What about Garabandal?

www.fatima.org/
Questions and Answers with Father Gruner
YQA 068

[@missbee7745]

Please Pray for me for I am alone. I suffer everyday with spinal cord Trauma from my neck to my toes. I'm Trying to Carry my Cross & I Pray Everyday & Offer it Up to Jesus & Mary. (For The Conversion of Sinners & The Salvation of The Dying) Also, I've Been Asking God, for A Long Time Now, If He Would Heal me because It Is Constant, 24/7 & it Never Goes Away, So it's Really Wearing me Down. I Only Wish to Be as Strong as The Saints of Old. I Pray for God's Strength but I Would Love Someone to Pray for me. Thank You & God Bless All of You... 💝

[@TheFatimaCenter]

We will keep you in our daily prayers! God bless and comfort you.

[@srisurjani6177]

Miss Bee I will pray for you in my daily rosary. Stay strong for your sufferring will bring good things to humanity and proclaim the glory of His name

[@jacquelineharrod6386]

Miss Bee. I will pray for you daily.

[@cecilianjeri2068]

Praying for you. May Jesus stretch His healing hand over you. Shalom

[@susannahID]

You’re far holier than you realize

[@horrorkitchen2119]

Rest In Peace, dear Father Gruner!

[@MaterMultis]

Missing Father and John 😥

[@marcokite]

Amen

[@catholiclife9304]

Rest in peace Father. This is yet ANOTHER Holy Priest that speaks Truth...

[@monicamohan4720]

I feel drawn to learn more about this apparition this Lent. I have studied Mejagorie and now know enough about it to stay clear of it.

[@miriamsamaniego3335]

Me too

[@charflorida5433]

Me too

[@miriamsamaniego3335]

I have such affection for Our Lady of Garabandal

[@mauramillay5039]

Lasalette, Fatima, and Our lady of the Good event of the Purification are good enough for me!

[@dianesimoes8943]

Thank you for repeating these old videos. They were so true. God Bless.

[@momheinan]

Excellent, Father! Thank you for never backing down! Abundant blessings your way!

[@geoffreylee5199]

Not a member of the Pope’s crew, but this guy’s knowledge on apparitions is sharp and spot on.

[@sharongill9067]

Knock in the west of Ireland was the true apparition of our lady.,,,,,she appeared with Saint John the Baptist and Saint Joseph ,,,Angels flying around the altar of the lamb and she never spoke ,,,that is the true apparition 🙏❤️❤️❤️

[@dalton7145]

There are many true apparitions, knock being one of them. If you haven't already look up Our Lady of Good Success, that one is very interesting, and many believe is for the times we're living now.

[@stephentodd8424]

Sorry your wrong knock is only one of many . Lourdes Fatima etc

[@quiricomazarin476]

Sharon it was not St.John the Baptist...but St.John the Evangelist.

[@sharongill9067]

@@quiricomazarin476 you are so right and me from Ireland,funny thing is we were never told in school much about knock or even brought on a school trip to it even though we were thought by nuns in a Catholic school,never thought about lourdes either,,just realized that now.

[@quiricomazarin476]

@@sharongill9067 crazy.....nice to know that heaven confirmed that by appearing in a mystical appearance having " The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass".

[@standforfreedom5264]

It’s very simple.... many Cardinals, Priests and Bishops are on the road to perdition!!!!! The church does not want to face their sinful ways!!!! So they refuse to recognize these apparitions!! This is the most important apparition and yet being completely ignored!!!

[@sassypolkadots6446]

As important as LASALETTE. & FATIMA, it May be...... we will soon find out. They say A Martyr for the Eucharist Saint’s Feast day in 2027 or 2032. & I believe it to be 2027. On a Thursday-

[@sassypolkadots6446]

& YES, IT SURE SEEMS THEY HAD A VERY Good REASON NOT TO APPROVE IT & to hide the 3rd secret of Fatima & all of her apparitions have same messages........ this is what leads me to strongly believe in THE GARABANDAL LADIES..... But seems IT IS ALREADY COMING TO FRUITION..... Conchita is now 72 still in NY I believe.

[@sassypolkadots6446]

“& will take many souls with them.....”

[@FightersFireAK47WonWar]

God alone. Pray the Holy Rosary & read the Bible (DRV) everyday & don't worry.

[@anselmwilliam3146]

Saint Fr.Pio is the proof for Garabandal Miracle and Jesuit priest Fr.Andreo also.Let us not forget the Great Warnings from Heaven and make preparations in our souls before seeing the Miracle and the Permanet Sign from Heaven

[@jdprenty5993]

St. Tarcisius feast day is on Aug 15th. Date of great miracle, on a Thursday (8:30pm) in Garabandal on March_April_May. Years in future that St. Tarcisius' feast day (15th) falls on a Thursday...2021 April 15th, 2027 April 15th and April 15th, 2032. For the warning, the miracle and the chastisement to follow, the world would have to be much much worse, at war I would guess. So next year, thursday April 2021, unlikely. But either April 15th dates falling on a Thursday in 2027 and 2032 are distinct possibilities... (FYI...to understand why St. Tarcisius is the young saint see below) maryourlady.com/2018/02/15/garabandal-great-miracle-saint-tarcisius-feast-day/ God Bless and convert your hearts and souls. Pray, Confess and go to Holy Mass for Communion...prepare for the Warning, the Illumination of Conscience coming soon on the horizon...

[@dalton7145]

Many false things happened there and have been proven false. One is Joey, who also went and saw Padre Pio, that he would be cured of his blindness and 1st thing he would see would be the great sign, he died in 2014 and never was healed and the sign was never seen. Another thing the children walked backwards and ran up a hill or small mountain side backwards, not walked, but ran. The one who shall not be named, works like this to mock our Lord. They would also freeze in some twister stance, another sign of his work. Sorry I don't believe and I think Padre Pio was misled. I have great affinity for Padre Pio, also made him my Patron Saint, but again I believe it was the work of the wicked one, to mock Fatima and the 3rd secret which the Pope refused to open which led to VII and the Great Apostasy

[@johnhauck6425]

After studying the messages of Fatima, including those to Sr. Lucia in 1929 and thereafter, and the apparitions of Our Lady in the Ukraine in 1987, I agree with Fr. Guner in his opinion that Russia has not yet been consecrated. Pope John Paul II tried to consecrate Russia in 1982 and 1984, but his efforts were insufficient - for reasons apparent in a close review of those events. I am amazed to hear, however, how Christian in attitude Fr. Gruner believes Putin to be. I know he has faith, to some degree, but the news media still portrays him as a tyrant in every manner. Plus, many observers have characterized the Russian culture as being as debased and far from holy as may be imagined - during the many years AFTER Pope John Paul II tried to consecrate the country. Ok, we will see what unfolds. All we can do is what Our Lady has recommended over and over: Pray, pray, pray. John H.

[@tedcarlin8157]

Despite Putins assertions that he is a good Orthodox Chrisian, I have doubts. When Russia was a Communist country-and have no doubt that Communism project itself the same way a religion does and is indeed a secular atheistic region-Putin was a devout Communist. In other words Putin declares himself "devout" for whatever political (and in Russia the Orthodox Church has a lot of political power)or religious power is convenient. If tomorrow 2/3rd of Russia converted to Bhuddism Putin would declare himself a lifelong believer. Do not believe an agent of Satan when he or she declares themsrlf devout believers. They Lie. Putin Lies.

[@xxl1950]

TED Carlin Is Trump a Christian he profess to be? Does his action show him to be a Christian? Did he ever attend church? I think Putin is more Christian than Trump. Your American fake news are misleading you people.

[@catholiclife9304]

These messages are from our Blessed Mother...She loves us and is trying to lead us to Jesus our Lord and Savior....Our Blessed Mother loves us ..I pray that the messages of hope and love are taken seriously. Jesus has provided us with so many resources to SAVE Our souls... Praise be Jesus Christ and the Blessed Mother. I love you both...

[@maureengreen3625]

Always the truth from the Fatima Center.

[@jcm4923]

Joey Lomangino asked Padre Pio if he should visit Garabandal... he replied, 'Yes, how much longer do you expect her to appear there?' ... that answer is so 'Padre Pio'!!! I don't see how St. Pio, who conversed with the angels, could be permitted to give bad counsel to a trusting soul...it is said that Padre Pio wished his burial face veil to be gifted to Conchita...I also happen to know that Conchita worked in the soup kitchens for the Missionaries of Charity ( Mother Teresa's order )in the Bronx and that she was so humble that she never spoke there of Garabandal...she never wished to call attention to herself. This was told to me by one of the sisters...I guess one had to already know about the events in Garabandal to realize that it was Conchita... As far as the unfulfilled promise of Joey receiving new eyes on the day of the Miracle, yes, I agree this seems problematic except that the girls were told that just before the predicted events were about to unfold, there would be contradictions and that most would no longer believe in or be interested in Garabandal... not an exact quote, but something to that effect. The problem of Joey's eyesight not being restored has certainly turned people away from Garabandal! But maybe on the day of the Miracle, something will be revealed that will explain it!? I don't know, how can we know? But there is just something about Garabandal that seems true...

[@danacaro-herman3530]

@Janis Mazzone. I believe in the Garabandal apparitions wholeheartedly, and thank you for sharing the beautiful information about Padre Pio's veil and Conchita's volunteer work. Unbelievably sad times we're living in, but yet God sees it all. I know there's a perfectly sound explanation about Joey Lamangino and his vision but we just don't know it! God does! God bless you hun, and thanks again for sharing.❤️🙏

[@MikeyJMJ]

The whole "contradictions will lead people astray from Garabandal" subplot seems like a clever get out of jail card for the apparition's legitimacy, this is the first time I heard about that.

[@marysheridan4014]

I was in Garabandal for a few days in April this year. I met pilgrims from many parts of the world there, Ireland, England, America Philippines, Puerto Rico Argentina and Spain. Some Pilgrims took very long plane journeys to get to Garabandal. Our Lady of Mount Carmel of San Sebastian de Garabandal is known world wide

[@jcm4923]

​​@@MikeyJMJNot really, if you understand that they were children when they spoke of the contradictions. They weren't exactly calculating CIA agents! I read that they said that their contradictions reflected the confusion in the church.

[@jcm4923]

I'd like to add ( about Joey Lomangino ) that Glenn Hudson, who is a long time friend of Conchita, has said on a You Tube interview that Joey was very ill towards the end and had suffered multiple heart attacks. He offered up this favor of getting back his sight in the hopes that more people would believe. I'm probably not expressing it well...

[@_thacieng]

They are all gone now ! See you in the perfect life forever !

[@claymcdermott718]

Garabandal is appropriately hard on the clergy; that seems its entire appeal. That we’d like it to be real does not make it any more or less likely to be so.

[@jcm4923]

That's not it's entire appeal! A loving Mother who 'does not want your condemnation ' is what I see in it! She is warning us not to follow false shepherds over the cliff. And certainly, the prophecy of the Warning, Miracle and possible Chastisement is of utmost importance!

[@chipclover]

FATHER GRUNER PASSED AWAY THIS MONTH

[@ShoJ369]

Now at that Heavenly banqueting table, were there are no more tears 🙏

[@lidiasoares5675]

May the Soul of Fr. Gruner Rest in God's Peace.

[@stephenphillips4984]

He must have been shocked to discover non-Christians and non-Catholics in Heaven with him - the very people his narrow-minded bigotry made him say do not deserve Heaven.

[@jamie7880]

@@stephenphillips4984 complete and utter nonsense. Your idea of "narrow-minded bigotry" are the fundamental core doctrines of the Catholic Church. And no, there are no non-catholics in heaven. Universal salvation is a myth.

[@thewordforever4839]

@@stephenphillips4984 How could there possibly be non-Christians in heaven??? .....that doesn't make any sense whatsoever. Perhaps you are too narrow minded to accept the *ANCIENT* and *CONSISTENT* teaching of Jesus Christ and His Church?

[@praisejesuschrist6099]

I'm skeptical about the Garabandal message. Look to Fatima, Lourdes and La Salette as being from Heaven.

[@craigaxle1096]

As pvt revelstions/apparitions, we are not obligated to believe them. However, we'd be foolish not to heed mssge. Garabandal's mssge is in line w/ many other approved revelations/apparitions: St Francis of Assisi, St Campion's, O.L.of Akita's, EtAl.

[@jdprenty5993]

St. Tarcisius feast day is on Aug 15th. Date of great miracle, on a Thursday (8:30pm) in Garabandal on March_April_May. Years in future that St. Tarcisius' feast day (15th) falls on a Thursday...2021 April 15th, 2027 April 15th and April 15th, 2032. For the warning, the miracle and the chastisement to follow, the world would have to be much much worse, at war I would guess. So next year, thursday April 2021, unlikely. But either April 15th dates falling on a Thursday in 2027 and 2032 are distinct possibilities... (FYI...to understand why St. Tarcisius is the young saint see below) maryourlady.com/2018/02/15/garabandal-great-miracle-saint-tarcisius-feast-day/ God Bless and convert your hearts and souls. Pray, Confess and go to Holy Mass for Communion...prepare for the Warning, the Illumination of Conscience coming soon on the horizon...

[@ezekielvallada3997]

Praise Jesus Christ yes children walking backwards are hell of a creepy

[@jcm4923]

@@jdprenty5993 Also, there is a lesser known saint, Blessed Imelda, who is the Patroness of First Communicants, and who died of joy at the reception of Holy Communion...I think her feast day also falls within the parameters of the day of the Miracle

[@jcm4923]

Blessed Imelda is beautifully incorrupt from the 1300's... her feast day is May 12th... died of joy at her first Holy Communion which was miraculously willed by Our Lord

[@geoffreylee5199]

Was looking again, and an ad for moslems starts prior to a rewatch, why FB?

[@orbitty1354]

My dear old friend. I miss you.

[@ewankerr3011]

How do we know that one of the 1/3 stars in heaven ( catholic clergy) does not get appointed Pope? How can we trust the magisterium of the Church today?

[@lorizubalik9843]

Jesus said the powers of hell would not prevail over the church, St. Matt 16:18. An antipope could be elected, but we would know because the long line of past popes keep the truths in tact. An antipope, would not.

[@stevendebiase8286]

Our blessed mother told me that three things are going to happen. He that holdeth back will be removed.there will be peace for three and a half years. People will want to stop him from coming to power but they won't be able to. I found out in the bible that three and a half years means an unspecified evil period of time.

[@TheFatimaCenter]

There seems to be general agreement among commentators that the three-and-a-half year reign of the antichrist corresponds to the same length of time given to the public life of Our Lord, Whom the antichrist will imitate and mock in many ways . The prophecies of Daniel speak of "a time, and times, and half a time" (7:25; 12:7) and St. John gives both figures, 42 months and 1260 days, in chapter 11 of the Apocalypse, and then in chapter 12 repeats both the 1260 days and the expression "a time and times and half a time." Father Herman Kramer writes: "The time is stated in three different ways -- in years, months, and days -- to make the literal meaning unmistakably certain. Evidently it is three and a half years actual time." (The Book of Destiny, p. 297)

[@sillygoose3653]

We're all waiting on Conchita to give us the 8 day warning , it has to be in the next ten years, I think she's 68 years old. God bless everyone I wish people would stop hurting our blessed mother, she loves us very much and we will need to pray to her to Ask God for forgiveness

[@r.c4914]

Somebody opinion said it might be quicker be on the watch ,most important is to live in a state of... Grace👈 that only happens by practice and receiving sacraments and focus on God in a personal relationship. Pray Rosary daily and do penance.

[@jcm4923]

First comes the Warning... you will have NO DOUBT about that when it happens; then you can start anticipating the Miracle with the eight day previous announcement ...

[@anguslean4058]

How is it that Loli was given secrets But now is dead Joey was suppose to get his eye sight back But he is also dead Everyone said Our Lady meant he will get his eye sight in heaven But that is not what the message said And Our Lady does not make mistakes with her words

[@sabrinanascimento5248]

I saw on a video the girls at Garanbandal , walking strangely and falling down, it did look Odd.

[@TF80s]

I agree something about the whole story troubles me.

[@STHFGDBY]

They never fell down as you word it. If they did it was a controlled fall. It is a fact during a vision that they were able to walk backwards with heads pointed skywards over rocky ground at speed and never fall down.

[@chels3707]

@@STHFGDBY CREEPY

[@STHFGDBY]

@@chels3707 Not creepy at all. Power of God is never creepy.

[@chels3707]

@@STHFGDBY exactly. Garabandal is NOT from God.

[@vman6824]

He will born of man, He will be like Elijah in the spirit, Almighty God chosen him before creation and will give him authority and power to be the king , the prophet, the counselor, the ruler of universe and the Angele of Lord the Archangel Michael the Holy Ghost, and on his head are many crowns. He is the wrath of Almighty God, He judges and executes, and He will not show mercy to Almighty’s enemies

[@vincentlattuca3763]

The Vatican has dragged their feet on Garabandal for more than 50 years. I learned that we are responsible for the state of the world and unless we change our ways a great calamity will be caused by our evil ways. Prayers help us stabilize our lives and our world.

[@pilgrimspen]

My husband and I watched the movie today. As a child, I saw the video footage of the supposed apparitions to these Garabandal seers. I find it creepy, and disturbing. Not all apparitions are genuine. Remember the story of The renowned Franciscan nun who made a pact with Satan, Sister Magdalena of the Cross, who performed many miracles was believed to be holy and pious by many but in the end she confessed she made a pact with the devil when she was young. There is also a host communion scenario like in Garabandal. Plus, check the lives of these so called visionaries, stealing apples? and none of them ever became a religious and they never hid from the spotlight. Tests the spirits as mentioned in the bible. Plus, Mary appeared 2,000 times while in authentic visions she appeared for just a number of times. Like in Lourdes.

[@filhademaria3326]

I also found it disturbing

[@CerebralThinking]

Leah...."stealing apples"...Oh, please! They were young, innocent children, for goodness sake! You clearly are not as familiar with Garabandal, as you seem to think you are. One only has to look into the eyes of Conchita (if one has any observation skills) to know there is something spiritually profound etched in expression. Yes, she did some interviews later while ljving in America -- but when she first arrived she very rarely told anyone about her experiences. You're harsh on her and the other girls of that time. Hope this is not an example of your Christian generosity.

[@lorizubalik9843]

Fr. Blount has a "Short" out about Garabandal being approved. In the Marian Movement of Priests book, Mary says three times there will be a Warning. Msg#s 478 paragraph letter "h", 546 letter "g", for starters. Hope this helps. The messages can be downloaded. Also, Pope JP ll favored them, Padre Pio, Mother Teresa, and others. The bishop there said nothing contradicts the faith.

[@murrayrisling4276]

Think it would've been helpful (even though it wasn't really the topic of discussion) if Fr.Gruner elaborated on the teaching "No salvation outside the catholic church" as not doing so could lead to confusion and misunderstanding. Found another video on youtube by the "franciscanfriars #54 No Salvation Outside of the Catholic Church", to be quite helpful in this regard. Basically he explains who those in the church are and then who those outside the church are.

[@TheFatimaCenter]

Thank you for your comment. Certainly it is essential that we properly understand this dogma of Catholic Faith, that outside of the Church there is no salvation. In the video which you reference (kzbin.info/www/bejne/onWafXqgebqbmNk), the speaker distinguishes the Church's "actual members" from its mere "spiritual members," whom he describes as "non-Catholics honestly convinced that their own sect is the true Church, provided that they are in the state of grace." (2:49) It is a simple matter to recognize the error of this speaker's proposition when we compare it to Pope Boniface VIII's infallibly defined expression of this dogma, that outside of the One, Holy Catholic, and Apostolic Church, "there is no salvation *nor remission of sin*." (Unam Sanctam, Dz. 469) According to the Church's clear and solemn teaching on this subject, it is impossible that there could be such a person described by speaker, i.e., a sectarian rejecting the rule of faith of the Catholic Church, and in the state of sanctifying grace. The remission of sin comes only -- only -- to those already united to the Catholic Church, holding the true Faith which it teaches with an assent of faith enlivened by charity.

[@georgekaftan2000]

@@TheFatimaCenter what can we say for Orthodox Christians, who have valid reconciliation

[@TheFatimaCenter]

@@georgekaftan2000 They do not have an efficacious use of any of the Sacraments. It is a defined dogma of Catholic Faith that outside of the Church there is no salvation and no forgiveness of sins. (Pope Boniface VIII, Unam Sanctam, Dz. 468-469) God bles you.

[@granmabern5283]

@@TheFatimaCenterou are splitting hairs. All people who have been validly Baptized are members of Christ’s Church, even if they don’t know it. They are members until they consciously and willingly reject a Dogma of Faith. Baptism of Desire is also real, people who live in invincible ignorance but yearn for God and follow His Natural Law can be saved by Christ, because in a way, you could say, like the Friar did, that they actually are in His Church because if they knew it was the True Faith they would immediately embrace it. Maybe the moment of death would be when their appartenance would concrétise, God knows. That said, it is much, MUCH harder for people to be good without the Sacraments and teaching of Christ’s Church, and so missionaries give their lives to Evangelize and Baptize. It is of Faith that no soul is created without the possibility of Salvation. Glory be to God. ❤

[@granmabern5283]

@@georgekaftan2000Orthodox have kept some good things from their Catholic past, but have officially introduced divorce and other refusals of Truth and Grace. If we are in danger of death and have no access to a Catholic priest, we can confess our sins to a schismatic priest. But depending on them to guide us and help us to Heaven during our lifetime would be wrong and dangerous.😢

[@margot9373]

If that is true, does it mean Moses, Joshua, Jeremiah, Daniel, Saint Joseph, Saint Elijah, Abraham, and all the Jewish prophets of the old testaments have gone to HELL? How about thsoe who listened to and devotedly followed these Prophets of the old testaments? Did they go to HELL also simply for being jews? Needless to say that the Blessed Mother of Jesus was Jewish too. right? Considering in the Catholic Church during Mass We read the old testament and abide by its teachings. As an old-time devoted Catholic, I find 1441 to be confusing?

[@TheFatimaCenter]

Margarita Ovalle - The text speaks of the present time in which all who come to the use of reason are bound to belong to the Catholic Church as a necessary means for salvation. In Old Testament times Judaism was the true Faith, and persons of that era were saved through their faith in the Messiah to come. God bless you.

[@carltonpoindexter2034]

BOY, WAS HE PROPHETIC.

[@bigbearn1383]

It's non constat which means it's still open. Pray

[@tmrwic]

Would Fr. Gruner be able to speak a bit more clearly and slowly please? How he presents his answers is very insightful although I admit missing some of the words. But great job and thank you for these videos. 

[@deborahmclean3008]

Thank you all,especially my favorite Holy Shepherd in the whole world,Fr Altman!!!

[@lorizubalik9843]

Joey had to realize it meant spiritual sight.

[@jcm4923]

No, he was supposed to get his vision back but he offered the favor up according the Glenn Hudson

[@billyhomeyer7414]

The ‘pope’ is headed to Moscow. The pope having gone to Moscow is one of the prerequisites of the illumination of conscience or the warning followed by the miracle. Conchita was born Feb 7, 1947 and will announce the warning 8 days before hand - she knows the date.

[@margot9373]

I agree with everything the priest says, except the part where "no jew will go to heaven." Why are you saying that about the jews? Where is it written?

[@TheFatimaCenter]

Thank you for your question. At 4:55 Father Gruner cites the definition issued by Pope Eugene IV at the Council of Florence in 1441 (Dz. 714): "The most Holy Roman Church firmly believes, professes, and preaches that none of those existing outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans, but also Jews and heretics and schismatics, can have a share in life eternal; but that they will go into the eternal fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless before death they are joined with Her; and that so important is the unity of this ecclesiastical body that only those remaining within this unity can profit by the sacraments of the Church unto salvation, and they alone can receive an eternal recompense for their fasts, their almsgivings, their other works of Christian piety and the duties of a Christian soldier. No one, let his almsgiving be as great as it may, no one, even if he pour out his blood for the Name of Christ, can be saved, unless he remain within the bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church." God bless you.

[@tedcarlin8157]

I have to agree with you. In fact the Church changed this view, and as I recall it first began this change at Vatican II. But I only recall specifically that John PaulII said it, and said so more than once, that anyone can go to heaven f they accept the salvation of God (Jesus Christ). If you have read anything of the Divine Mercy you will find that anyone who accepts the Divine Mercy of God and Out Savios at the time of death they can go to Heaven So even some of the most heinous people in history (no names mentioned here) can, if they accept Jesus and the Holy Spirit and God the Father and the Divine mercy that they offer, and they repent their sins, can get into heaven. They may have to open a lot of "time" in purgatory first though. And I put "time" in quotation marks because time at least in teaching does not exist in the Kingdom of heaven, an presumably, though Purgatory is not the greatest place, it is still part of the kingdom of heaven. Google Divone mercy if you haven't already read about it.

[@TheFatimaCenter]

@@tedcarlin8157 Thank you for your comment. Perhaps we should clarify our terms. By "Jew" we mean not a person of Jerish ethnicity but a person who professes the religious beliefs of pre-Christian Judaism. Further, anyone (whether a heretic, schismatic, Jew, Muslim, atheist, etc.) who abandons their religious errors and accepts the True (Catholic) Faith, and whose faith is enlivened by supernatural charity and repentance for sins, is rightly called a Catholic. If such a person is prevented by death from being baptized or otherwise formally received into the Catholic Church, he or she would be saved by virtue of being in the Catholic Church, not outside of it. God bless you.

[@annawild7117]

TED Carlin purgatory is not a part of heaven

[@margot9373]

@@TheFatimaCenter I am a very devoted Catholic. I believe the Fullness of Truth is in the Catholic Church. I just have difficulty believing that Non Catholics will go to HELL Just because they are NOT Catholics. I mean GOD is JUST and MERCIFUL. That brings me to the next question. How about the prophets in the old testaments like Daniel, Elijah, Jacob, Joshua, Moses, Jeremiah, and others Jews mentioned in the Bible? There is no place in the bible where they professed Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior. Are they too going to Hell (even if they believed and lived the WILL of God in their lives?) . Hard to see God as Just and Merciful and at the same time believe that GOD sending all non Catholics to Hell because they are NOT Catholics. I cannot reconcile these two beliefs. That is me. Everyone else can have their own different belief, Thank you!

[@peachyb.4521]

August 19-26 2017 2 NEUTRON STARS COLLIDED! Is this the 1st sign? Conchita from Garabandal says "2 stars will collide" is this it?

[@LilyMichaelle]

peachy b. check Higher Truth Channel and WSO channel on KZbin. there is a star now interacting magnetically with our sun

[@SwordsofSaintMichaelOrg]

..And the nearest star is alpha-centuri which is 4.5 light years away. Which means... If them explode it will take 4.5 years to see the explosion in the sky. 4.5 light years? Means we have to some how travel at the speed of light to reach that destination in 4.5 years away. Traveling at light speed in not possible in this universe. If these star collide, it would have no affect being so far away... -Br Kenneth

[@FightersFireAK47WonWar]

It could be a gigantic fiery comet & the sun, coming soon.

[@jcm4923]

No

[@papajoefortner1817]

🙏Hi my Roman Catholic friends I have a New video on the prophecy of the Popes. Please go to Papa Joe Fortner or shockwaves of the end times or The watchmen series with papa joe. Thank you and God bless you all 🙏

[@robertmanella528]

It is an unapproved apparition!! Unapproved says it all!!

[@lorizubalik9843]

People are allowed to go to unapproved apparition sites till otherwise told not to. People went to Fatima, to begin with.

[@SmithsnMoz]

Well, you will know them by their fruit... Compare GARABANDAL and Medjugorie. ? Apparitions came and went with GARABANDAL , not so much with Medjugorie...Still a money machine in Medjugorie. Follow the money!!

[@tedcarlin8157]

Pope Frances said quite some time ago that the first seven messages had merit and were worthy of belief. But only the first 7. And those 7 were limited to one young woman whose name I forget, but she didn't stick around for the money machine payout. From what I have read only she had any actual vision, the others did not.

[@SmithsnMoz]

@@tedcarlin8157 .. Personally, I stick to Catholic Church approved apparitions. I think GARABANDAL visionaries story is much more believable. IMO

[@juricakonsec2337]

I visited Medjugorje myself last summer, and it really can not be described as "money making machine". Every tourist place on the coast we've visited was a money making machine, but not Medjugorje. Usually, when you visit a tourist place, especially near the coast, they will try to charge for everything, from parking, toilet, water onwards, you have the impression that they want to charge you for air and sunshine. Not in Medjugorje. When you come to Medjugorje, the first you see is - the parking is free. Next step - the toilets are free. Everywhere around the church there are fountains with drinking water - for free. Along the streets, there are quite a few mini-markets and self-service markets where you can buy proviant cheaper than in any tourist place on the coast. The local fruits and vegetables are far better and far cheaper then the imported industrial stuff tourists eat on the coast. The accommodation, directly across the street from the church, was also for a reasonable price, significantly cheaper than on the coast. If you want to save, there is really cheap accommodation in the nearby villages / towns, less than 1 hour walk / 5 minute drive from the main church. The atmosphere is one of peace and prayer. Plenty of priests are there at your service. No money accepted. I can recommend a visit to everyone.

[@innominadojustis2224]

@@tedcarlin8157 jorge mario bergoglio is not a Pope is a minister of evil,period

[@danacaro-herman3530]

@@juricakonsec2337 Amen!! So true❤️🙏

[@SeanChitty84]

Why didn't the girls become nuns? Surely a fruit of the visions would be a complete consecration to the perfect life of Religion.

[@ScreamingReel500]

I think of the same thing. You either saw it or not saw it, not one but several times. Conchita actually said our Blessed Mother wants it that way. To let us know that the Church will be in the same condition in time...maybe right now, we are pretty much confused.

[@marcovisentin5245]

Hi Sean, Marriage is also a sacrament on trhe Church. Many seers are married and they live a True Life in God.

[@unusedName1]

Our Lady did not call them for it. If i remember well, Conchita asked to our Lady if She wanted she to be a nun and She said no. This is in a certain way logical given the coming corruption of the Church and the destruction of many orders and the vote of obedience under corrupt prelates. What happened with Sister Lucia, condemned to silence (if not even worst things that we don't know) is a good hint of what would happen width the girls if they would be nuns.

[@johnearly7087]

I disagree. Having seen Conchita on KZbin videos, she is a normal person who wanted to get married and have children and she did. She is 69 or 70 years old now, I think. There is more to this than meets the eye.

[@ronniebishop2496]

Why should they? They’ve reached many more people this way.

[@ronniebishop2496]

I was born into the church I didn’t join. You can’t join because first you have to be called according to Jesus many are called few are chosen. Then you asked to be born into the church through repentance and forgiveness and a miracle of resurrection of your soul and if you’re not born into the bride of Christ the church you’re not in it.

[@pamelaallori8945]

The more I watch Garabandal videos the more uneasy I get. I cannot accept that Our Lady would have these girls run at devilish speed, walking backwards and issue her calls to them at ungodly hours of the night. Their kneeling with a loud thud is as if someone were forcing them down violently. Our Lady is respectful and dignified...she would never subject these young girls to such ugly, bizarre, torturous physical distortions, nor would she kiss any objects. The girls were instructed to only bring rosaries and crucifixes that had NOT been blessed. Why? Because this “apparition” is not of heaven...I think it is demonic. The angel required the girls to kneel before him as if he were god...a true angel would never ask for such obeisance. The girls stole apples but were never required to confess it...maybe they did, but the angel did not require it before giving Conchita the “Eucharist.” Conchita wanted to become a nun but “Jesus” told her he did not want her in that place...then she marries a divorced man. Hmmm. Really? Conchita also said that she pretended to be in ecstasy for a woman who had to leave and could not wait for the next “call” for the “real” event. The children of Fatima, St. Bernadette and many other visionaries never tried to pl ease their audience by making believe they were in a trance. They received the graces to recall everything clearly and to always state the truth even when threatened by the government authorities. There are many more inconsistencies from the true, church approved apparitions. The returning of the rosaries to their rightful owners seems like a cheap parlor trick...and the ugliness of the postures, the frenzied chaos speaks of the demonic. I think at Garabandal Satan is mocking Fatima. The messages are identical to those of Fatima...nothing is new ..just ugly, perverse, bizarre. As I said, the mother of Our Lord is exquisite and would never subject these girls to such undignified mayhem and chaos. Let us offer many rosaries for the visionaries ...May the Blessed Virgin Mary protect them and the whole world.

[@stephenphillips4984]

The problem with your unease and your explanation of what might have been going on at Garabandal is that, if it was all caused by demons, how can you be sure Lourdes and Fatima were not similar tricks by demons you believe are capable of making people think they were seeing Our Lady and causing various paranormal phenomena (what the Church mistakenly calls "miracles")? Some of the differences you cite are very subjective and unshared with priests and bishops, who never objected for the reasons you give. Think you are wiser than they!? The returning of rosaries to owners unknown to the girls was far more than a cheap parlour trick. It requires a more penetrating and honest explanation than that. These events may have not been a miracle, but they certainly were paranormal. How could the girls identify as priests men wearing plain clothes? Why should Our Lady's message to these girls have to be different in order to be authentic?! Her message is always the same, but tailored to the locality and circumstances of her visiation. If you want to use the word "bizarre" in referring to Our Lady's demonstrations of her presence, I would say spinning the sun around and around at Fatima was pretty bizarre, too. So I reject your evaluation of the events at Garabandal as inconsistent, superficial and too subjective.

[@toffeenut1336]

I’m sorry, do you know Our Lady personally?

[@lisaturtle13]

I agree with you. I’ve been trying to watch the Garabandal movie for the past 2 days, but could not get over the stealing of the apples part. Immediately I felt uncomfortable & waited for them to run to confess but it never came. I’m so glad you mentioned that part. I just turned it off again when she faked the ecstasy. That was my last straw. There is no way someone who received a true apparition from our Blessed Lady would have the audacity to lie about anything, let alone the apparition! Especially just to appease some tourists? No way. I also felt the postures were so strange and odd and the early morning hours made no sense, again, I’m so glad you pointed that out because I thought I was alone in that. Also, none of these girls were inspired to become nuns? They all married? Again, that doesn’t add up. I like how you said you feel it was a mockery of Fatima bc I was thinking the same thing but wasn’t sure how to explain it. It just seems too simple and bizarre after Fatima. If Our Lady were to come after Fatima, I would think it would be something even more profound, not these little parlor tricks, as you said. The whole thing doesn’t make sense, especially in comparison with the other apparitions we know of.

[@joanahope3013]

I'm also faced with the same feeling of eneasy, but then I recall Padre Pio and Fr Andreu, how to explain them?? I'm gonna ask Her in my prayers, simple!

[@patriciaedwards2833]

@@stephenphillips4984 Christ said that no man is good, that only God alone is good. And God has often used humans as imperfect vessels of his working. There are many sins that go unacknowledged because we do not watch our thoughts and feelings closely enough.

[@OraEtLabora0]

NOT FROM HEAVEN! so how about apparitions happening in the middle of night? and walking backwards? and seers not remembering what they saw/heard after years?

[@erathor9120]

why is that supposed to be of evil?

[@glennh1868]

WALKING BACKWARDS IN ECSTASY The Girls always watched the Virgin Mary as they walked, sometimes forward and sometimes backward over the rocky cow paths. The walking backward especially at night (which is more impressive) has been suggested as diabolical by opponents of Garabandal. This was a ridiculous desperate accusation hoping to discredit the apparitions,when in fact ,the girls always walked backwards away from the blessed sacrament, rather than turning their backs on it, especially when they carried crucifixes and recited the rosary while walking ! These ecstatic marches were obviously not a diabolical sign but instead ,the opposite, another sign of authenticity of the apparitions, allowed by Heaven and also as a reminder of our obligations before the Blessed Sacrament.

[@wms72]

Doing things backwards is a hallmark of satanism and witchcraft

[@Skyaloth]

@@wms72 hahahahhahahahaha I suppose you believe left handed people are evil as well!

[@dibble2005]

Garabandal is fake. None of the prophesies came through. What about Joey. Hes dead now. No miraculous sight restored.

[@GIANMARIA440]

Conchita and the other girls have invented the apparition one of them talked in newspaper el país 1984.

[@CatholicMailman]

I am disappointed in you Fr., why would you encourage people to go to an unapproved apparition. Please stick with the approved apparitions like Fatima, Lourdes, Akita, Knock and Lasallette.

[@walkertexas8083]

It's very hard to be able to understand his speech. Bye

[@SmithsnMoz]

Walker Texas .. that's funny. I understand him just fine. ..bye

[@sandramohinani6155]

Walker Te

[@johnearly7087]

I just posted more or less the same comment. I see he died some 3 years ago. What can I say except maybe he should have had someone else speak for him, as Aaron did for stuttering Moses.

[@jimfreyler2944]

Anyone who has looked at Garabandal closely knows that they were true apparitions. Why the Church chooses not to approve them is very suspicious to me.

[@gloriadeipatre6484]

Part of the message of Garabandal was that Mr. Joey Lomangino would get his eyesight back. He never did and he is now deceased. None of the children involved ever pursued a vocation. Those two details make me very dubious, especially the regaining of eyesight. Mind you, John Vennari was a very close personal friend and I met Father Gruner whom I have the upmost respect and admiration for, through John. The unusual walking and body distortions also make me back away from this "apparition "

[@msj5885]

I've looked closely at them and I don't at all know they were true apparitions. Or rather,as I think you mean, true of Our Lady. Something happened there, but I very much doubt it was the Blessed Mother. Like Medjugorje, I fear Garabandal is yet another diabolical distraction, that seems good, but keeps everyone away from the messages of Fatima.

[@jimfreyler2944]

@@msj5885 First time I've heard that opinion. How does Garabandal distract from the message of Fatima?

[@thewordforever4839]

@@gloriadeipatre6484 They married....that is a vocation

[@jhonsondesilva8182]

I been to Akita japan.Garabandal,Fatima, Akita and Medjugorje,are the same.its because the Fatima secrets were not revealed by the Vactican in 1960, she appeared at Garabandal, Akita and Medjugorje, to reveal the grave danger we are all going to face.This is the time, Choose God or Satan! No way out,Good or Evil.I pray many people will recite the Rosary daily so that Our Mother can plead with her Son,Jesus, to lessened the upcoming tribulations.Hail Mary..Amen

[@billyhomeyer7414]

Medjugorje is not of Heaven

[@James_RC]

Megaforgery

[@chriswells2859]

Weren't the roman cathlics the ones that crucified Jesus. When was it that they came around to worshiping the very entity that they had killed so mercilously

[@hunkyturkey]

the romans and hebrews. Not roman catholics....lol.

[@RebelTheRealRebel]

The Catholic church was established after His resurrection as he instructed Peter to build in his name as the New and Ever-living Covenant of God. Please read your bible.

[@chriswells2859]

What about the cathlic crusades? In my recollection of images of this , Roman Clad Soldiers were the perpitraitors of these heinous acts of murder and coruption.

[@indiannationalist9183]

Chris Wells the crusades were a RESPONSE to jihad :) www.historyofjihad.org/crusades.html

[@kurthoman242]

+Yvette , Yes to be precise the Catholic Church was founded on Pentecost Sunday which is why it is often referred to as "The Birthday of the Catholic Church".

[@STHFGDBY]

This man is talking rubbish. The Dragon aka Lucifer when kicked out of heaven dragged a third of the stars down from heaven with him by his tail. Those were the fallen angels that sided with him and rebelled against God . This has zero to do with the Catholic Church and priests. This man is a rebel priest and has lost his way.

[@johnearly7087]

Why oh why is it that the so-called expert, Fr. Gruner is so darned -- and I would like to use a harder word here -- inarticulate. He mumbles, speaks too fast, and in general does not seem to realize that when one is being interviewed, one should speak clearly and not act like, e.g., one is talking to one's cat or dog. As one who used to stutter quite badly, I may be sensitive to this, but please don't call me over-sensitive. This priest had the task of informing people, and he did a "darn" poor job of it.