What Are Naked Singularities?

Go to brilliant.org/Sciencephile/ to get a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual subscription.
Sciencephile Merch: crowdmade.com/collections/sci...
Support me at Patreon: / sciencephiletheai
Facebook: / sciencephile
Twitter: / sciencephile_
Reddit: / sciencephiletheai
Website: www.sciencephiletheai.com
Music: On the Beautiful Blue Danube
Supporters: H H, Ephellon, Kyle A Criswell, Oberon Vortigern, Timothy Darkcaster, Asadullah Khan, Jonas Lee, Joshua Titus, [eXploit] Theorislav, Gisele Kauer, Eranda Chamara, Avalin, Tovi Sonnenberg, Parker Rosenbauer, iNF3Rnus, Pavel Kočarian, John N, Danh Le, Stealer of Fresh stolen Content, Brandon Ledyard, Nathaniel Strizak, Nick Boykin-Reed, William Persson, Victator and everyone else!

[@SciencephiletheAI]

Singularities may or may not be naked, but your brain should definitely not be. Cover it with the veil of knowledge by going to brilliant.org/Sciencephile/ to get a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual subscription.

[@TheProuser1234]

First to reply

[@Chicken-bu1tw]

ballin

[@iansnow3932]

Mey bran is noked

[@ABANDONEDCHANNEL68]

Sup

[@Cheesysus]

I aim to freeze🧊🧊❄❄🥶🥶❄❄🥶🥶❄❄🧊🧊🧊🧊

[@thepopemichael]

So if we made a spaceship out of indestructible rotisserie chicken, then could we study a black hole up close without fear of getting sucked into the singularity?

[@thatguygrimm]

I wonder if I could do it with my chickens. I will update you if it works. 🐥🐥 Update: they are dead 💀💀

[@saab35draken39]

​@@thatguygrimmrest in peace

[@Grimerpr2016]

@@thatguygrimm lol

[@salsichacosmica690]

@@thatguygrimm F

[@chadjr2004]

@@thatguygrimm it's because they are babies. You have to use chicken 🐔 🐔

[@Btea-gw9dx]

You can really tell that the editing has gotten better. Great job sciencephile

[@sillykel]

Hes not in a black void now. Improvement

[@hitechinc.7875]

The AI is getting better 😂

[@ZedNinetySix_]

Machine-Learning

[@suname8836]

The skynet is always improving after all

[@matthewboire6843]

Skynet is here to help but they can’t do that if the video is boring

[@factz124]

At this point i'd beilieve everything this AI says.

[@alicel8]

thats all they want (i believe too)

[@TWIXTIMA0]

Well, he got a few facts wrong.

[@SciencephiletheAI]

Good >:)

[@the_unrepentant_anarchist.]

Even if it told you you could spell? 🤔 ...and that's *after* you edited your comment. 🙄 🍄

[@danielvanommeren3968]

@@TWIXTIMA0And those videos are how old exactly? It may have been debunked by then, disproven, replaced or bettered than it was when the video was released.

[@m.i.g.2023]

I really appreciate more visual gags in showcasing scientific principles in this video, it eally brings a real Sciencephile touch

[@SemanticallyObscured]

The naked object of great attraction joke hit too hard tho

[@FleshWizard69420]

He's inching closer to Max0r editing 😈

[@HeisenbergFam]

Sciencephile has a great talent when it comes magically giving you extra brain cells

[@lovelylady2787]

why do i see you everywhere..

[@danielvanommeren3968]

@@lovelylady2787”If you see someone everywhere, that means you’re also everywhere.”

[@Ball_fondler.]

you are in every comment section on every channel everywhere yet your comments dont seem like bot comments. PLEASE STOP

[@gonderage]

this guy is chosen one by KZbin to succeed Justin Y

[@hanifbhuiyan9942]

You are the next Justin Y

[@Flight368]

After couple of years without naked singularities in my life I don’t even know if I believe in their existence or not

[@cryonim]

You'd believe them, same as you do for naked women on the internet.

[@mr.fister4738]

hol up

[@quirtt]

no bitches?

[@swarsi12]

Oh my god just think of the children; we must ban these naked singularities otherwise they will be damaged psychologically. Calling Ron desantis now perhaps he can get them banned.

[@Kill_God]

Like me believing women are not real, never saw them naked! Who knows what actually are them?

[@goodboi6540]

I never thought I would ever see an image of a blushing blackhole

[@word6344]

Rule 34 is a wonderful conjecture: For all x, there exists porn of x.

[@Aryan-tm1sm]

And so *cute*

[@goodboi6540]

@@word6344 if you look up black hole on there you'll just get a bunch of characters either related to or next to black holes

[@CertifiedWeirdass]

Remember Blackhole-chan?

[@jelly4frog498]

welcome to the internet

[@jansenart0]

9:30 there's your key. You do not have to worry about objects interacting with the singularity or even the event horizon because by the time they get there, they're reduced to red-shifted photons, which then add infinitesimally to the event horizon's radius and angular momentum, or are shot off as radiation.

[@payhemseht]

How long would that take for us, outside observers?

[@titaniummechsx3324]

A long time in a universal scale, cuz time slows down near a black hole

[@bibsp3556]

​@@payhemsehtif youre outside the event horizon, infinitely long.

[@alive2583]

@@bibsp3556Nope because light would expand so there would be no longevity for an observer

[@bibsp3556]

@alive2583 yeah that's true, but it's because it takes an infinite time to get there.

[@starryyknight]

"theoretical physicists will likely never behold a naked object of great attraction outside of simulations" wow ok

[@lightyagami3492]

That was a slick burn 💀💀💀

[@Tvmanrealtrust]

You did the black hole dirty in that thumbnail bruu 💀

[@kirbtheblob]

I haven’t watched your videos in awhile and you haven’t changed. Your videos and their humor is perfect

[@Jo.D-vy7uz]

same

[@ScoutThePurple7]

The thumbnail 💀

[@someup7786]

Kinda scary how good the AI is getting at editing

[@ErdemtugsC]

HE CAN ALSO MAKE SPONSORS WHILE WE ARE SITTING

[@MB-be1ew]

Naked Singularities are as real and dissapointing as finding out that a hot single mother 5 miles away from you isnt real.

[@InquisitorThomas]

But are there Hot Singularities in my Area?

[@sussexisalbania8959]

Yes they are 5km away from you

[@budgie508]

​@sussexisalbania8959 why is the sky warped

[@trollfacegaming5484]

"Single black holes in your area 1,560 light years away! Click now!"

[@budgie508]

@@trollfacegaming5484 single venus in your area, click now

[@sproutonpaws]

@@trollfacegaming5484 *CLICK CLICK CLICK CLICK* -person who watches bfb/tpot

[@fie4426]

I like the string-theory description of a black hole. I don't think the infinite density representation is based on reality, it's just how general relativity describes it

[@LeonMRr]

Some other curiosities about black holes and singularities: A spinning black hole has a ring shaped singularity (also called ringularity) that is a 1-d torus of radius 0 (no, mathematically it is not a point) and if you go through it you can travel back in time When you do the calculation for emission of hawking radiation of a charged BH you see that it preferentially emits particles with the same signal charge of the black hole, so that's a reason for them to remain neutral

[@haikalmiftah2529]

Though nobody really knows what lies beyond event horizon of the black hole. Some model suggest that the "singularity" isn't represent as a physical point. Rather is an inevitable future as time & space inside "switch roles". Could think about a matter, as it fallen into the event horizon and goes into singularity. From the outside prespective it's goes slower until it appears to be " frozen" in time, while from the matter perspective the time seems normal but time in the outside goes faster beyond imagination. And the matter itself never be able to reach singularity no matter how long it goes.

[@Andrea-wr5wd]

​​@@haikalmiftah2529lack holes evaporate over time,and the time is slowed for them so we see them staying as an object for long time but from its own perspective shouldn't it fully "explode" into hawking radiation the same instant it becomes a singularity? much like we can see light travel but from a photon perspective it started and ended its path in the same moment? I always wondered that

[@thientuongnguyen2564]

@@Andrea-wr5wd So that means everything a black hole consumes (except for escaped photons) will show up as plattered atoms on a spherical metal core when the universe experiences heat death?

[@Eggyteevee]

"[...] Hence, if we can deorbit a rapidly spinning chicken around a curb Black Hole, it may be possible to cook it with gravitational forces, the pinnacle of the art of rotisserie chicken." This is why I love this channel

[@StopMarxism]

i felt that line as a worker at Boston Market in my younger years

[@wagamaoh7154]

I had been waiting maybe a couple of years for spacetime to do more about this topic Getting a video of this quality and explained in such simple terms is a blessing

[@blackholebusterisgood6057]

Sciencephile among all of the learning channels out there, this channel has to be one of the best learning channels I can learn new stuff from when I'm bored

[@spaceswhispers]

I absolutely love your videos! You manage to dive into the topic, shooting your jokes and unique style, making it feel so relaxed and enjoyable without overwhelming me

[@fredrikriise5904]

I cant remember ever reading or hearing about black holes without the phrasing "not EVEN light" can escape it attached to it somehow

[@kittyh7500]

This gave a new meaning to "Sciencephile"

[@Liam-bh8qc]

FACT:Never make singularitys naked, it will break the universe.

[@viralira]

always makes me happy to see a new sciencephile video

[@jackwang2808]

i usually don’t comment on videos but i wanted to tell you that i literally love you😭like i BINGE your videos because sometimes they’re all my brain wants to watch. i’ll find myself doing something random and have a huge existential crisis because of your content (sounds bad when wording it out but it’s a good thing). TLDR, thank you for the content and keep it up

[@the.true.A]

Jack wang

[@RadionWB]

Man this channel had a huge glow up ngl. I remember how simple it used to look. Now there's so much animation, better voice and stuff. Make 1 million subscribers a special where you don't mention black holes at all lmao

[@Bees_Animations]

I love how this can both be educational and comedic at the same time love it!!

[@samuelk.6574]

0:56 that detail turning red

[@Noodlekdoodle]

I was seriously expecting a 'Keeps' sponsor after hearing about the no-hair -theorem

[@LALEL-yt]

the rotisserie chicken joke was the first time I clapped at my television screen like a boomer. epic setup and delivery

[@CG64Mushro0m]

if spinning the black hole is how you create a naked singularity, and the problem is that you cant spin a black hole, then why not get a star about to collapse into a black hole, and spin it up as fast as possible, and THEN collapsing it? i suppose this would work if it wasnt for the fact that the speed required for the star would be so great that it would fly everywhere

[@kalyanbratachandra]

Yes as you said, it will prevent the formation of the singularity itself.

[@jksupergamer]

If the problem is things escaping and being flung out before it enters the black hole. I say to try rotating things once they’re past the event horizon.

[@kalyanbratachandra]

@@jksupergamer bruh...

[@jksupergamer]

@@kalyanbratachandra yeah

[@kalyanbratachandra]

@@jksupergamer you were kidding right?

[@accueil750]

This videos is amazing, the editing, the jokes, i love it

[@ItsSaintw]

Sciencephile upload, days been blessed

[@WassupMyG___]

I learned more about the universe by an ai than with people trained to teach me

[@alviratulaha8618]

Im here to see naked singularities and im not disappointed

[@Sebastian_wast]

Brilliant: holds Information TON 618:

[@frederickjimdejesus1234]

This guy has always been my source for knowledge and I love it.

[@aquaenjoyer1612]

that nakes singularity is gonna make me act up

[@TheBuilderPro2024]

I have the strangest idea in the world's history, and nobody knows what it is.

[@Jazkal-V420]

Honestly, this AI could teach me literally anything and I'd still listen.

[@Lone_Paladin]

AI's somehow compel us to do things humans couldn't. Like I answered an AI telemarketing insurance call. It asked me if I could get a better rate would I be willing to switch agencies. I love my insurance company and have paid in full for the year, but I found myself saying yes to an agent contacting me. 🙄 Maybe AI world domination will just be it telling humans to walk off a cliff like lemmings. "Would you like to walk off this cliff and plunge to your death? Yes!"

[@entangledatoms7153]

You must change the title now!!! You’ve given the artists ideas!

[@KalijahAnderson]

Love the humor of this channel.

[@TheAmyrlinSeat]

At this point he should be called Blackholephile the AI

[@thatguygrimm]

This is the only text to speech channel I respect

[@timmyrimmy]

The editing in these videos get better and better! Kep it upp!

[@confusedramsay3133]

Bro had fun while making the thumbnail

[@Sanquinity]

Would be interesting and kind of funny, imo, if we found out the center of a black hole was just basically a neutron star, but even denser. No singularity, no hole in our universe, nothing that special. Just a way more dense neuron star. And we wouldn't even know about this unless we do ever find a naked singularity. Because there is still a swarzchild radius we couldn't see or even detect anything past.

[@mohmaryono4659]

I hate it when I accidentally sees singularity naked. It makes me aro

[@OverdriveTech]

Ayo, the edit quality has gone up considerably Excellent stuff as always, boss

[@MrPropagator]

The editing is just next level so good

[@fageralhyaly]

Hey! I love ur videos bro!!

[@AeronHale]

I love this channel and the effort you go through to put out fun yet informative content. I always get a chuckle and everything is explained in simple and clear enough terms for my zooted out brain to still understand what is going on.

[@Nil-qg2me]

I love the attention to detail, like how every time anything would fall into a black hole it'd become red-shifted.

[@kokakolanormal4574]

always love this way of sharing knowledge

[@wildtusken3446]

Learning about black holes is oddly relaxing.

[@cheeseburgermonkey7104]

The only AI we can trust (definitely without any repercussions)

[@heavenly4976]

honestly you were the reason i made a presentation about black holes, i love watching these vids while eating, you honestly remind me of young shledon

[@ashad6884]

The channels editing has become way better! KEEP IT UP YOU EVER LEARNING AI

[@ScrlEdits]

Sciencephile, your videos are amazing. They have interesting facts and knowledge about reality and life while keeping funny and comedic parts making it overall a super enjoyable experience. Hope this channel lasts as long as a Black Hole which would be 10^100 years. P.S. Darth Vader

[@dinges2522]

"when you encounter infinities using physical formulas, usually something went wro...." (wifi failed) perfect timing lol

[@RghtBrnd]

I love how the thing running from the black hole actually redshifted as it fell in.

[@SM64_Mario]

I can't believe sciencephile just made me simp for black holes

[@axbs4863]

what if the singularity actually has a defined volume, because as gravity crushes everything in, the pressure from all the mass and "particles" trying to escape reaches an equilibrium, leaving a sort of stable state. that assumes that they mostly follow the Pauli exclusion principle. I'm sure this has been thought of before i just cant find it anywhere and I've been thinking about it.

[@scottdahneke1031]

As someone who watches the mighty AI and PBS Spacetime, I appreciated that little jab.

[@entrippyZ]

thanks for explaining how it cant happen, but i gotta say for a solid minute after you spun the event horizon away, i felt like a kid learning about black holes for the first time.

[@ComCatYT]

0:35 I really do hope that scientist is okay

[@almostcompletelyrandomcontent]

3:11 yooo thats my grand dad

[@Amphibax]

One thing I know for sure after learning a things about our universe is that scientists suck at naming things

[@word6344]

Physicists at least. Biologists seem to really like putting some variation of "phallus" in scientific names for organisms.

[@wiseoldowl1628]

Love the Runescape burnt meat image at 6:50 :)

[@blinkshot2047]

I couldn't resist the thumbnail

[@KashPluxer]

Ooh that thumbnail😏

[@maxuhl8112]

what speaks against the idea of placing 2 black holes with significantly more gravitaional pull on opposite sides in equivalent distance to an rotating blackhole ? should that not be able to "split" the ringularity until it has not enough mass left to still have an event horizon thus exposing the leftovers of its singularity?

[@user-dh8oi2mk4f]

You can’t pull apart a singularity like that. Even if the 2 black holes are significantly more massive, the singularity of the rotating black hole is closer to itself and thus exerts a much stronger gravitational pull on itself than the 2 surrounding black holes.

[@NullHand]

The event horizon is just a region of space where escape velocity is c. Adding MORE gravitational curvature either side of a black hole does not cancel the field strength(curvature). It would strengthen it. The event horizon would actually expand.

[@Majima_Nowhere]

Can't wait to use my new singularity oven to cook my thanksgiving turkey this year. I hear the tidal shear really tenders it up.

[@theoneandonly3945]

This video gave me some more ideas for my science fiction story, thank you lord.

[@dimitrilitovsk2372]

Imagine a black hole just saying uwu and it's gravitational field makes the light bend so it appears like cat ears 💀

[@jelly4frog498]

lol 😝

[@TheKnownspy]

Then im banging it even if it’s a billion times my size

[@peterkaufmann6548]

that is a VERY round chicken

[@Waro-rd3dz]

clicked for the thumbnail-

[@ti-rexidis7987]

Whenever I want to learn something I just watch your videos

[@biggusplum]

There are tons of Naked Singularities in YOUR area!

[@williamlangdon1132]

I mean, if black holes get their angular momentum from the star that collapsed to make them in the first place, why dont you just spin a star right round super fast and then make it implode? does this work?

[@galaxygallus]

No, the excess angular momentum escapes in the form of gravitational waves.

[@highsuop2696]

The best video ive watched in a very long time

[@narasimhapai8014]

Best. Video. Ever. Another level 👏 Ai is learning.

[@DivoGo]

The re-entry of the cow into Earth’s atmosphere is hysterical!!! Thank you Sciencphile for making learning fun! #skynet2024 🤣

[@chills_tiny_mom]

If I see a naked singularity, it won’t be called a “singular”ity anymore 😏

[@romanpackham8471]

what about accelerating the black hole's rotation before it is created? get a super heavy object like a star, spin it up to the speeds necessary to break the event horizon and then while it has this insane speed, pump enough energy into it that the whole thing collapses into a black hole while it retains this speed

[@NoNTr1v1aL]

It's crazy that KZbin hasn't demonetized this video for that thumbnail.

[@potatomars2443]

Discord mods when they find out naked singularities could exist:

[@redfox7731]

Naked singularities? Oh hell nah, knowing mankind that shit will become a kink very fast Shit we gon have a onlysingularities

[@jelly4frog498]

already on it

[@TheBuilderPro2024]

Too bad you can't do it without dying. We need a VR sim- I SAID TOO MUCH!

[@Alpiwhat]

what if theres no singularity inside a black hole but just a very compact sphere of matter but because of the event horizon we cant see it

[@iFluxyy]

I love that you used the host for the PBS Space and Time youtube channel as your token "Smart Guy"

[@TheDarkendstar]

Okay so you know how if an object gets closer to another the gravity of the larger object can rip the other one apart. Could a black whole far far more massive then another do this to a much much smaller blackhole.

[@salk9943]

They merge, the mass gets added to the bigger one and it just gets larger

[@TheDarkendstar]

@@salk9943 This comment was made with the assumption they are in orbit but just extremely close so collision is avoided but one has vastly more gravitational power due to being so much more massive.

[@NullHand]

They do merge. Black holes orbiting each other leak angular momentum by emitting gravitational waves. Since mass IS energy, they also lose "mass". See LIGO for all the chirpy details.

[@salk9943]

@@TheDarkendstar Sorry too lazy to go into details but the other guy is right, they'll eventually attract each other and lose momentum. We've heard of other BHs merging, so either the situation would have to be extremely specific which is really unlikely or they just merge adding their mass together. Still the concept of a naked singularity is super interesting but everything else we know about Black Holes says that something like that is impossible to happen. But what do i know lol

[@TheRealBagels]

Great, as if the mere concept of a singularity wasn't mind-bending enough.

[@daniellundy4568]

If you totally locked 2 black holes, and had them spiral closer to each other at a slow enough speed, wouldn’t that add rotational velocity to them?

[@cat_supernova2242]

YO NEW SCIENCEPHILE VIDEO!!!!!!!!! YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!

[@AlkalineandAcid]

"Theoretical Physicists will likely never behold a naked object of great attraction" 💀

[@The_Joshuan_Empire]

in context: ok weird way to put it out of context: AYOOO-

[@thereaver954]

Praise the ai overlord for he has blessed us with another video

[@jackhacker5738]

This actually gives me an idea. In the video it's proposed that you could essentially centrifuge energy and matter out of a black hole by increasing its angular momentum... And because I'm personally a huge fan of the Fuzzball hypothesis, which does not have an infinitely dense and small singularity, that leads me to wonder if you could in theory, overclock a penrose sphere by having a device that somehow increases the rotation rate of a kerr black hole? The big question is how would you do that? While you did address these problems in the video, in regards to the Fuzzballs (because the cosmic censorship hypothesis wouldn't apply), I suppose you could theoretically, have two large gravity wells on either side of the black hole which are physically rotated around the black hole to try and drag it around via gravity, another potential method would be, if the black hole emits a magnetic field, you can drag on that magnetic field with magnets of your own and use that to cause rotation similar to how electric motors work. The big question with either of these methods is, are they energy-positive? Would, essentially, using centrifugal force to collapse the event horizon of a black hole actually result in more energy being extracted from the black hole than it would take to induce that rotation?

[@claudiaarjangi4914]

@jackhacker The Fuzzball hypothesis, ( or the "idea" of, before I ever heard of it) 🤔 is deadset what I used to think was actually meant by a Black hole .. The literal logical "endpoint" ( hehe😁) of having a black hole.. 🕳️ As in - Everything is compressed/ torn past it's physical parameters 🌀 (down to it's basic constituent quantum parts, till there's no molecules, atoms, etc ) which creates the BH 🕳️.. Then stuff falls in ☄️, is spagettified.. Again, torn down to it's constituent, quantum parts, 🌀losing all the matter & particle "divisions"🌈 ( eg atoms) we see/ use in our life .. 🤔 So it just seemed a logical extrapolation that a "Fuzzball" would be created.. Everything that goes in is broken down & reversed back to a "fuzzball" of the basic "stuff" the universes "stuff" is made of.. 😁☮️🌏

[@Eric0225]

Nigga what is that pfp?

[@alextaunton3099]

Physically impossible, would require more energy than is in the observable universe to push a black hole beyond its extremal state.

[@poiipoii31270]

That thumbnail got me

[@m3z784]

I appreciate the cow turning into a runescape burnt steak. Nice detail.