Villagers React To HOW FAT MAN WORKS ? | Nuclear Bomb ON Nagasaki ! Tribal People React

[@gushaynes5182]

I love that Raeen is totally concentrating on videos where he is learning he doesn't talk very much he is studious.

[@nikoalander3546]

Thats why i really like Raeen, he's smart :) and he's learning.

[@marioelburro1492]

I like his concentration, trying to soak up and understand information

[@focu2567]

Raeen got it whereas Sarru misunderstood, " bomb more powerful if it hits the ground"...

[@andrecostermans7109]

and him commenting first on the human aspect and the effects of the bombing, great mind , he surely would do well in local politics

[@VoMFilms]

Raeen definitely has a good head on him. Not only would he be a good student but he is kind and compassionate too. I see so much potential in him, and I bet he would go far with the right opportunities :)

[@the42project_II]

Other things worth showing are the events of Chernobyl or the aftermath of what happened after the bomb, such as the shadows left by the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

[@captaincanada67]

There's an amazing black and white film that was made by the American Government as they entered Nagasaki when it was safe with military and scientists studying the extent of the Damage and sadly the death toll. No video shows the destruction on the ground and the damage levels depending on how far away from the epicentre people lived, better then this formerly classified film.

[@ghoulie11]

Show Chernobyl, 3 Mile Island, and Fukushima meltdowns. Chernobyl was a disaster due to poor infrastructure, both the 3 Mile Island and Fukushima meltdowns were contained much more effectively.

[@Desert_Rogue_Tanker]

also i think they would enjoy or marvel at the fact at the same type of energy that can be harnessed to destroy could provide electricity to people and nations

[@the42project_II]

@@Desert_Rogue_Tanker agreed.

[@davidchen8758]

I actually wouldn't mind seeing them reacting to the Chernobyl mini series 2019.

[@Swrdfshtrmbns]

It would be amazing to see them react to videos about history in India. We never learn much about India on this channel.

[@taatyavinchu6019]

Tru, they should show their culture too 👍

[@backgroundmusik]

A lot of India's history was destroyed or hidden by the English. They couldn't handle that they had a rich culture before they got there. Some argue that there was a nuclear blast in "pre historic" India. I don't know about all that, but they have found the glass from something like it. India was in an "advanced" culture while folks in Europe were still painting mammoths on cave walls. Them, the Egyptians, South and Central American's, and arguably Atlantiens thrived during the I've Age. By advanced I don't mean exactly like us, I mean more advanced than we would have previously expected.

[@boomshakalakaboom543]

@@backgroundmusik Nuclear Blast In Ancient India Ok I Am Indian But This Is Just Pure Myth😂😂😂

[@southindiantemples8615]

@@backgroundmusik Well Ancient India Is Still A Mystery.....From Indus Valley Civilization To Vedic Era To Sangam Literature Work To Warrior Kingdoms To Mauryan Empire To Tripartite Struggle And Many More....

[@guoi8314]

@@southindiantemples8615And Also Mahajanapadas Era To Satavahanas To Three Tamil Crown Kings To Palas Of Bengal To Cheras Of Kerela To Islamic Invasions To Colonization Etc Etc

[@MaYkO-WWH]

Babu looking real fresh with the new threads! They All lined up from the barber, these three dudes are my favorite. It's like sharing information with a friend and seeing their reaction. Definitely has helped me through these tougher times. We all are truly the common Man.

[@madeincda]

Agreed. Well said.

[@backgroundmusik]

They do feel like friends. I think this is why reaction videos got so popular during the pandemic.

[@ShawnRavenfire]

It would be interesting to show them the positive side to nuclear science as well, such as power plant reactors and radiation cancer treatments.

[@Lundis919191]

2 sides of a coin, nuclear power and nuclear bombs. India have nuclear power and bombs.

[@jaredf6205]

Like that this bomb was a big part of ending the war with Japan saving a land invasion, it kept the Cold War cold and ended big wars between rich countries and is probably responsible for India and Pakistan having not gone to war.

[@OpenGL4ever]

The reinvention of Teflon happened because of the Manhatten project. They needed a material that is resistant against uranium hexafluoride and this material was Teflon. Today millions of people have pans covered with Teflon in their kitchen.

[@AhJodie]

@@OpenGL4ever Yes, now teflon is in every waterway and our bodies.

[@wepntech]

add smoke detectors, and microwave ovens to the list, as well as various medical technologies.

[@mekkur2551]

Show them the Tsar bomb, its 3333 times stronger than hirosima's little boy.

[@captaincanada67]

There was only one ever built and no one knows the exact power because the Soviet Union was a pack of liars who would tell the world what it wanted them to hear. There are suggestions it was smaller then this and some American Scientists believe it was 20% bigger then reported however only the Soviets know for sure. None have been made or tested since that single prototype.

[@01DOGG01]

There;s no content there. It's just a massive explosion.

[@mekkur2551]

@@captaincanada67 Tsar bomb was tested near sweden. It was estimated 50 megatonn. Before it was constructed, they wanted to make it 2x stronger.

[@92GreyBlue]

Raeen has such an intelligent mind he always seems to ask the right questions when it comes to learning about a particular subject.

[@SithCelia]

That was fascinating ... and horrifying. Babu paints this world like a garden full of so many different flowers. Here there be three mighty hearts full of love for all!

[@JohnHazelwood58]

"Sir God had made this world like a garden, there were different types of flowers everywhere..." < that are words to remember! ♥ *luv&peas

[@unkeymoo]

Do they know your country is one of the countries with the bombs?

[@GuardianGrarl]

I can't wrap my head around the mathematics of research methods. Imagine them trying to wrap their heads around the mechanics of an a-bomb...

[@AhJodie]

But, they did!

[@jovetj]

Before they could figure out how to make a nuclear weapon, they had to figure out how the atom works and what to do with it.

[@UliFandoms]

Finally. Thank you for providing them this knowledge.

[@jaizo_]

they have to know we want them to react to Kurzgesagt videos by now, there’s been so many comments for it…is there a reason you’re not? Yes you have to translate a lot but you already translate a ton for odd videos like this so it’s not that different (not hate, just suggestion)

[@nathanharvey8570]

I've heard it said that there's copyright concerns or some such.

[@100100freak]

Let's hope they will do it in the future. Kurzgesagt videos are so much better than 99 % they show them here

[@amateuryoutuber]

​​@@100100freakeah because the video they reacted is cheaply made (no hate to any animators with little money to work with) and it reuses animations a dozen times and specifically this video shows 1600 feet as the same height as a 5 story building.

[@wahidj34]

ive been waiting for this. ever since the first one where they thought it was filled with gunpowder.

[@LauraCourtneyette]

Raeen is spot on with his analysis.

[@t5ruxlee210]

All physicists around the world who were involved in atomic science, including those in Japan, knew that creating a uranium atomic bomb would be a very slow, very expensive, process with a production rate of perhaps one every year. This type of bomb, while very reliable and relatively simple in design, was not going to cause Japan's warlords to lose much sleep. When the Hiroshima bomb went off, it was understood. When the Nagasaki plutonium bomb went off soon afterward, Japan's war strategy left with it. All was lost on that day.

[@KentRoads]

And the war was won

[@CruelestChris]

Little Boy was literally an antiaircraft gun pointed at a subcritical mass, what in the world are you talking about?

[@Kenneth_James]

Raeen is a smart guy. He grasps whatever you show him very quickly. I am glad they no longer thing it is just tnt inside the Nuclear bomb. Under different circumstance I am sure that Raeen could be very successful in the US

[@monicapdx]

Very informative video, and they did get a lot of it, like how the fusion multiplied. The bombs are horrible, but people need to be aware of them. I remember in the early 70s, meeting a girl with mild epilepsy who had actually *never heard of the atomic bombs.* Apparently her parents had sheltered her so much because of her condition. She was horrified. (Note, we were college age.) We were equally horrified that she had no idea. You need to know the dangers of the world you live in, and their history...

[@KentRoads]

How is a nuclear weapon a danger lmfao

[@monicapdx]

@@KentRoads LOL, yeah, but have you ever met anyone in their mid-20s who's never heard of them? Even in ye ancient 70s, that was a mindf%%k! I mean, we were younger than her by a few years, but we grew up having atomic bomb drills like kids now have shooter drills. (Useless though ours were.) And she didn't know??? WTF?

[@OpenGL4ever]

@@KentRoads In the time of cold war it was always a danger. A nuclear war could have erupted at any moment, and the ICBMs only need about 30 minutes to reach the other end of the world. With submarine based nukes this time shrinks to 3 minutes. But it's nice to hear, that you didn't have to live in that time, kid.

[@KentRoads]

@@OpenGL4ever a nuclear bomb can sit there and do nothing indefinitely... it's the crazy people with the control of such devices we should worry about

[@OpenGL4ever]

@@KentRoads That's wrong if you talk about the H-Bomb. With a hydrogen bomb you have to replace the tritium from time to time, because Tritium has a half-life of around 12 years and thus decays.

[@manny3655]

Fantastic insight into the devastating effects of nuclear weapons, especially from people unfamiliar with such things. The empathy of our friends warms my heart and I share their feelings and thoughts. However, we must be realistic, Pandora’s has been opened. I also pray these weapons never be used again, but if a foreign adversary attempts to strike The United States of America or her allies, such measures must be taken. And may God help us all…

[@akyhne]

I still don't think they understand the difference, between gun powder, a TNT blast, and a nuclear blast.

[@OpenGL4ever]

@@akyhne The video that was shown them seems to be longer and what we saw was just only a small cutout. I hope they saw a long version of it.

[@akyhne]

@@OpenGL4ever Well, I haven't seen the original video. I just know from previous videos, that they think bombs etc. uses gunpowder. Gunpowder has a burning speed of up to 350 m/s. Explosives from 7.000-14.0000 m/s. The neutrons in a fission, travels at around 10 million m/s. Maybe they don't need it in such details. But they should have some indication, on what the differences are.

[@frgproductions6165]

Umm... why did the video end so abruptly? I was invested in it too lol

[@Bambi_Sapphic]

2:52 you should show them Oppenheimer's speech about shiva the destroyer of worlds, after witnessing the first test of the shameful weapon he helped bring into existence.

[@sageofsquirrels111]

While the science of it all can be interesting, I still am saddened by this particular invention by our species. :'( RIP all that have perished in such a way. Regardless of method, sword or bomb, civilians should be left out of conflicts,

[@thedoctorofallmen]

in a way the bomb stopped all large wars. No one dares use a nuke against another country with a nuke. In this way it has stopped major conflicts between China, India, Russia, America.

[@marioelburro1492]

@@thedoctorofallmen without them, i bet wars would still be happening. Humanity will only advance further

[@jovetj]

@@ItsMeBarnaby Absolutely. We can't know the concrete numbers, but there are good reasons these bombs were chosen as a desperate and drastic move. Japan absolutely refused to surrender. After the bombs and the war was over, the USA built Japan back up, and now we are very good allies. What happened was terrible, but good can come from terrible things, even if we do not always understand it.

[@loveisthemostpowerfulforce1397]

Yep I agree. Time for a more positive invention, like technology made with zero point energy.

[@littleredwritinghead3781]

God bless them. We should all react this way.

[@boredguy1297]

You should find a video on the theory of Mutally Assured Destruction and see what they think of the bombs after that.

[@Maraien]

9:24 Are the subtitles right? The video JUST said that the detonated the bomb when it was in the air because that covers more area

[@deehaley2737]

Raeen was so involved in watching this video, his analogy was good. Sarru said what I was thinking it's so scary. 😓😥😭great video though

[@dmschoice2571]

Thanks for this react! It was certainly essential after all the historical information to get some technical information, too, to the three. (My first comment here seems to have gotten deleted somehow, and I think I have an idea why: I used a ...well, typing sequence that might have looked like a internet URL, and the comment section might be set to filter those as spam. Something to better keep in mind here...)

[@WDCallahan]

“I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.” - Albert Einstein.

[@cablebrain9691]

Please show a video about what led to the bombings.

[@01DOGG01]

The bombs were dropped to test real-world effects and to show the soviets that they had the tech and were willing to use it. Kokura was a civilian town. They went to target the people rather than the nearby industry.

[@CruelestChris]

@@01DOGG01 "Civilian town" that is a _city_ and had one of the largest weapons plants in Japan?

[@01DOGG01]

@@CruelestChris That was next door. They were going to target the people not the factories.

[@CruelestChris]

@@01DOGG01 No, it was inside it. They were going to drop on the city centre, because WW2 bombers always did that because it made it harder to miss the entire target. Which they sometimes still did.

[@sonyawasmer2344]

It should be noted that the scientists including Oppenheimer, in later life, regretted working on The Manhattan Project.

[@KentRoads]

So?

[@sonyawasmer2344]

@@KentRoads So what?

[@KentRoads]

@@sonyawasmer2344 so without Oppenheimer Japan would have continued WW2

[@sonyawasmer2344]

@@KentRoads how could you possibly know that? Because the air and ground assaults weren’t working or you’re related to the Japanese emperor or something?

[@KentRoads]

@@sonyawasmer2344 because history is documented...

[@saliftrilok6129]

babu that is one of my favourite songs ,thanks for the transalation

[@qwazse4]

To those requesting they view a better, broader, explanation of the world wars … they did film a couple of episodes reacting to videos about the total casualty counts and the geopolitics. So these three now have as good a context as most westerners.

[@KentRoads]

Yes a video on how many died gives a true recount of the world wars

[@tomray8765]

Both Raeen and Babu are quite sharp-- They understood the Video and have a good idea about what atomic weapons are about.

[@focu2567]

Yes they do but it didn't click with Sarru.

[@tomray8765]

@@focu2567 Well, He is young, and I think he sorta got the idea.----I bet the other two are also quite sharp in day to day life too. No one pulls the wool over their eyes.

[@JRush374]

Scott Horton's Enough Already playlist would be a great thing for them to react to. It would help them to understand America's recent wars.

[@ghoulie11]

The scariest part is that the nuclear weapons we have now are more than 60 times more powerful than Fat Man.

[@gaming1zanagi-1999]

Yeah if you referred to Tsar Bomba then I agree.

[@yourguard4]

you mean ~1000 times

[@Matoakas]

Great video again. They have a very good understanding of what they see. Better than many I know actually 😅 They don't immediately distrust something that sounds crazy. They are curious and wants to understand. They would be great students. And do very well. Babu should read and write. He's such a master with words. The others have such respect for him, and listen to his words. With good reason! And Raeen would do great in chemistry, physics or something similar. He pay attention to details.

[@clydedeloach9066]

You need to explain to the villagers that the military leaders of Japan would not surrender despite the warnings presented by the Allies and the fact that their Axis Power allies had already surrendered in Europe. To end World War II and to save more millions of Japanese and American lives the decision was made to drop the bombs and get the Japanese leaders attention to stop fighting. By dropping the two atomic bombs the Japanese leaders surrendered. It was also feared that the Soviets and Nazis (prior to surrender) were working on atomic bombs as well. By completing the Atomic Bombs first the United States ended the war on its terms without endangering the homeland of the USA.

[@sandraard4306]

I just love you guys ! I can't help myself !

[@leojones7266]

About time ,now they know it not gun powder as in a previous video 😂

[@backgroundmusik]

Now show them how to best survive something like this. Things like decontamination of clothing and which direction to flee based on the wind and radiation. Maybe some effects of radiation sickness. Ouchi and his torture by doctors keeping him alive. I'm also still advocating for a first aid episode.

[@asummerday4448]

first aid episode would be good

[@OpenGL4ever]

First you need a lot of distance between you and the detonation center. The greater the distance the better. The next thing you need is a nuclear bunker 4 m below surface with air filters and an entrance around a corner build in such a way, that the radiation of radioactive dust, that falls into the entrance doesn't reach you. In that bunker you have to stay there for about 3-4 weeks. In this time frame most of the radioactive particles with a short half-life will decay. After that time, you can leave the bunker to collect and grow food. It does make sense to remove the top 10 cm of soil layer in a farmland to grow new food.

[@skyrat3816]

This was an interesting watch showing a simplified explanation of the inner workings of the fat man. With the destructive power of these weapons covered, please can you show them a similar video on how useful nuclear energy is and how it can power our daily lives.

[@WatchingDude]

This information will be really important for them. I think they now understand the magnitude of this bomb.

[@akashashen]

I'd love a video reaction on some quantum physics explainer video, or one of the Scale of the Universe videos that go down to sub atomic particles.

[@chipper841]

Hey fellas, India and Pakistan both have this kind of bomb!

[@disturbingmindset2586]

Great

[@halwacristal6909]

Salam, Old Baba shukriya for your nice ghazal!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@Tounushi]

The scary thing about the Fat Man is that even when you boil down the basic operating principle of it, it's mindboggling. Little Boy is a lot simpler, since you're essentially just slamming two rocks together. Here you're taking a rock and using fire to squeeze it down so it blows up. And then optionally you take that explosion's fire and use that to squeeze a metal-filled can for an even bigger explosion. So much of human technology can be dumbed down to the ideas of lightning, fire and rocks.

[@amateuryoutuber]

Show them the atomic bomb scene from barefoot gen 1983, it is of the Hiroshima bombing

[@lazarus5609]

11:09 if only it was that easy..for as long we stay divided and not 1..we will always have these..

[@TheBulitt]

At least now they know its not gunpowder like they thought from the previous videos...

[@CyborgRowlet]

Now I wonder what their reaction would be like to Uranium glass

[@Maraien]

Finally they know how a nuke works, they've thought these bombs have been using gun powder the entire time LOL

[@B055DERB055E]

I would like to know, how they think about Oppenheimer, recite to the Bhagavad gita 🙂

[@Hawk_of_Battle]

Honestly, this video is not all that great in some areas (the depiction of the neutron chain reaction is all kinds of wrong, and the english wording is atrocious), but for guys who've never seen any of this stuff before and aren't hearing it in english I suppose it works well enough. They now know a little more about radiation and can see the breakdown of the bombs mechanics. For any future stuff on nuclear technology/incidents I recommend Kyle Hills Half Life Histories, though that may just further terrify and convince them that nuclear power is nothing but bad.

[@LimerickWarrior1]

The scary thing about this is it might have saved the lives of 6+ million people. Japan had 3 mill troops to defend the home islands and civilians etc.

[@roguekiller23231]

Next, Please show them a video about Tsutomu Yamaguchi, the man who survived both nuclear bombs.

[@RealILOVEPIE]

Can you have them react to a video on the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Station Disaster or the Fukashima Dai Ichi Nuclear Power Station Accident.

[@Alrion1704]

4:15 center seat 😂

[@RicardoPestana]

Next video: Villagers build an atomic bomb

[@KG-jl1xf]

Chain reaction reminds me of the tale of Raktabija. 🤔

[@BigMateo24]

Chain Reaction reminds me of a bad Keanu movie.

[@KG-jl1xf]

@@BigMateo24 Haha indeed! It was the first Keanu Reeves movie that I ever watched.

[@Maraien]

Show them a video about the Tsar Bomba, that bomb was 50 megatons but could've been 100 megatons, and that was created in 1957

[@grugbug4313]

Solid! Top KEK!

[@manny3655]

Babu appears to be in fine form this morning.

[@TheBaraful]

I like videos about scirnce,especaly nuclear science...so I would recommanded more videos like this...About nuclear enegry pros and cons,nuclear power plants...etc. It is little bit confusing for someone who is not educated about it to show him end resoults then you explain it to them...Also you should make video about concept of atoms,moleculs...chemistry at general...let have one day of week when they have class from science... p.s I am European and in my country we have ,,science"class divided in chemistry class,physic class,biology class ,etc. and every class is at least twice per week,so thanfully my education system payes attention towards science...So I think your guests should get one video per week about it.Also if you need idea for theme or which subject you wanna pick I can propose few ideas...

[@smfmnoneya9134]

Japan bombed Pearl Harbor in Hawaii... which might be an important detail to mention.

[@aminy23]

There was also the Rape Of Nanjing and the Manila Massacre. The Atom bombs killed 0.1 million Japanese (105,000). The Japanese killed potentially over 10 million civilians throughout Asia. The Nazis killed 6 million Jews. To name a few more, they committed the Alexandra Hospital massacre, Laha massacre, Banka Island massacre, Parit Sulong Massacre, Palawan massacre, Wake Island massacre, Tinta Massacre, Bataan Death March, Shin'yō Maru Incident, Sulug Island massacre, and the Pontianak incidents.

[@Nimbus1701]

This is a very scary thought but the initial explosion of one of these things gets hotter than the sun significantly. Thermonuclear (fusion) bombs get hotter than fission bombs because if the type of reaction. I'll just say that the surface of the sun is believed to be around 15 million degrees Celcius, and somewhere between 5 to 6 thousand degrees Celcius on it's surface. A fusion type bomb gets significantly hotter for a very short period of time somewhere in the neighborhood between 200 to 300 million degrees Celcius because the hydrogen fuel doesn't start to fuse until it reaches around 70 to 80 million degrees Celcius, and then to maintain that reaction to produce an explosion it needs to get even hotter. So, in the milliseconds after a blast it gets between 10 to 20 times hotter than the sun. That's why if you are unlucky or possibly lucky enough to be directly under a blast you'd just be gone probably even before your body could even feel it or understand what happened. About a second after the blast you are talking about between 20 and 30 psi of overpressure which would destroy everything, even hardened steel and stone structures, and it is likely any silicates directly under it would turn to glass, not to mention what it would do to animals and people. You are talking about extraordinary temperatures at ground zero. I'm not even sure that you'd have enough time to spontaneously burst into flames before you were just gone. Obviously, the farther away you are the less you will be impacted. These things are massively powerful, with Russia detonating the largest (in terms of megatons worth of explosion at between 50 to 60 megatons). If it was dropped on New York then the entire city would be destroyed. I would like to see them react to that detonation, and there is a video of it. Those old bombs the US and Russia had literally had the power for 1 bomb to destroy large cities, even dwarfing what happened in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Let's hope those days are long gone. I agree with another poster that commented about wanting them to react to all the benefits that can be produced by nuclear power and radiation. It really is a double edged sword and can be used to either destroy the world or change it for the better.

[@env0x]

i love these guys so much lol

[@Blablablarandomguy]

As citizens of this planet we have to strive for a peaceful world, no matter what it takes.

[@apreviousseagle836]

Sadly, that requires nuclear weapons.

[@terischiech]

I don't think humanity should be praised for these 'accomplishments'.

[@aminy23]

It ended deadly wars in favor of cold wars. The Japanese killed millions of civilians from Singapore to China to Korea to the Philippines and more. Some estimates are higher than 10 million, the Holocaust killed 6 million Jews for comparison. The atom bombs killed 0.1 million Japanese (105,000), but created an immediate end to the war saving millions of lives from ongoing conflict. Today in the world, fewer people are dying from war than ever before and it's limited to Israeli's To name a few more, they committed the Alexandra Hospital massacre, Laha massacre, Banka Island massacre, Parit Sulong Massacre, Palawan massacre, Wake Island massacre, Tinta Massacre, Bataan Death March, Shin'yō Maru Incident, Sulug Island massacre, Pontianak incidents, and the infamous Manila massacre.

[@sinderella23]

Raeen for president! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@3COI]

You should show a video on Genghis Khan and other historical conquerors

[@minty_Joe]

I think understanding the dangers of such technology can help prevent from being used against any living creature, human or animal. I hope that this technology can be put to better use, such as scientific research or making electrical power. Not everyone wants to because of what dangers unfold in anything nuclear or atomic energy.

[@GdpJapan]

All of them are so right. I’ve been living in Japan for 22 years now, my family is Japanese as well. Justified or not justified, as they say, all nuclear weapons should be dismantled. Can you imagine a country that has a special handicap degree called “victim of an atomic bomb”? As any other handicap, we also have that in Japan, yet the government is more and more reluctant to recognize a citizen as a victim of the two atomic bombs dropped in Japan. Could not agree more with the three of them. That episode was the beginning of a shame period for human history. Blessings from Japan.

[@OpenGL4ever]

We don't have a lot of options to fend off an asteroid that's headed for Earth. Nuclear weapons are one possible option. If we dismantle them, it's one option less. And asteroids are time critical. The nuclear solution get's more important the shorter the time is between detection of the asteroid and its impact.

[@MrGrimBG]

Do you like large scale conventional war then ? Cause that is what you're gonna get if there are no nukes to keep great powers in check.

[@GdpJapan]

@@OpenGL4ever Well, scientists agree that blowing up with nukes an asteroid in course collision with Earth would just make matter worst. That is why NASA has launched DART, the Double Asteroid Redirection Test, which will calculate how much a collision with no gravity can change the course of an asteroid by just kissing it. And that’s what NASA is doing right now. Just because a huge nuke launched into space could fail in many ways, such as tearing up into pieces which will impact the surface separately, or just get the rocket wrong ending up with crash it on Earth. I know you can deactivate the nuke when things go wrong but that does not make it fail passive or fail safe. That’s why nuking the hell out of that asteroid is just against rational thinking. It is not my opinion, experts say that. Have a nice day, sir.

[@GdpJapan]

@@MrGrimBG With conventional war you can go 1 to 1, use cruise missiles, supersonic missiles and stuff like that which would obviously scale into a major diplomat conflict, such as Taiwan right now. Nukes are not good at aiming strategical targets. They just go boom, and that’s it. Whoever is around gets killed or screwed forever. Even though, I personally agree with you somehow: getting rid of nukes creates a very complicated scenario if other countries do not comply. It is not about military warfare, like fighter jets, troops, drones… It would be more like who fires first and who gets to fire faster and more and more and would be a major catastrophe for all human kind. Yet, if nukes just go like boom boom and usual warfare is lost, spending more cash on nukes than developing other weapons (which we need, of course, to save innocent lives) then spend more in nukes and the problem is over. Yet the USA has been dismantling it’s nuke arsenal (some of which still operates on floppies in some places) for to our safety’s sake. Right now I believe there is only one threat in this nuke stuff we are talking about. And that threat should be considered extremely dangerous. My blessings and thanks for replying so sincerely. It is always good to hear other people’s opinion, and we are not going to go mad with each other. God bless you.

[@OpenGL4ever]

@@GdpJapan They didn't. There might be some scientists, that have that position, but not all of them. A powerful hydrogen bomb is rather clean and and it really depends on how you use the bomb against the asteroid. There are several different options. But one definite fact is, that a nuke does contain the most energy per kg of all options we could put into space in a short time frame. And when that is the only option, then it's the only solution.

[@Moples223]

Also the horror of what they unleashed wasn't lost on the scientists involved. In the words of Oppenheimer "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds". From Hindu scripture of course.

[@slantos2668]

I join my voice with the fellows in asking that all nuclear weapons be disarmed/destroyed.

[@Amadeo790]

Wasn't the guy who created the atomic bomb so horrified by his creation that he was quoted "I am now dead, destroyer of worlds" or something like that.

[@Stroyer123]

Yes. Oppenheimer cited a Hindu sacred text called the Bhagavad-Gita "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds" when he witnessed the first nuclear detonation.

[@demon6937]

sir you should let them see the strongest nuclear bomb detonated in history the Tsar Bomb specially comparing to other nuclear bombs. as for the countries who owned nuclear bombs and dismantle it unfortunately they won't do it because to be able to carry those means you are superpower as a country.

[@realtsarbomba]

👍 You have my consent

[@danbaldwin9511]

Pray that the bomb used as a last resort does not become a bomb used for tactical or strategic daily use.

[@cferren6117]

With this information, and $5.00 they could by a coffee!

[@AhJodie]

Atomic bombs are horrible, and so are so many other weapons of technology..... Humans are so beautiful, and still have such major flaws, such as anger and greed. Love to all.

[@kyledufty7039]

my like is for babu song and your compassion. No need to fight, If you disagree...live seperate and be at peace. there is more land for everyone and if you disagree seperate yourselves. I hope thanos only destroys our technology and not the people.

[@Belnick6666]

have they ever reacted to a tv show? like other said, Chernobyl is a great show based on a historic event

[@srbrant5391]

It’s shocking that all of this is declassified from the get-go.

[@douglascampbell9809]

It's been declassified for over 30 years. I did a science report on it in high school. Knowing the basics doesn't give you the skills to make it happen. In atomic explosions they use the term shake, like shakes of a lamb's tail. At the time of the first atomic bomb, scientists needed a term for an interval of time equal to 10 nanoseconds. That's how close the timing needs to be to make them work. You need to have 30 some detonators at different space distances from the trigger all fire within a nano second of each other. The larger yield warheads have things happen while the initial explosive is happening but before the nuclear material goes up to increase the power of the weapon.

[@srbrant5391]

@@douglascampbell9809 True, true. Plus, plutonium isn't something that you can get at the Seven-Eleven.

[@OpenGL4ever]

@@douglascampbell9809 10 nanoseconds is the period time of a CPU running at 100 MHz. Today you can buy oscilloscopes that are suitable for measuring electronics at frequencies below 200 MHz for a view dollars and with a little more money you can buy much better equipment. And today, there are electronic components available, that can switch several out ports at the same time in a much shorter time frame. Today the electronics of an implosion bomb are definitely no more a major hurdle. But getting the Plutonium still is. That's why controlling the spreading of nuclear material is the main goal of the Nuclear proliferation.

[@manny3655]

Daaaaaaaaa Booooooooooooiiiiiiiiiiiyyyyyyyyyyyyz!

[@georgegonzalez2476]

It would be nice if they were informed about a few more facts, like the estimated number of deaths from a standard ground invasion would have been more than ten times as many. And that both India and Pakistan now have some nukes.

[@rakninja]

my friend, an estimate is not a fact. also, consider that most of the deaths of a land invasion would come from soldiers. killing entire cities was wrong in the medieval period, and it's still wrong even though we can do it in an instant instead of a couple of days. the atomic bombing is the blackest stain on human history, and it was my country, the very military i served in, that did it.

[@rmr5044]

@@rakninja War is wrong in general. The atomic bombing of Japan was the catalyst that prompted the Japanese to finally surrender. A mainland invasion might have caused more deaths than the bombings, or it might have not. While the bombs were awful, they informed people just how dangerous total war is and just how dangerous nuclear weapons are. The threat of mutually assured destruction via nuclear weapons is ironically one of the major reasons why major countries haven't gone to war with each other since WW2.

[@rakninja]

@@rmr5044 you think in the thousands of years that mankind has lived in societies large enough to have conflicts that can be called wars that it was only in the 1940's that we discovered "hey, total war is a really bad idea"? also, the major nations have constantly been at war with each other since WW2. the difference is that they do not generally directly send their own troops to face one another on the field of battle. the wars the US has been involved in for the last 20 years are the direct results of these indirect conflicts, generally against the soviet union/ russia. no matter how you slice it, no matter how you justify it, killing an entire city in the blink of an eye is the single most evil act any human has ever committed, and we did it twice. think of it like this, if you justify our atomic bombing because it forced surrender without the massive casualties of a land invasion, you justify the use of the same tactics against us. think about that in the light of our interference in the middle east since the end of WW2. to say it plainly: to justify the atomic bombing of japan is to justify 9/11.

[@georgegonzalez2476]

@@rakninja The US Army had very good numbers. The Japanese defended Guadacanal and the Solomon Islands, almost down to the last man, with huge casualties on both sides. The estimates were over a year of warfare, with huge casualties on both sides. Strange, but it's probably correct that the A bombs knocked a year and a million casualties off the numbers. Not pro-bomb, but numbers are numbers.

[@rakninja]

@@georgegonzalez2476 those numbers, however, were generated by people with an interest in developing and dropping the bomb. and, also, as i told the user above, by justifying such slaughter of civilians in the name of "ending the war sooner, with lesser overall casualties," you justify the same sorts of things being used against us.

[@briarpatch720]

after J Robert Oppenheimer built the atomic bomb he quoted the Hindu scripture Bhagavad-Gita. "I have become death, the destroyer of worlds" After the war he focused his efforts on making sure nuclear weapons were never used again

[@joejoeington6899]

And then they forgot it all and said it was filled with gunpowder in the recent video

[@LilyKazami]

To contrast with the atomic bombs, perhaps a video on how the Sun works would show the good parts of nuclear science.

[@apreviousseagle836]

Sky Scholar ;-)

[@daanishsandhu5479]

Plz show them mr slav science videos of comparison

[@nicepunk00]

Babuuuu

[@ogorhan]

make them react to the Tsar Bomba

[@norXmal]

I really don't think they would want to know how many nuclear bombs there are in the world.

[@starrynight1657]

I wish more people were interested in science rather than weapons and wars. Look at a basic introduction to atoms and what matter is made from.

[@abhaynayak6342]

Please react to more History videos.

[@jaded...]

Have them react to footage of hydrogen and nuclear tests

[@williamjordan5554]

India has these.

[@zatozatoichi7920]

The real scary thing is that these bombs are literal child's play compared to current ICBM systems.

[@MaticTheProto]

The only complaint I have with the video they react to is that the assets used are wayy too modern, Nagasaki didn’t look like that at all, neither did the bomber crew

[@thefallofKAE89]

Socom 2 kgm and gnostec?

[@leoc3492]

There is no gunpowder in a nuclear weapon.