What If: Total Drama All Stars Had The Orignal Cast?

[@needlebfdia]

it would have been good, though replace sierra with gwen and it would work

[@swampfire_edits8976]

Agree

[@HunterBATLightning]

This should have been the cast plus Gwen maybe Dakota and justin or Leshawna?

[@Hotdogenthusiast]

Gwen and Leshawna since they’re the missing members of the original final 5 plus it would fix the gender imbalance while also having more Original cast characters since it would make more sense having them be considered all stars

[@EliyusCarter]

I think Justin should be replaced with Noah and Gwen +Leshawna are a must

[@saltendo2177]

8 gen 1, 8 gen 2, even if this is only 10 of the contestants' second season, it's better than what we got.

[@TheAlphaXXO]

Nice vid m8

[@ShinyHunter69-s8g]

Good vid but only issue is Scott doesn’t really have a reason to hate on Duncan

[@bananabreadman]

I’m basing it more on Courtney hating Duncan, so Scott hates him by proxy

[@Princesse5667]

This is a very cool video !

[@mxpickle-b4r]

Dang, Heather being 2nd boot is CRAZY!

[@bananabreadman]

It hurt sending her so soon

[@BlueTotalDrama]

Nice vid!

[@lis.t.ekx2x]

WAAYYYY better than the accual season

[@IMakes-Edits]

Actually The cast didnt have mike or Cameron planned according to a old trailer Also noah and leshawna had promos for all stars

[@bananabreadman]

The trailer does include Cameron twice, and Mike once (as Vito). Also this isn’t based on the trailer, it’s based off the leaked cast list

[@superraul6449]

I personally should have to wait until PI was finished to do All Stars Afterwards

[@TMSandTDfan]

My version as 7 girls, 9 boys

[@Tytrovert]

What’s the cast

[@TMSandTDfan]

There’s also 7 Gen 2 and 9 Gen 1 Honourable Mentions: Courtney, DJ, Sam and Beth Gen 2 Mike Zoey (early boot) Jo Scott Brick And because of popularity Dawn Anne Maria Gen 1 Alejandro Heather Gwen Owen LeShawna Harold Lindsay And for popularity purposes Cody Tyler I know people like Dawn or Tyler aren’t All Star worry but still

[@Tytrovert]

@@TMSandTDfan no Duncan for an all star season is insane

[@TMSandTDfan]

I don’t like Duncan, so I’m not putting him in

[@Tommedian]

I would probably just ditch heroes vs villains all together

[@TigreeXD]

What happened to Justin- Wasn't he on the promotial ads for All Stars?

[@J-G9991]

He was, so was Leshawna, Cody and some others. But there's conflicting information, as the staff has talked a bit about early versions of All Stars, and they just seemed to talk about how some characters were replaced. My theory is that some of those characters in the promos were cut off *very* early on.

[@JothamMcintosh]

I like this video

[@Jediah-s6p]

Bruh where are leshawna Harold Noah and Justin they were in the og all stars cast

[@bananabreadman]

While they appeared in the first teaser trailer as possible options (Along with Bridgette, Tyler, Zeke), we never actually got a cast list including them. They were likely considered, but we never found a leak with them written.

[@Jediah-s6p]

@@bananabreadman alright

[@waffle_enjoyer_]

Wasn’t leshawna supposed to be in here too?

[@Jediah-s6p]

And Harold Noah and Justin

[@reaper897]

Put gwen back and add leshawna and a perfect cast

[@Princesse5667]

This sounds fake are you sure it’s not a rumor ?

[@bananabreadman]

Check the total drama all stars wiki, it was apart the original all stars leak

[@Princesse5667]

@@bananabreadman sorry I doubted you just crazy to believe Gwen wasn’t in it given how popular she was

[@bananabreadman]

Np, i didn’t believe at first either due to the uneven amount of guys and gals

[@picklecauli]

9 boys vs 7 girls and you first 2 booted are Lindsay & Heather, sorry but this worst than the original already Edit after I saw the whole video: I like that Lightning gets far, he's one of my favorites, the finale between Jo & Courtney is interesting, I like that Zoey and Mike don't get far together, and that you eliminated Zoey in the pre-merge, BUT my biggest issue is with Lindsay & Heather being the first 2 boots, also you could replace Cameron or Owen with Leshawna to be 8v8, I don't like the idea of 9 boys vs 7 girls and the first 3 elimination you booted girls

[@Daansstuff-alt]

Well this isn’t a my way this is a what if. This is based off of logical strategy.

[@ajb5119]

I am so glad Anne Maria did not make it into the All Stars cast.

[@riccardogiosi8500]

nice idea, terrible execution, especially the elimination order

[@bananabreadman]

If you don’t mind me asking, why do you hate the elimination order. Is it because characters you like were eliminated early, or because the reasons for why people were eliminated don’t make sense to you

[@riccardogiosi8500]

​@@bananabreadmansome Minor nuisances involve too many gen2 and too many males in the merge + Heather'selimination feel Like a random excuse to get rid of her, in Canon she was shown to have the votes over Jo and Alejandro, + Courtney and Duncan are Absolutely gunning for each other. Also the final 5 being all Villains is questionable as well... Jo is just too Op in this universe, especially considering this should be a What if, while it definitely feels Like a My way

[@bananabreadman]

To be fair about that merge point, it’s not like I planned the elimination order, it just happened to work out like that. Heather was not in a great position in episode two. She had no ally’s on the villains team in canon, the only reason she survived that episode was due to Lightning screwing up so bad and Jo gunning for his elimination. The only reason she had the votes against Jo was due to the fact she choked in what should’ve been an easy win and because she accidentally shot Scott with the leechball canon. And the only reason she had votes against Alejandro is that everybody, but Scott, had a reason to hate him equally or more than Heather. Courtney and Duncan gunning for each other felt like a natural choice after world tour with Courtney gunning for Gwen. And Courtney finally getting one over Duncan feels like the natural way to end the love triangle. I felt like I kept Jo pretty in line with canon. She’s beaten Sasquatchanakwa on screen, beaten Lightning in a race, and while she’s not the best manipulator she has been shown to be good enough to get into Anne Maria, Lightning, and Cameron’s head. There might be a couple mistakes but Im proud of it, especially for a first attempt

[@TequilaMockingBird91]

@@bananabreadman overall concern is hi imbalanced the season would be. Especially come merge. You have 5 males and 2 females in the merge. Also, you have 4 villains in the endgame.

[@007n7EzekielmilIer]

hm. chezburger

[@bananabreadman]

Yeah