Were the Nazis and Muslims Allies? | History of the Middle East 1930 - 1939 - 17/21

[@thesenate1844]

Shoutout to King Mohammed V of Morocco, despite being a subject of Vichy France, he refused to extradite any Jews or enforce any antisemitic laws, declaring all Moroccans as under his protection

[@huriale1617]

The Mosque of Paris, build to honor the muslim troops who fought during the first world war, also saved some jews during the Occupation.

[@reyson01]

So how come a larger % of Jews in Germany are still around compared to those in Morocco?

[@Followers_of_Tawheed]

@@huriale1617 This is part of our religion to disavow and fight tyrants such as hitler

[@jonathanwilliams1065]

@@Followers_of_Tawheed and yet so many are cheering for the massacre of Jews

[@wat9177]

the last righteous king of morocco

[@Jetpackpokemon]

This must have taken a lot of research, great job!! Thank you for helping me understand this type of history more

[@josecipriano3048]

Many in India sympathized with the nazis as well. Gandhi amongst them.

[@Sagar-vv9gd]

For west colonisation by France, Britain is good but Nazis are bad 🤡

[@bigbootros4362]

​@@Sagar-vv9gdBoth are bad, but the Nazis were a lot lot worse.

[@عليياسر-ف4ن9ك]

​@@bigbootros4362France: How did you know if they were killing millions of people like me?

[@DirkusTurkess]

@@عليياسر-ف4ن9ك Should google what he thought about South Africans.

[@barahng]

Mein Kampf is still quite popular in India.

[@SpartanStick]

Jabzy’s vids getting wilder and wilder

[@llamagames6803]

You play stick war 3?

[@SpartanStick]

@@llamagames6803 ye

[@arooster6951]

As someone who has planned to create their dissertation based off ‘Operation Mammoth’ and the prior German racial views of the Kurds, I do have to thank you for mentioning previously about the rare Hitler quote in his table talks. The most important part is the big difference between being called “Aryan” vs “Germanic”, since Aryan is a very broad term which originates from the term for noble in the Mitanni Empire (and possibly the Hurrians). Nowadays, modern day neo nazis warp the idea of “Aryan” into coinciding with “White” when this idea of a white race was mainly mistranslations or based mainly on Rosenburg and Himmlers views on race. Now to be called Germanic? that MUST hint at the fact that the creation of an independent Kurdistan would fall under the area of the “Greater German Reich”, of course this is just a theory, but even the Germans like Günther considered the Persians as a “darkened race” and Von Luschan concluded that the idea of the “Nordic ruling class of Ancient Iran” were not Persians but Kurds (Von Luschan 1911 and Günther 1927) Once again, you are literally the only youtuber who has discovered a quote which others including myself helped popularize back in 2021, I can’t help but thank you. (p.s. Sherif Pasha’s letters to Mussolini and his accepted refuge in Italy provide a new perspective on a Italian-Kurdish friendship)

[@TimurKhan-dn5vx]

Turks already destory our friendship both against kurds italians and germans.

[@NathanDudani]

pLaNnEd To CrEaTe

[@arooster6951]

@@NathanDudani​​⁠I’ll personally message you and link the video as soon as it is published. You’re gonna have to wait until May 2025, but i’m sure you’ll enjoy it. The dissertation proposal has already been submitted if that helps :)

[@Bladieblah]

It is common knowledge that with "Aryan race" the Nazi's were referring to blue eyed, blonde haired, white people. Whether that term has other usages historically by different actors is completely irrelevant because we know how the nazi's used it, that is just a basic fact of history

[@kanaxu1747]

Just 9 minutes into, but it makes me happy to hear you quoting "Atatürk in the Nazi imagination" by Stefan Ihrig. It's really an underrated work with not enough attention

[@kaanalpkaratas6091]

Ataturk did not ally with Mussolini as Mussolini was seeking Turkey as a part of his Mare Nostrum. Ataturk even showed up to Italian diplomats while being dressed with Marshall uniform, militarily denouncing Italy.

[@johnnyfives5416]

That because he and the ottoman turk fought italy invasion of libya and continue helping the local resistance even after the war was lost and italy occupational.

[@lordgrunwalder1607]

​@@johnnyfives5416well yes, and + because itally straight up claiming territory from Turkey 💀 it wasnt just a "old rivalship". İtally was straight up threatening Turkey

[@kalatiso5541]

Video lacks so many details, like the pogroms in Istanbul and how they were dismantled by ataturk and their leaders executed allowing the 15k Jews to come back to Istanbul to their property

[@SabracadabrO]

He didn’t “align”cuz the he knew the fascists would do to them what they had in plan for Jews,stop kidding yourselves..

[@raptorhacker599]

@@kalatiso5541 well cemal was himself a doner jew

[@zhcultivator]

Please consider leaving the list of sources for this video available so we can know where the information for your videos are coming from. Thanks as always for your videos.

[@luishernandezblonde]

To be honest, Muslims were a significant group of sympathisers for the Axis in general. As much as the Nazis enjoyed their backing, the Japanese also received significant backing by them, in particular during the early days of the WW2 in today's Xinjiang (among Uyghurs, Uzbeks and Kazakhs), Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Mindanao (today's Philippines), Indochina and Thailand, Central Asia and South Asia.

[@TP_ERK]

it is like finland being an ally of axis. just protecting their lands from soviet union and nothing more.

[@luishernandezblonde]

@@TP_ERK Not just only against the Soviets, many of them supported the Axis against China and Britain.

[@kraijom319]

Even Japan's native irregular fighters in Indonesia were commanded by islamic clerics

[@davidbowie5023]

German-Japanese jihadism was crazy. I couldn't imagine this happening.

[@luishernandezblonde]

@@kraijom319 The Japanese did even attempt to create a pro-Japanese Islamic state in Central Asia. Long even before Hitler sought to materialise alliance with the Muslims, the Japanese nearly achieved this task. That's why during WW2, the Soviets and Chinese had to carefully patrol the region due to the pro-Japanese attitude among these Central Asian Turkomens.

[@onatdeveci5502]

12:22 This one is false. As a Hatay native, being of Alawite descent, I can very confidently say that the people the Turkish government sent to Hatay were refugees/migrants from Hatay and it's surrounding region (meaning places like Afrin, Aleppo and Idlib) that were ethnically Turkish. Through my friend's family, I actually have a letter that a government sent to refugees from Hatay (and it's surrounding regions); saying that if they went to vote in the Referandum, their travel expenses and accommodation expenses would be subsidized by the state. The letter then added that what they did would be considered great service to the Homeland.

[@onatdeveci5502]

Also Jabzy; you've forgot to mention Greeks of the city, whom constituted %≈2 of the city's population. I also suggest you not group Alawites in with Arabs, since Alawism of Nusayris is an ethnic religion. Many Alawites, such as Hafez al-Assad's father for example, were against the annexation of the Alawi State into Syria. Many Alawites in fact voted in favor of annexation into Turkey, generally urban Alawites. Rural Alawites (then the majority of the Alawite population) did not participate in the referandum. This has the effect of magnifying the Turkish Turnout, since, at the time majority of the locals you've classified as Arabs were of Nusayri/Alawite origin.

[@intellectualcucumber]

Do Alawites consider themselves Muslims?

[@onatdeveci5502]

@@intellectualcucumber Depends on the Alawite.

[@SnubbenTroddeHanVarCool]

@@intellectualcucumber Alawism and Alevism are completely two different things. But unfortunately very often confused due to similar names.

[@LeixWUxLong]

One mistake bud, Afrin is ethnically Kurdi including the Ezidis.

[@Torarz01FIN]

Just finished the last episode. Perfect timing.

[@rursus8354]

So the answer is ... not applicable. There were Fascists worldwide, some Christian, some Muslim, some belonging to the Nazi religion. The national problems inherent in Western Colonialism caused great problems though. And there some Muslim imperialist visionaries occurred, and some other Arab nationalists creating a fictional Arab nationality.

[@jonathanwilliams1065]

Many of the Christian fascists opposed Hitler, and some, like Metaxas, actively fought against him and had pro British policies before the war

[@rursus8354]

@ottopotatum5775 Short answer is no. It is so simplified, that even you can understand it.

[@SusCalvin]

Nasser and a few others would try to keep pan-atabic ideas going.

[@SusCalvin]

​@ottopotatum5775Germany keeps recruiting volunteer battalions. They always seem to scrounge up someone from Belgium or across the Ostfront or Poland.

[@C-Farsene_5]

@ottopotatum5775 you can’t call all hot takes as offensive bro, some are just wrong

[@tacticalboii4302]

Muslim divisions germany had 13. Handschar Free Arabian legion Azerbaijani legion Idel ural legion (tatars) Skanderbeg division Sandzak battalion North caucasian legion Osttürkische SS

[@kazmahamza3115]

Too many foreign soldiers for a racist state if you ask me

[@ismaelnasser6360]

Enemy of my Enemy is my friend (uk and france ) ​@@kazmahamza3115

[@dillanspec4]

@@kazmahamza3115 muslims never destroyed europe and germany that was jews

[@tacticalboii4302]

@@kazmahamza3115 non european divisions usually were just canon fodder

[@mrmr446]

While of course the allies had a significant portion of the Indian Army, about ten percent of the Soviet Army and quite a sizeable French North African contingent with a smaller West African contingent, no doubt there were others in all far outnumbering those you cite.

[@poltergijstt]

Please never stop making content

[@KennedyJr2024]

And he should always have the same music

[@icysaracen3054]

Feels like I just watch the worlds greatest poker game

[@ottomanosman2463]

To be honest, as a Turkish person myself, I am fascinated to study about supports from the Muslim world to Japan and Germany here. The support for Germany prior and during WW2 is well-known as you explained (German officials wooing Muslims of Palestine, the Balkans and Iraq), but the support for Japan is somewhat overlooked. In fact, during Japan's rapid conquest of Southeast Asia, the Muslims in modern-day Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Indochina hailed the Japanese conquest; whereas Indian and Sri Lankan Muslims rebelled against Britain; whereas Central Asian Muslims (in both Soviet and Chinese parts) were excited with the prospect of an Islamic-Japanese alliance to fight Russia and China. Japan's puppet armies in Asia included a lot of Muslim groups, such as Azad Hind (for India), Thai Muslim corps and the Islamic battalions of Dutch East Indies. At least before the war turned tie in favour of the Allies. I feel the German and Japanese impacts have never truly faded to even today, and still very vivid.

[@teamjam2863]

Muslims were divided in sea about the issue. Main stream nationalism hated the Japanese and Western powers. The Japanese committed genocide against some Muslim population . Those who supported the Japanese were either desperate or promised independence which was a lie.

[@kalatiso5541]

Same arabs that turned their blind eye on the Turks

[@SCOTLANDforEVER12976]

This is wrong you know that Muslims india is who started and supported to stand against colonizer, amd there is no evidence of supporting what kind of support you means? If you don't know the history of Islam qhen they ruled they did nring justice to its region and that by itself is negative side because they will think that everyone is like them you have the historical records of when Mongolia attacked them or when the al andalusia fall so you can see the full picture there

[@yazovgaming]

Azad Hind were Hindu Nationalists LMAO

[@edmurks236]

Which types of Muslims are we talking about?

[@zhcultivator]

Please Jabzy, include sources in your videos please

[@mistymoonshine897]

Mussolini was not antisemite and a quarter of italian Jews were members of the fascist party. some anti-Jewish laws were passed in 1938 for the purpose of an alliance with Germany but were never really enforced. in short, it's not strange that Jews were working with Mussolini. at the time, Germany and Italy were not friends, they almost went to war in 1934 over Austria.

[@smortv9629]

It’s really intresting because the tripartite pact was more of an alliance of convenience then an actual alliance, Bulgaria also notably didn’t give its Jews to Germany

[@SusCalvin]

Italy is under practical German occupation at the end of the war.

[@Alte.Kameraden]

It's why I'd love to see more people remove Nazism from Fascism. Nazism even predates Fascism. Nazism evolved from German Socialism and goes as far back as the 19th century meanwhile Fascism evolved from Marxist Syndicalism and evolved over the span of the Great War into a new movement. One is built around the idea of the Totalitarian Corporate State and the other a Social Democrats Racial Religion were the Bourgeoisie are the J*ws and the end goal is the racialization of the means of production. 😂

[@davidjacobs8558]

I heard some where the surname "Mussolini" derived from Muslim. ie, his ancestor was a Muslim.

[@SusCalvin]

@@smortv9629 In the German ideal vision, post-war Europe would have been Germany and a bunch of client states with second-class people. And others just depopulated and colonized with germans.

[@scorpionjaxxer339]

Crazy. Never thought funny mustache man would think we are pure blooded aryans…

[@OfficialUKGov]

we are 🗿

[@ReaperCH90]

If you don't know it, you should watch a video about what the Nazis actually believed (especially Himmler). They send researchers to check if Tibetans were maybe the original Aryans.

[@Adir-Yosef]

he pretty much picked the name from Iran so that's not as surprise

[@dik943]

Only the aristocracy

[@TreyMessiah95]

Iran is litteraly called "The Land of the Aryans" Are you dense?

[@CarlosPEnis]

Everytime I watch/hear something about Ataturk I always picture an older Turk patting him on the back and saying "ata Turk" 😂

[@onatdeveci5502]

Great video as always!

[@Chestermcfly420]

Yes there are plenty of pictures with Hitler and the grand mufti Palestine

[@stephensdygert7600]

Good point. The father of modern Palestinian nationalism AL-AMAN-HUSSANI met with Hitler and Himmler in 1941&1943 topic of discussion was the Final solution. There are historical news reels of these meetings for anyone to see and hear. Himmler of all people thought this guy was extreme. Himmler wanted to deport all European Jews to return Judea/Samaria/Israel. He never used the term "Palestine".

[@MausyeetOfficial]

The most 3 am video i would get fr

[@nicbahtin4774]

27:12 lol some things don't change "Jews cant be thrown in the sea" Arabs: "must be a Zionist"

[@ferdinanddaratenas3447]

Well, they have been trying for a century but they always walk away running off to the UN asking Israel to show restraint. Go for round 526 I suppose?

[@EgyptianChiefKeef]

That wasn’t the thought of most people back then. Muslims and Jews lived fine and then Zionism ruined it. Most Muslims don’t hate Jews and vice versa but to paint it this way is stupid and shows you’re uneducated. Also, the state of Israel has been found guilty of numerous warcrimes and is probably going to get a very small punishment for it. Anyways, please do research before commenting something stupid.

[@king.g-l1g]

To be honest.. The Arabs say Jews...the one who say and promoted "Zionists, not Jews" are the communists xD

[@cendistbenjamin7066]

What is Zionist? a supporter of Zionism; a person who believes in the development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel. how could you separate a Jewish person from this? do you think you don’t believe your own self determination and protection do you believe that you don’t deserve to exist?

[@nicbahtin4774]

@@cendistbenjamin7066 Calm down I'm a proud Israeli zionist myself even believe Khane is right. I just lough at the blind Arab hate that even this series exposes. How in their eyes you can't be a decent person without advocating to throw jews to the sea. How jews legaly coming and buying and developing land that even they enjoy cause of the increase of uppertonity is somehow evil. I love this series cause it shows how even during the rule of the ottoman empire you didn't have peace How Arabs fought among themselves.

[@onatdeveci5502]

8:18 Although there existed a campaign to make the citizens speak Turkish, it was not mandated nor enforced by the government. The campaign you are referring to "Vatandaş, Türkçe Konuş"; was organized by university students, Türk Ocakları (which were mostly aligned with but independent from the government), or the local CHF parti chapters. There were instances where laws were passed (mostly in western Anatolia) that mandated speaking Turkish in public. It should be remembered that there was no organized effort to coerce or force the citizenry into speaking Turkish, both legislative and practical action varied by locality. For this I don't think it to be correct to connect the "Vatandaş, Türkçe Konuş" campaign directly with Atatürk.

[@davidprosser7278]

What surprises me is that Mussolini's government didn't invite oil prospectors into the bits of desert Italy colonized.

[@italianmapperchris3168]

Italy did send geologist Ardito Desio to Libya, to search for oil and other natural resources. He did find oil and in collaboration with the Italian petroleum company Agip there were plans to begin extraction. However, this was in late 1938 and operations were suspended once Italy entered WW2

[@AMR_k400]

Yeah their are a bunch of fossil fuels and iron ore in Ethiopia aswell , could've helped the axis alot.

[@6foot8jesuspilledpureblood82]

Iranians are Aryans not Arabs and it is not a traditional Muslim country.

[@Kuwait_Anezi]

Iranians are Indians

[@honsuaman8743]

not worry, most Muslims do know that Iran was never Muslim and Persia neither

[@noname-k9t3e]

Indo europeans ;)​@@Kuwait_Anezi

[@anon-iraq2655]

First book written in persian and 99% after it, were written by a Muslim :)

[@jaif7327]

did he say that?

[@ericcogley457]

Very informative. Thank you.

[@whosthatguy8396]

What is the background music especially around 14:30

[@zhcultivator]

Good video, I just wish you put in sources somewhere for us to look at.

[@cyborgchicken3502]

The sources of this are for some reason very difficult to find online especially if you're using Google Chrome and here on KZbin.... Jabzy's video is one of the few I managed to find regarding the topic.... Makes you think there's some kind of censorship going on regarding this info.... Especially with the Israel Palestine conflict going on

[@ryanmoore6259]

It's a mixed bag; the Mufti was considered a joke until after the war, and even many who did support the Nazis did so more because they hated the british and french occupiers

[@melm295]

No he wasn’t. His nephew Arafat continued To Fight Hitler’s war w help from Nazis who fled to Middle East.

[@Bladieblah]

He wouldn't be there leader if he was considered a joke, that is just not how these things work. Stop the mental gymnastics

[@pm.meowth4850]

That’s not true, they 100% supported nazism, there was a Muslim SS division you have to be a fanatic to join them, supported a white man’s genocide now it’s gone full circle… history is crazy

[@pm.meowth4850]

That’s not true, they 100% supported nazism, there was a Muslim SS division you have to be a fanatic to join them, supported a white man’s genocide now it’s gone full circle… history is crazy

[@zhcultivator]

Please consider leaving the list of sources for this video available so we can know where the information for your videos are coming from. Thanks as always for your videos..

[@EgyptianChiefKeef]

This is actually a pretty interesting topic you’ve brought up. While initially the Nazis were somewhat successful in trying to gain Muslim support by promising “liberation from Britain and France”. They were eventually unsuccessful because more and more people found out about the Nazi crimes and some even joined the allies. The majority of Muslims that served in WW2 that weren’t from countries that were allies, joined the allies not the Nazis.

[@jonathanwilliams1065]

That’s straight up false Most Muslims may have fought for the Allies because they were from allied countries, but those from non allied countries, and many from allied countries, flocked to the SS Hitler’s best pall was the grand mufti of Jerusalem, who would try to finish what he started just 2 years later

[@EgyptianChiefKeef]

@@jonathanwilliams1065 he was initially somewhat successful but ended up unsuccessful. There were very little volunteers from countries that weren’t under British and French rule and he had no reason to appeal to those who weren’t under British and French rule. I’ve meet Muslims who lived during ww2 and they weren’t pro nazi. The majority of them were actually fascinated by the soviets and the Soviet army which is what led to many Muslim countries almost becoming communist. You mean to tell me they were pro Nazi and communist at the same time? Please read or study

[@SusCalvin]

​@@EgyptianChiefKeefThe Soviets would keep a lot of influence in places like Egypt through the cold war. A lot of these places still have local communist or socialist parties.

[@EgyptianChiefKeef]

@@SusCalvin Had Turkey not joined NATO, communism could have spread in the Middle East

[@minestar2247]

@@jonathanwilliams1065 what do you mean by "finishing the job 2 years later" that's absolutely unrelated

[@hondoplays9461]

Stefan Ihrig's "Ataturk in the Nazi Imagination" is a great read on this topic.

[@EdwardNortonSSS]

Better explanation : some did, some did absolutely not.

[@zhcultivator]

Please put in lists of sources in your videos in the future....

[@guystevens5739]

Just Google it yourself.

[@happyveganearthlings]

This series you have going on with the Middle East and the surrounding regions is quite detailed and nuanced, which is a rare find indeed and I greatly appreciate it. I would love it if one day you did a similar deep dive into the region of the “American South”, (good luck to you to define that without a bunch of people arguing which state should be and shouldn’t be considered “The South” lol. I think a lot of people associate the south with being overwhelmingly long established African American and Anglo-Celtic American (I know Anglo-Celtic is a termed used in Australia, less so in America. But I think a term that fits due to people thinking of White Southerners as coming almost exclusively from the British Isles) and forget the other groups of people…funnily enough the inhabitants of the lands before large streams of European and African arrivals. You have the Lumbees of North Carolina, the Melungeons of Appalachia, groups considered “Tri-Racial isolates”, canary islanders of Louisiana, the Vietnamese on the Gulf Coast, a long established Mexican community in New Orleans, Charleston once having the largest Jewish population in America, the Texan German dialect, the Marshall Islanders in Arkansas and that is just scratching the surface!

[@Alte.Kameraden]

To be honest Fascism and Nazism should be split from eachother. Most Fascist movements rejected the Racial Variation of Nationalism that dominated Nazism. Most Fascist movements that did adopted it modeled themselves after the Nazis not the Italian Fascist. So the fact Nazism is considered Fascism is more of a misinterpretation of the time that has echoed into the present. TIKhistory has two good videos on Mosley which describes this divide quite well. How Mosley modeled his movement off the Italians but was in direct hostility with the British Union of Fascist under Mosley and the Imperial Fascist League which modeled itself on Nazism.

[@Foxarium]

It is reasonable to understand National Socialism as the very unique and organic movement it was. But it's unfair to completely disconnect it with Fascism, which is its core political philosophy. During the 1920s and 1930s, the main thing that divided Fascist movements (including National Socialism) were more so national interests than anything, of course there were rather minut ideological divisions, which were also influenced by national interests. The reality is that you won't really find any philosophical differences between Fascism and National Socialism when you realize that Fascism is not an ideology, but a political philosophy that movements connect to. Most people attempt to divide National Socialism and Fascism by utilizing Italian Fascism as the differentiating factor, but that falls flat since Italian Fascism is the Italian realization of Fascism, rather than the all-sayer of Fascism itself - and obviously, Mussolini is no Marx of Fascism; Fascism has no Marx. That being said, all European Fascist movements (Even Italian Fascism) at the time recognized the reality of race and embraced it. Though, not to the extend the National Socialists did as they were Germanic-centred and believed that the Germanic race should be the leaders of the white race. Speaking as a Fascist myself.

[@Alte.Kameraden]

@@Foxarium Well that was a load of garbage. Italian Fascism is the "Realization" of Fascism itself. THEY INVENTED IT. The Nazis didn't call themselves Fascist, evolved independently, and built their system off the Nordic Social Democratic Model, sure they borrowed from the Italian Fascist but so did they also borrow from the Marxist. Hitler himself even stated Fascism may work for Italy but will not work for Germany. When the Germans took control of Northern Italy in 1943 they didn't re-establish the Italian Fascist Party, but created a completely new government under National Socialist beliefs. The Nazis also oppressed and arrested the Fatherland Front leaders, ie the Austrian Fascist Party. The British who adopted Italian Fascism vs those who adopted National Socialist beliefs also clashed with each other in Britain. These are not the same ideologies. Claiming your a Fascist doesn't change that. Definitely being most modern Fascist have been poisoned by post war Nazi and Fascist Larpers who sometimes even belief Marxist propaganda about Fascism. Most famous example of this is National Bolshevism which literally just recreated Nazism, because they assumed Nazism was Capitalist at it's core. So removed the "Capitalist" elements which never existed to begin with. This same confusion is the primary reason the British Union of Fascist and the Imperial Fascist League basically went to war with each other in Britain. British Union of Fascist adopted the Italian system while the Imperial Fascist League Modeled themselves off National Socialism. Both ideologies directly clashed with each other. The only reason the Imperial Fascist League called themselves Fascist was because in Britain everyone called the Nazis Fascist. So similar to the British Fascist (another earlier group) they called themselves Fascist without realizing what Fascism was, btw the British Fascist under Rotha Orman were literally pro capitalist feminist who were anti Marxist, they never bothered to learn what Fascism was but can be best described as Larpers. Which is a common thread. You even see this today with the book Socialism of Duty, where the author literally uses Julius Evola as a bridge to marry Fascist and Nazi beliefs together... basically EXACTLY WHAT THE MARXIST DID... like Umberto Echo, and the author of Socialism of Duty considers himself a Fascist, yet believes Marxist propaganda on Fascism.

[@wowfly6485]

​@@Foxarium The first national socialist party which was from Czechia (biggest influence on German Nazism) predates the first national syndicalist party which was from France, National Socialism (although not Hitlers particular brand of it) predates national syndicalism. Fascism means Trade Unionism and Syndicalism is trade unionism hence why Mussolini's party was called the National Fascist Party, Mussolini said "What I am, I owe to Sorel.", Sorel was an influential French Syndicalist who influenced and supported Mussolini. In terms of economy (Keynesian Influenced) Socialism(nazi) and Trade Unionism(syndicalism/Fascism/Corporatism) are two different economic systems. And in terms of Nationalism, Hitlers Nationalism was based on race, Mussolini's was not race based see this quote, "Race? It is a feeling, not a reality: ninety-five percent, at least, is a feeling. Nothing will ever make me believe that biologically pure races can be shown to exist today". Philosophically Italian Fascism is almost purely Hegelian whereas Hitlers Nazism has influences such as the Völkisch movement, Hegel(to a lesser extent), Darwin and Nietzsche (Hitlers Nazism is also much more spiritual then Fascism). The Austrian nazi party was in violent and political conflict with the Austrian fascist party with Mussolini supporting the Fascists (including military support) and so the Austrian Fascists (Vaterländische Front) made the Nazi party illegal in Austria. The fatherland front like the Italian Fascists did not accept the racial ideology of Hitler. The idea that Nazis were Fascist is Marxist propaganda to try and make nazism not thought of as socialist. Marxist Socialism/Communism(international), National Socialism, Revolutionary Syndicalism(trade unionism) and National Fascism(trade unionism/corporatism) are all related ideologies based on the idea of a public sector (government or trade union) control over the economy. Marxism & Revolutionary Syndicalism are for the workers of the world, Hitlers Nazism for the German Race and Austrian/Italian/English/Spanish Fascism are for the Nation. TLDR: Nazism is not Fascist because National Socialism(pre german) came before Fascism(National Syndicalism), they have different economic systems, different philosophies, different conceptions of Nation/Race and the Spiritual aspect of Nazism is unique to German Nazism. National Socialists and Fascists were enemies in Austria with Italy initially supporting the Fascists against the Nazis.

[@Foxarium]

​@@wowfly6485 You wasted your time writing an essay and ended up creating a nothingburger. Ultimately you fail to properly understand a basic element of Fascism by thinking that Italian Fascism is the all-sayer of Fascism as an entirety when it very much isn't. Fascism will never be and was never intended to be a single unified movement tied to one nation or another. The very fact I addressed this issue in my former comment and you still ended up making this mistake is nothing short of actually embarrassing. Anyways, the points you make about Italian Fascism are not only irrelevant, but downright wrong and you don't even understand Italian Fascism.

[@wowfly6485]

@@Foxarium Don't you realize that Fascism is an Italian term coming from the word fasci or fascio which are unions(trade or otherwise). I agree Fascism can take many forms but National Fascism itself is the Italian name for National Syndicalism (syndicate is french fasci is italian) The Czech National Social Party was created in 1897, the Austrian DAP (who were already nationalist & socialist) which was the predecessor of the Deutsche Nationalsozialistische Arbeiterpartei in Austria was founded in 1903. The word Fascism was used for the first time in 1915. Please explain to me how National Socialism is Fascism when National Socialism is older then Fascism. And then kindly explain to me how National Socialism is Syndicalist. Ask yourself why the Austrian Nazis and Austrian Fascists were vehement ideological enemies of each other when they were both Nationalists from the same nation and supposedly both Fascist by your understanding.

[@jayfreechavez0000]

Great educational content

[@mrmr446]

While of course the allies had a significant portion of the Indian Army, about ten percent of the Soviet Army and quite a sizeable French North African contingent with a smaller West African contingent, also the largest part of the Yugoslav resistance and its' Albanian equivalent, I've no doubt other forces I'm forgetting totalling far more than the Axis allies. Not seen whole vid hoping this gets a mention.

[@NobleBoss]

Fun fact, there were more dutch soldiers that fought for the Axis than the allies. And also the last defender's of Berlin were French SS soldiers.

[@SusCalvin]

​@@NobleBossThe local fascists in Belgium run a big anti-communist recruitment drive I think. They try to do the same in half-pacified Norway.

[@aidanpysher2764]

I remember seeing a Fez with an SS insignia in a WW2 museum a while ago, and I was taken back at the fact that something as odd as it didn't seem far-fetched.

[@huseyinsartas9659]

12:15 I would like to make a correction. Ataturk never applied to the League of Nations, but Ataturk was personally invited by the British and members of 29 states.

[@FreePalestine07462]

Note: Yazidis are Kurd 19:54

[@araratamedi]

Thank you , truth is they're the most pure Kurds , they speak Kurdish , and have their prayers in kurdish.

[@jordam200]

Hi i was wondering if you could put this stuff on spotify as a podcast? I need more long car ride material.

[@johnnail532]

Enemy of my enemy is my friend?

[@Kubson-gr4mp]

no, its rather: evil likes evil

[@mojewjewjew4420]

Only a fool believes that the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

[@edmurks236]

Politics in the Middle east are a longstanding bloody minefield. Sounds like its just more of the same today nit much has changed just moving around the deck chairs. Incredible account of the history/politics or the region.Thank you.

[@damham5689]

There were Americans who supported Hitler too. Even IBM and father of President G HW Bush and Grandfather of President G W Bush, late US Senator Prescott Bush supported Hitler and became wealthy doing so.

[@christianweibrecht6555]

How is that relevant to this video?

[@barryirlandi4217]

​@@christianweibrecht6555every people had their AH supporters

[@MetatronsRevenge613]

IBM made machines that did the shoah en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust

[@CivilizedWasteland]

many major industrial figures supported hitler before ww2 because they were at odds with big finance and people of wall street. By 1945 big finance took over most of america's industries and then gradually over a period of time the rest of the world.

[@lv7603]

🙄 “what about”

[@meinkanal7438]

Where are the sources?

[@advicepirate8673]

I would like to thank you for your editing style. In the world of youtube there seems to be a race to the bottom in terms of spastic editing, constant camera cuts, and using underhanded manipulations in order to hijack the viewer's attention. It's the TikTok effect, great for maximizing personal views with the minor cost of destroying the ability of an entire generation to function in the real world. You do it perfectly. Subtle slow moving figures, just enough to give my eyes something to rest on while I keep my ears open. Thank you Jabzy. Thank you for not being an accessory to our destruction. I would think that it's a low bar, but the mass of garbage content that has been shoveled my way lately suggests otherwise.

[@AduckButSpain]

33:43 There were 100 men at their largest extent...

[@ItsBillTV]

Muslims? Algeria participated in the war against the nazis. Majority of muslim countries were occupied by the west at that time. What a ridiculous title.

[@bunnystrasse]

Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was friendly towards Nazis.

[@bunnystrasse]

Algeria was forced to as it was colonized by France.

[@Xiahoud]

Exactly. Millions forced to fight and die in WW1 and WW2 on the British or French side. Just for a few racists and KZbinrs seeking views jump on 21st century Islamophobia wherever they find it.

[@zhcultivator]

Fascinating video btw

[@nicbahtin4774]

18:30 lol these guys even wear the appropriate mustache

[@ALIKN1-1]

Nah we just following the latest fashions :)

[@kalatiso5541]

You forgot to mention that those pogroms were latter dismantled by attaturks government, their leaders executed and the 15k Jews were able to return to their property in Istanbul.

[@JabzyJoe]

Ataturks government post-1939?...

[@kalatiso5541]

@@JabzyJoe yeah I posted both comments at the same time, look foward to the next episode :)

[@revivalist355]

Jabzy , whats the name of the background sound . Sounds so peaceful

[@JabzyJoe]

Nevada city

[@sourpusstv7984]

Source?

[@HistoryForYou68]

When I saw the part where the character had a bride's outfit, I couldn't help but laugh

[@Charlie-hp2oh]

where does all this information come from ?

[@Ramirez83786]

History books. Not wiki

[@hamodalbatal464]

They absolutely did, other day I was reading some old archive news from 1930s where I saw in news papers a huge denomination in Aleppo, Syria, where they shouting “No Monsieur Or Mister, Allah is in heaven and on earth is HEDLAR” لا مسيو و لا مستر، الله في السماء و على الارض هايتلار

[@alkopolityk]

Jabotinsky/Zhabotinski/Żabotyński is read like dr Zhivago. He and his movement of Zionists-revisionists are an interesting topic on their own. They strived to build a "new Jew" similarly to fascists aiming for a "new Italian" and they cooperated with Polish radical nationalists since they have common purpose - to make Jews move out of the Poland. It was also Zionists-revisionists who played the most prominent role during the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.

[@barahng]

His talk of building an ethnic homeland and creating living room by clearing out the natives sounds more like mustache man though.

[@ocularpatdown]

@@barahngwow, that’s a real 💩ty take.

[@moosesandmeese969]

So the answer is sort of but not in any meaningful way. They were under the control of the British and French so appealing to their enemies seemed like a good idea at the time, until they realized the Nazis were also a colonialist expansionist regime like those that controlled them.

[@austinblair9869]

Its called a world war for a reason..

[@danielshoudy265]

Ataturk always fascinated me. He was definitely a unique leader. Not a Stan of his but he definitely was overall a good leader for his nation and the world to a certain degree. I have issues with certain actions of his but he is interesting as you said he’s hard to pin down.

[@67nairb]

22:14 that looks just like Saddam Hussein.

[@alter3602]

🤯🤯🤯

[@67nairb]

@@alter3602 Is that supposed to be Saddam Hussein?

[@monke3842]

have you ever thought about making a similar series of videos about recent South american history ?

[@SamFromItalia]

Well obviously the most based regime would be allied with the most-based religion duh

[@jadadra3729]

Fawzi al Quawiji was my great grandfather what a chad a thorn for the British from Iraq to Lebanon and Palestine. In the end it was disunity and greed that would unravel self determination in the region.

[@jaif7327]

insane lmao, are you turkmen?

[@memetv52828]

Team Germany and Turkey now🇩🇪❤️🇹🇷 👇

[@roderik3059]

Turkey didn't even fought...🦃

[@JustYourRandomTurk]

@@roderik3059overused joke. 0 laughs :)

[@roderik3059]

@@JustYourRandomTurk Maybe I'm lying. What Turkey did in World War II?

[@JustYourRandomTurk]

@@roderik3059 nothing. lol. better than spending millions of dollars as a newly founded republic and losing half our population tbh

[@roderik3059]

@@JustYourRandomTurk So why the hell do you writte team Germany Turkey? Ridiculous. 😂

[@armanriazi513]

Reza shah, father of modern 🇮🇷 ❤ Reza shah rohhat shad (rest in peace)

[@agxryt]

This is a great rundown on the shitty people on all sides, thanks for this. It's frustrating that we're still hearing about the impacts of these extremists, decades later

[@tenanaciouz]

funny since Marxists are the ones running the culture and currently running it into the dirt. Of course they are telling you about people dead not for decades but for over a century. Pay more attention to the current people casusing issues in your nation rather than people who have no power in other nations that say words you dislike

[@ラーメンのボス]

You seem like a liberal, might want to do some introspection before calling others shitty people

[@lavishkirad5816]

Noziees Called them as "Half apes". Were using them as allies in Middle East to conquer later. "It was like giving hope to a chicken before the day of supermarket meat sale.

[@GuidedPirate]

Dumb title. Thought this was an educational channel

[@JabzyJoe]

Would you prefer "An in-depth look at the Foreign Policy of Islamic Nations between 1930 and 1939"?

[@firasahmed5743]

@@JabzyJoe yes, yes we would

[@JabzyJoe]

@@firasahmed5743 will you agree to donate for the loss of income?

[@firasahmed5743]

@@JabzyJoe dont you have better things to do with your time

[@inovakovsky]

@@JabzyJoe Don't you already have an IRL job outside of KZbin?

[@jamesholland5139]

Politics can be so lethal

[@shadhinov]

brother muslims are all over the world, and outside of the middle east. bangladesh for example is a Muslim nation. was under British rule, and fought the axis ferociously in ww2. chittagong, was a major frontline in the asian theatre. meanwhile "christians" were also under the nazi team. but we can't say "did Christians support the nazis". add to that- the decision of states are not the same as the decisions of the people. as a history and anthropology enthusiasts you should understand the difference between ethnic groups, state, religious groups and nationalities. so yeah, the title of your video should be "did the middle eastern states support the german reich"

[@FF-le3ps]

Your forgetting that we muslims who fought in any side of ww2 were just used as canon fodder, wether it was for the western allies, axis or soviets

[@vaingloriant]

The title is a question. As all things, there is nuance, which is touched upon in the video. The answer to that question should be reached by the viewer with the information provided. He never claims that Muslims as a group supported Nazis, and provides instances where there was a conflict of interest. The reason there is no "did Christians support the Nazis" video is because nobody's actually thinking about that, meanwhile the question of Muslim loyalties is much more obscure. And why would he need to clarify about it being Middle Eastern Muslims? The video is part of a series ON the Middle East. The fact it's about Middle Eastern Muslims should be obvious, even with the title.

[@NoUsername534]

@@FF-le3ps Only true muslims did not fight in the war but those who did are not real muslims

[@FF-le3ps]

@@NoUsername534 tbh the vast majority of Muslims who fought in ww2 had little to know choice, either forced through gunpoint or starvation

[@NoUsername534]

@@FF-le3ps In islam muslims who are being forced to do sinful things but die rejecting it they are rewarded paradise but if they accept sinful things it makes them a Kuffar/Murtad

[@VictorianTimeTraveler]

I heard Alternative Hypothesis give an interesting argument that the axis could have won World War II if they had invaded the Soviet Union through Persia and captured the oil fields.

[@redtje943]

Morocco defended a lot of jews

[@Ratselmeister]

In Egypt the still honour Rommel till today. Dont think they do that with any british occupier.

[@maxmurphy47]

The answer is: Yes, they did. And still do

[@abhinavpatil759]

Were the Nazis and Christians allies?

[@DocReasonable]

@@abhinavpatil759 The Protestant church (founded by fanatical German antisemite Martin Luther) provided the blueprint for Nazism and the Holocaust. In Mein Kampf, Hitler referred to Martin Luther as a great warrior, a true statesmen, and a great reformer, alongside Richard Wagner and Frederick the Great. [At no time, however, did Hitler EVER praise or even mention Charles Darwin.] German economist Wilhelm Röpke concluded in 1946 that "without any question, Lutheranism influenced the political, spiritual and social history of Germany in a way that, after careful consideration of everything, can be described only as fateful."

[@tylertomlin3911]

Ey new episodes!

[@TheZerech]

One big mistake made in the video is the implication that the Havara agreement was signed by the Revisionist movement. It was signed by a member of the Labor movement and was opposed by the Revisionists. As to the situation in the British Mandate, the fact remains that Britain could have saved millions of Jews from the Holocaust, and didn't largely because of Arab pressure. In fact at the Evian conference only one country in the entire world, the Dominican Republic, offered to take 100,000 Jews. They ended up being able to take only a couple thousand because the war broke out. It should be noted that Jews were able find refuge in Shanghai also, but that was because it was basically an international free for all zone. I personally dont know why the Israeli War of Independence refers to the '48 war and not the struggle against Britain which ladted for several years and was quite bloody. Indeed it was the first and arguably most significant British Colonial defeat by an indigenous insurgency after the war. British troops ransacked Kibbutzim and drew swastikas on the walls. Some of them were ww2 veterans, how they saw camps and then three years later found themselves drawing swastikas, I can't fathom.

[@SusCalvin]

Britain and the others are placing their own immigration controls in the pre-war years. Germany starts to confiscate property of all Jewish exiles and refusing these now impoverished Jews in the UK etc re-entry. They have some idea that this will spread the "Jew problem". Jews in the UK have to fund refugees themselves.

[@mojewjewjew4420]

The dominicans only wanted to take them for the blanquamiento policy, also the Js deserve what they get for 0ppresing the arabs.

[@Herr_Floki_San]

I don't need to watch this the answer is yes.

[@rickwilliams967]

Two groups of insane murders? Yeah, prolly.

[@Moh3-rekibi]

the christians murdered an entire continent

[@thesaracen3992]

guess who is the biggest murderers of all time , yup , the west , britin , france , and USA .

[@manofwar2354]

Yes jews and europeans

[@randomperson-uj4bp]

@@manofwar2354 I disagree with both: Japanese and Germans

[@manofwar2354]

@@randomperson-uj4bp both germans and japanese did was retaliation to invaders Read what in ww1 did to germany and how nasty america was to japan

[@zhcultivator]

Interesting history here 🤔 this potentially has many alternate historical ramifications......

[@ironzombie39]

The short answer is yes The long answer is yes, they were Allies

[@salamyaya162]

They were enemies.

[@justacat2]

not at all

[@tea9532]

muslims fought with Britain and france

[@FarisAlight]

Short answer, yes Long answer, yes but also no (Muslim also fight with allies)

[@ehannasir8464]

@@tea9532 muslims fought with them also

[@stand4justice4867]

Seems like you've been receiving zio funding lately. Your videos lack credibility as they're biased and don't include strong historical references.

[@abhinavpatil759]

If you watch his videos carefully it's always been there. He's three inches removed from being a mustache twirling 19th century colonial administrator. To the extent he has an apparent fascination for China, Africa, or the Middle East, it is the fascination of Rudyard Kipling or Cecil Rhodes: the quaint, Orientalist fascination of the colonist for the native.

[@DocReasonable]

@@abhinavpatil759 It's a good thing Islam never colonized any African or Asian countries... oh wait...

[@abhinavpatil759]

@@DocReasonable Religions cannot colonize. Hope this helps, xoxo

[@theuniverse5173]

What the sigma

[@leovigildrekkared8702]

Same absolutist ideology. This is what michael stürzenberger knifed in Mannheim was talking about.

[@brasaepenta2002]

The just had a mutual dislike of jews 😂

[@saaduthehungryone4340]

Yes and no muslim can live with jews without a problem

[@usibistro]

You're mixing Zionism with Judaism here. A very idiotic remark.

[@ekadria-bo4962]

​@@usibistroOr zionist just a mask of anti-jew? Hmm

[@Bladieblah]

​@@usibistroThe Mufti's statements leave no room for ambiguity, he said the Germans had found the final solution to the problem and that they should do the same just like Mohammed did at the time. You can look it up, there is no doubt he was fully aligned with the policy of Nazi Germany towards Jews

[@kiko8u]

Short answer: YES (Sahih Muslim 2922)

[@History_Teller1250]

That Hadith is giving us a prophecy that one day the Palestinians will beat the Israelis and reclaim their land. The Israelis will try to hide but their very hideouts will snitch on them. It doesn't say that all Jews will be wiped out from the face of the earth...

[@Kerem-mf9oy]

​@@History_Teller1250Palenazis*

[@firasahmed5743]

@@Kerem-mf9oy cry more my boy

[@roejogan9322]

No one can cry more than pro Hamas Muslims on the internet ya hmar

[@firasahmed5743]

@@roejogan9322 Yes indeed, i am HMAR weapons system being sent to ukraine, lol

[@hermitcrabband1208]

this is not like what certain people think, some Muslim still support British and some Muslim support Nazi. Because Muslim having though decision to make at that time, if they support axis power, they will be poor, if they support British Allies, it will questioning they anti colonial movement, but even when Hitler in power, he is so busy in Berlin, and never trying to help Muslim country to be free from colonialism. after ww2 end, the idea decolonisation give chance to many colony to gain independence more better than Nazi propaganda.

[@Tirana-qg1ft]

Oy vey!

[@chadfrein8228]

Their is another technology that will see through lead shielding, let alone foil like new security PET SCAN

[@nicbahtin4774]

"Sword of islam" just like Timur who build pyramids of skulls of Muslims.

[@Ciech_mate]

Yeah ironically he killed muslims than anyone

[@Trump2024asw]

The awards ironic like the peace prize.

[@islammehmeov2334]

And like the crusaders wen they soups to protect Christianity but they killed and re..p christians in byzantine empire

[@Juan-st6lh]

@@islammehmeov2334 keep looking Moor

[@silentbyte196]

Bro Timur did skull pyramids in Isfahan and Syria. He also raided and pillaged Delhi on 1398, at that time it was capital of muslim Delhi sultanate

[@TheVanpablo79]

Spoiler: many did, many didn’t. Cheers

[@drago760]

Yes they did.

[@astratr3b345]

why the F.. you link religion with nazis ???? aren't nazis christians ??? so why you didn't use that term , did christian and muslim collaborate in WW2 ???

[@JabzyJoe]

I feel you're someone who is always offended.

[@maverick7291]

Actually Nazis ideology were not Christian. It was a mish mash of pagan/pseudo science/ socialism/nationalism Most of the high ranking Nazis were not Christian. And many Christians were imprisoned or killed for opposing the Nazis regimes. This includes priests and nuns.

[@astratr3b345]

@@maverick7291 so they didn't have pope Pius blessing, are you sure ??? , and vatican was not involved into smuggling nazzis after WW2 ???

[@maverick7291]

@@astratr3b345 Pope blessing no. Has there been individual high ranking bishops or cardinal that helped Nazis escape Europe yes. But these were the exceptions not the rule. Many more helped the Jews escape, in fact there are statues of them across Europe of these bishops,priests and nuns who died resisting the Nazis. That being said Vatican tried to keep the status quo since they were literally surrounded by fascist Italy and Nazis Germany was not very tolerant of Christians. In fact Hitler wrote in his book that he liked the Muslim religion better because of their warlike dogma, he found Christianity too peaceful. Look it up if you don't believe me.

[@astratr3b345]

@@maverick7291 sorry to tell you but Islam did not produce nazism , its product of christian faith , muslims did not persecute jews , but christians did for centuries , that is a fact

[@kubhlaikhan2015]

Nationalism always makes a lot of sense at the beginning then always ends with the same atrocious disasters.

[@ahmedbader8410]

Arabs in the World War I do not think that these wars are called world wars or others because the wars that preceded them are more dangerous than the world wars that were countries against countries, but from my point of view, an empire against an empire is considered a world war. In my point of view, it is not just a country, but regions extending over an area that reaches a continent. However, the Second World War did not have a role for the Arabs in this war, and no one was affected or even encouraged any country or any person. In reality, we cannot include the Arabs as a force at this time when the Arabs no longer want wars. Rather, some of them have begun to descend to the limits of extreme weakness that has become in the Arab countries. If they had power, the world would have become different from now. We must distinguish between the Arabs in the past and the Arabs in the present. In the past, they are the ones who do not know defeat and repeat that until the enemy countries fall. Rather, they pursue them and chase them for the sake of dominance. We cannot say that they were afraid of death, but they are the ones who wanted death or victory. This belief is merciless, and no one can say anything about them except that they are the reason for the security that was in their time. Now, look at how the situation has become in the hands of other countries. You do not understand how to make the world live in peace because they are not important in the world and the Muslims were the ones who united the East and the West and this led to a very large shortage in the European countries who do not know how their situation was unwanted and this caused the creation of the most hateful kind of hatred that entered the regions of the Arab countries in a barbaric form and hatred buried in their hearts from compliments to make them an example of progress and development and in reality only to make them live under pride and pride in the truth that is almost a nightmare for them any progress in the Islamic world they become in fear of returning to the dark life

[@karandeosingh2356]

Palistine was never a state.

[@usibistro]

Neither was Israel so what's your point

[@karandeosingh2356]

@@usibistro Israel is a state under the British mandate of 48. They've fought a defense war against Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Arabs in the in the surrounding area. What ended up happening is that Isreal defeated those five armies. The Palestinians had a chance for a two state solution back in 1948. They rejected it and went to war with Isreal and they've lost, that's why Palestine is not a state.

[@stephensdygert7600]

​@@usibistroThe Bible gives detailed geographical dimensions of the land promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. It's the only piece of real-estate in the history of the world that God gave to a people.

[@leonnozik]

@@usibistro So go there and tell the Israelis they are not a country

[@goodman_1955]

Gobbler or circumcised schlomo schlong​@@stephensdygert7600

[@lolmenx4]

just before i watch it if n+zis were still here they would be best chumps...100% like no chance they would be supporting eachother even more.