wonderful!

[@marklar7551]

And, he is feeling what a typical school teacher feels in a classroom.

[@houndofbelfast3727]

"you all" Unfortunately, it's just Adnan doing this on his own. He's said in his pinned comment that he wishes he had help from others with these videos.

[@weakw1ll]

Right!!!!! I just recently found this channel and i regret watching the other "tribal people try" channels before this one. They ask the right questions and it really helps us and them get cultural insight.

[@weakw1ll]

W channel

[@captawesome42]

Being presented with science such as this is likely frightening for people who do not have the exposure to it so I understand and agree with not pushing it. However, I believe there is value in at least approaching the topic even if it means moving onto other things shortly thereafter. Just presenting the information as a possibility is helpful. Do not think that your efforts did not matter even if they didn't succeed in the fashion you had envisioned.

[@SebHaarfagre]

Agreed! And, for anyone else interested in Astronomy, *PLEASE* watch "Life Beyond" 1 2 and 3, they're breathtaking. Full of CGI but insanely well done. Also, Astrum is my favourite topical channel here on YT.

[@stevensprunger3422]

Yes I agree at first this information may seem overwhelming to them and may not sink in immediately but perhaps after a while as they go on through life it will slowly sinking a little bit more so it’s was not a worthless endeavor……. Also we still have to respect the beliefs the religious beliefs even though we may not agree with them…… It can’t simply be dismissed…..

[@rna8arnold]

It took centuries for European people to accept these understandings of the universe. So it takes time. Might be a good idea to get a decent telephone for them to learn to use and let them try it out. Shoukd be fun.

[@M4TCH3SM4L0N3]

​@@rna8arnoldhonestly, Islamic scientists had discovered much of what Western science now knows centuries before we did (not relativity or quantum physics, but heliocentrism, etc.). The fact that they don't know this is mostly due to western colonization and "education" that erases most of the non-European contributions to our current models.

[@PsalmS-vi8zl]

I think Parvati is a very bright young lady and asks intelligent questions. Sometimes, giving people just a few "nuggets of information" can be a great way to teach new concepts. Instead of overwhelming the student, it provokes them to want to learn more. Enjoy your channel. All the best to you all at Trybals.

[@goldenageofdinosaurs7192]

Yes, I’m very impressed with her. By the questions she asks, you can tell she’s really trying to pay attention & absorb the information.

[@Where_is_Waldo]

This reminds me of my experience in my first permanent position at a full time job. I was working at an oil change shop and I very quickly noticed that, in spite of the stereotype that men are supposed to know about cars and engines, it was no more common for men to know about cars and engines than for women to know about the subject. What was MUCH more common among men was pretending (very obviously) to know about cars and engines. Women, by contrast, usually asked intelligent questions when they didn't understand something and were never finished asking questions until they understood. That's the difference I've observed: men have more of a tendency to try to convince people that they understand things, women have more of a tendency to try to actually understand things... not a rule, just a tendency, but Parvati does seem to exemplify this tendency and it always makes me smile. I remember when they asked Parvati and her mother if men or women were better and her mother insisted that men were better. I remember thinking that the look on Parvati's mother's face suggested she was thinking along the lines of "This is a trick, you won't catch me saying things I'm not allowed to say."

[@kinagrill]

Make them make those logical steps themselves? sounds quite ideal, yes.

[@AbeYousef]

@@goldenageofdinosaurs7192 its not even the absorbing the information in my view, she's thinking critically about new beliefs, and critical thinking is a practiced skill.

[@Pagliacci_Rex]

Imagine the ideas and breakthroughs that could be just waiting for something like this.

[@JoshuaC0rbit]

One benefit of being in a tribal village is that there's probably no light pollution so perhaps an adventure with a decent telescope would be enlightening and fun.

[@liambaylis9365]

I really appreciate what you are trying to do here. One strategy might be to show microscopic footage of microorganisms moving around. It will force them to consider that not everything they see is reality. Because language can be a barrier, visuals may be a good starting point. Keep up the great work - just because you invest a lot of effort into something, and the results aren't as expected, it doesn't mean it isn't worth doing.

[@johnthompson6374]

sooo, nightmares then. you're suggesting to give them nightmares. LoL. actually that is a wonderful idea. for them to be able to look thru the microscope themselves would allow them to see just how far removed and yet connected we are all to the great expanse and to the atom. Peace/JT

[@zarasha8220]

One of the coolest things I remember in middle school was when we took a field trip to a nearby park with a pond. We each were given a little vial to fill up with water from the pond, and when we got back to school we put drops of water from our vial onto a slide & looked at it under a microscope. We got to see what kinds of microbial life was living in the pond & seeing it with our own eyes made it easier to understand the stuff in our textbook, like the different parts of the cell.

[@liambaylis9365]

@@johnthompson6374 that would be excellent. Some dirty water is often enough to see a world unbeknownst to them!

[@liambaylis9365]

@@zarasha8220 it really is a whole new world!

[@nathanpayne3729]

Totally agreed 🤙🏻

[@sabbathguy1]

Parvati in particular asked some great questions, she has a sharp mind. Even if they aren't exposed to more learning in this area I feel like these are mind-expanding concepts that will stay with them forever and if nothing else, has maybe awoken some innate curiosity and yearning for knowledge that they otherwise would not have been exposed to. Appreciate your patience and respect towards Abdul as well. You can't (nor should you try) to undo a lifetime of indoctrination. You've opened the door for them, it's up to them to step through it, if they choose (there is no right or wrong).

[@jaygatsby3039]

Muraham's curiosity honestly is very endearing. He's such a curious person, and he just wants to learn everything. And the person translating all this and teaching them, you are an excellent communicator of science and you deserve high praise.

[@shandah.9103]

I feel their discomfort myself. I got a college degree but even today, the vastness of space and the fact that we still have so much to learn is frightening. The idea that science is a language of sorts (that is a world wide language that is common to all) is a way to talk about and reflect on what God has created, is comforting to me. On the other hand as well is the microscopic world, which is also vast. I hope they know that everyone in the world struggles to think about things this big so even doctors or lawyers or engineers focus on one part and learn that part in amazing detail to be a le to help other people. Thank you for the channel and thank you to our friends for bringing us all closer together. Said with much love to you all.

[@docgonzobordel]

The Universe is a strange place indeed, we as humans, are standing between the infinite of space and the infinite of the microscopic and quantic world..

[@winniethepoohxi1896]

As others have said, purchasing a cheap microscope and some test slides or have them bring a sample would be an incredible experience for them and a pretty good way to get hands on insight into abstract topics. It may provide deeper appreciation for the space lessons in the sense that just like you can zoom in to discover a universe of the microscopic you can also magnify outwards into the infinite expanse of the galaxies. Humans only have the natural senses to perceive a tiny sliver of it without specialized tools.

[@Where_is_Waldo]

That would be very interesting. Another idea I'd like to the team take on (although it might make for a long video which I am not opposed to, just saying it would probably be long) is deep sea documentaries. There's an entire world of creatures, big and small, that are completely alien to us right here on earth. This also might get less pushback than outer space concepts while sticking to the scientific endeavor, as with your microscope idea. I'd love to see the team explore both of these ideas.

[@roachdoggjr45]

It's either a camera tube or planted by satan.

[@Where_is_Waldo]

@@roachdoggjr45 Your highly uneducated comment is so bad it's unclear. Could you explain what you even mean by "camera tube"? Do you mean video tube? Like a little TV? Also, what could you even mean by "planted by satan"? Is that to imply that microscopes are some kind of evil magic? This is hilarious and I want to know more about your completely bizarre and unfounded perspective.

[@roachdoggjr45]

@@Where_is_Waldo Some people in bible belt states in the United States have made these claims. This was pretty much a joke reference to that.

[@Where_is_Waldo]

@@roachdoggjr45 I was wondering if you were serious lol. FYI I don't know if your initial comment was removed or just hidden but I can only see it in the notification that someone else replied to the comment I replied to. I guess I wasn't the only one who thought you might be serious.

[@TheFu3lman]

I think it's important to remember that Abdul is a product of his time, and good amount of us, regardless of how opened-minded we claim to be, have had a "get off my lawn" moment at some point. It does not change the goodness of his heart or quality of his character, and given what we've come to learn about him from this channel, he's giving this whole thing a really good shot. Don't get discouraged because you feel like you've hit a bit of a brick wall. Just adapt and everything will be fine.

[@MrThomashorst]

I dont agree. I think it's not regardless ... if you are really into "open-minded" you will keep your mind open for new things ... forever. If you are getting to confident the lazyness will prevent you from learning new things. Today I learned, that we are priviliged because of all the available knowledge we take for granted or even boring when we young and tought in school ... it makes me sad seeing grown people who never thought about our solar system because they dont know it exists😪 ... the world is small ... we are small ... like the pale blue dot😔

[@haruruben]

Why is this so tense? This is “cosmic horror” they’re experiencing, when you realize we’re a spec of dust. I remember the first time I went to a planetarium when I was a kid and found this all to be terrifying

[@TheOnlyGhxst]

I see it differently, there is no "cosmic horror", but cosmic insight. But, in the end, they have a similar feeling. It's amazing to know that we, humans, are made up of the same space dust and quarks that everything else in the Universe is made of though, because in reality, we aren't much different than an entire star.

[@haruruben]

@@TheOnlyGhxst you can see how upset they are

[@NecroxProduction]

I really doubt they even understood anything on the level to have an existential crisis. They probably don't even believe any of this. The old man straight up said it.

[@haruruben]

@@NecroxProduction I remember the first time I learned about it. It was scary and unbelievable… although I was 8 years old when I first heard these ideas. They just haven’t ever received this information.

[@Goldun-nah]

It’s mind boggling. They are hearing it for the first time as grown adults. We all have grown up with this knowledge being taught to us from a young age. Even with our habituation to this knowledge, the universe becomes more incomprehensible when you think further upon it. Their reactions seem more of an incomprehensible awe than fear.

[@Ella-Is-On-Fire]

I imagine it's a lot to take in when you hear about these things for the first time. Nice work keeping it respectful. Im sure its difficult to explain such complicated things in an understandable way.

[@mrgermanvono35]

It's great seeing Parvati ask good questions. She's very inquisitive and quite sharp of mind and seems to understand things quickly. She'd make a great scientist I think. This is a lot of stuff to take in for them! Especially when they didn't grow up learning about it quite like your or I did. Showing videos that are more grounded about Earth and smaller organisms or even the human body could possibly be easier and not quite an abstract idea for them. There's definitely a lot of videos out there that also really easily explain basic concepts of physics and space like gravity.

[@erowan1389]

Adnan, you are amazing! You have spent so much time and energy on educating all of us. I appreciate all your hard work and all the money you have spent over the years! I do not think anything you have done is fruitless. It takes a long time to change a person's mind when they learn new information that is different from beliefs they have had for generations. You have given them curiousity and they will continue to hear and learn more in the future. You are brave, you are moral, and you are generous and kind. Thank you for all you have done for all of us. While I hope you continue the channel, I hope you do what makes you feel happy and restful first. Life needs to be enjoyed, not just work.

[@ryanwoolsey6972]

This is by far my favorite topic you have covered on this channel, PLEASE keep them coming….

[@glitch._]

You are planting a seed of wonder and curiosity to these people. And even if you cannot undue many years of belief, you can make a small step of progress. I am so intrigued and would love to see more if these lovely people are willing. ❤

[@alexmckee4683]

No need to undo belief. People can reconcile their beliefs with other things that they know to be true or reason about.

[@mayorsnorkum4005]

Please do not stop with your project. For those of us with no access to tribal regions, simply the interactions with the tribal people are incredibly interesting. I feel that each session is able to impart new information to the tribal people, whether they are willing to accept that information fully or not. Thus, I think your project is interesting from both ends. The reactions of the tribal people to this new information, and the interesting insights that those people sometimes have to things many of take for granted. Many thanks for this channel.

[@ralfsstuff]

That is, among other things, what Religion can do to people. I really felt it when Abdul (I'm not familiar with their names yet) said Muslims were threatened by science as it clashes with their beliefs. It's disheartening to see science be made out to be a threat. Even as an Atheist I'd tell them God created everything including scientific discoveries, if it ment people weren't as reluctant to learn out of fear... .

[@TRYBALS]

I agree, do you understand Urdu?

[@emilyflotilla931]

@Shakeel Ali Thank you for your explanation!

[@aileenhampton6911]

God has a plan for the history of the world... He controls what is discovered, when. And then... sometimes things get forgotten for an eon or two.

[@sst710]

Which is a crazy thing to hear considering modern science is built upon the discoveries during the Golden Age of Islam. The scientific method was basically invented during that time. One of the main problems with religion is it can easily be distorted to manipulate people.

[@BlackKiryuu]

Abdul has no idea about real Islam. Science and Islam go hand in hand. Everything has been made my God and science is the way to prove it.

[@Where_is_Waldo]

Abdul, I'd like to thank you and express my respect for you. Many people where I live believe that science contradicts their view of christianity and, because of this, they claim that the scientific facts are not scientific in an effort to discredit scientists. I commend your willingness to learn science even when it might be difficult to reconcile that understanding with your beliefs.

[@FlareStarchild]

My response to his statement that some Muslims believe Science's goal is being against God and to prove all belief wrong is not a valid way of looking at it because we are all looking for answers and what would have been primitive people trying to understand their world, has now changed into a way to try to understand our world. We see it as we do when we existed with only our primary senses. But now we realized we get more accurate results that you can objectively show someone the objective truth, (truth regardless of belief) of that thing, when we follow a certain set of rules; Science. Science and faith/belief are understanding methods from opposite ends of the list of how to understand things, trying to meet in the middle and can't see they are the same type of attempted understanding. One is just objectively true (reproducible results and logical breakdown from the inside out as Science) and the other is still our more primitive understanding's personal truth (belief on why things are the way they are from the outside in. ie. A god or god's must exist because I exist and I can create things so that must be how I came to be.)

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

It's like these people prefer to worship the shadow of things instead of leaving the cave and finding out what casts that shadow.

[@lavendergal2508]

Isn’t Parvati Simply stunning? Just a lovely soul.

[@cloudy2110]

Parvati is asking the real good questions!😊

[@WanderIndiana]

Thank you for another educational and entertaining video. Your hard work and effort is evident. I can’t imagine the challenges faced producing this kind of content and appreciate the work, and reactions, from all involved.

[@kmo2959]

Oh dear Adnan, you really have a hard nut to crack in Abdul! It's up to him to come around in his belief of what you have taught him. If he continues in his way, what you did is not for naught. I think Parvati was becoming overwhelmed with the information, it's a lot for her and the other 2 to take in...esp. when you never had a clue in your whole life what is/was going on outside of your own "world". It would be like trying to teach a newborn infant calculus. Please don't feel disheartened, if you didn't reach them as you had hoped, you def. reached a big audience out here with those who (like myself) had forgotten things we were taught so many years ago as children. I personally thank you for your effort and time in producing this video. The folks there might not get it, but you have planted a seed. Keep watering and let's see what grows!

[@graythebruceii]

I love what you're doing with this channel. Among other things, it shows a public who might not have teaching experience how much patience teaching requires, even with engaged adults. I hope you won't be too disheartened by how much it takes to get a fraction of a result, but I've been there in classroom settings. In case it helps, you have impacts on people other than the participants on screen: Your viewers get to identify with people from cultures unlike their own, get to see stereotypes defused with clearly unscripted interactions, get to see what a real learning experience looks like, as opposed to what they look like in movies, and get to identify with and root for people half a world away from them.

[@arjay9745]

I absolutely loved this video. I understand it must be a monumental task and probably demotivating to work so hard and end up with a lot of footage of people who seem lost and uncomprehending. But never in my life have I seen anything like it. And that moment when Parvati asks "why don't we feel it rotating?"--curiosity in its purest form--is the sort of stuff I used to spend hours wondering about as a kid: if I met someone who had never heard the things I learned in science class, how would they react? I feel like it's only a matter of time before some big name discovers what you are doing here and you become a very famous person.

[@dominikwalker6608]

Videos like this are very valuable, not just for the individuals learning, but for viewers who might have a difficult time understanding other population's / culture's perspectives on things. I was taught all this stuff at a very young age in school, so this is intrinsic knowledge to me and part of how my perspective on the world and existence was established. I find it difficult to imagine myself in the shoes of someone who didn't know this information because it so drastically changes my understanding of the world at a foundational level I genuinely can't imagine. It is great to see these people's perspectives and what questions they raise.

[@steveurquell3031]

Its not a good day until Trybals posts. Cheers Adnan

[@bobbiejojackson9448]

Oh my dear brother Adnan. I hope this doesn't sound like I'm being forward. I am a very happily married woman, but I truly wish that I could somehow reach through the screen and give you a (brotherly) hug. 🤗 I wish you wouldn't feel so defeated. This is not on you brother. You've tried your very best to help them understand something that you believe is important, but in order to be a successful teacher, one must have willing and eager students. I can see by the expressions on their faces that they want to please you because they have such affection and respect for you. But as wise as each of them are, it's really just over their heads. Space is one of THE most complex subjects there is to teach and for some, people,even harder to understand. Having had such limited formal educations and being steeped in the lore that their ancestors have passed on to them through the generations, is very difficult for them to let go of or challenge. I feel as though Parvhati would be capable of understanding some things eventually, but when you think about it, she just recently learned that there is only one moon for the entire planet and I'm not really sure if even now she believes that. She also probably gets a lot of flack when she goes home and tries to explain it all in her own words to people when she doesn't even have the visual proof that she's been given here to show them. I wouldn't doubt that she doesn't even bring it up to friends or family in her village anymore, because they probably call her silly for believing what they consider to be nothing more than fairy tales. If I might make a few suggestions... they all love Bob Ross, Mr. Rogers, Michael Jackson and many of the musical performances you've shown them, but I've noticed they lose focus when it's music with a world message that is metaphorical. Quite a few of the more recent music videos you've shown them more recently, seem to go over their heads as well. These are very simple kind and loving people and while I believe Muraham has an easier time understanding metaphors, I really don't think the others do. I think they'd enjoy being artistic like following along with more Bob Ross paint lessons or maybe a video on sculpting with no fire modeling clay where they could make pieces to take home and keep or give as gifts. I think they'd enjoy (especially Abdul) seeing different architecture from famous mosques, churches, cathedrals. I think the key here is to find the type of content that they seem to gravitate toward. I don't think they want a formal education. I really think they'd very much prefer to be entertained. Don't beat yourself up, brother. You've done an extremely admirable job here. It's not because you haven't done it right or enough. I just don't believe that science is something they really have much interest in. I'll pray for you, my brother. For peace of mind and the self-satisfaction that you surely gave it your all. You know the old saying... you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink. You led well my friend. Very well, indeed. 💛🕊🙏🏻⭐️

[@fuffy442]

As I watch these videos I feel such sadness that, not too many centuries ago, this culture was a world leader in science and education. So many years lost to religion's suppression of human intellect. I applaud your efforts.

[@ITPalGame]

Certain religious ideas... When ever a statement is made about nature in the Hebrew scripture, it is always proven to be true. "the earth hangs on nothing" "the earth goes round in a circuit (or is round)" Etc

[@ire1398]

Islamic scholars are the only reason we in the modern world even know about the Roman Empire. In medieval times the leaders quashed information about them and even destroyed artifacts they thought were “obscene”.

[@Luke14616]

I think what you are doing here is awesome. keep up the good work!

[@louisleroux3556]

It's an excellent video, thank you, the disconnect between beliefs and what can be observed and proven causes a lot of tension, but I hope through discussion many can come to terms with it

[@neonmajora8454]

Louis le Roux Yeah it's sad to see how belief can prevent people from understanding things and even cause them to get upset over scientific research that is ultimately beneficial

[@hopenotfound1675]

parvati asking all the good questions

[@joshuaciresoli2927]

@TRYBALS I truly love this series and education is very difficult for the reason you described. However, you are doing a tremendous service to Abdul, Muharam and Pavarti. This is a ton of information to digest for your three students and this may have been the first time they have ever learned this. Even though we here get taught these things, it is over the course of several years and we still don't remember everything. Abdul was very closed at first, but I understand where he is coming from. The religious background he comes from is in conflict with what you are trying to teach him and he was resistant to engaging the subject at first, but he did make some engagement as you progressed with the curriculum. Mrs. Bheel did engage but she was overwhelmed. She is very smart and just needs time to process this information. She engaged with you and asked questions about the material, which is very good to see. As for Muharam, he was very contemplative in his reaction from the start. Abdul and Mrs. Bheel came around to the same reaction. It is hard to teach, but teachers have an obligation to educate. All you can do is offer the chance to learn. The decisions to learn lie with the students.

[@kinagrill]

And there was certain places you could see him go 'yes Venus is so hot that nothing can live there' and it made sense with his religious teachings, and it's quite true. we have yet to find life anywhere else in the whole wide universe. we are a very lonely planet where life has, quite miraculously so, popped up and is very diverse - from humanity, to various kinds of horses, tons of different species of fish, birds, etc. etc. etc.

[@realandrewhatfield]

Great job covering so much information in such a short period of time!! I think Mr. Rind is amazing, and always appreciate his sharing. There are many people in the US who struggle to separate science and religion, so this is not unique to any culture. If God decides something to be secret, scientists will not find it no matter how hard we try. In the mean time we will keep being human and exploring the unknown so we can see more of God's beautiful creations! Nothing scientists' learn takes away from the glory of God, it only glorifies his majesty. In my opinion, anyone who thinks or teaches otherwise is trying to subjugate people by keeping them less educated. The foundations of the modern worlds' math and science were laid in the your part of the world; imagine what the challenges engineers in their time had to overcome! Great job!!

[@ThePizzaGoblin]

While I am atheist, I do not believe science is a threat to religion. If God exists, God created the rules and laws that govern the universe. He (or she) created gravity and time, which creates all things. He created life and DNA and the ability for life to change and grow.

[@CeleWolf]

Agreed. All the religious people I know accept science like the rest of us.

[@snailsail4405]

It's mostly a problem to people that follow strict and specific beliefs rather than those who are flexible in that regard. Extremism is a wide problem

[@meowateyourchips7417]

It’s really what you make of it. I’m a deist. We accept the concept of a creator but we reject religions. The incomprehensible complexity and vastness of the universe to me is by design. The universe is perfectly balanced. Being in awe of it is more than enough for me. Feeling small and insignificant can also yield positive outcomes. You start to let go of small things you hold onto because it doesn’t matter.

[@hermaeusmora424]

Well it depends. It is a threat to those that take scripture literal. Science proved religions wrong over and over and the only way these religions stayed relevant is to "condemn" all these passages that in my opinion were meant to be taken literal as mere metaphors in order to still conform with reality. Thus the entire creation story in the bible needs to be a metaphor. Adam and Eve? Metaphor. Original Sin? Well... now it gets tricky, because Christians surely would not say that Jesus died on the cross for a metaphor. And this is for religions that have the luxury to have a god of the gaps that can recede to outside our observation, but what about gods that arent omni? Like Thor. While it wasn't science that ended Nordic mythology, if it had prevailed science would have killed it.

[@VoidDragon82]

A number of years ago I had a similar conversation with my mum. My mum is very educated, we live in England so the tv/internet is readily accessible and, the main factor, she is still curious. She struggled, rightly so, with the concept of how evolution works. I broke it down for her, we watched documentaries and talked about it. Patience and time is all that’s needed to chance your perspective. Thank you so much for your hard work.

[@fynntasticmovienight]

I think the language barrier might also be tough for them watching these videos. I still enjoyed watching this tho!! And, Im not a religious person, but as with religions in the west: i like learning about them. Personally, I would love to hear more opinions and talks from their cultural & religious perspectives. I know that might be very difficult and maybe not respectful.. But I would personally be very interested to learn more about their opinions about the good & bad parts of their lives, politics, culture, etc. I understand these videos are tough, so make sure to focus on things that can be easily produced as well (maybe them reacting to asian or middle eastern cultural things?)

[@DaBaSoftware]

Your work is amazing!!

[@derekbowbrick6233]

You need to find a way of getting a telescope up to these people so they can explore the night sky Really good video and nice presentation.

[@eddeh0772]

The host is so good at explaining this stuff, and shows a clear understanding beyond just relaying what’s being said in the video they’re already watching. A good teacher. Fascinating video, cheers!

[@Kambrius70]

Maybe you should do a series for them which shows the advances in science that Muslims brought about throughout history.

[@DaleAnnHarsh]

I grew up with science fiction movies about invasions from space and went through 12 years of public education where they introduced us to all of this gradually. I can't even imagine what it must be like to have it dropped in your lap all at once. And then asked for your opinion about it! I would hope I would be as open minded about learning what the panelists thought about what they'd just seen, and why, and hear their theories on how everything works as they were about viewing that video and listening to everything the moderator had to tell them.

[@garycarter6773]

Thank you sir. I appreciate all of your hard work. This knowledge can be overwhelming to anyone especially if it challenges all you have ever known. You expose them to knowledge but don't berate them for their ignorance. There are many people in the United States who are willfully ignorant. Again, thank you for your work, we appreciate it and appreciate our new friends and their beliefs/opinions. Hope you continue. :)

[@kinagrill]

Like flat earthers.

[@StorytellerDan]

Once again - Excellent video! If only more people out there were willing to listen & learn as calmly.

[@joyceetter8643]

I expect this is difficult for them to take in. The wiser elder man can understand but wants to stay with his faith. It is no different than some Christians who take the Bible literally and believe the earth is only 7000 years old.

[@jessbellis9510]

The difference is that this is the first time they've been exposed to such ideas, and are much later on in life than the evangelical christians who were taught this stuff in school and have access to the internet. Creationists are far worse because despite having all information at their fingertips, they've chosen lies & ignorance instead.

[@Mr_Spock512]

He's not wise at all ... he feels threatened by this science because it might erode his status as a "wise" elder in the tribe. His "know-it-all" attitude says a lot about him.

[@spartantkd1970]

I absolutely love this and all videos to date. Best wishes to all involved with this and other videos. Kevin (Sheffield, UK)

[@unicyclist97]

It's such a shame that belief in gods stops people from being curious. It's like they can investigate up to an arbitrary line, and everything after that line is "god", even though people who move past that line never find any gods either.

[@ecb1979]

I think this is fascinating. Don't give up hope. I used to find this concept boring at one point and now I eat it up because my understanding grew.

[@Entropy825]

This is an amazing thing you're doing. You have put so much thought and effort into it.

[@zihuanena]

To the creator … it is almost impossible to get a religious mind to become scientifically open … but it is possible. Don’t give up on explaining logic. I appreciate you and your respectful loving nature in teaching. I thank you and support your effort. ❤️‍🔥

[@constantdoodle32]

No it's not impossible. I think what you're referring to is "extreme fundamentalism". Plenty of people are scientist and still hold fast to a religion. I think it's hard to get a stubborn person to be open minded no matter their ideology

[@nachgeben]

@@constantdoodle32 These are people to whom this information has never been presented to them. Imagine if you were told that in reality, everything you know as fact was a lie, and were given hard, cold facts to show there's an eldritch god in the sun and space is actually an ocean, and actually all those shuttle crashes you heard about once from someone passing through your town were because they were bouncing off surface tension, not the atmosphere like you'd been told, and it's a vast and lively ocean up there. Something really wild, with photos, videos, countless essays and reports and research papers. You wouldn't know what to do with yourself. No one would.

[@NecroxProduction]

@@constantdoodle32 he said "almost"

[@theofficialgreenkane]

Some don’t like it because it’s proving their beliefs to be false. And humans like to believe in something. As science has evolved, it’s proving old ideologies incorrect- A hard pill to swallow.

[@raquellove5735]

¡Hola! :) I don't usually write on KZbin. I am an atheist. Please don't ever leave this beautiful project. I find it amazing all that you do, teaching the perspective of other cultures to other people like me, and vice versa. We cannot forget that this is a context of tribal peoples who are often very spiritual and mystical. Sometimes, that also has its charm in a good way. No one has the absolute truth, although I think the only thing that can be proven is materialistic science. But we have to understand that the world is made up of people who are different from us, as long as they respect the rest. I find them adorable when they talk about their ideas. We can also learn a lot of values from them. Nobody is perfect. We are all human and we make mistakes, we feel, we cry and we live joy to the fullest. I think it's a lot of information for them 😅Because we break their schemes towards life and the world, but it's very good that you teach them all that. It can be improved with more material, but it's also money. I've shown your KZbin to a lot of people who I hope will follow you. I love everyone's wisdom, especially Muharam. He seems like a good person and a kind hearted man. It is said that "The face is the mirror of the soul" and he has a very calm and sweet face. I love when he gesticulates with the videos, he is very heartfelt. He is very understanding and open-minded. I would love to meet him in person, hehe 🥰 Oh! I am working with teenagers in an academy to reinforce their studies, and I show them your videos. They love them, because it is something different from what they see in their environment. A hug from Galicia (north of Spain) 🤗

[@SwordTune]

18:36 Love that this guy is pointing how all the hard work it takes to package knowledge into easily consumable formats.

[@MarkMeadows90]

I like further educating my mind with science. I come from a Christian family, but I don't let Christian beliefs get in my way. I stand true to my beliefs and such, but science is a good learning tool for many.

[@sabbathguy1]

There's no reason why your faith and science can't co-exist, especially if you think about Science as an observational and working understanding of God's creation, a tool that has incredible power to help humankind

[@MarkMeadows90]

@@sabbathguy1 I don't let my faith get in the way. Doesn't matter to me.

[@CStone-xn4oy]

Science is the ceaseless effort to explain God's creation in terms compatible with human understanding. Science and Faith do not need to conflict.

[@MarkMeadows90]

@@CStone-xn4oy understandable

[@CStone-xn4oy]

@Remy If you read the Creation story, there are a lot of literary devices that suggest it is a parable, not an actual historical account. A lot of details are glossed over and there is a lot of symbolism. Read the beginning of Genesis and then read...say, accounts of Abraham's life late in Genesis and you will notice how different the writing style is even though its theoretically the same author. If you think about it a bronze age human would have no idea what God was talking about if God were to explain exactly how He created the Universe. Shoot even people today aren't entirely sure on all the details and there is always the slight chance that we got something very wrong (it wouldn't be the first time). If evolution and the Big Bang are indeed factual (and they are heavily supported by evidence) then that means that these were methods that God used to create the Universe and the creation story in Genesis was indeed a parable meant to simplify some extremely complex things to people who were not even remotely capable of comprehending the details. After all the focus of Genesis is on God's promises to Abraham and his descendants. The fact that God created the Universe is only a fraction of that book.

[@shwethakishore]

This is one of the most beautiful channels ever ! Thank you ! I'm going to share this with all my friends in India ! ❤

[@m0002856]

I was really inspired by Parvati's question in the beginning where she asked why the Earth goes around the sun. I have a good video that is a school demonstration of gravity and orbiting objects that I would love to share. It talks about some very advanced topics like space-time, but that stuff can be ignored if it is not understood. The important thing is that the video shows a marble being released and how it orbits around a heavy object. I think it can help answer her question. If I could be allowed, I would like to share the video with you! It's just a KZbin link, but I don't want to go posting links to another video randomly without asking first.

[@m0002856]

Here is the video in question in case anybody is curious. kzbin.info/www/bejne/g4W8Yn6gmpWsgsk&ab_channel=apbiolghs

[@LinchpinPL]

there is a cool physical demonstration of gravity - a whirlpool-shaped surface you can drop marbles onto which then orbit the central hole much like a planet or asteroid would orbit a sun or another massive celestial body, before falling into it. It also explains the concept of gravity well.

[@FlareStarchild]

@@LinchpinPL it is better but still not perfect. Explaining a 4d force with a 3d surface is better than nothing though.

[@kinagrill]

I recall back in my early schooldays, i was explained that the sun is so big that it makes the earth spin around it, just like how the earth is so big that it makes the moon spin around IT, and in turn a human is so tiny that we stand upright no matter where on earth we are, because we are always on the surface of it and get pulled down towards it. It really helped me understand as a kid at least the basics of what gravity was and how stuff spun around eacohther in space. Taking a big thing like the sun and comparing it to the earth and moon just clicked for me.

[@rv3superstar]

This was a very ambitious video; you tackled with some subjects within that topic that requires a good level of science literacy. It's also risky because if clashes with some of their belief. And it's important to also keep in mind that this topic does not even bear consensus in any society. I personally think there should have been a build up to this video about the various science involved into explaining the solar system. It's a very hard subject to discuss. (Also the source material had inaccuracies; for example; the number of star with planets; which is most likely all of them.) Keep the great work!

[@Azradok]

Those are very real images of a Mercury transit across the Sun, and those are radar images of the surface of Venus.

[@goldenageofdinosaurs7192]

Was looking for this. I was a little frustrated when he said that.

[@ontariobuds]

Parvati is my favourite. I wish her all the best.

[@AlyenaMango]

I have a suggestion for a video that would combine this space series with your other music video reaction content. Chris Hadfield, a canadian astronaut, recorded a music video covering "Space Oddity" while he was on the International Space Station. I think it would be intersting to show them footage of someone in weightlessness and give them an impression of how people are living on the space station. I'm enjoying your videos, keep it up! :)

[@lss74]

We so so appreciate and respect you. Thank you for your hard work ❤

[@peppernation9213]

Science and religion usually don’t mix. It is what it is. I think it’s good that you presented what scientists call facts to these people. If they don’t want to embrace it that’s OK too. Also I would like to add that watching your video was not only entertaining but educational. I’m sure I learned a lot of the stuff in school but most of it I forgot so this was like a refresher course for me. Ty

[@vinnie4v277]

They can mix, new knowledge about solar system "What if god created those planets, instead of only our earth."

[@doc5201]

I love this channel I love hearing all other views of people's lives. It opens your mind and enlightens. A person should never stop learning even if you have a different view on something. You never know how something could change you.

[@PaulEcosse]

Please reassure Abdul that science does not negate his faith. If one has faith - I would imagine - that very little can be done to damage that faith. He is simply being given the information, it's up to him what he does with it.

[@TRYBALS]

I talked to him about a lot before playing him this video. I even quoted a saying from the prophet where he said to the farmers of not having enough knowledge about the business of the world as religion is spiritual. And of course I told him about Ibn Al Haitham and Al Khwarzmi due to whom we have algorithms and optical knowledge today. I made sure he can be as much open as to learning as he can be. And I think he was during the whole video but I honestly don't know what happened in the end

[@TheKelJacob]

@@TRYBALS I think it's very overwhelming, particularly when you're older, to take in such vast concepts and not be scared that you didn't have the information earlier. Being scared makes someone cling to what they already believe.

[@nuusgtattoo25]

@@TheKelJacob agreed. It can be frightening, disorienting, and frankly embarrassing to come to terms with the fact that one might have a poor understanding of concepts others find fundamental.

[@amorky8391]

@@TRYBALS I think it is probably the timeline science puts to everything. Here where I live in the US we have a lot of people who believe the earth and solar system are only close to 7000 years old due to bible timelines figured out by scholars. So to say the universe is billions of years old is a direct contradiction. So lots of people here just think science is completely wrong on this kind of thing.

[@emilyflotilla931]

@@amorky8391 And then there's the Flat Earthers! Oi!

[@parkerxgps]

Thank you for sharing knowledge. No matter how well received, it can't hurt.

[@curtiswfranks]

"But what makes it go around the Sun?" That is such a good question. She blows my mind all the time.

[@LinchpinPL]

that is really a very good question and quite hard to explain. I'm not even sure I understand it correctly. I think it has to do with the original rotation of the protoplanetary disc.

[@curtiswfranks]

@@LinchpinPL: It does. The particles had some initial momentum and they retained that as the consolidation was underway. Gravitation is basically just continuously redirecting it. If you imagine tying a string to a stone and a swinging it around in circles, then you can see that in order to move in a circle at all, there must be an inward force. For the stone, it is tension in the string. For a planet, it is gravitation from the Sun. Roughly. There are complicating details such as the fact that planets orbit in elliptical paths around the solar system's barycenter. Moreover, GR is a more-correct description of what is happening. But the basic Newtonian model is enough if one wants to gain a basic understanding. The collapse from dust into a solar system preserved the angular momentum of the original dust cloud.

[@FranticWildcatPaws]

@@LinchpinPL simply - orbiting is constant falling, but the ground moves out of your way, because earth is round, and you're falling forever in a circular fashion. All you need is enough speed and no atmosphere to slow you down. And that's how everything in the Universe works.

[@unicyclist97]

I think she wanted to know what keeps it moving. So the explanation is that it was already moving while it formed, and there's nothing in space to slow it down: no resistance.

[@curtiswfranks]

@@unicyclist97: Oh, that is, if anything, an even better question because the answer distinguishes between Aristotlean motion (which has a natural tendency to slow down for no reason) and Newtonian motion (which obeys Newton's First Law of Motion).

[@TrashParty]

I like how the freedom of knowledge and thought is a threat to these people.

[@maryannashenfelder5513]

I truly enjoy watching her!!! She really listened and I think enjoying the video!! Very sweet gal!

[@HenryBloggit]

You should show them one of those videos where the camera zooms out from an atom to the Earth to the solar system to the Milky Way to the local group and all the way to the cosmic filament. I think they’d find the scale of the universe really amazing, I sure do.

[@aphishoutofwater7019]

I would like to hear more from Abdul Aziz Rind about why this type of knowledge is a threat. This isn't a mean comment, I am genuinely curious. Anyways, this was an ambitious topic to portray in understandable terms, I hope to see more like this, if a little less abstract to their current understanding. Keep up the good work guys, I thoroughly enjoy your content.

[@kinagrill]

Same here, actually.

[@adamgentile7953]

From what I could gather he mentioned that God has intentially kept secrets from humanity, and then his next sentence he mentioned that eventually these scientists will contine and eventually find God which might be the problem. Either way I'm with you and would love to hear the explanation.

[@aphishoutofwater7019]

@@adamgentile7953 oh that makes sense. Thanks ^^

[@nathanpayne3729]

I adore everyone in these videos, beautiful and thank you 🥲

[@zarasha8220]

It’s heartbreaking to see how damaging religion can be for so many people around the world, to the point where some flat out reject science & everything we’ve discovered with it. From astronomy to modern medicine, there are people who refuse to acknowledge the science behind it, and as one gentleman in the video said: it’s a “threat” to their religion. Have they considered the possibility that their god gave humans the tools of the scientific method & brains smart enough to use those tools to learn about and explore our universe?

[@txrick4879]

As amateur astronomer I suggest you show them the planets through a good sized telescope so they can see for themselves.

[@george-8043]

To the creator of this channel: Great video, you must be a very intelligent and hard working person to do something like this. I loved it and I liked how you said God created all of it. God is a mathematician they say! I also liked how you talked about the ancient Islamic Golden age, when such observations weren't a threat. Peace to you friend. I loved listening to their opinions and enjoy hearing each and every one of their opinions, beliefs and experiences.

[@MatthewMoller-gj1ht]

Sir, don’t give up. Keep presenting new science, music, and other material. You are doing a great educational service; one seed can grow an entire forest…😊

[@cmmn_crdnl]

Science = How God = Why

[@acarvajal23]

Since I discovered this channel, I find deeply fascinating to see the expression and reaction of these tribal people with their curious eyes and minds, with so much gained knowledge at their reach. It's like finding this knowledge myself for the first time when I was a child.

[@johnwaters8640]

Many of the concepts in these videos are too complicated for people who have never been exposed to basic principles. I appreciate the effort put into the videos, but you're like a highschool teacher, trying to teach highschool level science, to elementary level students. It's too much for them to take in all at once, without feeling like they should give up.

[@f.u.spammers3846]

They get a lot of words like 'nitrogen' without really knowing and understanding what an atom is, or how a helium atom is different from a gold one.

[@meowateyourchips7417]

Yeah, I don't think they even understand gravity and therefore, they didn't understand the sun's gravitational force and how mass creates gravity.

[@FranticWildcatPaws]

But don't all people in India understand English a little bit, because of colonialism? I always wonder

[@meowateyourchips7417]

@@FranticWildcatPaws They are from Pakistan. Not India. And in India, there are still many poor and uneducated people. They don't normally know English except for a couple of words. Some can''t even read and write in their own native language.

[@FranticWildcatPaws]

@@meowateyourchips7417 Ok, my bad. Thanks

[@kaseymeier5944]

Adnan, you truly have a gift for teaching. 🥰

[@winniethepoohxi1896]

I think it would be very worth showing them the James Webb telescope and the images that came out.

[@marielucier7982]

Remember long ago in Europe (I forget who it was) trying to convince everyone the earth was round and that the earth rotated around the sun.

[@oNobodyo]

As always, powerful content.

[@NJTRAF]

I’ve just stumbled across this series and, as a Westerner (British) it’s still mind boggling to me, someone who was raised with all of this information, who studied the solar system and space and still retains a fascination to this day at nearly 40 years old… so for these people who haven’t learned about it, weren’t raised with it, haven’t studied it it must be so confusing for them, particularly when they’ve been raised with differing belief systems (not just religious but overall how the world works, what stars mean etc.) It’s incredibly ambitious to try, and I completely understand why you would find it difficult to carry on with the series, but hats off to you for trying

[@SherriLyle80s]

It seems like he is battling his beliefs with science and truth. Muslims were the best science and mathematicians and much was lost from the Great Library of Alexander. Islam was at peace with knowing both wisdom and belief could co-exist so I hope he can also come to terms with that in the future.

[@hdufort]

Alexandria, Baghdad, Cordoba used to be great centers of knowledge, indeed.

[@hdufort]

Suggestion. Teach them the life of the great Muslim astronomers. Most of the brightest stars in the sky bear arabic names, and it's no coincidence. Also, the Beit Al-Hikma are among the oldest universities of the world. They helped bring progress in medicine, botany, astronomy, chemistry, etc.

[@manna6618]

I don't think it's a strictly Muslim thing...I think it's a religious thing. Even in Western countries with Christian beliefs the 'proper' answer is God made it. No the dinosaurs didn't exist, no we didn't evolve from ape like species, no the Big Bang didn't happen...God made it. It's hard to find a religion that isn't this way. He is just strictly religious, which means anything other than God made it is blasphemy. :/

[@meropemerope6096]

Why saying "Muslims" ? They were arabs or native North Africans, don't mix ethnicities and religions, you don't know if they were religious (it's really dangerous doing that). Plus, just to stay historically true, the Great library of Alexadria had the much destroying and his books being burned by the Islamic Armies that conquested Alexandria, the commander told his subordinates to burn the books cause they were haram (sinful) but it seems(not sure) that he secretly sold some of them on the black market that arrived to Byzantine...All of this just to say that the principal problem here is not "if religions and science can coexist", obviously they can coexist if everyone ignores "the scientific parts" of Holy Books, cause those parts are Obviously always bullshit. In the last centuries muslims had concentrated in focusing on what the Quran says about "science" and... sorry...but it says that the Earth is flat, the Moon is hanged and that the Sun is brought on the shoulders of Allah...so...well...not so much scientific. The thing is religious people should return to the time of "who gives a fudge on what's written on the Qur'an, i just think a Creator exists"...but apparently such time is not now 💀💀💀💀

[@Seek1878]

There was once an Islamic golden age, but a lot of that ended when religious extremists saw it as a threat to religion. Watch Neil DeGrasse Tyson's presentation on where Islamic history went wrong.

[@matthew6427]

This shows exactly why I love space. It's impossible to understand the scale, the complexity, and we still don't know a whole lot about it. It breaks your mind to try and imagine billions of anything, how many miles in a lightyear, etc. I absolutely love this video ✌️

[@4424673]

Show them the location they're in on Google maps, and zoom out, then, show them google earth!!!!

[@vickywhitesell7482]

Can you imagine what kind of a response they get when they tell the village what they learned today! And the responses of all the info of these educational videos. Reminds me of Platos Cave

[@sagnhill]

It is a shame how a persons religion will keep them perpetually in the dark.

[@f.u.spammers3846]

That's what religion is FOR.

[@mikehamelin7520]

this was very interesting to see. you are taking hard concepts and bringing it to tribal people. you must have blown their minds. I have enjoyed this series a lot

[@Regnilse]

Perhaps you could get show them the planets through a telescope, there's nothing like seeing Saturn with your own eyes. They might be able to see a pass over of the ISS some night.

[@kapitankrunch3]

Your work here is incredible. You are opening their minds to something bigger, and like another commenter stated, "they'll never look at the night sky the same way again." You are spreading scientific education to those who may not have heard of more planets than our own. Thank you for your work. Don't give up. Peace be with you.

[@TRYBALS]

You are going too fast with throwing all this complex information!!! Note: The first time Parvati learnt about Earth rotating and that the sun and moon were single bodies was during the Night wish reaction. I asked Abdul about his views on if the Earth is flat or a sphere during Aurora's reaction video. The video you just saw doesn't include me quoting a Muslim cleric here known as Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza who tries people to understand that both science and spirituality are too different subjects. I talked about Moore's law with a demo and about Muslim scientists due to which we have better understanding of algorithms and optics today with both Abdul and Muharam. I worked for four days just to record these videos but there is no way I can or should show everything here. It's been months I have worked slow and slow just because they can understand better. According to any youtuber of the world I may be the stupidest person not to make a video on JWST. But, we don't do that on this channel. We don't follow trends but have a higher purpose here. Hope you understand, I'm trying! Trying my bests regardless of no knowledge about space.

[@winniethepoohxi1896]

JWST is not really a trend its a milestone technological accomplishment and for that matter I don't think any of your rival channels have even covered the recent images (one channel used mislabeled older images). I don't know how you can say something at the cutting edge of search for alien life, astrophysics, and engineering is just a trend. Also parker solar probe gives us direct footage from within the suns carona. Incredible footage if you haven't seen it.

[@TRYBALS]

@@winniethepoohxi1896 I'm sorry if my English is that bad but what I meant was I have never featured anything just because it was hot topic.

[@winniethepoohxi1896]

@@TRYBALS some things are a hot topic because they are inherently remarkable. It doesn’t make sense to omit things like that just because it’s popular. If aliens arrived on earth it would no doubt be popular but still worth covering.

[@kevinquintana2647]

@@winniethepoohxi1896 What you suggest may be at the cutting edge of science, but I feel it would be too early to show them that.

[@pen1208]

Your dedication and hard work are truly commendable. Even when faced with challenges, your commitment to teaching shines through. Remember that every effort you put into creating educational content has an impact, even if it might not be immediately visible. Keep pushing forward, and know that your work matters. You may never know the seed you plant in someone's head. This is how I live my life, to be honest. I try to do my best to teach others and be as nice as I can be at all times. Even a simple smile can brighten someone's day. Sometimes we just never know. Same with my political commentary on social media. It isn't always for whom I am speaking, but for others who may read and see the points I make that cannot be refuted and countered with anything. That, in turn, accomplishes what I set out for. Every person here had a reaction, which was quite noticeable. However, I understand the need to balance the interests of the participants, as they are also important and a large part of the channel. I wholeheartedly appreciate your additional efforts to be more specific and provide more detailed understandings of various topics. It's important to remember that this knowledge was not acquired quickly over the years, especially in comparison to any religious beliefs. In my opinion, no matter how far back we look into the past, we can never rewind far enough to see the very beginning. For instance, what existed before the "beginning"? Once that is answered, what was before that? It's a paradox that we may never fully comprehend, in my opinion.

[@_GiGiBloom_]

Fantastic job teaching Adnan, You’re a good teacher! I understand what Abdul is saying but the Quran teaches science, so I’m confused. I think they are all interested, it’s just confusing to them because they’ve had a certain belief their whole life, it’s a lot to take in for them I think. I like that Parvati is asking questions, I think she wants to understand it, it’s just hard for her to conceptualize what you’re showing her. Don’t get discouraged, you’re doing great and we all love them and you and appreciate all of your efforts and hard work! (Break out the wax lips, see if that will lighten the mood lol)

[@elysehfm8797]

🤣

[@_GiGiBloom_]

@@elysehfm8797 I had sent a bunch of wax lips in my package to them 😂

[@elysehfm8797]

@@_GiGiBloom_, I was laughing at your original comment, but now it looks like I'm laughing at your very normal and helpful comment. Can't wait to see the wax lips video! Very cool. 😉

[@_GiGiBloom_]

@@elysehfm8797 oh 😂 I like third place lol there probably won’t be a wax lips video, I was hoping to see all the different candies and foods I had sent but it’s ok, I sent them for them to enjoy, I hope they did! I sent the wax bottles with the juice too and some other old school candy and sent pictures so he knew what they were. I think the kids would love them too

[@elysehfm8797]

@@_GiGiBloom_, oh no! Why do you think there WON'T be wax lips and other candies videos? I'd really enjoy that. I think the kids would love the wax lips. I know they used to crack me up! Old school candy is the best! Anyway, I hope Adnan makes those videos if he's up to it. Thanks for your generosity!

[@thajarin]

This video contains a lot of information that need a great deal of prerequisite information to be able to understand....

[@Erizedd]

By now this is going to sound like a broken record, but what you're doing with your channel in trying to educate these people on science and encourage their curiosity is an incredibly commendable and ambitious thing. I can imagine it can become incredibly disheartening, but I truly hope you don't give up on it. That being said, I also think you should take care not to burn yourself out with your desire for this - it's important to take a break every now and again and, as some others have suggested, focus on some more light-hearted topics. Especially as this will also give the people you're teaching a chance to digest what they've been told a little more; if you try to teach them too much, too soon, it can become overwhelming and hard to process new information when they're still coming to terms with previous things you've told them. Another thing you could try is searching out other tribal people who may be more eager or open-minded to learn, especially younger people who may in turn try to educate others, so you could see your efforts bearing more fruit in future. I want to reiterate that what you're doing is something really special, and unique in the world of 'reactions'. What other channels do often takes very little effort in simply showing people and filming the reaction, whereas you do the research and put in the time that makes your channel truly stand out. I really love it! In the end you have to do what's best for you, but I hope you'll take heart in what people have said and that it might refresh you or give you some ideas on other approaches to take in your ongoing journey to inform. :)

[@adriananeira3076]

This was amazing. For sure, one of your best videos ❤️

[@doctorviz00]

I understand your frustration, but patience and connection to the individual is a sacred skill which you have. Perhaps suggesting science is merely a way to explain God's creation will allow more openness and trust to the material presented. I must admit to having my heart softened by watching these individuals. I believe religion has brought many negatives to our world, but these people are more than their religion - they are good souls.