Volvo EX30 vs XC40 vs Zeekr X vs Smart 3 vs Model 3 vs Kia Niro vs EV6 vs Ioniq 5 vs VW ID3 vs MG4

[@autogefuehl]

This is our in-depth review compact EV comparison review with Volvo EX30 vs XC40 vs Zeekr X vs Smart 3 vs Tesla Model 3 vs Kia Niro vs EV6 vs Ioniq 5 vs VW ID3 vs Renault Megane vs MG4. We're taking a look at Exterior, Interior and the driving experience. 00:00 Compact EV comparison 01:53 Volvo EX30 13:16 Volvo XC40 30:12 Zeekr X 51:04 Smart 3 1:01:19 Tesla Model 3 1:11:08 Kia Niro EV 1:36:19 Kia EV6 2:12:15 Ioniq 5 2:38:45 VW ID3 2:55:28 Renault Megane EV 3:21:57 MG4 3:49:28 Which compact EV to buy? #Volvo #Zeekr #Tesla ►Subscribe here: kzbin.info ►Also subscribe to our KZbin shorts channel: kzbin.info/door/mKVmuPc9wUlLuuhnIeP7_w ►Follow us on Facebook / Instagram / TikTok @autogefuehl Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.

[@zelig9625]

Glad to see you included the Renault Megane E-Tech, although you didn't list the Megane in the video title.

[@rajaali-ck5vh]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@markakinmade7712]

😅

[@Erikkrols]

Very rarely test drivers mention the turning circle. I think it is an important thing to make our life easier in parking situations and deserved to be mentioned systematically in every test.

[@SchoRiginal]

Three and half hours of Autogefühl? Finally!

[@autogefuehl]

enjoy =)

[@fredbeblein2622]

You took a lot of trouble in making such a compilation. Thx for it. Just the thing for an EV freak like me, who is about to buy one next year. Dankeschön, Thomas!

[@vardieyal]

A comparison video it would have been much clear to see some charts comparing performances specs and prices... Thank you

[@wings9925]

Thorough, informative, interesting and entertaining, as always. Thank you Thomas. Your in-depth reviews are, for me, the video equivalent of the print media Autocar Road Test: The benchmark.

[@autogefuehl]

Highly appreciated 🙏🙏

[@hamiltonjohn5592]

Thank you for this indepth review. Amazing content as always

[@autogefuehl]

thanks !! Please recommend :)

[@amperformance7998]

In Australia, we have far fewer options for EVs, but I bought the EV6 as the best overall package. I was happy to see you agree. Another reason I bought the EV6 over a Tesla is because of my concerns over connected cars, tracking, data privacy, and security. The Australian EV6 does not have any app or ota connectivity. While that doesn't preclude the possibility of personal data being taken during servicing updates, it does reduce the amount and value of that data.

[@FrancisdeBriey]

Very good and balanced review, even if my final ranking differs from yours a little bit. I have the ioniq5 and am extremely satisfied. But I wouldn't mind to "downgrade" to the exceptional good looking EX30, except that the lack of ultra fast charging is a absolute no brainer, therefore I stay with my ioniq 5 for now. Tesla is out of the picture, for ME, because I don't find Tesla cars pretty, actually I hate their minimalism. Leave minimalism to Ikea & scandinavians, Elon. The only beautiful Tesla remains the model S, but I don't want a sedan... Life is not perfect.

[@autogefuehl]

WATCH OUT FOR SPAM/FAKE ACCOUNTS. Across KZbin/Whatsapp/Telegram etc., you'll find fake accounts taking the identity of original channels or people claiming to work on the behalf of original channels, they sometimes even use the same profile pic, similar names and include a telephone number in the name or their comments, trying to get you to message them on Whatsapp or Telegram. DO NOT MESSAGE THEM, they are trying to get your personal details, bank accounts etc. and in the end, they will ask for money or they will misuse your bank account. They promise you giveaways, prices, payment etc. Do not fall for these cheap tricks and PLEASE HELP everyone and MARK THEIR MESSAGES and their whole accounts/channels as Spam and/or report their telephone numbers/Whatsapp to the police. We from Autogefuehl will never ask for your bank details. Check out our original channel marked with the verified badge. We do have other official channels, so you can identify them and also subscribe if you like e.g. in your native language: 2nd channel for further reviews: kzbin.info KZbin Shorts chanel: kzbin.info/door/mKVmuPc9wUlLuuhnIeP7_w Spanish: Auto Sensación - Prueba de coches a fondo kzbin.info/door/ZospzTclE4Uf6Jvxbh842Q Arabian: حس السيارات kzbin.info/door/YSBKhMY_UpvcU1_4j8xJcg Korea: 오토센스 kzbin.info/door/6S_5hXKrjJ87xOg9GE_AHA Japan: カー フィーリング kzbin.info/door/8wumItayAPJnk059DLa30g Russian: Анатомия Автомобиля kzbin.info%D0%90%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%8F%D0%90%D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%8F Chinese: 車之感 www.youtube.com/@AutogefuhlChinese BMW theme channel: kzbin.info/door/IUeo4Kjlq7F2XrTwyXUYcA EV theme channel: kzbin.info/door/_KxbHUPuqC8JaUmDV9bGSQ

[@anthonyperini3352]

EV6 also has auto recuperation which is linked to the satnav map and the radar.

[@mclaranist]

Where is Kona???!!!!! This is one of the best EV compact. Tesla, EV6, Ioniq 5 is not ,,compact"

[@meersde]

Also with me: Contentwise an absolute bull's eye, as far as the model selection is concerned. I'm basically leaning towards the EX30 because I like the design and it's so nice and short. However, it has the worst price/performance and you always have to choose the highest trim (and highest price) for some useful features (22kW, 360 degree cam). That´s a nogo for me - from a german point of view.

[@1bluensx]

You do a great job on these videos. Very informative

[@autogefuehl]

Thank you so much! Please recommend / share our channel and our videos 🙏

[@MrCheGuev88]

That video HITS exactly what I want and what i need for my next EV (i am currently in a Kia Niro EV) ! Thanks so much

[@autogefuehl]

highly appreciated! Please recommed!

[@mikapeltokorpi7671]

I saw a XC 40 last weekend in Finland. Looked nice, I thought it was a hybrid. Interesting...

[@EVandPassions]

I also chose ev6 1,5 Year ago and I did 60K km so far without any problems and I am still happy of this decision. If this car has 22 kw AC onboard charger, then it would be perfect but at this moment there only 11kw AC and more then 150kw DC.

[@edwinmelissen9745]

I like the in depth reviews, would have been nice to see some charts and between the different cars a little "bumper" and a finishing of the review before switching. It makes it nicer to look at. Now it looks a bit like your not finished and already switching to the next car.

[@autogefuehl]

Thanks 🙏 there are indicators in the timeline where the timecode is shown with chapter markings plus a chapter list in video description and comment

[@matthewbrown8443]

Smart #3 the pick here imo

[@cip7464]

Is the EX30 available with ventilation at the back?

[@ClaudioAguileraMunoz]

nope

[@clivehunte3026]

Nice review, as regards to the paper bin on the XC40 that would be useful for the parking display tickets that all end up in the door bin.

[@DS-pk4eh]

a slides with comparing table would be very very helpful

[@Transport_Air_Rail_Road]

Ever used turn indicator on rural roads?

[@ellistreloar2047]

Hi Thomas, this was an unnecessarily long episode. Several of these cars are intentionally in a larger car category ie, XC40, EV6, Ioniq 5, Smart #3 and they are positioned to compete with the Model 3. However the Model 3 perhaps belongs here since the internal space is so small. Your statements about the EX30 being the smallest car is also incorrect, the MG4 is smaller. And that the XC40 is more efficient than the EX30? Where are you getting your efficiency data about the EX30? There are no reliable independent driving reviews published with efficiency data for this car. And it is lighter, smaller than the XC40, so physics will prove the EX30 to be more efficient than the XC40.

[@hermanstokbrood]

The base updated Tesla model 3 is just under €40k where I live. A no brainer, if you want the perfect mix of everything.

[@GrandeZizinho]

19:55 the trash can is useful and easy to empty. Would say it's a smart feature

[@antoniopalmero4063]

The EX30 looks great .

[@cmsvmylo]

For 32000 euros the entry level trim MG4 is the obvious choice for me. For 5000 euros more however I would go for the entry level EX30, which although it has a smaller battery than the 64kw MG4, it is overall a better package.

[@geraldh.8047]

Why the Volvo and not the #3 ? Design?

[@maxym777]

in Ukraine, the basic version MG4 costs 24,000 euros)

[@kresimirmilisa5560]

all very good cars.

[@Carautoline]

very nice content

[@MaximilianvonPinneberg]

How is the Hyundai compact? It doesn't fit in most supermarket parking spaces.

[@malikparyaz2891]

The car is so beautiful.

[@garrbunn]

how to stop this channel from auto play list..?

[@syedmoziborrahmandipty4483]

Price please

[@chasf3433]

EV6, Ioniq5 and Tesla 3 are hardly compact!!! Even the Niro is more a midsized car unless of course you live in the USA

[@autogefuehl]

For US it is compact, however as explained I put them in because a) people compare the Model 3 as benchmark since it is often same price as other smaller EVs and b) people also compare Niro vs EV6 and see what they go for

[@Cirom4]

I enjoy Volvo , so much❤

[@andygreyriderGRN]

Do you think they rushed out the Megane? It's all rather rough around the edges.

[@gustavoantoniocoloradoherr156]

que lux por las vistas a mis cnciones gracias ...........

[@IsmailNurulAzizah]

Exalent car

[@paulstein9258]

I liked the XC 40. Poor dealer network in US. I live in a large city and the dealer is 50 miles away. Bought the Toyota Highlander instead. Great dealer network.

[@G-MieInternational]

Nice car

[@jungjaekune]

3m wheel based EV = Compact EV?? 😂😂

[@curiosi-tea-96]

3:09:45 😂 aww

[@Alex-hr2df]

To my eyes the Tesla wins big time! Only aesthetically though.

[@lastminutesolutions]

Hyundai Kia assistance systems were by far the worst and turns itself off at the slightest bends. BMW's was nice when actually activated, but 50% of the times doesn't really engage and turns itself off without any notification when it feels it can't handle the road, which is as dangerous as it gets. Tesla's was the best I've experienced, but very jerky at slow speeds and phantom braking seems to be getting worse. But Tesla's autopilot has been the most robust for me and most trustworthy.

[@mad4tar77]

The IONIQ 5 is huge. Definitely not compact.

[@jungjaekune]

Totally agree with you.. Ioniq5 is 3m wheel based EV..

[@GrandeZizinho]

12:19 omg the ikea joke was so lame 🙈

[@0bzen22]

How many new goddamn cars the world needs. And that's just a portion of a fraction of the EV market, and of course, all SUVs... Jesus!

[@Bigguns761]

Tesla interior is so ugly... too minimalist... it's dead ambiance in there.... look's so cheap...at least they finally added a ambiant light... it's the only thing giving it some ambiance..

[@10secondsrule]

Sure ionic 5 is compact😂😂😂 maybe in the US. It’s a massive car with deceptive design language. Looks like delta integralle but 1.5x the size. Same goes for ev6. They barely fit in parking spaces here in Korea. No wonder they have remote parking assistance as if you park them next to each other you will simply not be able to get in.

[@gustavoantoniocoloradoherr156]

que lux por las vistas a mis canciones gracias ......

[@richard.beaumont]

Polestar?

[@autogefuehl]

compact? Atm not yet. I just put the Model 3 in because it is price wise relevant and people compare it thus also with smaller vehicles. Recent Polestar 2 review here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYmXl5l5jZuLadE

[@jungjaekune]

Ioniq5 is bigger than ix5 by wheel base.

[@stickygeiden]

"Best compact Ev" ... "Tesla model 3" 🤨

[@autogefuehl]

listen to what I am saying :-) The Model 3 is even here often a comparison vehicle because it is at the same price like many EVs that are shorter!

[@Alex-hr2df]

It is a compact EV though.

[@autogefuehl]

Ye for US size it is compact for EU size is mid size

[@greece3210]

Tesla model 3💪🏻

[@gustavoantoniocoloradoherr156]

que lux por las vistas a mis canciones gracis .......

[@gustavoantoniocoloradoherr156]

que lux por las vistas a mis canciones ........

[@Actually-y7j]

Only thing good in the video were the passengers legs

[@venkateshrao437]

The interior trim shown in video looks like that of the floor of the city buses or trams....lol it looks really cheap.

[@front2427]

im 7 foot 3 and my sons 7 foot four.

[@dangergamez]

Best and EV’s doesn’t compact together 😂😂😂

[@stevesimmons6685]

Never

[@alexpaynter6699]

It is strange that you push petroleum based seating materials for non petroleum vehicles. You may call it leatherette or vegan leather but it is vinyl which is derived from petroleum.

[@autogefuehl]

Thank you very much for your interest in this topic. I also bought cars with animal skin leather seats before I did my research and got to know the industry. The most important thing is: With today's modern materials, you have nothing to lose, just to gain. You achieve the same kind of luxury and comfort or even better while having the same or better durability with less impact on humans, animals and the environment. You can use fabric/cloth, microfibre or leatherette. The classic approach is using oil/plastic as source material. Overall, a vehicle contains about 300 kg plastic. A car seat needs about 5 kg plastic. So the overall plastic share for the seats is very low and it is at this moment the most efficient way to produce a car seat. A couple of litres of fuel equals a car seat basically. So if you want to save oil/plastic, rather look at consumption for energy, fuel and heating and to other car parts than the seat. Note that animal skin leather also always contains a plastic coating for durability. However, long-term we should of course find raw oil alternatives. So going further, seats can be made from recyclables (e.g. from PET-bottles or old fishing nets) or even increased share of plant-based materials (like pine oil, canola oil or start-up materials like Pinatex from pineapple leaves or Desertex from cactus fibre or the mixed-plant-based Mirum, so be seen at kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWLEf42bpMano6c). On a calculation base, by ditching animal skin leather from car interiors, the amount of emissions (CO2e) is reduced by 85 (!) % (www.press.bmwgroup.com/africa-dom-easteurope/article/detail/T0403389EN/on-the-market-from-2023:-bmw-and-mini-models-with-vegan-interiors?language=en) - and that is a very conservative calculation. So it is at this moment the most important thing you can do to make car interiors more sustainable. A good example for high-end luxury with ventilated animal free seats is the BMW X7 with Sensafin: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z6G1f56NbtOlqNk And the Kia EV9 with plant-based oil share: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKe7loOHnsSAd80 New leatherette materials can be superior in every aspect, even for cleaning: kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2qXiouAbJeIiqM More and more natural materials are rising: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIO2pIt7o9x7etE Also check out what the animal skin leather industry tried to with our channel: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIHCdKmCocZ5oqs For seeing how the animals are being treated and transported in the global leather industry, watch this footage: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpzNdHSjppaSbqc Note that the footage is genuine and was recorded by a highly decorated investigative journalist in Germany I know myself personally. In a high animal skin grade, the animals are specifically raised for this matter. However even if meat is the "first" misuse case, the hide remains a profitable body part. That means: If manufacturers put animal leather in a car and you demand it as a customer, you give your money to an industry that earns money by oppressing humans, animals and harms the environment, you make them more profitable. Alternatively, you could support industries with your wallet which try to improve the sustainability of materials. Also, if you turn the argument around to "meat is the waste of the leather industry" you realize that it doesn't make sense (and is ethically doubtful) to discuss the primary use of individual body parts of mammals. Mind experiment: You are getting slain down on the street; would it matter to you if it was for your smartphone or for your purse? We cannot change what we have bought in the past, but with more information and compassion we can change how we decide in the future.

[@gregp.7148]

@@autogefuehlthanks for this in-depth response on this topic (car seats)!

[@Javier-qk1cr]

Really well argued! Excellent video Thank you very much!!

[@wilfredvanvalkenburgh2874]

​@@Javier-qk1crA favorite new quote I recently stole is : "I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right".

[@Javier-qk1cr]

​@@wilfredvanvalkenburgh2874So I said!

[@mirokramarich4972]

Tesla model 3. By far.

[@johnmansfield3317]

Except nothing in the Tesla works. Windscreen wipers. Self park. Auto dimming lights. Lane change assist. Nothing in Tesla works properly, always in beta. All the loss of indicator stalks and Uss is bonkers. How many joe average’s will buy a car with no stalks? Plus it’s such a dull looking car though I do love the minimalist interior.

[@Alex-hr2df]

@@johnmansfield3317 so what's your pic within the same price range?

[@geraldh.8047]

@@johnmansfield3317don’t be so negative. Tesla FSD is a solved problem and will be ready in late 2016. Actually working windscreen auto-wipers probably ready in 2036.

[@DreDresChapters]

@@johnmansfield3317tweaking lmao. Tell me youve never owned a tesla without telling me you've never owned a tesla

[@jones9309]

@@johnmansfield3317EVS are trash especially Teslas by far worst drivers

[@donjuable]

EV3 IS COMPACT, NOT EV6

[@AlanTov]

The MG4 is actually a really nice drive. The Niro EV a great all rounder with a good interior. I couldn’t give my money to right wing extremist Musk who supports a terrible Republican party.

[@hesham3326]

👀 🖤🔘🖤

[@SPDATA1]

So boring...😅

[@thoniis]

Awful car.

[@garysu8241]

I think the Kias are ugly

[@zelcpavle5494]

I would buy a V8 😅

[@geraldh.8047]

Isn’t it a little sad to have to refuel constantly instead of starting with a full „tank“ every single day automagically?

[@stevesimmons6685]

I’ll never buy a ev

[@IrisToPan]

Weird flex, but ok. 😂

[@ellistreloar2047]

If your intention was to attract advertising income with this list of EVs I think that you will be disappointed. Like most people I imagine, I skipped to the last chapter only to discover a very poorly informed presenter. Sorry Thomas, you need to take some lessons from TeslaBjorn and raise your EV reviewer game.

[@greatestsportslegends]

WOW... You seem like a spoon full of sugar. Just because you didn't like the video doesn't mean you get to tear it apart and be insulting. They chose to review a number of different vehicles, comparing them on a multitude of levels. And again, just because you aren't interested in a bunch of them doesn't mean it wasn't important to have them all evaluated. That's pretty simple stuff. But you only wanted to see what you wanted to see, like a petulant child. And then, like a petulant child, when it didn't meet your standards you started to cry and complain. Your comment says more about you than it does about the video itself. Sometimes it's important to look at our reflection in order to learn and grow. I hope you do that before you make another comment like this.

[@JBNカーニュース]

Three and half hours of Autogefühl? Finally!

[@autogefuehl]

🙌🙌

[@gustavoantoniocoloradoherr156]

que lux por las vistas a mis canciones gracias ..........