What if Anakin was TRAINED by Yoda, Not Obi-Wan?

[@daeliusdrake7810]

I like that Anakin used force judgement instead of force lightning while fighting yoda and obiwan, because it shows both the extent of his training and control as a Jedi under Yoda, as well as his restraint and care not to hurt the two of them.

[@Dmoney8787]

I like the idea of anakin being an egineer if he was with the CIS. I feel like aside from phantom menace, his tech savvy skills were not used as much as they should have.

[@DarthTheorist]

100% agree, they made him a great pilot because of it but it could've been expanded more. Too much detail to fit into 2 movies I suppose haha we need an extended version like lord of the rings has

[@blindvision4703]

@@DarthTheorist I think I’ve heard people asking for the SuperCut of revenge of the Sith. Then again, you can almost get the same thing by reading the Matthew Stover mobilization of revenge of the Sith. And the version of attack the clones novel by Salvatore has an extra details as well. This could go either way, leaving it as it is or adding it. But is it possible that showing Anakin mechanical adeptness in episode two with contrast more with him not being able to save his mother. He talks about being good at fixing things. Maybe showing him being good at fixing mechanical things, but not being able to save his mother, could make for a more poignant contrast. As it is, we do have that scene with him in the garage anyway. About to watch this video now, which I’ve been avoiding for fear of a Darkside ending, which I tend not to be a fan of.

[@johnhorton4436]

​@DarthTheorist I'd Definitely think that Anakin would End Up with a Green Lightsaber if he were to be Trained by Yoda

[@trainion9626]

"Aw shit! The motherfucking Chosen One is dead!"

[@magnawaves]

This is some SOLID voice acting. Aside from Dooku (who can come close to the great Christopher Lee after all) everyone sounds like a great impression of the characters.

[@danielgoodrich264]

What if JarJar tripped knocking over the vase thus revealing Palpatine's Lightsaber.

[@TakeawayArtist]

Bro that wld be legendary

[@99thJediWarrior]

That slave line hits different. If you really think about it, Anakin had been a slave all his life. He wasn't simply one because he was born in it. He was a slave all his life, even as a Jedi and a Sith. But in the end, it took the love of his son (and the love he had for his son) for Anakin to see he was truly free.

[@histguy101]

As a Jedi, all his needs were met, and he had a duty, but he could leave any time he wanted. Thats not slavery

[@99thJediWarrior]

@histguy101 He's the Chosen One. You really think they would just let him go? If you do, than I don't know what Star Wars films you've been watching.

[@kuunt6065]

​@@histguy101 if he left, he would lose everything and everyone he knows and he had no real experience of the outside world. that's entrapment. part of why it felt like slavery

[@histguy101]

@@kuunt6065 He could go live on Naboo with his wife and do whatever he liked. He's an adult and adults have to provide for themselves. Sometimes people in the military struggle adapting to civilian life because in the military, you don't have to worry about feeding or clothing yourself, and everything is on a good schedule, but the vast majority of veterans adapt just fine. Military service also isn't slavery

[@realBatman-89]

​@@99thJediWarriorthis is dumb and not supported by facts

[@a.a.o.t-1213]

Holy shit man your impressions of the characters is fantastic. Almost as good as clone wars voice acting, like wow.

[@TakeawayArtist]

I’m pretty sure it’s AI is it not?

[@RoomAtTheTopStudio]

If you did this story as a proper cartoon or movie I would definitely support it. This is one of the best alternative stories I've heard or seen on You Tube

[@Kimscrazylife]

There are a lot of up-and-coming Star Wars channels, I follow quite a few of them. If you keep up work such as this, you will stand out among them. You have earned my subscription.

[@DarthTheorist]

Appreciate it! Definitely going to keep it consistent.

[@dawgsrule20]

Very unfortunate that you struck down Mace, but it makes sense that Anakin would strike him down in anger

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Mace is an asshole. I love a good story where he isn’t portrayed as invincible and magically capable of defeating any challenger because of his magic Vapad which he hoards for himself

[@jsavage9229]

That intro with the voice is somthin else 🔥🥵

[@kappakiev9672]

Was not expecting a What if ____ was betrayed from this

[@ryankuniyoshi96825]

Master Yoda would never step down from power unless his guilty conscience sweeps him away.

[@GlitchGhost1285]

By all means Yoda is not a bad master. He is just too stuck in the old ways sometimes.

[@connoreverright6592]

I don’t know if you know much of kotor. But could you do a what if the Old Republic had a droid uprising, while also at war with Dath Malak’s Sith empire? Or something similar. I would also like to see your take on What if the Sith Empire invaded the Republic during the Clone wars. (You could do something similar to PPSW with all/most of the Old Republic Sith somehow invading) Or, maybe what if the Sith Empire invaded Palplatine’s Empire.

[@thronedry6718]

Darth Theorist, I must commend you on a very interesting piece of literary work. Also, understand that not only do you have the voice articulation, you have the writing skill needed for a great channel in the future. Keep up the great work. Look forward to seeing more of your videos I do.

[@DarthTheorist]

thanks!! appreciate the kind words, will definitely keep it consistent.

[@KellymatthewBarnes]

This Anakin I routed for every “step of the way”.

[@NormalChannel95]

We will watch your career with great interest

[@Jeppe_P]

Decided to give this channel a chance and love how different of an approach you take to the story. Subbed.

[@DarthTheorist]

thank you!!

[@Brahmskillin]

Poor dooku, he was so close. I thought he was going to live

[@dianesinger9729]

Great story of Anakin coming to his own power and morals

[@sraLLars]

Really liked this a lot. A small point though. When you killed off Darth Sidious I was very surprised. I feel like he would have put up much more of a fight. The shackles he had on in that chair wouldn't have stopped him at all. Anakin opened them up pretty easily in the movie. But the rest was great!

[@Matt-yg8ub]

The shackles would’ve had to have been realistic or else Anakin and Obi-Wan would not have bought the deception

[@aidanmcdonnell3261]

I subscribed absolutely phenomenal

[@DarthTheorist]

Thank you!!

[@wb7585]

Damn dude was your last job a narrator from the history channel. This was also a very surprising what if. And this makes #7 to force judgement among content creators. Though it has been a long month

[@matthewmann8969]

Anakin turning for the dark side for this reason makes more sense because of his want to help the greater galaxy and to be enabled with his piloting, mechanical, and warrior skills him making conditions for Padme And Obi Wan to not be harmed makes lots of sense those are the two plus him wanting to free slaves in general yeah.

[@PH4NTOM609]

Very underrated video brother focus on consistency and you’ll be one of those big what if channels like Star Wars galaxy, fantasy folklore and pente patrol star wars

[@DarthTheorist]

thank you bro!

[@Matt21747]

i'm a new subscriber glad i found the channel. also was anakins lightsaber still blue?

[@x-track5190]

Aight this was good new subscriber

[@grandmasterbob1040]

Great video just subscribed

[@DarthTheorist]

thank you!!

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

Just subscribed to your channel now bro it’s really good so stay consistent 🔥. #TeamSithLordAllDay

[@DarthTheorist]

thank you bro!! Will definitely keep it consistent for everyone!

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

@@DarthTheorist Not a problem at all much respect ✊🏾

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

[@bu55c]

I WISH that had been the story line!

[@DarthZod]

I rather liked that story mate

[@EmperorDarthOP]

Darth Throrist i was wondering. Could you pretty please do a What If Darth Sidious Found and started to Train Anakin before the Jedi found him? (Perhaps almost even from brith). This all behind Darth Plagiuse's & Darth Maul's backs. Making sure that he is trained to be as poweful and as dark as he could ever be. With his name in this case being Darth Ultimus. The final Sith Lord of the Bane Knight Line. The one to end The Rule of 2 Once he killed his master Emperor Darth Sidious. Become the new Emperor. Emperor Darth Ultimus. And forming The Rule of 1. So basicly the most ultimate and complete triumph of the Dark Side possible.

[@brightlord-ov7cm]

He'd be jumping around with his lightsaber all willynilly and accidentally kill himself in practice one day?

[@phobicdragon8263]

I almost never comment or like videos and rarely subscribe. But God damn if that's not one of my top three "what ifs"...so live action adaptation? Lol. One can "hope" a new take could mean a...."new hope" 😂 let's see it! I'll definitely be watching more as this was my first of yours good sir and team

[@OkLowkey0725]

If Yoda Trained Him he would’ve Became Vader Faster 😂

[@EliasK1423]

I wish you Well on your journey to one k

[@DarthTheorist]

thank you!!

[@carmenlynn5441]

Yikes, this would make yoda lose his religion

[@goflux]

This is good and I'm enjoying many of these videos, but I think there were parts missing in a couple places in this one. In particular at 2:56 (which is definitely missing some of the dialogue, according to the beginning of the script in the description) and 11:58 (where it just feels like there's possibly a line or two missing after "I hear you enjoy building things, young one."). I've watched a lot of these and I think this is the first time I've noticed something like that, which speaks to the quality of them in general.

[@cameronclophus7998]

Form IV is the aggression form. III was Defense.

[@DarthTheorist]

Yes, good catch! Form IV was also master yoda's preferred form and in cannon, Anakin actually adapted Form IV to be more defensive 🙂

[@histguy101]

Yoda would have trained him just fine. He's had many padawans, and more wisdom and experience than any human could have. Obi Wan went from Padawan to Anakin's master the same day. He probably had little to no experience as a teacher

[@blindvision4703]

So he was a dark Jedi? Or a gray Sith? Is the ladder even possible? He doesn’t seem to be as evil as other dark Jedi.

[@DrJRaven]

Excellent theory. I like it, it would be great as a movie.

[@DarthTheorist]

Thank you Jonathan! Appreciate the comments you’ve been giving, thanks for watching our videos :)

[@bigwsly]

Can you do what if anakin was raised with maul savage and feral

[@TheForcesWrath]

I feel like the CIS should have won after Duku and Anakin killed Sideous and the jedi council to create a new Order one that uses both the Darkside and the lightside of The Force.

[@marcusisgod2592]

As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use technoguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals.

[@majesticmsfc]

Great story, loved the ending.

[@boydbeasley3751]

What if Rahm Kota trained Anikin? What if Chewbacca was born a jedi?

[@matiasandrade458]

What if padme came to mustafar and saved anakin after Obi wan left mustafar

[@TylerB-bd8ot]

Form 3 is the defensive form. Form 4 is the acrobatic form that qui gon and Yoda mostly used

[@warsawpactmapping83]

I love how much effort is put into these videos It all fits perfectly with each other!!

[@BrighouseRanger13]

Some thing cool what if ahsoka and ankian swapped places so ahsoka was the choises one and so and so one

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

And what if Anakin and his mother were never slaves, but still meet qui gon what if Anakin and Padme? Were a force dyad and what if tarre vizsla was reincarnated in Anakin Skywalker

[@WeazTintHD]

Good story. Like it. The true anakin this story shows.

[@DarthTheorist]

Appreciate it! really tried to capture his essence

[@youngmoneyclutch]

form 3 is the form for defense not form 4, other than that i loved the video, keep up the good work!

[@TimBooth-bc3vt]

Form 3 is defensive 4 is acrobatic moves and force based attacks just for your info

[@imisstheoldyoutube9845]

Dude your voice.... its epic! 😱

[@tonystank3091]

What if Anakin was betrayed and trapped in the World Between Worlds for 1,000 years? Edit: This is a joke. I brought it with me from the Dragon Ball What-If fanbase. Don't actually do it, it's cringe.

[@joshpeck9266]

To be honest I think plo noon would’ve been the best master for anikin

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

My friend next time make these other what if videos what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by a force itself, his real true creator flatter from birth But he still meets qui gon saves his mother and falls in love with padme

[@Doobie0113]

Timeout. Is this truly your natural speaking voice? Are you using a voice actor? Or some sort of program to add characteristics to your voice?

[@YamiAi]

With Yoda's training Anakin would not have been as drawn to the dark side so early, Yoda would have influenced him to be a better person to some extent

[@dravenbladesong1]

Good story. But it still fails after Dooku loses his hands. He can still use Sith Lightning without hands. The pain and anger from loses his hand could fuel it more.

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

[@Red_rum187]

You're annoying bro you post the same annoying crap on every star wars what if Channel stop Noone gives a f about your ideas

[@Red_rum187]

You're annoying bro you post the same annoying crap on every star wars what if Channel stop Noone gives a f about your ideas

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin was found by jedi belonging to another sect like corelia or those nomadic jedi who allow attachment. What if anakin went to dathomir in revenge of the sith to search for ways to save padme. What if yoda decided to swap the masters of ferus olin and anakin. So anakin with siri. Obi with ferus What if ahsoka and anakin crash landed on bendu's planet. Also what if darth vader joined thrawn in meeting the bendu and went on a spiritual journey back to the dust ball tatiotene.

[@bobablackfly602]

yoba!

[@rodgerscott8808]

What happened at the 3:00 mark?

[@803bucho]

Just a weird cut, I’m sure you figured it out but little Anakin just asked Yoda to save him mom. It picked up just after the question

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Yoda is such a dumb ass! Anakin is absolutely desperate to get out of that suffocating building and they are doing everything they can to keep him locked down for his long as they possibly can…. Which is fundamentally what’s wrong with the Jedi, the entire order is run by a bunch of ancient idiots with no concept of what goes on outside the walls over there Ivory Palace

[@DanielFincannon]

What if Anakin was a girl

[@MrOverlordSir]

so padme isn’t important?…impossible lol

[@cecilarthurton3795]

what if anakin was born female aniaka

[@Scurvybubble242]

bro i swear just make these vids a little bit longer like 35 min instead of 25 and you could overtake ppsw and all the other what if creators, just flesh out the stories and keep up with the great voice acting. You would be so much more recognised

[@DarthTheorist]

You think the videos being 35 min makes that big of a difference?

[@theogghost9872]

the clone wars were not a way to weaken both sides Palpatine had at that point complete control over the separatists. but he could not gain complete control of the starwars univere with just his control of the separatists alone. . so he used them to start a war after revealing the Sith to trick the Jedi into starting a war using clone soldiers he had made in secret, that the Jedi thought were made by a fellow Jedi so the jdei fought the war using palptines clones untill the had a foot on ever planet, then once he had all the clones in place like monaply peices palpatine took complete contoll over the glaxey with a single order. order 66. and instead of fighting the jedi head on he used the war to kill them with order 66.. Palpatine always knew that Anakin was the chosen one because him and his master tried to manipulate the force to creat life. so even if Yoda trained him anakin would have never joined Duku the only reason he sided with Palpatine in rots is because Palpatine made him think that Palpatine could help bring back padme back to life. even trained by Yoda Anakin would have either stayed with the jedi and worked to fix it from within or Palpatine would have done things to manipulate anakin to the darkside like he did in the movies..or even with the republic being corruprt anakin never would have joined the sepertists. if anything he would have took over and ruled to bring true peace and end the corruption just like he wanted to do with padme before he force choked her

[@ROCKhardRICHARD69]

The same thing would have happened but he would have been an even more powerful version of Vader. The biggest problem with Ani wasn't that he turned. He was always going to turn because of the rigidity and stagnant behavior the Jedi Order of the time chose to follow. The only two mainstream jedi that could have helped Anakin were Quigon or his own son Luke in the legacy series. Two jedi that didn't deal in absolutes. The jedi of Yoda's hayday were their own problem

[@Ty_Colis]

Is this a knock off account taking credit for the original guy that makes these? You better give him credit

[@803bucho]

No knock off, there’s like 6 prominent Star Wars what if channels. They all share ideas, just switch the stories up. Most are in communication with one another like pente patrol Star Wars, Star Wars galaxy and fantasy folklore.

[@birkneo]

these ai channels are getting so annoying.

[@DarthTheorist]

??? This isn't AI Voice over lol...

[@birkneo]

@@DarthTheorist is it actually not?!?! 💀 im so dead ass you sound like ai😭😭

[@birkneo]

@@DarthTheorist do you got a discord??

[@DarthTheorist]

@@birkneo 💀