VFX Artists React 92: Pinocchio vs. Pinocchio, Halo Live Action

[@morbid1.]

I'm 3D animator and I must admit... stop motion animators are different breed... holy fuck, this craft and artistry is mind blowing.

[@RhysKSmith02]

Yeah, they take a special level of patience and skill to do what they do. I always look in awe

[@blablamann2973]

Pls pls pls watch Mad god. The visuals are stunning!

[@MarineStudios]

As someone who does basic stop motions I can confirm they are very hard

[@teneesh3376]

And any movie that does it is purely out of passion now. Cause you can replicate the look of stop motion with cg now. The Lego movies and Oni Thunder God are proof of that

[@Marksman3434]

@@Nimajneb42069 actually, Dark Crystal isn’t stop-motion, that’s real-time puppetry. Very different

[@waltergarcia3689]

"father when can i leave to be on my own" the greatest voice acting of the Anthropocene era

[@Robotic_Boi]

"Ive got the whole worldussy"

[@4orb]

The Waffle House has found its new host

[@anoobis_]

That got me cracking up

[@waltergarcia3689]

@@4orb avg 12y/o

[@jaimefenger3730]

Second best, best is: " cOmE oN tIbO! gReAt AdVeNtUrEs AwAiiiIt! DIIIIS KA DIIISSS KA DIIIIS!"

[@jklappenbach]

Del Toro had been working on his version for years. This looks like Disney couldn't let Del Toro take the spotlight alone with a story that Disney felt like it owned. Which is telling, and sad. And it was obviously an emotional decision, as they didn't put out a competitor until it was almost too late.

[@nekokna]

Exactly! It made me sad that in the video they presented it like disney was first and then the others including del toros ☹️

[@nelsonth]

For such a big channel, it's disappointing they didn't do any research

[@KevinAllentube]

Check out the French "Beauty and the Beast" that Disney tried to bury.

[@jackthefrog80085]

Yet Paulie shore was the best of them all

[@jklappenbach]

@@jackthefrog80085 You're so fired.

[@GNIKPlays]

Halo: Landfall invokes the same raw gritty sci-fi feel that District 9 had and the fact that they're over a decade old and still hold up super well is a testament to how good their film direction was.

[@tommymaxey2665]

Yeah Diarrict 9 came out of the original plans for a halo live action show

[@imdurc]

I guess I'm in the minority here, but, I thought the Landfall one looked pretty janky in places.

[@Soliye.]

@@imdurc It was a proof of concept. They didn’t have to go full budget to show what they wanted to make. Yes the vfx are janky, but the action and all is still better than the Paramount show.

[@alexfrost2799]

One thing I think helps is the lack of Spartans. Spartans have always been unnaturally fast compared to humans. It's hard to make that look good from a visual standpoint.

[@Soliye.]

​@@alexfrost2799 Nowadays Spartans are superheroes winning wars singlehandedly (Infinite). While in reality they are tools/weapons to change the tide of a battle. They don't need to look comedically fast and strong to show their real strength. ...Unless you're making a Red vs Blue type show, then go all out.

[@harrywompa]

Del Toro's Pinocchio was so good, it was so thoughtful and actually made the moral not shit. Everyone was a real character too, I've never cared about Japeto before.

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

I also love how Del Toro's Pinocchio counterpart is in sense, a light in the darkness for everyone he comes across who is having a hard time with their lives. He changes Geppetto, he changes Sebastian, he changes Candlewick, and even Spazzatura.

[@GrimmBones]

@@TheLazyFusspot_3428 Yeah. And the best part is that he wasn't a really good person immediately. He broke stuff without thinking, he rebelled against anything boring, he was a kid, but a chaotic one. Doesn't mean well, but not doing his best to be good. Once he learns how to be good is when he truly becomes a good influence on others. I just love it so much.

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

@@GrimmBones That's how natural and human he really is, as opposed to Disney's live action counterpart...

[@GrimmBones]

@@TheLazyFusspot_3428 Yeah. In the original Diney's Pinocchio, he at least does bad things, like try smoking, breaking stuff, drinking alcohol, and whatnot. In the remake, he already knows those things aren't okay, and doesn't do them. Shows how much Disney has lost their vision they used to have.

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

@@GrimmBones It just shows that not everyone is perfect

[@gthm7]

Hey, so I was working in MPC Bangalore as a character modeller until yesterday, and the Disney's Pinocchio was the 1st project I worked on. I was so burnt out by the work, i was running on fumes and only thing that kept me going was my respect for my leads, sup and production manager. I was SOOOO disappointed when I saw the movie, because how rushed the story felt. I never cared to know if I got credits in any film after this. And the amount of creative changes we were getting. I mean the design changes we were getting while the compositing was going on. It's just sad.

[@Burner-B]

Man, I can't imagine how crushing that must've been. At least it is pretty clear that all the issues weren't VFX but "creative" choices. Like not hiring Paulie Shore as the voice of Pinocchio.

[@PoopiDScoop]

@@Burner-B He is talking about the Disney remake not the straight to dvd remake.

[@bombomos]

I'm sorry you got pushed so hard

[@WinedandDined27]

@@PoopiDScoop the joke went over your head. He was saying that Disney SHOULD have hired Paulie shore to voice Pinocchio.

[@PoopiDScoop]

@@WinedandDined27 Oh yeah, that probably would have made me actually watch it because I am unironically compelled to watch the shitty straight to dvd one based off of the three lines I heard from Pauly in this movie.

[@MonsterRat1000]

i was able to watch Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio in theaters about a month before it came out on netflix and i have to say, it was one of the best theater experiences that i've had in a long time. seeing it on the big screen gave me the opportunity to truly appreciate the amount of work that was put into making what was a more than decade long passion project.

[@TeaGamingPanda]

Damn lucky! If only Netflix films have an all around theatre release for everyone to see, never heard Pinocchio getting it at any of mines. Especially the All Quiet on the Western Front, apparently Germany (I think) had a theatre release, but America didn’t. I think, no matter if films are made for streaming services, they should AT LEAST be in theatres too. Movie theatres is where all the magic is at and one can truly appreciate the craft to its full potential than just your TV. It’s a different experience! It’s truly the home for movies I’m incredibly happy that you got to see it in theatres!

[@renelukas1067]

Same here 👍🏻 way better than woke Disney

[@Gentleman534]

@@renelukas1067 Disney has so many problems and gay people aren’t one of them

[@DeletedDevilDeletedAngel]

@@TeaGamingPanda pretty much some movies from streaming services were released to theaters but some are pretty bad

[@NRLazy]

Pinocchio: a true story. A masterpiece of this generation. I've never laughed so hard.

[@Driptacular_Dragonborn]

@Corridor2230 cringe bot

[@brandong7193]

Seeing them geek out over Neill's Landfall short was such a delight, Halo's marketing was top-notch back in the day. That short blew my mind as a kid

[@John-X]

i feel like...Corridor could do something like Landfall. wish they would. ik they're making a Halo thing but it's not gonna be Blomkamp-esque.

[@mikec4390]

I love how they mention Guillermo del Toro taking a dark spin on things when they go over his version of Pinocchio, because the original story is in fact really dark. Disney often takes dark stories and sanitizes them to try to make them more kids friendly (but then some aspects are still kind of twisted anyway if you really think about it).

[@SirsasthNigam.]

thats what Disney should do , make darker , truer to source live action films

[@ryanelliott6706]

Kung Fury. A ridiculous 30 minute movie on KZbin with a laser raptor and Viking women with machine guns. Super low budget. Self aware. But the VFX are 80s style.

[@Shenanigans303]

Yes! I love kung fury!

[@timrucker7428]

An all time favorite

[@FpvMental]

Watch the shivering truth and tell me you don’t see kung fury as the most boring hack retread

[@Lovicide]

Unfortunate they weren't able to release the full length movie they filmed a couple years ago. Funny enough, I think all they had left were visual effects but their budget ran out

[@lukedaigle6911]

I recommended this a while ago. Glad other people are starting to recommend it now

[@MrMando_1138]

I swear, all of the Bungie live action Halo promos for Halo 3, ODST, Reach were so damn good. Those were by far the best when it came to live action Halo content.

[@christopher3226]

Same with the live action Destiny ads. So much better than they needed to be.

[@nameforcomments4092]

They did those bits of future war vets, complete with scars, talking about their battles in a future war museum with a diorama, ohhh it was so immersive and well done.

[@clintonleonard5187]

I mean, they created Halo and they were the reason any of it was good, so...

[@tito12star]

Same with Halo 4: Forward unto dawn and Halo Nightfall

[@Miss_Trillium]

​@Héctor Contreras not as good in my eyes, but still a lightyear ahead of the TV show

[@SimplCup]

Now i want to see "Voice actors react", because there are many films, videogames, cartoons with great voices and that would be incredible to see such video on your channel

[@glennmorganfan9411]

YES!! Get a professional like @Brizzyvoices to be on the couch.

[@BeansBroBeans]

It'd be cool if they got Matthew Mercer or Ashley Johnson

[@grutarg2938]

That would be amazing. I’ve listened to tons of DVD commentary from Futurama which includes some of their voice actors and it’s so interesting.

[@Snafu2346]

I second this idea.

[@davemcdaniel4856]

You know Mark Hamill himself would show up if they did that!

[@brandanreese123]

I do want them to talk more about Halo cinematics and other Halo shorts. Their ODST trailer was also freaking remarkable. Why oh why couldn't the show deliver

[@stirlinggreer]

Was gonna say this. that original ODST trailer with the funeral... best halo storytelling yet

[@JayYoung559]

The Reach segment where the original Noble 6 died is still one of the greatest Halo ads ever made

[@minizimi3790]

That ODST trailer should have been the baseline for the entire story. Can you imagine following an ODST squad through training (with a Spartan killing one of them after orders to attack said Spartan), fighting insurrectionist, then running into the covenant and fighting with said Spartan? Easy 2 seasons right there.

[@silvy3047]

The show wasn't good because they waited 15 years for the franchise to be on its deathbed before making it

[@jennywdland]

The TELEPORTATION FIGHT SCENE from S2 E1 of WARRIOR NUN is INCREDIBLE and the show runner Simon Barry mentioned in an interview that it was the MOST CHALLENGING VFX SHOT in the whole show, especially on a small budget! It'd be so cool if you guys could break it down!

[@tamarap.5503]

I’d love to see this!!!

[@pineapplepizza311]

YES

[@brie8635]

Yees! Please react to Warrior Nun VFX

[@matchaT808]

I second this!

[@Amylue94]

That scene was so awesome. The teleportation and the choreography was amazing for a show that didn't have a huge budget. All the fights scene were awesome.

[@acemstudio]

God Disney's Pinocchio towards the end just looks like they literally ran out of budget so were like "Here....Do whatever you can with it." and just shoved it onto Disney+. Like it just FEELS so much like a direct to DVD movie. Meanwhile Del Toro's Pinocchio is a movie that RADIATES passion and love for the craft of animation. My parents even watched it and they HARDLY ever watch animations anymore. Takes a lot of convincing. But they loved it. And I love it. It's a gorgeous movie. I loved how the Life and Death sisters were like these biblically accurate designs and the concepts of life and death and what makes life meaningful, and what makes family family and the voice work and just EVERYTHING about it is incredible. I can't believe studios didn't want to back it. Their loss.

[@joeniedbala]

It was one of their "copyright renewal" films that would re-lock characters like Jiminy Cricket, Tinkerbell, Monstro, etc. When De Toro's was announced, they more than likely fast tracked it.

[@acemstudio]

@@joeniedbala I can buy that. I mean it's the same company that screwed copyright law so bad for the sake of keeping Mickey under their IP which I honestly understand as that's their mascot.

[@samuelsmith5400]

I swear these live action remakes have to be money laundering schemes, they literally almost barely break even and no one wants them.

[@shathaan1763]

Disney movies will never feel like they are made with love lol, most generic films rn

[@Qorram]

@Memes By Ryan69yt how is that "weird" is something important to the history line

[@WestcoastAudiGuy]

Something about the behind the scenes time lapses of stop motion animators doing their thing... It's so cool to see the characters move smoothly and the animator all over the map doing adjustments

[@terranbricklin]

I cannot fathom keeping track of the movement of the characters in real time. You're manipulating them to such small degrees, sometimes multiple characters doing different things at once, sometimes objects... it's insane. I could never.

[@StefanCreates]

@@terranbricklin I have so much respect for stop motion artists. I've done a little bit of it in school and let's just say it's not great :')

[@DJBaphomet]

While I'm slightly disappointed they didn't talk about Del Toro's Pinocchio more, I do find it nice since it means they couldn't really find much wrong with it to show off, so it was just a quick overview to see how much better it is than its competitors, if you can even call them that

[@grutarg2938]

Del Toro wanted to actually tell a story. The other two just wanted to sell tickets.

[@YayaFeiLong]

Granted, this is VFX Artists React, not Animators React I do hope they revisit the three Pinocchio's in a future Animators React episode

[@blahorgaslisk7763]

@@grutarg2938 Well Disney aimed at young kids who think a talking cricket in high hat is the epitome of cool... A True Story aimed at minimal effort, low cost and making a deadline to ride on the coattails of Disney. It's the Pinocchio your mom say you have at home. And finally there's Del Toro doing the Del Toro thing, making a grotesque version that concentrate on telling a story for teens and adults who actually care about story.

[@maximeteppe7627]

@@grutarg2938 even when his films are a bit mid (it happens even to the best) Del toro has a very consistent visual style. That's why the CG water in his Pinocchio works: the water's look was thought out in a way that would fit the overall art design. His Pinocchio is absolutely great.

[@seveneyes77]

They probably did in the extended version

[@DoodleChaos]

I was hoping they would also include the MeatCanyon Pinocchio short

[@DeltaByte]

It wouldn't be fair to compare something that good to the other three though

[@KudoYoung]

@@DeltaByte Am I a real boy papa?

[@4orb]

The Waffle House has found its new host

[@carlosfer2201]

@@DeltaByte GdT's is really damn good though.

[@jordanbridges]

@@KudoYoung *PAPAA*

[@Eivor85]

Sam's reaction to the 3rd Pinocchio was hilarious,I couldn't stop laughing 🤣

[@BarrettSmithBB]

Neil Blomkamp's version and his other work around the 2012 era was so awesome!

[@MisterDutch93]

District 9 is still my favorite "First Contact" movie by far. It's such a weird blend of aliens, realistic sci-fi, body horror and a South African backdrop that just make it a really standout film. There is nothing else like it.

[@forentertainment3259]

@@MisterDutch93 It's a shame that Blomkamp's career seems to have devolved into trying to recapture the magic of that film, without much success. He has a very clear voice as a director, and a great understanding of incorporating effects into his style, but I feel he might need someone else to write him a script.

[@1point21]

I'd love to see a reaction to the other Halo promo materials. The ODST and Reach live action trailers are awesome!

[@kenohki3492]

Yeah, Reach was my favorite one...both trailer and game actually...

[@theRok29]

definitely, Deliver Hope was fantastic with CGI and props

[@tallAldiProduction]

I really enjoyed forward into dawn too

[@RyTrapp0]

It honestly disgusts me how ALLLLL of this marketing material and the live action demo trailer are SO DAMN GOOD, how they're EXACTLY what everyone wants from a Halo show/movie - and yet the projects that actually get backed are half assed shit. It really makes me despise hollywood, it's hard to look forward to much besides the technical achievements always being made in VFX. Just like with the state of video games, at least we have indies out there to give us some quality stuff. If only those people could get the real budgets...

[@Scuzzlebutt142]

@@RyTrapp0 Indeed. Flat mate was watching the Halo Wars Cinematics last night, and it was better than the all the stuff in the Halo TV show. How is it they can get so much write in terms of story, character, and such in Video games but they balls it up as soon as TV writers/producers touch it? Halo should have been Band of Brothers in Space.

[@ScottThePisces]

I'm so glad that you did comparisons to what Bungie did with the Landfall live action shots! I think that's what we were all thinking when the Halo series came out and disappointed us all.

[@uria3679]

Paramount+ Halo show (and most original shows on Paramount+): I did it for the attention

[@EpicFatLip]

First mistake was showing Johns face! We know he doesn't show his face, yet it's one of the first things they do

[@cpl.barbarusc4814]

Add deliver hope Halo Reach trailer into the mix, that one also looks badass and feels like a continuation or a spiritual predecessor since is a prequel to Halo 3: Landfall, worth remembering and mentioning.

[@86Fallowcp]

Not all. You cant trust Halo fans with their opinion on modern halo.

[@Cheesepuff8]

Yeah when Neil Blomkamp was no longer working on it it was a big red flag

[@TheChildofAuraReborn]

Pinocchio: I honestly have to say that Guillermo's Pinocchio actually out-shined even the original Pinocchio movie, in terms of cinematic value. Not downplaying how beautifully animated the original was, but something about Del Toro's Pinocchio, the lovely songs and the amazing character designs, it just stuck with me a lot. Amazing movie, and I wanna see Del Toro produce even more animated/stop motion content (Yes I know he was in charge of Trollhunters; Trollhunters was amazing until the third season, we don't talk about 3Below, and Wizards was... all right). Halo: I am absolutely BAFFLED at how badly they bungled it. I'm thankful I never watched it, but holy shit I didn't realize how bad the animation was. It looked like the episode in Halo Legends "The Package", except that animation was pure 3D and had an excuse to look like that, because it was stylized. And we don't even get into everything wrong with the story, but let me say this: YOU DON'T CUT SGT. JOHNSON. YOU *NEVER* CUT SGT. JOHNSON.

[@l3capitan]

Warrior Nun especially season 2 is a great underappreciated show with spectacular vfx, would love to see y'alls take.

[@Talkimas]

13:07 Anyone else notice that the bullet counter seems to deplete completely randomly here? They didn't even bother to have it tick down per shot.

[@nezfromhki]

One thing you guys didn't note on in the video, but what really takes me out at times with the Disney one is the color grading. Like at 4:10 , look at the levels of saturation between Jiminy Cricket and Pinocchio compared to the rest of the shot. The colors of the animated characters are popping off the screen, while the rest of the picture is very desaturated and grey. They don't look like they're in the same world at all. It could have been a deliberate choice at some point to make the animated characters feel like they're more "magical" and otherwordly, but it's just distracting with the otherwise photorealistic look. Edit: I guess they probably talk about this in the extended version, but I'm not going to pay just to find out :P

[@kingbrunies]

The mix of stop motion and Halo live action in this episode made me think that maybe there should be an episode on machinima. It was such a big thing for so long I think it would be cool to watch.

[@AlexZenigata]

Red vs Blue.

[@kingkaizoku85]

suprisingly similiar profile pictures and names

[@rollie_rollin]

In S2 E1 of Warrior Nun, there is a fight scene with lots of short range teleportation, shot seemingly with no cuts and the showrunner mentioned that it was one of the most challenging VFX shot in the show. It will be cool if you could react to it and give us more insight on that scene!

[@jennywdland]

YES please react to this scene from WARRIOR NUN!!

[@bltamburica]

Yessss! This would be awesome!

[@brie8635]

Theres some great vfx in this show!

[@matchaT808]

I second this also!!

[@a.dalton4086]

Amazing scene, would love to hear more about it!

[@Thorax2552]

Landfall was so mind blowing and it's a damn shame the actual show failed miserably to capture even a tiny fragment of it

[@SpicyMelonYT]

Fenner is so dope! Literally every time he's on camera I know its gonna be good.

[@ItsFreakinHarding.]

I spit out my damn drink when that scene played of Pinocchio saying "Let's go great adventures await! Skedee...skedee...skedee!"😂🤣💀

[@Clipssssssssssssssssss]

Blurr studios’ halo 2 cutscenes are incredible for today’s standards let alone when they were made

[@MulderScullyFBI]

It would be AMAZING if you could comment the Teleportation fight scene from Warrior Nun 2x01 (starts at the 38:00 mark in the episode). Another cool VFX scene from Warrior Nun is in 2x08, starts at around 41:40.

[@a.dalton4086]

The teleportation fight scene!!! I think about it every day I swear it's so smooth

[@getyeeted9550]

There is a teleportation scene in S2 Ep1 of Warrior Nun that’s stunning, hope you guys will be able to break it down!

[@EricHamm]

Fenner is a good choice to see more often be nice to hear more of his opinions of what makes it bad and how it could improve. Can't wait to see more of him!

[@karlo.with.a.k281]

I love Guillermo's Pinocchio. Ats ome point in the film we asked ourselves, "Is this really a stop motion animation?"

[@SkullZie]

SAME!! its so fluid in motion that you dont even know!!

[@aggrogahu]

13:08 I love how Sam can deliver this joke without breaking out in laughter himself.

[@Carbon2861996]

I love the one a bit later ,,Dude, that's the face you make when you touch a crystal"

[@roacqua]

I would love to see a Warrior Nun Breakdown. Their VFX are amazing considering it's budget.

[@mjty2868]

S2 of Warrior Nun improved on their action scenes, especially the teleport and phasing scene which i love so much. Would really love if you can cover Warrior Nun. Thank you

[@affigeralbert3967]

Please more episodes with Fenner! He knows so much about Vfx and Comp and he has so much interessting stuff to say. Would be cool.

[@ethai1]

I would love to see you guys react to: -Silent Hill from 2006, the otherworld transitions and creature designs still look good imo, and the scene with dark Alessa when she "integrates" herself unto Rose. -Fight Club - it actually has some CGI shots, including the intro (which is one of my favorite movie intros) -Sam Reimi's Spiderman 1 and 3 (because you already talked about 2) - Spiderman 1's effects may not hold up very well today, but it still has some nice shots. And spiderman 3... The sandman effects? when Spidey punches through him? or when sandman is "born"? and of course, Venom! I think it'd actually be cool to do a comparison between Spiderman 3's Venom and Tom Hardy's Venom, vfx wise.

[@ItsFreakinHarding.]

What really blew me away was the day I found out that the entire sex scene between Brad Pitt and Helena Bonham Carter in Fight Club with CGI! When I first saw that I swore it was real!

[@ethai1]

@@ItsFreakinHarding. One thing I really like os the smooth transition in the intro to Edward Norton's face. I remember watching behind the scenes and I think they said they consulted a brain surgeon about the design, when working on the intro.

[@RyTrapp0]

I've been requesting the 'Fight Club' intro for YEARS LOL. They finally covered the 'Lord of War' intro a little bit ago though, so credit for that, that's another REALLY sick intro!

[@dreamsnow9657]

Yes, Silent Hill!

[@ethai1]

@@RyTrapp0 Same, and I ask for Reimi's spiderman films and silent hill for even longer. I don't know if they read youtube comments anymore tho.

[@dunstonlion1342]

Would love to see animators react to the new Puss in Boots movie! Plenty of excellent scenes to pick from!

[@dauph6252]

Yes! Puss in Boots was awesome

[@iamabread9614]

My Grandpa work as an stop motion animator for many movies. He loves his work and even made me love it too. My fondest memory of him and me is that we created a short 3 minute Warhammer 40k animation. It took as just a month which is amazingly short since be was still working then. We painted, added details, and he even made custom parts for specific scenes. His amazing and it gave me an incredible respect to stop motion animators. Also one time I went to where he works and it was every painter, collector, and creater of figurines dream. It was amazing to see people work and build art. I hope this medium of animation stays alive forever.

[@TeruteruBozusama]

Sounds like a lot of fun :D

[@lukefraser2244]

I haven't seen it in years, but Forward Unto Dawn remains a really key memory in my mind watching it. I even randomly visited the site where they filmed most of it, Simon Fraser University in Vancouver. Of all of the live-action Halo stuff, it still holds up with some really good moments

[@PuppetRebelPress]

Fenner's face throughout the Disney's Pinochio sequences was priceless.😬

[@emnersonn]

i like men

[@danny_thunder7378]

Agreed

[@Djarov1999]

Aggreed! But then again, there wasn't much competition.

[@Death0Row]

🙌

[@AltonV]

I agree even though I have only watched the trailers

[@r.daneel.90]

@@Djarov1999 I'm fact, there is a lot of competition

[@hurricaneofpuns3722]

Landfall is what got me into making cosplay. My first suit was an ODST because of Landfall's depiction of ODST armor.

[@chrisperrywv]

12:19 so I was cruising around Reddit last week looking for other people who thought the finale just looked so bad (I finally got around to watching it) and some people absolutely loved it and thought it looked incredible. I just couldn’t understand. The first person stuff was kind of cool- but other than that…

[@trapofonidrillore185]

This was suggested to me while listening to the song “Dupe- Gangsta” 🥶🥶🥶

[@blackfire-yf7hi]

I always appreciate your guys thoughts and insights to how visual effects are used in films. It gives me a new appreciation for the craft and the films that I've watched. same for stunt works.

[@smashdriven1640]

I loved Sam’s reactions to Pinocchio A True Story.

[@King_Olas]

I'd love to see your guys' take on Rango

[@EarendilMitsos]

I'd really like them to talk about the Universal movie logo. The 1920's one with the plane revolving the globe and the letters floating around it must be a real, practical thing, but I don't have the slightest clue of how it's done. Also how it evolved over the years. The modern one is full CG, but there must be a story around the old ones.

[@Death0Row]

Yeah almost 40 watched del toro's pinochio and i cried a lot😂Such a good movie and voice actors🙌

[@nightspicer]

Big congrats on getting the 6 million! I just wanted to say that the new Blender short would be awesome for the VFX series. As well as *Aslan from the Chronicles of Narnia!* where you could do a comparison to the "live action" Lion King. Also at the end of second CoN movie there's a big water creature, so it might be cool to see what you think about that. Maybe also, Max Schneider's Gibberish music video, the editing kinda breaks my brain there. The *last agni kai fight from ATLA* would be perfect for for the Animators React. It's so stunning! And for stuntmen react It would be cool to see you react to the duel from "Potop", it's really good sword fight (tho technically it's sabers i think)

[@cheddarbub6324]

I fully agree. Also I just saw a bot that copied your comment 💀 I got ur back

[@nightspicer]

@@cheddarbub6324 damn, that's a first time for me

[@Anatinea]

IIRC, they have already done a Aslan vs. Lion King comparison.

[@nightspicer]

@@Anatinea they did?? when?

[@ericjohnson6120]

It sickens me that Disney, a multi-billion dollar animation conglomerate, forgot that clothes absorb water.

[@d.b.4671]

"Oh, I didn't forget, Steve. I just don't care." --Disney execs, probably

[@Kobrakai21]

Fenner was a great addition to the couch. Looking forward to more from him and the rest of the crew. Cheers

[@benjaminsillence8278]

16:03 is everything I feel when watching the old HALO footage... so much potential...

[@giovannifacci]

Having work of Matteo Garrone 2019 Pinocchio, in feel a bit disappointed that hasn’t been included in this episode. I think Garrone captured the true nature of Collodi original novel. Which is not reapply a child story, it’s dark, grime and sad. It’s not an happy adventure like the Disney ones so Del Toro is not a spooky twist, the original novel it’s actually veeery spooky.

[@capsey_]

I would loved if you guys did an episode of animators react on Puss in Boots 2: The Last Wish! I really didn't expect anything from a sequel of a spin-off of a sequel of Shrek, but this movie is SO GOOD! Such a gorgeous movie and action is awesome as heck!

[@amadeusmalonje6948]

Some good material to react to

[@brannonhill4046]

A sequel to a spin-off from 11 years ago at that

[@MadMrMatter]

I'm a grown adult man and I loved the Guillermo del Toro Pinocchio lol super recommend

[@Benception]

It would be fascinating if you talked about the Marcel the Shell movie. The way that the stop motion footage can occur with hand-held camera work and live action. Would love to know how it's done

[@dylon2932]

The Core (2003) would be a good one to look at! Early-ish era VFX, trying to do bold things, fails, succeeds, and nobly tries to incorporate practical effects alongside its VFX only to have the latter look worse as a result.

[@darthtater38]

Love seeing the HALO content! Keep up the good work! It's worth noting that Halo Landfall came out in 2007 as promotional material for halo 3, not 2012. Bungie uploaded the video to youtube in 2012, hence the confusion.

[@2gamerzone7]

You guys should react to the flute scene from Alien: Covenant. I know you’ve covered clone shots before, but I personally found the interaction between the two quite interesting.

[@Hollyclown]

“I’ll do the fingering.”

[@wminion3890]

Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio is a 10/10, magical.

[@stevea2085]

After watching this video I will certainly watch his version and pass on the Disney one.

[@VitoHGrind]

Percy Jackson: Lightning Thief. Speaking of doing wet cloth, there is a scene when Percy first gets empowered by the water where it goes up his arm making his leather bracer, shirt sleeve and face wet that's pretty well done. Very curious how they pulled it off. Not to mention Grover (the satyr's) goat legs are kind of amazing.

[@OBryanAguiar]

true, they should react to percy jackson

[@cheddarssalad1230]

A lot to unpack in this video. I am flabbergasted that the Halo tv show looks like that. It’s ropey as hell. The Disney Pinocchio was also ropey. The cricket is so saturated in those boat shots that he doesn’t even look like he’s in the same movie. Loved the Del Toro one. My friends actually worked on it so congrats to Devon and Meg on the golden globe win. And I almost feel bad for the true story Pinocchio. If there weren’t 2 others the same year it would have been forgotten like it was intended. That said, it has probably made 5x as much money as it expected just because folks want to dunk on it.

[@khaaaaaaaaaannn]

Me and Sam both wheezed with laughter at the same point, and said "wow" at the exact same moment. Sam is my spirit animal

[@RA-nu7zh]

I know this might be ALOT of work for you guys but for the 100th episode. One idea is to gather all scenes you have reacted to throught this whole time and make a vote on the best 100 scenes. Relive them again and maybe have some new ideas. I am not saying this is a good idea. Merely, an idea. Love to you guys, from Sweden. You do not know how much you have helped me, keep my head up, the last 2 years.

[@perrinebernard277]

Warrior nun’s VFX was really insane mostly in s2 ! You should go check it out really you won’t be disappointed !

[@loganproksch9305]

thank you for talking about Halo, hopefully someone is listening out there and tries to do it right. I am still waiting for the film industry to recognize you guys and ask you to work on something though. I keep waiting for your logo to show up in movie credits or something, it's obviously clear that directors and people across the board respect you guys. I hope it comes through for you all, love your content btw.

[@RIMALDI]

3:31 to 3:51 taken out of context is just (chef's kiss)

[@thedovahkiin7896]

I always liked Huell, he was one of the few people of Saul I considered to be actually kinda nice. Glad to see he's now doing business with you guys :)

[@HBB4Fun]

I absolutely love the gritty Halo over the tv show one. You guys were hilarious!!!

[@AngelicaBob09]

Warrior Nun has some awesome VFX!!

[@jonsimo]

I always love when Sam is on VFX Artists react, guaranteed guttural laughter every time 😂

[@wesleywatkins1505]

Halo Reach and Halo 3: ODST trailers have my favourite shots because they're so integral to the story telling, reach especially. I still watch those trailers because they give me chills. I'd love to see you do the Halo Reach trailer one day!

[@CodyVibbart]

As someone who has seen animated movies, I can honestly say that this is good.

[@DiMono]

In 2014 Microsoft put out a movie in support of Halo 5 called Halo: Nightfall. I recall it being pretty good, and it's probably worth taking a look at in a future episode. Also, Halo 4: Forward Unto Dawn was FANTASTIC for 2012 when it came out, also produced by Microsoft. It's amazing what happens when the people who own the IP put it to use.

[@reddishcarp1237]

Halo Nightfall is regarded by vast majority of halo fans as shit.

[@DiMono]

@@reddishcarp1237 4.1/5 on Prime Video and 67% on Rotten Tomatoes seems to contradict that claim. You not liking a thing does not necessarily mean others don't like that thing. 😉

[@TuffMelon]

@@DiMono ...and a 67% is pretty shit on a rating system. Nor does it tell you how many of that 67% are actually Halo fans or even know about the content. 67% at best tells you it isn't the worst thing ever. It could be terrible Halo content which is dumb fun enough to attract likes from people who don't know better. Same goes in reverse, dude. Liking something doesn't make it good, either.

[@SalelakaMokonzi]

I never heard of Halo: Nightfall, and will have to check it out. I was also going to mention Forward Unto Dawn which based on my memory and what I just saw here, had substantially better story telling and graphics.

[@DiMono]

@@TuffMelon Considering it was released specifically to promote Halo 5 and it wasn't publicized beyond that audience *at all*, I would expect that only people who play the game or are familiar with the IP were even aware that it existed. 67% liking it is 2 out of 3, which is a far cry from the "vast majority" thinking it's shit. I'm not claiming that me liking it means other people like it, I'm saying the evidence does not support a consensus that everyone thinks it's bad. In fact, most people seem to think it was pretty okay.

[@LilMackTheSnack]

You guys always deliver such high quality content, it always makes my day better when I get to watch a video from you. Thank you for all you do ❤️

[@DannyForan3D]

ive been a big fan of you guys for a while now. I finally can say you saw my work! I worked on the environments in Guillermo Del Toros Pinocchio.

[@lukasbieri]

You and everyone working on this film did an incredible job! Well done!

[@TeaGamingPanda]

8:08 I love how happy Fenner looks about wanting to see the whale scene

[@alerocillo]

The Halo live action trailers for H3,H3ODST, and Halo reach will always hold a special place in my heart. It's the closest thing we'll get to a Great Halo live action film.

[@guillermozabala5094]

Remember reach

[@andykazoo]

I recommend SODAZ on KZbin

[@Death0Row]

Yeah the reach one was freaking epic😁

[@geojimz]

Delivery Hope was amazing. I still watch the “directors cut” version every once in awhile. It was so epic.

[@gamertherapyconsoleyoursel5804]

I'd love to see the Crew react to the Red v Blue fight with Tex and compare that to the fights in the Halo show.

[@JocelynMakenna]

I would love to see y'all talk about doctor who. Anything from classic who to the beginning of the reboot into the new stuff (specifically the flux arc!!)

[@coldermusic2729]

You guys should look at halo forward unto dawn. It’s so GOOD!!! It was a series in 2012 created on KZbin to market halo 4 and be a possible starting point for a film adaptation too (which sadly never ended up happening). The series follows a cadet in training, where there base ends up getting attacked. It’s is such a cool and original concept as we never see the franchise in said peoples perspective. Not the best cgi in the world, but I think it still looks pretty amazing

[@patriksanchez1240]

The Pinocchio VS was so entertaining lmao. A Dune comparison (Lynch 84, Mini Series 2000, Villeneuve 2021) would be insane.

[@morpheuslordofoneiroi3293]

I can't wait to see a Zelda movie come out, and you guys comparing it with that amazing Live-Action Legend of Zelda skit you did a long time ago 😊 Honestly, I really wish you had expanded on that skit. Same with that little Tether skits you did. Those were so much fun!! 😊

[@GoodPintOfAle]

Go guys. I would like to suggest you a challenge. Take old movie with practical effects and try to recreate it in cgi. Like Jason and Argonauts or Clash of Titans. What do you think?

[@cstephen98]

You should have included a reaction to the original Disney Pinocchio. That would have been the Avatar or Jurassic Park of its time and animation being that it was only the second Disney full-length animation after Snow White. It's really just a set of (stunning) set pieces, showcasing what Disney had learned and invented in the animation field tied, together by a simple narrative.

[@MirAuch94]

at 5:17 the water doplets on pinocchios legs are also very weird. They already look strange when the water is going back, but they just completely disappear after 2 seconds.. even the falling ones!

[@jesterday3965]

I liked the first Halo movie that existed. I don't remember exactly which one it was, but I loved it. It felt good. I should find and rewatch it to see if it stands the test of time.

[@Mariopwnzu]

The biggest tragedy about the Halo series is how fucking good the props are Like the entire prop and costuming team did amazing only for literally everyone else to just drop the ball entirely

[@KatsuyosDimension]

I am probably too late, but please do the Lillith teleportation fight from S02E01 of Warrior Nun

[@michellejohannsen9823]

I was hoping they’d pull in the Pinocchio live action with Jonathan Taylor Thomas made years ago to see how it stands up against these newer versions.

[@-ratto-]

10:54 DVD rentals are still very popular in Japan, but you can't buy this movie in Japan!

[@MandalorianOfMiatas]

16:00 The entire Halo community sighed like this too. It could've been so much more...

[@darryljack6612]

Instead of including a Halo segment yall should have included an examination of graphical quality of the video game "Lies Of P". Which is another Pinocchio property with a Bloodborne type vibe to it.