Twelve Minutes / ALL ENDINGS - 12 Mins to Survive & Escape a Time Loop, Make the Right Choices

[@ManlyBadassHero]

Welcome to the Time is On My Side Club, how Time is On My Side are ya?

[@Goldskull_Mystic]

The *time is on my side* , my friend. I have one trick up my sleeve. *ZA WARUDO*

[@Looogacy]

Time for more time time zones and time

[@Voidalot]

*Times Up for You Manly Kun...*

[@Bl0kymtt]

Yeee

[@marophile2924]

When its 2 am in ur country

[@thebbcjoke]

Wife: "Honey, didn't hear you coming in." Hubby: "I'M STUCK IN A TIME LOOP AND I CAN PROVE IT!"

[@justamanofculture12]

"Something is wrong i can feel it."

[@adamai2873]

this will sound hilarious af in real life. Like a meme or something

[@hungphan5089]

01:20:38 Wife: *dying* Hubby: *"iT iS bY fOrGeTtInG tHAt..."*

[@mikbubble8049]

Every freaking day he tries this. He even has my job and all the calendars set up for this prank. Our friends are in on this too, always telling me about the same 'new' plans. One of them has been working on the same porch for the past 3 years just to play along. 😾

[@insaneyogurt4993]

@@justamanofculture12 I said that out loud during this video actually, different context tho

[@VueiyVisarelli]

"You never know when you're gonna need a knife, a mug, and two spoons." Gaming has taught at least 2 generations of people to be *kleptomaniac hoarders.*

[@skyking4557]

'You never knew When you're gonna really need to use this' Hoarding Health potion to 999 and never use it in fighting. 'You never knew when the upgrade price will skyrocketting' Hoarding Upgrade scroll and Gems,never used it until max level

[@dimwitacans]

lol

[@unknownperson8527]

"You never know" lmao

[@mikbubble8049]

As a kid I would pick up anything laying around 'just in case' until my parents had to explain to me that escape games weren't realistic.

[@banann_ducc]

Bethesda in a nutshell

[@kingcobra4733]

I love how everyone has infinite pocket dimensions in their pockets

[@leenone8456]

@@mintpanda1372 Now I know, we need more than just pockets, we need infinite pockets (and an inventory sheet to keep track) 🤣

[@jofx4051]

Its called 4D pocket and Doraemon has it 😂

[@kaylynnwalsh3311]

XD

[@valhallajester]

What are you talking about? All dudes pockets have an infinite space

[@SimonPetrikov12]

That's why they're called pocket dimensions

[@R421Excelsior]

I believe this entire story really is the man's imagination. He was in a state of hypnosis, which the father used to explain why they shouldn't be together. That's why when he "wakes up" the father says it's a shock to take it in that way. And that's also why he mentions the man's imagination. Then the protag has a choice to leave or use the hypnosis to forget.

[@carlwheezer1640]

@Arthas So it is truly by forgetting that the protagonist can live in the present moment... Until he forgets and stops replaying these scenes inside his head, he'll experience this loop of an illusion over and over again. Woah, that is a nice touch. It wraps up pretty well.

[@testacals]

Honestly that's the best explanation that makes sense.

[@OrkPaladin]

Yep that's makes the absolute most sense, that's also why the father mentions that it's unhealthy to believe so strongly in these stories.

[@areighteen1177]

It’s cool that the protagonist has actual characterization, that he is aware of the loop and makes comments on it as opposed to the game just resetting without change each loop

[@Takkkkkkkkkk]

Well its because the game is about a guy stuck in a loop

[@pixadragon46]

Like Subaru and Rika , right ?

[@cameronfrierson7230]

There’s a Netflix movie called the Endless by that premise. Highly recommend

[@monochiota1783]

@@pixadragon46 well. it can be compared to that but subaru's characterism isn't looping like this one. The looping i'm talking is about the mc that is picturing the word HUMAN. Human - a monster who will either chose it's happiness or the surroundings future. The one that started this time theory was the human whom likes to get both of that feeling. curiousity, What would be life could be if i got that offer? Chains. Tied up. Imprison. That's what we are for. We human who could do anything for a thing. I know all what i've saying might be confusing but it is just what it is

[@pixadragon46]

@@monochiota1783 ok 😄

[@microgravity3954]

The most upsetting part of all is when they have lukewarm tap water with dessert

[@MT-th8ox]

🤣😂🤣😂🤣

[@kemmli]

Why would it be lukewarm tho?

[@gluxetv8327]

at night it should be colder right?

[@Slimtailz]

@@kemmli idk usually it takes a second to get cold and they just pour it straight into the cup

[@zakum911]

If you only knew how hard it is to get clean tap water here in Asia..

[@irl_Five]

Damn for twelve minutes it feels like an hour and fifty-five minutes

[@hushh_.]

for real tho, its almost as if i've cooked an entire meal before this video ended

[@buckethandlee]

cant forget the 50 seconds either

[@heiceonmycreamtillicone]

Ikr ú-ù

[@irl_Five]

@@heiceonmycreamtillicone ayyyye

[@heiceonmycreamtillicone]

@@irl_Five ayyyyyyyye

[@blar2112]

The game tells you from the beginning that the time loop is infinite. From the first time you execute the game, the menu says "continue". If it has no start.... Also, the red book quote: "It's only by forgetting that we really drop the thread of time, and approach the experience of living in the present moment" I think that this is for the player itself, the only way to finish this game is by forgetting it.

[@Egguu]

Damn dude. You just made me question the universe.

[@LuaTech]

Damnn

[@alexskorpik11play79]

@@LuaTech h

[@LuaTech]

@@alexskorpik11play79 h

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

I didn't like this game. It was just a random time loop which we have no idea how it works, why it was triggered, why after 8 years, what are we supposed to do to stop it, why the watch is valuable to the "cop", why the protag didn't question his lack of memory after killing his father, why he didn't just see his father dead infront of him etc. Interesting concept, but horribly executed.

[@sof4096]

The moment you said you didn't want the twist to be what you were thinking about it's when it dawned on me lmao

[@melz4766]

Same i literally said out loud "omfg...😶"

[@andreah9587]

🎶Sweet Home Alabama🎶

[@jacobosaldarriaga4820]

"oh...oh no..." is all that was going through my head when those words came out of the cop's mouth.

[@MasterChiefSpartan]

Me too the first thing I thought of is the present

[@shafwandito4724]

When the cop said the flower name, I knew it was Dahlia. And I instantly went "Fuck. no please I just want a cute loving couple story! not a fucking surprise incest like this!"

[@chiangedison8080]

I love the reason for the "cop"'s reason for stealing the clock to pay for treatment. He quite literally wants "time", so that he can be with his daughter for longer.

[@aragic9983]

ohhh u should mark that as a spoiler, accidentally scrolled down and saw this damn it, not blaming you though

[@thetalkativefos716]

@@aragic9983 my dude, you went into the comments before finishing it, what do you think it's called the comments for? We comment on the video so of course there are gonna be spoilers

[@centraltime3680]

@@thetalkativefos716 i see both sides, but to be fair he said accidentally, and that he didnt blame the guy

[@aragic9983]

@@thetalkativefos716 he was one of the top comments, and like I said I *accidentally* scrolled down, kinda a bad habit that I do, you right though, always finish a video before scrolling down

[@thetalkativefos716]

@@centraltime3680 although accidentally scrolled down why did he stop and read the whole thing, like come on

[@diy_cat9817]

"You attacked me. You don't have the moral high ground!" Sir. You broke into my house 🧐

[@me-ree5185]

Sir I- You were the one who was about to kill my wife and you see you have moral high ground?

[@him1517]

@@me-ree5185 well to be fair he was killing her out of vengeance

[@me-ree5185]

@@him1517 ok yeah I get that but he didn't have to kill the protag. The protag is guilty but the man didn't know so he had no reason to.

[@SkiggsMoDiggs]

@@him1517 vengeance doesn't justify an action

[@JEazy-jh1qp]

@@SkiggsMoDiggs matter of perspective.

[@nickirkland1347]

God damn i didn't expect this, i thought it was just your usual murder horror story with time loop but this is so intricate. I won't even complain about the biggest twist because they told the story so well. I really love these kinds of stories/games. Also, what an exceptional line up for the voice actors... Amazing

[@karentookthekids1267]

Cop: WHERE'S THE WATCH?! Wife: I DIDN'T KILL ANYONE Protag: sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir?

[@PupperinACupper]

The funniest part

[@azadalamiq]

sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? sir? xD

[@potato560]

Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir?

[@UrzaderGehasste]

Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe?

[@us3r003]

Sir? Sir? Are you there? Sir?

[@bengermin3104]

This game is actually so depressing. This isn't even horrific anymore, I'm just sad now

[@Starboy-3027]

That's the real horror.

[@uabri5698]

Your profile picture is.

[@Yandel2105]

Dude your pfp scared me more than the whole entire video lmao

[@RoseVeteran]

IKR!

[@justamanofculture12]

@@Yandel2105looks like cursed Thomas lol

[@PupperinACupper]

***SPOILERS*** The creepiest part was definitely when you stabbed her and then proceeded to recite the book she was reading over her dying body.

[@dorianshrv6967]

Lol

[@moophette9457]

yEaH wTf

[@justamanofculture12]

That's the best part. You should watch charlie's playthrough. He legit said he killed her father while eating the desert 😭. Lmaooo this game is ridiculous and i love it.

[@twins2307]

That was the funniest part for me. stabs her, says he's sorry, then starting saying a quote

[@SamiTheAnxiousBean]

I'm curious how the cop would react if he entered the apartment to find her dead Or if you stabbed her when he was in the apartment

[@BloodRose-75]

There’s a lot to this game. 2:02 Moarse code: “all endings are also beginnings. We just don’t know at the time.” The thin vertical lines are new letters whereas the horizontal lines are spaces (I knew what it was very quickly though I couldn’t read it straight away)

[@solaronyou8610]

Hate morse code.. shit never make sense.

[@ReySilverskin]

Ah, I have a computer science degree, so my first thought was binary code (and my second thought was some kind of base-4 code) Morse code makes a lot more sense

[@TheWeirdo1337]

knew it was Morse code the second i saw the painting, but i'm far too lazy to translate it. was looking for a comment like this, thank you random dude 2 years ago

[@BloodRose-75]

@TheWeirdo1337 hahah no worries man! 😎👍

[@freshtapcoke]

My fellow hams in here? 😄

[@jkuang9548]

I really like how the paintings are correlelated with the game. The left painting in the hall is the library wall with the red book in the father's room. The right painting is a painting of a dahlia flower. The tree painting behind the couch changes seasons when you progress (starting from spring, then ending as winter). The wedding painting in the bedroom change into a painting where the flowers disappear and the woman is recoiling from the man, and then later change into a painting where the man is alone with a monster in the background. The egg painting above the stove starts out as an egg, then later turns into a cracked egg with a snake's eye looking through the egg crack, then finally the egg is gone and reveals the snake eating its own tail in a loop, forming the shape of an egg. The painting next to the fridge is morse code (circle = . square = - | = a new letter _ = a new word) which spells out "All endings are beginnings, we just don’t know it at the time." I just thought this was all a neat touch.

[@MusicLoverICI55]

Woah, the detail

[@abowlofsangria3412]

That’s really neat!

[@ayyylmao101]

That's FANTASTIC, it adds so much!

[@giangtran3217]

Can I have the timestamps for the wedding and egg paintings changing please. I have been skipping through the video again but haven't found them. Thank you!

[@Rickiumm]

impressive detective work .- -.- --. --. -.-- .- - (that's just gibberish lol)

[@miaironstone6783]

As soon as the cop screamed “YOU KILLED YOUR FATHER AND MARRIED YOUR SISTER” and the time loops? This is literally just Oedipus, it’s Oedipus, conversations about inescapable fate and murder and incest? Yea it’s Oedipus The King

[@MichelleWilliamsPewDiePie]

Different incest though.

[@miaironstone6783]

@@MichelleWilliamsPewDiePie my guess for that is that they knew the age difference between a guy and his mom would be too noticeable so they swapped it for a sister since huge age gaps arent as common now

[@MichelleWilliamsPewDiePie]

@@scotchdeblanc Exactly, yeah.

[@miaironstone6783]

@@scotchdeblanc he didn’t really know, he was living a fantasy and had to have the reality of the situation revealed to him (like oedipus) he was living happily before cryptic messages telling him about his situation were revealed. The eye thing is different but overall the two stories have a lot in common and I find it hard to believe there wasn’t some inspiration

[@Sylfa]

Was nearly literally the plotline of a Dr. House episode as well. Father cheated on wife with neighbour, seemed to be racist asshole when kids started dating - kids ran away to get away from him only to discover they are half siblings due to a rare genetic disorder. Guy wanted to talk, girl ran away. No kids or murder in that one though.

[@jackin_it]

Man’s life went to shit and time really said “nah I gotchu fam”

[@Ralyx0]

Nah, he died and time said, "just wait, it gets worse".

[@destroidhak2556]

"where i was born that was a damn warmup! Get the hell up, there is much more to go!"

[@LTElb]

And then he said 'Oh yeah, that's great. I wanna stay here.' And time said 'Wha? I couldn't hear ya. I'll you do exactly what I did before'

[@emilyau8023]

Ikr where was that when I had sh*tty times?

[@VVen0m]

Kronii being compassionate to mah boi

[@maledictionwolf]

I think the imagination line defines the entire game. Have you ever replayed a scene over and over in your mind, seeing all the different ways it could have gone, from the mundane to the ludicrous, building entire lives and stories in the future and then having to come back to reality? Basically, I think the entire story except the backstory (father, nanny, protag falls in love with sister, asks father for permission, father says no) takes place in the protagonist's imagination, daydreaming what could have been if he'd tried to stay with her, how it could all come crashing down, and obsessing over it, never letting go of the "one that got away" (his sister) to the point where he'd rather live in his imagination than reality. Thus the empty house when he left her life, and the "continuation" ending you get from the book is basically an Easter egg of sorts, a fantasy imagination kind of deal, rather than the mundane kind.

[@lufcik69]

"imaginating" all the possibilities is basically proved the moment time goes back 8 years.

[@anon_148]

What am American take on the story. I'll just leave it at that.

[@cutekitty2358]

Pretty realistic when they showed him not dying instantly from the headshot. Most people survive shooting themselves in the head for awhile afterward. It really depends on the size of the bullet.

[@eafesaf6934]

Never knew that. I always assumed that a bullet that penetrates the head, also penetrates the brain and since it's more than "just a small wound" the person dies of pain shock or some shit like that?

[@someone2447]

He missed the brain, downsides of shooting yourself through the mouth

[@TemmiePlays]

i thought he shot himself in the gut

[@travislyonsgary]

@@eafesaf6934 The brain has no nervous system, generally speaking specific parts of it being damaged cause the body to die due to it disrupting connection to other parts. Internal hemorrhaging can aid in this of course but pain and shock are attributes of the rest of the body more than the brain itself( a good way to frame it is that what kills is a disruption of resources so it actually takes time for those resources to get used up)

[@slumberbalu3098]

Thats why you have to eat the barrel, the shoot in the chin dosnt make it !

[@bellavelarde1703]

Wife: Guess who made dessert? Manly: *Collects the entire kitchenware* "I have two spoons now"

[@judyhopps9380]

hey honey, I made you a nice mug of tap water

[@MekongMonsterSC]

@@judyhopps9380 so romantic

[@MichelleWilliamsPewDiePie]

"I can sell these- I'll make a fortune"

[@trje246]

lmao! _Thought this would be a good time to comment_ as i'm currently 12 hours into the game and feel like i've exhausted every avenue. yet, have still only uncovered 2 of 12 achievements. Hiding the spoons feels like the only thing i haven't thought of. SO doing this next run! cheers! 😁 🥄🥄

[@iwonderwhatnameishallhaveh1194]

Imagine how stressful it must be for the wife….her husband just comes home and her husband just seems so upset and starts talking about a time loop telling them stuff that happened 8 years ago how she murdered someone. Just yikes.

[@pikachu-hd6lr]

Eh could be worse He could tell her shes his half-sister💀💀💀💀

[@lukebunch6327]

@@pikachu-hd6lr he actually does eventually he confesses to everything

[@emilym3219]

Tbh all that stress is bad for the baby

[@Vesperad0]

@@emilym3219 I'd say the (half) incest is worst but y'know, that too /s

[@lightlylemony]

@@Vesperad0 nah incest will make it cuter, thats what they do with dogs after all!

[@pungetello]

This game reminds me of my friend, who basically invented a bunch of things about his past and convinced himself they were true, and got to the point where he couldn't tell what had actually happened and what hadn't, including his ex-girlfriend who died. It blew my mind that memory can be manipulated that much, to where you can forget and fabricate hugely important events like that. So, I think that last line about his overactive imagination, and needing to let her go, suggests that much or all of this was memories fabricated by the husband. (I mean, if he can forget that he killed someone, I'm sure it wouldn't be hard for him to make false memories)

[@claranadine1086]

That sounds terrifying 😣

[@pungetello]

@@claranadine1086 I know, right?? Idk how my friend is so chill about it.

[@El_chara]

That thing is scary because I got some problem with lying I lie a lot because I want to be intersting and sometime I have chose thing that I regret and now you make me wonder if all of that is real

[@pungetello]

@@El_chara If I were you I would ask someone who would know if it actually happened, if you're unsure. Not everyone is as curious as I am though, so if you want to just forget about it that's valid.

[@zacmayes2802]

Dissociative Amnesis is a thing

[@mikbubble8049]

"It's something flowery" I was immediately like OH NO

[@aHumanBeing97]

The best part, is that your wife is able to open that vent without any help whilst you can’t.

[@АндрейКомысов]

Player can use keys to open vent. On wife's dead body there are keys , so basically she could of use them to open vent

[@aHumanBeing97]

@@АндрейКомысов ahhhhhh, That makes a whole lot of sense, thank you!

[@anormalintrovert5365]

@@АндрейКомысов or she could use science

[@Maber610]

@@anormalintrovert5365 or she is stronger than all of us

[@MGrey-qb5xz]

@@Maber610 she became more powerful after banging her brother

[@Serpentar9000]

nothing says "romantic" like having 2 small cupcakes and tap water for "dessert"

[@ShamelessFNGRL]

"Only the best for my husbro!"

[@DH-gq7bm]

Holy shit hes a brother husband

[@DH-gq7bm]

AND SHES A SISTER WIFE

[@bonecag3]

@@ShamelessFNGRL HUSBRO 😭😭

[@NessieNice]

Looks like chocolate lava cakes to me. But yes, eating lava cake with tap water? Do they not have milk at least?

[@yusuka4ev830]

I love how u can hear how angry the character is in the game, the heavy breathing in the closet, you just know he wanted to kill that man.

[@MistyNightASMR]

I like when the "cop" showed up the first time and Manly was just like "Bye, Wife!" The contrast between the character and Manly is really funny 😆

[@iandrezdon3428]

The fact that Luis Antonio got William Dafoe, James McAvoy, & Daisy Ridley, a bunch of professional actors/actresses, to voice in this game, makes this game twice as better

[@helloworld2784]

Godamnn

[@snoopdoggy8352]

William DaTimeloop

[@peanutbutter3564]

@@snoopdoggy8352 lol

[@HighlyRegardted]

Damn … right after Lighthouse too? Such a crazy showcase of his acting abilities, highly recommend if you haven’t seen it already

[@myusername0wns]

Nah they sucked

[@shutendouji3241]

i’m not the only one who went WTF at the cast list, right? i never would’ve expected a celebrity actor cast for a video game that’s like this.

[@Onichizo]

As soon as I saw James McAvoy I was like YOOOOOOOO

[@1Tako1]

I actually didn't recognize any of their names. I just searched them up and when I saw the movies they were in I was just like, "Wait a minute..."

[@shutendouji3241]

@@1Tako1 hehe, understandably!! i know daisy ridley did voice over work for a ghibli film but wasn’t sure about james mcavoy

[@letoppdelaklass]

Don't forget Willem Dafoe

[@solanumtuberosa]

@@letoppdelaklass you know im something of a voice actor myself

[@devnax835]

Summarizing the 'reality' plot: Spoilers* The reality is the past scene in the study with the guy and the dad, set on New Years Eve. He has met his runaway future wife to-be at the party, and he went back to tell his dad the good news/his dad found out and called him home. Only for MC to find out his wife-to be is his half-sister. So they talk it out, and the loop is a symbol of him imagining a happy future. The dad mentions MC's 'good imagination' at 1:24:22. The cop isn't a real person. He is a symbol for the dad in the imagined future. In reality, the dad is trying to tell MC to leave his daughter, like how the cop will always intrude on the couple and end it. The dad still loves his daughter in reality, and wants to stop the relationship. MC can see that and is guilty, he imagines it as the cop's daughter having cancer and desperate to cure her. That's why Willem Dafoe voices both characters and the dad is suddenly bald in one study scene. The reality is that there is no good ending in the future. His wife will hate him when she finds out the truth, they will have an incest kid etc. so he keeps looping scenarios in his mind, trying to find an ideal future. The real ending is choosing between 2 decisions: The guy can insist on staying with her, accidentally kill his dad when they fight. Then suppress his memories and marry his wife. Or he can choose to break up, keep his relationship with his dad. And in the future, live in an empty apartment alone. Anyhow Manly, you're awesome. I was watching a streamer and they played for +8 hours, so you probably played even more to get all the endings/changes. Thanks for the playthrough and your hard work

[@sapphosdescendants3997]

Thank you so much for the summary!!! I’m usually pretty good with these games but this one was tough to get my head around. Your explanation makes so much sense!

[@FeenieVonKarma]

Great explanation! Honestly it took me a while to piece most of it together but this really makes a lot of sense. I guess I'm used to VNs where you can try to predict what's gonna happen, but at the end of it they really explain or overexplain what is going on, yknow? Whereas this is a shorter game asking you to work it out :)

[@angelcoffee1972]

Oh wow. Your summary is way better than my he🏒🏒 theory 😅

[@Bomba.02]

The mentioning of the MC’s great imagination confuses me. The father might be talking of the scenes that the son imagined and that he told him about, but that doesn’t make sense, as he wouldn’t have imagine the cop as he didn’t kill his father. So while the “good imagination” almost led me to think that all these scenes are created by the son after he discovered the truth, they don’t fit with the dead father narrative. At the same time, the ending where he forgets her lead to a broken watch, that I think symbolises a “wrong timeline”. Either that remark to his good imagination is some sort of fourth wall break or I can’t put it in the narrative. If it is a fourth wall, then I think the true timeline might be the one where the father dies, because in the other one the watch is broken at the end.

[@mibusuzaku]

@@Bomba.02 (*Spoilers Directly Ahead*) “killing” his father if he choose to go through with the incest relationship is more metaphorical in his “IRL” rather than in his stories. No “father” or psychologist/clinical hypnotist wants to let there son/patient go through with continuing a relationship they know will break down and unravel eventually in “cancerous” manner that will “kill” his wife/sister/the “fathers” daughter, and him. He’d be a “monster” if he went through with it, knowing about it. So he can either continue going to meetings with his psychiatrist about his Oedipus relationship or end it and live a lonely life without her, a broken heart. All endings are doom for him if he can’t push past the emotions and settle them into the past and imagined route he can’t step on. At least that how I saw it, a confusing mess but I believed the killing was mainly just about the kick back choosing to go willingly into that situation would lead to, because at some point it will kick his door down and crush him and his wife if he went through with it in modern society, in a city at least.

[@AndBlissEverywhereBliss]

*>Brutally stabs his wife and cries about her dying* *>Loots her body and then recites a book quote* *>Refuses to elaborate further* *>Resets loop*

[@BriarPatchNyra]

"Daphne? Daisy? Something like that." Uh oh. Didn't she want to name their kid Dahlia? EDIT: Oh dear.

[@doctorrogue1923]

*Distant Sweet Home Alabama starts to play*

[@alittlebitd3ad]

Fellow Ace :D 🖤🌑🤍💜

[@joshualeahy2162]

@@doctorrogue1923 *Banjo music intensifies and grows closer as the washing machine begins to spin*

[@joshualeahy2162]

@@alittlebitd3ad Why only a little bit though? :o

[@alittlebitd3ad]

@@joshualeahy2162 hm?

[@ashleysalomon4349]

This game really took “you’re like a brother to me” to a whole new level

[@musicgamerlover]

Protag: Babe! I'm home. You wanna know something weird? Well you know how we dated for a couple of years then got married and after all the years of sex we had I got you pregnant? Guess what? I'm your long lost brother and murdered our father! You'd think that'd be the weird part but actually no it isn't. The weird part is I totally forgot about all of it until I got stuck in a time loop and just now remembered. Weird right? But it doesn't matter, what's a little incest and patricide? We have our love. Hey! Where are you going?

[@FryingWater]

Shit do be going down in Alabama

[@TheHellmo]

LMFAO

[@alligatorsun1854]

"Don't mind me honey! I'm just going to my corner and have a major mental breakdown after realizing my husband is my half-brother who killed my father many years ago!"

[@PipTheFireThief]

But.....its in his imagination....you understand what the story was about right?

[@valhatan3907]

@@alligatorsun1854 dang man, too many shit happens at once. Sad to be that wife.

[@sydandpie146]

is no one gonna talk about how the protag went from killing the father to being with the 'wife' hundreds of miles away on new years eve at a bar, the same day? like, didnt the 'wife' literally use that defense to prove she was innocent? huh????

[@fatcatattack]

Good point

[@riplix20]

I feel like that scene is some kind of trippy remembering of events, cause the dad just got shot like a week prior, I doubt he’d be out of hospital in a position to try and beat a teenager if that was the case

[@aellaainsley7]

no he shows up a few weeks later, that pic was just her alone at a coffee shop

[@sydandpie146]

@@aellaainsley7 someone didnt watch the video

[@omgnoi]

This was my first thought!

[@ghosty8193]

the fact you got more progress in 19 minutes than Matpat has in 2 whole hour episodes is just telling

[@bagseys]

Watching him at times is abit painful sadly, love his content but his gtlive is a mixed bag

[@crossedpawsgacha8702]

TRUE

[@ghosty8193]

@@bagseys yeh I love gtlive and game theory and all that but it was painful to watch. He got SO CLOSE to getting an ending but he can’t just let things play through and he fucked it all up. May (begins the camera mat) needs a walkthrough or something

[@Hayden_Cat]

Cory to

[@redtortoise]

Sometimes I feel like he already played the game before. I notice he knows the map a lot before even seeing it.

[@lemonberry_soda]

Chronological order as far as I can tell SPOILERS The protag falls in love with the wife. They date, grow closer, and eventually the baby happens. He is delighted until the father finds out about him and tells him the truth. When he finds out, he is devastated, but he does in fact, choose to leave. He disappears from her life entirely, leaving her confused and alone. The clock ticks for eight years. The protag is living alone. He is miserable. He works a boring job, has a rickety, dangerous apartment, and is still single. He is wifeless and childless, and he hates it. So he starts imagining. "What could've happened if I had fought back," he thinks. "What could've happened if I made myself stay?" And he escapes to a make-believe where he's happy. But it never could have worked if the father was still alive, he would have told her or hurt him. So, in his dream, he kills the father "accidentally." His imagination is too vivid, so he ends up trapped in this "what if" loop, where the father (in this daydream, as a cop) refuses to stop butting his head into the protag's perfect daydream. Of course. It's the father's fault that the protag's life is so fucked up, after all. He was a bastard child that ruined and killed multiple lives, raised in a world where he was always called a monster, and the one time he has a chance at happiness, well the father fucked that one up for him too. It gets to the point where he can't even remember reality anymore. He forgets what really happened eight years ago. All he has is this fantasy life with his loving wife and soon-to-be daughter. So, depending on the ending, he stays forever or finally moves on. There is no watch. It's just Time. Time is one of the most valuable things out there. The father barges in every 12 minutes and demands to take their time away, just as he did eight years ago. The wife hates time because it took away her boyfriend and forced her to be a single mother. The protag made himself forget, so he has to find the lost time every loop. One last thing. Bumblebee is very much the Protag's eight-year-old daughter. Bees go to flowers, of course. She isn't dying of cancer. As another commenter put it, he just wants the watch so that he can have more time with her, because even though he never met her, the protag still loves her.

[@cirese2570]

wait so did the wife actually shoot the dad or was that something he made up too? This really explained a lot!

[@preciousmorival2201]

That is a great way of putting it. And if the father just told his son that what had happened. then maybe they would have never had a baby. But the mom told him that he couldn't keep the Son. Then how was he supposed to know.

[@sei_pika]

This actually sounds like the explanation that makes the most sense, especially given the father commenting that the protag needs to let go of his obsession with his wife-- because he keeps obsessing over a future where they could have been.

[@SuzyW0ozy]

She does have cancer, or is sick. They text and she says she misses him and she’s in the hospital. The insurance company messages him about hospitals bills and how he’s over due to pay them.

[@cyberlemmingasaservice7740]

@@SuzyW0ozy Her being in the hospital constantly could also be a hint that she is a child of incest

[@Tridelo100]

The small screams of cringe from Manly as he discovered that alabamian plot twist are quite something

[@ronnznx]

How could a game with only 4 rooms make me feel so many emotions at once

[@xChieftainx]

So my synopsis is this games two paths is in his head the true ending is him accepting he cant be with his sisiter. The bad ending causes the proverbial time loop which isnt actually a loop but him playing out the events of if he was with her anyway in his head and then puts him back at the two way choice

[@mazzpsykoziz]

Imagine finding out you've been going to town on your half-sister by a dude coming to murder her and getting stuck in a weird groundhog day scenario and that you had repressed killing her dad. What a day. Also nice little subtle The Shining reference.

[@spiderbrine8877]

The rug?

[@BuetifullPersun]

I’d keep going to town. Honestly that’s a great life to be in that time loop. Endlessly end that old dude and go to town on onee-chan

[@JV-un7qw]

technically he did no kill his dad. It was an accident

[@John_the_Paul]

He still killed him. It just changes from murder to either self-defense or manslaughter

[@ashtimbog]

@@HiddenRealm didnt be shoot himself accidentally?

[@iskandar4661]

That does _not_ sound like Daisy Ridley. She’s really good in this. Everyone is phenomenal

[@noahrevan5452]

It's always weird hearing people with British accents speak with an American accent.

[@iskandar4661]

@@noahrevan5452 And it works strangely well

[@YourPalKindred]

Wish she was this good in star wars lmao

[@SeymourDisapproves]

@@YourPalKindred I thought the first and second movies were fine but idk if any single actor could have saved the fanservice shitshow that was the third one lol

[@user-jl7cz2pe6d]

I know right? I expected to hear more "Yo-ho's!" and animalistic screeching.

[@averynelson1186]

What's great is that you got all the way to the credits without killing the wife even once. Almost every other playthrough I've watched, the player kills the wife, usually over and over again, like, to the point that the main character does it quickly and cleanly and soothes her while she passes.

[@thomasvleminckx]

psycho

[@bestbedwarplayer]

Probably because there's a difference between a playthrough where the player doesn't know what interactions need to be made to progress the story and a walkthrough with all the endings where the person does know lmao

[@comicdweller8146]

@@bestbedwarplayer I don't think that he knew either, the video is titled play through not walk through, he doest tell you how to do things, he says lots of things that tells us he doesn't know how it goes, like questioning the next move to make or saying "I think that is all of them" etc etc.

[@BuckBlaziken]

51:18 The “Sir.” Spam was honestly funny

[@marcxworld5708]

Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir? Sir?

[@joshualeahy2162]

@@marcxworld5708 Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe? Babe?

[@PrettyGothBoi6085]

Kinda reminds me of "SHAWN!" from the heavy rain glitch.

[@joshualeahy2162]

@@PrettyGothBoi6085 Ayyy

[@joshualeahy2162]

@@PrettyGothBoi6085 sHaUnNnNnN

[@beesknees5621]

Cop: YOU KILLED YOUR FATHER AND MARRIED YOUR SISTER?? Wife: YOU MONSTER! GET THE HELL OUT OF HERE!!!! Protag: babe? babe? babe? babe? babe? babe? babe? babe?

[@retrogamingcommentary4163]

Also protag: What the--?! I did everything right!

[@therealalmightyloaf3285]

sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?sir?

[@professionalredhead9687]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@VoidstriderLucatiel]

@@retrogamingcommentary4163 I killed my father, and married my sister! What did I do wrong!?

[@door-to-doorhentaisalesman2978]

**Sweet Home Alabama**

[@sboy1024]

That "sir sir sir" is right on par with "Jason! Jason!"

[@wolf_quill]

Or SHAWN SHAWN SHAAAAAWWWN

[@kajerbear1512]

Left Click to sir 🤣 🤣 🤣

[@deadpan904]

Or: "Jesse! Jesse!"

[@Local_gremlin2009]

SHAWN!

[@sergiob8501]

51:15 😂

[@DethKount]

I was surprised to find out it was actually Willem defoe

[@SmartyPoohBear]

30 min left until I finish the video, but I'm honestly surprised he hasn't attempted to hide in the closet with the knife and jump out to stab the "cop." Cause that was the direction I immediately thought of when I saw he could hide in the closet.

[@jofx4051]

Looks make sense to me... wonder what would happen

[@thethmooteresa]

Check penguin's gameplay!! He did the hiding thing alottt

[@lamihadamshareef5270]

@@jofx4051 get bodied

[@DolorCinAmet]

cop overpowers him and beats him up. even with hindsight he can't win over the chad cop

[@neovoid5008]

The moment I saw that when the protag turned on that dangerous light I knew emedialtly you could nock some people out . Because omg those sparks flew...

[@biomechanicalcyber-jesus7573]

Wife: “What are you doing?” Manly: Nothin’, just turning the “copyright strike” off…

[@2189fallenangel]

Lol

[@skeletonorchestra1504]

Spoilers for the game but WHENEVER THE CLUES STARTED POINTING TO US BEING OUR WIFE'S HALF BROTHER I ACTUALLY SCREAMED THIS IS NOT THE PLOT TWIST I WANTED OR EXPECTED

[@silverfox1160]

I had to pause and just sat there with my jaw wide open... like what the fuck

[@beep3242]

The "half brother" part is above the comment cutoff, this wouldn't help someone avoid spoilers. Might wanna click enter another time after the "spoilers for the game" bit.

[@Daddy_Grimm]

@@beep3242 if a person didnt want spoilers for the game they wouldn't have clicked on a video named "Twelve Minutes / ALL ENDINGS".

[@InedibleMuffin]

@@silverfox1160 SAME. I had to pause and stare as I processed it all for a few seconds like, "Oh... Oh no... No.."

[@brokengirl8619]

I love the plot twist

[@BrandonAEnglish]

Although the game's endings were so cloudy to wade through, I loved this game so much. So unique and interesting -- and it must have taken a LONG, LONG time to recreate all the different situations. My hats off to them. Also, loved Dafoe's voice!

[@themanoffate]

I love how the characters actually make comments on the weird stuff you do in this game which would just be ignored in others, these fine details really show the effort put into making the game

[@hive5123]

First video of this game from you and you are already hitting us with a "All Endings" in the title The dedication from Manly warms my heart

[@oathkeeper5168]

P pbbp ooooo

[@oathkeeper5168]

Bppp p

[@oathkeeper5168]

Popbpp You pop g

[@oathkeeper5168]

Popbpp You pop g

[@oathkeeper5168]

Popbpp You pop g

[@0amburgh063]

THE PART WHERE ALL THE PROTAG DID WAS SAY “sir?” WHILE THE COP IS TIEING HIS WIFE DOWN IS SO FUNNY BWHHAAHHAA

[@RobertYoung122]

Protagonist: Sir? Sir? Sir?... Cop: (zip ties protagonist) Protagonist: "I'd like to talk to your supervisor".

[@smilefriend7171]

He became an indian

[@H0und0fHircin3]

Reminded me of Ethan looking for his son in Heavy Rain. "Jason!" "Jason'" "Jason!" 🤣

[@omgnoi]

Or after he stabs her and then he reads her the book 😂😂😂

[@Cypher791]

“She deserves the truth, I will tell her everything and we will get through it” 😌 Wife: Get the hell out of my apartment right now! ☝️😐

[@lightningmonky7674]

Yeah she had a lot of gal judging when she was the first to try to kill him, hypocrite

[@michaeltalpas]

"Daphne? Daisy? "... Dahlia?" Oh sh...

[@toxicradiant9858]

What are you doing step bro?

[@michaeltalpas]

@@toxicradiant9858 I didn't even make that connection. Jesus..

[@Alamia27]

Why? Did I miss anything?

[@Faramik2000]

@@michaeltalpas could you explain

[@hel2727]

@@Faramik2000 her father had an affair with a nanny. that nanny is the main hero's mom = he and his wife are half-siblings. that's partly why he killed his father (in the pocket dimension that is)

[@amyyaku5022]

Spoilers: Feel bad for the protag. He's called a monster by everyone not because of his own actions but because of things outside of his control, assuming that it's true that the son and daughter were separated somehow. Maybe he gets his sister pregnant, the father confronts him about it, one thing leads to another and he kills the father, sure, but its most likely out of self defense or just an accident. But regardless of which, he's in shock and runs off, and his mind is filled with so much guilt and shame from everything that he's caught in a loop. It's possible after running away he's using a hypnotist to make him forget so he can move on, so he might not even be a teenager but an adult living in the same empty apartment we see in the game. It's like time is still going but his mind is kind of replaying his mistake. And in terms of the loop the protag is in, I wish there was an ending where the protag could tell the truth to the wife and the wife and even the fake cop gives him the support and compassion he needs, because from what I'm seen the protag isn't a bad person he just made a mistake that's constantly eating away at him.

[@rumisanes]

totally agree! that part where he broke down and said 'I did everything right... I did everything right' really makes ya feel bad

[@drawingdragon]

For real! When the wife thinks she killed her own father, he's nothing but supportive and still trying to protect her - even though she "killed" him out of anger. But protag turns out to be the real killer - but it was obviously in self-defense, not hatred. And what does waifu do? Shoves him out of the house and calls him disgusting and horrible. I get that was more because he was her half-brother - but neither of them knew that. I just don't get how fast she 180'ed on her feelings for him as if he did it all intentionally.

[@professionaldumbass7789]

@@drawingdragon He is her brother, I don't think that I would wanna be in a relationship with my brudda.

[@drawingdragon]

@@professionaldumbass7789 No no I definitely agree. I'm not defending incest at all. I was just saying that I feel sorry for the protagonist, because he's being treated so horribly (in that one ending) for things completely out of his control. He didn't ask to be born from the father's affair. They called him "monster" just for existing. He didn't intentionally murder the father - he reacted in self-defence. And he didn't know the wife was his sister until AFTER the damage had been done. I do think it's very interesting what Manly brought up, though; that maybe none of it happened at all and he's just a man who's psyche has been wrecked by guilt. If that's the case, maybe he totally is in the wrong and is just projecting his shame onto others. Or, alternatively, maybe he really has just had a long line of horrible luck, but feels ashamed anyway, and that manifested itself in the form of his wife treating him so horribly when she learned the truth. Maybe he was just so ashamed of the truth that he assumed everyone should be and would be.

[@angela.luntian]

His mistake is remaining in this loop willingly. He can get himself out of his obsession of what could have been and the mindfulness ending is the start of him rehabilitating his mind. There is no compassion to get from the wife nor the father, because theyre already long in the past. 8 years since, I think.

[@TemmiePlays]

I have my hypothesis. there's no time travel, no loops, no bumbleebee, and murder. husband and wife aren't together. they don't live together the entire game is in an office where a person is hyponoitixzing the MC. The hyponotist is Wife's father. he finds out on new yera's eve that you two are gonna hook up, and discovers you're related. someone figures it out, and he spends the night hypontizing you to show you all " the different loops of how this will pan out " the paintings _ did_ matter, Manly - they change with each new thread. the plant changes, too. As does the image of the egg on the fridge ( becomes snake eye, then ourobouros ) You MC, are being shown all the possible ways things can go, if you live a life with your half-sister. This is why in the mindfullness ending the " cop ": sayds ": you have a good imgainaiton, but you need ot let her go " he means - no matter hwat way you try to make this work out in your head ( as we see in the :" loops ) , it WILL NOT work out. it always ends in sadness, and the _ only other ending_ where it doesn't - is the one where the apartment is _ empty _ meaning , you didn't hook up with her, you had no baby, you did the " right thing " the watch exists bc the watch is the tool for the hypnotist to use. Just like Dafoe says in the true end " It's time to wake up "

[@DolorCinAmet]

and it's also a nice touch that the cop and father are both voiced by Willem Dafoe

[@gaymertink]

There it is folks! Thats the explanation I was looking for. I couldn't get why the cop and father was the same voice actor. That's ties that shit together in a neat shit pie lol this story is wild!

[@radicalwings]

I love this game

[@danio2634]

THIS!! You hit the nail on the head! It would make sense why the clock towards the end had a “dreamy” effect as the MC stares at it in his father’s room as his father tells him he has a great imagination.

[@rumisanes]

mhm i believe hypnosis is the basis of it all too! i'll just add my bit here since this is the comment that really solified it. i believe reality is the interrogation with the father, in the room with books and the chair. you either choose to accept reality, and let go and forget - or deny it and stay stuck in the looping daydream. not to mention the flower description, tieing into dahlia, sounds exactly like a relaxing method you'd use for hypnosis

[@birchbarks550]

Spoilers I like that, when you hover over her, on the main game it says "wife" but once you confess that you are her brother & the murderer it changes to "her"

[@pixelpancakes489]

From first glance, this reminds me of a game I saw a really long time ago, where you're stuck in a looping dream and have to find a single, progressively harder difference every time then commit self die, and at the very end there was nothing unreal and you didn't commit self die.

[@taylorl.9875]

If someone knows this game pls tell the name

[@Kachopper9]

@@taylorl.9875 Knock Harder

[@pixelpancakes489]

@@Kachopper9 AH THAT'S THE ONE THANK YOU!!

[@ErinJeanette]

Damn this is why I love comment sections

[@succulentfruiit4107]

It also reminds me of this one game that pewdiepie played a long time ago, all I remember was this once scene where the character was surrounded by candles, and each candle showed how a certain person died. One of them was by hanging. I also remember the ending, where I think she’s trying to like reset something in her house and she’s sticking her hand through a narrow hole to press a button, and then when she presses it and her hand explodes off. That’s all I remember and I’ve been going insane looking for this fucking game

[@kittynanami]

the Voice Actors were James McAvoy and Daisey Ridley. I heard about this game because of the cast, seems very interesting!!

[@jaysea5939]

When Manly mentioned Willem Dafoe, I wasn't thinking it was the actual actor

[@1Tako1]

I never heard of this game before and thought it was an indie game. So I was really surprised that the voice actors are, I assume (I don't really follow celebrities) are big-name actors!

[@itsgonnabeanaurfromme]

@@1Tako1 how are you surprised if you don't know who they are?

[@1Tako1]

@@itsgonnabeanaurfromme Oh, I searched them up! I always like to see the people behind the voice acting.

[@azadalamiq]

@@1Tako1 not the first game, he was in beyond two souls.

[@sonyyung5510]

Just so yall know Dahlia is known as the goddess of fate in Lithuanian mythology, something to think about along with the Oedipus connection as well.

[@ind1raa_]

I think that’s a bit too deep...

[@sonyyung5510]

@@ind1raa_ Hey you never know. Last game I played had alot of obscure references like that, so I wouldn't be surprised with this game either....

[@jpqgg]

@@sonyyung5510 oo what game? does manly have a gameplay of it?

[@jpqgg]

@@sonyyung5510 ooo kay! tysm!

[@nemanomenas2249]

lithuania mentioned

[@imabot1664]

I love the fact that during the second loop once the man broke in, manlys first idea was to go into the other room

[@acronolozki]

Cool fucking game-- its the first time i actually admired this camera perspective, ngl. Gotta love murder mysteries.

[@cronagorgon8869]

Ive noticed the small details.. the main painting in the living room changes seasons when you play through the game and change things and you can also see the cops car pull up to the apartment outside.. this game is so good..

[@marthofaltea1751]

You can also hear the cop come up the elevator

[@cronagorgon8869]

@@marthofaltea1751 that too!

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

I didn't like this game. It was just a random time loop which we have no idea how it works, why it was triggered, why after 8 years, what are we supposed to do to stop it, why the watch is valuable to the "cop", why the protag didn't question his lack of memory after killing his father, why he didn't just see his father dead infront of him etc. Interesting concept, but horribly executed.

[@potatothedueg7684]

@@jaideepshekhar4621 I beg to differ, the questions that are left unanswered make it better in my opinion.

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

@@potatothedueg7684 But it shouldn't abruptly just cut off. There should be something left to be imagined. Imagine a show where nothing makes sense. It leaves a lot of questions, and that doesn't make it better.

[@gamerguy9961]

It's sad the that the true ending is just you figuring out you will never get out of the time loop

[@L16htW4rr10r]

Really? It did say that you should wake up in the end. If Manly's theory about the MC was being hypnotized is true, the true end could simply mean that there is no reason to keep on looping to find all the possible branches and he could finally move on from his past.

[@jofx4051]

@@L16htW4rr10r After you say this I think you as MC should 'awake' from game so there is no continue in the game...?

[@L16htW4rr10r]

@@jofx4051 I didn't think about it that way, but that theory is very plausible and explained so much! Especially when you realize it is on the view was from the Second person perspective! (Or like as a God or something) I always wondered why it was like that from the very start! It's because it was "us" observing their lives!

[@emilyau8023]

I regret coming to the comment section before I finished the vid

[@fieldzs1552]

There’s no time loop, The father even said that the protag has an active imagination, The two endings are the incest ending or the empty apartment ending

[@GenericProtagonist7]

I'm usually not one for romance stuff, but that dude being so enamored with the concept of having a family with her that he completely forgets he's going to be brutally murdered is so sweet. This also seems like a less fucked up version of that movie The Butterfly Effect mixed with Groundhog Day.

[@hwng1254]

"Time is on my side" I've never heard something more powerful than that

[@ErinJeanette]

I literally read this comment as he said that. Always weird when that happens when scrolling lol

[@hwng1254]

@@ErinJeanette you're living in a simulation bro

[@dilapidatedcastillo500]

I just think of the Rolling Stones. R.I.P. Charlie Watts

[@jonathanrobles1734]

@@dilapidatedcastillo500 Fuck! He died yesterday

[@lowouu]

@@ErinJeanette BRO SAME LIKE W H A T

[@kiyaragrosz5017]

The twist I was expecting: He was the killer all along! The twist I got: ew ew ew eW EW EW EW

[@loiiysailor1177]

SWEET HOME ALABAMA!

[@kobatohanato876]

It was both damn

[@squiggletrash]

@@loiiysailor1177 *I WAS ABOUT TO SAY-*

[@jonathanrobles1734]

Well, it was both

[@beanzy1891]

Mmmmmmmmmmmm

[@jacqulyynw]

No one else mentioned it, but the carpet in the hall outside the apartment is the same as the Overlook Hotel in 'The Shining' film. Just thought it was interesting.

[@yandereskitty]

I thought it looked familiar

[@esmeselin4478]

Yess finally saw a comment that talked about it I instantly noticed it lol

[@sammysabo]

Yep lol

[@bonecag3]

I knew it looked familiar, couldn’t place it tho

[@YourPalKindred]

Glad I wasn't the only one to notice

[@lymb3914]

The story and voice acting here is actually amazing.

[@70sleadgarfieldmug]

Something I like about the progression of this game is that you’re not expected to retrace all of your steps perfectly to get back to the point where you were at before resetting. A lot of endings exist purely just to give you information but aren’t in and of themselves a true route to the ending, such as when you have to use the broken light switch to question the cop. It keeps the gameplay exciting and makes you have to try to connect the pieces of evidence to solve a mystery, instead of just relying on guesswork as to what arbitrary ending the game decides is the “true” outcome.

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

I didn't like this game. It was just a random time loop which we have no idea how it works, why it was triggered, why after 8 years, what are we supposed to do to stop it, why the watch is valuable to the "cop", why the protag didn't question his lack of memory after killing his father, why he didn't just see his father dead infront of him etc. Interesting concept, but horribly executed.

[@sskhussaini]

​@@jaideepshekhar4621I think a comment explained this best: Basically, the last ending in the video is the true ending, the father isn't dead yet, he hypnotized the male protagonist to make him imagine the entire scenario with his wife/sister and see why they wouldn't work out as a couple. If you listen closely to the ending dialogue, he'll say, "What a vivid imagination you have" or something to that effect.

[@katlicks]

That first twist was interesting That second twist was even more interesting That third twist was really sweet But that fourth twist was just "Eww" followed by "Eww"

[@SmartyPoohBear]

Read this comment while 1hr into the video, and just from that last statement... Oh boy, is it gonna be what I think it is... Edit: oh god, it is

[@katz5610]

really, the baby is not gonna be great 🙁

[@slowyourroll1146]

@@katz5610 I'm halfway into the video and judging from your comment I'm suspecting that last twist is something rather yucky.. I really hope it's not what I think it is EDIT: It was exactly what I expected it to be.. WTF

[@KookieDanish]

I'm almost to the fourth twist Edit: wtf

[@alleyah2592]

Yea samee I read this at an hour and ten minutes the twist frigging shocked me

[@SatumitheNeet]

Oh shit I was waiting for this it’s the perfect game for a Hero that is badass and very manly

[@SatumitheNeet]

@stonk for 12 minutes

[@rinyeongi6322]

@@SatumitheNeet nice

[@Kale6196]

@@SatumitheNeet SIXTY NINE

[@badcreations9527]

I love your comment

[@ThatMadBoxx]

The amounts of twists in the story makes it such a good game and never had a ever had any emotions like this over a game

[@Jaakeup]

can I just say I appreciate the creators who carefully place their midrolls in their videos? The way you timed the ad to play at the end of the first ending was great. What's even greater is that the ad was an ad for this game. Thank you for putting in that extra bit of time. It shows and I appreciate it.

[@f.n.8540]

meanwhile the only ads i get are "hey last chance" financial scams...

[@placeholder_username9528]

@@f.n.8540 - The creator doesn’t choose the ads, only where to place them. I think Google chooses the ads at random based on your history.

[@idonargesy8197]

@@f.n.8540 i keep getting that guy with the lucky bracelet that his wife cheated on him and the other one where he was homeless

[@pauledwards2052]

I always forget KZbin has ads. People who don't install adblock are so weird.

[@meh4315]

@@pauledwards2052 I mean, I would, but do they have that for mobile?

[@Looogacy]

This game is so amazing the concept Is unreal and it definitely deserves all the credit it has and more the story is frustrating but very intresting and if you fail you have a tiny bit more knowledge its very entertaining to play

[@ultimatelyawesomeultranigh384]

I think is saw this game as a footnote in game informer magazine like a year ago hmmm

[@lastfatality]

Insest baby this game is based off of rick and morty

[@sketchysketches381]

Seems fun to watch people play but frustrating as hell to play yourself

[@PhazonEnder]

@@lastfatality I have to ask, "incest" or "insert?"

[@lastfatality]

@@PhazonEnder incest

[@JannieDaMannie]

Willem Dafoe: *Interrogating your wife* James McAvoy: Sir? Sir? SIR??

[@mismylaa]

damn, the story writing on this is so good. the production quality, too. i wish i didn't spoil myself by watching the whole video though, would've loved to play this one.

[@dsagent]

This game has such a massive BRUH moment. Also imagine killing the wife and yourself and the cop walks in.

[@orangecalamari1906]

When we saw the "stop obsessing over her and wake up" line, it felt like the game literally told us to stop playing it already XD

[@skyez3038]

Game really said: What are you doing Step Bro 😩

[@parasitecandy1719]

Yeah but they missed a step

[@ranacroak9156]

@@parasitecandy1719 I-

[@galvanicmonkey4644]

I just stumbled on this video through recommendations, and I have got to say this was a fantastic watch. 30 mins after finishing this I realised this reminded me of old KZbin how there were long gameplays no edits like old PewDiePie, Markiplier and so on I thought that format wouldn't work anymore, you make it work somehow with some cut edits I just wanted to commend you on this amazing work and feat

[@ataarono]

its edited, boring repetition for the endings is mostly cut

[@drewpeacock9087]

There are countless edits

[@ausdorian3252]

I like how this game goes deep dramatic history learning acting And then you enter the new loop and is "let's do a little trolling"

[@jayceel251]

1:40:34 "the clock broke, weird" Maybe the clock breaking is a symbolism for his ever-lasting time loop. The minutes, the time, it will always go on but he will forever be stuck in the one hour: thinking about what, if anything, he could do differently. Because it is in that one moment everything changed. He chose to leave the one he loved without a word and now it's all he can think about. He lives in that one hour and has now conjured a world where everything could have been different but the cop (symbol for his dad) breaking in every 12 minutes shows that it isn't right and he knows it. That's why even if he gets a 'good ending' he resets because it isn't right. This poor man.

[@2189fallenangel]

Right?! :/

[@OhKeiSyd]

I loved your take on this and it’s the only one I read where I truly think this is what happened!

[@ataya6507]

I think the loop broked because he accepted something

[@farzana2686]

This is the best theory I've read yet. It makes the most sense.

[@farzana2686]

Notice how when he agrees to leave his sister alone, his future is so bleak and empty? He loves her and can't see happiness without her. Both endings where he returns back to the apartment with her in it, and the empty one, aren't real. It's that very decision he made in that room with his dad, that's where he was this whole time. All that we see here beyond that conversation with his dad are conjured up possible realities in his head.

[@NotepadAnon]

You could interpret the "Imagination" line to be that the Protagonist is imagining all these situations, but keeps living in this time loop scenario he's devised for himself. Especially if you pair it with the "Stab Your Wife" part where he's saying "I don't know why I'm doing this!" which is just some bizarre imagined scenario he's put himself in after undergoing DeFoe Mind Freaking. >Cop wants to "Protect his Daughter" which sounds awfully familiar right? >Protagonist keeps reliving the happy moments with his wife over-and-over again >His wife just happened to know his mother's name and put it on a onesie, she bought no less. >The Dad looking and sounding exactly like the Cop who "personally knew" him, but doesn't know anything about him or his daughter. The only "real" event taking place is the Mind Freakening by DeFoe after being confronted and wanting to forget.

[@areaxisthegurkha]

Don't forget the Dad turns bald like the cop. Also remember when the wife said her dad likes keeping guns? Just like the cop...

[@areaxisthegurkha]

Also "personally knew him" sounds like something the protagonist would've said since he's the child of an illegitimate affair..

[@yaboyfluid9124]

The twists and turns and the elite voice casting is crazy would never have guessed they voiced these characters

[@VueiyVisarelli]

38:01 "You thirsty?" * _pulls a full cup of water out of his pocket_ * I literally lol'd. 😂🤣

[@TheVillainHyde]

lol i was literally dying when that happen😂😂😂😂😂

[@treytavares1727]

"Why are they drinking tap water with desert?" Because all the money is going to rent, that apartment is 10k a month.

[@dionysosalters3624]

10k for this?!

[@92kosta]

@@dionysosalters3624Yes, in NewYork.

[@Whyeventhisthingexist]

Must be new yorker

[@spicymouths]

I have played this game, and it's chilling. We did try all of the possibilities: ex. hiding in the closet before your wife notices you, and let the day happen. It was a thrilling/traumatic (to some) experience when we did that. Voice actors did well on their job.

[@Jeff-fo3ck]

Yeah specially when the VAs are James McAvoy (professor xavier) And Willem Davoe (green goblin)

[@gamblorrr]

@@Jeff-fo3ck also Daisy Ridley

[@Jeff-fo3ck]

@@gamblorrr oh yes the Epic Rey

[@monke6395]

Yeah the voice acting looking grade A on my part

[@frds_skce]

@@Jeff-fo3ck *Willam Dafoe My guy, don't do him like that

[@FeedingTheDragons]

This game was done so well. The music, the voices, the conversations. I really dig the immersion. This was so good. Thanks for playing it.

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

I didn't like this game. It was just a random time loop which we have no idea how it works, why it was triggered, why after 8 years, what are we supposed to do to stop it, why the watch is valuable to the "cop", why the protag didn't question his lack of memory after killing his father, why he didn't just see his father dead infront of him etc. Interesting concept, but horribly executed.

[@krismas7531]

Honestly the MC is not at fault for any of this, the Dad died from his own gun from an accident while trying to beat up the MC. The Dad brought the MC into the world and never told him until it went past the line which never should have been crossed. The Dad Cheated on his wife and caused her to suicide, caused her daughter to feel so much pain. All of these burdens is somehow placed on the MC who did nothing wrong. The Dad should have told the truth to son and the daughter. He kept calling the MC a coward but truthfully it was the Dad who was at fault and the true coward here.

[@kalezuki9231]

Yes. The poor son ends up being a "monster" because of his father , messed up that he ends up falling in love / lust for the wrong person but from what I under stand he didn't know for a long time.

[@CaribouGutSludge]

The virgin leave the horror scenario before you get murdered vs the Chad go back in time and make it so the horror scenario never existed in the first place.

[@DMAN99]

by the sounds of it, Willem Dafoe plays both the “father” and the “cop” so I thought the implication was that they were the same person, especially since “father” loses his hair and looks like “cop” in one of the loops, so that would make “wife” “Bumblebee” then, but she sounds young and she’s sick apparently.

[@stinkymonke3622]

you could imply the sickness is the incest child wife has

[@blazerheata6479]

@@stinkymonke3622 I don't really understand this reply, but I do wanna say that there is an incestrial sickness (kind of) called Thalassemia that does cause one to go through chemotherapy during bone marrow transplant, which is one of the only few ways to treat it. So, possibly?

[@stinkymonke3622]

@@blazerheata6479 i mean bumblebee having cancer may be symbolic of wife being pregnant

[@blazerheata6479]

@@stinkymonke3622 ahh okay

[@bluerobo2]

The answer to that is simple. It's fake. The 12 minutes we're living is a figment of his sick imagination. The "cop" is the father coming back to repeatedly ruin his happiness like he had before. Bumblebee is fake too, she represents the daughter that he left behind 8 years ago since he left the "wife" after finding out the truth and never truly processed. The pocket watch is time that he wants to spend with his daughter, and the sickness? I think their daughter is sick, due to being the product of incest. So he wants time with her before she dies

[@HighlyRegardted]

This game is intense af but the repeated “sir” and “babe” was hilarious

[@samwilliams7400]

An ad for this game popped up while I was watching this gameplay. The world is truly imploding upon itself. Edit: in nomine Jesu Christi I thought getting 200 likes once was a lot how the hell did I get 1k thank you all-

[@ArmundJay]

me too! so weird lmao

[@somekidkekasuars7881]

Me too i got it as soon as i read your comment.

[@Markm8]

Holy shit i got a ad for the game after i read your comment like 2 minutes later

[@Asmr_Eclipse]

I literally got the ad for this game at the beginning of the vid before it even started… I was freaking the hell out for a hot minute

[@missmasquerade228]

Same, oh my god!

[@crypto66]

I always imagine the worst part about these time loop stories is the waiting, followed by having to do essentially the same things over and over again. It's already bad enough with the magic of skipping and montages, but imagine without.

[@broken_hq7807]

Me: "Wow, this is wrapping up really nicely!" *Realizes I'm only halfway through the video* Fu-

[@beatriceexd6676]

I HAD THE SAME REACTION