Whale of a Birthday Rant [Spongey Bits]

I revisit a review that's long overdue.
Patreon: / pieguyrulz
Art: ohemgeeitsern.deviantart.com/
My Twitter: / pieguyrulz
Music by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...

[@spencergage95]

Wait a minute, if Krabs' mother was poor, than this all makes sense. Mr Krabs just psychologically fears losing money due to an irrational belief that he'll "become poor again" just by spending a little bit. All that he'd need to do to get over this would just be to spend a little bit of money and realize that he'd still have plenty left.

[@DeadlyAlienInvader]

I think that's what I'm going through as well.

[@kylecampbell565]

Well this was one season before Friend or Foe at this point Dunces & Dragons was the orgin of the KRABBY PATTY

[@jonesentertainmentgroup7335]

I feel Krab's mother being poor (like Pieguy said) should've made him buy her something nice, so she wouldn't look poor or feel poor like he did.

[@connorlynch1874]

Good point.

[@johnsantos507]

@@jonesentertainmentgroup7335 Well, he can't because Mr. Krabs doesn't want to spend money. He wants to be a rich Krabs and let his family such as Pearl and Betsy Krabs being poor. That's why Mr. Krabs is a terrible character who loves money.

[@almightytallestred232]

I honestly think that Squidward's performance was hilarious.

[@XXLittleSofyXX]

same

[@RealSirMikay]

*Squidward was a boy band impostor.*

[@harunmulaomerovic2414]

True

[@anigga]

Facts lmao

[@flag098]

I NEED 4 PLY, 4 PLY, 4 PLY, WHEN I CRY

[@TheDSGuy]

Imagine if SpongeBob knew that Mr. Krabs was being too cheap, so he intentionally spent a lot of Mr. Krabs' money.

[@Kyranyoutubevids]

And then mr krabs would say: rarrr spongebob! You’re spending all me money!!!! And then Spongebob will say: but mr krabs, I’m not doing WHAT YOU SAID!!!!!!! And then Mr krabs will say we’re not talking about this or this we’re talking about THIS!!!!!!!!!!

[@isobelmiller7464]

You know, the "It's A Boy" banner kind of made me speculate. I figured out that when Pearl was born, instead of buying an "It's A Girl" banner, Mr. Krabs just went to his mother's home, dug up his "It's A Boy" banner from when he was born, crossed out "Boy", and wrote "Girl" at the top. Shows how cheap he is.

[@jaelie8398]

Isobel Miller That's a really good theory. I've never though about that

[@moghraliamneeson]

That's a good theory but Krabs did say that he got the banner on sale, so there's that.

[@isobelmiller7464]

@@moghraliamneeson Oh.

[@smokesterify]

"Mean Spirited" is one of those Terms starting to get over-used in Spongebob reviews....

[@flashorb2707]

But ita still true

[@smokesterify]

Yeah...

[@smokesterify]

***** I think Mr Enter is entertaining and makes great points... But Popularity doesn't always bring good things...

[@DeadlyAlienInvader]

Can you blame them? Maybe if it wasn't one of the BIGGEST problems that this show has, it wouldn't be mentioned so often. By the way, if you're gonna whine about "overused" criticism, then don't bother to watch anymore SB reviews because they'll most likely criticize the same exact problems that others have already pointed out. Go watch different reviews about different shows.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

DeadlyAlienInvader My problem specifically is the word itself. So many people use it as a catch all instead of actually explaining the real problems. I agree there are too many episodes where the characters act horribly and aren't punished or even acknowledge their bad behavior, but the word gets thrown around so much and is such a loose term, I think it's lost all meaning personally.

[@LavaIshawtLink]

I don't care what anyone says.... I always always always love squidwardj in this episode. Yes I agree it goes against his character but the joke lands, and it lands so hard. The episode that comes to mind is when Squidward moves and discovers that he misses Spongebob and he secretly enjoys playing with a reef blower or him hiding his love for krabby patties so I understand your point but the smugness and confidence in his routine was SO squidward, like the talent show episode (which I think does it best) and his dance routine is a complete mess but he is so confident that's partly what makes it so funny. That routine and squidwards twerking (idk why that's now a running gag but thank god for it) will forever be one of my most favorite and probably most quoted spongebob moments ever.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

LavaIshawtLink Love what you want to love :) My goal is never to make anyone enjoy something less, simply to explain my opinion and let people decide weather they agree or disagree.

[@LavaIshawtLink]

Of course :) Wouldn't expect anything less Pieguy!

[@jonnyboy4289]

***** At least you don't force your opinion to others forcing everyone to "kneel to you" and not take the stuff you review seriously unlike Anita Sarkisean. Also, at least you aknowledge that everything you say is all your opinion.

[@lewismelrose4334]

The "It Tastes Like Dishwater" is one of my favourite lines in the whole of Spongebob. Shame it had to be in this episode.

[@EBTheOriginalMaster]

"It Taste Like Dishwater" It is dishwater. That quote was pretty funny. XD

[@XXLittleSofyXX]

true

[@TheLynnster]

At least in bossy boots, mr krabs actually gave pearl a present for her birthday. Even if it was 2 dollars

[@brrgames]

In my opinion, this episode is a meh. It does have a lot of funny moments and I do like the Boys Who Cry band but I really hate Mr Krabs in this episode. Never have I seen a father be so ignorant on what the child wants especially on the birthday of that child.

[@flowerbunny91]

***** i love this episode but i agree with you on the Mr Krabs part. He was getting annoying.

[@sandradefosse213]

hello BRRGames

[@Nobody-eu6tb]

BRRGames mrkrab isnt pearl father she was adopted

[@katzinhatz1]

Yeah i agree. Spongebob's scenes where he buys things and spies on pearl are funny. And squidward's scenes were fine. HOWEVER, mr krabs was bad and his cheapness did bring the episode down. And he doesn't do anything enough to redeem himself. He says he cares, but he doesn't show it. Still, i think some parts are funny enough to barely call it a meh, however i can see why ppl think it is bad.

[@blossomsonic6712]

My opinion on this episode was best cause the dish water scene was funny even if I hated pearl's friends in this episode pearl is funny and I love it.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

LOL Yeah guys this is a reupload. The earlier video had a weird glitch with the cross fades and it took my internet forever to upload this fixed version.

[@KaiVellichor]

***** OHHHHH.... so not to rush you or anything buuuttt will you make a NEW vid soon... ik what you said in your update and I respect that, butttttt seeing a reupload and nothing else for another 1-2 weeks seems... ehhh.. buttttt it's ok either way, just askin

[@jetsetpanda3525]

***** Hi PieGuyRulz

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Kyler Herrington ... This is a new vid. It's a reupload from earlier today.

[@KaiVellichor]

***** ohhhhh my bad :P when you said earlier I thought in the long past! oops .-.

[@CubicPanther]

So... can you please collab with someone to make a top 10 best/worst Spongebob episodes/specials, please?

[@sodaddict]

I find this to be a good episode for one reason and one reason only, and that's 2 words: 4 Ply

[@OfficialCyaned]

Oh, the origin of Squidward's Twerking. Wait a minute...so he's responsible for the millions of females twerking on the internet! Thanks a lot Squidnator.

[@agenda4256]

Twerking was around before this episode

[@spencergage95]

SarahandAshley In addition to Squidward, Robotnik (AoSth) and Amethyst also twerked once.

[@Double_K_A]

***** I didn't see any genes.

[@eliassalazar423]

Don't forget Miley Cyrus.

[@OfficialCyaned]

Spencer Gage You can now add the Powerpuff Girls on that list.

[@BagelGabe]

I seriously would've liked the episode so much more if it went the way you said. Especially the whole Squidward thing! You should seriously be a writer for SpongeBob! (even though that probably won't happen)

[@jellieman5752]

I also really, really hate Pearl’s friends in this episode. They just rub it in her face that her parties suck as if it’s her fault.

[@lukerbom12]

I said I was waiting for this one. It was the first Spongey Bits on an episode that I actually liked. But you're really good about never actually making me upset with your opinions even when they differ from mine, which is very rare. This was a really well done Bits. I don't see anything wrong with the term "mean spirited." I loved your idea for how the Squidward Boys Who Cry thing should have gone. That was genius, I really wish they had done that! I still like this episode, though. I really do find it funny. I found the credit card routine hilarious because of the store clerk at first, the thing with the seahorse and that old lady, and especially the "Billy Fishkin" thing. I was only nine years old on 5/12/06 so I probably wasn't aware it was overused, I just thought they did it well. It's just my opinion, and I understand that humor is subjective with a lot of these episodes.

[@blossomsonic6712]

I like it 2

[@Freezepark]

i thought this episode was alright.

[@yuyi01a36]

Thethreebrothers Umm it's his opinion, you don't have to change your mind and hate this episode, cause he hates it..if u are the kind of person that he gets influenced of others opinion only, then ok what to say about it...i love this episode..but anyways i respect his opinion

[@Freezepark]

Yuyi01a i clearly said "I thought".

[@yuyi01a36]

Thethreebrothers οk

[@legoguy016]

I actually think this episode is really good, despite the Mr. Krabs crap. Kinda like how Pieguy rates The Two Faces Of Squidward.

[@durece100]

The first episode of Rocko's Modern Life was "Who Gives a Buck", where Rocko receive a credit card. (Only in Season 1).

[@MazSix45]

I think Squidward was just saying he liked the band so Mr. Krabs would let him perform on stage. This is evidenced by the fact that Squidward was literally singing about himself crying and needing 4-ply tissue, and didn't seem to possess the same qualities as the actual band.

[@brettquimby3274]

I thought this episode was good. Mr. Krabs may have ruined Pearl's birthday, but Spongebob saved it, and he did so in a way that got Mr. Krabs the punishment he deserved.

[@LuxyHugs]

This episode made Pieguy's tear ducts give issue

[@Ryan-id1kr]

He couldn't use just any tissue

[@raszze]

@@Ryan-id1kr he needed 4 ply 4 ply when he cry

[@lukeoutset1959]

something that while it probably wouldn't fix the episode but it would make it better is if it was more if a classic surprise party plot like Mr krabs throwing a fake party to stall while he has spongebob by the real gifts and unknowingly maxing out Mr krabs credit card as a little gag that way mr,krabs is shown as truely caring for his daughter

[@morbidsearch]

1:37 What if she was adopted at birth?

[@Korlinium]

4:02 It's the Bobmucs transition! *LE GASP*

[@OptimusPhillip]

I feel like if Mr. Krabs wasn't just being cheap and wanted to do all this himself from his heart, that would probably suck less.

[@JackTSS]

I took these times for granted lmao, I still love these. Hope you’re doing well, pieguy.

[@PIKACHUxSNEASEL64]

Would it make sense if Spongebob liked Boys Who Cry.

[@TheDSGuy]

Mr. Krabs is even worse in Bubble Troubles. He isn't as much of a main character in that episode, but that one line, "I guess I can't have her croaking at the Krusty Krab. It would be bad for business." It shows that his motivation MUST be for money. It CANNOT be to save someone's life.

[@beta511ee4]

+The DS Guy Pretty sure that line was supposed to be a dark joke.

[@TheDSGuy]

I don't mind that it's dark. I mind how selfish Mr. Krabs is.

[@morbidsearch]

+The DS Guy It's far from the worst problem of that episode.

[@JKEBP]

Funny, PIEGUYRULZ actually LIKES that episode, Karen 2.0, InSPONGEiac and Oral Report!

[@SweetTop7s]

I still like this episode, even though you do make some good points, and has always been a guilty pleasure of mine with the hate it gets from most others due to its main flaws. In fact, it is officially my 5th favorite episode from this season. I find some of the jokes (Pearl's dream, Squidward dancing, Spongebob stealing stuff while Pearl and her friends go to the mall) to be among the funniest in the whole season, and I don't think you have focused enough on the jokes. While Mr. Krabs is a greedy jerk in this episode, I feel he does get what he deserves in the end. He was cheap to Pearl for so many years, and now he likely lost just about all his money he has (It was stated at some point that it costs a million dollars to make Boys Who Cry appear) as punishment for that, and it is satisfying to me. Also, the ending is among the happiest in the show, and by far Pearl's best ending (She has had some pretty unfortunate endings in the past such as The Chaperone and ESPECIALLY the Tunnel of Glove) which brings a smile to my face. I do think you state some good points, and I do agree with your opinions on almost all other episodes, this is just a weird exception where I can't understand why everyone hates it except for the flaw of Krab's greediness, but he is punished for it at the end.

[@mandymartin9787]

I agree. I actually really liked this episode too

[@anthonysandoval5512]

Me too

[@BigTeddy899]

I actually like this episode.

[@vladimirlenin3068]

I've always loved this episode

[@isobelmiller7464]

You're a lot calmer than Mr. Enter, I'll tell you that. Now, I like Mr. Enter, but the dude has some issues.

[@RyanStorey1231]

I didn't know the "idiot who does not know how a credit card works" thing was a stock plot. I have literally never seen this used as a plot anywhere else. And I never watched Rocko's Modern Life growing up, so I wouldn't know. Where else has this plot been utilized before?

[@flowerbunny91]

AntonyBlalock I love that show!lol

[@RyanStorey1231]

I take it back, I do remember seeing this plot on "Ned's Declassified" with Cookie.

[@pichugirl6]

***** I remember it being between Ned's Declassified with Cookie and also Lilo and Stitch the show did one too.

[@PhantomAarantula]

I mean even if Mr. Krabs was going to return all of Pearl's gifts, I'm not sure how he'd manage that with Boys Who Cry. Especially with what Squidward said about their prices.

[@m4hblaze]

This episode just shows how much they've botched up these characters.This isn't even just with Mr.Krabs either.They don't even know what music Squidward likes,not counting the older seasons.They try to make us think he likes jazz but the next episode he's listening to boy bands.I know people like different genres but this just doesn't match up to character.

[@raszze]

Or Squidward just acted like he liked the music in order to perform on stage? That fits his character.

[@theumpireofthebottomlesspit]

You know people can have two or more favorite genres of music right? So who’s to say Squidward can’t as well? And I don’t think boy band is even considered to be a genre anyway. I think it is just a term to describe a group of males who work together in a song.

[@m4hblaze]

@@theumpireofthebottomlesspit dawg that comment is 8 years old and yeah obviously you can like more than one genre of music but squidward has only consistently been shown to be into like 1

[@MrD-on6dp]

One thing I really think about is why does Pearl still hang out with her "friends"? All they do is treat her like shit and basically spend this whole episode berating her and putting her down over her bad birthdays. What does she see in them, seriously? They're freaking horrible.

[@superdonbros]

I don't know why, but this and the season 4 review are really nostalgic to me. Maybe it is because back in the summer whenever this was first uploaded, I REALLY liked your videos. Now i'm a little more normal about it, but back then I watched your channel 24-7. You are certainly one of my favorite KZbinrs, if not my favorite. I don't know if you remember, but I was in your spongebob live stream. I've been with this channel since the whip cream video, and I have no plan to stop watching! Your the best PIEGUY! Also, what happened to the Days After Christmas videos? You know, the videos where you showed what you got for Christmas? Thanks, hope you read this!

[@hyperman864]

umm. i feel like squidward was either talking about some different band, or was trying to steal the show or something because he clearly did not know anything about the actual band.

[@Eltrio2]

Why is it odd that Squidward would like Boys Who Cry? People can have a diverse palette of tastes. You can enjoy bad music, or music that isn't your typical mo, without being ashamed.

[@beta511ee4]

+Eltrio2 What is "bad music" exactly?

[@Eltrio2]

Skeeter Mania Music that isn't good.

[@Ethan-ey4jx]

Because it’s creepy

[@cristianphilospher5576]

Wait isn't the creditcard that spongebob uses that of mr. Crabs?

[@vgjf3618]

8:46 But the number one spot usually speaks out to you, right Pieguy?

[@Sigmundfruit]

Mean-spirited is the Mary Sue of Spongebob, a buzzword thrown around by people who don't know how character critique works

[@bon-xt2js]

Robert Pysh More like animation reviews in general. It thrown around every time someone critiques any comedy related cartoons. As oppose to actually pointing out the flaws, and how to fix them.

[@TheCynamaticals]

Robert Pysh these kind of pics make me more terrified of creepy pastas

[@Sigmundfruit]

The Cynamaticals that pic was meant to be a joke. How do you get scared by a parody of a picture that was never scary to begin with from an awful, awful story?

[@TheCynamaticals]

Robert Pysh logic

[@beta511ee4]

Janelle Villanueva Seashorse Seashell Party is a good example of this. Admittedly the humor is incredibly lazy (except in the B plot to an extent), but the main reason people hate that episode is because of its horrible "moral". As far as I can recall, only the last part of the episode builds up to it. And it's not like it's trying to teach something to its viewers at all. It's there to stick with the status quo (could've done this a lot better, though). Before I opened my senses, I was in the same crowd as Mr. Enter when it came to hating the episode. As of now, I know at the end of the day it's fictional universe. Because of that, I now simply experience apathy towards it (still a flawed episode nonetheless). Same applies to most bad SB episodes (only a few actively strike out as abominable/bannable to me).

[@zoelegant6489]

Doesn't Pearl's friends say that "That's not Boys Who Cry!" It could just be a song of a band that's unrelated, or there are two bands (one possibly not being a boy band) called "Boys Who Cry

[@fruitosdor7230]

Greg Leland that was to squidward

[@zombies4evadude24]

To be fair when his Mom “fainted” (an obvious substitute for death) in Sailor Mouth, Mr Krabs pickpocketed from her . In Enemy in Law, Mr Krabs tries to hide his money from his mom so he doesn’t have to buy her anything. And who can forget the infamous scene where he sold Spongebob’s soul for 62¢. With this information and more, it can be argued that Mr Krabs has always been greedy and uncaring, even to his family and close peers. For this reason I don’t completely hold that against him because of pre-established character flaws, so this episode isn’t really a Scumbob to me, but it’s not very funny or interesting either. It’s a meh for me.

[@johnsantos507]

You're right about Sailor Mouth, Enemy in Law and Born Again Krabs. Eugene Krabs loves money more than anything. So, I say he has to be arrested.

[@lieutenantmoo334]

I love the death ray eyes

[@shageta456]

This episode came out 2 days before my 6th birthday and my parents wren't cheap

[@FormulaFanboy]

PIEGUYRULZ IS AWESOME

[@MegaMelodytime]

you know, this episode the worst Mr. krabs is a greedy bastard episode. what I think would make it better is if someone attached a timer to Mr. krabs chest and he has only that day to spend his money for pearls birthday party otherwise, he gets eaten.

[@kylecampbell565]

8:40 oh PieGuy just u wait till one Coarse Meal probably my most hated episode of the show

[@MysteryMan17]

I have a suggestion for Spongey Bits. Perhaps either "Every Scumbob Episode from Seasons 4-6" or "Every Meh Episode from Seasons 4-6" could be done.

[@anonymusmysterious5401]

Uhhh, that would take a lot of time... Making it and watching it

[@ryankmetz3740]

I hope to see Pieguyrulz take on The Seddie Arc on Bottom of the Bakery.

[@OptimusPhillip]

One thing that confounds me is why Boys Who Cry wrote a song about Pearl. All we needed was one line about how Pearl won a contest or something so the band wrote a birthday song for her, but we didn't even get that.

[@wariolandgoldpiramid]

What do you mean? They never wrote a song about Pearl

[@OptimusPhillip]

wariolandgoldpiramid "It's all about _Pearl_, on her 16th birthday!

[@wariolandgoldpiramid]

OptimusPhillip this is a birthday song. It's obvious that, just like in the song "Happy Birthday To You", the name of the birthday person is inserted into the song. Spongebob payed them to sing the song, so obviously he told them the name they need to insert. They did not write a song for her.

[@stratkids]

I guess Squidward sometimes just has a inner modern teen girl

[@nascarfanatic2425]

One cheapskate gag that was kinda funny was the bubble wrap gag. That was probably Mr. Krabs' positive highlight of the episode, though. Everything else really makes you draw from having the slightest bit of like for him.

[@zennanperkins770]

While I do like this episode, I understand a lot of the points you give

[@ExcelMK]

All of your thoughts were my thoughts XD

[@joemcmahan3590]

To be fair, Mr.Krabs does get his comeuppance in the end and Pearl thinks her dad got her all that stuff so, in my opinion, that kind of ties everything together.

[@thomashuffman3237]

Remember Krusty Love? Where Spongebob called Mr. krabs out on making him run back and forth to get things for Mrs. puff? Nothing like that here. Spongebob basically just let’s Krabs treat him like a slave.

[@FrozenUSA]

This is what bothers me about post first movie Spongebob as a character. He rarely gets annoyed at anything of real importance anymore. He should have ranted and raved to Mr. Krabs about how exhausting it was to follow Pearl around and buy her whatever she told her friends she liked with nothing for him in return. He does exactly this is Krusty Love and the best Soongebob getting mad scene was in Can You Spare a Dime? where Spongebob gets so angry at Squidward mooching off of him that he literally chokes Mr. Krabs for being the reason Squidward lives with him in the first place. Spongebob lost his backbone somewhere along the way between the end of Season 3, the first movie and Season 4. I think it would have made the episode better to have Spongebob rant and rave to Mr. Krabs about Pearl’s birthday present and Pearl hear about this and get mad at her father. Then the presents show up anyway and she gives both Spongebob and Mr. Krabs a kiss on the cheek to thank them. I disagree with the Squidward performance scene here. I can’t stop laughing when I see it. It is so out of character yet so much in character for him that it just works for me. The performance and the actual song are the reasons why I really like this episode. Lastly, I do agree that the flanderization of Mr. Krabs has gotten out of control post first movie with this being a good example. It wasn’t like he was super generous in the classic episodes, it just wasn’t the only thing he was about.

[@thomashuffman3237]

@@FrozenUSA took the words right out of my mouth, my friend. Another prime example is when you compare and contrast “Rockabye Bivalve” and “Patrick’s Staycation”. In the former, Patrick makes Spongebob do all the work with junior, and lies to him about going to work, even though that’s just an excuse for him to go to his house and watch TV. There, Spongebob chews him out for it, which leads to the famous “OVERTIME!!!???” Scene. In the latter, spongebob is going out of his way to give Patrick a nice staycation, and Patrick just criticizes him for EVERYTHING, even stealing Squidward’s food and Spongebob’s bed. There, Spongebob doesn’t even TRY to stand up to Patrick or call him out on his ungrateful behavior, and just let’s him walk all over him. Seems that the writers are so afraid of making Spongebob an unlikable jerk that they just turn him into a complete pushover. SMH 🤦.

[@heroawesome8495]

I think the episode would've been better if he invited spongebob shopping to MAKE him spend money on pearl because he thinks he can't. We would've watched his relationship with pearl and spongebob

[@PurplePineappleChannel]

I quite liked Squidward's boys who cry performance.

[@abigailvanlangen4078]

The credit card thing also happened in Apple and Onion’s episode Falafel’s Fun Day.

[@sherifflasso]

I actually quite like that bizarre show.

[@Otakupatriot117]

As far as Squidward's concerned, you pretty much explained the joke yourself. It's ironic that a classical music fan would like a boy band. And it's not the first time Squidward liked something you wouldn't expect him to like, and he often pretends he doesn't like it.

[@tracyart1389]

I feel stupid because this is the episode that made me notice that Crabs is spelled wrong. You know it's bad when you learn something from a modern Spongebob episode.

[@danielj8085]

I wouldn't consider season 4 to be a modern season.

[@silentsweeperx]

While I find that this episode is pretty freaking boring, I have to say that the boys who cry gag (the name of the band), is easily a personal favorite joke of mine. Anyway pieguy, nice vid as always!

[@magnus1536]

Hey PieGuy, can you please put an upcoming review at the end of your videos like Mr. Enter does?

[@leandrocesar5207]

Do Spongey Bits on Choir Boys please :D

[@flowerbunny91]

***** "He elaborated so much in the initial review on why he hates it so much." Can you send me the link to that? I can't find it.

[@mollyawesomeness3572]

You can find the inital reviews in the "Every Episode of Spongebob Reviewed: Season I'm probaly too late and you already know, but whatever.

[@Oney105]

Molly Awesomeness season 6

[@shageta456]

This episode came out 2 days before my birthday, and my parents weren't cheap about it. They did the best could to make me happy. Now bear in mind I was about to turn 6 at the time so I might've been too young to remember what I actually got but my parents gave me what I wanted, so seeing this (and I haven't seen this episode in a long time) is really sad. The fact that Mr. Krabs won't go out of his way to make Pearl happy for her birthday is borderline pathetic.

[@artbytesia]

Especially because he promised he wouldn't be cheap.

[@nascarfanatic2425]

I too, have a distaste for this episode. People wanted a Pearl Torture Porn, and this is what they got. Another pain of the innocence plot that doesn't work.

[@HawkknightXC88]

As if Mr Krabs wasn't already a worst character within Spongebob he just cheapen his own Daughter's Pearl's Birthday and just makes him a very bad father figure in a way. If it wasn't for Spongebob getting Pearl all of the Gifts that she wanted along with the boy band this episode would had been ten times worst than it already is.

[@28604]

Do you still think SB should be cancelled? If so, why? I think it's getting a lot better.

[@Dilbert1999]

I'm not sure if it's particularly fair to use other episodes like Friend or Foe and Krusty Love when reviewing a Spongebob episode since, aside from a few episodes, the show doesn't really have any continuity.

[@raszze]

It’s great imo because of its comedy as it was one of the funniest of the season. Krabs is its only real drawback and he frankly wasn’t all that bad. Sure he wasn’t good, but compare it to episodes like The Cent of Money and he’s perfect.

[@KanonChan926]

. . . I used to think that Boys Who Cry were cool when I was younger, and Chip Skylark XDDD

[@seanmyster6]

I've been wondering; Do you think that it's possible that you could go back to an episode that you've reviewed and decide you'd like to change its rating, and if so, would you actually go through with it via Spongey Bits? (example: you come back to an episode that you gave a Scumbob, but decide that it's actually not as bad as you originally thought, and change its rating to Meh.)

[@seanmyster6]

Long question short, what's your policy on episode rating revisions?

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

I've answered this question elsewhere and the short answer is that I'm confident enough in my ratings that a situation like that should never occur.

[@seanmyster6]

***** I see. Thanks for taking the time to reply, and keep doing what you do!

[@TacomasterStudios]

I hate Pearl more than Krabs in this episode.

[@mayathelegend8119]

Me too

[@SuperLordGaming]

Would you put this higher up then some of the others in the bottom 5?

[@lilbolo45]

Pieguy, if I ask for a crossover video, would you remember me?

[@anthonysandoval5512]

While I do somewhat enjoy episode I can see why some people dislike it. Personally my biggest problem is mr krabs being so cheap to where he gave pearl a cake made of cardboard. The ending though I did like with Pearl getting those gifts thanks to SpongeBob.

[@FromElsewhear]

When you get to season 7, and you're at One Corse Meal and/or A Pal For Gary, say "Scumbob. You all know why. Next!"

[@SweetTop7s]

Adam Baldwin And Stuck In The Wringer as well.

[@wariolandgoldpiramid]

No, no, no. He will go into these episodes in detail

[@MickeyFan1928]

In the episode Growth Spurt (kinda forgot what it was called) Mr Krabs seems to go through a lot to help Pearl with her hunger problem. This episode shows that Mr Krabs does care for his daughter a lot. You should watch it

[@ErimlRGG]

I know this is old... But he stole food from anyone instead of paying for food for his daughter... Yeah.. Best parent ever...

[@REDCVidz]

When I first watched this, it just nothing to me. I didn't feel something bad about this episode. Its only decent.

[@nitroedits2834]

FERST!!! KAHN I GIT AAAHH WITNESS???

[@generictitle7942]

Maybe this is a bit too sophisticated for current Spongebob, but what if Mr. Krabs was being frugal not because he didn’t want to exhaust any money on Pearl, but to teach her that money wasn’t everything. Like maybe Pearl was asking for a whole list of materialistic nonsense, so he gets Spongebob to go buy a bunch of cheap stuff and throw a small birthday party. Maybe her friends leave her because the party was lame, but at the end she still appreciates her dad actually caring for her. Is this just wishful thinking? Probably.

[@taylornoren642]

Mr crabs did this in an earlier and much better episode squeaky boots but it worked because he got pearl what she wanted in the end and he was proud of it but here he doesn’t feel proud at all he just doesn’t act like he cares about his daughters birthday at all

[@FrozenUSA]

Squeaky Boots is an annoying episode for a completely different reason but the Pearl bits were great. He does get her what she wants in the end and they are both happy about it. In this episode Mr. Krabs is not happy about all the money Soongebob spent until Pearl gives him a big hug and a kiss and thanks him for a great party. I like the idea of Mr. Krabs surprising Pearl with a great party but under the guise of a horribly cheap one. She would freak out like she did here and then someone or something would wreck the Krusty Krab and the walls would fall down to reveal the party of Pearl’s dreams complete with Boys Who Cry as entertainment. At first Pearl would think that perhaps Soongebob and Squidward did all this since her father is so cheep. Then they would reveal it was all Mr. Krabs idea and they just helped him pull it off. The episode would end with Mr. Krabs saying something along the lines of “Nothing’s too good for my Pearl.” She would hug and kiss him while we the audience see him secretly cringe at the thought of the credit card bill to come.

[@GDNachoo]

Who thought that he would change the rating at 4:01 ???

[@butterbiscuits1044]

Meh, I like this episode.

[@lordroy88]

But I love squidwards performance

[@simpsonsfanatic777]

Are there any modern Spongebob episodes that have done mean-spirited humor correctly? I know some of the classic episodes did.

[@SweetTop7s]

***** Sing A Song Of Patrick kinda did.

[@marvinthemaniac7698]

Honestly, I think Spongebob buying all those gifts for Pearl with Mr. Krabs' credit card without his consent was karma for being such a stuck-up cheapskate all those years on Pearl's birthday.

[@artbytesia]

Yeah, he did deserve that.

[@marvinthemaniac7698]

@@artbytesia I'm glad someone else agrees.

[@artbytesia]

@@marvinthemaniac7698 I do like the episode, I just don't like how Mr. Krabs was written. Krabs, can't you think about ANYTHING BESIDES money for once?

[@spectatorsturner]

It’s an Animated Atrocity,

[@OldworkbyEmmaCRB]

So Pearl is turning 16 in this episode yet in an old episode she had her junior prom?

[@jaelie8398]

OldworkbyEmmaCRB Spongebob doesn't really have a specific timeline

[@DAMDOC]

It's because He knows that she's not his kid

[@vestonbruno2795]

Next time, maybe you should put "Rule of Dumb" in number two instead.

[@isobelmiller7464]

Yeah, the part where Squidward says he likes Boys Who Cry is just out of character for him. But I actually think he might've just been trying to make Mr. Krabs feel better. I mean, his performance, if he really liked them, wouldn't he care about putting on a better show. He was probably just making up that song he sang.

[@raszze]

It wasn’t out of character considering he could’ve said it in order to perform on stage.

[@isobelmiller7464]

@@raszze Good point.

[@crystalmaiden7791]

People can like multiple different genres of music. I'm a metalhead, I still like a couple pop songs, despite liking a bunch of metal-esque bands. Why can't someone like both classical music and one boy band?

[@AutisticTransbian04]

Am I the only one who likes this episode

[@sherilyngaston6877]

pls review Phineas and ferb.

[@ladyaceina]

wait wasnt this up before

[@BeansRUs]

Yeah i could've sworn i watched this before i left for school

[@808bloo]

It was earlier I'm sure something happened or maybe two videos are out

[@memeworld2217]

i like that episode i think is overhated to me frunny scene is squidward saying 4 ply

[@VidyaBros1]

Wait, how is No Hat For Pat a good episode? That episode was so horrible. It was a Patrick torture porn done completely wrong. After everything we have all seen Patrick do, I surprisingly actually felt sorry for him because of this episode. And also, he did absolutely nothing wrong in that episode. All he wanted was to have a job so he can feel useful and have a work hat. I never thought after seeing everything horrible Patrick has done after the first movie came out that he'd ever gain sympathy ever again from me. But this episode just made me feel so bad for him. Like how I felt bad for Mr. Krabs in Pat No Pay because he did absolutely nothing wrong in that episode, all he wanted was to be paid for his merchandize. That was a Mr. Krabs torture porn done horribly wrong.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

***** Yeah, you're supposed to feel Patrick. The episode put Patrick through heck, but gave him the happy ending he deserved. He was being used, and SpongeBob even was willing to go against Krabs to defend Pat. The episode was explicitly about how wrong it was for Patrick to do sell himself out. Bad things happening to a character don't automatically make an episode bad. Drama has to come from somewhere. It's not like a Squid torture episode where squid is somehow the bad guy and all the torture is "ok" according to the episode because SB and Pat weren't intentionally hurting him. That's utter garbage because squid is put through the wringer for very little reason, and usually doesn't even get a happy ending. No hat for pat is a well defined story about Patrick wanting something so badly, he would do anything to get it. If you want to hear more, check out the review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/r5zHXoZ_mZKJnMUh17m3s

[@VidyaBros1]

***** thanks. Btw I love your episodes. I watch them all the time and I love Mr. Enter's videos. Our channel is a let's play channel but also a few months ago we started doing reviews, starting with Teen Titans Go. Any advice you got for starting out? Because we do want to do more reviews in the future and balance doing that with doing let's plays.