We React To OASIS - Rock 'n' Roll Star

[@TicketTooooRide]

What makes Oasis special is the pure genius of Noel Gallagher´s songwriting. The amount of well-written tracks on those first two albums is beyond anything a songwriter could ever dream of. The focus doesn't necessarily lay on the instrumentation with Oasis, but more on the pure melody of the song itself. To assume that Liam is the only relevant member seems a bit naive when you literally have one of the most highly praised songwriters of all time. Id recommend doing "Dont Look Back In Anger" next.

[@jeemywilson]

Look I love Noel, seen him as recently as June but the truth is without Liam nobody heard any of these songs.

[@TicketTooooRide]

@@jeemywilsonOf course but to say that Liam is the only reason for the bands success is pretty ludicrous

[@jeemywilson]

@@TicketTooooRide I know what you mean but it’s still accurate. Liam would have made it singing any songs. I don’t think Noel would have, people forget Noel was late 20s roadie with a catalogue of songs nobody had heard until Liam started singing them. Both great but Liam is the reason we have heard all these songs.

[@bucky7162]

Liam could have made it without Noel, The Rain weren't great but they were far from shit before Noel joined. Noel on the other hand would have been lost at sea without Liam in the beginning! And this is coming from a massive Noel fan. Noel was the genius in Oasis without a doubt but it was and always will be Liams band. Also a lot of Noels songs were literally stolen verbatim, right down to the melody and lyrics. Go look up the real peoples songs "feel the pain" and listen to the chorus. He also stole Rockin' Chair from the real people and another few tunes.

[@TicketTooooRide]

@@bucky7162 None of them would have made it without each other. The Rain was below average at best. They wouldn’t have made it past the Boardwalk. A lot of Liam’s vocal development came as a result of the improved songwriting (Noel said this himself). If you’ve read the Supersonic book you get a sense of how much Noel carried the band. While the others didn’t give a shit, he kind off held it all together. Liam would never be disciplined enough to run the band himself. If Noel never joined Oasis he wouldn’t have been as driven with his songwriting. Joining the band gave him the motivation he needed, but without Liam singing his songs they obviously wouldn’t be as good. So both really needed each other. As for Noel borrowing stuff, yes that’s true but the biggest hits Wonderwall, Don’t Look Back In Anger, Champagne Supernova, Slide Away, Rock N Roll Star have nothing stolen melody wise. And even the things he borrowed, he made it his own and improved it tremendously. It’s not like he stole full finished songs, he just took little bits and put them in.

[@jasonq111]

The boy is wrong. Noel is an absolutely impeccable song writer. They are legends. U guys need to listen to at least 30 more songs to get a full picture.

[@alambyant]

Oasis are cool as f**k ✌️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@davidl9771]

Oasis were so big because they were an antidote to all the cheesy boy bands that dominated at the time

[@TheRetroManRandySavage]

Play your boy headshrinker or cast no shadow. Two great, but totally different sounding oasis songs. If your boy doesn't like either of those then there is no hope for him.🤣👍

[@EJdub]

American teens don't seem to be into much rock and roll anymore, might be wrong but never really see it much.

[@reactionextraction]

I’m trying my best here, ha 😎

[@SJ19_998]

Cast no shadow is an absolute gem

[@Tim1999]

Noel Gallagher also sings some of the songs. Please react to 'Don't Look Back In Anger,' which is one of their all time classics, which Noel sings. Noel wrote 90% of the songs, so for me Oasis was not just about Liam. Thanks for doing more Oasis.

[@runningsuperska]

Oasis were a breath of fresh air in the mid 90's.

[@Shakermakerukuk]

Give them a chance, I’ve been an oasis fan for as long as I can remember. Seen them 3 times, saw Noel and high flying birds twice and Liam with Richard Ashcroft play. Check out some live acoustic stuff with Noel. Another band I recommend is the stereophonics, the lead singer Kelly Jones has an amazing voice

[@LambriniSupernova]

Great reaction check out, The Masterplan and half the world away

[@DerekDerekDerekDerekDerekDerek]

Noel does some really nice guitar work on some of the songs and his songwriting is what makes Oasis. The drums are really good too but yes overall there's not much instrumentally.

[@emmetlynch14]

This band was the 90s in the UK & Europe. America doesn’t know what it’s missing

[@biblical1982]

You should have played the live version

[@william2603]

Before digging into Oasis's music, I shared the same thought with the guy on the left. I didn't know why people loved Oasis as Wonderwall was the only song I heard from them, and it was just "okay" to me. Liam sure stood out when you first listened to the band, and I agree the sound of the instrument was not "exquisite" -- but the rawness of it made the band so attractive. That rawness made you feel related. Noel wrote compelling lyrics and composed catchy melodies. Combining Liam's vocals, Oasis made some of the best songs in history.

[@andy9042]

You also should of done a live version

[@tashrif46]

You guys have to do Columbia and Slide Away from this album as well.

[@sagan666]

Do Talk Tonight. Or the Masterplan.

[@imnosuperman9935]

Oasis - The Masterplan! Great channel lads 🇬🇧🇺🇲 Edit: Also if you'd like, check out Oasis- Cast No Shadow, a song written by the Gallagher bros for their good friend Richard Ashcroft, the ex lead singer of The Verve.

[@lewistravel1]

Both brothers have extensive solo stuff too ..

[@scotty6388]

Lol do you not give the lad pocket money if he isn’t on the videos? Looks like he’d rather be anywhere else

[@tashrif46]

You guys need to react to Falling Down by Oasis.

[@andrewbeardsworth5461]

The guy on the left,maybe needs his hearing testing..Oasis was the best band

[@mrd268]

I like Oasis but they are far from the best band and he's right Liam stood out in that group.

[@Liamnesque]

Masterpiece, mad fer it

[@davidpearson6785]

Liam is an amazing singer. Don't feel guilty for having your own opinion ty it's as valid as anybody else's opinion., In fact, if Liam heard you say the band was just him being amazing with 3 other people in the background, Liam's ego would LOVE that 🤣🤣 Listen to Noel singing the importance of being idle then you will think wow Noel is amazing too. P.s this is definitely not in my top 20 oasis songs either , my least favourite song on that album

[@reactionextraction]

Not in your top 20? 😳 yikes I missed on this selection, ha

[@davidpearson6785]

@@reactionextraction only because they have so many incredible songs 👍

[@jeemywilson]

Go to do a live performance. Wembley 2001 cigarettes and alcohol would be a good place to start.

[@zak6209]

You should listen to a song that Noel sings

[@ianmac3648]

Aye if you want a sleep 💤

[@zak6209]

@@ianmac3648 funny guy

[@msunderstood1100]

I always skip the songs Noel sings. I just don't think he has a very strong voice. Yes he's a great songwriter and an okay guitarist, but singing...not so much. JMO. I do like his new song Easy Now, the only problem is I find myself wishing Liam was singing it. Cheers!

[@dontletherspeak7575]

Check out "The Girl in the Dirty Shirt".

[@BlackpoolAl]

Hey guy's, its time to visit NEW Abba....... Don#t Shut Me Down, New Song After 40 Years!!!!!!!

[@neilj6322]

Kids hey....again. Please do the reactions on your own dad

[@BelfastManUtdTherapy]

Kid on the left always seems like he had an ex gf/bf whose favourite band was Oasis, but cheated on him or something. Always seems tense, even stressed during oasis reactions. im sure im wrong just a wee observation 🙂

[@startracker5895]

This young kid doesn’t know what we talking about! 🙄

[@msunderstood1100]

I completely agree with your assessment. Liam is what draws you in. Noel may have written the songs, but Liam was the star of the show.

[@EJdub]

Nothing really special about Oasis? American teens need to stick to rap

[@tashrif46]

6:13 okay good band? No they were a great band. 7:03 I cant believe he said instrumentation is mid🤦🤦🤦🤦. Noel Gallagher even said that the instrumentation were tailored to fit Liam's voice.

[@48Ender48]

*Slap*

[@davidl9771]

Try acquiesce

[@tashrif46]

Young fellow needs to listen more. Oasis is miles, miles better, then whatever garbage music is being produced today. So saturated and everybody sounds the same. As they progress the instrumentation gets more complex. God knows what he will say when he reaches Be Here Now 😂😂😂

[@andrewrodigan7102]

There's no hope with this young generation.

[@LgFaver]

maybe a change of pace would be welcome by your angst seeking/thinks Maneskin is the coolest thing since sliced bread/too cool for school/probably thinks Radiohead are legends LOL/tortured soul of a son... so feed him some newer Oasis and play him "Gas Panic" or "(Probably)All in my Mind" try those.

[@jemxs]

Ty's opinion is spot on, the music is good, songs are good, Liam's twang is interesting at first but is tiresome after awhile. I loved Definitely Maybe in the 90s but never listen to it in decades(oh I'm old). Ofc the Michael Hutchence incident didn't help their longevity in my world.

[@reactionextraction]

Understood 😎 I find myself listening to Oasis more & more just because its become sooo much an electronic music world out there & not much legit classic 90's Rock that is this captivating. Sometimes ya just need badass guitar vocal driven rock as change up. HA

[@MrBillyboyroge]

@@reactionextraction try some bad ass bass fused with jazz chords, a funky drummer, live DJ and awesome horn section kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYvaY4qHrt2boLc 🔥

[@shuttz98]

I think if it was sung by a different vocalist you'd realise how good the band are

[@Idkwhattomakethis12]

Kids incredible boring