What If Everyone Luffy Asked Actually JOINED THE CREW? | One Piece | Grand Line Review

🔴 Subscribe for more One Piece content: www.youtube.co...
NEW WORLD REVIEW:
/ newworldreview
PATREON:
/ grandlinereview
DISCORD: / discord
REDDIT:
/ grandlinereview
FACEBOOK:
/ grand-line-review-3607...
Teespring:
teespring.com/...
Follow me on Twitter:
/ grandlinereview
Music:
- Epic by Bensound (www.bensound.c...)
- After The Fall by Purple Planet (www.purple-plan...)
Jolly Roger Design by Ambereddraws:
/ ambereddraws
/ ambereddraws

[@JoyGirlYT]

This was wildly exciting! But still not as exciting as speculating what if everyone pressed that subscribe button. EVERYONE getting One Piece content straight into their KZbin feed? Now that’s exciting.

[@GrandLineReview]

See? This person gets it!

[@random_dude2582]

@@GrandLineReview exactly

[@RareSeldas]

Should I smash the subscribe button harder than your mother?

[@Tjon9198]

Does joygirl write the subscribe jokes?

[@ik5506]

RareSeldas that was uncalled for

[@slyshyguy1955]

Luffy: You’re a doctor?! You should be our doctor! Krokis: Well shit guess you’re right

[@soul4speech]

Would love that scene.

[@diivine_entity]

Can’t argue with that logic 😂

[@us4army1]

That would be an answer he would give

[@Slime2sjsuu]

U gave me god laugh man thank you😂

[@omarashry007]

Cue soviet bugs bunny meme

[@punkrider8758]

Alternative ending to the War of The Great where the pirates win. Luffy to Whitebeard: Yo old man! Join my crew!

[@ShockwaveITB]

Whitebeard trains the crew for 2 years.They go to fisman island....stomp punk hazrd...stomp, dressrosa...stomp, wano interesting but the full whitebeard crew plus the strawhats... stomp lol

[@ashutoshsu480]

@@ShockwaveITB this reminds me of Eminem-Kamikaze's chorus for some reason

[@valentino.m.g]

@@ashutoshsu480 lmao, Fack, Fack, Fack

[@pantheman2842]

@@ShockwaveITB Whitebeard would fight Kaido directly, I think.

[@beingofinconceivablehorror1854]

@@pantheman2842 I don't think old sick whiteboard could 1v1 Kaido. But a few years before he got sick he definitely would win that fight. Such an exciting battle to even fantasize about.

[@lightyearpig12]

Remember when Luffy was offered Foxy's entire crew as a reward for winning the Davy Back Fight? Imagine if he kept those crewmembers and we'd have to juggle 515 characters.

[@koro394]

that would be funny

[@michirusagiri3934]

Just think about the so much longer openings we would get like 18 minutes and 2 minutes show.😂

[@kauanjos3199]

515 backstory let's go

[@swagginandlaggin9804]

It was Nami who made the offer

[@Dumbsourplum]

they'd probably be thrown in the back

[@andrewbasil2214]

We're all better for not having such a large crew, I can only imagine how zombie tree's multi-chapter backstory would have broken us all even more than the death of the Mary

[@HighKingOfSkyrim37]

Knowing Oda he would have made us fall in love with him... and then stab us right in the heart.

[@tpsam]

Zombie tree and zombie unicorn Forever in our hearts

[@Soinetwa]

that would make his demise even more tragic rip zombie tree also that would give the big tree in WCI some additional backstory.. did u know those two were siblings?! crazy yeah one came to life becuase of shadow fruit other came to life becasue of soul fruit and both brothers died helping luffy :(

[@irontroll3320]

I can imagined this sad goodbye since Grand Line Review's first video about alternate SHP

[@MOTHblank]

​@@HighKingOfSkyrim37 that damn lumberjack T.T

[@catsorafgc]

“KAIDO! JOIN MY CREW” “...Sure”

[@carsonspinks1067]

And like that luffy solved the entire world conflict as everyone joined his crew and nobody ever fought ever again. Instead they would all good off on a much larger version of the Sunny

[@TheClickbaiterA]

@@carsonspinks1067 and they live happily ever after.

[@Dcent_K]

@@TheClickbaiterA The End.

[@mubarakugas6896]

@@carsonspinks1067 rock pirates fought

[@carsonspinks1067]

@bruh moment new earth model just dropped, "Ship Earth" flat earth's and ball earthers in shambles

[@beboboi]

“Our new mascot is a bush in a box so never fear” *Sad Karoo noises*

[@poopiediaperbaby7815]

Love that pfp my man

[@deathscythe4553]

So like a jack in a box?

[@brayden1682]

Yes ironically I am in a box

[@godusopp1126]

@@brayden1682 and my name is in fact jack.. holup

[@COOLERthenU]

Its ma bush in a box

[@chickennugget9254]

Zoro, Sanji and Jinbei? Pfft.. Luffy, Ace and Sabo? Don't be absurd Gaimon, Carue and Leopard Centaur are the new monster trio.

[@thijs4305]

Well quite literally as they’re all animals/non humab

[@skinnylegend2.040]

Karoo

[@smolgobbo3826]

Kin’emon’s legs tho

[@KachellZ]

@disabled account Gaimon is god, but human

[@M4XD4B0ZZ]

Love em

[@cumbrap]

I used to think Luffy had a good eye for talent but I'm starting to think he just gets really lucky with his picks.

[@thotobliterator1587]

Yo digby’s a One Piece fan? Eyyyyy!

[@papaofthejohns5882]

Hey now, his only bad pick was the bush chest guy! Crocus is a doctor, Iceberg is a shipwright and bureaucrat, Vivi is a negotiator and knowledgeable in the matters of kingdoms etc. Ace and Sabo don’t need explaining.

[@skrillex4u]

Also he could have died so many times but he is very lucky

[@blackflowers5996]

He just like to ask weird and funny characters to join his crew...

[@JACKBOOT12]

I mean the fact that he is even alive is pure luck the dude has lady luck in his pocket Kinda like Jack Sparrow in POTC

[@rjtarius]

if this really happened, ODA will surely makes us cry about the Zombie Tree & Unicorn backstory

[@johnivynnsantos9234]

Who knows they might still meet the owner of their shadows

[@tigerstark2198]

And then 60 chapters later we will find out that they are still alive somehow

[@anuraagsaxena7942]

@@tigerstark2198 which chapter?

[@coolguydude7252]

@@anuraagsaxena7942 🤦‍♀️it’s a joke

[@lucacz7259]

@@anuraagsaxena7942 wtf is wrong with you

[@jeebus.h]

Imagine Luffy asks the Yonko to join his crew and their only response is "Bet. Let's get this bread."

[@cristoda21yonko]

Jeebus H. Christopher 😂💯

[@Tenznimi]

Lmao imagine if that was his devil fruit: persuasion. "Join me, all 4 yonkos" "Aight" "Join me, all 7 warlords" "Aight" "Join me, all 3 admirals" "Hmm... aight" "Join me enel" "Aight" "Join me, grandpa" "Aight" "Join me, the elders" "Aight" "Join me, dad" "Aight" "Join me, celestial dragons" "Aight"

[@andriejeroi.delapena8462]

@@Tenznimi Everyone: So what we gonna do? Luffy: let's get the bread...... And the meat

[@ifeanyiogbennaya7773]

Lmfaooooo

[@underated8139]

@@Tenznimi Then who would he fight?

[@denilsonthomas]

Wait if Luffy had a Ace as a crew member throughout Sabaody, then Ace would’ve met Rayleigh and learned more about Roger through him.

[@ericmartinlillo4972]

He didn't like roger so most likely they don't talk to much

[@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr]

@@ericmartinlillo4972, Ace could have learned Haki from Rayleigh like how Luffy learned Haki from Rayleigh and how Sabo learned Haki from Dragon, so that way if stronger opponents that are stronger than Luffy and Ace they could have defeated them together with the Haki training they got from Rayleigh.

[@1DcoolJ]

@@ericmartinlillo4972 As a kid Ace asked every1 about Roger then attacked them for insulting him and later made a grudge against him but if Ace had the chance to talk to Rogers best friend he surely would have and it may have reduced his hate of Roger

[@regiman222]

@@1DcoolJ Plus in this timeline he doesn't have Whitebeard as a father figure, Roger is still the only dad he has so would probably like to hear about what he was like when he was alive (after all, unlike Usopp Ace's dad didn't abandon him, he died/was executed) and Rayleigh would probably be happy to.

[@shaunakkulkarni4679]

@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr did white beard not teach ace haki? I would have thought he did since he tried to fight logia users.

[@mrCetus]

Imagine Kuma sending 50 people to different island and we're watching all of the story that explains what happened them

[@janimayares8086]

Ace would be sent to Whitebeard.

[@rylinnmain]

I really can’t get over, tree and unicorn zombie’s deaths. Those were some hard times in One Piece history...

[@buciallstar]

especially after the 10 chapter backstory revealing the original bodies of unicorn and tree, since they were gol d Rogers horse and treehouse tree when roger was a child.

[@greyraiz1301]

@@buciallstar 🤣🤣🤣 you're a legend

[@101falcon]

@@buciallstar Then Oda would bring them back 100 chapters later to reveal a missing sibling/friend that also turns out to help the strawhats and tragically meets their end in the process just to hurt us more once we start recovering

[@luuser7765]

Seeing Crocus meeting Brook on his ship would be really interesting

[@434444334]

Holy shit yes that would be amazing

[@autinjones7194]

oh yeah! Damn! that would be both awkward and crazy!

[@Phyrrus]

And Crocus Meeting Rayleigh in Sabaody...since both were with Roger

[@luuser7765]

@@Phyrrus truuue

[@RustyNips]

If crocus going to join the crew I don't really see why laboon can't just swim and follow behind the seas don't really seem all that bad he would be fine then he will get to see brook then also so best ending And during the 2 year time skip laboon could hang around and help sanji wanted poster guy the Fishman from arlongs and Kuma defend the sunny then see all the other Wales when they go the the new world

[@Sanjidub]

If you made an excuse for Jimbei we can also make an excuse with Chopper. Let's say Crocus knows what bit Nami, however, he does not possess the antidote. Being as smart as he is (and after a few dramatic zooms) he suggests going to Drum Island, which is known for its experts in medicine ;)

[@acandela1294]

Not far fetched at all. Why would crocus bring along a random vaccine for an extinct disease. Makes sense that they still go to drum island and chopper gets asked

[@Kenny-o6i]

I agree, I think the official Strawhats are definitely tied together by fate.

[@gtdc4685]

There, Luffy asked Chopper to join as the emergency food

[@AnonymouseNeedsHelpjk]

ye kureha states she the only one who still has the anti bodie

[@kennethjones5992]

Chopper is left out, this is the darkest timeline.

[@alfonsopayan09]

Community? 😲🙏🏻

[@m.a.l.icious1369]

I hv a theory on that I posted in comments

[@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr]

Kenneth Jones, if Chopper wasn’t left out in the alternate timeline where if everybody Luffy asked to join his crew immediately joined Luffy then he’d stay on the ship with Shrubman until he only needed one rumble ball to have all his transformations unlocked, and then the doctor that was taking care of Laboon that joined Luffy’s crew would be the person that watches over Luffy’s ship with Shrubman whenever they land on a new island, and the other 13 crew members helps Luffy out in battle.

[@MK-ms4uz]

Yeah but Ace is alive

[@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr]

M K, you’re right that the alternate timeline that was made in this video Ace would be alive.

[@NorthernShinigami]

"...Only his legs. Luffy did not, I repeat, did not ask the rest of him." LMAO

[@n0wheregrrl]

That was the part where I completely lost it. 🤣

[@434444334]

Man those legs better have a killer backstory

[@koraboinaneelaveni7147]

Lmao 🤣🤣

[@gtdc4685]

Luffy just steals his legs and runs away 💀

[@SonnyBeedon]

this was funny but just quoting it in the comments for likes in just annoying i hate ppl who do this

[@Bobsyagod]

Why do I get the feeling Usopp would clue into Luffy's ability to just ask people to join and they magically agree? Any time they run into someone strong that scares him. Usopp would be like "Luffy, he should join the crew" Depending how fast he notices this, the crew gets big and strong pretty quick.. and probably also has some dinosaurs from Little Garden :P

[@xywen]

Now that could be Luffy's second devil fruit ability

[@berndpenguin3956]

why do i somehow instantly think of a Haruo Nijima -Style behavior when you talk about this? XDD Ps: Sauce of Nijima is Kenichi the Mightiest Disciple ^^

[@beyondkujo]

lol usopp is the reason the grand fleet exist

[@urtoryu_dy_althraidn]

Enel + Blueno would pretty much make them invincible with teleportation and near omniscience.

[@kdawgtb]

"Shanks, I feel guilty for making you lose your arm. Join my crew when I grow up and I'll make up for it" Repeat this for garp, any admirals, etc.

[@matthewpopow6647]

I'm just imaging Kuma running out of ideas on where to send the extra straw hats. Crocus just gets sent to Shaki's bar because he doesn't need a training trip.

[@komodochiya]

Where does gaimon go 💀

[@joelcoll4034]

@@komodochiya to the island they met him and he is unable to return to shabaody

[@milesfp2001]

@@komodochiya Gaimon's box gets sent. Kuma doesn't notice because Gaimon was by some shrubs. Gaimon now spends 2 years on the archipelago getting an extreme box upgrade from Raleigh.

[@DsgSleazy]

@@milesfp2001 lmaooo this is the best one

[@kantan66mv79]

They wouldn't have lost

[@droidflamingo5478]

If they all joined then robin and chopper would get to do even less stuff than they do now.

[@GrandLineReview]

Chopper especially according to this finding...

[@droidflamingo5478]

@@GrandLineReview oh god no he never joins! So wapol eats him.

[@GrandLineReview]

@@droidflamingo5478 T___T

[@retrogamermax8287]

Robin is important you know. Without her, they can't get to Laughtale as she is the only one that can read the Poneglyphs.

[@droidflamingo5478]

@@retrogamermax8287 oh i absolutely love robin I just wish she got to fight some more

[@Feeble_Weeble]

Now I'm imagining a story where everyone says no and Luffy has to grow super powerful and become the pirate king on his own

[@autinjones7194]

That sounds like a good idea!

[@ilyasbasuki3207]

I feel like Luffy would awaken his fruit faster and thus become even more powerful, but with no crew to help him he wouldn't come close to finding Laugh Tale. He'd probably end up roaming the seas like some overpowered boogeyman.

[@mateusisraelsilva5934]

Maybe he’d still get Robin, because she’s the one who asked Luffy, even though I doubt he’d be able to reach that point by himself. He would probably have stayed forever in East Blue sailing randomly as he doesn’t know how to navigate.

[@lightningjadejavier]

@@mateusisraelsilva5934 while yes Robin did ask him but since he has no crew he'd probably be the one to beat up every pirate hunters not zoro and instead of helping vivi since nami said to zoro to help vivi he'd probably just set sail to other islands meaning in the no universe vivi and Robin dies from croco

[@grokborketharek8165]

He'd have to learn how to navigate and cook or he'd instantly die lol

[@ravenfal1496]

It’s like Luffy has Geass but the only thing he ever commands is “join my crew.”

[@gingfreecss3808]

Lmao

[@urtoryu_dy_althraidn]

If Luffy did anything else with Geass the world would be ending right now, just imagine the chaos.

[@raftel7440]

Tree and unicorn need to join so the strawhats can be truly be yonko level crew.

[@pc_screen5478]

Well since the owners of the shadow faintly remember what their zombies were doing (like Lola calling Nami Namizo), I think they would have tried to join the crew anyways since Luffy's power is absolute

[@MemerGuy318]

You should call it geezer tree

[@WinZacianGraal]

Imagine the Thousand Sunny being much larger than it was originally. Pretty interesting.

[@neosildrake]

Moby Dick sized Sunny.

[@DarthDude380]

There is a major detail you are missing. Blackbeard's original plan was to chase down Luffy and capture him for the world government so he could become a Shichibukai. Ace just interrupted that and ended up fulfilling the same purpose so he never went after Luffy. I think a better situation would be to substitute Impel Down/Marineford for a situation where Luffy is captured and the rest of the crew attempts to free him. If they also failed to free him from Impel Down, potentially Crocus could gather up the Roger Pirate remnants to have their own war at Marineford for Luffy

[@blakejones9514]

Sheeeeeeeshhh

[@kushiro6302]

@The One Whitebeard thinks his crew as family. There's no way he's just gonna wage a war with the marines and sacrifice his family to save some stranger.

[@justkiddlemonzz5615]

Yeah I thought about this too.

[@justbny9278]

@@kushiro6302 while Ace could've asked WB, I think Black Beard would just not be concerned in this case and would go after WB's fruit in a later occasion after breaking out people from impel down using his warlord position to further his crew After that he could abuse the knowledge of WB's territory to go steal part of it and raise in power until he got into a better position to trigger WB's death

[@Diego-ck2pn]

@@kushiro6302 wheres he talk about whitebeard?

[@chrisderkonig1379]

Luffy meets Aokiji for the first time:" Wow you are a actual iceman???? Join my crew! " Aokiji:"Oh man here we go. Come on little man hop on my bicycle we have to get my penguin."

[@wail1063]

Imagine if Nico Robin saw him with the straw hats

[@dcarnegie1992]

I can picture this 😂

[@angelrose1714]

I can see that thats so fucking cute

[@aziatouchsilent8507]

**instantly quits being an admiral**

[@SKsuprakirby]

Aokiji: "AYO Garp, your grandson asked me to join the straw hats, so... aight imma head out"

[@greenfroppy212]

Could you imagine how much more OP Luffy's crew would be if this was real. But it makes me sad that Chopper won't be in the Straw Hats if this happened

[@jotarokujo8423]

He would be , im pretty sure

[@michirusagiri3934]

Also if we would had the Foxy's entire crew with 515 characters. 😂

[@inkchariot6147]

The Sunny would have to be twice as big to accommodate.

[@edwardmoreno6223]

​@@inkchariot6147+q

[@jmtz3149]

Most importantly this alternative universe would create the true monster trio Gaimon, Karoo, and Kinemons legs.

[@leonblum816]

You wildly underestimate Leopard Centaur, good sir...

[@MoonAlongMyHead]

I'd love to see them all go "docking" xD

[@Streek471]

Nakama Gaimon would make the journey to Laugh Tale too easy with his army of rare animals.

[@dguytheguy4653]

@@AxxLAfriku I'd be ashamed too from the look of your vids but at least you get pretty good views lol and that's the main goal

[@clintonemok2105]

@@AxxLAfriku do what you like to do

[@theboneman7493]

@@AxxLAfriku Yes. But to each and their own.

[@krlllx]

@@AxxLAfriku no they are amazing videos subbed

[@trustyrat8632]

AxxL tbh from the look of the thumbnails and titles I would be ashamed too but you do you

[@AdrianEN]

Imagine all the hilarious interactions we would get. Gaimon alone being in the crew opens up so many possibilities.

[@comicknightzero]

10:09 Lmao, could you imagine: *The crew finishes up their business in Wano* *Everyone makes their way back to ship* *Luffy stops Kinemon* Kinemon: Wait, I thought I was part of the crew? Luffy: Uh-uh, just the legs Kinemon: Just my legs? *Luffy nods* Kinemon: ..... Kinemon: k.

[@jacobharris5894]

Room! Sword slashing noise

[@GM.Nobody]

..

[@avykn]

....

[@gabeskai]

....!

[@qixe_6007]

....!~

[@peterlalah7277]

Chopper would still join. The crew would still have to pass through Drum and wait, for the log to set. Luffy would probably want to deal with wapol as he does in every other island, and with all the time he spends on the island he would definitely meet Chopper, and would immediately ask the talking reindeer/ raccoon to join the crew. And they would definitely meet cause Chopper came down to the town, plus was living in wapol's castle, luffy's new target. Even if they don't go to drum specifically for a doctor, Chopper would still join.

[@bloo6639]

Peter Lalah the disrespect to call chopper call him a raccoon

[@peterlalah7277]

@@bloo6639 😂 that's just how they see him at first. I would never disrespect Chopper

[@jrozlie2280]

They already have krokus as a doctor (but if Hes not able to Cure it they will still have to go there)

[@cuveedommartinic.balasta5032]

@@jrozlie2280 Luffy would still ask Chopper because in the canon universe Luffy didn't even know he was a doctor until he became an official member.

[@jrozlie2280]

@@cuveedommartinic.balasta5032 well at that rate Krokus mightve already taken the act

[@eenn78]

A thing I think you're missing is Dr. Kureha says that the poison Nami was effected by was very rare and she happens to keep the antidote just in case, so I think that they would still have to go to Drum island for help and then they would recruit Chopper and Kureha meaning there would be 3 doctors on the crew

[@tomdekler9280]

I think it's safe to assume that anyone from Roger's crew is a legend in their field. Crocus would need Kureha about as much as Sanji would need Wanze.

[@TheFreakEclipse]

This is the alternate timeline where Luffy maxed out his charisma

[@ForeverLeaf0]

lol XD

[@marcellofp7465]

Lmao

[@alitaher003]

Luffy’s Charisma is maxed out though.

[@TheFreakEclipse]

Yeah, you’d think, but then if that were true, this video would be canon.

[@VioletLunaVirgo]

@@TheFreakEclipse Nah, it's just the encounters he failed required an Intelligence check is all, he passed all the Charisma ones.

[@alphahunter4791]

Honestly, I think Luffy being the impulsive person he is might've just asked Frankie to join because no one fills the Robot/Cyborg role of the straw hats at that point

[@nousername191]

I agree. This is the man who took Chopper because, and I'm paraphrasing because I can't remember the exact quote, "Reindeer with 7 transformations. Cool".

[@SmokeyNalgaz]

@@nousername191 yeah exactly, i actually just rewatched that episode recently, luffy doesn't find out he's a doctor until he agrees and hes on the ship and theyre leaving, nami tells luffy that's why she thought he was inviting him.

[@napdragon94]

Chopper still joins because they'd need supplies to cure Nami from Kestia which is a rare disease eradicated over 100 years ago and she just happened to have the antidote (it's unlikely Crocus would it handy) so they would still go to Drum Island and Luffy would still ask Chopper to join because he's a "cool transforming reindeer"/emergency food supply!

[@gtdc4685]

Yay

[@OmnipotentSaiyan]

Luffy asked Ace to join his crew in Alabasta too. I just want Ace to have Mera Mera no mi.

[@rolando3734]

Yup and it would also still have a reason for marine ford to happen

[@SnowHertz]

@@rolando3734 Marineford happened when ace was in white beards crew, if he’s with Luffy, plot armor will always have him from being captured like that

[@rolando3734]

Trustin Duong idk I don’t think pre time skip luffy does to hot against Blackbeard but yea I guess your right at least he still has the Mera Mera no Mi

[@justsasha8110]

I have read the novel and when Ace left the island he ate the fruit in another one and got a kinda weak crew and not that loyal tbh

[@34Nor]

Could I have an F for the best crew mates ever, Zombie Tree and Zombie Unicorn. I pour one out for both of you.

[@kenflict9931]

F

[@neoteneX]

F

[@Kylekashi]

F

[@somedanieiguy1]

F

[@gtdc4685]

F

[@yaredkokeb5362]

Actually, the blood transfusion wouldn't even happen now that I think about it. because Ace has a blood type of S (O) which is the universal donor.

[@agnomaahh]

Blackbeard was originally hunting for Luffy tho when Ace rather took his place for the execution

[@san709]

true, good catch

[@edsoncharlotin8755]

it prob starts a whole diff arc, when ace still dies saving luffy ...

[@AriEru16394681315]

I do think shanks will not let luffy die especially he knows what blackbeard can do

[@enigmafiresup4658]

@@AriEru16394681315 If black beard succeed in his capture of Straw hat luffy it would be mean certain demise for Blackbeard. He would have to deal with Dragon, Shanks, and ace who would maybe bring a Whitebeard and a couple divison commanders, and of course the rest of the straw hat crew. Blackbeard would not survive, and if the world government decided to hold a public execution in Marineford then they no doubt lose since they are probably not strong to enough to fight Shanks and his entire crew with Dragon. Include Ace and whitebeard and it's a wrap.

[@ericmartinlillo4972]

@@enigmafiresup4658 not really, dragon couldn't care less about luffy they've meet 1 time and didn't even talk to each other, he is definitely not going, ace never meets whitebeard so there's no connection betwen them, only one i see going to save luffy is shanks

[@Zoapman]

It should have been like this: Crocus lacks the materials on curing Nami and thus they still head to Drum island.

[@mubarakugas6896]

Or: they need to charge the log pose at drum island thus they head there

[@elyisusking3603]

@@mubarakugas6896 nah, they got an Eternal Pose from Baroque Work straight to alabasta, however i do agree about the lack of medicine, after all, Nami got an extinct disease and i doubt Crocus would had a medicine for a disease which was never heard in many centuries

[@Superstar-sw5iy]

@@elyisusking3603 Im pretty sure luffy destroyed it but I could be wrong

[@elyisusking3603]

@@Superstar-sw5iy no, if you mean the Eternal pose Robin gave to Luffy, that was before Little Garden, The Eternal Pose to Alabasta was stolen from Mr. 3

[@okamisenpai6988]

crocus would have died on little garden he didn't even have the power to defeat mister 5 in the whale no way he would have survived mister 3 and all that shit. so chopper would have still become a crewmember anyway

[@kinuwa_k4791]

"I gained 9 more members" "but at what cost?" " i lost a racoo- I mean a deer"

[@generalyousif3640]

Imagine Crocus meeting Rayleigh in Sabaody that would be interesting

[@sabooo]

And brook meeting crocus... Interesting.

[@birdwithinternetconnection2624]

that profile picture is amazing

[@generalyousif3640]

@@birdwithinternetconnection2624 thx mate had it for years :)

[@jashn6506]

And ace meeting crocus and Rayleigh

[@unlucky-777]

Imagine Kuma sending 50 people to different island and we're watching all of the story that explains what happened them

[@434444334]

Ah yes the spin off manga

[@dcarnegie1992]

One Piece What If ..... ? Series

[@unlucky-777]

@@dcarnegie1992 That would be fire

[@tahjiboggs3387]

@Mr Popo oh yeah do you know how many more backstories there would have to be

[@neosildrake]

I would probably be forced to stop watching, because there's no way the whole series would be finished in my lifetime and I could not bear to die before the end. On the other hand, it would be a sure way to confirm life after death and/or ghosts, because I WILL RETURN TO WATCH THIS END ONE WAY OR ANOTHER!

[@sol15_]

I think Luffy would still pick up chopper, because correct me if I’m wrong but the log pose will still point to drum island, and the crew would still get caught up in that conflict while the logpose is finding the next island, so Luffy would still meet chopper and probably ask him to join the crew anyway because of his circumstances rather than for the need of a doctor

[@DavidbarZeus1]

No, Sanji stole an eternal log pose to Alabasta on Little Garden from one of the Baroque Works guys ... I THINK it was Mr. 5. Still, even then it's easy to write Chopper in as well by saying that Crocus doesn't know what actually ails Nami so they go to Drum to talk to their famous doctors.

[@purplefox532]

@@DavidbarZeus1 or he could know what ails her but doesn’t have the right ingredients so they go to the nearest island which includes chopper

[@MensoJero]

@@purplefox532 You're both right, they literally said it was some ancient disease that couldn't just be treated. The doctor would've realized this and suggested the island for either some herb or the medical expertise of the renown medical personnel who might be able to do something about Nami's illness.

[@acandela1294]

Dr korreha says it's a vaccine. And she implies most places don't have it but she decided to stash it away just in case.

[@Football_Head21]

I like how everyone just joined for no reason but a change of heart lol

[@BigCyan]

They all joined for a reason

[@darthzayexeet3653]

This AU in a nutshell: Luffy: “Do you want to j-“ Everyone: *“YES“*

[@evaa_ln3763]

Damn, I'll pay to read that au :")

[@darthzayexeet3653]

@@evaa_ln3763 Me too, this crew seems way more interesting somehow lol

[@jlassijlali290]

Yes i need freinds..... Flash in JL movie

[@evaa_ln3763]

@@darthzayexeet3653 fact

[@murnirasma4879]

@@evaa_ln3763 what is aw

[@chidoalex0742]

how did they escape smoker on alabasta if ace didnt have the mera fruit, thats the only reason they survived smoker

[@ghostlysniper]

True lol

[@Nsjisjbxibdbcjd]

Well, they have Crocus in this situation, and he could very easily take down Smoker.

[@christianmayonove6914]

Can you imagine Gaimon infiltrating Enies Lobby and fighting a CP9 member? Lmao

[@arandomguyontheinternet2308]

Problably spandam

[@phantom4461]

Gaimon gave lil buggy the work

[@SenpaiDaT]

You have Ace for that now

[@drivforc7867]

Didn't he also ask Smoker in alabasta and also said to someone (I don't remember who) that Law was from his crew? Also, only Kureiha had the pre-historic medicine and Chopper was asked to join because of his transformations, so that could be an excuse. This video is great! I was thinking one of those days about that and I'm glad someone did it. Imagine a OVA like that, would be a mess. Poor Bartolomeo, everyone joins but him.

[@keen9276]

The real monster trio: Buggy D. Clown, Go D. Usopp, and Gaimon D. Shrub

[@Lachgummei]

Gotta cut one, you clearly missed Con D. Oriano as most important member!

[@keen9276]

@CockStirredMartini yes

[@keen9276]

@Anonymous XDDDDD

[@clockoff94]

Con D Oriano is a true strawhat!

[@clockoff94]

@CockStirredMartini ??? You mean the monster trio? Everyone knows Go D. Ussop Sniper D. King Cond D. Oriano and Buggy D. Clown could stomp the whole verse tbh

[@animeomatic3987]

Imagine Oda gives us a back story for all the crew members that's another 2 years added to one piece end

[@cinalaophelie]

11:00 wait, if ace doesn't die and isn't in the newspaper, how would Sabo regain his memories?! How and where would they even meet since the Meru Meru no fruit wasn't ace's fruit? And would they even recognize each other? (Luffy was a bit clueless when he saw sabo so...)

[@depressedrocketsfan2880]

He was sent to investigate so he would see Luffy anyway

[@notxon300]

I think theres a couple other ways he could regain his memories throughout the timeskip and dressrosa. So we know Sabo would still be on dressrosa as he was sent there by dragon, meaning theres definitely some chance he'd come by ace and luffy, see their faces and regain his memories that way. This is an asspull but I think maybe one way or another, robin going to train with the revolutionary army, and being a straw hat will somehow make sabo regain his memories.

[@Rikoyasha15]

@@depressedrocketsfan2880 idk they may not even bump into eachother Sabo saw Luffy on the TV and made an effort to find him, Sabo may not recognize or recognize his memories especially with Luffy I n disguise

[@bibhaspantha1112]

I think we would still have chopper as doctor kureha said that the medicine for nami was rare and luckily kureha had the medicine... So yahhh, they would come to drum island from their ship doctor's request

[@igorporfiirio4915]

Maybe, but Crocus is an amazing doctor, so I wouldn't bet on that

[@bibhaspantha1112]

@@igorporfiirio4915 could work if Oda wants to add chopper in the story

[@kleptomania2631]

@@igorporfiirio4915 I mean majorly better than kureha? Probably not, so I don't see him coming up with an entirely new cure quickly, when kureha needed medicine. His skill also has nothing to do with him having the medicine and without it, he can't cure Nami. So I see it as unlikely for them to not search for it.

[@HighKingOfSkyrim37]

Well they have Crocus on the crew and that guy has been to the new world. He had seen the dangers of that place first hand and he would be the first in line to tell everyone, being the crews doctor after all, that they are NOT ready for the new world. Also they could have a nice reunion scene with Crocus and Rayleigh.

[@jo2399]

They might have also needed to stop at Drum Island to get the antidote, which I doubt Crocus would have on hand

[@HelixMaster12]

My favorite part is when Gaimon went into his monster form to beat Kumadori.

[@jmch187]

This became hilarious once he stated everyone who would be there at Innie's Lobby to save Robin😂😂😂

[@MaggotKing556]

Ennies Lobby*

[@jmch187]

@@MaggotKing556 thanks

[@usopphammergataling3910]

Robin be like: *I* *WANT* *TO* *LIVE*

[@andriejeroi.delapena8462]

@@usopphammergataling3910 then everyone decimates ennies lobby to dust

[@attackcrash0787]

@@MaggotKing556 *Enies Lobby.

[@silvers6793]

I think they'd still need to head up drum island, because before the events of this they'd have no supplies for medicine or have visited any island with any Seeing as how whiskey peak was a struggling bounty hunters den with dwindling supplies And theyd still come across Wapol on the sea and inevitably need to find an island with supplies thus adding Kureha and Chopper to this list

[@caturviriyananda9586]

agreed

[@SailentZen]

*I also doubt that they’ll have the medicine for the mite that died out 100 years ago or something so y E*

[@marsupialmaniac8083]

I feel Apis could’ve actually been a pretty useful member, being able to talk to animals could be very useful, she’d basically be the crew’s scout.

[@luckyy_198]

Chopper can do that already

[@primordiatree1014]

@@luckyy_198 well chopper isn't recruited in that timeline

[@Khe0ps7]

This clearly prove that Chopper is indead the most important crew member without him no Drum island arc, Wapol isn't defeated, no discovery of the wapo metal, the marine and vegapunk probably won't achieve the same level of power during the paramount war maybe no human weapon. Franky wouldn't create something as great as the general franky. But the same could be said with Crocus if he joined the crew the change in the story could have been insanely huge, in saboady he will meet with his former vice captain and with this fact we may learn sooner that Ace is Roger's son, seeing a former crewmate being a pirate again with one highly value by shanks and the son of his friend, Rayleigh joining the crew isn't an impossibility. Concerning the paramount i still think it would happend either way teach is still chasing Luffy to become a warlord. I can see a version where either Ace or luffy is captured (trying to save luffy and we learn about Ace's father) and the rest unfold almost in the same way but instead we may have Shanks coming with the revolutionary army this time and the help of whitebeard (because Teach still kill his son). By the way i don't think Ace would have wait 2 more year for luffy to be a pirate, i think he would have began his journey the same way, eating the mera mera no mi, being part of whitebeard crew until the first bounty of Luffy. At this point he would join his first captain around Alasbata but before blackbeard kill Satch so that the event in Jaya doesn't feel too weird... But notheless those 3 a probably the one with the bigger impact if they joined or not the crew

[@bsm1214]

I feel the same way, rayleigh would join them after some talk/see crocus. War would happen and I think that with all the crew members (+rayleigh) would be able to take back ace and win, there would be a funny scene where luffy asks whitebeard to join his crew and he must say yes so welcome first yonko xD. During the timeskip whitebeard + rayleigh would train whole crew so they will be very strong in the new world and maybe team of luffy, nami, brook, crocus, rayleigh, whitebeard, sanji and ace would take down big mom (something like oars fight from thriller bark), luffy vs katakuri would still happen but they will have much easier escape. But going back to enies lobby, kumadori vs crocus would be funny to watch, maybe this time we would have ace vs kaku? or maybe ace would take down buster call while luffy and lucci are fighting. Would crocus + ace + zoro be able to take down kuma in thriller bark ? I think yes. There is so much questions about this whole idea, would shanks join the crew after wano when luffy will see him xD?

[@jacobharris5894]

Bsm12 They should make an ova with this premise. It would be hilarious to see ridiculously powerful people, like Yonko and Roger’s former crew members joining Luffy’s crew. Also I think Robin is the most important because they literally can’t find Raftel without her. Any pirate crew that makes it there will inevitably have Robin with them to read the road poneglyphs, unless they can get it out of one of the Roger pirates somehow. Come to think of it does Buggy know where Raftel is because he isn’t particularly strong and would probably spill the beans pretty easily to save his life.

[@wearethelegion5817]

​@@jacobharris5894 She isn't that important if luffy has crocus and rayleigh, they probably know where laugh tale is so they don't need to read road poneglyphs, but she can still be useful because of ancient weapons. buggy probably know where laugh tale is but he had to stay on lodestar because of "I can't go on that island" disease with shanks (oden flashbacks). But i agree with Bsm12 with that whitebeard stuff, luffy would ask him to join the crew (even as a joke) after winning war so we would have 1v1 kaido vs whitebeard in wano or sanji rescue team (nami, crocus, rayleigh, whitebeard and luffy) vs big mom, that would be hilarious and amaaaazing fight. I would like to see luffy asking Buggy D. clown to join his crew tho, even if he is weak i still like him and seeing his improvement from weak buggy to pirate king crewmate level would be awesome, imagine his bara bara no mi after training! whole shanks arc would be funnier but i think buggy would forgive shanks all that bara bara no mi stuff.

[@jacobharris5894]

We Are The Legion Ah that’s true in this scenario. But if you just talking about the actual make up of the crew then Robin is probably the most important. Other pirate crews could possibly get information on the location of Raftel or the red ponygliphs from the former members of Roger’s crew but that is probably harder than kidnapping Robin. Most of the crew members are probably either so strong that most One Piece characters could not defeat them or willing to die without disclosing information, if not both. Most of them are probably hidden also and no one knows their whereabouts except a select few. The weakest known link I would say is definitely Buggy but like you said there is probably some reason he can’t say where it is. It would be too easy otherwise. The only people that they are willing to help find Raftel are probably Luffy’s crew or other benevolent crews like his.

[@wearethelegion5817]

@@jacobharris5894 yes, in current scenario robin is the most important but as I said, when former roger crew (which saw laugh tale) is there they can go there without robin. in manga buggy was too scared to go to the laugh tale so he stayed with shanks and both of them don't know where the laugh tale is.

[@pewperclipped3709]

Dude..... just hearing the statement “ace, luffy, and zoro joining together” THAT early in the show throws my head into places I never thought it would go lol.

[@edsoncharlotin8755]

theyd be winning every fight so easy , ace had got haki super early on in life by this time too. idk how they would put that in the story and w ace scout background hed prob go places and find a DF, when they went to rescue nami. i could see ace going ahead getting stranded some random place and popping up to fight w a new DF

[@gren7074]

@@edsoncharlotin8755 maybe even mihawk fight would go dif if ace didnt let zoro do it by himslef accept ace is prob weaker cus he never joined wb

[@armormartin4267]

I’m an apis fan. Tbh Warship Island arc is actually one of my favorite arcs. 3rd to be exact. 2nd is skypeia, and 1st will always be Alabasta

[@eyuin5716]

I can’t believe you neglected to mention the great Con D. Oriano

[@erezsolomon3838]

Con d. Riano*

[@milesfp2001]

Con D. Riano's power spans across all time and timelines. He is always there helping the Straw Hats. He repaired the Merry on Skypiea. He tickles people's noses when someone in the world is talking about them. He was Joy Boy and he waits on Laugh Tale to reveal all that he as done, as he did to the Roger Pirates.

[@sherwinpalero7404]

Hahahahahaa

[@creeper-p8m]

@@erezsolomon3838 no it’s Con D. Oriano

[@verzeihturncoat27]

Kinimon: "I am leaving!" *stays* … damn legs won´t move

[@ASIRA89]

Wait.. I want to know what happened to Apis. She seemed like a rather important character with the potential to hear the voice of dragons.

[@FantasmaNaranja]

genuinely haven't laughed this much in a while Thank you GrandLineReview.

[@GrandLineReview]

:D

[@Neronova888]

So mihawk saying that luffy has the ability to make allies wherever he goes is a literal power, impressive.

[@a.z.t7345]

What if Luffy actually had 10 nakama join his crew before entering the Grand Line like he intended? Do Johnny & Yosaku get recruited? Does Luffy meet Bartolomeo sooner? Think it'd make a good vid

[@irontroll3320]

I was planning to make a drawing of everyone Luffy have asked to join his crew but haven't do it yet. And then, this video comes up. I guess it's a sign

[@Eldaviidd.06]

Have you drawn it

[@Victoria_Viray]

Dang it!!! Even in an alternate universe Straw hat crew Bon Chan still didn't make it? *sad Okama noises. ಥ⌣ಥ

[@kradehteno8233]

At least he wouldn't be stuck on Impel Down. With this strong crew he wouldn't need to cover their retreat in Alabastra.

[@mahboi8149]

@@kradehteno8233 Better late than never, Mr. 2 wasn't captured there. There's a short story on the manga covers that will tell you what happened. Search for Miss Goldenweek's "Operation: Meet Baroque Works"

[@LuffyxNamiisathing]

Mr. 2 is still alive

[@TheSteve5154]

About not picking up chopper and the old lady doctor, I don’t know how to spell her name, but they would most likely still join the crew. The disease Nami caught has been extinct for over a hundred years. Crocus most likely wouldn’t know how to treat it due to not being that old, therefore they would have to seek out someone who was that old, and boom. Now the straw hats have 3 doctors.

[@TheVoiceOfAllThings]

You completely forgot how Luffy told Law he was joining his crew in Dressrosa!

[@CurrentSoulKing]

I guess Kinemom no longer has legs now :(

[@ZaKRo-bx7lp]

He attaches himself to Kaido and becomes a Yonko

[@nousername191]

The rest of the body can accompany him, but the legs are the crew member.

[@marcellofp7465]

Imagine if that two zombies in Thriller Bark became a main character and were in the battle against Kaido

[@Carnage0583]

If everyone he invited joined his crew then he probably have zombie crew since he invited almost every zombies he met in thriller bark

[@giornogiovanna3274]

But everyone would eventually die after that night

[@434444334]

@@giornogiovanna3274 big ass tragedy

[@pc_screen5478]

Jinbe did have a connection with Luffy: Arlong. When he first met Luffy in Impel Down Jinbe knew he had already defeated Arlong. He also apologized to Nami for letting him roam her island. So assuming he is in FI post timeskip he'd still approach the SH to apologize, at which point they would have joined forces to defeat Hody. No way Luffy wouldn't ask him

[@Aufeii]

Hody wouldn't have been an issue though since he was able to take control only because jimbei wasn't there to stop him. Since jimbei wouldn't have had to let go of his warlord title if the paramount war didn't happen he could still protect Fishman island

[@lewisaino]

Mostly Ace

[@jovinprime]

8:00 the reason this video was made

[@yogameing9547]

Actually in nami's village lufy asked doctor of that village to join the crew

[@jwallE93]

Then Ace would still be alive :,)

[@chibum12]

Yup

[@crazycat4929]

Yeah! He had a massive hole right through him :(

[@llaero306]

He wouldn't fight at marinford since Luffy asked him to join his crew at alabasta

[@roanjadedelacruz6488]

Then he will be sent by kuma to the island where he finds the mera mera fruit

[@candyboi6440]

:) :)

[@ifcyanwasgrey]

6:20 I don't know about you but that's Icepops

[@flawless__aj]

Imagine if Luffy, Ace, and Sabo really formed a pirate crew together

[@ozairahmed1352]

Not gonna lie they'd probably be wiped out by the world government for getting too dangerous lol

[@klaythompson7509]

@@ozairahmed1352 facts😂

[@katastrofygames]

Every island they go to in adventures would run out of food immediately.

[@somedanieiguy1]

@@ozairahmed1352 just those 3 alone could probably take down alot of people. Maybe a navy admiral? The biggest worry is the navigator and the cook

[@supremedreams2]

if all of the guys luffy asked to join the crew actually joined, the straw hat crew would be able to reach the subscribe button for regular one piece straight into your youtube feed

[@patcheskipp]

I think after iceberg they'd be at 10 crewates which I think would stop him from asking other people to join the team. Brook might get invited just so they can have a musician.

[@rjrafol275]

Nami's disease is rare. Crocus is a retired ship doctor, He probably doesn't have the medicine for Nami's disease because of it's rarity. So the trip to Drum island should still happen.

[@revolvingworld2676]

If it did they'd probably have 3 doctors. All they'd need is Trafalgar Law and that would make the Strawhats officially the best medics in the world.

[@merenba1700]

Chopper should be in the crew. If I am correct, luffy didn't invite him to be a doctor. He invited him because he liked him so much he called Chopper his friend. So basically, they have two doctors now

[@rchaelk2319]

Would actually be very helpful with such a large crew tho.

[@alyssasmith2838]

In a scene from the anime, Luffy was surprised Chopper was a doctor at all and claimed Chopper was initially requested due to being a "7 Point transforming reindeer"

[@felixgarcia9650]

The point is that there's no need to stop in drum island bc crocus can heal nami

[@saltnotfunny8621]

@@felixgarcia9650 the virus Nami got is a very ancient desease, Nami just got lucky that Doctorine had some just in case. there would be no way that Crocus can heal Nami

[@darktempest]

2:27 that pic looking mad sus

[@myco_psycho1998]

The crew really missed out on that one old man stuck in a treasure chest

[@434444334]

His arc has him realize how powerful he can be and takes out a random member of the enemy XD

[@punkrider8758]

Respect for acknowledging that Merry was the first Crewmember to die

[@fullmetal3539]

5:06 personally I don’t think they would’ve not stopped at drum island as the ailment nami picked up was old and from little garden they would’ve needed kurehas expertise as for all I can tell she’s the only one who known about the disease

[@timpark02]

I think the Paramount War still would've happened. Blackbeard's original target was Luffy, and had he captured him, a similar situation would've occurred, just with Luffy being the one set for execution. The secret revealed at the execution would be him being Dragon's son, and the Emperor that showed up would be Shanks instead of Whitebeard. Dragon would've broken into Impel down to get Ivankov to join the war as well, and have shown up at the end where Shanks originally does. Same lines from Dragon, with him debating whether we should go see the now passed out from trauma Luffy. Sabo would also regain his memories at Marineford. If they were fighting Shanks, I doubt Mihawk would've participated in the war either, so he would also be booted from the title of Warlord. If Ace was already a part of the crew, I feel for "fate" related reasons, when Kuma separates them, he would've sent Ace to the island with the Flame Flame Fruit, and he would've trained it over the timeskip, which is coincidentally the same amount of time he has it for before his original death. Also Chopper would've still been recruited, they had to stop at Drum Island anyway, to follow the Log pose.

[@-hello6177]

Good job Tim, you're the only person to create a good way for the story to follow the same beats despite the completely different players

[@ezzyshian]

The whole drum island could also ties with how Nami's sickness is an ancient one and Crocus just didn't know what sickness or he lacked materials to make the medicine so they go to drum island. The rest is cool though.

[@berlin6752]

Sabo wouldn't lose his memory tho

[@lukeyyyyyy]

agreed but the crew had an eternal pose for alabasta from whiskey peak.

[@BigCyan]

@@berlin6752 also ace and sabo are not part of straw hats ace is a whitebeard pirate and sabo is a revolutionary.

[@KhangNguyen-pl8fo]

What if Shank actually let Lufy join him when Luffy first asked him?

[@Bleederbaby]

That would've been crazy

[@Glitch-lk6sh]

Imagine if he said to garp

[@kimom5727]

If nami told the strawhats about arlong that mean they would skip usopp and sanji!! Also luffy asked Zeff first instead of Sanji so if Zeff says yes, luffy would most likely ignore Sanji

[@st_king_jay]

*Luffy would take back the offer when he comes to know that Crocus knows about ONE PIECE. Nami becomes sick. So, Chopper Joins!*

[@joelcoll4034]

No, whats the problem with crocus knowing that as long as he doesn't tell luffy?

[@Junior915YT]

@@joelcoll4034 it still ruins is adventure

[@user-we2dm8xc9m]

If gaimon did join the crew then buggy would be dead due to him being stranded on the island gaimon was on and getting help from gaimon to rebuild his raft and find his body parts So if gaimon did leave then buggy would most likely die on that island or atleast be stranded

[@Coelohihi]

Buggy D. Clown (AKA the real king of the pirates) wouldn't die from being stranded on an island smh did you even read/watch one piece?

[@projectgarchomp2380]

@Eduardo de Borba Osti Well, when he was Mini-Buggy; he was nearly eaten by a large bird; only having survive due to the fact he was spat out since he tasted terrible to him...

[@ham1847]

@@projectgarchomp2380 you FOOL mini buggy is 10x STRONGER than NORMAL (ew) BUGGY!

[@feroniks366]

@@ham1847 I’m sorry to correct u but infinity multiplied by 10 is still infinity

[@13vatra]

Buggy would be dead? Best timeline ever!

[@adric2459]

luffy to god: hey you! join my crew!

[@OfficialHexcraft]

Completely lost it with giggles when he got to Kinemon's legs.

[@Abhisbj]

Would they need a time skip? Since Crocus was already on board, he can tell Luffy about Haki early on, to help him train, if not train him personally ( as we don't really know if Crocus can use haki).

[@caturviriyananda9586]

yes, especially on alabasta where they need to face logia sand.

[@generalyousif3640]

Ik this is late But Oda actually confirmed himself that Crocus has both observations and armament Haki

[@TheUnknownWarrior]

@@caturviriyananda9586 haki wasn't needed tho thery just used water

[@dqlHuiShi]

@@TheUnknownWarrior with haki you don't have to hassle until u realized his weakness, just pinch with haki n win

[@hearo2761]

while crocus would probably be able to cure nami don't forget that the disease is supposed to be extinct thus crocus would not be able to get the medicine needed to treat her so they would still end up at drum island and recruiting both chopper and kureha

[@gib5685]

OOO WAIT THO. I THOUGHT OF SOMETHING. Originally, Blackbeard was going to Water 7 to hunt Luffy when he ran into Ace instead. So if Luffy got captured instead, the war could’ve still happened. But it’s complicated. Granted, Ace was in a 1v1 vs Blackbeard and this would be Strawhat Pirates vs. Blackbeard Pirates (at Water 7). I definitely think Blackbeard has much less of a chance of winning here. But if the Strawhats did lose, there may be some fatalities and I wouldn’t put it passed Blackbeard to capture everyone in the crew who had a bounty above 100 mil (Luffy, Zoro, and Ace (probably)) So the war would set up 3 executions and they’re the 3 strongest members in the crew. The remaining Strawhats would have a hard time even getting to Marineford, but let’s say they make it somehow. They help out a little bit, but I think the majority of saving comes from outside the crew. You know Shanks would show up and there’s a good chance Dragon would too (based on how Ivankov talked about him during the war. When he was under the impression that Ace was also Dragon’s son, Ivankov says something along the lines of “why would the Navy start something with both Whitebeard and Dragon?”) That would be an opportunity for Sabo to get his memories back when he finds out that both Luffy and Ace are set to be executed. Overall I have no idea who would win this war. Whitebeard was a beast at Marineford but the fact remains that he wasn’t even close to being in his prime. It’s not completely unreasonable to assume that Dragon is Yonko level, so having both Shanks and Dragon on the Strawhat side would definitely stand a chance against the marines. It’s also not unreasonable to assume that Shanks has allies in the New World similar to how Whitebeard did. After writing it out, I feel like the Strawhats would have the same, if not an even better chance at success than Whitebeard. I’d be super interested to see how this version of the arc would turn out :)

[@gib5685]

I just realized that I completely forgot that Crocus would be a part of the crew. That’s a factor for sure lol

[@coderhea]

How’d he meet white beard when he’s on luffy’s crew??

[@joeass2399]

I think that blackbeard would've never met luffy though cuz they would just take ice berg, get the news, buy a new ship, do enies lobby and dip. No franky shit or anything.

[@BigCyan]

@@joeass2399 also ace wouldnt of been with them he is still a whitebeard pirate he just went to hunt down blackbeard.

[@kenzo5096]

Why do they need to execute zoro ? Even luffy is useless , they will just send them to impel down and hop bye