Vocal ANALYSIS of System Of A Down's "B.Y.O.B." leaves me utterly shocked!

Now with my ears piqued by Daron Malakian's vocals and my love for Serj Tankian's style, it's time to tackle B.Y.O.B. from System Of A Down. I was not expecting the dichotomy between these two styles in the same song, and it works really well!
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to System Of A Down performing "B.Y.O.B." for the first time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Written and Performed by SOAD
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions. Here's the link: • System Of A Down - B.Y...
Show System Of A Down some love: / @systemofadown
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑‍🤝‍🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have a sister channel: THE SINGING HOLE. Join us there to examine how ordinary creatures create extraordinary sounds. / @thesinginghole
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#systemofadown #Reaction #TheCharismaticVoice
-------------

[@ronkerr5080]

There's a reason they won a Grammy for this one. Amazing song. Great analysis. Overlapping themes of consumerism, blindly following propaganda, and the horror of actual war

[@MetalGeek464]

At times I'm wondering is it consumerism or weapons dealers that are pointing at. I read enough articles about how that goes down and the parties, desert (middle east) could be a reference to that workd and it's effects. Or I'm fing way off base.

[@claudballs5679]

Yeah communist Rock. I suppose if you're a low-life that thinks everything should be free and you shouldn't have to work for a living this band is just the bee's knees to you. as they'd say back in the day

[@nikolah.8472]

@@MetalGeek464 maybe, but i think its more the campain to justify the iraq invasion. The party theme was like the recruits getting catched by "It will be a piece of cake, we will win like its nothing." The glorification in that time was enormous.

[@Makaiton]

As this song has aged and history has progressed, I think the original intent was to make the song more timeless, transcending the U.S. past, present (at the time), and predictable future. After all, how many years has the U.S. been at peace over it's lifetime? I think their intent with the smooth area was to hit more than one thing. I'd argue it can be interpreted several ways, all probably canon: 1--The American draft, or the ever-present fear of it's reimplementation 2--Consumerism; I think this is brought out by the visuals of the party as well as the helmets saying things like "BUY." 3--The callous and inhuman perspective of those in power when engaging in war, counting both the lives of their soldiers *and* their victims as worthless 4--Propaganda, and how it recruits and subverts us 5--The callous disconnection of the American people in regards to what the U.S. government does

[@HollowGolem]

@@MetalGeek464 ¿Por que no los dos?

[@soulessshadow5356]

Daron's "WHY DO THEY ALWAYS SEND THE POOR!" in the opening really sets the tone for Serj to come in.

[@j897xce]

Thanks for casually sharing the lyrics with us!

[@soulessshadow5356]

@@j897xce I think you completely missed the point of my comment...

[@j897xce]

@@soulessshadow5356 I don't know the lyric. So if you made one up, I'm just gonna hear that from now on

[@soulessshadow5356]

@j897xce oh haha, yeah that's the line that Daron sings right before Serj comes in. I love how it sounds on the album but live it's even better! Sorry for the misunderstanding :)

[@FaulFerkel]

This line reminds me of Black Sabbath’s “War pigs”

[@aterzian]

The La La La La La La La ooouooo part is actually taken from Gwen Stefani because they were in the next rehearsal room and System kept hearing it, and they included it in BYOB.

[@benjaminnevins5211]

Can't imagine what Gwen Stefani was hearing lol

[@Wil_Dsense]

😂😂 LOL that’s hilarious and brilliant. Hahaha

[@vitisxvinifera]

Was that from the song “Rich Girl?” The “na na na” sounds?

[@aterzian]

@@vitisxviniferayes! That’s the song.

[@philly4444]

@@aterzian is there anything out there on Gwen's reaction to her "contribution" to the song?

[@llamavacuum3895]

This song came out as I returned from Iraq. It was... challenging. I loved SOAD, but this song challenged my 'identity.' Then I spent years working through the things most vets work through. Returning to this song and the lyrics after I had grown out of my indoctrinated identity brings so much value now. SOAD was calling out BS in society and our leaders before it was cool. I have my son listen to their music now, hoping he doesn't have to run through the same identity crisis I had as a young adult.

[@Mr.Crow7]

I hadn't quite enlisted yet when the song came out, however, I did hear it around the time, but I was in Iraq and I completely agree with your conflicting feelings. It took me a long time to realize that there's a difference between patriotism and agreeing with the government

[@kyleespinoza7201]

Thats so interesting, I remember when the video came out and there were tons of comments from vets (probably, they said they were but anonymity and all) who definitely felt attacked by the song, and then years later the sentient was almost completely 180.

[@321doucheface]

rage against the machine was doing it for a decade before these guys did

[@cerbuscankerous3714]

I thought the line about blowing up the sunshine referred to the desert Music festival crowd who set off pyrotechnics whilst poorer people have to enlist to further their lives through better health care and education, with all the risks that entails? Its not a critique of the military, just double standards.

[@bullie86]

Welcome home bro

[@Finvaara]

I first heard this song right after i got out of the army, a disabled veteran feeling used and abused. It really hit me just right. I joined up because i was poor and didn't have a lot of options, and because i bought into the patriotism hype they had been feeding me since elementary school. This song is now old enough to enlist. Older than i was, in fact.

[@michaelavanduesen]

one of the first things I thought about when I was old enough to understand the lyrics and meaning was about high school recruitment into the military. My grandfather unfortunately got drafted so he wasn't recruited. But I know my high school constantly had recruits because we were 30 minutes away from Ft.Riley. I've continuously, since graduating high school, had army recruiters try to add me on FB and one somehow got my phone number. I know people who either are, were, or about to join the military. And while I respect my grandfather and veterans, I don't like the brainwashing that goes on in the military alone...but brainwashing in society in general as well. I've heard some of the things they've been told, convinced about, and manipulated into believing. And then many soon come back to reality once they are in and deal with the day to day bs on post..and then the bs/trauma when they get deployed or on rotation. Some take years to really come out of it. Some never do. They are sold on a sweet dream of a life, this wonderful coverage and protection, and beautiful ideology of serving the country. And while protecting a country is important, wars are obviously verrry complicated and it's sad that these young men and women get to be the pawns into it bc they get brainwashed while still in high school or from family even. You hardly ever get the reality of what it means and what it's like serving until you're in and don't want to be there. And if it's not war, it's the crap that goes on at bases and surrounding towns. Then retiring is a whole can of worms. Sorry I ended up really digging into the convo when it was just supposed to be about my high school. Even with any of your feelings and opinions of serving, I still want to extend my gratitude. I still have respect of vets and active duty even if I have my reservations about war and the DoD. I am also happy that this song really hit you and resonated with you. It's always great to feel heard, understood, and seen. Especially when it comes to such a conflicting, complex, and controversial topic. I know it comes with also negative emotions and thoughts too. I am hoping you're doing alright!

[@this.is.a.username]

"a disabled veteran feeling used and abused" Not much sympathy for anyone feeling this way who joined up after the internet explosion in America. Even back in '97 there was easily searched forums full of Gulf war/earlier vets that were blatantly and bluntly honest about what you were going to go through.

[@Finvaara]

@@this.is.a.username i joined in peacetime, to avoid being homeless, and my only internet access was when i walked a couple miles to the library and waited to use one of the computers. While i was enlisted war began, and things changed a lot very quickly, but the problems i suffered were due to abuse by a bad actor in a position of command, and in no way related to external forces. It was just an abuser getting away with abuse in the Army.

[@beegeebad3193]

Yep now your government's instigating conflict here in Asia..

[@sharkbait_11b]

I did not join in peace time due to a promise I made myself on Sept 13 2001 but I did my dance in the desert in 2008 and yes we were used as pawns I look back and I'm proud of what I did with the men I was there with I'm not so proud of why our country sent us there

[@krisfrederick5001]

When System came out there was nothing like them. They were so unique, violently dark and harmonic. Their first album may still be my favorite because of this, you couldn't tell if they were being humorous or deadly serious. The answer is "Yes."

[@foramoreperfectamerica8490]

SOAD is either completely nonsenical or dead ass serious, depending on the song. Sometimes its both like Cigaro.

[@pubbiehive]

There's still nothing else like them imo.

[@Woooojcio]

Man, great describtion I feel the same way about them. This feeling are this a joke or a truth?

[@foramoreperfectamerica8490]

@@Woooojcio Depends on the song.

[@0x2A_]

@@pubbiehive I agree

[@ChemAndAdrenaline]

Let's not how forget how utterly amazing Daron Malakian's backing vocals are. You HAVE to be able to keep up with Serj, and I'm not convinced anyone else could do him justice the way Daron does.

[@jaredpickrell8310]

Couldn't agree more. I feel like they accompany each other so amazingly. Almost to the point of they are weaker without each other. I absolutely love Serj's solo work and collaborations, along with Daron's foray into Scars on Broadway as the sole lead singer. However, they both fall short (in my mind) when I compare them to their work in System of a Down. I miss system so much.

[@martenveersoo8502]

@@jaredpickrell8310 my question... why the fuck doesn't Serj even feature on SOB. WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

[@Leland2point0]

Something ive always felt gets overlooked in this song.. Serj's tone changes when he sings "you depend on our protection", almost screeminging it in the face.of the listener. The way he emphasizes "you" and "our" in that line really demands the listener to contemplate who is giving and who is receiving in this interaction, and the heavy load of what is being provided. Only 5 words, but very powerful.

[@thrashandburn10221]

Yessss my favorite part to karaoke. You cannot help but point accusingly when you sing it

[@PuckTheFenguins]

@@thrashandburn10221 lol as im sitting here singing the song in front of my computer holding my finger up pointing accusingly while reading this comment

[@jakeh2049]

The government, the “leaders”, people “in charge”… they depends on us (taxes, military, food production, infrastructure, literally everything) we run the country for them, and we’re supposed to be on the same team (same table..) yet they bullshit us all the time and treat us like we’re fucking children. That’s the meaning. And why he says it that way: YOU depend on OUR protection, yet you feed us lies from the tablecloth

[@jakeh2049]

Wow typing that out ^ also made me clue in that the next line lalala IS mocking, exactly like she says it sounds. Like a child imitating a teacher or a parent, he’s mockingly imitating these “authority” figures when they speak to us like: “lalalalalalalalala…ouuuu”

[@daevski]

Absolutely. Well noticed.

[@kennylaysh2776]

I honestly don't think we'll ever have another band like SOAD. They are still as fresh to me today, as the day this came out. They always give me chills.

[@SirQuack-mi9sz]

The greatest artists are like that They are their own entirely

[@zockertwins]

Check out Haken. Very similar sound and progressiveness, but less heavy and aggressive.

[@quintupleton]

I suggest dir en grey! Definitely they’re own band but there sounds and emotion reminds me of system a lot

[@kaygee2121]

Agreed. They have been one of my favorite bands for so long, but the only one I've never seen in concert. 🥺

[@thomasray6955]

Chills hell.... I'm here for the comic relif lol but I do support most of the message they deliver

[@SiQuemaCuhh]

SOAD isnt only good music, they were trying to tell the public of all the BS happening around us while we were being lied to about the world. Crazy how their music is still so relatable

[@friedpickles342]

Just remember. The most godless cult owns the music industry

[@SiQuemaCuhh]

@@friedpickles342 yup already know that.

[@satevo462]

@@friedpickles342 Found the Nazi.

[@martinpalmer6203]

Proxy war in Ukraine makes it relevant again too

[@SiQuemaCuhh]

@@martinpalmer6203 every war is a proxy war

[@sfr8382]

There is something very validating to hearing professionals gush about music that meant a lot to us that we were told growing up was just loud noise. It's a very therapeutic to hear others who are respected in their fields to feel the same feelings I do when I put on a System of a Down track. I've been listening to these same songs for like 20 years and it feels just as good as the first time I've heard them. They have aged incredibly well and still evoke emotion from me every time.

[@adamkrawczynski2570]

Feel the same brother

[@dsnow5562]

One thing to keep in mind while listening to B.Y.O.B is the context of when this song was released. This song came out at the beginning of the GWOT and American support for the war on terror and American patriotism was at an all time high, I remember the first time I heard this song and the amount of cognitive dissonance it garnered in me was crazy, from what we were being told about the war to what SOAD brought out with song, to someone who supported the war and after 9/11, it was crazy. And then when you factor in that most of the band had family killed during the Armenian Genocide and that’s where most of their anti war sentiment comes from, it’s just wild looking back on it from this far down the road.

[@rickwilliams967]

Dude, just spell the words out.

[@jaredjabouri7935]

I appreciate this comment.

[@ahall9839]

@@rickwilliams967 wym? ong fr fr

[@ewertoncao]

For us, from the global south (I’m brazilian), the lyrics always make sense… bands like soad and ratm talk to us

[@jacob6908]

I guess that’s strange because the Armenian Genocide was in the Ottoman Empire. It was the Muslims that did it and forced Islam on them.

[@Arthur-ek7nd]

I feel like Daron gets overlooked. He brings so much to the band, perfectly complimenting Serj's deep and warm tones with his own high tension voice. His screams in this and when he screams "FATHER!" in chop suey are great examples.

[@ireallyreallyhategoogle]

The guitar also.

[@lukewilliam3601]

Yeah. And apparently he writes a lot of the music, which is part of the reason they're no longer together. A lot of ego, mostly from Serg, from what I've read. I'm sure it's more complex than that.

[@ireallyreallyhategoogle]

@@lukewilliam3601 Serj

[@lukewilliam3601]

@@ireallyreallyhategoogle lol. yeah. typo. thanks.

[@lisarodgers8075]

Trust me, Daron stole the show last Saturday when they performed 31 songs at Sick New World. It was so euphoric. I was completely sober but felt extremely high at the same time being there and experiencing System live.

[@christopherrego8301]

System is one of those rare bands that you can listen to the whole discography without skipping a song.

[@Gizmo42Rodeo]

Maybe you can. I cant.

[@Cvillain626]

I do that on road trips :D great way to pass the time

[@evanhayes5891]

I can listen to yo momma without skipping a song, too!

[@jessicaparkinson82]

Yes! sometimes I think I might skip I can't help but remember there's gold in each single song!!!

[@korie4198]

As a veteran, this song hits different because you have your soldier persona and your normal persona. The amount of stress causes extremes between the two. So does the way the government uses you compared to what you wanted to serve for. It definitely isn't for everyone and a lot of people come out traumatized or have trouble transitioning to civil life because it's such a unique environment. I always felt this song captured that ambiguity perfectly.

[@Badmeets3VIL7]

As a long time System of A Down fan, a lot of the fans have failed to mention a hidden gem that was not a single and not well known, but is incredible in its own right. I highly suggest you listening to Radio/Video by system of a down. The harmonies in that song are unparalleled. Truly a shining moment between Serj and Daron. I promise 🙏🏾

[@kynzilla]

Oh my goddd, this song makes me LEAVE MY BODY, hahaha. It’s easily my favorite upbeat SoaD song ever, and it’s SO TRAGICALLY UNDERHYPED. D; Whyyy, I’ll never understand why so many people sleep on it! The fact that it’s so infectiously + theatrically quirky, punchy in all of the absolute best ways with the screams & overall, just a bizarrely delightful blend of 3 or more diverse genres makes it such a necessary listen! I can’t overstate how ridiculously excited I got when I read your comment, so I just had to jump in & second it! Thank you so much for suggesting it!

[@Badmeets3VIL7]

@@kynzilla Absolutely!!! When I say I've listened to everything SOAD has to offer, I'm so serious 😂 there isn't a song I don't know by them. Radio/Video is such an incredible song and I'm sure if they would've pushed it as a lead single like hypnotize it would've blown up in a huge way. It's ironic that it wasn't a single because of how much they mention "being on the radio" 😭 A hope this wonderful young lady sees my comment! Among other fans like you and me! IYKYK 🔥🔥🔥🔥 thank you so much for leaving a comment 💜

[@nicomakian1290]

YES!!!!!! Radio/Video is hands down the best representation of SOAD's vocal ability. And those harmonies blow me away!!!

[@bobsaget0429]

my ex girlfriend and I would go on roadtrips and belt this one out. great song.@@Badmeets3VIL7

[@jaredpickrell8310]

It would be a challenge to name a song by them I haven't heard, and I would LOVE if you could... Because we both win lol. Radio/Video is such an amazing song. System is one of those bands where their popular works are enjoyable and their not so well known songs are also incredible, often moreso.

[@klbearsfan1254]

I think that the gut-punch in this song comes from how blunt it is. There's no layered metiphores, no culturally specific references, and no poignant melody to soften things up. It grabs you by the head, gets right up in your face, and screams at you that there's a serious problem that you are enabling it by doing nothing to fix it.

[@Nalianna]

if it makes you think, then they're doing it right.

[@johnd1431]

exactly

[@Inferiis]

There are some metaphores, you need at least 2 brain cells to understand the meaning, but obviously not at Tool level. Like Moses's dry mouth or blowing up the sunshine, he doesn't literally say middle east, but it is obvious.

[@klbearsfan1254]

@@Inferiis I did notice that I misspoke on the internet, so thank you for one of the most polite online corrections ever. I do love the metaphors, but if listeners miss them they can't miss that ending.

[@cr-nd8qh]

Lies from the what?

[@GrunkleBearnison]

WHY. DO. THEY ALWAYS SEND THE POOR. This isn't a question y'all, I'm literally just quoting the lyrics of BYOB 🤦‍♀️

[@sandiegoe1]

Because they are willing and able. That's the common sense response. The political responses will be much different

[@leonidasneves7972]

WHY DO THEY ALWAYS CENSOR POOORNN

[@Skurian_krotesk]

​@@leonidasneves7972 BAHAHAHA 😂😂 Thats a good one !

[@Andrew-uk2no]

Because the presidents don't fight the war

[@baejus]

Kind of a WHYDEYALWAYSENNAPOOOOOUR

[@sirhodlholdington7550]

“Dancing in the desert blowing up the sunshine “. Everyone is having fun while the world is going to shit/ending. It has a pop sound to show the good time everyone is having while doom is impending. The song outside of the chorus is a call to wake up those unaware of this. Quite a smart way to market a message.

[@daevski]

Definitely correct. I also think that “going to the party, having a real good time,” is pointing at the patriotism, too. ‘Go into the war; we’ll all be there, winning… having a real good time.’ Trying to paint the ugly picture as pretty.

[@joephinnell3933]

I'm not sure why but everytime I hear this section I imagine it's burning man,blowing up the sunshine is when they set burning man on fire and the smoke is blocking out the sun

[@irieman442]

SOAD has an incredible drummer that makes their music possible. Without a solid drummer and Bass you can't pull off these crazy mode shifts. You can set your watch to the drums and Bass in SOAD songs.

[@nmF14T]

U mean John Dolmayan?

[@BofOnDope]

As a teenager I was always told the music I listened to was just noise. It is so nice seeing someone with musical knowledge analyse and explain why it is so good and why I have loved it for so many years. Thanks for all the great content

[@Axe_Slinger]

I told my Dad in the 80s that Metal had 2 main forms Neoclassical and Neoblues. He didn't understand it except with Yngwie J Malmsteen but not the rest....Until Trans-Siberian Orchestra and Symphonic Metal. After, at age 74, he went with the family to a Trans-Siberian Concert he started to see what I meant!

[@EdddSaid]

Ackshually all music is noise 🤓

[@stoneysdead689]

LOL- You have no idea- you should've grown up during the late 60s and 70s. We caught 10 x the hell you guys did for the music we listened to. They grew up listening to blue grass, country, and big band jazz and all the sudden all their kids were rockin' out to Hendrix, Zepplin, The Doors, etc. They grew up with WW2 and patriotic heroes- and their kids were protesting Vietnam and watching the illusion crumble when Kennedy was killed and Watergate broke. The world changed and parents were on one side while their kids were on the other. It literally broke families up, some of which never mended. And here's something odd to consider- the role technology played. Hear me out- back then to get what's called "distortion" or "overdrive" from an amp you had to turn it up until it started overdriving the tubes- and it was insanely loud. There literally was no way to play the music we listened to quietly- you had to turn the amps up until they were rattling everyone's teeth to get the tone that made rock and roll, rock and roll. This is why our parents called it noise and constantly complained about how loud it was. By the late 70s this issue had been resolved- you could get that same tone at bedroom levels if you wanted by using a pedal. I always wondered- if that technology had of been available back then- and the music didn't have to be so insanely loud- how different would it have been? Rock would've never been known for the loud, extreme music it is- think of what that could've changed.

[@Axe_Slinger]

@@stoneysdead689 Dude my Dad was born in 42 and he was a Greaser. Rock and Roll had JUST been born. The hell HE caught listening to Elvis, The Big Bopper, and Buddy Holly made your days look EASY. See there's always somebody who had it worse then you which is why you never compare hardships!

[@Axe_Slinger]

@@stoneysdead689 The first Guitar Pedals came out in 1946 - DeArmond Tremolo Control. The 2nd was in 1948 Trem Trol 800 Tremolo. In 1962 the first Fuzz Pedal came out - Gibson Maestro Fuzz Tone. In 1967 the first Wah Pedal was made by Vox. They also had 10 and 15 watt heads. You could get bedroom level sounds much earlier then the late 70s!

[@nicholsr1]

I think System Of A Down is one of the most lyrically, musically, and artistically profound rock bands ever, period. Even their songs that may appear relatively vapid at surface level (e.g. Vicinity of Obscenity or Radio/Video) are aurally gripping rhythmically and harmonically. Serj and Daron's vocal timbres mesh perfectly and damn, you can't help but nod your head to the grooves this band creates. SOAD is artistry in its truest form.

[@chrismathieu5032]

So true mate !

[@JayR607]

It’s really a cut above the rest. Amirite?! 🤣

[@dustinmyeye8752]

Really? With the library of insane rock bands?

[@Padastic]

I agree but aren't they more of a metal band?

[@3tonmonkey33]

Well Said

[@bryanmcneil9872]

This woman is smart. The way she understands the themes so quickly all the while analyzing the actual production and vocals

[@uitham]

Damn this comment seems kind of patronizing doesnt it?

[@connorvoelz7144]

@@ajewishchristianmuslimhonestly this analogy seems more patronizing to me. What’s wrong with complimenting someone and being genuinely impressed for doing good work? It’s not like they said they were surprised or anything. You’re making it seem like what she does is easy as writing on a chalk board.

[@JayJay-fl1gk]

I always took the screaming section at 20:55 to wake you up from the brainwashing. Its so instant and unexpected, like someone waking you up from a sleep. But if your woken up while something bad is happening then its going to be even more intense and scary. I take the chorus as the govt trying to lull you to sleep and SOADs screaming as them trying to wake you up

[@-8l-924]

I think you’re totally right. I read your first sentence and had a realization that there are competing narratives in the song that alternate, and I had the same conclusion you have. wow what a cool song, and you put it really well.

[@JohnJan721]

This is good theory, I approve.

[@Exhumed.Consumed]

Yes, the smooth chorus is the official sales pitch, the screaming is the resistance

[@devinosland359]

Yeah, even more so with the "going to the party in the desert" that's how the US marketed it. "We're just going on a little excursion to the desert, you'll have a great time and you get to play hero with all your friends and guns"

[@andrewjuby6339]

Absolutely! Both sonically and, in the video, visually they keep hitting this feeling of the metal parts "breaking through" the pop parts.

[@StoneyWoney]

While BYOB feels like a straight in your face song, I always thought it is also one of the most intricately composed SOAD songs out there. The play with contrast, meaning, expectations, and all those switch ups while still keeping that adrenaline up. This song carries the perfected form of "organized chaos" that I love from this band.

[@abstractlij]

Definitely agree

[@abstractlij]

Also is that the pin from Watchmen? Great movie lmao

[@TheAlibabatree]

Check out The Mars Volta.

[@SilverAlex92]

Oh yeah, I been listening to SOAD for like nearly twenty years, and I just realized that "Dancin' in the desert Blowin' up the sunshine" could be a reference to the Afghanistan and Iraq wars and the bombings that happened there. You can always find something new on songs you thought you understood for years.

[@chriswhetsell7510]

When their song "Sugar" hit the radio back in '99 or so, it literally changed my taste in music. That's how distinctive SOAD's sound is. There was nothing like it at the time.

[@gtyrone83]

And nothing like it since

[@rokuthy]

That song really changed my perspective on music

[@ricardo_vds]

Distinctive but also musically schooled and creative, true artists compared to formula following bands like Linkin Park.

[@heisen1815]

@@ricardo_vds compliment a great band without saying some unhinged baseless shit about another great band challenge (literally impossible)

[@prodbysteexy]

still is nothing

[@WilliamCooelho]

I like how they incorporate their Armena roots into the melodies, being in the instrumental part and in the intonation, especially the Lalalalala lalalala part...

[@BL00DYME55]

lol I don't think that Lalalalala part has anything to do with their armenian roots. Literally the entire world knows what "lalalala" is, it's in no way special to Armenia. And if I'm not mistaken, that specific part was them making fun of some other song or singer, but I'm a bit hazy on the details.

[@Kjeleman]

This song still gives me tears 20 years after.

[@mattstyles]

I’ve been listening to these guys since I was 12. I’m 33 now and I’ve been saying for the last 10 years that they were light years ahead of their time. My favorite band to this day.

[@just_gut]

They were the next evolution of a very culturally conscious musicianship that goes back over a century. Very specifically they remind me of that next step on the path of earlier bands like RATM and KMFDM in their near past, and a lot of punk from before that like Blag Flag, the Clash, Dead Kennedys and more. They just took all of these great elements and took it to a whole new level.

[@kingdavey90]

Right there with ya, I'll be 33 in October.

[@thefirehawk1495]

Most of their meaningful songs are basically early 2000s occupy wall street anti war sentiment that got the democrats a win for Obama as a backlash for Bush era politics. Alas here we are in 2023, Democrats are strongly pro war, pro big pharma, pro government and many of the people voting on them have an inconsistent world view due to brainwashing. The video was as accurate then as it is now.

[@Steeny8096]

Same here, they'll always be my favorite! Grew up with them and I'm 34 now and they'll never die

[@Smokey1419]

They were always too goofy for me, but much respect for always sounding fresh, complex, and thoughtful. True legends

[@landonw7099]

“I-E-A-I-A-I-O” by System of a Down has awesome vocals 💯

[@Oxtorayk]

I think the "Nail on chalkboard" analogy is perfect. Something i really love about system of a down is how they sound so in the pocket, air-tight coupled with each other with those little amusing and interesting discrepancies jumping at you here and there at the same time.

[@harmless3449]

9:15 this is by far the most perceptive and insightful commentary I've heard someone provide about this song during their first listen. I listened to this at a much younger age and got lost in the energy of this track. While I fully understood the meaning and messaging of the song, I didn't start to understand how many subtle elements in the composition and performance corroborate that message until very recently. I was listening to this track a few months ago and during the "Everybody's going to the party" bridge I thought to myself: Oh my god, the vocals almost remind me of someone mocking something in a singsong voice. They sound so jaded. The lackadaisical delivery is so easy to miss and I think you're the first other person I've seen point it out. It contrasts so starkly with the second verse towards the end of the track when Darron's harmonies come in, where it's delivered so passionately and almost reminds me of desperate pleading. Like you said, it's almost sickening. It's so good. It's like the first verse is you being invited to the "party" by the people who secretly know what you're in for while trying half heartedly to make it seem like a good time, and the latter half of the second verse is you REALIZING how awful it actually is once you're there. And then you get angry and can't help but wonder "where the fuck are you?" When you think of the people who got everyone into this mess.

[@mastersquinch]

"where the fuck are you" the first time reads like the extremely aggressive reaction towards people who didn't support the war ("We don't live in a fascist nation! Blast off, it's party time, and where the FUCK are YOU?")- which also tracks with the snootiness and irony in serj's delivery of the verse. It's all chill and everything's going according to plan, so long as you comply (Note the emphasis on "YOU depend on OUR protection!" It almost sounds like a threat). The second time reads like anger towards the warmongers.

[@harmless3449]

@@mastersquinchAgreed, and on the surface "YOU depend on OUR protection, yet you feed us lies from the tablecloth" could be read as actual soldiers on the ground taking jabs at the government administrations that are depending on them to protect democracy and the government, yet that same government withholds information and manipulates them through the chain of command with little regard for their well-being. It could also be read as the general public and their distaste and anger over the suppression of what was really going on in iraq and our real reason for being over there. You can interpret this song from the perspective of someone actually fighting in the war, with "where the fuck are you" being pointed at the the president/government, sitting back while they send young men to die. You could also interpret this from the perspective of a civilian not already involved with the war being ruthlessly pressured by the same president/ government to throw their lives away to accomplish their goals. People in both perspectives might almost certainly wonder "why don't presidents fight the war?"

[@GNelson1989]

This song was written in contrast to us invading the middle east it also spent forever at the top of the worldwide charts, I remember the first time I heard SOAD I was 11 and the college kids next door rolled up playing their music, I was instantly inthralled, they recorded a tape for me and I listened to Toxcicty over and over and have listened to them since.

[@travisprugh6347]

tapes were non existent when toxicity came out. you sure it wasnt on cdr? i worked in a music store during this time.

[@MacPNW]

This was one of my favorite albums to repeat endlessly during my three trips to iraq.

[@clintcgalliano]

This was similar to my interpretation. Local militias are encouraged to fight battles that support specific agendas without the architects of those agendas having to put as many boots on the ground (at all or at least as soon), hence BYOB, Bring Your Own Bomb.

[@rollingfury]

@@travisprugh6347 I'm sure it was some old tape they had laying around.

[@computerpunk41]

Recorded a tape for him... You know I can plug the album into a cd/cassette combo boom box and record songs from the CD to a tape.

[@LGreymark]

B.Y.O.B is the most like a Sledgehammer of any song I've ever listened to. It mashes you up with rapid tempo switches, screeching vocals and a brutal message.

[@supsoul7235]

Matches my 2 emotions

[@polpeeniz4397]

That's not what sledgehammers do

[@dmitryowens]

It's annoying to me.

[@charles_cody]

the fact she is blown away by this song roughly 2 decades after it's release is so impressive for SoAD

[@WolfFireheart]

Pfffffft!! Good music is good music no mater how much time passes. Beathoven, Mozart, Bach, their music still slaps. What worries me, is that the topics of this song is just as relevant, 2 decades later.

[@charles_cody]

@@WolfFireheart War has always been fought by the poor. Always since before the modern state.

[@WolfFireheart]

@@charles_cody The, other topics... Brainwashing, manipulation and all that...

[@Knives47]

Hope she does Lost in Hollywood next! It's an absolute masterpiece. The vocals and melodies will give anyone goosebumps.

[@atvena]

Not to mention what the song is about

[@Cadinho93]

My interpretation is that this song was written about the 2003 US invasion of Iraq, the way the media and politicians were hyping up the public to support the invasion. Then once the war began it was covered in the news as if it was some kind of video game, a spectacle of technology and explosions that was disconnected from any real world harm or consequences. Also, dancing in the desert blowing up sunshine. BYOB = BRING YOUR OWN BOMB!

[@1TemplarKnight]

I agree it was exposing the chaotic and terrifying reality of a warzone vs the hyped up encouragement to join the army and be part of this party in the desert.

[@electronblue8334]

That's exactly it. The operation was called Desert Storm and that's what SOAD is referring to. The government was selling a war effort as one big party where you go in crying "Freedom!" and then walk out again. Easy peasy. Except the reality was a bit different....

[@ttrmotocross]

Being 10 when 9/11 happened, seeing the propaganda machine turning full force, and growing up with a whole generation of people my age that slowly started to find out how awful the GWOT really was has been an insane ride.

[@Bossfightmedia]

@@ttrmotocross You must be really lucky that you seen the Propaganda machine from behind to begin with. Most people still believe that the Prop machine itself is a conspiracy theory and you only want to shake their trust in their Goverment. At which point you should really consider if you are able to even think foryourself anymore I guess.

[@benmackie6322]

That's not an interpretation, that is what it is about lol.

[@rossjohnmclean]

18 years old but as relevant as ever, this track is still stunning after hundreds of listens - one of SOAD's best, in my opinion. The message is unequivocal, the juxtapositions in lyrics and music show-stopping, the imagery conveyed by the lyrics and reinforced in the video simply jaw-dropping. A completely fearless band, always a welcome tonic from the anodyne popular music scene of today. I love that Serj falls to his knees before he utters a single sound, as if to pray - then spits out "Barbarisms by Barbaras"… surely a reference to Saint Barbara, the patron saint of artillerymen and military engineers. Brilliant, calculated and unhinged in equal measure. Take note kids, THIS is how to make music with a message. I'm glad to see this had the intended effect on you Elizabeth :)

[@iamcraig85]

18 years old....fuk. Well that just ruined my day

[@bailey3209]

​@@iamcraig85 same here, jeebus

[@larrychang14]

That's a really interesting take on that first line of the song. I had never heard of Saint Barbara, so never made the connection. Do you have any insight as to who "Victorious Victorias" is referring to in the next line?

[@electronblue8334]

Not sure about saint Barbara. George H. W. Bush's wife was called Barbara, she was First Lady during the first Gulf War 1990/91 and mother of George W. Bush who declared war on Iraq in 2003.

[@rossjohnmclean]

@@larrychang14 I’m guessing it’s playing with alliteration to mirror the first line? I’m definitely sticking with the Saint Barbara theory, since she’s also the patron saint of those who work with explosives - which fits with “Bring Your Own Bomb”, also patron saint of armourers, which might be the inspiration behind the “pointed heels” reference (as in a knight’s pointed sabatons). Anyone else got ideas on Victorious Victorias? Regardless, the venom with which Serj and Daron deliver these lines is one of SOAD’s crowning glories, such an outstanding performance, even by their impossibly high standards.

[@bogdana7304]

i really wish someone has the power and connections to show this to Serj or Daron .. this lady is out of this world ❤

[@brookenebergall4171]

As a soldier during 9/11 this song has a lot of meaning to me. All the soldiers going to the desert and where was everyone else?

[@tayzk5929]

Serving the evil system in their own way, similar to the soldiers

[@devinosland359]

The "where the fuck are you" is pointed towards the leaders. They send people (often poor and desperate people) off to fight in wars while they sit comfy at home

[@pretzelthedude]

I really wish Serj and co could see this video to see that someone actually GOT it. I remember an interview with Serj years ago where he felt so much disappointment that people heard this song and were dancing/thrashing to it, but nobody gave a damn about the whole point of the lyrics (much like most of their songs sadly). Band with so much "WAKE UP HUMANITY" in their lyrics, but nobody wanted to hear the pain and face it, they just wanted to party... EDIT: if you haven't yet, I swear to you, you NEED to watch the video to Serj's "Empty Walls". It brought me to tears.

[@josephbrambil2868]

have you seen knox hill's reaction to this song? If you don't know him he does similar videos as the charismatic voice, but more of a rap/ hip hop focus. However, he has a few metal break downs, and he does a great job of breaking BYOB down and putting the pieces together in real time. I recommend it.

[@danielknecht5531]

It is a very similar reaction to Hey Ya! by Outkast

[@gantybop]

Propagandhi's Chris Hannah (my favourite lyricist of all time) wrote in the first line of their 1st song on their 1st album "Dance and laugh and play, ignore the message we convey; it seems we're only here to entertain" An outstanding band with lyrical content similar to SOAD, but more in the punk/hardcore/progressive thrash genre. For those interested I'd recommend the songs "Iteration" (Strong anti-war message), "Purina Hall of Fame" (strong animal advocacy) "Without Love" (best love song ever written about a cat)

[@ViridianFlow]

The lyrics are pretty obvious if you just actually listen to them, but people just gloss over the words as if they're only there to add another instrument. The people screaming "Why do they always send the poor" into the government saying "You depend on our protection" in an imperious tone. Everybody going to a party in the desert, blowing up the sunshine (literally covering the sky with the dust and smoke from their bombs) and taking the oil while they scream that they're just here to bring them "freedom". It's hard not to get the lyrics.

[@luckyfk3452]

Because this song is hollow. Rich 1% rebelling against the "systems" his on top of. Fucking millionaire teaching the unwashed masses about how consumer culture is the evil while playing instruments worth 10's of thousands of dollars. Also he's advocating for "systems" in which his little bad just couldn't exist at all. It's garbage hypocrisy, fake activism to get some pats on the back from fellow 1% liberal elitist clique.

[@aqsw57]

This is the first soad song I heard. It was the 2005, I was 15 and my mind was blown. A friend of mine gave me mezmerize which was freshely released and I started listening to it everyday. Byob, radio video, questions, violent pornography and sad statue were my favourite. Then only 6 month later that same friend came to me with hypnotize and said "hey, they just released a new album!". Best feeling ever

[@os_cube]

For me it's similar. First song i heard in 2009, similar age 14 at the time. Best friend introduced me to them and back then i delivered the newspaper as a side job after the school once a week. Listened to mezmerize and hypnotize on repeat during my shifts, ahh simpler times xD.

[@solidkink]

Somehow, first song for me as well and now I’m like 10 years deep in SOAD music universe

[@xsystem1]

I know that feeling bro 😊

[@honigdachs.]

"Where the fuck are you? Why don't presidents fight the war? Why do they always send the poor?" That's so to the point. The way the music explodes in this section and both voices express the anger in those lyrics is grandiose. Love it.

[@charleyfromage4424]

You have got to check out "Dreaming" from them. Daron's voice at the end is just literal chills

[@onethousandlostsouls]

Indeed . Possibly one of their best songs , imo .

[@sionat29]

Your ability to interpret and describe the emotional levels of the music you listen to and how the band is trying to portray the meaning to the song through the sound of their instruments, voices, cadence, as well as with the lyrics, is the absolute best.

[@BobbyGeneric145]

Id love for her to sit down with Serge.

[@guen4413]

@@BobbyGeneric145 That would be absolutely amazing. And considering Serj's love of classical music, they would have a lot in common to talk about.

[@arkofwill156]

​@@guen4413 q😅

[@ColinDelia68]

I've never seen someone feel the beauty, passion, anger and fury of music so intensely as you. Music lovers will know exactly what I mean. Watched nearly all your reactions. Thank you!

[@kingchuckfinley]

It’s honestly amazing. I almost thought it was too much, but the more I’ve watched her the more I understand that she genuinely feels SO much. It’s beautiful.

[@ChantalMonette]

I think it's so poignant the way your reactions changed when your brain connected to the meaning of the song. The gutpunch feeling is real, and it's like... such a good song, such a powerful song, and SOAD has always been a true champion for using their platform to make their voices heard on these issues.

[@bellablue5285]

I was in college when this came out, in a *heavily* military populated area. What was great about it was that it was (and still is) so catchy that it was almost insidious, the lyrics come in with a one-two punch. Definitely had to be careful where I turned the radio up when it came on. I started with Toxicity in the 90s (got the cd at Kmart of all places), and honestly, this one wasn't surprising given their earlier stuff, but whoa boy did it feel very brazen when it came out given all the post 9/11 stuff (not to mention I've no doubt that for a lot of us who were teenagers at the time, that day was our first big exposure to real world existential dread...)

[@demondaddy328]

I remember the first time I heard this song. I think I was 13. At that age, it was just a really cool song that I loved head banging to. As I’ve grown and experienced SOAD’s music (and specifically their lyrics) I always come back to this song and it makes me so emotional. So glad to watch you react to this one.

[@zepo82]

same, I might have been a little older and in a bar...but It's good to come back to the lyrics

[@mitchelllion6052]

It is very awesome to see someone that appreciates their music and listen to this song for the first time lol It reminded me of my first time hearing this song too

[@kkkkgt4121]

me too i have vivid memories of dad playing rock/metal on the way to school. i blame him for turning me into a metal head lol

[@hdemi1590]

Me too, about 14 !

[@ZombieJesus1987]

I was 13 when I first heard the singles from their first album, but pretty much the same feeling here.

[@toddpaluzzi]

First off... Props for the unedited version. Was pleasantly surprised to hear the message as it should be. Second, I highly recommend seeing them live if you get the chance before they go on hiatus again

[@joshuaguerra2651]

Gonna see them at sick new world in a few weeks!!🤘

[@toddpaluzzi]

@@joshuaguerra2651 amazing lineup

[@conradkostelecky7935]

Well to each his own I guess. From this one example I wouldn't go see them for free if they were in my backyard. But enjoy and carry on. I guess it goes to show music takes all kinds of sounds to please folks. This is not my vibe.

[@joewalsh4713]

​@Conrad Kostelecky you... must be new here. System of a Down is not everyone's cup of tea, as with all music. I heartily recommend you check out some of their other Obviously Politically Themed Songs such as Prison Song, Cigaro, Mr. Jack, Hypnotize, or Deer Dance? Though Aerials may be more your style if this was just too HEAVY in its musical and lyrical styling or too obviously anti-war and anti-fascist in its messaging.

[@michaelbrooks742]

Say what? My God I really have been out of touch lately, did you just say they're touring again, as in the original line up and all?

[@nOT_sURE08]

Such a challenging song to learn on guitar, too. It's not technical in terms of key and scales. It's actually really simple in that regard. But it is definitely a lesson in technique, speed and precision.

[@SgtKaneGunlock]

Im always impressed by Serj's vocal range

[@fish_bacon]

The constant tempo changes is what makes me love them so much. Every SOAD song feels like you've listened to five songs in one.

[@scionofdorn9101]

And every song is a discrete, unique creation that takes you on a different journey than the others.

[@davidkru5062]

Like five songs in one... That's why they only put out 5 albums. Not 25. ;-) Daron and Serj should get their shit together and make a new album. No front, but as far as their creative differences go, they're bloody divas... Musical geniuses...

[@-8l-924]

same, that’s a key element for why I like them. I’m not a musician but to me that’s so creative to come up with it and takes a lot of talent to pull it off really well.

[@kraigsmyth]

As a teen I heard this while becoming aware of class struggle and the military industrial complex. We were poor and my brothers shipped out to support the family. I nearly followed, but got a good scholarship. My brothers made it but got messed up, one pretty bad (at least he got 100% VA disability support). This song hit hard.

[@deptusmechanikus7362]

"why do they always send the poor" guess we know now why US is never getting public healthcare, higher education and affordable housing despite being able to afford it ten times over.

[@MrMacgamut]

The passion in your voice as you talk about this song brought tears to my eyes. I am officially subbed.

[@JoshieMadhatt]

Serj is one of the most versatile, unique and amazing vocalist. Idk if you have ever listened to their self titled album but I would highly recommend Sugar, Spiders, War, Suite Pee, and Soil. Those showcase the most out of Serj's amazing range of different styles and everything EDIT: I see you did Spiders but I really would love to see you do Sugar and Soil particularly. But seriously even if you don't do any reactions from it that first SOAD album ( self titled) is absolutely amazing and I love it even more than Toxicity

[@Jimmy1982Playlists]

Sweet! I come to this channel _in particular_ for your SOAD breakdowns 🥰 Makes me listen to one of my top 5 all-time bands in a whole new way and I fall in love with them all over again! Edit/Post-Script: This was the lead single off System's first new album since the start of the Bush/Cheney Iraq War... Daron had family in Iraq, had spent time there as a teen, and his family was dealing personally with the fall-out of the war at the time. Also, the chorus always made me think of the fact that Lebanese youth would go to dance clubs at night during the Lebanese Civil War in the '80s, almost in defiance of the war around them, often pausing to take shelter for air raids... my family is from Beirut, Lebanon and Serj & John were born there. BTW - I recommend you watch the 2002 Big Day Out live performance of "Psycho"... the solo/freakout that Daron does at the end is, just - 😍😲🤯🤯🤯 _AMAZING!_ A must-see.

[@gegart01]

Me tooo

[@Syphered08]

same

[@goassnmane]

What are the other bands in your top 5?

[@Skurian_krotesk]

Yeah you get it Elizabeth. The first reaction in a long time that really made me connect to the meaning of this song like when i heared it the first time. That made me cry. It's a real gut puncher. The party part is such a ridiculous irony. They really play this at parties with thousands of drunk people singing along but every other word is wrong because they have no idea whats going on in the lyrics and they have no idea that just around the globe there are people being slaughtered while they are having fun dancing. I think thats the essence of this song. Its a wakeup call to pay attention.

[@tmsather]

Bingo. Couldn't have said this better myself.

[@FrazerJones71]

The party part of the song is how the government sell war as some sort of event you should be a part of and wars like the one in Iraq are portrayed in the media as a spectacle, who remembers the bombing of Iraq being shown around the world like it was some sort of super intense firework display

[@donosborne9086]

It was like when I realized what the lyrics to "99 red balloons" by Nina )and covered by Goldfinger) was about. Listen to it if you haven't. It's all upbeat but the song is really a gutpunch

[@missdee9404]

I love listening to your interpretations on songs I've known and loved for a long time. I love re-experiencing it for the first time through your eyes (and ears!) and hear your awe and delight. Bonus, you're much more technical and experienced than I am in musical and voice analysis, so I'm always learning cool new things!!

[@RicoHerwig]

I really love how you can appreciate all kinds of music for what they are! A true example for what musicianship is, in my opinion! Thank you very much for sharing that!

[@j.n.54]

BYOB was written in direct protest of the Iraq war. All of the band have family in the region who were directly affected by the war. The chorus is about people signing up for the service to go fight in the war hence Bring Your Own Bomb. Great song, great band and a great vocal analysis.

[@BananaDave89]

I love how Elizabeth is now 4 maybe 5 song into SOAD and they're still making her brain fall out of her ear like a moist cake! SOAD never fail to impress and I love watching these reactions and deep dives into them. I'd love to see a reaction to Sugar or Prison song. (Edited especially for @scoot3200 for his belittlement of my little mistake of misspelling Elizabeth's name without an "A" and the fact that Elizabeth has done 7 videos of SOAD and not what I put of "4 maybe 5". In his own words "Not very hard to verify". Thank you.)

[@wiltchamberlain9920]

I was constantly giggling watching her reactions as the song kept twisting and turning and she was having a real bear of a time trying to keep up. It was amazing. This whole song is about trying to keep you off-balance and watching her react to it has been great.

[@anaisr-p2.085]

Sugar❤

[@MatthewXLY]

If I was her, after hearing aerials (the first one she listened to) I'd have poured myself a glass of wine and listened to everything they'd ever done. Her restraint is phenomenal.

[@BananaDave89]

@@MatthewXLY I couldn't agree with you more! I'm amazed at the restraint 😂

[@IconicDumpsterFire]

Definitely sugar! That's one of my favourites by them right now.

[@JWildberry]

This was the first song I heard from them, and I immediately went out and bought the CD. It's so powerful.

[@vitoriamagalhaes5777]

Watching her reactions always makes me feel like I'm listening to these songs for the first time again. Awesome!

[@briarhaven01]

This band is legendary for a reason. Not only are they top tier musicians and song writers, but their insight and perception into the human condition and politics unparalleled by almost any other band I've seen.

[@yourbrainonheroin]

I love hearing your analysis of a song like 'BYOB'. 'Deer Dance' & 'Prison Song' are my SOAD faves and this has always felt like their spiritual successor to me. There is so much going on here and it's fascinating to see it articulated and appreciated by someone who's so well-versed! ❤️

[@beverchakus4441]

I love these videos! I just recently found out how amazing SOAD is, i can't stop listening. But hearing you talk about and break it all down is amazing. I hear it all, but i can't put words to it like you can. Thank you. So awesome!

[@tbo72787]

I usually watch these videos for the vocal analysis, but it is so nice to see someone actually get the point of this song, instead of just being amazed by the tempo shifts. Awesome video.

[@Driver8takeabreak]

I cannot understand that someone would listen to this song and not instantly recognize it as a war protest song. It blatantly hits you over the head (but also has a lot of other subtle themes).

[@tbo72787]

@Dave Messenheimer I was referring more to the juxtaposition of the mindset at home and the actual reality of war. You're right that most people get the basic premise.

[@therealkakitron]

I was the bass player for TOXICITY, a SOAD tribute in the Los Angeles area for a while until I moved to TX, so I'm a bit biased for anything SOAD, but this lady has made me appreciate their music and their message even more, which I thought was not posible. What a beautiful and insightful way to analyze this song. She's definitely earned my admiration ❤️

[@martchristy9981]

Hey! You want to hear her singing!

[@JenniferOrtegaDWG13]

I make this comment in regards to your SOAD playlist since I just went through it. I have LOVED the band for quite some time. I still can't help but sing and drum along to it with my whole being (my fitbit even showed spikes in energy that I haven't had in a while)! Hearing your reactions and your analysis was extremely refreshing and fun after a slight hiatus from rock and metal. And I greatly appreciated the effort you put to understand the meaning, feel, and lyrics of the song. I myself did minimal research and had only drawn my understandings from wayward context and history that I find about SOAD. But this? This was a great journey that goes further than what I would have done on my own. It's made me fall in love with the music even further. Can't wait to see more content (especially with that one sleep token video I spotted earlier). Hope to see you do more SOAD songs!

[@Hmmhattricker]

I love this, how the true meaning of the song slowly unravels in your mind. I was sitting here, just nodding more and more as you discovered the layers of meaning. And I am a singer, so I am amazed by your knowledge in that department. Thank you for giving us such great videos :)

[@shell8481]

Btw, seeing these guys live, in their prime in a big stadium was something else and burned into my brain forever, fantastic experience

[@McrLoVrfanAlt]

Omg, I wish I would have lived this 🥲

[@phoenkix]

I saw them right when Mesmerize came out and they opened with BYOB. Incredible show.

[@rh3toricalanswer]

When I first discovered your videos, I couldn't explain why but I felt unsettled and uncomfortable, because my brain kept telling me "she is playing up for the camera, there's no way she's that engrossed in the music" but the more I watched your videos the more it became clear that you have a gift; your mannerisms are sincere and it's evident that you not only hear the music, but you can feel it and see it, as if the notes are exploding in front of you, like at a fireworks show where you can both see, hear, and feel their impact.

[@joshshultz1250]

Do you not feel music?

[@DerEchteBold]

@@joshshultz1250 Very strange objection ...can't you see that she might come across as a bit too affected or contrived? I'm sure lots of people would think that feeling the music is exactly what she's not and that she's only acting. I don't think that at all myself but I can absolutely see how it could seem that way.

[@kevinmack8411]

We'd all love it if you stopped blinking like Hillary during a seizure ...and let the damned song play without stopping it 8 times at the same spot. Affectatious and over analyzed

[@theTwilightSystem]

Her pure passion and enthusiasm for music is always nice to watch. I thought she was faking it or playing it up too when I first found the channel but now it’s my favorite aspect of the videos.

[@rolandkarlsson7072]

@@theTwilightSystem - now, this is a reaction channel. All reactors are setting themselves in a reaction mode when filming their reactions. They do not listen in this way in normal life. They do not make all those gestures and look that perplex when listening to the radio. It would be a very weird person that did this. I would say even sick. So - you need to have control over your reactions so you know when it is appropriate to burst out during listening to a song. So sure, she is exaggerating. Like all reactors are exaggerating, more or less. What, for me, makes a good reactor. A reactor I want to listen to is * The reactor is not lying. If they say that they have not seen it, that shall be true. * The reaction is true. It is not faked. The reactor really means what (s)he say. * The exaggerated reaction is reasonable, fun or at least not annoying. * (S)he is not shouting or making loud noises or silly sounds. I hate it when in the middle of the song, there is a shout that is 10 times louder. * There is information in the reaction. * The reactor has a nice persona. * If it is the first time the reactor has heard this band.

[@bazparkes6516]

Glad you enjoyed SOAD, a band myself and many others(turning 40 soon) grew up with. As an aside, my mother is 75 and has ben to see them live a number of times. Massive fan.

[@rocketscientist14]

You are honestly super cool & I love how you don’t judge ANY genre or artist.. you have a completely open mind & when you had Will Ramos on that just reinforced it for me x1000. You are a great soul & are helping further the world of music, whether you believe it or not!

[@tyo9409XX]

I was really worried with how much of their content you have reviewed that you would have skipped this song. To me, this song is their true masterpiece. Vocally, it has everything that makes SOAD who they are. Musically, the duality between the pure panic of the versus and the relaxed tempo of the chorus. I was college student when this song came out and the effect hearing "WHY DO THEY ALWAYS SEND THE POOR" has resonated with me for the rest of my life.

[@shaunketterman2985]

These guys were on top of the world back then, man I wish they kept going. This channel is amazing. Vocal analysis on a musical and interpretation level = YES.

[@Pope_Rat]

I’ve never seen anyone else get so deep into a song and break it down than you, it’s so cool and crazy

[@kimberlyjones3234]

I just found your analysis of System of a Down and I loved it. I've been a fan of theirs for over 23 yrs so I absolutely loved this. I'll definitely be watching more of your videos.

[@jjshred]

First saw SOAD in 1998 with Slayer.. Just remember thinking “Weird, but kind of awesome.” Sugar was the song that stuck with me, and loved ‘em ever since. Really powerful messages in their music, and then they hit you with hilarious nonsense. Great insights, love seeing someone from another spectrum of music appreciate the music I’ve loved for decades.

[@vdi419]

damn, respect for listening to soad for 25 years

[@ryanlasenbby3974]

Epic song too

[@petercolson2990]

I really, REALLY want her take on Sugar. It was the first big hit, their introduction to the world, and told you IMMEDIATELY who they were

[@TheWonderfulBlake]

Love the reaction to the start, cause even though I was literally 8 years old, it’s almost exactly like mine. My older bro put the CD on in the car; after the intro song, the guitar is jarring and then when Daron goes “you” I turned my head, like “oh this sounds interesting,” and then when he shouts “WHY DO THEY ALWAYS SEND THE POOR?!?” And Serj comes in with his deep, almost operatic vocals, my jaw was dropped certainly for the rest of the verse, but quite possibly the whole song. I was utterly amazed and simultaneously baffled something like this even existed. Had no idea what the hell it was just knew I needed way more.

[@TillsRojas7]

My older brother and I discovered Chop Suey at 8 & 9 years old thanks to an older neighbor who played it for his little brother and us. Me and my brother went home, listened to it again, and began listening to more of their songs because we couldn’t believe music like this existed and it was breathtaking.

[@andrewcatania7425]

Thank you Charismatic Voice! I loved all of the System/Serj videos!

[@KaJaKTrial]

I really love when with You I can listen to a song I know really well, to listen to it in a brand new way. And to be able to name some of the feelings, I had while listening to this song but didn't know what they were. Great analysis!

[@matt-hu7gc]

This is why I love your channel. Not only do we get expert vocal analysis and musical breakdown, we get your interpretations in the artist’s intentions with the sounds and styles that they choose in their work, and the meanings they present. Most of this song is far from “beautiful” sounding in its literal sense but its aggression, tempo and craze creates - in my opinion - one of their greatest works of art and expression

[@Marlieseee]

I know you've already done a lot of System of a Down songs, however, 'Lost in Hollywood' is one of the most beautiful harmonies, and Daron is taking on the main vocals. It absolutely gorgeous ❤

[@danielgantner7468]

that middle section gives me chills every single time

[@F3Ibane]

Lost In Hollywood is an absolute gem. The harmony between Serj and Daron is transcendent.

[@marijazafirovska4795]

Yesss! Their voices melt beautifully together.

[@StephxInfectionlol]

My favorite by them

[@benthicblues]

MY FAVE SOAD SONG BY FAR!!!!!

[@_lin_al3177]

its a delight to see someone listen ACTUALLY listen to their music ,understand the meanings and ideas the present. they have so many songs with brave i could say commentary and inner monologue its amazing

[@nicholassydor6398]

I really liked all the themes she highlighted in this video it led me to a deeper understanding of a song I really like from my favourite band. Great video!

[@Crcmvnt]

Never comment but subbed for quite some time. It’s incredible the growth into heavy music you’ve amassed. Your ability to not only interpret, analyze and understand it is incredible. Thanks for all you do, great content.

[@cdpgeorge]

Not all people who listen to metal/rock are brain dead idiots. And if you have the audacity to look into it, the music itself is sometimes inspirational, inquisitive, and informative. Some are misfits looking for a place, some prefer not to hear the typical generic sex, drugs, gangster, etc..., and some enjoy the music, the lyrics, the message, the vocals or all of the above. I guess my hope is the rock/metal that I listen to isn't a corporate sheep, but expressive individual.

[@tehs3raph1m]

I'm not normally this excited for a future event, not even Christmas... But I'm glad you're doing it and that you get the message in the duality of the song.

[@AddedColor]

Awesome video. “Layers to the expression”. So true! They say so much with their vocals

[@jlrthebassplayer]

I want to thank you for this analysis. You always manage to see or point out aspects of music art that my ear goes too. This band is both immensely strong musicianship and messages. I love a number of different styles and I would love to get your feedback on Barenaked Ladies they have these things with 5 part vocal harmony or interplay. There songwriting tends to the fun and silly so maybe start with "One Week".

[@lordofentropy]

The thing I've always loved about this song and still do after I guess almost 20 years of listening to it: SOAD managed to make one of the most dance-y/head-bop riff and rhythm sections ever in the, "Everybody's going to the party..." chorus. The contrast of the heavy aggressive section with a pop-like dance groove reflects the situation of SOAD being anti-consumerist and progressive while simultaneously being a chart-topping multi-million album selling popular band.

[@joshshultz1250]

It's not just that the chorus is head boppy... it's that it really shouldn't be when reflecting on the lyrics. She had it right when she said it made her feel sick.

[@apocalypticg4119]

Always love the SOAD reactions. One song you could look at is “Streamline” it has some of his best vocal moments IMO

[@JP-eq7eh]

I second this! Also Streamline is from an album that you haven't covered in any of your other videos yet. Going from the pure chaos energy of BYOB to arguably one of Serj's best vocal performances in Streamline would be a really cool contrast.

[@stevendeakin]

Even though I watched this the first time round... I find myself drawn to watching it time and time again! Could be my favourite video by you!!

[@penzlic]

How their voices overlap in "where tf are you" at 14:36 give me goosebumps every single time. Daron screaming and Serjs calmness. Absolutely fantastic

[@owenjones3197]

This song feels more important in today's world that it did in 2005! Still such a powerful song!

[@thistimeimhere]

Propaganda is much stronger and more obvious now than then. Especially in America where they repealed the law stopping government from lying and using Propaganda on its people.

[@Woooojcio]

As a non native english speaker for me it was a great party song. But later down the line, when I understood the SOAD lyrics I gain a new respect for them. As a Pole there is so much that we I share with their feelings. It's feeling that is hard to described but I adore them.

[@pierrelautrou1210]

That's what's great with SOAD : catchy songs with deep meaning For my taste I prefer French fries to "Freedom" fries, I didn't always agree with Jacques Chirac's politics but in this instance I think he got it right. I don't know why but this song always makes me think about the song "Deify" by Disturbed : kzbin.info/www/bejne/hIvCqIdrpt1ji68

[@Snipergoat1]

@@pierrelautrou1210 SOADs lyrics are deep only if your own thoughts on the matter are shallow. Otherwise they are the trite cliches of the middle class revolutionary. The same type of people who make up antifa. I prefer it when congress deals with matter larger than what to fall medium thickness sliced potatoes boiled in fat. But I suppose doing that is better then fucking something else up so I'll call that a 50-50 on their use of time meter. Chirac wasn't acting on any guiding principles other than he had no immediate way to take advantage of the situation so he fell back to standard French position #2. Criticize the US or NATO while being behind the NATO barrier. This was the result of The Suez crisis where the US and the USSR (If you can believe that those two cooperated on anything in the 1950's) collectively ran France and Britain out of Egypt basically saying "Empire's are bad M'kay." The more cynical around might have seen little thought bubbles over the heads of the of the US and USSR. USSR: You should just invade and conquer them, like we do, and the US: You should just control them economically, like we do. While Britain grumbled a lot they decided to live with it. The French, seeing that they were covered from every potential outside attack vector by NATO and know that they were not going to be able to expand militarily for the forseeable future, France withdrew from NATO and and started being that annoying kid who talks smack while living under the protection, even if indirectly, of the same guys they talked smack about. (They are much like SOAD in this regard.) This is when the US started seeing their first Allie(France) in much the same light as our first foe(Britain) did. in short Chirac wasn't being a statesmen or wise or even peace loving, he was just being French. Let me bring up an old adage regarding US military policy in general "How does one reliably triumph in a battle involing a larger, better train and equipped force? Endeavor, at all costs, to be the superior force." Everybody loves an underdog but in real life David gets pasted by Goliath almost every time. And since you mentioned Disturbed songs I'll bring up "Indestructible" kzbin.info/www/bejne/l4jbc6V_Zcxkoac

[@danielarizmendy5399]

Glad I found this channel. I dig breakdowns like this.

[@TheWRCS]

I love this videos because it gives me a different perspective of the songs I grew up listening to

[@marute2483]

If you want a crazy vocal performance, I suggest Forest from system of a down, one of my favorites and such an amazing song.