6 HARDEST Vocals Singers CAN'T / DON'T Sing ANYMORE (Live)

[@abcdlovexoxo]

Miley has been sounding so much better since she's embraced her lower register and naturally deep voice

[@heymikey6]

zombie stardust Miley’s range is everything. Her lower register is so velvety. 🤤

[@elisepieren4197]

She underwent surgery...

[@tiffprendergast]

Elise Pieren yup

[@MR-cd6wb]

@@elisepieren4197 what for

[@elisepieren4197]

@@MR-cd6wb vocals

[@destiny2301]

people: the high notes can destroy their voice if they do it too often Brendon Urie and Ariana Grande: *visibly sweating*

[@gustia8842]

Lol that's so true

[@jjj61827]

...... Ariana lip syncs almost all of her high notes in live performance

[@opal8469]

Jules // no she doesn’t. we all know she can sing damn well in her swt

[@siah3404]

needy butera she does lip sync those as well

[@kathleen.9577]

*and I oops in death of a bachelor*

[@Kristie27]

The third time Kelly sang “since you’ve been gone”, she was very pregnant. I’m sure she had a hard time breathing, and couldn’t make those high notes at that time.

[@mirandabealko6990]

My same thought. Talking whole pregnant sometimes sucks... So singing and jumping around like she did!

[@chystal9161]

No maybe it's the fact she gained so much fkn weight.

[@MelaninBarbie33]

@@chystal9161 yess asshat you gain a lot of weight sometimes from pregnancy.Whats your point?

[@user-vr2yk8ii7r]

Chystal alot of women get fat bcs of pregnancy

[@myahobbswunsche9806]

Chystal ok that’s rude and maybe she gained weight because she was pregnant. Ever thought of that genuis

[@azrialine]

why do people expect singers to hit every high note perfectly everytime

[@--Fullsun]

@Zute what does money have to do with hitting a high note?

[@--Fullsun]

@Zute mmm I see

[@fluxoff]

If you're gonna flex, better stick that thing so it never falls off.

[@fashionspy96]

Most* of the times And why? Well... For the same reason why an employer would expect the employee to not Fk up the project they're working on 😂

[@kristinkeeling1]

@@fashionspy96 must be speaking from experience 😂

[@bcsushi91]

people: humans age, voices age celine dion: what is age

[@autistic22]

True😂😂😂 she still got it

[@BT-ch9gf]

Shall we go for it? so much!

[@jasminerogers9096]

Celine is so damn healthy

[@bhavindave3003]

byh c I was about to put her name in comments, but you did it 😂👍

[@Morganstewartofficial]

That's true af

[@edwardduda4222]

Your voice naturally gets lower as you get older so it will be harder for them to sing those notes.

[@paladarto]

Not for Mitch Grassi too

[@rahulbanerjee7443]

what about Sia?

[@Angel-xe2tl]

Sia is unnaturally super talented. she sounds the same. im 99% shes not human. (im saying this in a good way)

[@multimanjazzman8203]

JayJay Forever Celine's been lip syncing since prime. Celine can still reach the notes but it's always been extremely heady above Eb5 85-90 percent head voice and is sometimes strained, always nasal, most of the times unsupported

[@-SUM1-]

That's when you go through puberty, not when you're an adult. Lol

[@tayla3095]

Do remember people AGE. Singers are HUMANS. They AGE. Their voices CHANGE.

[@jaedaq8336]

GachaTayla yeah ... does it ever drive you crazy just how fast the night changes...

[@itsmeabbey1077]

@GachaTayla why the fuck are you getting offended? The person who made this wasn't saying their bad singers. Okay. They literally just said that their pitch changed. so keep your fucking hate and hurtful comments off the internet god damn

[@alexisvaracolacci2793]

Ehh: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJ3MY2V4q9yXocU

[@armyblinkrose4504]

Mariah and Britney would bet to differ... cough cough lip sync 24/7

[@tayla3095]

@@itsmeabbey1077 I'm not offended I'm just making a point. And you are contradicting yourself a lot in the same comment

[@maratumale]

As a performer myself, we easily tend to get tired singing the same version for years that we sing it differently over the years. But that doesn't make these celebrity singers any less great. They're just giving it a different vibe. They're still rockin it. From a singer's POV.

[@ilaydaylmaz5601]

Exactly. Our voices change just like our body and mind. While we were good at one technique before, we may adapt to a new one later..

[@AminaIssakhanova]

I think it also depends on how much you perform. if it's one song you can actually put all your energy in it, but if it's a concert, it's wise to spread it evenly so that you still have voice at later songs

[@jenniwilliams3295]

Kelly has also admitted to mixing up some of her old songs cuz yeah she's kind of sick of singing them. But she most certainly still has it, in fact I would think her range has actually expanded. Didn't know this but the only time she sang A moment like This was on idol and then three other times and she's never sung it again she loathes that song. Even during her karaoke she nailed some really high notes. But listen to her album the meaning of life and pay attention in the background where she goes whistle tone in about four of the songs.

[@jenniwilliams3295]

@@ilaydaylmaz5601 there are so many factors that can go into a person's voice's changing. In the cases of people like Mariah and Axl Rose they burn themselves out their voices are destroyed. Martina McBride is one of the crushing ones for me. Her voice has always been absolutely incredible. In fact some of the best country music came out of her. However she sang through a tour with bronchitis the whole time. She didn't even have a speaking voice she's worked on getting that back but she will never be able to sing the same again. Mariah also just destroyed what was left of her voice, people keep arguing with me but that Christmas performance a couple years ago that wasn't a mistake. The Christmas special with her I think it was Ariana grande and Jennifer Hudson and Kelly Clarkson where they all went into whistle tone was pre-recorded or they just cut her mic. Because she does not have that note like the other three do.

[@cxp5818]

I always thought about this! I would get so tired of repeating the same words in the same tone over and over again.

[@Lololol24LA]

Demi’s songs are so so SO hard to sing, I’m not surprised if she goes flat cause it’s so high, and the climax of the song, so she has to sing it with so much power, must be tough

[@tornadicdoge627]

Her first note wasn’t even flat tho haha. They just forgot how to think correctly when typing that she was

[@TuesdaysArt]

Someone also said she was sick in one of the newer clips...goodness knows I'd sound like Marge Simpson if I tried to sing while I was sick!

[@claratiny]

*they, not she

[@brianaguilar8283]

@@claratiny 🙄

[@S0ph.e]

@@brianaguilar8283 you roll your eyes now but yet you’ll bawl your eyes out and act like a Karen whenever someone misgenders you. It’s not hard to respect someone’s pronouns. 😐 Nobody is gonna disrespect you, so don’t respect them.

[@Tony_Kaku]

I cant imagine singing as a job every other day at a concert for 10 years. My voice is ded after 2 Bruno Mars songs on the way to work. 🎤💀

[@4kelly446]

Lol

[@andredailey5147]

Well they also practice and build vocal stamina...they have lots of technique(or they should)...yeah but same

[@tula__]

Ikr. I can't sing the next day after a long session of me trying to sing some of my favourite songs.

[@sh_joy]

Lots of practice, and warming up is SO important and helpful. But yeah it's still really impressive 👌😅

[@lucarey4110]

😂😂

[@TheLovelySheri]

These ladies can sing, I sound like a dying banshee.

[@blahblah-yd8si]

At least it's a banshee , I sound like dying PIGS

[@maddisonnecas5159]

Same!! Lol

[@prettygirlpandora]

Sheri same girl, same 😂

[@andylim9477]

Ikr

[@zain1423]

Sheri ur likes r 666

[@tatiannatownsend1531]

I love Kelly Clarkson’s personality. So sweet and humble and always willing to make a joke or give praise. Never seen her say anything negative once

[@더킬루시퍼]

but what has she been feeding herself?

[@Ta-ks6uc]

​@@더킬루시퍼 why would you leave such a comment. You are rotten inside and you let it out.

[@tuckerruiz8337]

@@더킬루시퍼 food

[@JiafeiProducts6969]

@@더킬루시퍼 She had a thyroid problem and the thyroid regulates basically Everything to Sugar levels and Blood pressure in the boody, She hasnt ate Anything

[@pebbles7732]

I know right she’s great

[@nightsaber9634]

or maybe they just got bored singing same song every day for 10 years

[@christinawinter3970]

😂

[@thgie3258]

Was my thought to

[@puddang2379]

What no lol

[@visoykan]

that is exactly right.. they just bored

[@rebeccat6825]

Ryan Thompson ?

[@veelavon]

completely off topic, but leona lewis looks incredible

[@asmrsleep3079]

It's like she doesn't age

[@yaboiTyTy]

@@asmrsleep3079 because shes an absolute GODESS

[@alleytovar1194]

With her.vocals.she should be more famous

[@asmrsleep3079]

@@yaboiTyTy You got that right

[@minxsburlesqueshow7229]

It's not really off topic. Btw you're right

[@michaelmartinez6437]

My throat started hurting just by watching them I’m on the only one? And I don’t even sing

[@celia9815]

Saaaaaame i was looking for someone to comment that

[@carolinamoreira1205]

Me too!

[@iadorexyou]

I tried singing it with them and my cat started to freak out lol

[@21phandomsatthedisco29]

Lmaooo sameee

[@lizziepeskett7641]

Dude it wasn’t hurting until I saw Christina’s first note, I was like fuckkk how can anyone do that

[@Gomba13]

I love that Kelly says she didn't know if that was going to come out. She admits that even to her some vocals are challenging (which makes me feel okay with not being able to do all the vocals I wish I could), but also, she is taking the risk of messing up, which again shows she was ready to forgive herself for messing up and that people don't need to feel bad about themselves for not being able to do all the vocals they wish they could. I don't have her skills, but what she says makes me feel good about the skills I do have.

[@laracroftvideos]

I think Leona could still do the high notes but she chooses not to because she prefers to come up with new ways how to sing her old songs.

[@MsAppoo-de6qm]

she had damage to her vocal chords but she still sings so amazing😊

[@catinabox3349]

DayvinDazone yeah

[@terriannaharold9084]

Right I can’t believe they came for her like that

[@Anna8765]

She needs to make new songs

[@tehanim96744]

DayvinDazone yea and some performances don’t really need high notes !!👍👍

[@Vamaze]

*takes the peak of someone’s career just to compare it to 10 years later and call a 5 second note short*

[@madelinerincon9628]

IJBT lmao right

[@mattbacera]

It’s making comparisons. If they say it’s short, that means it’s short compared to the original.

[@4amcuriosity162]

Internet in a nutshell

[@smogfry2005]

I feel like the person that made this video doesnt realize that singers are human, they get sick, they get tired, etc. Sometimes they shorten it because they didn't get a good enough breath, or they are getting over a cold, or they got a bit winded for a second. Just because ten years later it was short in one performance doesnt mean she cant hit it anymore.

[@terriannaharold9084]

THIS WHOLE VIDEO WAS JUST A BUNCH OF HEADASSARY

[@amanidupree5368]

I wish people understood what it takes to sing like these girls do. It’s amazing, but exhausting. They have pure talent, and will always be able to sing beautifully.

[@peerlessvenerablefartculti7384]

And you Aaron, how about not undermining people who work hard? Talent or not, these people still work hard.

[@crystal-zl4oj]

Well said.

[@charleneelizabethdickens7145]

@Aaron Wolfenbarger is the only moron here

[@charleneelizabethdickens7145]

@Aaron Wolfenbarger. A comment like that means that you belong with flintstones age not today

[@charleneelizabethdickens7145]

@Aaron Wolfenbarger moron have no learning disabilities but u talk and like u do

[@Asian_Import]

I actually think Demi's voice has gotten better over the years. It's stronger, fuller, and somehow even more emotional. Her recent rock releases and remakes have blown me away.

[@thekenyashow1560]

Demi getting “worse” is actually better than your first example of her.

[@nicolerene1244]

The Kenya Show agree!!!!!!!!!!

[@Dash120z]

exactly she had a cold in that performance

[@allyexpress]

I agree I really like this momment 4:29

[@carloshernandohurtadocardo4085]

Agree! Lol. Firsr example was just awful lol

[@carloshernandohurtadocardo4085]

@@roxannert2099 same.here

[@m.applehead.j_lover1473]

I don't think Demi lost anything g she just gained more control

[@yikes9803]

Yeah gained more control over her heroin shoots

[@Crystal-qg1se]

M.applehead.j _lover agreed!

[@darrelldelp468]

I love Demi

[@superninja6481]

@@oni_senpai_879 lol that's cuz it was flat... the "don't" at 4:33 was flat. just compare it to the original. i mean it's just one small flaw so it really doesn't matter and nobody cares cuz she's so talented vocally. tbh all the artists in the video are really talented and have more than proven they can sing live so even if they mess up or lip sync i don't really care

[@ladyJustis]

Not a good singer

[@emmalauren4161]

Some of these singers probably just got bored of singing the same song for 5+ years and changed the performance a little, they are all amazing vocalists. Great observations though

[@Whats_your_motivational]

Emma Lauren I was thinking the same thing. Who wants to hear or sing it the same way. The one is 11 years later. And you don't know if their throat hurts, they were tired or just wanted to change it up.

[@justincase9284]

I've literally seen bands that HATE HATE HATE their most popular songs. Playing the same shit over and over for ten+ years would make you hate it, too.

[@jolenemartin6784]

Justin Case true cue in kurt cobain

[@amandahugginkiss61]

I am a classically trained soprano who has sung professionally for 20 years. I do vocal warmups and exercises regularly. But I’m much older than I used to be. It’s just harder now. I used to hit all this stuff without a warmup. Now I’m in the necessary warmup phase. That’s why these QUEENS who come out and slay it in their older years are the true talents. After all of the hormone changes women go thru, all of the pregnancies and body changes. Those women come out and slay. Those are the ones who deserve accolades. They stand the test of time and still come out and put it down for us.

[@cleanandgreenketo]

I appreciate this comment!!!

[@JanePixel]

I also appreciate this comment!! I’m a singer too and I beat myself up for not being able to hit the same notes I could as a younger person. You’ve made me feel so much better. Singing is something that makes me happy, so I’ll keep on doing it even if my voice has changed :)

[@sillypsyborg]

Great comment. Same for men. Depends somewhat on genetics and somewhat on the style of vocals they sing. Rock/metal/operatic singers usually experience the most fragile voices or dramatic damage to vocal cords as they age. But good technique counts for a lot. Self-care. And how long you've been singing. Some people don't even realize they're talented until they're older like you mention! Or they didn't have money or resources or role models to develop a voice. We take these singers for granted too.

[@kevinwalsh4652]

Let's face it, getting old sucks, perhaps the greatest vocalist touring presently is Lzzy Hale, night after night, slaying it vocally, she's been doing it at a high level for two decades, getting better, getting stronger...diet, cigarettes, alcohol, drugs, stress, skipping daily vocal exercises, etc. Once they make it, most don't care, in his prime, no one could hit the octaves Axl Rose could, saw him last year at Fenway Park, it's just sad...and pathetic to see these geriatric fossil dinosaurs hanging on for the $$$

[@yureino]

NO. Queens who slay when theyre older DOES NOT MEAN THEY'RE TRULY TALENTED BUT IT SHOWS THEY HAVE GREAT TECHNIQUE & HEALTHY HABIT of singing.

[@annabelravenbredesen-arntz2914]

Won't..... It's notes they won't sing in every single one of their concerts cuz it will literally destroy their voice....

[@hayleyscomet3447]

Bellaisbrb exactly! Even if they use amazing Technique they still have to push a little.

[@yepok6520]

Once every 8 years should be ok though, no? 😄

[@trinitylivingston1286]

@@yepok6520 what do you mean?

[@Sallyy2011]

Huh? Did you hear all the opera singers? G5 is not a really high note (especially not in classical music). Sopranos can go an octave higher than that. They also have some concerts a week and do that for some decades. With the right technique you will not destroy your voice by singing a G5 every day 😉

[@morangoatomic997]

Salome Muhr - I agree.

[@silenceseppo7079]

Incredibly harsh an Leona. We all know she’s still capable.

[@myahobbswunsche9806]

Roga yes ikkk she still sounds so beautiful😍

[@MorganBF1]

Does the person running this channel even sing? Lol really wanna know.

[@qiuhuiwang693]

and equally forgiving towards miley...

[@misakixxchan]

ikr she's probs just tired of singing the song the same way all the time lol

[@sakuraharunoswife987]

none of these are harsh..... they were just seeing the artists progression and how they sang the song...

[@clairebones1988]

Just sounds more Controlled and less showy off. They no longer need to prove their vocals in the later concerts we know they can sing by this point so it's just more relaxed

[@lonnie3856]

Girl we tired

[@DazBRayy]

@@lonnie3856 😭

[@Boultbeeable]

People forget that pregnancy affects people's voices too. Kelly had 3(?) kids, and she has said in interviews it really affected her voice. As did Christina. It affects your breathing, and vocal chords. Kelly has said she can no longer reach certain high notes since having each of her children.

[@Chiacesther]

Wow, what women sacrifice for motherhood.

[@trendkiller6611]

One of the reasons why I have never wanted children.

[@TrollextheTroll]

That's no excuse.😠

[@AndrewFaust-x1e]

@@TrollextheTroll That's a perfectly valid excuse. My mom is a singer and her voice was affected after she had me and my 2 siblings. People's voices change due to pregnancies, and just age overall.

[@Chill_330]

Damn I don’t want childern lol 😂

[@crashtheproducer9737]

I’m not a Demi fan but how the hell do you call that flat? She wasn’t tryna hit a high note that time. She hit it rough so it sounded more powerful since it’s meant to sound like a more powerful note.

[@kait5617]

I think it was a little flat. Nothing against her though. I can't sing for the life of me lol 😂

[@MonumentToSin]

Yeah, I'll admit Demi is flat about 50% of the time that she hits those high note, but that other half that people call "flat" is actually her voice just getting a little rough. If she could just work on keeping a clear tone in the higher register, people wouldn't think she was that bad. Not that she's a bad singer, she has the range, but her high register needs better sound.

[@ms.artichokecheesepizzawst3239]

Lol

[@monroe8566]

Demi is an alto and the people writing her songs (or composing them) keep on forgetting that like-

[@王一一-s3y]

She still sound stable even it is not her best performance.

[@AalyceHusbands]

as a music major, the amount of incorrectly used music terms in this video is giving me hives

[@JaeMonroeVocalist]

Perhaps this is the page for the mentally challenged? LOL

[@PIX-HUGEIFY]

shade

[@adannaokoye]

i felt that in my bones

[@1d280]

I can relate...

[@_arina_161]

Aalyce Husbands no one said they were pro 😑

[@NaditaHerrmann]

This is not fair. Nobody is the same healthy in every single concert. They are sometimes more tired, probably had a concert almost every day for weeks and got a cold, nobody knows. They also sometimes want to do thing differently to don't bore the people with exact replications of the recording version. Maybe they all still can kill all these notes today.

[@ytubeanon]

they're called "performers" for a reason, cry me a river

[@chelletothebelle2145]

@@ytubeanon and performers dont always perform the same way each time and they have days where they don't do good(????) Like we're only human. Make it make sense buddy. If you ain't in the entertainment business or dont know anything about it, stfu

[@ytubeanon]

+Chelle To The Belle: obviously you don't know what a performer does as a career, good chat idiot

[@trishtrain2075]

Nobody ever said they were always going to sound the same, we all know singing the way they do can really hurt your voice

[@Azzyy444]

ytubeanon maybe they just simply don’t *want* to sing it the same way every time???? imagine how many times they have to sing that song obviously they will want to switch it up. what’s not clicking?

[@mizzysparrots4874]

Demi sounded so immature in the first clip, and fabulous in the last one, yet shes being critiqued in the last one??

[@cheyennealexis]

Okay.. Demi did NOT lose her voice, she only Gained more control over it

[@Chicken_Nugget1]

Nah she lost it.

[@Melissa-np6rf]

@@Chicken_Nugget1 nuh

[@Melissa-gh6wg]

The heroic watering can - no she really didn’t lol.

[@hayleianne2134]

The heroic watering can nope

[@kristinag7033]

Yes!

[@stressedandinneedofrest3826]

I'm just impressed that they even used to be able to sing these.

[@Sb-or1do]

pop_o_rainbow Yeah

[@DenyingFate]

Why? There are dozens of rock artists who could do these with ease. Maybe not as high but their voices are way more powerful.

[@stressedandinneedofrest3826]

Nayvio Campbell That may be so but not everyone is a rock singer. I never said I wasn't impressed by rock singers. Just like you said "maybe not as high".

[@abdirisakawes6544]

Nemi Alger ikr

[@amandanightstar8012]

Have you heard Kelly's new song? She can do it even higher

[@addiction1101]

See Kelly Clarkson is a mother of 3 and she's somewhere around 40 but she can still sing, like damn Edit: how the hell did I get 640 likes I barely ever get 6?! I love chu guys

[@__-sm2nq]

Kelly Clarkson is 37 years old

[@a.m.m6145]

Yeah. One's age and number of children they've given birth to have got do little to disrupt raw talent. I could see it affecting, perhaps, elasticity of the nether regions, but luckily, our vocal cords don't keep track of the number of diapers we've changed. ;) Case in point I guess.

[@ahashi1924]

@@a.m.m6145 Also, aging can affect the voice. People's regular speaking voices change as they age from 25 to 40. A singing voice also changes based on how old someone is because of the amount of singing they have done.

[@danielsonicky]

I wonder why sia not in list 🤭

[@jclaneva]

@@ahashi1924 Actually, what happens is that you lose some of the elasticity in the vocal chords, just as you do in your muscles and joints, and that loss affects the voice. That loss costs you in your range, and not just at the top. It can cost you a few notes on the bottom as well. :)

[@sarahw4006]

the way demis voice has matured and changed is so incredible theyre such a good vocalist

[@khalidm3015]

I was SHOOK when I heard Kelly’s high note the first time

[@manjeetnirala7789]

khalid m she still can hit high notes ,at that time she was pregnant

[@katetheninja4945]

Is that a reference to Shane Dawson ??

[@xoxodee1392]

When Leona Lewis sings bleeding love, back when she hit it hard, makes me cry it was so beautiful 😭

[@hollyrodgers1806]

I scream/sing that song multiple times a week 😂

[@gachastrangergachalife9484]

She is not a human she is a Angel 💖

[@avariley1025]

Xoxo Dee ikr

[@ninaangelicka1590]

Me too

[@michellenicole782]

Omg me too! I thought i was like the only one that cries because its so beautful..( other great singers too)

[@Slrsniper]

“Dodged” I laughed so hard when I saw that

[@marshalllee3827]

Leon Resident evil 4.if u can relate.😂

[@GamesLover-sj2rs]

Yes, hahahaha

[@ImakeTrax]

Tickled the 💩 outta me! 😂😂😂

[@jobelijander6217]

Its great to see that everyone in the comments are understanding of the artists' vocal maturity. Like.. singing a vocally demanding song for some years or more than 10 years will really put a strain in your voice and thats understandable and normal. Vocalists and singers are no different from athletes after all. Vocal Cords are a muscle and they have their wear and tear too. I just hate how everyone is indifferent when it comes to Mariah Carey who has sung her hits (and still does) for almost 30 years. Most of her songs are even harder than some of the songs shown here. Why cant everyone give her some slack? Her WHOLE discography is VOCALLY Demanding and i just hate that most people dont have the ame attitude everyone now has in this comment box towards her. I just wish everyone is as kind as you all are. 🥺

[@itskate2991]

Leona has a voice like no other! My goodness. So graceful and she can hit so many different notes.

[@echa0111]

Is it true? Is it already be counted with Christina Aguilera, Beyonce, Mariah Carey?

[@adriansarac3535]

@@echa0111 during her prime definitely yes

[@10061986100]

Só underrated🙄

[@emmaezzaouya76]

Went to a Miley concert and I can tell you the girl truly can sing

[@charinamoreno6012]

Emma Ezzaouya You are lucky 😭

[@racheltison6333]

Emma Ezzaouya same! Shows me that most of these fail videos are just one bad song of the artist's. Well most of them I imagine...

[@jonw7538]

well yea, a lot of people can actually sing... but if you're a celeb on stage for millions of dollars you should be the best

[@emmaezzaouya76]

Jon W well she is the best

[@lilywilson22]

I went to a Hannah Montana concert when I was three. I got scared cause of all the screaming girls

[@hammy.m]

why are all the recent recordings look like theyve been shot on a potato

[@cupid297]

hamster these are old songs lol

[@Avri_Citron]

The Audio sounds tampered with and echoey too, on all the recent 'fail' songs also. Like the author was messing with autotune. To court likes and views. You cant really hear the artist properly.

[@L_A_Rivers]

The clip used for Kelly is from 2015 when she had vocal issues. She’s now doing F#5s all the time and has recovered a whole lot.

[@calebriggins9762]

Not gonna lie, Demi’s voice used to be kinda weak at first but it’s gotten a lot stronger.

[@Hannah-nh5qj]

In what universe? All she's done is change her technique- she's always been incredibly powerful

[@sisjbdhdghhshhzbbsjaknsnnz7732]

It’s because Demi had an eating disorder

[@adambrown7670]

She’s only gotten stronger throughout this video

[@vigtoria8123]

Tbh I don’t think her voice sounds good. Like I mean she’s talented. I just don’t enjoy listening to her voice or the way it sounds

[@swedishfish5622]

It got SUPER STRONG. I didn't even know that range existed until Demi came along.

[@veelavon]

the only thing different about demi and miley is that they’re voices have matured

[@lucymccaig2777]

Demi is a bitch

[@nickiminaj2491]

@@lucymccaig2777 wtf?

[@haislaangie2899]

Exactly

[@haislaangie2899]

@@lucymccaig2777 what the hell are you talking about?

[@zachsimpson1340]

its all the heroin she did. itll change a genderfluid person

[@bayanmoran]

Leona Lewis is unreal omfg

[@okokokok9935]

queen moran she can still hit those notes that was just a bad performance

[@bayanmoran]

Nimblevermin82 AJ: No I mean she's amazing

[@bayanmoran]

Mohammad Waleed in a good way

[@okokokok9935]

queen moran oh ikr!

[@JakobTennisMB]

I LOVE her but she cannot still hit those notes. She's pitchy and a shell of her former self in every single performance after 2014 or so

[@AlinaMedina]

As a singer, I’m actually loving videos like this because it shows that even the world’s greatest pop singers aren’t perfect, and yet most people don’t notice their mistakes.

[@chadsy1164]

this title is so confusing. “they can’t/don’t sing anymore” but nailed it either way????? it doesn’t have to be on a high note everytime they’re singing this live. sometimes it is the artist’s technique not to sing it originally.

[@anormalperson1851]

Demi’s songs are extremely hard so for her coming close in those videos is extremely good, but we all know she can still sing it.

[@gladysolvera6566]

plus remember Demi had bulimia and other eating disorders and that can affect your throat and obviously your vocal chords can have some or lots of damage.

[@ariannalovescorn9486]

Demi actually sounded better as the years went on

[@sisjbdhdghhshhzbbsjaknsnnz7732]

Arianna that’s because she had a eating disorder

[@famousfuture7427]

What does her disorder gave to do with her voice

[@sisjbdhdghhshhzbbsjaknsnnz7732]

bkcatch purging or throwing up destroyed her esophagus.

[@EvelynMedrano-s3q]

Indeed

[@kiwicatnip]

Everybody sleeps on Kelly Clarkson but she was a legend

[@BSPT12]

*is

[@edro51188]

She's still the G.O.A.T. of American Idol

[@shiannebailey-gatchell6579]

Got a lot of respect for Leona Lewis, she is literally an angel

[@runningwithlola]

That first clip of Miley she looks like she’s wearing a diaper. 😂

[@anaricooper9262]

runningwithlola I thought it was

[@zackied596]

I thought the same. Hahahaha

[@Melissa-np6rf]

Lol😂😂

[@VeeAmericanEagle]

runningwithlola 💀💀

[@stoneghana4171]

Yup

[@bitsnbobs6634]

*me in the background struggling to hit the lower notes*

[@bunny697]

Bits'n Bobs *I can't hit a high note (": My voice cracks every time..*

[@johnmaverick5932]

OkaiiAggie i cant sing

[@DomoniqueMusiclover]

Hahaha Lmfao.... hilarious

[@alinaanzures5080]

Bits'n Bobs I can't sing a high note.... My voice cracks everytime......

[@kitkat70703]

Bits'n Bobs I cant sing low notes either, but I can get the really high notes.

[@aaaaaaaaaaaimee]

Okay I’ve seen Demi & Miley live and they are both incredible singers. Every performance will have factors that effect it. All love for these talented people ❤️

[@macethorns1168]

Miley isn't "great" LOL

[@vincikeeper1581]

​@@macethorns1168you're right, Miley is better than great.

[@PlasticSkies-e9k]

​@@macethorns1168miley has best low notes ever in any mezzo soprano in any generation right now yes its crazy it has both girly quality and baritone tone and incredibly full if highs ariana if lows miley

[@AshleeBarrera]

I disagree on the Demi Lovato one... she was like inexperienced then but is freaking amazing now!

[@workcultureworks]

"like" inexperienced?

[@TrinityRoseOfficial]

They gotta change up the song after sing it so many times

[@enericonacentoenla1e]

Wow I'm really surprise to find u here hahah. Love you💛

[@lovedly]

shook-

[@kiianamxmb5195]

I'm sorry but i'm pretty sure miley Cyrus and demi lovato only improved so....what?😅

[@princesskb4401]

Kiiana mxmb Kelly can still sing high like when she did at 18. She just doesn’t everytime. It will mess up their vocal chords and it’s hard af to sing right when your vocals are messed up.

[@meriasunday7139]

I live for demi 😂💖

[@lilo3310]

I really believe miley improved in more calm songs wich is way better bcz low notes are underestimated and way harder than high notes that can be mistaken for shouts

[@n.s.c6011]

@Jennifer Rivera You're deaf.

[@n.s.c6011]

@Jennifer Rivera You claimed Demi sounds "horrible" live. I wouldn't trust your opinion on anyone's vocals.

[@miriamdavis2988]

I'm an armature singer and ill tell ya, some days your voice just flows and WANTS to sing but other days, no mater how much you try, it just isn't there. And voices get worn out and tired too. So I see this video as real and encouraging that no one is perfect and we all have good and not so good singing moments ❤

[@oliviahenriquez2141]

demi didn’t lose anything she just gained more control over her voice 🙄

[@FF-mt4ce]

and gained weight 🤗

[@Whitewitch_25]

F F and? Is that a problem?

[@FF-mt4ce]

@@Whitewitch_25 no, shut your mouth I just can't take this.

[@lonernaet5112]

Yess her voice is dope asf 🔥🙌🏾👏🏾👌🏾💕 love her 😊

[@excusemebutwhat5690]

Olivia Henriquez - Yeah, she’s learned a lot this past year. And her voice.. 😍😍😍

[@c0sm1x36]

This really isn’t fair, they’re famous for their singing but it doesn’t mean that they have to perform high notes they sang years ago at every concert or performance. LET THEM LIVE!!! We’re all human!💕

[@musicsavedme3534]

Leona Lewis can't be human with that voice

[@guitarmissy8830]

Leona blew me away immensely!! She used to be as good as Christina Aguilera but age really does take a toll on vocalists. The voice was not intended to be used that way. It was just for speaking.

[@claudiarose1571]

AGREED

[@jakeyjakes_]

Guitar Missy she has bad hashimoto's too tho. It's been really bad for her voice

[@chloemarr5296]

Musicsavedme and Ariana grandes human No she is better than her

[@kennedyolowinski5209]

Musicsavedme ikr😂

[@adriennewhitaker2913]

I love it when I hear the honest beautiful imperfections in real singers voices when they perform from the heart. It is what makes live performances so wonderful. Simply amazing! If I want to listen to perfectly executed notes every time, I can to the recording.

[@natopal0819]

THISSSS!!!! i pay for the authenticity of the artist and their show, not for perfectly executed performances or else i'd just watch the music video..

[@dannifofanni7667]

The fact that the comments are coming for the guy who made this instead of coming for the artists, makes me have a little bit of faith in the YT community.

[@poppie3691]

righttt

[@karaaaholbert]

So we’re gonna talk about how Demi was “flat” on her second go but we’re not gonna talk about how Miley was flat on her first one??

[@berl2343]

Kara Mason selective amirite

[@noelaida1548]

100 th like💪

[@kinsleymclay7522]

Demi sounds amazing no matter what.

[@deekayteeohthree]

Facts

[@sincerelyalaskax]

Demi sounds amazing either way! And, she wasn’t even flat. It’s just how her voice is

[@uns0ciable4ever]

kelly clarkson is a force to be reckoned with, such a vocalist

[@dallascowboyshighlights9632]

amelia cool I know she gained some weight but holy hell, I didn't realize how much until seeing this old performance.

[@laurapurkess1]

That was so strained what are you on about

[@StevenResnick]

Incorrect she's terrible especially her newer songs

[@uns0ciable4ever]

why are y'all pressed

[@rhettmitchell]

Steven Resnick where

[@OurLucylocket]

Speaking as a singer myself, its often the case that you may have to preserve your voice an not push it if you've a lot of performances to do, its called (holding back), then there's, Lack of sleep, Travel, Jet Lag, Cold, Flu, Acid Reflux, Asthma or having an off day and any number of medical conditions that can effect your vocal, along with the fact some voices get deeper as they get older, We are just human like everyone else, we have bad days too and your voice can even change from day to day. Unlike the other muscles in your body your vocal cords get weaker not stronger if over worked.

[@elinaufreisen]

3:05 oh you call me a BANANAAAAAAAAAAAA edit: LMAO thx for the likes & y'all weirdoes like me :)

[@rea747]

😂

[@lei7417]

😂

[@sangsangatlau7749]

😂😂😉😉

[@Rich.3938]

😂

[@paerisane146]

I laughed 😂

[@hopeandrade7396]

I will say, a lot of Demi's early performances right after Disney were surfing her drug/alcohol days. So that may have something to do with the quality of her voice at the time.

[@JustNatax3]

Hope Andrade Yeah I thought so too, she had quite a lot of problems, she sounds better today.

[@megarielang]

She also was bulimic.

[@beckymoore8162]

She’s a beautiful singer I’m obsessed I’m seeing her in june 🤣

[@mooabdzar3972]

If you notice, actually Demi's voice has grown stronger now. She sounds better.

[@kennedyolowinski5209]

Moo Abdzar yea

[@mbr7156]

believe it or not, people don't see (hear?) those connections... she could have literally torn her throat to shreds

[@anafloreslol]

No she was better before

[@famousfuture7427]

Vegan with Down syndrome and Alzheimers what does her old eating disorder have to do with her voice

[@emilysoto1985]

bkcatch she had bulimia which can destroy ur voice. my singing voice used to be really great but i suffered from an eating disorder for 5 years and it's not as good now. the acid in ur stomach can literally fuck up ur throat and vocal cords so much and when ur throwing up nearly every meal for years, it takes a big toll on you.

[@pamelajeanunlimited]

I'm a professional singer. At 43 years old, hysterectomy gave me hormonal changes and aging. My voice is changing too. I just sing low and raspy. These women are musical icons. ❤

[@TheFoeminator]

Leona lewis can actually still sing the high notes but she doesn't obviously when she has to sing other songs or the performance is long, but ive seen her sing the high notes when she's like a guest for 1 song performance

[@DJDONTKNOWW]

Sometimes a singer gets sick tho so just because they screw up a note doesn't mean they lost it.. you cant always sing live under the perfect conditions

[@splritwolf]

Love that when Miley skipped the 'octave part' the audience did it for her 😂❤

[@johnlemon4647]

Star vs the Zootopia ahhahahaha

[@DRodMuzicman]

Very Professional 👍🏼 Do what you are capable of. Being real deserves respect. ✌🏻❤️🎶

[@JayyNyxx]

Demi's voice is actually so much stronger now and she can easily hit those notes. Those runs in the beginning were actually kinda bad. She is so much better now. She shouldn't be on this list at all actually lol

[@kayleesayswhoa]

The Gleeful Geek I actually thought the Wal-Mart sound check one sounded better even tho it was a little pitchy.

[@kimcharlinekb]

She was actually sick at the Wal-Mart sound check!

[@kayleesayswhoa]

kcharline wow! Better than what I would've done. (:

[@kimcharlinekb]

Me too lmao. Demi is amazing

[@Thaydontcry]

The Gleeful Geek now she has the technics but she lost her voice.

[@theavrillavigneproject]

I think some of these depend on the concert/live, like, if they've been singing for a long time and feel their voices tired or are just in a not-so-good day and think they won't make it, they dogde the high notes or don't do them as high

[@fluffyriko1309]

TheAvrilLavigneProject i am so agree with you.

[@learnmore5092]

Omg isubscribed you!! I also loooovvvveeee avril more than anything

[@slicplaya]

What you don't realize is that they do hundreds of shows and they have to learn/ are taught techniques to save and keep their voice aka career. All that singing scars your vocal cords as well.

[@beena3593]

What you don’t realize is that the person who made this video probably knows that.

[@Sam-gk6kb]

A lot of these singers don't have great technique and DON'T look after their voices, Christina being a shining example. In fact the only person here who has actual great and healthy technique is Kelly Clarkson.

[@carter...apollo147]

I think the person who made this video is perfectly aware of that... they’re not saying anything bad about the later performances, just pointing out what’s changed.

[@Riplie_]

Whoever made this video honestly doesn't know that much about music. They are using incorrect terminology that anyone who'd spent even a year in any choir should have known and misjudging what actually qualifies as a high note with... the vast majority of these singers. And Sam is correct, their technique is atrocious. They are not being taught preservation techniques, they are being taught how to belt, and that's about it, Kelly Clarkson included.

[@Jento]

That is a joke. Kelly has never been skilled. She's got a mediocre sound and her songs take little/no talent.

[@tinagarcia3955]

My mom’s a singer and I’ve also been a singer. As a high schooler I was a first soprano and definitely couldn’t do the low notes. Now that I’m older I’m more a second soprano and I can even get lower than when I was in high school. Our voices change as we get older. And sometimes notes are cut shorter or changed because we’re either sick, or we’re trying to preserve our voices. These women in this video kill it every damn time no matter how they change the song.

[@liyah2523]

I disagree with all these artist they sound more matured and experienced

[@bradoliver5252]

If you think this is a bash video, it's not. They all can hit the exact notes if they wanted too, but when you sing the same song for over 4 years you do stuff different, and that's fine.

[@_sc300]

If by “you do stuff different” you mean lowering your high note to avoid embarrassment, that’s a pretty trendy theme for most artists it seems 😏

[@shacorieadavis6059]

Brad Oliver so true

[@livhasberg7652]

Brad Oliver exactly what I thought

[@chloe1098]

Exactly that’s what I thought,, especially miley.

[@marianalourenco2825]

i agree this video doesn't make any logical point

[@beatrizamorim6873]

When "We Can't Stop" came I was like: 4 years?? Noo!!

[@martyna8134]

Beatriz Amorim was looking for that kind of comment, just to say I can relate 😂 I was shocked!

[@beatrizamorim6873]

tina Xx haha yeah Time goes too fast

[@emmaoneill8831]

Beatriz Amorim unless your 8

[@opheliarose2299]

I know i feel so old

[@iamyou105]

Yesss! 💘

[@leahluralarsen5674]

Say what yall want, but Demi’s voice will always be my favourite bc her voice is incredibly awesome

[@lorrainerodriguez8879]

sometimes i feel like the singers like to change up their notes because it must be tiring to sing the song in the same notes over and over again.

[@radush7784]

thank you for this ! ! !

[@tommy_girl8058]

You’re 100% correct

[@Gorgeousbaebeauty]

Exactly, thank you

[@farky42]

That COULD be a reason

[@eirebhoy132]

Is was going to say the same thing, comparing how someone sings a song 8 years after is stupid, I doubt they sung the songs exactly the same every single time.

[@slaymeclarksonc9086]

okay so Kelly does NOT belong here. the "11 years later" is because she literally just came from pregnancy where she vomited 24/7. and the "this year" was actually 2015 as well...plus, she has dodged the note multiple times even in her vocal prime. she does it to preserve and take care of her voice. it's not fair to say she can't sing it anymore when that isn't the case.

[@adara4635]

BScottFAN Lol you sound very uneducated, please read a book and come back after.

[@wallewaltz]

That probably was the most wrong thing i heard someone saying about vocals.

[@BScottFAN]

shut up idiot, you are delusional, bye felicia.

[@enfpflower5751]

slaymeclarkson c: then why does Beyoncé with kids still can sing perfectly and put on a show ? She doesn't have vocal technique and that's why her voice is exhausted.

[@mistickoenig8816]

it says cant OR DON'T sing it anymore.

[@eldenjr]

That's why singing is the hardest thing to do. It is your instrument and the hardest one to keep strong. Unlike a guitar or any other man made instrument parts can be relaced if broken. Vocals can't usually be fixed once broken. Please singers, always take care of it. Get training. Get rest. If not, blow your guts out for ten to fifteen years, make all the money you can then quit!

[@Nicolacurran1]

That's a ridiculous comment. So singing is harder than brain surgery or nuclear fusion?! Gimme a break. You either have a talent or you don't and if you do take care of your body - simple!

[@eldenjr]

Nicola M .........IN MUSIC! Not talking about any other profession.

[@keremkarabutucancallmekk7678]

Nicola M gurl chill why you so offended

[@jeffree6996]

Learning an instrument is harder then being born with a great voice. Singing is god given

[@jeffree6996]

flowerpretty 8 of course but you must have an attractive singing voice. Someone with an "ugly" voice cannot learn to sound good. Or even hit ranges or difficult notes. You must be born with an attractive singing voice to want to be heard by people. I can sing any song. Will it sound good? Eh. Can I be taught to sound good? Nope

[@rebeccaleanne9218]

I really love Kelly! Her personality is so bubbly and fun!

[@SKHodgdon]

Hello. Professional singer here. Have been for over twenty years. These people are human beings and extraordinary human beings at that. Do you have a job that you have to execute in front of thousands of people? A job that can be affected by lack of humidity in the air, your period, the common cold, being overworked, lack of sleep, acid reflux, allergies...the list goes ON. Singers attempt to meet your expectations time and time again under oftentimes uncontrollable circumstances and your expectations are exceedingly high. When your body is your instrument, some days you have to accept what your body is able to produce and hit an alternate note or cut a note short rather than push it and risk a public train wreck. You also have to take great care of yourself and sometimes you have to pull back to prevent permanent injury. Our careers rely solely on the health of our vocal chords which are just two tiny bands of tissue in our throats. When you're talking about a famous singer, it's not just her/his career in the balance now...it's an entire team of people that are counting on them for their livelihood. So I say, if these singers need to key something down, choose an alternate note, or cut a note short so they can keep themselves and their family of technicians and musicians employed and keep doing what they were put on this earth to do-then SO BE IT! And while I'm ranting, every time you comment on Kelly Clarkson's weight, you look like a tacky douchebag. She's a beautiful woman, a lovely soul and can sing rings around your ass. I'm going to go learn some new songs now and keep practicing doing what I love. Ya'll take care XXX

[@jimpolk3553]

A little dramatic, don't ya think?

[@smtz5247]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@christina-zp5op]

Well said

[@Blind.]

@@jimpolk3553 incredibly

[@jesussequea1562]

Loved the comment. Haters gonna hate

[@dearjordie]

Leona Lewis probably got so tired of si ging that song

[@lucarey4110]

🤣🤣

[@PiginaCage]

lmao the subtitles though "Cracked", "flat", "she lip-synced" "ad lip"

[@michaelreger3887]

annoying AF

[@gamaliel5584]

Dodged

[@nikita-jade6700]

The font is shit.

[@Kelkelly22]

Ikr lol and they weren’t even that bad

[@antitititfragile]

now its removed lol

[@HanaTheRussell]

I love your really positive spin on this. I thought you might just be ripping into them. But you make great points. Some of these things shred their vocal cords. Maybe it was worth it when they were new, and just trying to make a name for themselves. But once they'd made it, they need to preserve themselves for longevity. I really do hate lip syncing though, personally. If your voice is dying that much then I'd rather they just do less shows, as opposed to doing shows but lip syncing through them. Also the 'dodges' are okay for me as I love hearing alternative renditions of their songs.

[@SuperBubblyme]

Miley said in her documentary she did for MTV while promoting bangers she always hated that high note in "We can't stop " lol

[@prithvishbanerjee6922]

Thank goodness.. I also hated that part.. even when she sang it perfectly!! :-P

[@weerty0187]

Vane or she just likes her deep tone, idk, high notes don't really fit her, she always had a Pretty deep voice so...

[@dottedlines]

Weerty01 Nope. Just watch Miley belt continuous high notes in her performance of I'll Take Care of You. She's fantastic with all notes when she wants to

[@zacharydbooth]

Kelly Clarkson is amazing.

[@concepciongonzalez7276]

Zachary Booth obese

[@JustNatax3]

Concepcion Gonzalez That's more like overweight... You can definitely still see her shape and hips, she's not just blob... LOL

[@millertime1101]

Zachary Booth she was

[@ferniejasmineabdulghani.6662]

Zachary Booth Sooooooo truuuuuueeeeeeee

[@4elovechishe]

omg......she got fat

[@carlaobrien1326]

Demi still blows me away to this day

[@clara-stbs]

She's amazing 😍❤️❤️❤️

[@funkycoldmedina29]

This was a pretty cool video. Didn’t bash them and still kind of gave them their props the whole time 👏🏼

[@tintorres5310]

Demi Lovato can still reach the high notes until now. But I believe she just change her way to sing

[@phattsins]

Brendon Urie: *sees title* Brendon Urie: *Is that a **_CHALLENGE_** I hear?*

[@OmgILovePitbull]

Royale Clown his voice is absolutely magical!

[@loveunicorns4819]

Leona Lewis has such a great voice

[@catherinemclean6343]

I love how if someone Mist the note you were understanding and not hateful! Great video!