Why I DISLIKE FNAF In Real Time...

[@Tylerland264]

Please keep the disclaimer at the beginning of the video in mind. Also, please do NOT harass the developers of this game, that's stupid and immature. This video is meant to serve as critique towards the game. Also, in terms of why I reuploaded it? I just don't give a FUUUUUUUUCK anymore. LOL! Also, the video that was going to be in this video's place will still have a Feburary release. Just gonna grind hard! >:)

[@IrtazaFNAFPro]

Yeah this explains the reason behind the gore/harrasment back last year

[@JCCO2468]

No that was Honko being a total pathetic loser, don't globalize all haters into that guy like how many kiddies have done worryingly, even the dedicated haters of irt outted him after that crap.

[@ChaseLusby-i7n]

The worst video

[@TOM-ro7rt]

taaryn absolutely deserves everything for abusing and overworking his devs ofc not the other devs

[@theeggplantman13456]

I think the idea of moving Animatronics could be applied to FNAF 3 because it could make springtrap more alive and unnerving more in FNAF 3 than a remake of FNAF 1

[@creaturw]

I agree. This concept would work better for Fnaf 3 or maybe even Fnaf 6 because the robots arent lifeless souls of children anymore, they're not hiding their humanity in those games. Plus the phantoms already move which adds to the concept, and so does Springtrap in a couple instances

[@amalgamatheblob]

Yea, would be much cooler to put this concept on springtrap cause it would've fits on him a lot since he's a corps

[@Mr.sosmog]

Yeah and the phantoms have 5 or 3 animations to make them look more like hallucinations

[@eduardoaguero1220]

Hw fucked fnaf 3 up super hard too

[@WhiteSealtheGreat]

@@eduardoaguero1220 mmmm eh. i actually like the fnaf 3 mechanics

[@Egg_guy456]

A good chunk of the fnaf fandom: > hype tha game > be inpatience >send death treads and gore to the devs so thy work faster > game released rushed > wonders what went wrong.

[@GaelMiraflor]

Absolutely facts ✋🗿🤚

[@JCCO2468]

The team hyped the game themselves beyond repair, it wasn't the fans of IRT's fault as it was the LARGEST marketing campaign for any fangame I've ever seen, filling so many niches it was impossible NOT to be excited. The fans, even if they got impatient, more was so Taaryn, who tried to rush the coding of the game since the beggining until the infamous gore incident happened. The fans weren't at fault either, as no life shit eating loser "Honko" was behind it all with his underlings he has for friends, the gore possibly being AI generated as how the now removed gore in Dormitabis Remastered was generated in AI, being made to try and further his shadowy hacker persona when he can only hack people if they download his shit. The team didn't rush the game, as Taaryn made a poll for them to vote for the release date (both awful as it was announced in FNaTI's 10th anniversary and released in TRTF's 10th anniversary), but Taaryn did a shit move by forcing the new dev that got into the team to recode the ENTIRE game AFTER the release date, which was very bad and caused horrible optimization as a result. So yeah! The fandom, believe it or not, wasn't at fault here! Real Time Studio's director Taaryn and a unfunny edgy troll that haunts dormitabis are to blame here, doesn't help Taaryn deletes all negative criticism or even CONSTRUCTIVE criticism for IRT if people don't glaze it, pretty scummy.

[@AndrewJohn100]

@@GaelMiraflorit’s not the fandoms fault this game turned out the way it did.

[@MidaGames_]

The fact that the whole gimmick of this game is to watch them move, But if you do your night is ruined because of how much the power drains, is the pinnacle of bad game design in my opinion

[@GrigolaVirouDesenho]

Yooo it's Mida

[@CarlosYadielStudio]

I agree…

[@apairofhands3464]

The fact that a literal reskin of Freddy is a cooler character than whatever the lockjaw wannabe is supposed to be is hilarious to me

[@DjDeadpig]

Guess “Brother” has become the new Lockjaw

[@greenbeengamer64]

@@DjDeadpig let’s go!!!! Super Duck

[@mr.nobody2836]

More like "Sonichu" for FNAF

[@Aurum_301]

Damn that’s crazy

[@StardustXevo]

Let it be confirmed that springtrap has super cancer in fnaf 3 in real time, and there goes your golden ticket

[@I_X_1]

@@DjDeadpig yeah, I’d say it’s even worse to be honest. Looking back, Lockjaw wasn’t that bad looking in comparison to his surroundings

[@paytongauthier6452]

By the way, brother is actually a self input of the developer. so that’s probably why he was the main character of this game in the first place

[@cookies_and_mustard6414]

@@paytongauthier6452 apparently Brother came first, and then the dev based his oc design off of Brother. But it still doesn’t give a good impression to people either way.

[@Tapir123]

Lockjaw refre-

[@4notherguy]

Actually, Brother came first, the dev's OC was inspired by brother.

[@GaelMiraflor]

Yeah that’s the first impression I got when I saw it, it’s just literally the dev’s self insert. Not that they won’t work but couldn’t have been done well, but no, just shows up rarely.

[@3dible]

The virgin Brother Vs The chad Lockjaw

[@Ed_sheeran_in_a_monkey_costume]

You can completely break the animatronics and delete them from your night by spamming the monitor

[@MONO-97]

Bro how does that even happen 😭

[@Man_Aslume]

Ngl all jokes aside someone needs to bring this to their attention Someone other than me

[@Ed_sheeran_in_a_monkey_costume]

@MONO-97 The animation of the camera is moving up and down with the constant checks for animatronics moving when flipped up and everything else moving breaks the timing/logic of the game, making it completely freeze the animatronics and all moving stuff (like the fan and paper in your office stuck in a two frame loop) even tho the animatronics do move as normal off the stage but get removes after

[@Ed_sheeran_in_a_monkey_costume]

Its a easy way to get the 6 hour mode done

[@Ed_sheeran_in_a_monkey_costume]

@Man_Aslume I cant do the foxy night the intended way

[@emilioescobedo8487]

I like the idea of Foxy running down both halls, but why does he exist? From what I can recall, he is the only animatronic who can attack when you are not distracted, and if he fails to enter, he'll drain some power. He's here to prevent you from doing a Movie Mike, and sleep on the job., he's here to end your whole career, and yet, he's just there.

[@jakeford12]

If I recall, a gmod FNAF map did the same concept, but it actually works because of how in gmod you have to move to the place before foxy gets there.

[@Yasmiiin_24]

honestly, i feel like the idea of "fnaf moving in real time" couldve just been used on an original fnaf fangame, or maybe even a fnaf-inspired indie game, since RT studio seems to be making an indie project. everyone on the comments here seems to agree that the concept doesnt fit for the original game. afterall, how are security cameras from the 90's able to show such smooth footage, when even nowadays they cant do such thing LOL

[@creaturw]

@@FIDELELIZONDO-zw3oo Are your fingers tired from fighting for your life in every person's replies? Also, YOU didn't even play the game so you don't get to ask people if they have

[@Nikkkkkkkkkkk]

Unironically TRTF 1 > FNAF:IRT At least that one was so bad it was funny, this is just a major disappointment

[@freddyfzd]

Finally! A KZbinr that doesn't just glaze!!!

[@hellomitchell]

Seeing people on twitter talk about the Foxy rizz jumpscare like it was actually good was so funny to me, they tried to hype it up.

[@metrofox1424]

If I were to remake FNAF 1, I would have more supernatural things happen, such as chairs moving, doors closing, and children's laughter play in the background. FNAF in real time went in the direction of Steel Wool which, while I respect, don't feel a remake of FNAF 1 should do Edit: Going with a similar direction as Steel Wool isn't bad at all and can work in certain stories. I just feel a supernatural story like FNAF 1 shouldn't go that route

[@Jocka-v6f]

I do agree, I guess if they ever were to do this again they probably could add more to the game

[@JCCO2468]

Fun Fact!: the difficulty of this game being so easy was made on purpose to spite the MML community and avoid adding it to the Max Mode List, despite testers BEGGING AI Buffs as Taaryn forced the whole team to rush it when the game had to be recoded from the ground up on it's last month. This might be one of the best reviews on the game omg, you could've easily torn IRT apart too if you realized that Donovan duck and the rebuilt animatronics nullify the existence of FNaF 3 IRT, the only IRT game Taaryn made in advance behind his team's back 😭😭😭

[@DevelopingCity]

Just wanna state as a tester for the game the programmer for the game was not rushed. He had agreed to a deadline. Please don't spread misinformation about Real Time Studios

[@JCCO2468]

@@DevelopingCity A deadline voted before forcing the coder to recode the whole game, as far as my understanding reaches

[@JCCO2468]

@ Wanna make sure, please, ignoring any stuff I got wrong: you, alongside with the whole team in future projects by the Real Time Team, make sure to manage Taaryn's directing because he went very overambitious with this first project, there never seemed to be a "no" during the development of In Real Time, so please do help him pulish ideas and avoid whatever mess happened with this game. This comes from a genuine place of my heart, he's a begginer dev, and he got into all this trouble because he bit more than he could chew. Everyone on the team did a great job on what they did, but it's a shame the game turned out the way it did, makes me sad because if the ideas and gameplay had been pulished further this could've easily surpassed the first FNaF, but where it stands it's below mediocre...

[@shibainu2528]

There is one thing that occurred to me about Foxy, I'm not sure if they could do this *before* night 3, but I hope not because that would make this next bit a little better. Think back to the first time you played / watched FNAF, you probably were watching the animatronics "teleport" around the establishment, with the cameras getting interference whenever they move. I do suppose that makes sense, it would probably take a lot of resources to make animations for EVERY character on the cameras, which Scott didn't have at the time due to FNAF being the "last resort" game (If I recall correctly) Then in Night 2, you expect more of the same, and hear the phone guy talk about an animatronic in pirate's cove. You check and what do you know, there is what appears to be a fox behind that curtain. No biggie, just track them on the cameras, close the door when they are outside, you know what to do. The fox leaves pirates cove, and you expect to see them in the west hallway next. ... THEN THE GAME PULLS A LITERAL FAST ONE ON YOU, AND MAKES HIM *RUN* WITH SOUND EFFECTS AND EVERYTHING. Maybe you had the door down already, maybe you had a slow reaction time, whatever. Point is, that moment is TERRIFYING the first time you play the game since it already taught you that the animatronics will not visibly move on the cameras. Now, let's fast forward to FNAF:IRT. You probably are a FNAF veteran at this point, ready to expect anything. The first night had an intense finale, but whatever, maybe they just wanted to spice things up instead of making "FNAF 1, except they have animations" no biggie. Night 2, Foxy is now active, you learnt everything from him last time, they won't catch you by surprise this time when they run. Night 3... they throw a curveball at you by not only making an entire night DEDICATED to Foxy, but have him run down the left hallway, stop, turn around, and go to the other hallway instead. *Then* they put the cherry on top with having the music kick in at that exact moment you realize "HE'S GOING TO THE OTHER SIDE?!" Like, there is this other youtuber who goes by the name of Vonii, I don't know if they purposefully exaggerated their reaction for the content, but *that* is the reaction I am talking about. The same panic you had back in 2014 because Foxy ran on the cameras.

[@Wizardjones69]

You know its bad when the original fnaf 1 is scarier than the "updated version"

[@ElPolloLoco7689]

That has to be the dumbest point I've ever seen made about a horror game lmao Look at the Resident Evil remakes being overall less scary than their older counterpart, but still being considered good games and you'd know your point makes no sense. Make a point that makes sense instead of dogpiling for the sake of it. Edit: I don't even like the game btw, just felt like shitting on the comment.

[@Wizardjones69]

@ElPolloLoco7689 literally irl is a downgrade on every aspect Its a HORROR game

[@WaksWorld05]

I'm tired of every FNAF 1 remake coming out, as it's one of the least flawed of the main games. If you want to remake a FNAF game, why not 2 or Security Breach?

[@Chaotic_Overlord]

The reason why no one would remake security breach Is pretty obvious to me.

[@JaydenBakare]

​@Chaotic_Overlord People have actually done this funny enough. There's a Security Breach mod called FNaF Security Breach: Blast To The Past, I suggest you check it out.

[@lucaschannel726]

This game was so bad it actually made me compliment and say good things about security breach. The game that broke me and lead to me stop following the mainstream fnaf that I still don’t like is way better than fnaf in real time. Let that sit in

[@AndrewJohn100]

The mainstream FNaF concluded with FNaF 6. Of course the series was gonna move away from it.

[@lucaschannel726]

@@AndrewJohn100although I agree fnaf 6 is the true ending. Not really what I was talking about. I was saying how bad fnaf in real time was that it made me say good things about security breach a game I still don’t like and yet I have more nice things to say about it over in real time.

[@ReeceConnor.]

Honestly it sucks that this game was basically the Security Breach of the fan game genre because like Security Breach I feel like personally there’s so much potential for this game to be something truly special and unique but sadly it had to to suffer the fate of Security Breach but hopefully Real Time Studios will also follow the footsteps of Steel Wool where they’re future games can be massive improvements of their last games

[@ferringsylveon219]

That FnaF World boss music goes absolutely hard though.

[@Kenji_195]

"Made only for clout" The more I think about those words, that phrase, in a broader, more general and less specific context, the sadder it is Edit: I was notified with an answer I meant to respond but Idk if it was deleted or stupid youtube just didn't feel like displaying it, so just to make myself clear, I'm not saying THIS fangame especifically was made for clout, Idk if it's true or not, not gonna base my thoughts/argument on this video alone, this comment was referring to, again, in a broader, more general context, regardless if this one is or not, the idea alone of making something just for clout is sad

[@GustoGustoo]

i loved the "HOLY FAZBALLS!" in the analog cutscene, and this motivated me to put that line in every single fnaf fan-game i make and i also want to see other fnaf fan-games using that line aswell

[@Nostalgia2000erafan]

You know it’s going to be a unpopular opinion when Tyler has a hot take,

[@sarah-ht7lh]

Tbh i still like the game even after watching this video. Tho I must admit it has it's problems. If i were to make it, id have more atmosphere elements. These are possessed animatronics so why not have paranormal like events? Such as maybe in the dinning area a chair could fall over or forcefully go flying, or maybe lights on one camra go out for a bit, or even sometimes hearing sounds of what sounds like people near by but no ones there.

[@pik3177]

i feel like that the "tik tok" foxy boss music screams is like more of a steel wool's fnaf music to me

[@jamisonrules]

I think brother should have been replaced with golden Freddy

[@JCCO2468]

Could've been the Marionette to keep Goldie's mysticism, as she IS canonically in fnaf 1 thanks to fnaf 2

[@JaydenBakare]

Brother basically steals Golden Freddy's role, but then has no explanation for their character and barely makes an appearance. It worked for Golden Freddy, in fact, it was the main part of their character, but making Brother so vague and soulless did a disservice to whatever they wanted us to think of them.

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

The foxy boss fight is still so stupid. You shouldn’t have a night focused only on one character for a full night. Phisnom actually talked about fnaf plus back in December about what he would’ve had in the game and the game would’ve had the idea of character focus PERFECTLY with each night having a special event or a light gameplay change to introduce the new threat. Unlike IRT, these “character spotlight sequences” don’t just get in the way of the experience. If IRT had this where special events occurred each night like how the original fnaf 1 had rare camera changes, it would be a neat way to tell you “this character is active and here’s a little thing to let them stand out without interfering with the game”

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

@@FIDELELIZONDO-zw3oo have you even played the game

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

@ No. that’s all I needed to hear. You need substance in a game. This isn’t a movie you can’t have style in a game without an actual game to go with it

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

@ that doesn’t make it good. It’s still lazy, boring, and insanely clunky

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

@ it’s a G A M E

[@creaturw]

@@FIDELELIZONDO-zw3oo Then what is the point of making a game? Visual Novels are a completely different ball game than trying to create a game like Fnaf. They're lore-centric but they're designed in a way where the gameplay is still an important factor.

[@monobro141]

12:01 HOLD UP IF there is ANY FNAF 1 characte that should have a boss night it's Golden Freddy

[@ReaperAssassim]

we don't even know if golden freddy is real in fnaf 1

[@monobro141]

​@@ReaperAssassim I meant as a real threat that can kill you not the "he is a hallucination theory"

[@JCCO2468]

I find it hilarious that Bonnie was gonna be the one having the boss night instead before Foxy, it's so stupid it was even considered but not a Brother boss fight 😭

[@JaydenBakare]

​@@ReaperAssassim It's pretty much common knowledge nowadays that Golden Freddy is real.

[@IvolexST2]

I didn’t care for fnaf in real time but I never realized how not scary it is

[@WhiteSealtheGreat]

I actually did play it. but gave up on night 4. simply cause i was looking for chica in the cams and freddy's jumpscare made me fall out of my chair hitting my knee of the desk. but other then the animations nothing stood out to me

[@kekshrekmcgee5104]

2:05 Don't you think that "The worst FNAF fangame" is a little hyperbolic when games like Dormitabis and like Scratch Games exist?

[@Tylerland264]

Read the disclaimer

[@kekshrekmcgee5104]

@Tylerland264 Have u ever played the original Return to Freddy's? The game that tried to pass itself off as FNAF 3 just for Scott to get involved? The one that used reused assets and stole Candy's whole character design and renamed him Sugar? Now that's an objectively worse game

[@duckling8]

I'll take dormitabis game play over this

[@FNaFMAN623]

Well tbh, i did like the funny Foxy jumpscare. And i'm glad my boy Foxy gets a jumpscare like that!

[@MARKY2428]

What makes me roll my eyes is that everyone treats this whole ''omg fnaf Scott renders but recreated and they move'' thing like it's the second coming of christ when people like me and many others have been doing it 1:1 accurately in programs like SFM of all things since 2020. It ain't that special. But as soon as somebody turns it into a game OOH NEVER DONE BEFORE! One thing though, I have absolutely NO IDEA what you're talking about when you say the models don't look like the ones from Fnaf 1. They're..literally the same, this fangame if I recall correctly uses UFMP's Fnaf 1 pack which is basically Scott's models recreated to a tee. Not sure where you saw the differences. Maybe it's the different rendering settings the team could've used.

[@Man_Aslume]

You know it's bad if Roblox games are doing it before Real time

[@Man_Aslume]

Even fnaf 1 free roam games did it before Like creepy nights at Freddy's

[@AldinRamic]

Can I see your one-to-one recreations of five nights at Freddy's 1 renders?

[@overanalyst241]

@Man_Aslume i was gonna say, fnaf 2 reimagined single-handedly fixed fnaf 2 rng issue, kept the game challenging, cooked with animations, delivered with the lore that might actually be better than the original because it's more concise and gave us a whole ass new experience by inventing its own gameplay for a night roblox games are crazy fr

[@MARKY2428]

@@overanalyst241 Haha, right. Call me back when ALL the characters are in and every character jumpscares you. Then I'll consider it

[@TheFazzyDude]

Extra thing that confirms IRT is an industry plant: Before it released, they got into a loop of sorts where they collaborated with another fan-project, advertised the collab, didn't elaborate what the collab would do for the game, then they moved to another collab. Something that worries me with that is that this collab-loop is already starting to become normalized as something you NEED to do to get anywhere in the community, partially in thanks to IRT. Also, side-note: I think we can all agree IRT is worse than TRTF 2.

[@DevelopingCity]

Those collaborations consisted of Spike's Ahoy, The Fazbear Facility, FNAF Rewritten, and Blood & Gears. Freddy Fazbear from The Fazbear Facility can be seen on the cameras. Brother has an entire night dedicated to him in FNAF Rewritten. Blood & Gears and Spike's Ahoy haven't released yet.

[@TheFazzyDude]

@@DevelopingCity ..if I'm being honest, I didn't know about Facility Freddy being seen in the cams, but I did know of the Brother Bonus Night in FNaF: Rewritten

[@oofi422]

I'm so tired of modern Fnaf and Fnaf fanmade projects completely misunderstanding what made Fnaf scary and special in the first place.

[@fshhsbshsbsbsbsb1679]

@@oofi422 Bro, look at the live action film. Even Scott doesn't know nor care anymore

[@AndrewJohn100]

@@fshhsbshsbsbsbsb1679 It's an adaptation, and their subject to change.

[@oofi422]

@@fshhsbshsbsbsbsb1679 Exactly!

[@eveofinprov2600]

@@fshhsbshsbsbsbsb1679 care? I swear y’all just be saying things atp.

[@bluekirby6480]

Yeah, I rather download and play Fnaf Battington and Rewritten, cause (based on the no commentary playthough of both games), even though both games are just Fnaf 1, Battington has a great art style and Rewritten have a secret ending, with a different gameplay

[@JohnnyCarver2024OC]

I knew that game wasn’t gonna be special when the used the in real time gimmick. It’s like how they used 3D for movies

[@Cyclopsaws1]

Calling it the worst FNAF fan game is a bit of a stretch. Also that last message just felt like a jab at the creators, but it feels like they wanted to remake FNAF 1 but also make their own thing just seems like confusion ruined it

[@Tylerland264]

Read the disclaimer

[@Cyclopsaws1]

@ I did, I understand your points I just feel they did care but they didn’t know whether they wanted to recreate FNAF 1 or put their own spin on it

[@Mohamedahmed-g2k]

the director is literally a racist bigot dude

[@SwaggyG_2102]

I remember seeing this game being teased as the next big fnaf fangame when it was announced by fnaf tubers. Folks should've learned from Chompers not to put all your eggs into one fnaf fan basket.

[@CaptainZaimon]

My own impression so far (as somebody who hasn't been following the behind-the-scenes-drama in the slightest) has been that the devs clearly have plenty of talent and the core idea of "FNAF1 but with some new stuff to accommodate our OC" is really good (the Deluxe fangames were pretty much just that - albeit with characters alluded to in canon - and worked very very well as a pseudo-remake, I thought) but so many things just feel frankensteined together or suffering from the team ignoring the principle of "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" (like the Phone Guy - he genuinely brings so little to the table compared to the original FNAF1 calls it felt jarring). Also, some things seem tacked on just to make the game more "epic" or perhaps more hype for KZbinrs/streamers to react to (I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who got extreme tonal whiplash from the Foxy boss fight - I couldn't figure out if I'm supposed to feel scared, tense or laugh at the lame jokes Phone Guy drops).

[@Wizardjones69]

4:30 Hw does a much better job because of how huge they look in game, like pretty bulkier compared with the player Making them more a threat

[@Uzi_SolverAngel87]

I honestly agree with most of your opinions. I remember seeing the game get heavily advertised. It honestly reminds of some bad sequels because they would also sometimes overhype the movie with advertising. One controversy from the game I did not like was that there was someone on Twitter (I think) sending random gore images to the team behind the game. That is so appalling. No one should be harassed for that even though they are not putting a lot of passion for it atm I have not played Fnaf irt but I don’t think I should play it because of no passion being used to make the game. I also really don’t want to see Fnaf fan games just made for clout because to me, that ruins a community/fandom.

[@TheKaijuKing54]

I personally doubt that this game is an industry plant. The people behind it seem to actually care. Sure the game is flawed, but that doesn’t mean that the people behind were making it purely for the clout.

[@JCCO2468]

Only one that shows signs that did it for clout was Taaryn, as the team did have fun making it FOR THE MOST PART, Taaryn seems to be the only true problem with the game and why it turned out like this

[@TheKaijuKing54]

@ If you don't mind me asking, what's necessarily wrong with him? He seems like a chill guy to me.

[@JCCO2468]

@@TheKaijuKing54 As far as my research goes, he tried to keep on rushing the game even way before the gore incident caused by the demo's failure, creating a huge ass promotion campaign for his FANGAME, making shit behind the team's back for the future games (IRT 3) and shove characters of his future projects in them like Piñata Puppy. All of this sounds like just an overambitious begginer dev but... Then you realize that he IGNORES all criticism, if you complain about his game he deletes your comment (EVEN WHEN YOU'RE CONGRATULATING HIM, he deleted my comment on his apology when I was praising him for apologizing, just to then delete it alongside others comments, only leaving the ones glazing him, making me believe the apology was an attempt to save face), going as far as ignoring his OWN TEAM'S CRITICISMS AND FORCING THEM TO DO AS HE SAYS. Most of the problems with the game were made ON PURPOSE, not to be experimental, but out of spite, like the low diffictulty to shit on MML players, something that affected everyone in the end as this game puts you to sleep. Problems do not end there, as he seems to not just like to hog the recognition for the game, but also MONEY, as shown by the merch he made and how he was found talking so cold about his Piñata Puppy game to make it match and copy other mascot horrors, thinking about the money first and the game second. Damn, after the gore incident he left the team, but came back the second the new team was gonna redesign the brother, many people marking him out as a Narcisist for how much fucking attention he gave to a character that serves 0 purpose or meaning. I think there's more to say too like how all the collabs were shoed in as the team had no clear vision for them, but my brain cannot process it rn, it burns and Taaryn is a mess of a developer. I think the FNaF Movie game will be better than IRT because it'll be an original game, but IRT 2 and forward... Yeah no. All of this was made for attention, and while the people who worked on IRT were genuine, Taaryn wasn't there to show something he loved, he was there to get praised like the little saint he thinks he is... I hope fangames don't devolve into shit like IRT, games made for naive and slop youtubers, not for it's own players, which ironically was the main reason FNaF saved the horror game genre, it was made out of passion and desesperation, offering both youtubers AND players an actual chilling experience when at the time it was better just to watch the KZbinrs play the games instead of doing it yourself. Now... We're back at where the problem began, and that scares me. Would be glad if you could spread the word, filtering my thoughts as rn I am not in the right place of mind, but I do hope I didn't sound petty or entitled, all my worries come from a rightful place, as this game is the modern day equivalent of the first TRTF if it was as praised as the next Jr's, it terrifies me.

[@TheKaijuKing54]

@ Man, that’s messed up. I’m sorry to hear all that.

[@JohnSapato]

The only appeal I had for this game was the fact that I never played FNAF 1 before, I was one of those people who just seen a ton of videos of it back in the day, so I figured this would be a great way experience FNAF 1 fresh. But then I found out I had to own a copy of FNAF 1, which wouldn't be an issue if I thought it was worth it for the altered experience, since I already "experienced" normal fnaf 1. But a quick look at some reviews and what not I got put off from getting it. The fact they could move in real time wasn't really anything I was super hyped for since many fan games have already done this. My appeal was playing something that was the pure fnaf 1 experience but with movement.

[@monobro141]

kinda off Topic but in my worst fangames like I forgot to add Return To Freddy's/FNAF 3 Fan-Made Some excuse it because the developer was a kid or whatever but to me if you're just gonna plagerize Candy's and the official FNAF then you're on my shit list ACTUALLY PUT EFFORT INTO YOUR PRODUCT. Like fr what's the point of a copy and paste game i don't get it

[@Kaybeeguy]

My biggest gripe with this game is both the people who defend the game and the creator of the game. People excusing the creator being such a entitled brat really makes me angry and the creator himself just cannot take any form of constructive criticism at all. And people excusing it as a "small developers first game" is stupid imo. Just because you are an indie studio, doesn't mean you shouldn't ignore all standards, especially if the standards for a game is being put this high, and that doesn't mean a game isn't free from criticism. I believe people who defend the game and the creator are part of the problem. If FNAF IRT gets better, then I think that would be a good thing, but I really doubt it. Overall, my feelings are very similar. FNAF IRT is not just a massive disappointment, it's literally a disgrace to the first FNAF. It's overall just a shittier FNAF 1 and at that point, you might as well just replay FNAF 1.

[@flamingpaxtsc]

I didn't have much of an issue with FNAF in real time, and here's why: -I first heard about the game when it came out, so I didn't have any hype or expectations (this also means no background knowledge of anything the devs did) -I enjoy games mostly for their innovative gameplay, and since this didn't stray too far away from FNAF1, it was pretty good in that aspect -The presentation of the VHS tapes and 8-bit arcade sections were really neat -The scariness of FNAF1 was already lost on me as I've been a fan of this franchise for years now; I got what I wanted from the title, it's FNAF in real time Brother--and the lore--is the biggest problem for me, because...it just doesn't make sense??? I'm not good at reading into games as I'm playing them, but it really felt like Brother didn't have anything to do with Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria. Making an original character just for monetization purposes is cringe imo. I give fnaf irl a 7/10; I enjoyed playing it, but I don't have any desire to think about it anymore.

[@Foxyboi1985]

Monetization purposes for a game that's free...?

[@flamingpaxtsc]

@@Foxyboi1985 Yeah

[@Foxyboi1985]

@@flamingpaxtsc Read that sentence again and [think] about what's wrong with it.

[@flamingpaxtsc]

@@Foxyboi1985 Yeah, I did. I disagree. I don’t think monetizing a free game with merchandise is necessarily a bad thing, but making a new character that doesn’t fit into the game at all or have anything to do with the story-JUST for money-is.

[@Foxyboi1985]

@@flamingpaxtsc Do you really think that the FNaFIRT team created Brother just for marketing...? Fan games can't even legally make merch unless they're endorsed by Scott himself, that's the whole reason why a few fan games never got merch until after the Fanverse Initiative.

[@Brysontheblue]

Fnaf 1 will always be my favorite horror game ever,I know it has it flaws and I know many people dont like it but I think is by far the scariest in the series.But the idea of making them move all the time ruins the impact of seeing foxy running down the hall way and the jumpscares.Because the animatronics moving in original was scary because the player usaully sees them as stautes on the cameras.

[@sammysaysdontbeshy4851]

I blame the FNAF jr mangle boss for night 3

[@monobro141]

Also i'm just gonna say this this ain't a new idea fans have already animated the animatronics moving since 2014

[@Fazcoasters]

Donovan is supposed to be the father of a child who was killed by William Yet he’s screaming HOLY FAZBALLS lmao Also I gotta say, Dormitabis is easily the worst fangame purely because of the disgusting self insert crap

[@matheuspires2462]

5:26 idk, they look normal to me

[@Cooltimegaming]

me too

[@ryanlally8116]

I've always felt like this game was like Jr.'s 2.0.: A lot of people love it, a lot of people hate it, and I'm just inbetween and looking at it as a cool idea in concept that didn't live up to the hype in real time (mediocre with mild pain) Honestly I'm alright with that if it means we get more well-thought-of games in the future from this team!

[@cactusman60]

I feel like the concept would've worked a lot better if it was either focused on FNaF3 or Ennard's night in SL. That game and night only have 1 animatronic to focus on meaning the devs could spend more time fleshing out how the character would move. They can also easily play around with the body horror of those characters given how Ennard would likely be falling apart the more the night goes on and the more frantic Baby gets when you won't follow her commands and go to the scooping room, and Springtrap has a guy already in him. It'd be sick if on Night 5 William got tired / annoyed of the suit dragging him room to room and so tries to rip himself out of it and then a boss fight starts where the goal is to enrage William enough for him to be tricked into starting the fire himself. But no, instead we get silly paper plate Mangle, KZbin clickbait, and a bunch of cheap walk cycles disguising themselves as a FNaF1 remake that makes the copious amount of FNaF Plus remakes feel like something Steel Wool would shit out for Help Wanted 3.

[@YeEast-ud3gg]

are you insinuating that help wanted 1 and 2 are shit? if you are i dont know what world your living on, because both of them were absolutely amazing and did exactly what they aimed to do.

[@mayamia1607]

Also the lore is kind of confusing which is why I don't like it at all. Plus It's not very interesting imo I would rather know the whole bible lore lmao

[@superkoopa3695]

I want to agree with you on this, but I’ll have to wait until I can get my hands on the game so I can play it first. Although I did expect something off with the line “you’ve never seen us move like this before”. I mean I still like the song, but it kinda felt like the team was over exaggerating the “never” part considering there are other remakes of FNAF 1 that have done the exact same thing, and those are higher of quality. I really hope that the team can learn from this. Great video. ❤

[@Zebra_fandomfella03]

I understand your thoughts. But FNaF in real time is still better than the Fnaf+ fan recreation that used the ai phone guy Voice.

[@terrancebloxlore3209]

fnaf in real time is still better than Dormitabis (2018) since that game has [REDACTED]

[@tre_treanim]

Fr

[@terrancebloxlore3209]

@ have you seen the backstory for dormitabis

[@Lammy2023]

Tbh, fnaf plus is better than fnaf in real time. Don't care about the phone call. The gameplay is just more fun and scary.

[@pepebowser]

I genuinely never realized the phone guy voice was AI. I thought the voice sounded weird but I thought that was just because of an actor’s weird voice.

[@BF9211-1]

The game looks fine that’s all

[@MrHimalayas_]

The only reason I like this game is because I can play on my school computer which is a mac and last time I played it like 4 girls were watching me

[@soggy3464]

the huzz were NOT watching u lil bro 😭

[@Wendydeez76]

They make shit like this but unique and cool fan games like jolly 4 go through development hell or just get cancelled 😭

[@3dible]

That “or” is now an “and” for Jolly 4’s case

[@cube4982]

Just notice while watching 8 bit video on this he just easily cheese it by just turning on light of door, see a shadow, and close it and that it. Animatronic don't just rush in door near half second like that could have been punishment not keeping tabs on animatronic or they could sneak in within blind spot where you light door to see only bit of their shadow

[@victorgaminglounge3967]

Yeah TBH. As a person who ACTUALLY played FNAF 1 in Real Time myself (I have a full 2-part Playthrough of it and my run on 4/20 Mode for GOLLUMBOI), I enjoy this game for being just another typical remake/reimaging of FNAF 1 but with a twist. However, I would agree with everything you said ESPECIALLY regarding the gameplay since it was SO EASY. ESPECIALLY 4/20 Mode. Trust me, I have beaten 4/20 4 TIMES on the First Try for my playthrough and for GOLLUMBOI's FNAF 1 Max Mode List Discord Server compared to the OG FNAF 1 where it took me MULTIPLE ATTEMPTS to beat it for my playthroughs on IOS and PC (Twice to be exact) and to showcase my 4/20 Mode Run to GOLLUMBOI as well. Just to show you how easy it was, I beat the game TWICE on the EXACT SAME DAY to get Footage for my playthrough of the game. That's how easy it was. And while I do like everything that the game has to offer to spice things up such as the Mini Map, the Foxy Boss Battle (which was a bit difficult for me at first but then I got used to it on my other three playthroughs of the game once I got him down to a T), and the inclusion of a storyline taking place after the OG FNAF 1, but like what you said the execution of it all just flat out sucks. And plus after you have beaten the game you forget you even played it the following day (which has happened to me trust me). I might actually play the game again after I'm done with my next two playthroughs because before I gave the game a 7/10, but after seeing this video, Phisnom's video on this game, and the polarizing response this game has after its initial release, I'm possibly thinking of either giving it a 6/10 or a 5/10. I'll just have to wait and see when I revisit that game again.

[@victorgaminglounge3967]

However, for what I can say in my opinion I wouldn't consider this the worst version of FNAF 1 or the worst FNAF Fan Game of all time as I have two contenders. The worst FNAF 1 Remake in my opinion is FNAF 1: Entertainment Service. and The worst FNAF Fan Game I have played so far is a two-way tie between Five Nights at Withered Freddy's and Project: Freddy Legacy. Which I have done playthroughs of on my channel as well.

[@bonnieboy1487]

I think FNAF In Real Time is more or less a decent fnaf fan game. Seeing the animtronics move on the cameras and getting up close to you in the office is a really cool gimmick to me. However the jumpscares are pretty bad and brother should of defiantly had a boss fight instead of foxy. And I really don't like how useless the open world is in this game because how you could just go to the next night instantly on the main menu instead of doing it from the open world while avoiding the animatronics, it just defeats the purpose. And everything else is just fine, its just your average fnaf 1 remake. However I do think calling this the worst fnaf fan game ever is just false. Because this game is no where near as bad as games like DORMITABIS, FNAC 2, FNAF EVOLUTION, FINAL NIGHTS 1 AND THE ENTIERTY OF THE RETURN TO FREDDYS! Trust me FNAF In Real Time is not one those games its just overrated.

[@Tylerland264]

Read the disclaimer of the video

[@Jackrispy]

Such a flawless take. Great job talking about the lackluster gameplay too, people tend to skip that :)

[@maxthedeveloper179]

Also, in Brother's jumpscare sound OMG meme sound

[@marcelolopes735]

14:55 I see nothing wrong about this tbh. Foxy is just trying to rizz you up

[@foxythepirate3335]

I think we need to stop making fnaf 1 remakes

[@monobro141]

True like FNAF + got cancelled over an argument over a mid ah game FNAF + ripoffs have viruses and one ai Scott's voice And then we have this

[@extremempsilvamps5851]

@@monobro141 Real Time is not that bad to be compared to the rip off who used ai voice

[@pepebowser]

What about Next week at Freddy’s and FNAF 1 rewritten?

[@matheuspires2462]

@@pepebowser fnaf rewritten is good But next week at freddys is a bit too complex You have to read lots of instructions while the animatronics roam around and you have to control multiple power panels, and the 'definitely not a virus desktop buddy' can be sometimes annoying

[@pepebowser]

@@matheuspires2462fair. I mean I never had a problem. Ok I’ll admit there were times I did get annoyed at Comcat. But I still had fun with the game. I was able to beat night 6 after my first couple tries

[@ghak17hakim25]

Fnaf 1 fan made remakes are overused as hell like we need more other remake like 2,3,4, etc

[@danthebluetank6636]

This is honestly what (sorta) worries me if I ever make my own fan game one day I like the idea of the game. It was honestly funny to see people go crazy over not finding the animatronics thinking it was a bug when in reality they had literally just moved through the blind spot, which is something I kinda like and it brings tension until you can track them down again. I got no clue what happened behind the scenes…But I will say, it’s a curse happening in this fanbase :/

[@TeenelsonGaming]

Im not rewriting my comment from the original upload. But i still agree with her. This fangame sucks and i would rather play fnaf deluxe edition.

[@ZaWaterPumpkin]

I have no idea if I should re-comment with me saying how long it will take for Taaryn to block you on Twitter

[@Charizardslash]

This fangame's main concept doesn't even work Help Wanted already had the animatronics moving... IN REAL TIME

[@MoltenRage41]

This should be another story of devs just not taking criticism instead of taking it in running with it and making something better they become defiant thinking all the criticism is just from "this politic" or "they're just jealous of My success" stuff and unfortunately because of that they don't make a very good game it's just unfortunate that these guys got in their hands that they think they made a really good game and didn't accept any criticism from the demo that's my advice to people criticism is necessary to make better things you've got to accept it or if you don't you make things like this they cluttered mess that this could have been so much better if they just accepted the criticism from people from the demo who gave them really good criticism to improve it so yeah if you're a film or game maker criticism is something you need to accept. Now thank you for listening to my TED talk.

[@Daqfire7]

Yay the video is back up

[@wiedzmiarz]

Honestly, I think calling it the worst fnaf fangame in history is a bit of a streach. Especially when The Return to Freddy's exists. Is FnaF IRT bad? Some people can say it. I had my fun with it while playing but it sure is really braindead sometimes and has its own problems (like Brother. I still don't understand that guy xd) One day I'll finally do that God Forsaken 6 hour Night for shits and giggles

[@Tylerland264]

Read the disclaimer

[@wiedzmiarz]

​@@Tylerland264Wait, there was one? Wth, yt bugged and cut The first 5 seconds of the video for me lmao

[@jkilolboom9295]

My only thing i got against the game is how bad it runs on my compute (i got it this december) like the nights start eith a black screem for the first few minutes and the video lag

[@creaturw]

I replied to eggplant but I think I should expand my thoughts. I think IRT would work better as a recreation of Fnaf 3 or Fnaf 6 (with the proper animatronic AI like the main criticism of this game). With the first couple games, the appeal behind them is lifeless still robots with minimal movement, and those small instances of moving further scare the player because of it (Foxy in Fnaf 1). Fnaf 3 shows the phantoms and Springtrap himself moving a lot more in certain cases, and Springtrap is more linked to his human self than any others since he's still William's corpse. Fnaf 6 would have been another great option for Taryyn to explore more of the human souls' lore like he seemed to want to here. The robots there aren't hiding their humanity anymore and they're conscious to the point of speaking in their human voices (at least Liz and William), so they can be given more life and movement if he wants.

[@TGUBOfficial]

I never liked the concept of this game since the moment I heard of it, I always felt like something was off about it. I played it on launch day, and I vented about how fucking awful this game was with one of my groups on discord, and we all agreed that it was garbage. You had everything 100% correct about what was wrong about this game, and I respect you for making a video about this disgrace of a fangame. That's not even mentioning the failed merch line that fnaf irt was supposed to have, it was sketchy AF dude . . .

[@JCCO2468]

Doesn't help that: 1. Piñata Puppy (percy ripoff) was gonna be a character in IRT 3 before it even got announced. 2. Taaryn deletes almost ALL criticism that talks the game on a bad light despite being honest, EVEN in his """apology""" he did where didn't tackle half the shit he did to his team. If I don't trust him as a director, less im going to trust him in mascot horror.

[@FruityLegion]

idk tbh when i played it i was like WHOAAH I WAITED FOR THIS but... its just fnaf 1 but a little more different and now its boring for me

[@Jocka-v6f]

Though I like this game a lot, I agree there are a lot of ways it could be improved

[@sandralugo73]

I knew you would disliked it as many people hated in real time

[@efecengizyakskltavuk8301]

So... you are the new UnderTheMayo of this game...good

[@Thy_Punishment_Is_OOF]

You played it?

[@phantomgamer2241]

Many things with this fangame are soooo wrong, this was sell as a “retelling of the story of the first game” yet we have a fnaf 1 sequel, with more easy gameplay, extra unnecessary content, and the brother, he was sell as a important character to only be use only for 6 minutes of the game, the worst fangame I have ever seen, and that’s to much thinking that trtf2 is a thing

[@monobro141]

Speaking of TikTok Foxy is it me or does EVERY FNAF + RIPOFF fell like some TikTok FNAF After Dark edit bs

[@PSIkid]

I always felt like there was something off about this fangame. You put into words what I was thinking.

[@Nalyd69420]

0:50 what huh how does one come to that conclusion

[@ToyToyTL3]

Right? Like what does that have to do with ANYTHING?

[@matheuspires2462]

I have no idea how giving the main villain a orientation helps with the story The game made me full of questions and almost no answers

[@whiirl.1]

i did played it and after watching your video i noticed i have NO critical thinking skills.

[@cynical_glade2781]

FINALLY, SOMEONE HAS THE GUTS TO SAY THIS

[@ScanLineMangle5083]

I actually want to express my opinion on fnaf in real time. Honestly I really really disliked the game before its initial release of the game or the demo. Now the points that you made on the video are valid and I agree with those points. I want to add another layer to it. I think the name fnaf in real time is just not exciting or interesting, at all because when I saw the name it wasn’t interesting the thing was the game was basically a ripoff of fnaf 1 that Scott made but added movement to the animatronics for visual appeal, and honestly it is ass. Also the game was doomed to fail when it was first teased and released.

[@charlieweaver2038]

A part of me feel like this game get a bit too much over hate. Considering the fact people gave death threats and gore to the developers and everyone on twitter had a completely meltdown all because they won an award. But I see where people are coming form. Maybe the fnaf movie game will be better, would you make a video on that?

[@thekeybladeninjaturtle7380]

Well, at least the developer of the game is a nice guy to talk to, right? ....Right? Unrelated note: Have you seen FNAF Vs TF2? If not, do you think you can do a video about it? I'm intrigued to hear your thoughts on it

[@HighBarReviews]

Everyone said I was just negative when I said this was gonna be ass, being a D-1 hater has it's benefits

[@GSPScorp]

*This is my first exposure to IRT aside from the 6 hour mode. I’ve heard some bad things but from this review alone it’s a tad bit overrated. BUT, this should’ve been a mod. I like the idea of seeing the animatronics move, in the original game, the cameras breaking just felt tacky to me rather than mysterious. But all these unnecessary gameplay changes, like I just wish this was a mod I could apply to the original game instead of… this.*

[@williamtatum5002]

I’m going to be hated for saying this… At least this game is somewhat better than Dormitabis

[@GAMERJAG]

I played until the foxy boss fight and then i just closed the game becuase the night was so annoying with the bad voice acting on the call, the loud alarm when you close 2 doors, and the boss music. Couldnt hear myself think. And i hate the minimap aswell

[@indroopp]

Let it be goofy. I get its trying to remake fnaf 1, but its kind of its own self contained thing that just so happens to be about fnaf 1. I don't see how its disrespectful

[@CaitEden53]

I really like what I’ve seen of this game (though I’ve only watched Dawko’s playthrough, I haven’t actually played it, you totally called me out lmao) but these are all pretty good criticisms and they do make sense :) Nice video!

[@lordofthefeathers923]

I knew i wasn't the only one who didn't really like this game. The concept is great but, the execution was awful. The fucking dubstep playing at the "Foxy Boss Fight" just screams parody ESPECIALLY his jumpscare

[@crimsonnight8936]

what a trainwreck this game was