Tudor Black Bay 58 - 2 Years Later!

My review and thoughts of the Tudor Black Bay 58 after two years. I love this watch. Don't mind the scratches...it adds character!

[@Steve-kx4yz]

Bro, seeing the nicks and scratches made me feel good about the shape of mine too. Seems like all the watch videos these days have these super pristine fresh out of the box watches with zero wear to it. Thanks for keeping it real - keep it up

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you! Yea, I don't baby this watch so much. However, I am a little reckless at times. I need to find that nice balance.

[@jinoy5002]

Yeah coz they return it, exchange for a different model, shot a video, rinse and repeat

[@sudstahgaming]

This is why I'll never collect watches it's like ripping pieces off money when it's already slowly blowing away, you should wear a watch to wear it not meant to be sat in a box.

[@Alogicchannel]

I love scratches and dings on my watches. A good watch takes it so well, esp Rolex and Tudor. The care free old money look, like the Rolex my grandfather (didn’t) hand down to me lol.

[@jamiebishop9512]

Just send it off for a polish every 5 years with the service.

[@rafayz9033]

This vid has some of the best videography and closeup shots I’ve seen of any watch review. Seems as though there’s a new sheriff in town...

[@BrandonMenancio]

Wow! Thanks! I still have work to do but the compliments are much appreciated!

[@FABM27]

Agreed

[@SoCalWatchReviews]

A great video for sure, keep it up man!

[@WhiskeyMikeSix]

Agree!

[@TheRazerlg]

I agree...

[@themightysquid]

The best way to determine which is your favorite watch is to see which one gets the most wrist time. My BB58 is one of my most worn watches for the past 2 years. Sometimes I’ll put on a different watch, and then end up switching back to the BB58 by the time I leave my home. It never ceases to impress me with its comfort, beauty, and I even like the 60 click bezel.

[@watchyourstyle]

Love that you show off the scratches up close like a badge of honor! They’re made to be worn and loved!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Right!? I could’ve been a little more careful though 😅

[@chadbailey7038]

After hours of research and looking for the exact watch I wanted, I made the decision this week that this is my ideal watch! I’ve always wanted a vintage Milgauss with the red triangle 🔺 and the old Submariners before they got big and chunky! So happy I discovered this watch and your review. You’re a cool dude and any DBZ fan is a friend of mine. “This isn’t even my Final Form!!!” Lol 😎

[@robertdumitrescu8104]

I really like the fact that you have scratches and dents all over the watch. It's what it was designed to be - a tool watch. Great review, thanks!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Robert! I tend to actually wear my watches. I could be a little more careful at times, but oh well 😅

[@dvirshany]

Really liked the camera work and didn’t get any cringe feeling that I sometimes get with new youtubers. It’s a definite subscribing for me. Please keep it up, I have a good feeling about ya!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I'll try my best to keep providing the good stuff.

[@FABM27]

Agreed Dvir

[@DoubleVisionSoundSystem]

Love that tracking shot of the seconds hand at the opening! You’ve also got a great camera presence. Great review, well done!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Philip! I was trying to illicit some excitement with that seconds hand transition shot. I’m glad it worked!

[@KirbyYoung]

It's awesome how transparent you are on showing those scratches and signs of usage. It's meant to be used. Perfect

[@BrandonMenancio]

That’s what tool watches are do in my book!

[@rjg02005]

It's so refreshing to see such a good-looking watch that's actually been worn. Nicks add character. Thanks for sharing.

[@theguardian3431]

I trust you, man. Your remind me of my childhood hero: Super Mario.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks?! Lol I prefer Link, but Mario will have to do!

[@yashwantgupta3518]

ROFL

[@lic.luismoreno4212]

Ahaha

[@Miamis4me305]

Well done. As a watch freak I can say you’ve done a great review. I’ve had mine for two months now and it does not come off my wrist. I love bracelets but this watch is a strap magnet. I only wore the bracelet for a week. I’ve fallen so hard for this that I am in the process of selling the rest in part to fund the blue. This, the blue and my gshocks is all I need. New sub

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! That'd be a pretty neat collection. Two BB58s and G-Shocks! Awesome!

[@MrThekikster]

A couple of seconds in and I’m loving the vibe of this video. It’s a watch video with a tech channel vibe. Definitely a nice change of pace from normal watch channels. Excited to see more of your collection.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! You nailed it! Yea, no cardigans or suits on this channel lol

[@chrisross9467]

I love this colour scheme! Thanks for the review, seems like the perfect all rounder, looks class without being too over priced

[@deparoo]

Wow! The production on this video is amazing. Can't believe this is your second video. Looking forward to your future videos.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! more to come!

[@sshah2545]

The photography in this video was absolutely top notch. Great video dude

[@adelalenezi2901]

I saw this vid today .. after i’ve put my name in my local tudor store .. you just made me never regretting my decision .. see you after 5 - 8 months of waiting .. thanks and keep it up

[@BrandonMenancio]

Oh snap! Hopefully you don’t have to wait that long for it! Once you get it you won’t regret it. It’s just awesome!

[@adelalenezi2901]

Brandon Menancio i dont mind the waiting .. i want to enjoy my reverso 😎

[@Valera_Scotland]

Great vid man! Really well shot, good subtle humour and you present well. 103 subscribers should be 103k!!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I’m glad someone appreciates my humor haha. 103k...one of these days!

[@Valera_Scotland]

@@BrandonMenancio I even watched the Nike vid even though I'm not really mad for shoes.... fantastic start... keep up the good work. Subscribed

[@Valera_Scotland]

P.s. awesome 80s music. Genius

[@michaeledwardlenzi]

Nice work, Brandon. I just bought the 58 Blue and am stoked to start wearing it every day. We have the same wrist size so it is good that your video reaffirms my own thoughts about dimensions and wearability of the watch. Good luck with your channel, man! Enjoy the process. --Michael

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Michael. You have the same problem as me. Everyone online seems to have smaller wrists so it's harder to gauge how they'd look on us. The BB58 is the perfect size for my wrist. Enjoy the BB58 blue!

[@karlsuisun]

Love your content and style! The BB 58 is at the top of my short list for my next luxury watch for all the reasons you stated.

[@mikenajarro3354]

I really enjoyed your video. I think the review and the videography was top notch. I really like how your love for the watch comes through. As a fellow BB58 and Explorer owner, I can relate. Can’t wait to see more videos. Keep it up!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks man! I try to put my own flavor in these videos. Nice two watches!

[@Swisha90s]

You are so easy- going and have a really nice,all- over vibe over the whole review. It's so easy paying attention, and exellent video for newbies as well. Stunning shots of the bb-58!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Whao...Thanks! I’m glad you liked.

[@Newtypenewtype]

Good timing! I'm scheduled to check out the blue this week and wanted to hear more thoughts on longer term wear for the OG!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Lucky you! I can’t wait to see the new BB58 blue. The OG is sturdy, accurate and a great value. Love it. 👍

[@Venmanayan]

@@BrandonMenancio og is the way to go

[@edwinty1010]

Love your videography and review style, very fresh! Was between this and Explorer 39mm last year. Picked the latter at the end but your video does make me rethink the BB58 again haha

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Edwin! I had the opportunity to buy the 39mm explorer about 2 years ago. I sort of regret it so good choice! Having both would’ve been great.

[@L2snakegold]

This is one of the videos that inspired me to get a bb58, love this watch, thank you.

[@jaysmall5586]

The sped-up panning shot that tracked the second hand was a nice touch. I hope to see more from you. Funnily enough, I'm on about the same timeframe getting interested in mechanical watches as you. Alas, not prepared to spend as much. But that's why I watch other people talk about it.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I was hoping people would like that shot. Yea, it can be an expensive hobby. Some of the watch youtubers make it much easier to make an informed decision.

[@robertarevalo5306]

Hello Brandon, just happened to run into your video. LOVE IT. Great work and love your honest review and opinion. Keep up the good work my brother. I will check out your other videos.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Robert! Much appreciated. More videos are on the way!

[@SaiiTube]

I really enjoyed this video! I‘m looking forward for the upcoming content! 🙏🏼

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks dude! Content coming.

[@sivarendensivalogan]

Ok so I’ve been looking at a Tudor for some time now and a lot of the reviews have been from watch owners with really expensive taste and posh accents. It was refreshing to see a review from someone to earth which I think is what optimises the Tudor brand; aimed at normal people. Really enjoyed the review and I liked the DBZ figures and Naruto figures in the background. Jiraiya is one of my favourite characters! Would love to see a review of the new Tudor BB58 Navy!!!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you thank you! Jiraiya and Itachi for me! They're my favorite Naruto characters. If I ever get my hands on the BB58 Blue I'll definitely make a video.

[@n00bsky39]

I absolutely loved your review. Please keep making watch related videos because you're clearly great at what you're doing

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! More watches are definitely coming.

[@jesserendon5450]

This is the start of something really good. You are an absolute natural. The attention to details in your videos is mind blowing. Subbed and liked and rang the hell out of that BELL!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Jesse! I'm back on the saddle. More to come soon!

[@rafiwick35]

Excellent review and props to you on discussing your thought process regarding the competition!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Rafael! Big purchases require a lot of thought for me.

[@Sojourner88]

I love that you've got all the little dings and scratches on it - you're using it as it should, not babying it in a draw 95% of the time.

[@mistertran510]

Love the videography and your laid back style, especially in a field that can be more stuffy.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you! Trying to bring my own personality to the mix. I'm glad people enjoy.

[@jmaldonado01mex]

Great job on this video, great shots and audio as well...worth my sub, please keep up the great work!!!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks, will do!

[@johnhipwell5989]

Great review, I really like you view on this watch!! I have had my 58 since August 2020 and I love it.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks John! I'm glad you're liking yours as much as I love mine!

[@shrivar12]

Nice work mate, the production value of this video is so high! I was shocked to see you only had 489 subs. Keep it up.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Much appreciated! Maybe it'll grow a little someday.

[@shaheenevans]

Great review and editing - picked up baby Smurf yesterday and wears just as you say

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I didn’t know that was the new nickname for the BB58 blue. Thanks for keeping me in the loop haha. Yea, they fit perfectly on my wrist.

[@reaschuring]

Hey man, I work in a very industrial environment. I wear the stainless for more formal events but I run the NATO fabric strap for work. Each strap has it's own place and time.

[@andrewdavidsonofficial]

Just discovered your channel! Love the videography and commentary. Can’t wait for future videos

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks and welcome aboard!

[@jermeyelliott1671]

Really liked your honest review fam. Keep doing what your doing.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I'll try my best.

[@WatchSociety]

Well done Brandon! All the best

[@BrandonMenancio]

Dude! Thanks! I watched some of your videos. Nice work!

[@a.j.e4349]

Great video and most of all I like your honesty. Keep up the good work pal!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks AJ!

[@jeremycraveiro]

Really good video, I love my 58. Would be cool to see a video on your explorer 👌🏼

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you! Don’t you worry...the explorer video is coming 👍

[@gabass1987]

Great vid man! I am sure your channel will grow in no time!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Gabriele! As long as people enjoy the videos that’s all that matters to me. The more the merrier!

[@lukasqux]

Great review bro!! I’m thinking of getting one as a 40bd treat! This video helped me a lot. I love this watch!!

[@99thVeil]

Great review. I love your style and funny asides. “Who dives in these things always” 🤣 Very refreshing in a sea of ubiquitous watch review channels. Looking forward to more.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you! I'm glad you enjoy. My friends think it's cheesy, but that's me. I uploaded my explorer video yesterday. Check it out!

[@jondobbs]

i love your positivity + I own a 58 so you've made me feel good about my watch again :) subscribed

[@huetsoob]

amazing production quality! subscribed

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks for the sub! Much appreciated!

[@MinuteMon]

Love this review Brandon and happy to see your actual wear into the watch 😉 to the next few years!

[@Matt-ce3dx]

Killer video! Can’t wait for more. Can’t wait to see a review of that GS

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Matty Mac! The GS is coming...don’t you worry!

[@farizshakir2252]

Black Bay 58, A grand Seiko, and a 5 digit serial Explorer 1? Your good taste in watches earned a subscription my guy

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! On the hunt for the next piece. It's taking me a while!

[@GOMD77]

Hmm, I guess I will give it few more years to see if Tudor will upgrade its bracelet and the ceramic bezel. I really love the look of this watch. Great review brother!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks AJ! I actually don't mind the aluminum bezel. The rivets are...okkkkaayyy I guess lol.

[@nickdi23]

Brandon, you don’t have many videos (yet) but I’m hooked! Awesome shots, good commentary and you have a great personality. Keep ‘em coming, I’m subbed.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Nick! I definitely appreciate your comments. More to come! My Explorer video is up as of yesterday. Check it out!

[@oldnotwise71]

Just found your channel via the GS video. Had to giggle to myself, as your choices are very similar to my own, as first was the GS, next I found the Black Bay and now I've just seen that you have an Explorer video. The Explorer is the only Rolex that really interests me and I'm currently saving for a Black Bay in Bronze for my 50th, as if I want the Explorer I'll be saving until I'm 65 at this rate. Fantastic cinematography and great great content, I wish you every success and look forward to your next purchase.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you thank you! Great minds think alike I guess lol a black bay bronze is pretty cool! I want to see what the bronze looks like after a couple of years.

[@oldnotwise71]

There's actually a guy with a channel called "An Indian Abroad" who's been doing a patina update over the last year. Because it's going to be for my 50th, I like the idea of something special that will age with me, I'm just hoping that next year they come up with a GMT version.

[@willclarkfinancial]

Bro, seriously loved your 2yr update review. Just hopped in with my Milgauss about 3mo ago. This may be my next

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! Ooo Milgauss is nice!

[@rkhmelnytskyy]

I got mine in October 2018 and still loving it. I've had other watches as well and hope of getting couple of Rolexes (Explorer, GMT-II) and Omega Speedmaster, but Tudor will remain in collection always. The only issue I've had is bracelet, doesn't sit perfectly well on my wrist, maybe the T-clasp from BB54 will sort the issue out.

[@zevongrie1402]

Really enjoyed your video! I am contemplating adding one of these to my collection and was debating in my mind between the regular BB and the BB 58. Hopefully in 2 years I will love mine as much as you have yours. Cheers!

[@MazAmeli]

Love this video! Great humor and style. Love that you're not all stuffy and preppy like every other watch review channel on youtube.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Maziar!

[@Oldmansland1]

I just got one of these. I think it might just be the best watch ever made. It’ll certainly stay with me forever.

[@btyc]

My name is also Brandon, I like watches, tech and gear - and now your channel / production quality. You have a new sub 👍

[@BrandonMenancio]

Great name and great taste! Thanks Brandon!

[@IamJoppe]

keep it up man! love this style to the video. lovely camera work and great commentary. you just earned a new sub !

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thank you thank you! Welcome aboard!

[@ceorellana1]

Great video! Love the energy.

[@mikestinson3696]

Good job! Subscribed 😎 Can't wait to see the rest of the collection.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! Definitely more to come!

[@theblackbayexplorer5026]

serious collection for having just started a few years ago! Nice review

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks!

[@rockisled]

Very good reviews and excellent quality, keep it up mate

[@BrandonMenancio]

Enrique! Didn't realize you commented on this. Thanks man!

[@rojachalla]

Hello Brother Brandon: Fantastic review. You have made me a believer in Tudor watches. I will be getting one

[@alexestrada4023]

Solid camera work and explinations dude! Subbed!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Alex. You da man!

[@mistermikeyjay]

A Rolex Explorer and a Grand Seiko are two of the four watches on my “must-have” list. Nice! And nice review.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! Great must-haves. I think I have an ever changing list. One week it's this and another it's that. haha

[@MyAffordableWatchCollection]

Awesome video Brandon, very well done. Great timepiece.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks dude! Keep doing great work on your channel too!

[@Retroweld]

Brandon, you nailed it! 👊 Awesome job and love that watch. 👍

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks and Thanks! Dude, I wish I could be as handy with the tools as you!

[@atl3630]

Great job with the video - I dig your work. Much appreciated!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@peterashton5941]

Great light hearted and informative review. Many thanks.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Peter!

[@Watchugoton]

First video great vid and so nice to see you got scratches on that watch and I’ve subscribed. 👍🏻🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! So many people are scared of scratches. I think it's inevitable so why not embrace it haha.

[@Watchugoton]

Brandon Menancio it’s true they worry about scratches and those same people will pick up a vintage watch with scratches and say it’s got character. 🤯 good luck with channel and just be you, you will never please everyone so just please yourself. 👍🏻🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

[@Myrslokstok]

You should have at least 50 times moore subscribers, I am usually right in this things, I was with you at 2.261! Very nice produced videos, good closeups, good light, sound and natural voice and dialog, no comercials.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks so much! Lol I hope you’re right lol.

[@Myrslokstok]

@@BrandonMenancio I'm usually right, but remember it will the toughest before it turns around.

[@MathieuVuylsteke]

Keep up these cool videos and your channel will explode! Guaranteed! Nice to hear your opinion before jumping into the blue version

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! The blue is nice, but I'm a little biased towards the OG58.

[@TheLumeRoom]

Excellent vid!! Just subscribed. Love the 58 👍🏻

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks man! Much appreciated. More to come!

[@kmc2317]

I like your vibe and I love how you don't baby your watch and embrace all the dings and scratches that come along. Cheers!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Karlo!

[@julianadams2206]

Good video and nice to see a watch being reviewed that has picked up a few scratches from being worn and enjoyed.

[@mrmondo1882]

Waited 5 months for mine , arrived at my AD just before lockdown , looking forward to picking it up in the next couple of weeks ! 😎 great vid , like your style dude , subbed . Simon

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks man! I hope you enjoy it as much as me!

[@thetheo5309]

dude your channel is massively underrated! I just found your channel

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks!

[@dooks85]

Just found your channel! Fantastic review. I have the bb58 blue and also the 214270. They are two of my favorite and most wearable watches. Awesome review and I am now subscribed!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! Mannn...this is my first watch video. My tastes have changed a bit. Sold my bb58 to make room for some grand Seikos. Still love Tudor though. Great bang for your buck.

[@justbob7828]

Just subscribed! Great commentary and very good quality video overall. Nice to see a BB58 with some wear, it sure tells how much you enjoy that piece. I’m really looking forward to your next reviews (presuming there’s more to come), particularly on that gorgeous Grand Seiko.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Bob! More is definitely coming. Soon too!

[@christophertrapp4195]

Hands down one of the best watch reviews I've ever seen on KZbin! Your camera work puts many others to shame. I love my Harrod's Black Bay, and I sometimes wonder why my ceramic sub cost twice as much. The clasp is way better, but twice the money better? Keep up the good work and I'll keep tuning in! Subscribed.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks man! Oh, the Harrod's! I love that color! The sub's clasp...twice the money better and extremely hard to find!!?? No thanks! Black Bay all the way!

[@mt4100]

Solid video dude. I like the editing and graphing you added. I have BB58 and love it. The lip on the underside of the clasp drives me crazy occasionally...but it’s a small gripe. Thinking about getting the Blue....🤔

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I heard people with the same complaint about the underside of the clasp. I haven’t experienced it myself though. I guess I’m lucky!

[@Sam-be4yy]

Really good review and perspective. Keep up the good work!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks, will do!

[@rajputatunda1318]

We more or less have the same collection (minus the Seiko 5 and plus a Tag). Great videos, man! Following you now.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Raj! That's because we're both super cool lol

[@mawtrader87]

I think we have the exact same taste in watches! Love the Rolex explorer too.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Good man! What's your grail?

[@LoinclothRising]

Vegeta's ass during the "watch thickness" section was gold. I see you, funny guy.

[@BrandonMenancio]

😂 Nice and thicccc!

[@RedwoodAggie]

Great quality video/macro shots. The review style is different from most watch reviews I've seen, which I like (feels more tech review-like). I like the comparison to other options, and I've made those same mental comparisons myself. The BB58 is very high on my want list right now, but it took some time. I did not immediately fall in love with it, though I was not in deep in the watch world when it was released.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Sean! I watch way more tech videos than watch ones. I’m sure it sort of influenced my style a bit. When I first started really liking watches I was drawn more towards dress watches. I thought dive watches looked goofy. As you can see, my opinion has changed quite a bit since! 😅

[@kma86]

This is definitely one of those super casual watch reviews! No potential confusing geeky stuff here, love it!

[@krishnar3493]

Brandon, great to see those little scratches. Wear it in good health

[@BrandonMenancio]

Will do! Thanks!

[@lastofmykind8]

Dude this review was awesome! Sick collection too!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! more on the way.

[@lastofmykind8]

Brandon Menancio Subscribed. 👌🏼

[@phobos8571]

Don't listen to people telling you you shouldn't buy watches on leather or nato, i bought my blue 58 on leather and i couldn't be happier. I also got the nato strap for the summer and to be able to swim with it (yeah, if you buy a diver you should get it at least a little wet).

[@jeffrx]

You made a good choice. I'll be picking one up when the AD calls me

[@BrandonMenancio]

Nice! Hope you get the call soon.

[@SuperAJ360]

Waiting for the Explorer video mate! Awesome vids so far!! Cheers

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks. It's coming!

[@jnac216]

This video is great Brandon being realistic with a first entry level watch. I’m in the same camp as you and thank you for helping me decide.

[@gid-vicious]

Do more videos, I like your style of review!

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks! I’m on it! Trying to bring my personal flair to the watch world.

[@dongordoofthegalletas]

My wife may have mentioned that I've picked up weight, during my latest "winter redesign". I may have responded, by quoting Brandon during that incidence..."My increased crown, makes me easier to grip, during screwing!" The win, going to both Brandon, and the Black Bay 58. Thank you much, my friends! 👍

[@Mr-Merchant.]

Good review, I do think your right that the Seamaster is not a timeless design "yet" but in 25 years we will all be wishing we bought an early model. The 58 maybe inspired by vintage watches, the Seamaster is a modern classic in the making.

[@BrandonMenancio]

Thanks Allister! Hmm...great point. In 25 years will the BB58 be a vintage vintage inspired watch lol? Preferences change and you and others are convincing me that mine might for the Seamaster. Thanks for the cool insight!