What If Anakin Skywalker Never Turned To The Dark Side & Led The Rebellion

[@RealXa1n]

If George Lucas started Star Wars from Episode I instead of IV, it could’ve went exactly this way. Full story of Anakin with the tragic fall of the Jedi and the rise of the Rebellion against the Empire. Love this scenario

[@datingwiafusexclubdatingwiDOKI]

Same here. I love this way I hated how it was before. If only it did start this way from episode one instead of episode four like Aniken, being on the light side, and never turning to the dark is way better in my opinion, and a way better for the rebellion in the Jedi and I love this way more. I think we all agree that this is a way better win then how the prequel’s happened in its loss worse and I think that’s how we all would want it to happen anyway because man it’s sucked before seeing Aniken being on the dark side and it kind of sucks for four minutes. It was so painful like the prequel‘s because Aniken would be on the dark side but in this time one is just way better. Any mix revenge of the Sith way better it makes it less painful and less hurtful to watch because at least he didn’t turn right everyone we wish this is how this would’ve happened in the actual timeline, this should happen in the actual timeline in the comics. At least I think with George Lucas should make a cannon then this is what happen in the actual timeline Branigan never turned to the Darkside in this home things what happened? I think we’d all love to see that this is what we all wish things would happen instead of what actually happened during revenge of the Sith and the prequel‘s like man you know how painful it is, like in the actual time alone like it was sad kind of before but now it’s better

[@DrownedInExile]

Yeah but then we would have never had one of the greatest film villains ever: Darth Vader.

[@Mann_mit_Kaffee]

@@DrownedInExile I saw a video about a vader analysis. Vader is not one of the greatest film villains, but he is the most iconic of all film villains ever.

[@Endrgamr262]

@@DrownedInExile they could have just made Vader a different character if they did this

[@tmcwas3717]

@@Mann_mit_Kaffeehe is easily THE greatest villain in all of film

[@WlmaAlexender-zl6nx]

This is one of the better "what if" scenarios of all time. Anakin being the chosen one, this was his best response to the empire. And I like the way you handled it, bravo!

[@ezekielsparadise4633]

I like how you included Anakin using the empty ship distraction like he did during the liberation of Ryloth.

[@Knight2007_]

Wait this story was actually so satisfying to listen to, like I was so invested. The idea of a more powerful version of obi wan, ahsoka and anakin dueling palpatine seems so cool. And the Jedi leading clones against the empire was really nice.

[@jessw9043]

This is also one of the very few what if's that has Obi-Wan living at the end of it. Also one of the very few that still has Anakin in a sense "whole".

[@ninjago0o9]

this actually makes lots of sense in my opinion

[@robertalix8147]

Yeah, I agree.

[@ITrooper089Productions]

The only change I would make would have been to have Anakin open up to the ghost of Qui-Gon, but other than that, it's a very well made scenario.

[@82dorrin]

An interesting idea. Anakin doesn't turn to the Dark Side, but things kinda go to shit anyway. The Empire still comes to power.

[@DrownedInExile]

Well done! Just a few things. I wish Anakin had only deflected Windu's strike, instead of maiming him. Palpy would have used the distraction to fatally blast Windu with lightning. Hera Sindulla should have been part of the air-wing. And lastly Palpy, upon defeat, should have tried some final taunt: "Go ahead boy. Strike me down with all your hate, and your journey to the D-" (Anakin beheads him dispassionately, almost as an afterthought) Obi-Wan: "Did he always talk that much? It's a wonder you didn't kill him years ago!"

[@jamesbellefeuille2926]

Obi-Wan would say something that snarky.

[@casbot71]

Anakin survived the fall because Windu's corpse broke his fall.

[@outspokengaming8850]

Well if Anakin survived why not windu after all Jedi and sith have survived a much greater fall

[@Happysecret180]

​@@outspokengaming8850in a planned scene, boba fett shot windu but it was scrapped

[@jamesbellefeuille2926]

"I'm still alive, motherfucker!"

[@ravenebony2267]

​@@outspokengaming8850it depends on how unconscious Windu was from Palp's zappy-zap

[@TheCorpsehatch]

I want to see a series or movie based on the stories from these videos. They are amazing.

[@dr.veronica6155]

I appreciate the mental image of Anakin leading the 501st into the Jedi Temple like in the movie but as a good guy this time. Also, it's hilarious to think of the 5th Brother fighting Anakin. He was so bad at everything that one time, Ahsoka basically just shoved him into a wall and he was not only unable to stop himself but got knocked out from hitting his head on the wall despite the fact that he was wearing a helmet and it took the hit entirely.

[@anon_laughing_man]

Legit this is the best Star Wars What If thus far. If only this could actually be made.🤟🤟🤟

[@DarkForce0017]

This is a truly magnificent take on a classic What-If scenario of the Star Wars Saga! Love it!

[@unclebozo9845]

This is one of your best in my opinion! Here's an idea: What if Dooku discovered the world between worlds and saved Qui-Gon?

[@annabednarska6990]

This is the best What if story I've ever heard ❤ They should turn it into a movie with Hayden, Rosario and Ewan in it.

[@timalsept2854]

Don’t forget Temuera Morrison as Rex

[@annabednarska6990]

👍@@timalsept2854

[@jessw9043]

Totally agree!! If not a movie maybe a good like 8 episode limited series.

[@Happysecret180]

And the others voiced by him, anyone without helmets with his face, one of the stunt ppl could be the TCW VAs​@@timalsept2854

[@chargeminecraft]

This is exactly what my fanfiction will begins, Anakin Skywalker never turn to the dark side, but Palpatine still wins the war and turn the Galactic Republic into Galactic Empire.

[@Zukatuku]

What’s the name?

[@JoseAntonioSolisRios]

name

[@chargeminecraft]

@@JoseAntonioSolisRios Star Wars Reboot: Season 7 Clone Wars: The End of Clone Wars. And then Star Wars: The Adventures of Skywalker.

[@JoseAntonioSolisRios]

@@chargeminecraft page fanfiction ao3 wattpad

[@chargeminecraft]

@@JoseAntonioSolisRios what

[@jotheunissen9274]

The biggest twist of it all Shaak Ti SURVIVED

[@dalejuliancelecia7110]

Better version for the return of the jedi than the original for sure.👍👍

[@tavonnedillon9299]

Mannnn I then seen many videos on what ifs for Star Wars after Episode III and I can honestly say… I wish this was in movie format with all of the live action main characters. Anakin, Obi, and Ahsoka🤞🏾🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@marcusappelberg369]

This is one of my favorite what if. Well done!

[@Intrepid_A]

What if instead of the trade federation invasion of Naboo, Palpatine and Plagueis orchestrated a military dictatorship to take over naboo years before the events of the phantom menace?

[@angelusfallox7148]

Who would have thought that you can't 1v3 Anakin Skywalker, ahsoka, and obi wan Kenobi. It's almost as if they fought an entire war together XD for real though what a fucking beautiful thought The three of them fighting in unison in the final fight. God I would pay to see that

[@ThatOneOf3StrongholdPlayers]

“I dunno bout these claims of saving someone, I’m just gonna keep a close eye on Padmé” the what if scenario.

[@Open_Zipper85]

I watch revenge of the sith all the time and every time I expect Anakin to get it right this time lol.

[@TenkoBerry]

This was quite Great ❤

[@chevin0]

I haven't had time t finish watching yet, but my guess is a whole lot fewer Rebels running away and the Death Star never got completed before getting blown up. the Emperor was basically the only one who could have slowed Anakin down

[@iowaredneck9416]

He fell, but came back before it was too late. This was a good light side what if, but I think it would have been good for Anakin to tell everyone the truth of Windu. It would show an even greater balance to the chosen one while requiring the galaxy to show compassion and forgiveness

[@TheCiroth]

OMG, this story made me realize how close the three really are. It seems clear as day now that Kenobi is the Father, Ashoka is the Daughter, and Anakin is the Son.

[@jessw9043]

Now that would interesting to see them embody those three.

[@PdaPupGaming]

Well who’s the Mother

[@edisonlaw934]

@@PdaPupGamingpadme of course

[@Krypton853]

Many ppl have done what If Anakin never turned. But this Story is actually good.

[@monster_in_a_garden]

I absolutely love these “what if” scenarios, you really capture the essence of the characters and the Star Wars universe as well

[@magnawaves]

Mace seething in the force that only 1 person knew he got wrecked by Anakin and that their response was "lol it's ok buddy" Anakin got away with all of it! 😂

[@justinbrown5766]

This is an awesome story I’ve never even thought about ani leading the rebellion what a cool concept.

[@codezero7981]

my favorite what if.

[@Grimfist66]

Another great story. You should really expand your stories and do 30-60 minute episodes.

[@warpdriveby]

This is really well done, and fun so I hope it doesn't seem overly critical to point out a small thing that seems off, at least to me. After describing Anakin take Windu's hand and get blasted by Palpatine as normal, you then several times refer to Anakin having "cut him down". It would be a distinction to Yoda, despite it still being badly misguided, and you even give Yoda a philosophical view of it as well. It's not a huge deal, and nothing would change anyway, I'd just use it more strictly.

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

oh great what if man really maybe also make other ones i and many others mentioned that you know you can do it one at a time

[@Ol-T1864]

Haven’t heard it yet but this is the one I’m most excited for

[@Basicelements1]

Your content is so much better than what is being produced today! Thanks for the great stories 🎉😊

[@EvilGingerChill]

I really liked this, honestly would love for you to revisit the same scenario but expand upon it and maybe make a couple hour long story, break it into parts and just have a little series really diving deep and expanding on it. My only complaint is I wanted more haha!

[@littlefoot5013]

1.) What if Ahsoka and Barris joined together rather than turn against each other? (This could either be: A.) They both either left the Order together or stayed in it together and worked to try and reform it. B.) They both partook in the Temple bombing.) 2.) What if Darth Vader realized that Leia was his daughter when he captured her on the Tantive IV? 3.) What if Luke was killed on Hoth (either by the Wampau or killed along with Dack)? 4.) What if Han Solo was strong in the Force? 5.) What if the Yuzzhan Vong invaded the Galaxy during the Clone Wars?

[@RyanTheDark]

I love all the way you be foiling up Sidious's plans. Lmao

[@brothers_of_nod]

I've seen ones if Obi Wan managed to save Anakin on Mustafar, but this is a fascinating take, I like it.

[@Rack-Aid]

Love the videos bro keep up the good work!!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thank you!!!

[@galaxytrongamerop6018]

I love this type of story as well. Thanks for such an enjoyable story

[@alfietannock5010]

I’m so happy I have an active imagination, you just made the best movie for me and I’m genuinely just sat here smiling, you healed my chuldhood that Disney ruined thx homie

[@sheikhrajelali4835]

i doubt anikan would be very tolarant of the blatant nepitism considering how the new republic currently is in the asoka show. he would call out certain members of the rebellion on there bs.

[@tracyjohnson5486]

Just discovered your channel. You got a new subscriber in me. Great "What If" Star Wars stories!

[@TheDARKESTKNIGHT-]

What if order 66 was executed by accident at the beginning of the clone wars

[@GreenNeptune22]

That gonna be awkward one haha

[@furious_pie466]

*Jedi bust into the chancellors office* Palpatine: o-oh u-hhhh master Jedi how may I help yo- Yoda: A lot of fucking explaining to do you have Mace: you’re in charge here tell us why the clones attempted to kill us Palpatine: ohhhhh uhhhh ummmm ANAKIN THE JEDI ARE TAKING OVER HELP ME! Obi Wan: I guess Dooku was right

[@Ale12287]

​@@furious_pie466palpatine: send lightnings Plo koon: blocks and send them too Palpatine: oh fuck that's why i executed order 66 when he was in a ship

[@CharlesLaBuhn]

You went pretty far out there, why did you not bring back a damaged but powerful Mace Windu? This was a great feel good movie and having him show up would have been nice. But once again you did a wonderful job and I am looking forward to the next time.

[@KenshiImmortalWolf]

bringing back windu is often it's own what if

[@Mann_mit_Kaffee]

Because his death is part of anakins redemption, it has to be done.

[@CharlesLaBuhn]

@@Mann_mit_Kaffee "Even Harrod loed his family" is an old saying that the most evil people can sometimes look "Good". Anakin was evil to the core, killed trillions, and will still rot in Jedi Hell.

[@Mann_mit_Kaffee]

@@CharlesLaBuhnThats not the point, its yoda redeming his murder of mace windu, not the actual kill count. ALSO anakin didn't trillions at this point of the story.

[@CharlesLaBuhn]

@@Mann_mit_Kaffee I believe that if Anakin killed Obi Wan on Mustafar he would have killed the Emperor and ruled himself. Ps HOW MANY CHILDREN DOES HE NEED TO SLAUGHTER TO BE TOTALLY EVIL? DO NOT FORGET WHEN HIS MOTHER DIED.

[@Edward2Fan47]

Would make a good what if that should be animated on Disney+

[@oliversherman2414]

This is an interesting scenario

[@kahn6287]

What if Dooku just went home after leaving the order, or what if Dooku became a Gray Jedi

[@gcolson3388]

Here's an idea of mine: "What if Mace Windu found himself on Earth in the present day?" I noticed in "Wrath of The Sith" that after Palpatine blasted him with Force lightning, it looked like Mace Windu just disappeared . And, remember, no one ever found his body.

[@walkerhartge9177]

What I would have liked to see in this video is this. 15 or 20 years after the declaration of a new order. One final climactic battle on coruscant. Anakin and Sidious dueling, the city in the background. Mon Cal cruisers and Star destroyers falling to the surface of coruscant. Luke and Leia duelling starkiller(w/ his true sith name(Darth something (not Darth Starkiller)))elsewhere on the planet.

[@DennisHeikki]

This was epic! Really enjoyed the scenario. This could've been a interesting movie(s)

[@yanyanzhang5813]

It’s a great story. But in my opinion, I think Obi Wan would become the grandmaster and become Leia’s master while Ahsoka taught Luke. In my mind, the Jedi had become a duty to Anakin, he had been poisoned by the expectations he carried as the “chosen one”. I think he would have retired as a Jedi, or become a blade instructor to the next generation, no longer wishing to be the warrior they had all forced him to be.

[@GamePlays_1230]

No why would a father who has been treated evilly by his what supposed to be community ever let thrm be trained into the order remember the order was poisoned years ago The very first evidence of that was how they treated anakin while he was a child

[@MatthewJamesKalasky]

14:16 Just like velociraptors.

[@shawnpanzegraf5642]

What if Grievous survived the transport bombing meant to turn him into an IGBC enforcer? (Not needing to be rebuilt as a cyborg, but now aware there were forces intending to do to the galaxy what had been done to his world?)

[@MATEUSthe7th]

The only thing I would change about this WHAT IF scenario is Darth Sidious finding a new apprentice after losing Anakin. Perhaps a cyborg Mace Windu, Darth Maul, or Barris Offee. In wouldn’t be in Darth Sidious’ character to be caught off guard so easily. He knew Anakin lived and Obi-Wan escaped so he would’ve anticipated that they come to execute him eventually. And having an apprentice to hunt or duel them, if the situation ever arise.

[@timalsept2854]

Amazing idea. Loved it!

[@dprescott1970]

This was an awesome story 😊

[@casbot71]

.... or we could load up a transport with bombs and program it to swerve and crash into Palpatines office as it approaches the hangars.

[@wasabi-24_42]

Yea this is the one, this is the what if that need to be made

[@zachpierce8342]

What if Grievous survived into the rebellion era?

[@DarkDyllon]

Grievous isn't that much of a threat since Obi-wan survived, Obi-Wan was basically the only 1 that was well equiped to handle the good generals fighting style, since Grievous is 100% offense, while Obi-wan favours defence over offense, granted normally Obi-Wan can actually tire his opponent out but obviously doesn't work with Grievous, but his defensive form gives him an edge against the general, it would likely end quicker than the actual version of their battle, since the main reason why Grievous survived that long there was because he could run away when needed, with the Jedi in hiding, they could easily strike while Grievous is unaware, Sidious would keep him around knowing full well that he doesn't have an apprentice and thus nobody to actually help him out, Grievous is the only 1.

[@rickyk4583]

If Grievous survived into the main timeline where Anakin becomes Vader, I imagine Palpatine would've hunted him down. He's one of the few people who would've been able to restart the Droid Army. In fact, his presence alone would've kept the Separatists alive a bit longer even after Vader killed their leaders. That being said, Grievous would also have been loyal to Sidious during all of this (it's heavily implied that he knew about Order 66), so maybe Palpatine would've kept him around as a secret assassin of sorts.

[@tobiast471]

​@@DarkDyllonI actually don't think Palpatine would have kept Grievous alive it wouldn't have looked good for the Empire in the eyes of the people because everbody knew that Grievous led the CIS army

[@DarkDyllon]

@@tobiast471 he would keep Grievous in the shadows, obviously making him and Palps be linked is a bad thing, but with Palps not having any force sensitive allies anymore (in this story atleast) he would need someone to do the dirty work for him. Sure he could play the hooded wicked man again like he did sometimes, but that's a risk he won't be willing to make unless the benefits far outweigh the risks. Like when he went for Maul and Savage, leaving those 2 to their own devices would be a bad idea since Savage follows Maul and Maul is a loose cannon, he would turn on Sidious if he got the chance, it's not like he could send Grievous and Dooku to Mandalore and kill Maul and Savage, since likely Maul would just shred Grievous to pieces since Grievous' whole point is that he's intimidating, doubt Maul would be intimidated, let alone Savage and Dooku wouldn't stand much of a chance against both Savage AND Maul. Palps always wants to keep allies so that he can shift the blame or send them to do his dirty work, obviously being the leader of the empire means he can't just go out and let his assistant just do things in the background, there would be more focus on him. he would likely make a ploy of "we're actively hunting down Grievous!" meanwhile sending a few soldiers to some locations every once in a while.

[@PdaPupGaming]

Well this aged well

[@Exile97]

Absolutely loved the story my only issue or i guess criticism is i dont think ahsoka can even remotely hang either sidious, i think to the way he toyed with maul and savage, he could of just walked up and killed them(Maul & S) in a few seconds. But still loved the way it played out😂😂

[@rickyk4583]

Yeah, the only way she survives is because Anakin and Obi Wan are there

[@KenshiImmortalWolf]

Sure but unlike Windu's gaggle of masters you have a trio that not only have fought along side each other for years (clone wars) but also trained together for years ontop of that (the 5 year rebellion build up) So even if Ahsoka isn't able on her own to even concern sidious, her ability to act in tandem with anikan and obi-wan make her a bigger factor in this cause Sidious can't just focus on her with the other two there to exploit him trying.

[@Exile97]

@@KenshiImmortalWolf that sounds wonderdul in practice but i would take sidious pressing all 3 of them at once the way he did Maul and Savage. they cant defend her in my opinion

[@KenshiImmortalWolf]

@@Exile97 i will point out that ahsoka beat maul solo which is something obi-wan did in his youth. I don't think the maul savage thing is as big of a deal as you think it is just because the show gave it such dramatic energy. Savage never pressed assaj who held him off with only one of her sabers. Savage is big and strong sure but any time savage has had to fight another force user he gets folded every time, he probably was holding maul back being there cause maul was worried about him dying.

[@Giantsfanghg]

@@Exile97you’re vision is clouded based on cannon, you’re completely negating the fact that this is supposed to be a what if, and this what if just happens to have the most powerful force user ever still in his prime and not vastly weakened by mustafar incident, this version of skywalker wouldn’t have even needed obi wan and Ashoka to cut down sidious here but it was put in because it further solidifies the hero trio we all love

[@deanturner4154]

I would love to see a Star Wars trilogy like that

[@The_Meme_Jesus]

Good job bro

[@dianesinger9729]

Great what up I love Anakin taking charge with the survivors

[@CPUReddragon24]

what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him

[@blazefazbear]

This might be a good one: What if plaguies and Sidious were Jedi and Yoda and mace were sith (Yoda the master mace apprentice and plaguies is grandmaster and Sidious is master of the order)

[@TarsonTalon]

"This is where the fun begins..."

[@grzechudubrowski7874]

Or maybe something else? What if dooku and grievous survived and joined the rebelion with the droids? 😁

[@JohnnyArrazola]

Cool My brother man

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Kit Fisto and Mace Windu survived in Revenge Of The Sith

[@mads-Riley-Art]

I like to believe that Kit would've joined the Rebellion and mace would've gone rogue and become a lone grey jedi and hunted Vader and Palpatine on his own terms

[@mattm600]

Mixing franchises: What if Thanos's snap reached the Star Wars galaxy c.Revenge of the Sith?

[@jeremyk.6456]

What if Revan found and trained Yoda? Possibly to revolutionize the entire Jedi Order to become what they’re truly meant to be for the people and galaxy at large.

[@BinkBinkgmd]

They are literally thousands of years apart from eachother it wouldn’t be possible

[@markknudsen1755]

Am I the only one wondering if at 9:10 Luke and Leia are speaking Shyriiwook or Galactic Basic? This is an interesting direction!

[@theervinalliance6339]

This is a fantastic story

[@HyperJohnua]

ive got a what if suggestion for you, what if knightfall darth vader had to fight dark times shakti (force unleashed) during the jedi temple raid.

[@blairterry9435]

Anakin tells Obi-Wan that he must train Luke to become a Jedi when both he and Lia are born and are separated to not only protect them, but also hide from the Sith knowing all too well that Sidious will not stop until all the Jedi are destroyed and the galaxy is his to rule for his galactic empire. He would eventually train Luke if something happened to Obi-Wan like being found by the Inquisitors.

[@jediofswtor5738]

I got an idea. What if a Klingon or Federation ship arrived in the Star wars universe. Maybe during the clone wars?

[@VashtheStampede007]

A Borg cube

[@debutriah2854]

@@VashtheStampede007oh god

[@Happysecret180]

​@@debutriah2854Borg ewok

[@catjuzu]

I liked this one very much.

[@nicholasthomas6407]

There would have never been a rebellion. Anakin would have kicked old palps backside

[@That0therG]

I'm still baffled that Palpatine looses in all these fanfics, or that ahsoka and obi-wan survive

[@grandmasterbob1040]

Awesome video

[@sheikhrajelali4835]

what if the new republic was smarter in how it dealt with the aftertermath of the rebbelion, could start with mon mothma being overthrown for being nepotistic.

[@dxleto_67]

Love your videos man!

[@Fingios24]

Weeeeeeell, in the original story Anakin was a founding member of the Rebellion before he was killed by Vader. He and Vader were separate people. And in another script his name was Anakin Starkiller.

[@CommanderAlien18]

Great video

[@KenshiImmortalWolf]

While i like this story, the title feels a bit inaccurate. It doesn't feel like Anikan is leading the rebellion so much as just is the rebellion. I'd of loved a slower burn story where Anikan Obi-wan and Ahsoka become founding members of the rebellion like Bail and Mon Monthma. Still taking time as they act against the empire in the outter rim to get more gear and clones. Instead of just 2k getting something closer to 5 or even 10 k but the clones starting to age out and becoming trainers for rebel troopers like the empire used them in the empire thus making the rebel even stronger as the clones in the rebellion would be better teachers without the focus on numbers as strength. As well as The training of the twins. Maybe even taking advantage of small rebellions like lothal.

[@disneyknightspadilla1406]

I wish they should do a new series where all the events can be altered because I’m looking forward to see it changed.

[@TheDogBasti]

W vid AS ALWAYSSSSSSSSS

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Well thank you!

[@notyourbusiness99450]

Then star wars would be even more chaotic than they are now

[@robertnickerson8463]

The story was good, and it had a heart warming ending... Anakin redeemed himself after he had apparently helped Palatine kill Master Windu... Would have Windu have found another way to survive because Palatine blasted Anakin with the lightning bolts yet Anakin found a way to survive. ..

[@MrPopGY]

I was thinking about this type of what if 😂

[@itstaylor2137]

I need a full movie

[@liamwalton3469]

Should of had Anakin be found by an injured Mace Windu and R2D2 after jumping out the window, then have Anakin, Mace (now with a metal hand) and the Wookiees rescue Luminara Unduli on Kashyyyk after hearing she’d been captured by the empire before being joined by Master Yoda, Obi Wan, Quinlan Vos and fellow order 66 survivor Nari (from the Kenobi series) on Kashyyyk with Ahsoka arriving later alongside to everyone’s surprise Asajj Ventress wanting to rejoin the Jedi and becoming the new Padawan of Master Windu

[@dylxnmonxrch]

well written

[@ludwigvanbeethoven182]

What if mother talzin killed dooku in the clone wars

[@itzxsliick7036]

Can you make a fanfic of this where anakin catches Mace as they both fall? About how that would change the story again

[@Don.Denaro]

Day 2 of "what if Vitiate returned in TPM and Trained Anakin?"