UNSOLVED: Tennessee's Shelley Mook case

Young mother and teacher Shelley Mook dropped off her daughter at her ex-husband's house in Shelbyville, Tennessee, on Feb. 28, 2011, and has not been seen since.
From 2017: bit.ly/2TpsXez

[@lsoviravong]

I'm sick of enabling families that support poor/toxic behavior like Tyler's. Tyler is the way that he is because his parents always bailed him out and excused his behavior.

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

Same. The parents are as guilty as he is in my opinion

[@robertmahler8894]

Agreed, but also how about women that ignore multiple red flags and warning signs that they are in abusive and dysfunctional entanglement,why is that?

[@hayalistanbul5418]

@@robertmahler8894 Manipulations, and threating .

[@ericaf2024]

💯

[@lsoviravong]

I agree……most women are easier targets for certain types of men bc of their lack of self worth, what they’ve seen demonstrated at home, temperament, etc. Same goes for men who are attracted to dominating abusive women.

[@cfq.tufanuf7601]

During the 911 "butt" call he was talking to his father so this tells me that his father was probably the one who drove him back after he'd burnt the car out. Tyler's father knows what his son done alright!

[@misskay8131]

His father definitely knows what he did and had something to do with it!

[@cindylemons9677]

Totally agree!!!

[@paulinamagana7529]

Yass

[@udliketoknow]

I think Andrew is aware of what happened also because he almost sat back and watched her get murdered and then was hesitant on weather not to be a witness. I think he was hesitant because he didn't want it to lead to opening up the other can of beans

[@Joanla1954]

His dad likely taught him how to be a bully too.

[@dallassunderland]

Mrs.Mook was my 8th grade english teacher. She would come and sit by me and a friend and talk about movies, music etc at Harris Middle and expressed that she wasn’t looking forward to having to go to her ex husbands to pick up her daughter. The next day she wasn’t there, then the next then the next. After about a week they pulled us into the auditorium and told us all she was missing. She was a great teacher, woman and mother. We always looked forward to her classes, she was seeing another teacher Coach King who was such a nice, cool, reserved guy before she had went missing

[@llamalady8700]

Bullshit. A teacher is NOT going to discuss personal difficulties with CHILDREN she TEACHES.

[@hesherette]

Good brother Andrew to tell the truth about what happened on the boat! major respect for that wonderful man going with his morals instead of his enabling family.

[@joaquimrodriguez8961]

One would hope it's the truth.

[@ktrain1100]

Yes it was good to know that even though he knows his brother's crazy personality, he did the right thing. Some brothers and sisters will protect them and they are only adding fuel to the fire.

[@julie.1081]

That had to be one of the most difficult things he'll ever do. But he proved he was a much better man than his brother. I hope his family hasn't shunned him.

[@halo218813]

@@julie.1081 he'd be better off if they did shun him. They are garbage people 🤷‍♂️

[@nookac0la]

This man literally attempted murder and only got battery?? Tf kind of world do we live in

[@YoungHaveNot]

Meh

[@LaLaLonna]

A man's world

[@JW-28]

@@LaLaLonna yeah right. Wtf drugs are u on?

[@theresafoss7849]

@@JW-28 apparently a truth serum.

[@jashardwallington]

@@LaLaLonna theres women who get away with making false rape claims an nothing happens to them. I want justice an for all Regardless of gender innocent until proven gulity

[@j9andphoenix]

The fact he answered that one question spoke volumes - he was going to mark his territory that HE was the last man she ever had - not her new boyfriend. - either way - he is guilty. His body language is full of contempt and arrogance. And I wrote that before I saw what happened to Robyn - thank God that Andrew chose to do the right thing.

[@jenisbetzke6228]

.....and - just in case - to explain his DNA on her body!

[@dozzer009]

I’d like to know how you get out of an investigation and/or accountability by simply invoking the 5th.

[@AlyP171]

@@jenisbetzke6228 That’s why I thought he said that.

[@ThePaleKnight72]

@@jenisbetzke6228 That's exactly what I thought as well.

[@DrineThePoet]

This

[@pameversole5886]

The recorded 911 butt dial is proof that his father knows what he’s talking about so maybe he was his ride home after torching her car.

[@karlaingermanson7519]

Lol no.. "they are going to try to bust me with that car?" How tf is that proof? Good thing your not the prosecutor

[@karlaingermanson7519]

Hes def a pos

[@pameversole5886]

@@karlaingermanson7519 that’s NOT all that was said...you need to listen again. At least they did get him for attempted murder in Florida. Hopefully they’ll get him for his ex-wife’s murder before it’s over.

[@mariawestman9026]

Police once told when asked about-why being a police..?..?…? - bc that’s the only thing left for me to do.. poor guy…..😂😂😂😂

[@UCONN_HUSKIES]

Plead the fifth over 150 times, guilty!

[@Onix.556]

Don't forget "you have the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law". It purposely says NOTHING you say will help you, it can only be used against you. Remaining silent isn't guilt, its smart, especially when nothing you say will help you. However, all that being said, this dude is guilty as hell.

[@penskepc2374]

Actually thats what anyone with a brain does lol

[@watchgoose]

his attorney could have told him to do that, also.

[@jameskudla7957]

He pocket dialed the cops, what a MOOK!

[@mrsx7944]

Exactly 😂😂. How could anyone be that dumb??

[@nadana6418]

@@mrsx7944 be that dumb? Well just think about how dumb our justice system is? They can’t even arrest this man for murder and another attempted murder..wtf

[@alyciamarie4163]

I’ve seen it before in other cases... crazy

[@kendrawillis3322]

I’m really proud of his brother for telling the truth!!

[@mrsx7944]

Right. I wasn't expecting that.

[@shila8379]

Me too! And this just shows that sibling really can be the exact opposite, which is scary. Raised in the same household, same parents, but their idea of having morals is like night and day

[@mrsx7944]

@@shila8379 it can happen. My sister is a Ms. Goody Two Shoes and I'm. . well, not 😂😂

[@justicejane2429]

Thank you Andrew...you are a real Man!

[@Sabbathissaturday]

It seems more of the norm to me that there is always a good sibling and a not so good or rotten sibling.

[@tootime2]

He answered the question about sex was to cover his tracks when her body is found or his DNA is found somewhere

[@shila8379]

Idk if anyone has ever told you this, but your iq is higher than the average persons. These comments and the law enforcements comment on the matter have be in shock that nobody else figure that out smh

[@tootime2]

@@shila8379 it is strange how people couldn't connect those dots. My iq was relatively high when young but after years of stress, 13vhead injuries and drug abuse it went a lot. Lol . Now with healthy eating for my microbiom, yoga, meditation, moderate exercise, good sleep and a happy life it may improve. But thank you

[@ew0711]

My exact thoughts.

[@cynthiaisako]

Exactly !

[@ImplosiveCatt]

DNA could have been easily transferred through their daughter's clothes and stuff.

[@christinamoller5742]

What kind of a father wants his six-year old to play with matches, let alone hurt her grandma???

[@palmerdirector9169]

The kind that would beat and murder women if they make him angry. Narcissist

[@AnnieisOkay.]

Props to the brother. Now he needs come forward and say what he knows about Shelly’s disappearance.

[@mrsx7944]

Probably nothing

[@mikeawesome9212]

Yeah if his brother knows he's legit and tells the truth he wouldn't fill him in on sh*t.

[@stacistaci6657]

She should have listened to her mother. Who in their right mind would date a mam suspected of murder?

[@mrsx7944]

Sh believed he was innocent.

[@stacistaci6657]

@@mrsx7944 She shouldn't have taken that chance. She's lucky to be alive.

[@mrsx7944]

@@stacistaci6657 agree

[@niamphdollieofficial]

Some people set themselves up for failure I'm sorry. You gotta be realistic sometimes not go based off of what you personally feel. Women let their feelings cloud their judgment

[@stacistaci6657]

@@niamphdollieofficial So true!

[@dawnrio9667]

Chewing gum or eating food while you're being questioned is CRASS

[@84Mazzy]

A'la almber heard

[@derekarmstrong9024]

I know or wear sunglasses or smoke a blunt or chew tobacco or sip from a liquor bottle or drink lean or sniff lines or point guns

[@montserratq4222]

@@derekarmstrong9024 hahaha 😄

[@harley_fangurling3013]

Riight amber turd in her case was eating cookies and smiling during it

[@christinamoller5742]

I was just about to write this!!!🙌

[@7solseven]

Tyler was good looking ? Really ? He looks like he puts raisins in the potato salad. 😆🤣

[@mrsx7944]

😂😂😂

[@mrsx7944]

Imo he was very cute.

[@johnadams4471]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@itsbrittniewitchh5191]

💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀 i can’t like this enough. i literally spit out my drink.

[@FreedomWriter3]

Lmao! 😂😂😂

[@sutherngirrl7590]

If nothing about this story raises a red flag, that second 911 call damn sure does!

[@mrsx7944]

What a fool to do that!

[@m.marrakchi9393]

@TOMMY GOODWIN seriously. And exactly how he said every word, tone and all. Crazy.

[@ericaevoy1]

For the love of everything let your kid learn a lesson and make them sit in jail!!! They’ll never learn if you don’t.

[@ChathamASGhetto]

Facts! In my teens went to jail and put on house arrest, my parents let me sit there .haven’t been back since. Jail wasn’t for me and I learned real quick. P.s your beautiful, much love from Canada 🇨🇦

[@RebLLee]

If they’re in jail you’ve probably already failed

[@newyorktitties8954]

Yeah just give up on your child and let them rot in jail around criminals and unspeakable violence. I'm sure that will *not* turn them into a complete monster...... Y'all turn out babies like you're trying to create an army but once they turn 18 and the welfare checks run out y'all ditch them and wonder why they end up in jail. Y'all ain't shit , been saying this for decades. Keep ya legs close if you don't want to be a parent to your child and are just looking for a ride on the taxpayer gravy train.

[@DottieMinerva]

You can tell that’s part of the reason he’s the way he is. No consequences.

[@DottieMinerva]

@@newyorktitties8954 who said anything about ditching them and abandoning them? Actions have consequences. Not paying for them to get out of jail isn’t abandoning them 🙄

[@TheRockyTopRock]

“Oh he was good-lookin’...” gahhhwwwddd lol. Please stop letting them drink before the interview!!!

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

🤣🤣 dude is definitely NOT good looking to say the least!

[@ephwurd2yurMother]

@@kathykelleyskillercontent1795 and neither is she(possibly a he)

[@sangaywangchuk4480]

🤣🤣🤣

[@dcvirgo8707]

@@ephwurd2yurMother you seen her neck too lol

[@cuteyalexia]

Well, beauty is in the eye of the beholder 🤷‍♀️

[@whosyourdaddy4579]

*You can just sense the entitlement and narcissism oozing from Tyler Mook!

[@AnnabelleJARankin]

He's a creep.

[@mrsx7944]

@@AnnabelleJARankin he's arrogant damn he's cute!

[@shila8379]

Agreed! Narcissists always have this stuck up look in their eyes, it’s crazy. It’s like a mix between stuck up and evil

[@staciehahn9175]

right!? He is pretty proud of himself... I love his accidental 911 call tho,

[@Sidneycozzoi]

So his last name is accurate

[@BunnySlippers82]

It's a miracle that Tyler's brother turned out to be a good man when considering that Tyler's father was acting proud and guilty af during the taped 911 call, that Tyler's mother bailed his sorry butt out of jail immediately, AND that they pressured Tyler's brother to lie on the stand. They don't seem to care how many women Tyler kills as long as he doesn't go to jail for it. Sick pos.

[@ginaharden2111]

...sometimes an apple falls a little further from the tree...

[@Kkayoodle]

Finally a family member that doesn't enable. Good job Andrew. Your son as an adult will reflect these actions & your character as you raised him.

[@ns2110theonly]

Someone should share this KZbin video with Janey Peterson.

[@starrynightfall00]

The brother deserves to sleep well at night because he saved the gf and did the right thing in court. The rest of the Mooks were clearly protecting their golden boy, and they probably let him get away with everything his whole life.

[@rissam9301]

8 min in and I know the ex husband definitely has a hand in all this.

[@cassandrareed8971]

Definitely

[@staciehahn9175]

Agreed!

[@penskepc2374]

You should go watch "Matt Orchard's The Oldest Cold Case ever Solved". The fact is you dont know anything until all the pieces fall into place.

[@dreamsofturtles1828]

His face says "I don't care, you got nothing on me- ha ha" The look of a narcissist whos certain he's won the "game." The arrogant gum chewing tops it off.

[@donnaj69]

I'm sure lots of people did. Not hard to assume that

[@aliyahh9892]

He DEFINITELY killed her. The daughter was literally a witness to her mother’s disappearance. Hope the find her and get justice

[@soniarican6275]

I Truly Believe He Did It , It’s Written All Over His Face !

[@rissam9301]

He can’t even hide it. One would swear that he’s really proud of what he had done.

[@cesarebachelli]

Written all over his smug looks. But he got away from it, for now.

[@britgaddis]

Yup

[@rissam9301]

@Akbar Shabazz-Jenkins and you absolutely right

[@skreemqueen756]

Oh yes, he’s quite proud of himself too.

[@susanprather5962]

"He was good looking." TF.

[@seversley831]

Right I was like mmm 🤔 where?

[@mrsx7944]

I thought he was a cutie.

[@donnaj69]

🤮

[@Sabbathissaturday]

He is not my cup of tea. At all. (I’m female)

[@pixis3935]

To be fair, to each their own. And she also wasn’t aware of his past. Good for her for ending the relationship, she would have easily been next.

[@brynsmith117]

The simple fact of his mother bailing him out and the buttdial call. his parents gotta be involved and why would he NOT ANSWER what time he had sex with Shelley? That doesn’t make sense. you confirm you had sex but won’t say when? i’m really intrigued by this case because in my opinion, he’s extremely guilty. i hope Shelley’s family gets the justice and closure

[@timd4524]

That way if they find her body and check for DNA, he thinks he's giving himself a pre-alibi.

[@Franklin5261]

@@timd4524 that was my thoughts exactly!

[@crimetimeAU]

The father xame to his rescue 100% IMO Allegedly LOL

[@malibubarbie9098]

Me too! This is super close to home. My aunt lives in Shelbyville. I never heard of this case. I’m absolutely intrigued with it now. I’m holding on to hope she gets justice one day. This is devastating.

[@mrsx7944]

@Jus Sayin I don't think he killed Shelly.

[@whisperflame427]

Andrew is a stand up guy who saved her life. Thank God for that man! Glad she's still alive and sad for the family who wasn't so lucky. Praying for all 🙏🙏

[@tameriajones593]

My name is Tameria Diane Jones could please pray for me too that God would send his Archangels to bring back me and my mother's belongings that we had back at our old apartment from the Donna's apartments in downtown Los Angeles, CA 90007 or where ever that stuff is and return my son Aziz Ford back home to me from Brooklyn, NY.

[@whisperflame427]

@@tameriajones593 Absolutely I will! Our family will gather together tonight and pray for you! When two or more are gathered in his name ❤️❤️❤️

[@chriscanada3809]

Ummm…Andrew a stand up guy?! No he isn’t!!! He sat there and listened and watched his brother trying to kill his gf before at the last minute helping the gf. A stand up guy wouldn’t have allowed this behaviour to occur and would have stopped it instantly. The only reason the gf didn’t die was because she was able to get air before she was pulled out of the water. Then he wasn’t going to testify against his brother. Then in his testimony he was down playing his brothers actions and didn’t fully state what happened. He is probably with holding info about the dead gf too. He is far from a stand up guy. But at least he helped at the last minute before the gf was killed. This family is sick and psycho.

[@beagledog2001]

@@tameriajones593 yes, I will. Will pray right now. Lost some belongings a few years ago (my own fault, so I know how that feels!)

[@judybrown7601]

Players

[@wdoerr27]

“High school sweetheart” but he was 6 years older? Lmaooooo

[@johnhuber354]

Lol

[@Marine2111usmc]

I caught that as well.

[@ephwurd2yurMother]

@Tazer Face I am Groot

[@NicoleCzarnecki]

She was in high school when they began dating.

[@misskay8131]

So obvious that he is guilty! His concern about that 911 call says it all. Not to mention him pleading the fifth all those damn times!

[@mtaylor7307]

Seems that the 5th is the way to avoid penalty if there's not hard DNA because juries are reluctant to convict unless it's rapped up like a CSI episode.

[@josetovar1321]

Did his lawyer advised him to chew gum to deflect his nerves????!?!

[@mrsx7944]

Probably

[@lynnhexler-haan3357]

It stop's the jaw clenching & twitching.

[@HaleyBug221]

This girl was so brave to immediately go to cops...and just for him to be free

[@micheleh5706]

I think he got the girl out on that boat with the intention to do exactly what he did. In his mind, it’s like “how dare she break up with ME “ after questioning him about Shelley’s murder. He’s narcissistic and violent.

[@justicedaniels9924]

EXACTLY!!! He was proud to answer the question about them having sex but didn’t want to answer any other questions. That’s a huge sign of narcissistic behavior

[@ladyglittersparkles1563]

Oh yeah, and having witnesses there to help make it seem like an accident. He’s evil and needs to be put down.

[@MA-ck4wu]

That girl shouldve never hooked up with him again after finding the mook case on google

[@tylerbunch6826]

Happened in my home town, had friends as her students at the time. It was absolutely stunning to our community.

[@genevievesuzi1549]

Yes! I'm shocked she hasn't been found. The private investigator is my ex husband and I remember making the flyers and putting them everywhere. Our son is a Tennessee State Trooper here in Shelbyville and our other son is working on his law degree. He wants to make a difference somehow and I believe he will. We have way too much evil in this world. It's sick!

[@boomerdwight4560]

You can tell he's guilty and the family is acting upon as accessories to the murder of Shelly Mook and attempted murder of Tyler Robin

[@Regired2]

Yep, I thought the exact same thing. That SOB did it. Robin was very lucky bc she was soon to be his next victim. Def should have listened to Mom.

[@talosbitch8434]

Husband did it. Can I get a playlist of episodes where the husband/boyfriend/lover of some kind didn't do the crime?

[@yup_its_ME.512]

not feasible...the playlist I mean, not those cowards doing it!

[@Ruriko.Y]

not a playlist but there's one uploaded yesterday. the wife went to a party with her "gay friend" who eventually killed her.

[@yup_its_ME.512]

@@Ruriko.Y yes I saw that one too but he said they were having "relations" he was her student. We go back to someone the victim knows their killer!

[@spiritwalker9903]

Can I get a Playlist of parents that didn't hurt their own children...im so sick.of it. Current amber alert in Tennessee.. Summer Moon Utah Wells. So many sm pages and youtubr channels are following.

[@jeffreyb8770]

Mollie Tibbets was not murdered by her boyfriend.

[@Melicious8675]

What about Andrew's girlfriend on the boat? Was she not a witness too????

[@jennjohnson2303]

The ex-husbands ego made him answer that question 😡 Unbelievable! Beautiful life stolen!

[@hunterwise9412]

I’m not going to lie, I can not believe the brother ended up being such an upstanding individual....

[@mrsx7944]

Agree. That takes a lot of guts.

[@ns2110theonly]

Agree that the brother ended up being such AN upstanding individual.

[@rocknation7065]

I hope they find some peace in Shelley’s case.

[@KandisStarr]

Dont hope ..its like a curse word.. Her case has closure!

[@KandisStarr]

This is very personal and planned! She has justice i speak it into existence!

[@elsablue3646]

Its usually domestic violence. She was dating he got jealous. Just get the evidence. Its him. My ex same type of guy. Its so horrible and they dont care about the kids at all. Im praying for justice and strength for the family.

[@bohemianchic638]

Grown men act like they can’t handle Rejection when it’s apart of life nobody owes you anything grow up

[@jdt3594]

Easy for a female to say that has probably only ever been rejected a couple of times in her whole lives, meanwhile men probably get rejected that many times in 1 day. The few times you do get rejected, you don’t care because you know they’ll always be a long line of men that won’t reject you

[@a_s2557]

@@jdt3594if you’re getting rejected multiple times in one day, reconsider your approach… or even approaching at all. Regardless of gender

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

Amen to that!

[@quinncreel6091]

@@a_s2557 🤣 You might also wanna consider "paid" acceptance. 🤣

[@terryduckworth5105]

Didn’t have an enemy in the world…. Has an ex husband 🤷‍♂️ That’s an enemy

[@mrsx7944]

True

[@sadieireland8282]

Absofuckinloutley 💯

[@fronthal157]

There are fully amicable divorces. Be cynical. Don't be a jackass.

[@gigilovesgod8825]

Unfortunately

[@terryduckworth5105]

@@fronthal157 oh yeah more marriages that end in divorce end with a great relationship. Don’t be soooo stupid !!!!!

[@CassidayJacobs]

That woman tried to get a confession from her grave, I swear... I have never, ever by accident called 911, in my 34 years of life and it happens to him. Perfect and Poetic

[@cUser691]

If I’d discovered his past from credible sources, I wouldn’t EVEN need to call my mother first. I certainly would not confront him and agree to meet anywhere. I’d be gone, esp since if I had a child. I wouldn’t endanger my kid by hanging around w him.

[@shannimonet]

Imagine if his brother wasn't there, she'd be dead

[@ns2110theonly]

Wait, what does “especially since if I had a child” mean?

[@Jin420]

Stories like this makes me never want another relationship... Ever 💯🤣 I want everyone to hate me. All these women in these stories are all loved & light up the room, etc... No thanks. 🚫💯🤣 I'll remain an introvert & single. 💯🤣 (Just started watching though lol)

[@mrsx7944]

Don't be a drama queen. There are MILLIONS of happily married couples in the world. Just be sure to pick a nice decent man.

[@tatianarizktaylor1818]

Oh yeah, whenever someone dies, it’s like “They were so beloved,they lit up the room” lol 😂 I think I’ll just hide in the dark😂😂😂😂

[@mrsx7944]

@cindylou who that's a blatant lie. You can't say "most" guys are anything because you don't know MOST guys. It's like saying "most" females are overly emotional drama queens. Don't stereotype.

[@mrsx7944]

@cindylou who why is your husband telling you what to do? Sounds like you married a bossy controlling man. Shame on you.

[@psalm5537]

@@mrsx7944 we are tho lmao

[@heatherbowlan1961]

Why weren’t they considered attempted murder in the first place !?? The brother is an honest God fearing good man .

[@mrsx7944]

He is.

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

Our justice system can be incredibly frustrating 😤

[@TornSparrow1974]

20:25 Picture says it all "You'll never get me for my past, and I'll most likely walk before my time is up in here. I'm the man." ... Ugh.. Sincerely wish someone would legally wipe that smug look off his face! It appears that Andrew is the only decent person in that family.

[@paulinamagana7529]

Good job Andrew ! Thank you for saying the truth 💯💪🏼

[@hennylynnxx]

man it’s crazy how the universe works. 911 butt dial from a murderer himself…. just wow

[@sarahstauffer4874]

The spirits where at work.. Justice will prevail! It's only a matter of time.

[@spitfire3984]

The fact he called 911 on accident and talked about the case…that’s suspicious.

[@edoboleyn]

I actually wonder if someone else in the family did that and let them talk.

[@lp1643]

His body language shows guilt but also he seems like a creepy weirdo . There is something off about his face .

[@angb1672]

Arrest Tyler already

[@mrsx7944]

He's already in jail.

[@cresylove4765]

He prob wanted to 💩 himself when he realized he butt dialed 911 whilst having that Convo with his dad.

[@mrsx7944]

Exactly 😂😂

[@dawndawn45]

God works in mysterious ways

[@casmyneedmonson466]

She’s truly missed, we still have hopes down here in TN🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@chrisrandolph3650]

Did you know her? I’m in Murfreesboro and this is so hard to hear about

[@casmyneedmonson466]

Yes, she was a teacher at the middle school in my hometown. She was my little sister teacher 8th grade teacher when she went missing I was in the 10th. But my sister’s was her student and she always talked about how she was the best teacher she’s had. Now my sister is now 24 years old and that happened in 2011. That’s sad they still haven’t figured out anything. I don’t even see her poster or nothing with her pictures anymore in town. But ppl still talk about her here everybody believes it’s her husband. I just wish somebody says something.

[@godofyoutube3410]

She was my teacher to. I was in her class a day after she went missing

[@genakirkland5528]

​@@casmyneedmonson466what part of Tn? Cumberland county here! Cmcss...

[@psychedelicpsycho]

June 30th was actually Shelley’s birthday so everybody please wish her a happy birthday in the comments!

[@mrsx7944]

Aaawwww that's sad. HAPPY BIRTHDAY IN HEAVEN SHELLY! 🎂🎂🎂

[@PirosmikeyNone]

YOU CAN'T HAVE A BIRTHDAY IF YOU'RE DEAD !

[@mrsx7944]

@@PirosmikeyNone but ppl that are still living can remember a person on their bday. . Dead or not. Stop being a dunce.

[@laurynvalenzuela9588]

@@PirosmikeyNone ummmmm.... it's still the day she was born????? Your comment seems heartless. People are still affected by what happened to her. Don't be this way. Let people cope the way they want. If someone wants to wish her a happy birthday even if she's no longer with us then let them.

[@annerhodes5763]

Happy Heavenly Birthday Shelley 😇💖💖💖💖

[@seversley831]

Momma is always right!! Young girls listen to your mother!!

[@bd3825]

Women: "he was good looking". Shakespeare: "love is blind". Me: "got ya".

[@Maxvansteel]

It's always "he was good looking." And people (not me) wonder why there's so much violence, divorce, and single parent families nowadays.

[@cynthiaisako]

😂😂😂

[@maribelcaudillo258]

he he he!

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

😂😂

[@estherbitengo9212]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@rubytuesday5412]

I watched this twice and still can't find the good looking guy! On another note.... pleading the 5th for every question except about the sex! Wow, he's the man! I'm feeling second-hand embarrassment!

[@kf2642]

Most underrated comment.

[@andreamarksberry345]

I pray with all my heart for justice to be done for Shelley and her family…

[@Kimberle_]

I would be at Every Parole Hearing. I would not let him out.

[@SteveGoadArt]

It's rare to see families side against their own, which in itself should be a crime. Good on the brother for doing the right thing. Families that stick with their own regardless of what they see, hear and know in their own heart is wrong are simply what's wrong with this world. Turning a blind eye to the truth and siding with evil under the guise of 'family & love', makes you one and the same.

[@jazzyjazz9872]

Being interviewed with chewing gum in his mouth -- how disgusting he can be !!!!!

[@johnhuber354]

He’s Vulgar & Cocky. His Body Language speaks For Him, That He’s Guilty.

[@4278mary]

You are a good man Andrew and I guarantee you that kind of behavior will reward you in your life. You saved her life and your own by your actions.

[@MichelleIbarraMHAEdD]

Oh, man, that guy is arrogant, but that won't last, he's too pretty. He will get passed around in prison.

[@florahangel1718]

And they will have fun with him. Am sure he will enjoy it the way those two women enjoyed it. Good luck to him.

[@mrsx7944]

He's pretty he's also a big guy. He'll be ok. And he's probably in a minimum security prison.

[@SirBrucie]

That's disgusting

[@minae9935]

@@mrsx7944 there’s bigger men in prison

[@mrsx7944]

@@SirBrucie very

[@CC-js5ou]

What's actually sickening and frightening is he's learned he has to kill them or he could go to jail like he did for the attempted murder, when he gets out and does this again he won't stop until they are dead. Again.

[@dickfitswell3437]

He clearly killed her. The little girl is with her mom and her mom gets out of the car and goes inside then the dad comes out gets the daughter puts her in her room and she's never seen again. And then they got him going to a dumpster. And then the 911 call that was recorded. Then him calling 911 and asking about that being recorded. I believe a grand jury would indict. And if that's all you get then fine but then everybody knows he's a murderer at the minimum

[@vanillagorilla9841]

Plot twist, he is in jail right now for attempted murder on his new girlfriend after all this went down.

[@TrashwareArt]

"I just thought he didnt do it and he told me all the things I want to hear" Ladies when is it time to take accountability?

[@amandaconnor2863]

Excuse me. Women fear these men and avoid the conflict. How about parents to these abusive men? I don't blame victims.. blame parents

[@harley9850]

Amanda Connor how about blame the person who did the disgusting thing?? What the hell. We want to blame everyone except the one in the wrong.

[@DottieMinerva]

His parents have blood on their hands too.

[@mrsx7944]

No. They don't.

[@JuneBug79824]

Where's Dexter when you need him smh

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

Right?!?

[@loricarter2394]

This beautiful woman (mother, friend, daughter, and sister, etc) deserved so much better than what she went thru with this monster, and now because of this “man” this poor little girl doesn’t have a mother or a father.

[@RealityChick77]

God bless Andrew! That had to be the hardest moment of his life but he acted honorably

[@johnhuber354]

Yes. Without His Testimony, He would’ve Never been Convicted.

[@skeletalrut]

i am related to shelley. she was my mother’s cousin and they were very close. so close that shelley is my godmother. i don’t know if any of you will believe me when i tell you that. she was truly the most amazing woman ever and was such a good mother. we miss her everyday. i’m convinced that she’s still out there.

[@Ha3lyrockss]

In those 12 years I would move out as far as possible

[@johnhuber354]

Yes. She’ll be Looking over Her Shoulder The Rest of Her Life.

[@neaswaifu6976]

Tyler definitely is in on it. The fact that he called police when she didn’t come to pick up their daughter. The fact that calling POLICE was his solution for the situation and came to mind just says so much.

[@cfq.tufanuf7601]

I want to know what exactly the police are doing on the case and why its taking so long? If I was the towns Sheriff, Tyler would be under lock&key ages ago... Tyler Mook = Guilty me lord

[@shonenhikada9254]

because he is male

[@cfq.tufanuf7601]

@@shonenhikada9254 so am I? I'm not guilty of anything, and I've never laid my hands on my girl or any girl for that matter.

[@mrsx7944]

@@cfq.tufanuf7601 the Sheriff has ZERO control of that. If the DA doesn't charge him he can't get arrested.

[@cfq.tufanuf7601]

@@mrsx7944 ah the old district attorneys job......ok

[@lifesajoke6965]

It's hard to get a conviction without a body or any real evidence that she's even dead. They only get one shot in a trial, if they try to get him now and he's found not guilty that's it. They could find her body in a trunk in his house and still wouldn't be able to charge him. I'm sure they are gonna keep building there case in the hopes of finding more evidence and right around the time he's about to be released they will attempt to charge him with murder.

[@Candie183]

I cannot imagine what she went though when he killed her. I hope one day he gets all he deserves

[@kellymccain3403]

I hope so too........This guy is the perfect example of an arrogant, narcissistic douchebag. For a self-involved jerk like him, being locked up for 12 years is a nightmare. That arrogance will get his a** beat up in prison, and probably killed:)👍👍

[@MrsDannunzio]

So glad ANDREW testified against his brother!

[@bradley-sky-watcherlynn2612]

Justice will prevail, if not here on earth, when he meets his maker.. the one and only,, Holy God...

[@Eastsid3]

Glad Robin got away and this dudes brother had the stones to testify.

[@Godisgreater123]

why is the little girl's testimony not considered evidence to her mom's murder? She said that her mommy never came out of his house..was never seen again..yet he has never been charged in her disappearance..

[@34stzoo]

Tyler killed Shelley and Tyler's father helped him! I guarantee his brother is not the outcast of the family because he did the right thing!

[@lovemealways7]

I hate when they say he or she was loved by everyone which isn't true because someone didn't like them because they ended missing or deceased

[@truecrimelover3228]

Totally not about this video, but I agree! I always joke with my parents and friends if something happens to me don’t lie about my personality lol! They always say things like “they were well liked and outgoing. They had such a nice attitude and were super motivated” or “they loved life and everyone that meant them loved them.” I’m like nope be honest and tell them I was nice but introverted and didn’t like most people. I was overly sarcastic and often lazy 😆 And didn’t have many friends but probably pissed off a stranger🤣🤣🤣

[@lovemealways7]

@@truecrimelover3228 LMBAO!!!...we both have the same left turn sense of humor 😂

[@truecrimelover3228]

@@lovemealways7 I always tell them if they lie and I end up dead I will come back and haunt them in the most annoying ways 😆 there can’t be this many Happy, Positive, outgoing, life lovers out there??!?? Right? I mean?

[@mrsx7944]

@@lovemealways7 they literally describe EVERY victim like that. It's so phoney and annoying.

[@mrsx7944]

@@truecrimelover3228 they all "light up a room" 🙄

[@einienj3281]

Her family needs answers.. someone knows.. R.I.P 💔♥️

[@shonenhikada9254]

she is still alive.

[@einienj3281]

@@shonenhikada9254 I doubt it..

[@CrimeAllTheTime]

@@shonenhikada9254 If this video and his actions say ANYTHING about her being alive or dead then it's the fact that she is NOT ALIVE anymore. Not sure where you came up with your crackpot conclusion! 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@nekamichelle1487]

The new girlfriend thought she was better than the ex wife like he wouldn’t try to do the same to her! Now she’s crying smh.

[@Firebro999]

I need to stop watching these at night

[@PrincessSn6w]

The brother did great in telling the truth ! And I hope he confesses so they can finally put her body to rest.

[@ataraxia199]

No offense to the new girlfriend, but it kinda looks like she has an Adam’s apple

[@mikeysardar8674]

This is such a great channel!!!

[@unlimitedmovies123]

His family is just as guilty. Thank God his brother came forward! He would have done it again if he want punished. Kudos to him for standing up against them all!!

[@CrimeAllTheTime]

I've seen this case and other videos/news articles and reports that have even more information than this video and I'm not saying he did it BUT..... I'm 99% positive that he's 100% GUILTY!! Disgusting!

[@Sabbathissaturday]

Oh my goodness!!! Children that young do not lie. Her statement alone should be enough to arrest him. That poor child.

[@sharonwilliams6673]

No proof he did it??? The little girl told them her mother went into the house with him and never came out. Then he comes and gets her out of the car, sends her to her room, and she doesn't see her mother anywhere in the house?? Come on!!

[@adamburdt8794]

His smug face says it all. Guilty

[@mrsx7944]

Please never sit on a jury!

[@adamburdt8794]

@@mrsx7944 Sat on 2...The foreman on 1. You do realize people treat actual court cases different than a YT comment section?

[@mrsx7944]

@@adamburdt8794 I would hope so. You can't judge Innocence or guilt from the look on someone's face.

[@adamburdt8794]

@@mrsx7944 If the judge asked me if there was a reason why I couldn't be fair an impartial (which they do). If I thought their face would prevent that. I'd say so. 👋 Your honor I can't be fair and impartial. His face loookkss guiiiilllty. 😆

[@siiiiiuu7]

What tf is the matter with this guy? He thinks he can just go around killing and drowning whoever he feels like? Makes you wonder what else he's gotten away with

[@johnhuber354]

His Parents Failed.

[@hailboognish81]

He sounds like Paul Flores during his deposition in the Kristin Smart case...

[@bobbeezel2593]

Enabling parents once again produce a spoiled, arrogant, sociopath. Why do some parents treat their kids like they’re are the king or queen? Like they deserve to not have accountability. To not have to work for a living. To have chance after chance to screw everyone over. They abuse, steal, assault, lie, cheat, even murder and there’s mom and dad defending their actions once again! Once again solidifying to the man child that he can do no wrong and deserves another chance (again).

[@Gtagfuntoy]

Poor Lily Anna Only God Knows The Fear She Had When All This Took Place One Second She’s In The Car With Her Mom Then The Next Second She’s Told To Get Out The Car And Her Mom Didn’t Come Back 🙏🏻 This Is Something So Horrible That She Will Never Forget For The Rest Of Her Life 💔😢

[@pauljordan4452]

Agreed. You don't use capital letters for every word.