Uncovering Bonnie's Killer - FNAF Theory

In this video we revisit the very first theory I did on the channel. How killed Glamrock Bonnie? Using new evidence from help wanted 2, we can finally put this question to rest.
Clips used:
FusionZGamer: • FNAF Security Breach R...
Game_track: • HEADLESS FREDDY CHASE ...
Aloneaardvark: • Secret Vanny Chasing G...
Music:
Caught in a Loop - Security Breach OST
Alchemist's Fantasy - Pizzeria Simulator OST
Smashing Windshields - Pizzeria Simulator OST
25th Hour - Schlatt Crossing
We Shop Song - Lud and Schlatts Musical Emporium
Winter - Vivaldi
Elevator 3 - Security Breach OST
Timestamps:
00:00 Intro
00:13 Why Did I Revisit This Theory?
00:55 Starting With the Evidence
04:38 Looking at Our Old Suspects
06:14 Our New Suspect, Cassie's Dad
08:09 How He Did It
10:54 Outro

[@FoxNinja4000]

Bonnie accidentally spills Monty mystery mix on himself, goes to gator golf to ask Monty if he knows how to get the stain off, gets attacked by Chica who went into a pizza frenzy and unintentionally killed Bonnie. Chica hides his body and lives secretly in guilt.

[@TerminalError]

Not a bad idea, especially since Twisted Animatronic pointed out that Chica can sometimes cry when she thinks she's alone

[@kitthemusician]

Chica goes crazy for the pizza flavored goo… finds it in Bonnie bowl… blames Bonnie… and takes it out on him in Bonnie Bowl. I don’t think it could have been the Cassie’s dad bot… interesting take though! Could see how it could work

[@TerminalError]

Thanks! I definitely think Chica is a good possibility, too, especially since she apparently cries when she thinks she's alone. Twisted animatronic made a video covering her crying that's really interesting and almost made me want to change who I thought it was

[@skyenight-by8yh]

As much as I want to *think* Monty didn’t do it, at least forcefully since he was probably possessed by the glitch, the evidence still seems to point there. I honestly didn’t expect Cassie’s father to be the suspect, looking through this video, I can honestly see how that’s possible. 😅

[@TerminalError]

Honestly, I feel like people not even considering him, makes him the most likely.

[@Chills-zb9lj]

Counter theory, the blob did it because it thought it was burntrap

[@TerminalError]

Could be, but why wouldn't the Blob add Bonnie to itself?

[@itsraeofsunshine]

Always here for Glamrock Bonnie theories 👏🏼

[@TerminalError]

Gotta find who did my guy dirty! Also, I liked your sims build video!

[@VillainVac]

why no focus on aspects of the lore that can lead to actual importance.

[@v1ct0rygames32]

The contradictions between Bonnie's circumstances in SB and RUIN, as well as a line in The Storyteller has made me come to the conclusion that Bonnie was replaced while he was active and THEN killed. For example: - His green room is said to be in Rockstar Row in SB, but then we find his green room (confirmed by both the pause screen and the files) behind Bonnie Bowl in RUIN. - idk whether you believe the books are canon to the games, but even if you don't, Tales has been shown to be pretty useful when figuring out SB / RUIN, however, in "The Storyteller", it mentions a character in Bonnie Bowl acting up. While not directly calling the character Bonnie, we only know of one Bonnie Bowl related character. The weird thing about this is Monty is part of the main band during the story

[@TerminalError]

That's not a bad theory! It would make sense as to why we don't find Bonnie with his claws in ruin, and the note saying Monty is replacing him says Bonnie is out of commission, not missing, so he could've been damaged from an earlier event and got replaced because of it. Though it does raise some more questions, like how damaged does someone have to be to be replaced since Monty is said to be damaged by the hurricane bucket multiple times and needs constant repairs. Also, why would someone frame Monty if he's already in the band (or if you think Monty did it, why would he if he is already a band member)? Pretty good theory, gotta ponder this a bit.

[@orizingaming]

Very interesting. I don’t believe Cassie's dad would do it. There is a lot of evidence and I'm not sure, but when i theory craft I'll keep this in mind. You've done a great job with all thses theories! :3

[@TerminalError]

Thank you! I know it might be a stretch, but I definitely feel it could be him. It definitely feels stronger than staff bot lol

[@iballisticwolf0]

I love and appreciate your dedication, care, and effort put into your theories, including this one!! I love the creative thinking.

[@TerminalError]

Thank you! I'm glad you like them!

[@rfolwell7557]

I still dont believe it was cassies dad but i dont think it was monty either. At least your theory this time was a step up from mop bot!

[@TerminalError]

That's true! Not blaming poor mop bot this time!

[@1x3x23]

You're now one of the best theorists who makes videos regularly, keep it up!

[@TerminalError]

I'm gonna keep going till I burn out! Or maybe skip a week for a vacation so I don't burn out lol

[@SnarkyTeaSipper]

This is probably a very stupid theory I have, but what if Monty did actually axe Bonnie off… because Bonnie was either mistaken for Vanny, or Bonnie himself was being suspicious. Sketchy characters in the history of Fazbear Entertainment tend to be rabbit-oriented, especially if they have ties or relations to Afton, and apparently, according to the logs, the public are still calling out Fazbear Entertainment about what happened to “those kids”. Maybe Bonnie was under control, acting majorly suspicious possibly to the point where the public noticed, and so when either when Monty was ordered to dispatch of him, or if he did it himself because he sensed danger in his own Gator Golf area, Fazbear Entertainment decided to erase any mention of Bonnie from that point on. They should definitely have the ability to make copies of their animatronics, based on all the spare endoskeletons, much bigger budget in comparison to old locations and the massive Parts and Services area, (which I do keep looking at as an annoying plot hole in the whole Missing Bonnie story, like why wouldn’t they use any of these instead of this dumb cover up?), but if Bonnie was mighty sketchy, then they would go ahead with a cover up? Not to mention the Prototype Freddy, even if it is a red herring, it still opens up the idea that copies of the characters could be produced. I have noticed a lot of Bonnie theories always say he’s 100% a good guy, and never consider he might be sketchy. Either from his own volition, or if he was controlled by Glitchtrap. Maybe Bonnie was the first animatronic to be controlled based on the weird rabbit motif that seems to plague the vast majority of antagonist characters? Which might then lead to the VANNI mask having to incorporate a vanishing feature if Glitchtrap’s supposed first pawn was easily found and broken. Very dumb, very sorry

[@TerminalError]

Not dumb! Very good, actually! In fact, it would give a reason why fazbear would actually let Monty join the band after Bonnie's disappearance even though his last sighting was in Gator golf. I tend to forget about the plot hole of fazbear just making a new Bonnie, but maybe it has something to do with him not getting fully deactivated. Maybe the pizzaplex is programmed to only have 1 of each animatronic activated in the building at once so they don't have 5 Freddy's running around.

[@SnarkyTeaSipper]

@@TerminalError that’s a pretty good point, it would be easier to keep track of only one copy instead of multiple. However, if the staff were absolutely not able to find Bonnie after tracking him from the cameras to Monty Golf, then it would probably be reasonable for them to cut their losses and build a new Bonnie, possibly even with a new “Bonnie save file” for his programming, as it were. It would still be scummy of them to replace a character like that, especially it’s all but confirmed they treat their advanced human-like AIs like dirt, so I don’t think that’s too unexpected for Fazbear Entertainment to do that. They aren’t known for being 100% squeaky clean. It might make more sense for them to cut corners this way, as it involves only one endo being used and possibly only a handful of staff to work on it. It makes less sense for for them to go through an extremely thorough and possibly very expensive deep clean of all Bonnie memorabilia and replacing it with Monty stuff. In a location that’s estimated to be the size of a stadium with 7 floors, and with absolutely no oversights. And would probably require some additional third party workers, like interior designers, electricians, merchandise producers etc. That is, unless they were forced to retire Bonnie from the public eye, one way or another. I have no idea why my thoughts on this are way too thorough, though I’m trying to read into the Missing Bonnie situation almost entirely from a business perspective (disclaimer, I am not good with business)

[@robertlperez8731]

now this i can get behind, though i think the princess really did recognize cassies dad, if he's Jeremy from help wanted, and especially if she is Cassidy. i could totally see this though, and i definitely think the monty mix is the reason for the green on Bonnie. overall great theory, luv this reflecting on your first theory, you have come a far ways in such a short amount of time. love your theories and heres to so many more 💜

[@TerminalError]

Thank you! Cassidy definitely could've recognized Jeremy since he seems to be a recurring character now. We'll hopefully see Cassidy and Jeremy interact more in the future since they both seem to be guarding spirits of some sort. It's was really exciting to reflect on my first theory, and I definitely feel like I've improved vastly in these few months, which is an amazing feeling! I can't wait to see how I'll be in another year!

[@justafriendlycryptid]

"You... I remeber you from *that* day all those years ago. Youre one of Mikes friends." Some edgy silly that came to my mind.

[@TerminalError]

I could definitely see afton holding an almost 50 year old grudge on poor Jeremy. Also, I had no idea you could bold text in a comment?!

[@justafriendlycryptid]

@@TerminalError Aye you can make things bold with two *'s You can also -strike- words out with two -'s. d(^

[@Unknowncameraman15]

In hw2 we see claw marks on the model of Bonnie and it looks like the gator did it 🐊

[@TerminalError]

Those marks are on the ruin model, too. Still, it looks similar to the damage Freddy gets from the staff bots to me.

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

Well hw2 does give more proof that Monty offed Bonnie because for a gutterball the animation on the screen shows Monty crushing and replacing Bonnie on the screen. Also about the claw things, no Monty always had claws they aren’t specifically for the bassist. I mean both Freddy and Roxy have claws. Paint transfer also fits because the green on Monty’s claws are exactly where a plaint transfer would be. We also know there are tons of secret tunnels and utilitunnels that have no cams that Monty could have traveled through.

[@Unknowncameraman15]

@@bonnieplushtuber5517 agreed

[@thehackedcat2644]

I’m SO exicted for the FNaF timeline video (He said it in his live)

[@Jack-ok6oo]

this video is fire keep it up

[@TerminalError]

Will do 🫡

[@TheEKdude]

Whenever I watch FNaF theories, especially yours, it feels as if I'm watching the news. And it's a great feeling.

[@TerminalError]

Lol, I thought I looked like a news anchor while recording this

[@That_Purple_Bandit]

3:20 It's interesting, but I also feel that it's probably not likely. We have never seen anything about Bonnie with a green jumpsuit, and I just wonder "why?". StealWool deciding that to be it feels really strange, because if the attack was supposed to look like Monty did it (Whether he was framed or not.), there are much better ways to explain the green on him.

[@TerminalError]

That's true. That's why I didn't go with that idea in this theory. Just wanted to cover my ground on possible reasons there's green on Bonnie

[@That_Purple_Bandit]

@TerminalError I know, I found your thoughts very interesting and enjoyed to hear and reminisce on. Keep doing what you're doing, king! 👍

[@aileenboyd2660]

This is like dogon rompa investigation

[@TerminalError]

Is that a good thing? I haven't played it

[@Headshotzer]

Ello there

[@TerminalError]

General Kenobi!

[@avuizosm5405]

Hello! In your previous theory, you said that you wanted to make your own FNaF timeline. I wanted to know your opinion on something, because I am making one of my own. Do you think Elizabeth or the Crying child died first? In FNaF 4 mini games , a lot of evidence shows that Elizabeth died first (empty girl's room etc.) but that would not make sense, because why would Afton build Circus Baby so early in the timeline. What do you think? By the way, your theories are well thought out, keep it up.

[@GoofyFNaF_Player]

Hey TerminalError!How’s the next video going?(I’m thehackedcat on a different channel)

[@forgod2388]

u already made a theory on that!

[@TerminalError]

Yes, but this is updated

[@user-yb2rx6yp9b]

Why when we go outside in winter in FNAF:HW (pizza party ending) we see Pizzaplex being built in the middle of nowhere? Or is it just because developers didnt want to see community making theories about the city? Or is it new city being built lol

[@amyrose6333]

The damage isn’t from a attack, it’s from him falling from the catwalks in gator golf which is identical to shattered Monty’s damage, so he either fell or got pushed off but there is green paint, which could be Monty or Roxy, but they would have have to carry bonnie to bonnie bowl which leaves Monty because Roxy couldn’t be able to carry bonnie

[@TerminalError]

Bonnie getting pushed off the catwalks is an attack. The damage is similar to Monty falling from the catwalks except for Bonnie being unable to move after. The damage is closer to Freddy getting disassembled by staff bots. If Bonnie was pushed, he should've also survived the fall unless there was more to the attack. Monty doesn't have a motive for destroying Bonnie since he seems to have more of a grudge on Freddy, and even if he did do it, fazbear entertainment wouldn't let a dangerous animatronic on stage and would most likely decommision him and use a safer animatronic to replace Bonnie, like Mr hippo

[@Levisworld9]

Everyone you should do this 4:30

[@TerminalError]

Listen to this guy! He knows what he's talking about!

[@Oreo-kv4gc]

Monty didn't have Upgraded claws before Bonnie was destroyed only after Bonnie was destroyed Also Monty looked up to glamrock Bonnie as a fan idol friend Also vanny Glitch trap burntrap william destroyed glamrock bonnie they would

[@TheRadioDemon892]

by god I'm early, 32nd person to like the video!

[@TerminalError]

You were early, but I'm late to respond. Ironic. Hope you enjoyed Alastor!

[@TheRadioDemon892]

@@TerminalError I did keep with the good content and enjoy your day

[@mizzviolet]

i have a crush on you 😔 you make me think

[@aetheriox463]

its monty. thats who did it.

[@TerminalError]

I'm a believer that he didn't do it still 🥲

[@That_Purple_Bandit]

It feels way too obvious to be Monty who did it, such a deep mystery being that obvious doesn't feel right...

[@real-lkjohhnycagearthurmorgan]

sigma

[@ethanburley6877]

Hey terminal error u remember ur video about why the fredbear hat changes I think I know why it might change U see when chuck e cheese pizza time theatre opened I heard in each location the characters had different cosmetics on And in fnaf 3 if I'm correct phone guy says "the suits have been put in the multiple freddy locations" if there was only one fredbear diner why would he say multiple? So I think there was 3 fredbear diners and in each one they gave fredbear a different hat and bowtie but that's just my theory