What did the Ottomans Ever do for the World? | The London Circle

[@laserresal]

The fact that the Ottomans then and Turks now are the owners of that part of the world is the biggest gift for that region&world 💯

[@soran1461]

Dream big like ordugan does😂😂😂😂😂

[@laserresal]

@@soran1461 it’s been a fact for almost 1000 years 😆😆

[@panosgeorgedimitriou2290]

​@@laserresal1000 years of backwardness..Anatolia was a beacon of civilization and wealthy place for thousands of years until babbons (turks) and Islam came

[@KenanTurkiye]

KZbin: '' STOLEN LEGACY - BY GEORGE G. M. JAMES | AUDIO BOOK ''

[@KenanTurkiye]

@@panosgeorgedimitriou2290 Here's some OFF TOPIC knowledge many do not know. Jesus Christ the Messiah (peace be upon him) was taken to Heaven by Lord/God/TheCreator because some wanted him dead, so God saved him (be patient, continue reading, you will see ''the matrix'', upto you to escape it). (extensive detail in folder 3 in my playlists) The word 'christ' comes from the Greek word 'christos' meaning chosen/annointed (annointment is the act of chosing) the word 'messiah' comes from the Arabic/Hebrew word 'messiach', again meaning chosen. (Arabs and Hebrew are cousins and are both Semitic people) ...back on topic... So, Who chose Jesus? TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord did. To do what? To convey that there is TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord and only ThatSupreme power should be worshipped and prayed to and NO idols/conjured up god/s, be it a man, a spirit of a man, a sun, a star, a moon, a tree, an animal etc etc to be worshipped in any way form. Worshipping anything else besides TheCreator is idolatry/paganism/blasphamy and will bring Hell. Anything that is worshipped besides TheGod is a god, that is, it is a false god, hence with a small ''g''. There is one Creator, hence why TheGod, the only One deserving of worship. Jesus did not speak Greek or Arabic or Hebrew, he spoke Aramaic, and from translation into translation into translation, we can see that he worshipped TheGod. John 20:17 '‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’” Mark 10:18 ''Why do you call me good? No one is good, except God alone.'' John 5:30 "I cannot do anything on my own." John 14:28 “I go to the Father, for the Father is greater than I” (that ''father'' does not mean flesh and bone father, rather TheGuide/God, look at John 20:17 as detailed above, are you also the flesh and bone son of God? pls think! worship TheCreator/TheGuide/TheGod and not the prophets, peace be upon them all) What does Allah mean as a word? It means TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord. What does ''elaah'' mean as a word? It means any idol or conjured up god (elaaha is the plural of that) they are false and do not deserve worship of any kind, hence why Islam rejects all gods, because worship is solely is to be done to TheGod/TheCreator/TheLord/Allah, which is the trial of this life on earth, to worship only your Creator without equals or partners. Why are all religions in opposition of Islam? Because they have a god or many gods, because they worship creatures of TheGod in someway, be it prophets, saints, angels, sun, star, moon, animal, tree, by offering them things, making prayers to them (FOR THEM is different, TO THEM is different, 'to them' means you think they have the power to respond/accept that act), or they worship their dead loved ones, the spirit of their loved ones etc etc, all of which the Devil wants done so people ruin their direct worshipping TheGod, the Devil loves that you go astray like that. Have you ever read a Quran from start to finish? That you can answer for your self. (I recommend the Sahih International english translation, it's good). Best wishes. ------------------------------- .....btw..... Jesus did preach to worship the OneGod/TheCreator and not anything else, and so did his followers, peace be upon them all. This unsettled the Roman Empire because this idea of Monotheism went against their pagan beliefs where the emperor was both emperor and god. They persecuted the followers of Jesus and even attempted to kill Jesus, even a Roman Empire servant Saul of Tarsus was out to kill Jesus. Saul never managed to meet Jesus in real life but after Jesus was taken up to Heaven Saul said he saw a dream and said he will now preach the teachings of Jesus. Saul of Tarsus is also known in todays christianity as Saint Paul, so todays christians are actually on the teaching of ''Saint'' Paul which brings in trinity and godhead figure of Jesus and rejects Monotheism. -Jesus was commanded to preach Monotheism, which he did and early followers were Monotheistic (Islamic) believing people, which later changed with the Roman Empires paganism spreading -Jesus was commanded to preach ONLY to the Israelites, which he did, but after him Saul of Tarsus aka ''saint Paul'' started to preach to the Gentiles, which is the foundation of todays christiandom. -Jesus was commanded to rule for the circumsicion which he did, but it was taken out after he left -Roman Empire in 325 AD held a council, with empire alligned 'scholars'' to decide and VOTE on whether Jesus was to be worshipped or not, they VOTED that Jesus be accepted as god (in aliagn with the pagan beliefs of the Roman traditions) and ever since the trinity became the 'christian way' (not what Jesus preached), and sinc that time the Church has chronicled how many times the ''Bible'' has been changed, verses removed and verses added to SUIT this altered idea of trinity! Best wishes, life is short.

[@louistan7560]

The Ottoman Empire was rich and cultured as compared to the squalor in England and France. The Christian Crusaders were n9thong more than robber bands and marauders flying under the flag of their religion.

[@bmark1185]

That goes for Islam as well. So-called "Religion of peace". More like "death and usurper" cult.

[@kd1405]

The religious ideologues "robber bands Nd marauders"? Thats literaly blasphemy! Also the Ottomans didnt use national flag either. They also used the flag of their blood thirsty religion. What an abomination.

[@Saber23]

Lol this is pure racism against white Europeans and I’m saying this as a Muslim the Ottoman Empire was evil, the leadership was full of adultery and homosexuality not to mention they massacred countless minorities throughout their empire

[@Saber23]

Lol this is pure racism against white Europeans and I’m saying this as a Muslim the Ottoman Empire was evil, the leadership was full of adultery and homosexuality not to mention they massacred countless minorities throughout their empire

[@Dosadniste2000]

Pity you werent invaded by them.

[@ullymolly4966]

When the ottomans arrives to europe , people ask : please save us from them and taxes ! We heard you have justice! We better see ottoman turbans then crusaders cone

[@mbndr6]

I think it was Fes/Fez instead of Turban.

[@ullymolly4966]

@@mbndr6 fes is late ottoman era

[@kaanerdem2822]

17th century the dutch said "liever turks dan paaps". Prefer to be Turk then pope's servant. Even was crafted on their coin, google it.

[@Verschiedenes]

The Turks are kicking ass. And they are doing an awesome job at doing it. Stop wining and complaining 😘

[@Saber23]

I’m guessing you’re Turkish yourself? Considering the blind almost delusional pride you have it would make sense, the days of the Ottoman Empire are over pal and Turkey is a joke

[@Saber23]

Such an insecure little child

[@laserresal]

@@Saber23 being insecure is planted in your DNA ages ago because of the upcomming Turks 😂 Wich is understandable because your ancestors fought all there lifes against Turks. From Atilla to Atatürk 😉🤘🏼

[@Scalpaslan]

The program was very enjoyable and thought-provoking. As a Turk, in the last years of the Ottoman Empire, millions of Turks and other Muslim peoples from Europe, the Caucasus, the Balkans took refuge in Anatolia and Thrace (today's Turkey) as a result of the attacks of England, Russia, Italy, Greece, France, Austria and other Western countries. When evaluating Turks, not only administratively but also sociologically should be evaluated. For Westerners, Turk meant Muslim. The real power source of the dynasty and the state was the Turks. The Turks were the source of all the ideals of the Ottoman Empire. With this idea, they fought, died and had a high will for the continuity of the state. Because of this vision and sacrifice, the Ottoman Empire continued as a Turkish Empire for centuries. With its justice and tolerance, many people accepted Islam. They were fair in giving the job to the competent, an intelligent and talented peasant boy could be in the management of the world's largest empire. Because especially Oghuz Turks (24 tribes), Seljuks and Ottomans consciously based the Turks' entire outlook on life on the Sunni understanding of Islam in every field. Arabs and other Muslim brothers should know some sociological historical events. In the last years of the Ottoman Empire, when the Turks were weak in numbers and power in Russia and Europe, they were a Muslim generation fighting. Massacres and even genocide of Turks and Muslims were committed. The immigrants from 3 continents who were able to save themselves settled in Turkey and every child grew up with the war stories of their great grandfathers until recently. While they were in such a difficult situation, the pro-British attitude towards the Turks who were martyred in Yemen, Gaza, Crimea, Central Europe, Baku, Iraq and countless other places was taught in the minds as an Arab betrayal. The Arabs were also taught to be hostile towards the Turks. If we want to build the future, we must talk and solve our problems within ourselves as a family.

[@FREE_LAND_1]

Ottomans was mixed up Muslims Arab's turks kurds Albanians Bosnians caucuses afhgans etc not just turks

[@Ugi494]

​@@FREE_LAND_1 you are screaming that under every comment. ofcourse Ottoman Empire is Turkish Empire. Just like ruling over many nations doesn't make Mongolian Empire not Mongolian, that doesn't make Ottoman Empire not Turkish. that's the definition of empire. do yourself a favor and get educated.

[@ayhankaracaoglu6845]

@@FREE_LAND_1 such an idiocy ! are you ethnic Kirmanchi ? most perhaps, disgusting ambush culture, bending power, opressing weak ! Turks are the brain and arm of several empires including Seljuks and Ottomans !

[@linobenetti6578]

The ruling elite was ottoman...not poor devils from Tirana or Sofia or Athens.... Turks are turks...but it won't stop there...all those wishing to be or become Turks are turks as well...very staunch if I may add. Zeus Akhbar from Kalamata everyone

[@Scalpaslan]

@@FREE_LAND_1 Your little brain doesn't understand. It's a waste to talk about this with you. It's a Turkish empire with countless ethnic and religious groups ruled by Turks.

[@svart7716]

Turks are the reason Islam has had magnificent times. Great moslem empires have Turkish roots and foundations: Ottomans(Oghuz Turks), Mughal(Caghatai Turks), Mamluks(Kıpcak Turks), Seljuk(Oghuz Turks) to name a few..

[@CineRanter]

Yakoob Ahmed is an incredible scholar when it comes to Ottoman history. You go in a lecture wanting a nostalgic ride down memory lane, you leave contemplating your own knowledge of epistemology.

[@Saber23]

He’s also a complete liar and distorts said history

[@sinanuludag6573]

Finally they teach about ottoman empire instead of bullshit Rome

[@sahanhalil]

İn any part of history Only ottomans achieved unity in islam one way or another, good or bad... From phophet to Qıyamah only one muslim empire did it...

[@steppenwolf5956]

agreed 100%

[@fredricocosta7977]

Ha ha ha seriously you believe this lie?

[@oguzhan9424]

@@fredricocosta7977 Its not about believing it just is so!

[@fredricocosta7977]

@@oguzhan9424 the Umayyids were a greater empire and spread Islam further.

[@oguzhan9424]

@@fredricocosta7977 Different era, different structure. Does not change the fact that the Ottomans has achieved unity.

[@KenanTurkiye]

Since 2008 Israel in their efforts to occupy, killed/injured 251,642 Palestenians, nearly all civilians, women, children, elderly, since 2008 Palestenians in their efforts to defend against the occupation, killed/injured 5,887 Israelis, mostly soldiers. search '' The Human Cost Of The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict'' (the data there is only covering 2008-2020 and excludes the 40,300 Palestenians killed and another 93,356 injured due to latest destruction as of 24 August 2024) These values do not include the dead of 70+ years of occupation, does not include the millions of evicted people, does not include the millions of people afflicted by the conflict due to malnutrition, lack of medical servives, education loss, income loss, broken families etc etc etc. The occupiers celebrate what they are doing, because USA, Britain, Germany, France (governments) and the like are helping and encouraging them. Humanity is taken hostage by bad politics.

[@KenanTurkiye]

My country Turkiye has many times proposed that we muslims establish a peace keeping force and have our selves established in bases in Jordan and the region, but Arab countries have so far succummed to foreign pressures and not accepted such an offer, as yet. To all the Arab brothers and sisters; without falling out of Islamic etiquitte and manners, and without endangering yourselves or others, please rally your leaders/governments, so we can get together and do what's needed to stop all this, ...condemnation, throwing an aid pallet or two from airplanes and posing for the cameras for the media isn't right, we need to establish a peace keeping force to stop the brutality. We need to show a steady force, we need to first unite, please don't just watch, be active in your countries.... ....and all nations can join in on this peace keeping force, from all corners of the world, all beliefs, because this is about SANITY against INSANITY !

[@KenanTurkiye]

EVERYONE please make a playlist about Palestine like I have (4th playlist) and ask others to have such a playlist. Or copy directly the list I have and ask others to copy it from you, and they ask others copy from them. We need to spread the truth, millions, billions of us.

[@Saber23]

@@KenanTurkiye lol your “country” is a corrupt one that lies constantly and persecutes its Kurdish population

[@Saber23]

@@KenanTurkiye it’s ironic because Turks themselves are insane, stop persecuting the Kurds

[@SalihYildirimtr]

Globally noble Turks NEVER breaks when promised to do something, but West does break its promises, and Turk does not applaud Netanyahu whose community has killed 5 Allah-assigned Prophets. Türkiye is the unique nation members who always seek for Global Peace and offers "Win*Win Policy to all nations across the globe.🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘❤💪

[@rajairfan2768]

the Turks said that they stop selling gas to Israel. yet we still see ships sending it to them.

[@heritage433]

Like our prophet Mohammad saw: لَتُفْتَحَنَّ القُسطَنْطِينِيَّةُ فلنعمَ الأميرُ أميرُها ولنعمَ الجيشُ ذلك الجيش

[@Thewonderingminds]

Wake up, *conquer means no personal creativity none zero, and thus eventual and unavoidable self dissolution* OKAY NOW ??

[@ahmedh.mohamed2166]

you got it all wrong .. the prophet was talking about the coming conquest in the end of days dum dum under leadership of Eessa. ibn marriem and AL Mahdi and the prophet continued to praise the entire army in another hadith especially the five scouts who will scout the dajjal

[@ahmedh.mohamed2166]

Muhammed El Fattah killed his brothers converted Christian people and chapels by the sword isn't that against our Islamic teachings you ..... go learn Islam you know so little

[@toni_2891]

😂😂😂😂😂​@@ahmedh.mohamed2166

[@ahmedh.mohamed2166]

@@toni_2891 laugh you 🍑 off for now Toni 😂😂 we will see who will get the last laughter 👀👀🤌

[@user-bo7qi7em3g]

был Мир в Мире и внутри империи во время власти Османской империи. Вновь дай силы туркам

[@enginkazanci4727]

You cannot "analyze" the Ottomans independently of what Turks in general did the last 2500 documented years. You MUST put it in context and continuation with the other 16+ Turkic states leading to ths Ottoman empire. The Selçuks for example...Europe, until the 16th century, were game from those of the east, just like the Chinese...

[@Thewonderingminds]

A simple look at any contemporary map, is tangible evidence that *the turks advanced and conquered up to the point the opponents' religious nihilism had long time before prepared to do so* .

[@stouellette]

Selcuklari "Selçuk Turks" diye yazsak belki daha iyi olur diye dusunuyorum, cunki Selcuklarin Turk Imparatorlugu oldugunu bilmeyen yabancilar var. Oguzlardan/Osmanlilardan once Anadoluda yer alan diger Turk kavimlerini boylece bu yorumlar icinde biraz ogrenebilirler. Selamlar.

[@linobenetti6578]

game ??...thats an understatement...they are hostiles...I am half italian half greek... They still incursive...in the full and complete meaning of the word... There is no way a European society can deal with them ....cause european culture fundamentals are nor part of their society... ...Lebanese or Syrians are way much more eurppean compatible than the Turks..

[@osmanisildak2448]

For some reason, unlike the British Empire where the dynasties are not referred to, in Turkic empires they are named after dynasties.So I can't agree more on the point you are making, especially the importance of the Seljuk Turks' two centuries of rule that made the Ottomans so successful.

[@Thewonderingminds]

@@osmanisildak2448 Had not been the religious nihilistic preparation of the people conquested, humanity would be far more advanced and avoided rivers of blood and unimaginable suffering.

[@HaZeFiT_uA]

Ne Mutlu Türk'üm Diyene 🐺🇹🇷

[@Havana1961cu]

varlığım Türk varlığına armağan olsun

[@atillakaragazi838]

Thank you Dr. Ahmed. This is possibly the best video I have seen on KZbin about the Ottomans. I added it to my favorites and will watch it again in the future. All the best.

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

selçuklu devletinden beri oğuzların 1000 aileden oluşan sülaleleri güç olarak görüp bölüp değişik yerlere yerlestiriyorlardi. bunu osmanlılarda herhangi sülalenin güçlenip iktidara sorun olusturmamalari icin uyguladı.

[@Saber23]

💩

[@haldousuxley]

@33:16 man ottomans empire collapsed before Nazis, it was the Turkish Republic who had some level of sympathy. study before you made a podcast!

[@giuc100]

@@haldousuxley we didn't have sympathy. We didn't like Jews being exterminated at all. Remember we took Jews from the hands of Spanish as well. We didn't, and I say didn't as things seem to have changed now, have any beef against Jews and had no sympathy to Hitler but nowadays, we have a problem about how they are conducting themselves against all international law

[@Cettolini]

I wish that my Arab brothers could dream of a time when they could live freely and no longer be anyone's slave. My greatest wish is for them to wake up and come to their senses. Regards from Istanbul.

[@KenanTurkiye]

Heres something off topic that you may find interesting. :) The name of my country has nothing to do with the interesting and delicious bird 'turkey'...... .....but the name of the bird does have a connection with the name of my country, let me explain. :) In the past 40 years 37 countries have changed their name, partially or fully. Obviously one can not change the name of an apple or an orange etc in other languages, but country names are like peoples' individual names, so if you're named John we don't call you Karen. :) Name of my country has always been Türkiye, it's been known as such since around the 1200's. The name it self has a suffix, '-iye', that is Turk-iye, where the -iye suffix means 'land of/belonging to', just like the Latin suffix of '-ia', which exists in such country names like Austr-ia, Austral-ia, Indones-ia etc. Basically, the use of '-iye/-ia' is the same as the the use of '-land' suffix in country names like Ire(Eire)-land, Po(le)-land, Eng(Anglo)-land and so on and so on. Many would remember the country Czechoslovak-ia which changed it's name to Czech Republic and a few years ago changed that to Czechia (that is Czech-ia). The Latin suffix -ia probably originates from Turkish -iye as Turkish been over 10,000 years is much older than Latin which is around 1300 years old. Spelled in different languages in different ways to phonetically resemble (to sound like) 'Türkiye' we got various spellings like; Turq-uía (in Spanish), Turch-ia (in Italian), Turq-uie (in French) Turk-ei (in German) Turk-ey (in English) Mind you this was way before the animal we currently know as turkey was found by the europeans when they explored the north americas. The bird was first sent to europe from north americas in the year 1519, so up until that point there was no bird named turkey.... ...they came across the bird and thought it was a specie of the fowl/chicken they had been buying from the country of Turkiye at the time, so they named the bird 'Turkey Fowl' to define 'Turkish Chicken'... ....just like how a dog breed is known as German Shepherd (because it's from Germany), American Bulldog, British Terrier, Greek Harehound etc etc. In time you don't get to call the harehound simply as Greek or you don't call the terrier Britirsh, or shepherd as simply German, but in time the Turkish Fowl started to be called just 'Turkey' and later 'turkey', and this went on for hundreds of years. Now in modern times, this caused confusion, especially when we have people across the world unable to point to their own country on an atlas. Basically we didn't change the name of our country, we changed the mistake made in the English language. : ) So, there's some tid bit information for you to have a great day, if you read upto this point you have a great night too, ohh just have a wonderfull life. : ) Best wishes. ;)

[@osmanisildak2448]

It is Turkland. Now we went one step forward to have Turkiye the official Name globally and the next generation may change it to Turkland

[@KenanTurkiye]

@@osmanisildak2448 Are you a teenager?

[@A.gustMackensen]

Englisch language, is a poor copy of Germanic and latin Mix. So if they call a bird Turkey, it Shows how poor thid bullshit language is.

[@gunesinan814]

This is very informative, thank you!

[@KenanTurkiye]

@@gunesinan814 Thank you as well, have a great day.

[@serhaneroglu5402]

Khazar Empire was a first and last jewish Turk empire in the Turkish history they lived for near 300 years dont hide them

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

Khazars choose Judaism because of the cruelties of Christians and cruelties of Muslim Arabs in their efforts to convert them.Turks would not become Muslim for another hundred and fifty years until the Muslim Persian missionaries came along and introduced islam to them. For that reason until this day in Turkey many rituals of islam are expressed in Persian. Finest example of compulsion in religion is a futile effort that backfires. Turks knew that from their own experience.

[@youravaragetoxicmasculinem9508]

32:32 wht kind of a statement is this? WW1 was not anything remotelly similar to WW2 and WW1 Germany and WW2 Gemany. WW1 was about Germany being late in Colonisation and wanting new colonies because all were held by France and Birtain, for Ottomans it was about not being a colonyy themselves,Britain and France wanted to colonise Ottoman Empire and that left no other choice for Ottomans to joing with Germany, there were no Ottoman Empire in WW2 there were Republic of Turkey, and it stayed neutral in WW2, Ottoman Empire offered refuge to all Jews that were kicked out of Spain during reconquista.

[@giuc100]

My thoughts. It was a very ignorant question by the interviewer. Republic of Turkey was not involved in ww2

[@OğuzKagan-g5p]

The Ottomans were renowned for their architectural achievements, including the construction of numerous mosques, palaces, and bridges that are now considered architectural masterpieces. The Sultanahmet Mosque (also known as the Blue Mosque) in Istanbul and the Süleymaniye Mosque are two notable examples of Ottoman architectural prowess. In the realm of art, the Ottomans developed a distinctive style of calligraphy, miniature painting, and ceramics that influenced artistic traditions across the Islamic world and beyond. Ottoman calligraphic styles, such as the Diwani script, are highly regarded for their beauty and complexity. The Ottomans also made important advancements in various fields of science and technology. They were pioneers in military engineering, developing effective siege weapons and fortification techniques. The Ottoman navy was also formidable, with innovations in ship design and navigation. In the realm of administration, the Ottomans established a relatively stable and efficient system of governance, which allowed for the efficient management of their vast empire. The Ottoman system of land tenure and taxation, known as the timar system, was influential and widely studied. Furthermore, the Ottomans played a significant role in the advancement of trade and commerce. They controlled strategic trade routes, such as the Silk Road, and facilitated the exchange of goods, ideas, and cultural influences between the East and the West. While the Ottoman Empire was not without its flaws and controversies, its contributions to architecture, art, science, and trade have had a lasting impact on the cultural and intellectual heritage of the regions it encompassed and the broader world.

[@abeuser3757]

Ottomans where not only Turkic there where al kind of etnicity it was al about Islam. One ummah was the main cause

[@XMatrix2025]

🙄

[@sultanmomenofzenata177]

What ? ​@@XMatrix2025

[@AM-ul8ql]

I have to speak out because of the comments which obviously Dr. Yakoob Ahmed is aware of. You(Dr.Yakoob Ahmed) are doing a excellent job keep on going no matter the comments. I and many other people see you're a good and intelligent muslim. So a big JazaakAllahu khairan Dr. And its funny that you speak out and mention it in the video how we muslim have gotten good at criticizing but not problem solving. Here you speak with facts and you're academic and some guys think they know more and starts commenting wrongly and falsely. But since we are so good at criticizing, the thing to criticize is the short video hahaha. I wish the interviewer had delved deeper into some of the question because it really resonated and felt relevant but I understand the constraint a one hour video has to do about a 600 year old country.

[@kdakan]

Ottomans were sufi's in the beginning, they conquered eastern Europe before they conquered whole part of Anatolia, and the way they converted masses of Christians living there into Islam was by sufi Bektashi dede's who didn't put strict rules. Ottomans adopted more strict sunni sect as the state religion two centuries later when Selim I (Yavuz Sultan Selim) conquered the holy lands and became the Islam caliph.

[@faisalniazi1899]

Ma Shah Allah. Great combo ☺️

[@eSedat]

Um die Frage auf dem Titel zu beantworten reicht es aus, sich heute die ehemaligen Gebiete des osmanischen Reiches anzusehen....Unruhen,Kriege,Konflikte

[@evetmat6046]

ne anlamda ...

[@HaZeFiT_uA]

​@@evetmat6046diyor ki eskiden Türklerin olduğu yerde zulüm,savaş falan yoktu.Türkler bir bölgeyi aldıktan sonra orası inşaa edilirdi halk devlet işbirliği yapardı ama şimdi Türklerin olmadığı heryerde savaş ve huzursuzluk var.

[@evetmat6046]

@@HaZeFiT_uA aynen öyle kardeşim...

[@noorsaadeh]

Dr Yakoob is brilliant as usual.

[@fifichilli4928]

It is interesting that that guy started crying over chalifat show how prejudice his views are. Ottomans survived fir 600 years and all other empires before them they collapsed.

[@osmanisildak2448]

time please

[@edddik]

What the Ottoman empire did is killing one and a half million Armenians. They committed again outside to Armenians. This is what they contributed to this world.

[@T-unit-84]

Turks are the best of humanity

[@turtlebeach3116]

@@T-unit-84 i feel annoyed by them And what makes them the best ? You cant just say that

[@bmark1185]

Until their dark, bloody, overly censored secret is out.

[@T-unit-84]

@@turtlebeach3116 AtoZ

[@turtlebeach3116]

@@T-unit-84 what is atoz ? You can't just expect that i know explain pls

[@Shook1917]

So you are a Turk not a Muslim. Open your mind because you sound ignorant.

[@FerayKelan]

He said politicial and military leadership but at 1909 The Sultan Abdulhamid that has 100% power was overthroned by coup soldiers and they replaced puppet Sultan for show but the coup commander Enver Pasha was leading world war one and the others he was not successful we lost many lands.

[@ugurmehmet9165]

Ben kibrisli Turkum Allah korusun üçe turk milleti amin 🇹🇷

[@laserresal]

That guy is just a jealous&frustrated “muslim” educated by Britian spreading misinformation 👎🏼

[@ozkang654]

they found the if you gonna put powder and iron ball in an iron pipe and make an external trigger it will blow up and iron little ball will move really fast and hit the target

[@user-bo7qi7em3g]

был Мир в Мире и внутри империи во время власти Османской империи. А запад всегда был грабителем крестовые походы и арабская весна тоже план крестовых походов для грабежа

[@baghdade]

Anas Altikrity need to pray for forgiveness, will never forget your visits to Washington.

[@AliKublay-ld4ju]

Esselamunaleykum verahmatullah veberakattu they made yours live like humans there was no killing s esselamunaleykum verahmatullah veberakattu

[@anonymous_a]

33:15 Hitler in WW1? what are you talking about?

[@laleodekon5085]

What is the speaker’s academic credentials?

[@bozkurtkara8337]

Ottoman empire was the first who gave woman rights! For example, woman could devorce the man or the woman getting a share of heritage from her parents.

[@noorsaadeh]

Actually earliest Islam thru the Quran gave women all those rights. 6th, 7th century!

[@CTzons]

Islam*

[@bankreas3523]

those are rights given by the sharia of islam since the time of prophet muhammad to this day, ottomans didnt invent it

[@dopejoel]

everyone goes to Turkey to see the Roman stuff

[@songulbulbul2126]

So not true..

[@Musa31344]

How about everyone for aya sofya and blue mosque

[@hayrettinankarali6946]

onlarin anadoludan calinanlarini londra da berlin de paris de vs yerlerde gorebilirsiniz ,daha dogrusu butun batili ulkelerin muzelerin de tum dunya dan calinmis eserleri gorebilirsiniz

[@giuc100]

I suggest you follow the research for Etruscans and ask yourself who were they

[@osmanyussuf7069]

We learn the mistakes but we can fix now insha Allah because the capitalism has changed its course on human rights freedoms and equal opportunity,live and let me live, and choose colonialism plundering and corruption agression and profeteering on human sufferings

[@nejathakan5521]

LA GALİBE İL ALLAH

[@FREE_LAND_1]

Ottomans were mixed up Muslims Arab's turks kurds Albanians Bosnians caucuses afhgans etc not just turks

[@usmanzaheer3857]

Afghans😂😂

[@Scalpaslan]

Your little brain doesn't understand. It's a waste to talk about this with you. It's a Turkish empire with countless ethnic and religious groups ruled by Turks.

[@svart7716]

What? Afghans in ottoman?

[@postachamdi6286]

Ottoman army were from akinjis, sipahis azaps etc which were turkish. Janissaries were from balkans. And there is nothing related to arabs or any other race. Ottomans belongs to turks. Remember that we ruled you, we dont belong to you.

[@mehmetozdil2406]

Ottomans was Turks but the population was mixed. Don't even try to say that they aren't Turks 😊

[@dirk-piehl28]

too much reverberation in the sound. voices bouncing off the walls, so distracting.

[@TahaAlZadjali]

Actually nothing that is the reason the fall happened at the end.

[@MohammadAlirevert]

There sultans live in luxury and that shows me that they are interested in the dunya !

[@songulbulbul2126]

Have ever read about sultan Abdulhamid?? Please do. There is also a soap about his life..

[@Musa31344]

Not all of them

[@aksaleskikaya6953]

MuslumMam Turkiye Turkic Turan 💫🍎☝️ LaGaLiBeIlLalLah 🍉💫

[@linobenetti6578]

Turkey s greatest contribution to our modern civilisation was the institutionalisation of Harems.. European Royals would turn green faced with envy n jealousy when compared to Sultans. The were hors pair insuperable.

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

I know you are an ordinary individual making ordinary comments. But those who are interested in serious history would want to know, “harem” is the LADIES QUARTERS WHERE SULTANS MOTHER,SISTERS,DAUGHTERS RESIDED. GET IT?

[@FREE_LAND_1]

Ottomans weren't khilafah WAKE UP GUY'S Ottoman were Muslim state NOT khilafah

[@Ugi494]

Selim I took Caliphate by ending Mamluk Empire and became 88th Caliph. please stop spreading misinformation.

[@osmanisildak2448]

@@Ugi494he is saying only Aa arabs can be Halife. Halife in Turkish. Over 40.000 thousand arabs died in Gaza, very publicly, and where is the Arab league? You had war with Syria, called 6 day war. Not even a week. We do not need to prove ourselves and our ancestors doings, history does that for us.

[@fredricocosta7977]

@@osmanisildak2448Where was Turkey? Selling oil to the enemies of Muslims. Sometimes I wonder how many Turks are really Muslim at all.

[@1299I-e5e]

Wahabi = yahudi brothers

[@1299I-e5e]

Abbasid, umayad , ottomans all are hanafi muslims ❤

[@honesty_provides_tranquility]

We also had the Mughal Empire (which was economically greater and had a greater Muslim population) … why does everything have to be so Ottoman centric - which was very Eurocentric in its own outlook and in its bloodline of marrying Greek and Bulgarian nobility

[@louisdeniau8571]

because western christians attack ottomans because they are muslims and they want to eradicate muslim identity and they look at ottomans and mughals and all muslims and all non whites as the same. so when you divide, they conquer. you must infight amongst yourselves not in front of wolves. protecting ottoman identity is not actually protecting the uthmani khalifa. protecting ottoman identity is protecting a generic muslim identity because thats what it represents to non muslims. muslims and non muslims think differently

[@cardanotony1097]

Nobody’s denying the Mughals friend But 5he way ur denying the ottomans great ashamed SinCE the ottomans gone just look at 5he Middle 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸east Not counting the other part of the world In the hands of bastards ( 🇮🇱 🇺🇸 ) as a Modern slaves. Finally ask urself what’s happening to Palestinian brothers Past 💯years WHY We keep talking about the ottomans ❓right❓ 🤔🤔🤔

[@cardanotony1097]

@@ABC-wi6vtand Hungarians too mate

[@fredricocosta7977]

They have a huge inferiority complex. Ottomans wanted to be European and Turkey wants to join the EU. Nothing changes.

[@eren9001]

Because the Mughals had less influence politically and no caliphate. It was rare that ottomans married foreign nobility but I can't understand why it matters anyway

[@laetitiavisagie-gg6kk]

There is no doubt that Islam left us many good systems we are still using to this day. I have respect for the legacy of the Ottoman empire. My only critique is the tradition of taking many wives and concubines who bore many sons which left many Sultans killing their brothers and half brothers to get to power or stay in power. I don't understand why they could not change that aspect.

[@arifrahmanchughtai5322]

Civilization and justice andaesthetics

[@nejathakan5521]

❤

[@r.k5088]

Dr. Yakoop Ahmad, I am sorry, but where are U educated ? If England.. regarding the Muslim world, are they the right one to judge.. Anything ?

[@Reewnat]

He has resided in Turkey and educated there.

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

turk muslims surfer under press of georgian Erdogan..

[@mandolorian25]

I would suggest people read the book Lawrence in Arabia. The decision of entry of the ottomans in WW1 is not how he describes

[@hawkeye1018]

You want to listen to the british spy? spy whose job is to lie and deceive, and british whom most countries enjoy the independence from? I doubt your intellect.

[@gregmichaels1106]

Actually, they did stole many Christian land,s like Constantinople Cyprus genocide of Armenians yes they did many evil

[@giuc100]

But that was how things were. Why don't you cry about colonisation of Americas, Africa etc in the same way. Or Palestine?

[@Musa31344]

What a silly question

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

also he has jew siblings

[@michaelattia9834]

The ottoman empire lived by a policy of divide and rule. It forced the people of Bosnia to convert to Islam. Hence, the ceaseless wars in the Balkans.

[@mehmetalierkut7179]

😂😂😂you so funny , little boy

[@h9081]

You cant force a belief , it will only have the opposite effect.Come up with something else because you sound like you might hate islam or Turks.

[@giuc100]

Do Bosnians think like this? I think not. Turkey has always taken care of Bosnians and their links cannot be diminished like this

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

Worship to Allah. dont workshop to states ör human in part.

[@FREE_LAND_1]

الدولة العثمانية لا الخلافة العثمانية كفى مذب و ترويج للدولة العثمانية يا أتراك

[@kaanseckin2357]

😂😂😂

[@serhaneroglu5402]

Aptalca konuşuyorsun

[@xe6ze]

Es ist das Osmanische Reich oder das Osmanische Kalifat, nichtsdestotrotz war es das selbe!!!

[@Havana1961cu]

nothing

[@alevi_yoruk_kurdistan]

Her biji kurdistan

[@CamilaJohson-f9v]

Ottoman. Que mas me gusto. Osman burak. En todos sus proyectos. Me gusta su energia. Angel. Demon. Jajaja. Lo quiero. Muchisimo es super profesional

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

gerçekler acıtıyor mu?😂😂😂😂😂

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

200 yıldan fazla süren celali isyanlarını ve osmanli zulmünü öğrenin.

[@issith7340]

Turkish contribution to civilization: destroying the civilization, that had a language, written in every and each ancient site that turists go to turkey to pay respects to. Greek. ( fortunately greeks , still made up of surviving and getting away , and establishing their world again. All big turistic attractions of turkey, have greek names. 🤣

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

So?

[@kd1405]

​@@sibelshinaishin5170 so that tells to the world turks arent locals there but are the greeks

[@xe6ze]

Die Griechen haben ebenfalls andere Völker unterworfen unter Alexander dem Großen. Jetzt waren die Griechen an der Reihe unterworfen zu werden, so ist der Lauf der Geschichte. Sobald es um die Türken geht, versucht man alles abzusprechen, was sie erreicht haben oder was sie geleistet haben. Sie sind ein Türkenhasser, mehr nicht.

[@YunusMK-d5v]

Yes, exactly, we don't destroy anything/anyone, you however, are known to do so. We have mercy, we have respect to human life, but you have thousands of so-called gods with their sick-minds. It's good that we didn't let you 😂😂😂

[@Maybeautyjune676]

​@@kd1405And Greeks came to current Greece from Africa , Subsahara.Go back Africa !😊😊

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

Almanya imparatoru ingiliz krali ve rus cari kuzenlerdi ama 3 tane ayrı devleti yineliyorlardı. Aile Alman diye rusyaya Almanya denmez. Yani T.C. devletteki 16 yıldız da büyük bir yalan😂😂😂

[@Soload808]

Seninkisi nası bı qt acısıdır 😂

[@OttomanGrandson]

Bir yerlerden acın var galiba

[@delly41]

@@Soload808 onun acısı bitmez kımıldadıkça acımaya devam edicek :D

[@Karahan1603]

Türk devleti o devletler yegen

[@serhaneroglu5402]

Ne skmslar sana

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

so you will understand how us muslims turk surfer under erdogana regine..

[@ss-fr3kr]

Yaziklar sana

[@andycandal5934]

Slavery was a ottoman way of life

[@EV-EV-EV]

Yes

[@andycandal5934]

@@nesrintercan1220...'cause Turkey was and is a freaking racist country. For centuries the turks were enslavers, ruthless, abusers, cruel, merciless, genocidal, torturers, fanatical,. Turkey has a long history of human rights abuse and intolerance. Don't try to whitewash Turkey's abhorrent past 'cause we know better. The only way to deal with turkish brutality was by sheer force. Remember Lepanto !

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

Andy, people shouldn’t make comments on serious issues where one is required to have some historical knowledge and some intelligence. Otherwise they would make a fool out of themselves as you have done here.

[@kd1405]

​@@nesrintercan1220 you did worse upon us. You imposed blood tax. And we are white and christians mind you. How you expect collective whiteness and christiandom to ever forget/forgive something like that?

[@letsdothis5131]

Go learn history facts bro 😅😅😅

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

as a jew Tayyip erdoğan controller turkey..

[@fredricocosta7977]

The Ottomans are highly overrated. Lots of what they did was simply copying what the Romans, Umayyids and Persians did before them. This was not the Golden Age of Islam and Spanish Muslims did more for Islam than Ottomans did.

[@tanura5830]

Ottomans are not overrated. Every empire had influence from others and no Ottomans didn't simply copy Romans that's totally wrong. No one sais it was golden age of islam. And the golden age of islam wasn't good either because there was slavery and other horrible stuff. What did Spanish Muslims do for islam?

[@eren9001]

Ok Fredericocosta

[@fredricocosta7977]

@@tanura5830 Ottoman Turks saw themselves as the continuation of the Roman civilisation, they even called themselves the new caesers, you can look this up. As for Spanish Muslims here is a brief list: trigonometry (Jabir ibn Aflah), astronomy (Al-Zarqali), surgery (Al-Zahrawi), pharmacology (Ibn Zuhr), and agronomy (Ibn Bassal and Abū l-Khayr al-Ishbīlī).

[@fredricocosta7977]

@@tanura5830 After the conquest of Constantinople in 1453, the sultans of the Ottoman Empire laid claim to represent the legitimate Roman emperors. This claim was based on the right of conquest and mainly rested on possession of Constantinople, capital of the Byzantine (Eastern Roman) Empire for over a millennium. The sultans could also claim to be rulers of the Romans since they ruled over the former Byzantine populace, which continued to identify as such. Various titles were used by the sultans to stress their claim, including kayser-i Rûm ("Caesar of Rome") and basileus (the Byzantine ruling title)

[@SeventhSeaSinbad]

Agreed.

[@linobenetti6578]

They ravaged n savaged Anatolia ever since their advent... They conquered Konstantinople... emphasis on the word conquered...and they still proud to this day... such a glory...imagine a steppe-culture tribe stepping out of the steppe to conquer Konstantinople... The Austrian Vienna was too unlucky to avoid the Ottoman conquest... Intellectual dislocation....or happenstance poor interview questionnaire...?

[@andeezaima319]

Every empire are such. American, British, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Russian(pretty much of the lands still not decolonized). Even in our modern era, the western invasions, occupations were and still condemn by the UN.

[@linobenetti6578]

@@andeezaima319 u right about that...thats for sure.....but with the Ottomans there s a peculiarity and i ll explain : the americans dont go around bragging they exterminated the native indians neither the british are proud and cocky they canned and whipped India to death or the Japanese that they forced all indochina women to prostitution....the Ottomans though they organise fiestas and public events on how they ravaged n savaged konstantinople and massacred its 3M+ inhabitants... They still proud ...to this day ... Thats tribalism.

[@kd1405]

​@@andeezaima319 maybe. But not againt Christiandom. Turks did all that against Christiandom.

[@xe6ze]

@@kd1405and the Christian do it all against the Islam. Its humanity.

[@vahramkhatchikian4349]

As an Armenian we did not see anything good from Ottoman Empire...they subjected us and committed genocide...

[@Levent-1975]

After living 400 years of peace and brotherhood, practicing your religion and language freely, not going to army, becoming rich in crafting and trade and then provoked to have a flag and became a pion of imperialists, started slaughtering innocence people and then for what ? To have a flag and be a satellite country of France. Congrats ! you have now a flag but no freedom, you have your own land but can not have a policy since you are too small, your rich people care about you ? In the past you lived freely and rich no one sent you wars or used as pion you did not have flag but you were more free then today. Bravo. now go and enjoy your leaf country who ever blows you more you go with them and die for your rich imperialists brother countries. yesterday fr, now ru.. who tomorrow ? We do not care you will be left alone living in 1970s. and your supporters will never allow you to strengthen and improve they dont work that way... unlike us.. one incident and you throw your 400 years of friendship to lions. Good luck with them..

[@sinanss175]

Ha ha ha😮

[@sahanhalil]

Ottomans saved life of whole armenians for 7 centuries. thats a huge change. in any part of world, Armenians could be vanished in history very early.

[@ferdinandthinker2400]

What about rusaia?

[@steppenwolf5956]

you are lying but repating lies don't make lies become true

[@demetridar506]

It was 600 years of darkness. An Imperialistic adventure that promoted the elimination of progress. At least the western empires promoted the advancement of technology. The Ottoman empire just destroyed. The founder of the Ottoman Navy was a Greek pirate. Modern Turkey continues operating with the same principles.

[@Drigger95]

F off

[@TAMERLIN56]

What a nonsence...cry greek cry.

[@demetridar506]

@@TAMERLIN56 Yes indeed. The Ottoman monuments are perhaps the most impressive in human history.

[@andyd568]

Ottomans were thieves and killers, from a historical point of view.

[@RomeoSuvar]

You are delusional. Darkness?? Your voice is full of hatred, not logic or knowledge.

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

Ottomans were an eupapian state. they werent turk eidher muslim. they fair to loose power so they keep turks away from royal family. when turkik clans had 1000 man they devided force to some move.

[@steppenwolf5956]

you are lying buddy OR you have no idea what you are talk about. I think you are an Iranian so your position aginst Turks is understandable as persians and shia never supported the sunni islam

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

i loved in istanbul for 15 years. go and see how ottoman loved in palaces. have many women they had in haram. ottoman family not married to turks. they ofraid to louise power. they inde sadettin kelp in history.

[@Factsspeakinguser]

I couldn’t have read more rubbish than this 😂

[@ullymolly4966]

Stfu haters

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

@@ullymolly4966 yürü git. insanlara nefret aşılayarak mi insanlardan saygı bekleyeceksiniz.?

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

A big lie " there were 16 big state in history" the state who formly spoken turkik were ugurs, gokturks, karahanli and turkey. the rest is persian and arabic states😂

[@stouellette]

also the great Turkic Selcuk Empire which was there before the Ottomans

[@HasanBasri-ni8kc]

@@stouellette their formal language was partsy. great selçuk empire were a irany state only royal family was a turkik.

[@Pazendeci]

Today, half of Iran is of Turkish origin. If there were only rulers of Turkish origin, that state would not last long.​@@HasanBasri-ni8kc

[@Factsspeakinguser]

@@HasanBasri-ni8kcSelcuk Empire were a state that had Arabic as religious and scientific language, Iranian as state and literature language and Turkish as palace and army language. The ruling class, which were the dynasty were Oguz Turks and the army were almost only Turks from Central Asia. In the perspective that the Empires were ruled by the army and density in ancient times it was clear, whose state it was. It is one of the 16 states Turks established and ruled. They maintained the local and regional cultures and traditions, which is why they allowed them to talk and get education in their very own respected languages. Like I said the empires made out of the dynasties, so based on that you can understand whose ethnically it can be categorized.

[@turan2815]

One of the 16 you mention Ottoman and Seljuk is included you fashist

[@edbop]

The fall of the Ottoman Empire was a boon for the people of Africa; their enslavement and castration had been a great stain on the character of the Muslim world. It is not that Islam is absent from the discussion table of civilisation, it is simply that practices such as honor killings, child brides, enforced marriages, killing of apostates etc are no longer compatible with much of humanity's conception of civilization. The Ottoman empire was a medieval empire that failed to evolve and reform, hence it fell.

[@CTzons]

Wtf are you yapping again? Oh repeated anti muslim lies, 1.Honor killings violate the islamic sharia. 2.Child brides? Seriously? Yeah idk if you know but The age of consent IN ALL ABRAHAMIC RELIGIONS (Not just islam) Is when a woman reaches Age of consent + Both the spouse and the husband and their familes must consent to the marriage 3.Killing of apostates is only applicable when the apostate start to spread misinformation and hate on islam and wage war against islam 4.Forced marriage? Okay now I have to stop you RIGHT there, Like the amount of far right propaganda you took must be too high, Forced marriage is as haram as homosexuality, Both the spouse and the husband-to be and their familes MUST consent otherwise MARRIAGE IS NOT APPLICABLE.

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

By the way you are either blinded by hate or too ignorant to give accurate information. Every word you wrote is historically incorrect.

[@edbop]

@@sibelshinaishin5170 Prove it.

[@harbinger2838]

Butchered 3 MILLION Armenians.

[@delly41]

Your lies are parabolically increasing, so what was the population then?

[@sibelshinaishin5170]

@@delly41this is typical. Poor people all civilians living in peace in eastern Anatolia suddenly had to face Ottoman fury. Well i guess we all have to overlook the facts that Armenian gangs slaughtering Muslim civilians,men women children by thousands dumping their bodies in lakes or burying them in mass graves, burning civilians alive after hoarding them in to the mosques and setting them to fire. Read the book by the first Armenian presidents memoirs about the cruelties of ARMENIAN GANGS and what they did to the innocent Muslim people of the area.

[@Ugi494]

i knew there were 6 Billion Armenians killed by Turks. please bro, don't lower that number so your French backed genocide tales can stay more dramatical..

[@mda990]

It is 5 million now. Most respectful historians think 2 million Kurds killed by Armenian liberty warriors were muslim Armenians actually. So ottomans gen0cided 5 million Armenians😢 how cruel they are

[@Karahan1603]

Ufak At civcivler yesin

[@KrejgMuys]

You play with your glasses too much

[@Lion_Kurt]

🤘🐺🐺🐺🤘🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷