Exploding Beethoven: Tempest Sonata Live from Paris Valentina Lisitsa

[@msieurJIM]

I like these few seconds of waiting at the end, before Valentina comes out of the music, and the audience respecting that before starting to applaud. A true sharing of passion between Beethoven, the player and the listeners.

[@XavierBergeron]

I was listening to KZbin's automatic playlist of you while doing some work and that almost gave me a heart attack.. Wow. Incredible performance!

[@jaeyounglee5410]

10:52?

[@IloveSPIDERZ]

Yeah, I was sleeping with that same auto playlist. Lol

[@jurassicdrawings1793]

I think Beethoven's ghost made the light explode to test her.

[@kennywarp]

+CMCdoesMusic hahaha good one.

[@hehheh5446]

+CMCdoesMusic haha, u have a creative mind :)))))))))))))))))))))))))))

[@RamiEkhlasi]

+CMCdoesMusic, well he scared the SH*T out of me

[@edryno]

+CMCdoesMusic Beethoven cant underdtand how much can be loud the test... is Deaf :P

[@jurassicdrawings1793]

edryno I'm sure that in death, deafness isn't a problem.

[@OmgLoLw2gLuvUidkROFL]

10:53 Omg!! She handled it absolutely perfectly! I would have jumped out of my skin. Omg! BRAVA, Ms. Lisitsa, BRAVA!! Beautiful playing too. ;)

[@livu69]

I was concentrating on something for the job, listening this song quite loud.. and then... boom. I almost shit in my pants

[@JoseFerreira-de7oe]

@@livu69 Same omg hahahah

[@simonfredheim9581]

What even happened?

[@requiem165]

Light Bulb probably burst

[@11thShadowDragon]

I like how she just BARELY flinched. I probably would have jumped out of the bench and dove under the piano.

[@lucabrenkmusic715]

11thShadowDragon i would do the same

[@11thShadowDragon]

piano.feurich.luca xD

[@LordCargena]

I do that being in my house, and because I dont have a piano I fisnished under the table.

[@11thShadowDragon]

LordCargena Aw xD

[@FINNMegurine]

There's something similar in the movie 'The Pianist' :)

[@Marathonracer]

This is a gorgeous performance. That's definitely an overhead stage light that blew at 10:53, because you can see the dramatic lighting drop on Valentina and the keyboard immediately afterward. compared to before when it was much brighter. She barely flinched and it didn't effect her playing even for one note !

[@roncoffey4900]

Agreed! (AFFECT, not Effect) . Valentina plays the last part of this sonata so dramatically, so perfectly; it is the best I've heard.

[@ЕленаБорисова-щ8е]

Why, she played in 1915 in Donezk that was bombarded by Ukrainian troops.

[@geraldmuller4683]

Not many pianists would have the courage to play a whole recital on a more than 100 year old piano! The combination of your art, this piano, that has obviously a soul and Beethoven is pure magic. I regret all the more not having been able to attend this concert due to a sore throat and painful cough that would have been criminal to inflict on you and the audience.

[@JoachimMink]

Warning: At 10:52 you will hear a very loud explosion from a bursting spotlight, perhaps. She didn't make any mistake but I almost fell from my chair...

[@MinecraftMagpie]

+JoachimMink fuck me i fell over and banged my head against a wall

[@thezokman]

+That Guy LOL

[@MinecraftMagpie]

ITS NOT FUNNY THERE IS A HOLE IN MY WALL

[@thezokman]

That Guy HOW THICK SKULLED ARE YOU TO CAUSE A HOLe IN YOUR WALL? HOLY JESUS DUDE

+JoachimMink Wish I saw this before I fkn pissed myself

[@youngpaderewski3668]

I fell asleep in bed listening to this, and the sudden noise awoke me so quickly, I thought someone was shooting outside my house.

[@skimask777]

Never make the mistake to fall asleep while she's playing.

[@07XJuvi]

Same thing here 😂

[@mdoyle1981]

10:43 President Lincoln, how are you enjoying the performance? 10:52 BANG! 10:53 how unfortunate.......

[@superoxidedismutase5757]

ROFL

[@crimsonmoon8870]

lol

[@moiseshenriquez8442]

LOL LOL

[@Bunglespice]

Too soon...

[@stefanolencina]

AHAHAASDASJDKLAJSLAKJSDÑLFKASD

[@lyoung36]

Yes, Dear. At 10:52, That was your old piano teacher telling you, "Don't slouch! Sit up Straight! Mind your Posture!". And it worked.

[@lyoung36]

Oh yes, lest I forget. Magnificent job, and your artistry is very enjoyable.

[@acanthusfacilitairedienstv9047]

😂😂😂👍🏼

[@tg4q391]

I'll make a wild guess that you take piano lessons.

[@elserso1]

She's so unbelievable! Great interpretation, Beethoven is just the Best Composer ever.

[@THEARTURLIVE]

His is the master of all composers!

[@thefractalbible8214]

Beethoven is the maximus composer ever. No Bach, no Mozart, no others.

[@claudedebussy8057]

I can see why the video is titled 'exploding beethoven'

[@delrenatoaltoe]

@@fernandopaxeco7709 Olha um Br

[@yanayrton]

Oui Claude! Despite the auditorium (the venerable Salle Gaveau) caprices and idiosincrasies - a insignificative minor event -Valentina gave a impressive memorable ,strong personal performance from this sensible Tempest Sonata from the timeless teutonic genius called Ludwig.Ars Gratias! "Ludwig van Beethoven IS the very apex from the Human Creation.He remains not surpassed by anyone . He stands reverentlly by meritus & absolute grace close near and imbricated with The Mind And Heart From God." ― Yan Ayrton, a young composer in development and evolution. >>> .ARS SEMPER.VITA PLENA. Yan Ayrton, classical composer

[@karengilliland2439]

Wow, I had read in the comments about the exploding spotlight, and I thought I was ready for it, but when it exploded, I jumped a foot in my chair! And Valentina didn`t miss a note and didn`t jump, that is total concentration and professionalism, I`m impressed.

[@12stepsbeyondtheeventhorizon]

Phenomenal sonata...played by a phenomenal artist. I'm blessed to live in a generation where such geniuses can create the art they create.

[@jcinfan]

I find it amazing how well she kept her composure after that explosion and continued her magic

[@Metadeth1997]

10:52 holy shit that scared me

[@AxelBrzostowski]

That's whay the title is "Exploding Beethoven" :P

[@intannurarifah]

lol agree..what is that?

[@SoraSnake]

I was doing homework , maths , and i get shock by the sound , i was using headphones XD

[@grantboscamp149]

that was a stage light exploding, scared the shit out of me

[@fernandopaxeco7709]

Håkon Dekkerhus 666

[@10mimu]

10:52 OMG she didn't even make a mistake.

[@jorgeamaro2686]

she is professional! (she is like: I don't give a flying shit!)

[@GabrielSoleronedish]

+Istari Pallando por allá pegaron a uno :P

[@Coto9206]

+Istari Pallando whattafuck?!

[@10mimu]

+Simone Coletta didn't you hear the bang? I would've shit myself

[@Coto9206]

+Istari Pallando i said "whatta fuck" because i heard it!

[@amusiq]

I have listen to the best pianist in this era and hope you all agree that Valentina is on the top of this list. Divine expression of what Beethoven composed. Can't get enough of her playing.

[@luisamarante2110]

1st movement 0:12 2nd movement 9:30 3rd movement 16:18

[@trardac]

A lot of movement 10:52

[@IloveSPIDERZ]

@@trardac I was going to say "bowel movement" lol

[@Toxxic88]

10:52 , RIP headphone users

[@zacharyaquino]

I seriously thought it was a gunshot, and jumped out of bed.

[@fredyvideo]

damn!! WTF was that? even her got scared the shit out XD

[@erggish]

oh my gosh.... ahahahahaha... that was an explosive art! :D

[@jamesmclaughlin7729]

I just happened to be using some headphones (and some loud one too) when that light bulb popped. Scared me to death, especially while it was in the calm, slow section....

[@MrBetovenforever]

That happens for not reading before the comments.That did not happen to me

[@kradomirchoukroutov6362]

music is not just a sheet with notes, there is an internal rythm, phrasing, swing, call it whatever, which makes music exist.And it is exactly what I think she feels best, she makes MUSIC! thank you ma'am

[@kingtoadius]

amazing how she held her composure and continued on, simply amazing :)

[@soogoonu]

LOL she's so focused that she barely noticed the explosion

[@josephwesthill2174]

WARNING: headphone users beware of loud, sudden noise at 10:52

[@AmiGoldfarb]

Joseph Westhill where were you two minutes ago? damn

[@xXxMareanxXx]

Joseph Westhill I should have read your comment before listening to this... = )

[@Gulfstream005]

Joseph Westhill I hope whoever was responsible for that was promptly escorted from the auditorium and thence to a somewhat different type of auditorium as well.

[@8807947]

+Joseph Westhill That is why this video is called "Exploding" Beethoven...

[@josephwesthill2174]

Exploding indeed. :D

[@789armstrong]

I absolutely love this piece.One of Beethoven's greatest works played here with total mastery of every note.Tremendous feeling and expression with a vivid imagination, but never to the point of becoming sentimental.This is the way Rachmaninoff would have played it! Incidentally Artur Schnable once said Rachmaninoff's Beethoven was the best he had ever heard.

[@amyhsu9849]

great

[@marcvincenti6720]

She's got the beautiful hands of a wide receiver, capable of grasping anything, and one of the most beautiful trills possible. This is a textbook case, I think, of the virtues of playing in steady tempi-making momentum itself an expressive feature. She lets the tunes play themselves, as in that little, importunate, meek, obsessive four-note figure that nibbles and nibbles its way through the entire last movement, ending with the quietest of swallows, the mousiest of gulps. What a pianist! She makes Beethoven so clear!

[@chopinanalysis]

Without question... one of the greatest pianists of our time..!

[@jeanfrancoistobias5906]

Thanks for this french, old and famous factory which disappeared last year to renew with the past. PLEYEL !!!

[@selinossani7157]

I love the sound of Pleyel pianos. It was Chopin's favourite. I can understand why.

[@acuriousergeorge]

Wonderfully played, and nice to hear a late 19th century piano. I noticed wearing headphones (BEWARE! DON'T DO THIS) that at 10:43 and 10:46, right before the "surprise" that there was a slight twang -- almost imperceptible. I wonder if it was from the piano or from the light filament about to pop.

[@IloveSPIDERZ]

Interesting... I thought that twang was the piano!

[@Silver.moon848]

Thank you for your beautiful performance and talent. Amazing Control, Timing... The New Pianist Generation is just Outstanding... !

[@jeremykirk2508]

The loud bang at 10:52 made my day, just seeing Lisitsa be so wrapped up in the performance to be completely unaffected. Beethoven would have shit a brick

[@ちばつよし-e4x]

ピアノの素晴らしさを最高に引き出している❤❤鳥肌が立つ、感激❤

[@Myaccountishacked]

I love Valentina Lisitsa..... great performance !

[@chrispetro3465]

Her left hand hits like a real thunder!! Wonderful! I keep my breath. Thank you for entering in our lives.

[@xantochroi]

still clapping in 2020 here. what a wonderful performance

[@SggK1957]

Dear Valentina! I am totaly blown away by your pianoskills! I think wow - she must write incredibly fast on her laptop :) Thank you SO much for posting these wonderfull videos. They are truely appreciated! I wish you all the best in the world.

[@bonjourmelancholy]

I must say, the 3rd movement is my favourite in the sonata :)

[@og189]

Quelle maestria. Éblouissant. On dirait que vous mettez en scène cette tempête comme si vous y étiez. Vous étiez vraiment inspirée ce soir là .

[@yohannes8900]

Damn! WTF was that? I didn't saw the warnig!? I almost fell off my chair. I had my headphone on with high volume. But you Valentina, you just kept on playing as if nothing happened. Respect! Love your work as always!

[@charliesommers494]

Such an emotion charged performance! You are magnificent dear Valentina. You are also a real trooper to have ignored the explosion and continue with such a brilliant rendition of one of Beethoven's finest offerings.

[@MyCynthia911]

You are amazing, your play is amazing. I really love to hear you. I'm French, and I hope you will come back in France, again and again, until I can come to see you in live, front of me ♥ ♥ ♥ I had a heart attack at 10:52. I love how you remained calm, even if you have a little startled and this is normal. Professional way!

[@lilysumichan1467]

WONDERFUL!! So you have a special piano for this concert. Amazing sound! You and the piano make a beautiful music. You are very talented. I am so thankful that I found your videos. Thanks for the heavenly music.

[@james4piano]

I'm not sure if I could have continued without skipping a beat like you did! I saw you jump, but your heart and hands just kept going - love it!

[@spicasalmo6992]

que c'est beau!Une finesse d'interprétation qui permet de ressentir l'émotion de Beethoven.Merci Valentina.

[@felipounpassepartout7301]

Vos doigts sur le clavier sont semblables à ceux d'une fée qui comme par magie fait valser les notes de musique. Vous êtes véritablement extraordinaire 🤔❤

[@felipounpassepartout7301]

Merci infiniment pour votre réponse 🙏😊

[@fredericochopin]

Wow! Exploding indeed! Dear ValentinaLisitsa , the way you managed not to turn a hair in such adverse situation only proves that you had plunged wholeheartedly into Beethoven's mind. Bravo!

[@vahidmirkhani]

I'm alone right now in school. It's 5:54 PM and I'M ALONE!!!!! No one is here and I was doing my work while listening to this. At 10:52, I thought I heard a gun shot in our building so I paused the video and went out to see what was happening. After a while I thought giving the video another try, and it was there!!!!!!!! Phewwwwww, you scared me to death :D

[@goldenscarecrow397]

Holy...! I was listening to this while studying and I literally jumped on my chair! How could she not even flinch?! She's incredible, it's a blessing to have her

[@claushenrique]

If she was playing in Titanic I bet she would go on playing until the ship had sunk. Incredible.

[@tristancouloumy]

+C Henrique She'd keep on playing even after the ship had sunk !

[@edd4339]

+Tristan Couloumy what are you talking about...whatever it was is scared the shit out of her. It was her great sense of showmanship that kept her playing. Many others would jump up and look toward the noise and maybe assuming it was a gunshot, even run off the stage ruining the performance. She didn't because she's a true professional in every way

[@tristancouloumy]

+Ed D do you even humour bro ?

[@Hobott]

+Tristan Couloumy If she played this sonata at the time of the sinking, I think God himself would like to hear it to the end and therefore would not allow Titanic to sink . So, Lisitsa would rescue Titanic.

[@mudkip_btw]

People just think of the craziest ways to deal with extreme talent and skill lmao

[@jrjr5464]

Is really wise and beautiful the way to interpret the music I think you are among the best dear lady Valentina. I admire you and god bless you.

[@JesusRocksTryPrayin]

I've never heard this song and (I'm no authority) it doesn't really sound like Beethoven to me. It's such a magnificent piece and sounds sooo romantic period. Thanks for uploading music; besides being marveled by how good you are I've become aware of so many beautiful pieces. You do the world a service

[@Sportfuck]

it sounds like romantic period thing, because she plays like it. Listen to some other people do it. It is indeed VERY beethovenish. and i do mean the word "VERY".

[@JesusRocksTryPrayin]

Achi Oragvelidze I agree :D

[@razhidiz]

This piece is Beethoven's Piano Sonata no. 14. It's called Tempest because Beethoven wrote it for Shakespeare's play the Tempest. He liked it so much that he interpreted the play in music.

[@Kurentacc]

razhidiz uh, Ain't the 14th the moonlight?

[@Sportfuck]

Eliott Cohen True that. this is 17th.

[@belmontbug]

Valentina, you are awesome. I have watched you play both live and on youtube Bosy's and Steinways, but never a Pleyel. The richness of the bass, but the pristine clarity andt at times, almost brittle treble came as a complete surprise. I loved it. Thank you. You are a complete master of your craft like no other i have heard in 60 years of listening. See you in Bristol..

[@kevito666]

RIP my speakers at 10:52 lol

[@fvdp]

RIP my ears, scared the hell out of me

[@renan.p.b]

what was that, btw?

[@artmaniac-nn5mj]

No. It was probably a firework or party popper. I mean if it was a light bulb, wow, that is a big light bulb.

[@TheCelsocelso]

JAJAJAJJA what was that? xD

[@lucabrenkmusic715]

kevito666 ripp my heart!!!

[@Desireyso58]

Dear Valentina: Knowing that i would never be able to see you, at least I'm grateful of all your kindness. You are simply the best piano player. I admire you from the first video I've seen of you. Excuse my french. I only speak spanish.

[@ementalman1]

its nice you chose this piano because it sounds really close to beethoven original sound..also great performance!!

[@MusicSmileAll]

Valentina Lisitsa's piano, so beautiful...; I'm fascinated with it and herself as a person, too since I knew her existence last month. Centainly, I have her DVD/CD, still these youtube videos are fabulous as well. Thank you, Valentina Lisitsa.

[@InfiniteTriztan1111]

It's amazing the way you play,excellent skill, i'm amazed by the focus and concentration you maintain ,really great.

[@greenpeace8238]

Валентина ты неповторима! Как творчески так и духовно! Greetings to you from the Far East Russia

[@Наталья-ж7ъ9й]

хоть один комментарий на русском ! Рада . 👋

[@HDeriau]

If you listen carefully with headphones, you can hear the low rumbling sound of the subway passing 3 or 4 times rue de la Boetie during the performance :-)

[@olyv1]

I was there and that was quite frightening ! But as anyone can notice, perfect concentration of Mrs Lisitsa, not even a single wrong note or tempo variation !!

[@buggsy5]

Theatrical performers are used to such occurrences. In the theatre where I do many lighting designs, we have several such lamp explosions every year. Some are much louder, such as when a PAR64 lamp explodes.

[@rolfeichele5158]

Beethovens spirit was with you, exactly in 10:53 on the 3rd beat !! That's swing, isn't it Valentina?? ... I love this performance 🔝

[@khool63]

je n'ai vu personne tourner la page d'une partition pour aider valentina mais l'immensité de son répertoire ,, la grâce alliée à une mémoire inouie , une force de travail au service d'un caractère et d'une passion inégalable ,une pointe de persévérance et valentina atteindra les sommets d'un génie qu'ont atteint si peu de mâitres ,, tout simplement éblouissante , merci valentina ,,

[@Vesperia3]

This wasn't a light bulb ! This is a tempest so it was the lightning !!! :') Anyway, awesome work as ever. I'm really sad that I wasn't in the audience... I'm French and living near Paris but I didn't know her back then...

[@ScottWarner86]

I actually thought it was too when I read the description. I was like tight, just like Tchaikovsky added cannons, Beethoven added lightning.

[@ArtistForgotten]

Beethoven never added Lightning to this piece, it is bad that they used it in the 2. movement, it would fit for the 1. and 3. movement but not for the 2., where everything should be calm. Then there is the thing that it is Tempest sonata, but it is not some outer storm where is lightning and thunder, it's the inner one

[@Marathonracer]

+Yami Hayashi It was an overhead stage light that blew. You can see the dramatic loss of light on Valentina and the keyboard immediately afterward compared to before the explosion. As far as the tempest supposedly being "the inner one", this is from..... Peter Takács Plays Beethoven The Mind of Beethoven ,,,,,,," In the same vein, the main theme of the “Tempest” Sonata alternates lower and higher registers in creating this image of struggle, here perhaps between the blind forces of nature and the helpless, pleading human being" ......... " one can recognize the spell that nature cast on the composer. For example, listen to the spacious sense of awe in the opening of the Adagio of the so-called “Tempest” Sonata, Op. 31, no. 2, in the noble key of B-flat major" ........... "Another common way of experiencing nature in Beethoven’s day was on horseback or during a coach-ride, both often characterized by obsessively repetitive rhythms. One can imagine one such nightmarish ride in the finale of the “Tempest” Sonata, a constant, hypnotizing texture of sixteenth notes interrupted by violent sudden ff explosions". In Wilhelm Kempff's lecture he does say that Beethoven supposedly told his secretary that if you want to know what it's about, read Shakespeare's "The Tempest" in which the Duke of Milan conjures up a storm. Sometimes a tempest is really a tempest.

[@MisterPathetique]

Victor Bordier Je suis français aussi :p

[@BrunoNeureiter]

SvartHal Nobody cares x,'(

[@jonahwilliams6150]

This piano sonata was performed just the way Beethoven has played it. So superb . Valentina is such a God - given artist. I was astounded by her artistry.

[@IvanGreindl]

Superbe interprétation ! Merci pour ce beau partage. Le *Pleyel* a un son très différent d'un Steinway, mais il est riche et plein. Le projecteur éclaté ne semble guère vous avoir perturbée. Bravo !!

[@Canari2009]

Always so beautiful when Valentina plays Beethoven !!!!!

[@GuillaumeEngrand]

Galaxy Note 7 in the room ? ^^ :D

[@ShivamKumar-yt4nt]

lol

[@prestonjones3319]

Guillaume Engrand nah I think they shot the guy who was coughing

[@brianstark1527]

😂😂😂

[@tg4q391]

It was probably Kim Yon Kun farting..

[@NICOSIADON]

Marvellous!!!!!!!!!!!! what an Amazing and a Brilliant performance...the more you play...the more I listen....the more Envigourous we become!!!!!!!!!

[@markharrison2625]

I was at Les Jacobins in Toulouse, France last century when a complete power failure occurred towards the end of the concert. A small torch was found which, together with a few cigarette lighters, gave enough light for Jorge Bolet to continue playing Liszt as though nothing had happened. An artist is an artist.

[@shannonburns8607]

Nerves of steel to say the least! Yet richly expressive color and depth. Close-up view of her hands is wonderful.

[@FranklovesBunnies]

So beautiful and love the dress :)

[@melinaz3385]

It is titled, Exploding Beethoven! I ran it back and watched the moment again and saw the barest of jumps from Valentina, but she is so professional she continued on beautifully!

[@kkasper007]

You are most Beautiful and precious !!!

[@gilgemash]

Valentina Lisitsa ! The Empress Of The Universe ! Greetings from London

[@intentionalresults.888]

As Elton said..... "Dont shoot me, I'm only the piano player"

[@mobyhunr]

I had explosions of emotion. The clear bass and crisp range of treble of this piano with you is amazing. Epic

[@Ember-Rodriguez]

I let auto play continue to play the tempest so I didnt see the exploding part in the name and combine that with me reading alone in the dark at 4:00 am and I was fairly scared :P

[@nelsonescalante3493]

what are you doing alone in a dark alley at 4am?

[@fieldmartan4426]

"reading alone in the dark." I'm not a magician but dont you need light to see the you know the fucking words.

[@Ember-Rodriguez]

Online books cause I'm cheap :P

[@lallallama]

i did the exact same thing.... except i was doing homework and my heart is like dying rn from the explosion... scared the sh*t out of me lol

[@youbreakdown]

OMG what was that?! I'm so amazed of your capacity to lead that moment with totally naturally. By the way I love this sonata, particulary the 2nd movement, is very precious... You're really awesome Valentina.

[@fwiendawan]

So, I let KZbin run on its own in the background, so I didn't see the warning in the title. I was just relaxing to the lovely piano music and then jumped five feet in the air, ROFL!! It took me a minute to realize the sound came from the vid.

[@lilyaann1483]

I just LOVE listening to you. Thank you so much Valentina for everything!! One day I hope to see you live that a dream for me :)

[@مسعدالشعب]

I was doing some Lagrangian mechanics, and then I suddenly hear BANG!!. And it was said that I was accelerating towards by chair at 9.806 m/s^2.

[@oliviercabrol46]

Valentina Lisitsa est vraiment une virtuose du clavier, toutes ses interprétations le prouvent irrémédiablement. J'adore ! Je suis aussi fan sur Facebook. Bravo aussi pour son interprétation de la rhapsodie Hongroise de Listz.

[@MusicDopy1234]

Hahaha, I thought you honestly meant there would be a firework or something. I expected it to be for effect when the piece gets dramatic..... but BOOM.... right during a calm section :D

[@vadimginkovsky794]

Спасибо, Валентина! Вы чудо!

[@amirprog]

i think it requires more technique to walk with these shoes then play the hardest piano pieces. anyway, bravo Valentina! literally. i like your channel.

[@charleslentz3896]

Consummate Artist and Professional that somehow "feels" the composer's notes and plays them to the highest original level(s) as one can possibly imagine. I am a fan..... often in "awe" of accomplishment....and thankful I can both see and hear. :-)

[@СветланаДавыдова-з5з]

Beethoven написал свою новаторскую и трагическую Sonata Op. 31 № 2 в 1802 году, в период тяжелого душевного кризиса. Как исполняет ее Valentina Lisitsa? Пианистке прекрасно удалась вся Sonata полностью, а не только ее первая часть, являющаяся драматургическим центром Sonata. Основной конфликт выражен уже в исполнении Главной партии, состоящей из мучительного вопроса "быть или не быть" (Largo) и энергичного ответа (Allegro). Этот речитативный вопрос повторяется на протяжении всей первой части, чередуясь со страстными, протестными эпизодами, виртуозно исполненными Valentina Lisitsa. Вторая часть - некоторое отдохновение от внутренней борьбы в общении с природой - прозвучала светло, нежно и торжественно, но пианистке и в ней удалось сохранить эмоциональное единство с первой частью, передать оттенки душевного смятения и волнения. Третья часть (Allegretto) часто исполняется пианистами оживленно, легко и светло. По - иному интерпретирует ее Valentina Lisitsa. Она не сглаживает контрасты, конфликт не исчезает и не разрешается - исход борьбы не предрешен, трагедийность не исчезает. Длинная пауза тишины в конце исполнения Sonata подтверждает ее драматическую трактовку пианисткой. Мне понравилась данная интерпретация своей близостью к нотному тексту и духу музыки Beethoven, виртуозным исполнением, яркими контрастами, глубиной воплощения содержания и целостностью концепции. Считаю исполнение данной Sonata вершиной в творчестве пианистки Valentina Lisitsa. Светлана Давыдова

[@JoysiUSSR]

Красиво выразили эмоции. У меня попроще: благодаря игре Виктории (тоже пианистка, публикующая на youtube) и Валентине я снова сел за фортепиано через 30 лет (после неоконченной ДМШ). В данный момент через полгода уже играю 1-2 части лунной сонаты (делаю попытки разучивать третью.часть - пока техники не хватает) и это приносит мне удовольствие.

[@СветланаДавыдова-з5з]

Marat Sadykov Спасибо за отклик! Только мне бы хотелось знать Ваше мнение об исполнении Valentina Lisitsa Sonata Op. 31 № 2. Эта труднейшая Sonata заслуживает Вашего повышенного внимания. Рада за Ваши успехи в овладении "Лунной" сонатой. Сколько радости доставляют собственные попытки в приближении к идеалу!

[@carlamatos5165]

Я влюблен со звуком рояля, я не жалею, что никогда узнав. Но мне кажется, огромная легкость моей души в те моменты.

[@СветланаДавыдова-з5з]

carla matos Это очень радует! Я, например, только тогда могу говорить искренно об интерпретации, когда меня очаровывает качество звука исполнителя.

[@СветланаДавыдова-з5з]

Благодарю всех, кто откликнулся на исполнение Valentina Lisitsa Beethoven Sonata Op. 31 № 2 и мой комментарий к нему!

[@mikesierra8156]

Valentina, I love your talent and your courage. You are a beautiful person. You raise my soul to the sky. be happy for the rest of your life. Thank you.

[@Emma-ob5oj]

I didn't understand why the title is "Exploding Beethoven" then at 10:52 I understood lol. It scared the sh*t out of me!

[@willthain727music]

Wow. Your musicianship never ceases to amaze me. Concentration did not flutter for a second. Can't wait to see you in Toronto in April!!

[@SlimMixer]

16:20 one of my LvB favourites! very nice :)

[@792Paul]

I was at the concert, you were wonderful, thank you sooo much!

[@Agusfn20]

i was listening this with headphones, i thought something exploded in my house

[@wladypimentel]

Valentina you are unbelievable. Love you!!! You should play more Beethoven, it's so full of heart.

[@Thomas11611]

I bet that was a sign for people who were sleeping to wake the hell up hahahhaha

[@antonk6359]

Beethoven would approve.

[@WebArtsTV]

+ Томас Кроуфорд Зная Бетховена, если б он был в этом зале, и там кто нибудь спал, то Бетховен бы послал всех и ушел оттуда)))) Ну судя по его Биографии он так делал не раз, когда кто нибудь говорил во время его игры)))

[@Thomas11611]

+Jony Frank Was you writing to me?. Sorry, I don't understand Russian xD

[@colincooper236]

One does not simply fall asleep during a Valentina Lisitsa concert.

[@peter-andrepliassov4489]

He basically said that if Beethoven was in a concert hall and a member of the audience fell asleep he would send everyone out of the concert hall. However, judging by his biography he did not once send anyone out of the concert hall if someone spoke during his performances. I'm not the best at reading Russian (not my first language), but he said something along those lines. :)

[@rudolfbrink]

Brilliant Valentina thank you for sharing kind wishes Rudolf..

[@yanayrton]

Despite the auditorium (the venerable Salle Gaveau) loud caprices and sudden idiosincrasies - a insignificative minor event -Valentina gave a impressive memorable ,strong personal performance from this sensible Tempest Sonata from the timeless teutonic genius called Ludwig.Ars Gratias! "Ludwig van Beethoven IS the very apex from the Human Creation.He remains not surpassed by anyone . He stands reverentlly by meritus & absolute grace close near and imbricated with The Mind And Heart From God." ― Yan Ayrton, a young composer in development and evolution. >>> .ARS SEMPER.VITA PLENA. Yan Ayrton, classical composer

[@elisenielsson416]

Bravo Valentina. Beautifully played. We love you.

[@sxduranable]

holy crap!!! That startled me!!! LOL!!

[@xXxMareanxXx]

+Suzie Duran I see what you mean now! =)

[@EpigeneticAlteration]

I've watched this video at least 10 times and every time I'm expecting it and still nearly have a heart attack! Valentina has nerves of steel to continue playing like that.

[@danieljdick]

Same here.

[@IloveSPIDERZ]

It just happens out of nowhere!

[@derekgulbranson]

Beautiful dress. Modern yet classic. Love the color. Almost as beautiful as the performance.