What If Metal Sonic Turned Good? (Part 1)

Following his defeat on Little Planet, Dr Eggman abandons his greatest creation. What changes will this stir in the robot, and can it lead him down a path to redemption? Find out now!
Support me on Patreon: / pickleddill
Follow me on Twitter: / pickleddill128
Join the Discord: / discord
#sonic #sonicthehedgehog #sonicfrontiers #sonicsuperstars #knuckles #tails #amy #shadow #sega #segagenesis #fanfiction #whatif

[@Mariocat99]

Interesting enough, it would be cool development. To be half-hero and half-villain. If Metal had some good in him. He'd be an anti-villain at best

[@comicfan1324]

I’m really enjoying this series so far. I too have made a couple what if episodes exploring Metal’s potential for good, so I’m glad to see I’m not alone in that thought process

[@PickledDillPodcast]

Thanks, I’ve started watching your content and I’m really enjoying it too :)

[@flashbeat9521]

​@PickledDillPodcast i agree I think metal sonic becoming his own person and not a copy of sonic is something truly unique

[@ominouspigeonmaster1571]

I wasn't expecting much I will be honest, but this is much better than I anticipated. Metal Sonic is definitely one of those characters where true change and growth comes slowly. So far no ones broken character to speedun his development, and that to me is the mark of good writing. Using Mecha Sonic in the narrative was a clever way of planting small seeds of doubt into Metal.

[@user-cf7gt1ne8k]

It was eggman fault he closed the door before metal got him😂

[@takeruneverborn4740]

Metal Betrayed by his creator and replaced by a "Superior" Model aids his former Adversary and Organic Counterpart Sonic realizing what he has done wonder what path he should walk?

[@Kamenriderbuild964]

so this is just the sonic version of what if Cell from DBZ turned good

[@Garrulous64]

Fun idea so far! Excited to see where this goes!

[@theblacklorax]

Thumbnail already looks fire, its to see how this unfolds

[@kirklinguinihoodinithecubo8525]

Metal Sonic is my favorite character, and hearing a lengthy concept of if he became good makes me smile

[@Sonicmid]

Yo a sonic what if? Definitely want to see more of this

[@Normandy1998]

As the guy who done the gameplay for this video, will promise I'll get better, meanwhile enjoy the great story and laugh at my skills

[@theblacklorax]

LMAO, my boi did fall off in chemical plant twice

[@Normandy1998]

@@theblacklorax yeh was very rusty, at least we can laugh at my bad skills

[@YeomasBros.2008]

Did you know that if you press jump twice you can drop dash?

[@inkchariot6147]

I've never seen anyone suck this bad at anything since game journalists.

[@YeomasBros.2008]

@@inkchariot6147well if you wanted to know why game journalists claim sonic was never good now you know why

[@TerraEmperor1]

Metal is such a complex character in the Sonic universe. Can't wait to see your take on it more

[@Gunsandrosy]

Can't wait for more! As a writer for hobby Ive learned so many new words and descriptors just from tuning in. I appreciate you soo much, dude!

[@jacobfrye3614]

I think at this point if Metal Sonic stays as an Eggman sidekick he'll be wasted potential. They should build on his motivation to become more than just 'metal sonic' from sonic heroes

[@PickledDillPodcast]

Hopefully this story will scratch that itch for you

[@finnfogdall4576]

I remember when there was a good metal sonic named shard from the archie comics

[@AverageEnemy]

Same, sad he died tho😢

[@MrMartellSincere]

I love seeing what if stories of metal Sonic

[@matthewsimmons9277]

Wonder how metal will react to mecha Sonic’s ability to turn super?

[@MrwhatifWatcher-mc7hh]

Imagine metal Sonic found the Master Emerald and by wishing to become real Metal Sonic get an organic body by the power of the master emerald

[@jackattacktron1000]

Thank you so much for making this. Metal Sonic is also one of my favorite characters in the series and I genuinely want to see him redeem himself for the better in the official canon.

[@godzillamcentertainmentVCU]

This is too good.

[@luigifaniac1312]

Ok as a Metal Sonic fan myself I do find intrigue with this idea for a what if. But the timeline here makes no sense, like the whole bit with amy and the bit with Tails feels more like it should happen after Sonic 3 & Knuckles. Because the timeframe of events in S2 and S3&K wouldn't work to have this happen in where you put it. As I'm sure Amy and Tails aren't aware of each other until after the main 4 classic games. Also because of how S2 goes Tails would be way too busy fighting Robotnik with Sonic, and one other key detail, S3&K happens immediately after S2's ending.

[@houjuunue7053]

Waiting with baited breath.

[@TriggerStudios]

Algorithm Fuel 🎉

[@builderbenny]

shard in a nutshell:

[@ToonyTails]

Is this like some continuation that the Sega Scourge did like 5 years ago?

[@user-js6cy2cx3q]

❤❤

[@EvaDemopoulos-jt4nu]

Metal sonic would finally be put to rest

[@burpyiscool16]

Imagine a sonic game were it’s focused on metal sonic and we see what happens and we are not counting sonic 4 episode 2

[@TheStoryBuster]

An amazing story

[@attackonyugioh92]

an amazing comment

[@TheStoryBuster]

@@attackonyugioh92 an amazing response

[@coolfungamerz6447]

​@@TheStoryBusteran amazing @

[@inkmanstudios4798]

So now that your doing sonic what ifs What others do you have in mind for the future and would you be open during given ideas for some new what if videos?

[@PickledDillPodcast]

Yeah if I like the ideas I’ll do them since this one was suggested to me in my discord. In terms of Sonic ideas I have all the ones that were also in the poll plus some loose ideas regarding stuff like the werehog and caliburn

[@takeruneverborn4740]

@@PickledDillPodcast Yeah i wonder about the Storybook Series what the next adventures would be,Also what would happen if Sonic kept Access to the Werehog transformation heck Sonic has so many things from spin off and side games that could work in whatifs my favorite if Emerl and Gemerl co existed

[@malldavid16601]

Sonic ova movie:

[@miaflorsol3232]

I like the video

[@Normandy1998]

Algorithm ⛽⛽⛽⛽⛽

[@masonmayo7592]

:)❤

[@darealblazegamer2416]

What if Piccolo stayed evil part 2!!!!!!!!!!

[@PickledDillPodcast]

Best way to get more of that series is to share it with your friends since I use views to gauge interest and whether I should continue a story

[@miaflorsol3232]

Hi

[@LORD_PINKY_DINKS]

the gameplay hurts to look at

[@coolgamersonicyes7196]

Classic sonic doesn't speak 💀

[@LiMe251]

Doesn't he talk if you stand still for too long.

[@InterminableFan996]

Shhh the havent played sonic cd yet