What is China's interest in Afghanistan | Taliban interest in CPEC | Asia Geopolitics

[@archerc3811]

"Taliban can't take over Afghanistan" oh how 5 days can make a difference 😂

[@archerc3811]

@5th generation War 3 days seems like a stretch, I'd give it two weeks

[@karagis75]

Yes 👍🏽

[@slumy8195]

i know right! history has shown us, great empires won with few men outnumbered beyond a man can imagine. Its the truthful men that win wars not those that do it for a piece of paper with a number on it (useless dollars)

[@jesseterrell9354]

@@archerc3811 3 days sounds about right unless the US makes an effort from the air to slow them down which looks like what is happening.

[@danwelterweight4137]

@@jesseterrell9354 they just entered Kabul as I speak.

[@testbox366]

"Taliban can't take over the whole Afghanistan, it is simply impossible" They just DID !

[@wongpiangyow]

Narrator has been smoking too much hashish. Simple India-centred narrative.

[@evanmedi6144]

actualy taliban doesnt controle Bangeshire County which always been a thorn in their back, its the location of the alliance of the north US allies and the one who drove them outside afghanistan with the help of USA in 2001. so untill taliban can secure that region it still doesnt controle afghanistan whole

[@pierrecurie]

Ya, that aged like milk

[@Year--1915]

Russia and china approved the tailban. tailban should also wake up. China will take everything. Look at what xhina is doing in africa. Xhina is trade black slaves with arabs.

[@fazilmohammed2374]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😎

[@bangguyraj]

And it's all over now. The Talibans had the quickest knock out bout in the political history!

[@trumpcard749]

This person should take the video down for his own good lol

[@HeadphoneGuy2009]

Taliban is nothing to compare to china forces!!

[@HeadphoneGuy2009]

Russia has play greater control over china!!!

[@HeadphoneGuy2009]

Kill of the communist spreadsheet in the world!

[@abhishekanshuwali3808]

Exactly

[@khitai8227]

it's the old Silk road, they still use it

[@jangelbrich7056]

Apart from the recent dramatics rendering "Taliban can't take over Afghanistan" wrong, yet the overall geostrategic analysis of this video remains very valid. Thanks, this was very informative.

[@jithendraparlapalli7039]

Take over happened because of Kabul but that doesn’t mean they have full control. Ground reality is different and can change quickly as of today they are losing ground in one district and lost their own personal. Not easy to keep the position for too long if they don’t know how to make it politically possible.

[@mAviralbhanu]

Many districts are not under taliban..And northern alliance rules them.

[@funnycat1957]

They took over Kabul, not quite the whole country yet.

[@junksails814]

@Facts keep liberals away Northern Alliance is a myth.....its a loose gathering of ethnically diverse people

[@footjn532]

He has said practically.Surrender and betrayal are other things

[@jetblack6850]

The question should be" What is The US interest in Afghanistan" The US have been there more than 20 years.

[@haiderabbasi145]

Why would indian ask fhis question, nobody is talking about about the whole truth. Everybody talks about the half truth that suits them. E.g for indian people, united states using india is good China using Pakistan bad lol

[@Tom-jt1rv]

@@haiderabbasi145 Stop propergating bullshit. Pakistan is knees deep in debt to China, and giving away diplomatic power to China, even beraying Muslim Uighurs by forcibly returning them to China. Give me a time when Pakistan had the balls to contradict China.

[@animebeargameplay5679]

@@haiderabbasi145India suffer by usa and Pakistan have 100% vaccine china care Pakistan. What India have 0 help USA laughing u guys mess your life.

[@pissonthe0fighteverybody276]

Well research it why did the US attack Afghanistan? Because Bin Laden had training camps and were using Afghanistan as a base of operations to murder thousands of Americans. 9/11 right? Okay so the US gov said hey Taliban give us Bin Laden. Taliban said no we love him he kills the Great Satan (America) citizens. That’s why but I’m sure if someone comes to your country murders thousands of your citizens. You would pat them on the back. However there was no reason to go to Iraq. If Saddam was that bad and I believe he was a monster. He could have been killed without invading the nation. But it’s okay I think you will realize one day in the future. That the US wasn’t that bad.

[@joela.4058]

Bin laden was only a small piece of why US invaded (and stayed in Afghanistan) I’m still trying to wrap my head around why US was willing to invade and spend trillions in Afghanistan. A lot has changed since bush but I think they saw it as a way to contain both China and Iran while potentially exploiting the mineral resources there and creating an ally in the region. They were gravely wrong. It was probably the biggest and most expensive US military blunders in history.

[@MultiMojo]

"Taliban cannot takeover the whole of Afghanistan" - this video did not age well. Hope this guy wasn't an analyst at the Pentagon

[@nurlhaqchaniago6143]

Most probably belonged to the diaspora who earned the trust of his white superiors(no more….)

[@cosmicerror5129]

@@nurlhaqchaniago6143 nope, he teaches Indian civil service aspirants

[@user-vv7ir1pl4j]

This whole video is anti china and the Indian accent gives it away

[@dsgkong02]

@@user-vv7ir1pl4j You are absolutely right, he is definitely biased against China. Like the West, he sees no good with anything Chinese

[@view1st]

The Taliban ARE Afghans so I find it silly when people say the Taliban can't take over their own country. It's like saying that Modi's Hindu nationalists can't take over India. Of course they can, they live there.

[@joshuaxie8527]

"Taliban can't take over the whole Afghanistan, it is simply impossible" LOL

[@AshTech1122]

😂😂

[@booksteer7057]

What a difference a week makes. :-(

[@kennethblocher6110]

👁👄👁

[@booksteer7057]

@@DS-ll5fn Yes, the commenter is laughing at that claim. See the LOL?

[@ahmadkhan788]

LoL check yesterday news

[@akbrahma7739]

Congrats Mr Sengupta, you've just been upgraded from a UPSC guide instructor to an amateur political analyst, with international audience, esp Paks. Hell, who knows, we might one day see you on the live network. Very happy with your work, cheers and wishing you luck. 😊

[@billy402]

The chance that there will be high speed rail in Afghanistan before U.S. looks a lot higher.

[@tecumsehneo2174]

@Space Rock Real genocide by the US over its 200+ year history or the alleged genocide by China? Authoritarianism of the US over the rest of the world? Debt traps of the US elites over its own citizens and all over the world? With the US track record of destroying what others build, China will need a lot of luck in helping to rebuild Afghanistan. What did American tax paying citizens get for spending over $2 trillion in Afghanistan - a bunch of crooks who got insanely weathy.

[@tecumsehneo2174]

@Space Rock You are alive right now correct? What is the US doing with over 700 bases around the world? Look up the definition of genocide. What happened in the death camps of Europe or what happened in Rwanda is not happening in Xinjiang. What happened to Japaneses Americans in the 1940s is not even close to what's happening to the ethnic minorities in Xinjiang. I've seen the fake news by our main stream media and supposed independent platforms like John Oliver and Vice. To me sources like the ones I'll link have more credibility. The Vice fakenews is in the playlist for contrast... kzbin.info/aero/PL17RIulJpRx1SmzyuP8vEA3l5LiE77_vX

[@tecumsehneo2174]

@Space Rock As for Chinese Nationalists... I'm American and here is an American that I agree with: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qprbgKyfh511Y5o

[@tecumsehneo2174]

@Space Rock Here's another American that more Americans should know about: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYLMZWBvbKyLqKs

[@tecumsehneo2174]

@Space Rock So you don't trust KZbin links. Might as well since it's owned by Google. Maybe you've heard of George Carlin? Do a search for his "Life of worth losing" and watch him tell the truth through humor. Maybe it's a little easier to digest that way. The other American I linked was Chalmers Johnson - author of the trilogy Blowback, The Sorrows of Empire, and Nemesis. Every American should at least know who he was.

[@ahmerakbar1]

Chana already has the road route to mddle east from Azerbaijan side and iran. They dont beed to connect with Afghanistan for that. Reasons they want to connect with afganistan is for their mineral extraction, to make sure east turkamanistan movement does not get any kind of support from taliban and to make money from afganistan's development.

[@oceanwave4502]

You should not put all eggs into one basket... (there should be multiple routes from China to Europe/Africa, just in case one of the countries along those routes like to play dramas...)

[@madeinchina1450]

it is easy to draw a line and make a youtube video, but actually, those mountains (Afghanistan to China area) are over 5000-6000 meters. Not accessible for the commercial road.

[@slayerofsatanists]

Right IF TALIBAN SUPPORTED EAST TURKISTAN THEN YOU KNOW WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN

[@HimanshuSharma-oe4mk]

@@madeinchina1450 there are passes in those mountains - they've been used since time immemorial.

[@razil6749]

@𝓔𝓱𝓲𝓶𝓪𝔂𝓪 𝓚𝓪𝓾𝓻 yes. 1) cpec. China recently said it has got the evidence of raw involvement in dasu dam project 9 Chinese killing. Thing to be noted thwy had said this earlier before the investigation. This would not have been true if China wasn't really eager about CPEC. This just shows how hateful a common Indian is because of CPEC in Pakistan and development being done in Pakistan. This also shows Indians as a nation don't like muslims, Pakistan and Islamic states. They are just hypocrites trying to get into OIC.... 2) India has not been kept in any regional talks regarding Afganisthan till now despite their 4 consulates bring present in Afghanistan near Pakistan border. Despite their huge diplomatic presence in Afghanistan nobody not USA, Not Russia, Not China, Not Pakistan, Not nobody literally cared India for involving them to talks. It is a kind of foreign policy defeat for India one after another. So, it is evident that other superpowers knows India is not a regional factor in Afghan issue. Then the question arises why all these consulates in Afghan, (which is far more than necessary with a country which does not share a common border and is also a small country) It only means India is the terror spreading country in Afghanistan in the means of Tehric-e-Taliban and taking advantage of Refugees crises in between Afghan-Pak border, including teams of Insurgents into Pakistan while a refugee spike....though this Tehric-e-taliban has no relations with the real Taliban....

[@morningstar3870]

Russians came and bombed Afghanistan, Americans did the same. Chinese will come and build roads and infrastructure. That’s still better for Afg. The rest you may interpret the whole thing the way it suits you

[@donhancock332]

Alexander The Great tried to conquer Afghanistan.So did The Mongols.As did The British- twice! They all tried to do it by force.China will simply buy it!

[@santoshkashmiri4000]

Kindly eloborate your areas of disagreement to enhance our knowledge. India too did not join Afghan military to counter Taliban rather they invested in building infrastructure for the benefit of Afghan populace. China may do it to exploit their mineral resources . Your opinions are solicited

[@morningstar3870]

@@santoshkashmiri4000 China doesn’t interfere in other countries internal matters. They just want to do business. Give and take. India sides with Afg govt which was installed by the US, but most Afghans support Taliban. If taliban is bad, so is Saudi.

[@joela.4058]

While I agree that China is much much better at diplomacy than the west, you are erroneous to think China wouldn’t use military might if it can or wants to. You’re also forgetting US bombed but then spent 2 trillion on roads, hospitals, schools and infrastructure as well.

[@yonzanheeromani518]

Very true

[@mathewjohnable]

Today ie; August 15 2021, Taliban has taken over Afghanistan. Iran and Taliban are bitter enemies. In 1998, Taliban has murdered Iranian diplomats despite the plea from Iranian leadership.

[@cyndiharrington1751]

The Shia need to be protected..Taliban known to be ruthless

[@RoamMeYo]

Religious ideologies are of little importance when there are larger things at stake. But, religious beliefs are emotions that can motivate the larger masses for a rebellion movement. Politics is not easy, people need to understand and learn to live in harmony just like other beings of the earth, else doomsday isn't far.

[@PerryMartinsshow]

If the Taliban and Iran are bitter enemies and the US practically left Afghanistan in a hurry leaving behind military hardwares that can be easily resuscitated, doesn't it seem that the US is indirectly arming and empowering the Taliban as torn on the flesh of Iran. So the US is still in play in the region. Knowing also that Pakistan has been double faced, the US might be developing relations with the Taliban to still be in operation in the region.

[@dallasyap3064]

@@PerryMartinsshow Those military hardware seized were from the afghan forces not US forces. Some of those hardware has been destroyed by air strikes.

[@PerryMartinsshow]

@@dallasyap3064 We all know that the hardware is US hardware, we have also seen that most times they are able to crudely salvage some even after they have been bombed.

[@Lawleet]

Bro, Talibans have conquered afgan easily with love and peace just after a few days you made this video. You had mentioned that it's practically impossible for Talibans to win, now you might have figured out that you should never underestimate the power of a common man.

[@curiouspmindblowinghistory5369]

THat's why china is one of the richest countries. They always see the business side of things no matter how ugly the situation is.

[@magellanmax]

One week after this video was made-----The Taliban has overrun the entire country and are running everything.😅 Never underestimate the Taliban.

[@ijaz420ali2]

👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

[@gordonramsey2742]

@@ijaz420ali2 👍👍👍

[@btiger9495]

As usual he spoke too soon.

[@funnycat1957]

Or that sorcery book, the K___n, which gives them the motivation to do everything possible and impossible to achieve their goals. The only way to prevent future disasters is to be conscious of the threat, 'cause Islamic radicalism won't be satisfied with just Afghanistan.

[@mafiaclub8654]

The Taliban will be wiped out totally soon.including ISIS.. Just watch..

[@khalidbarkatullah6298]

The workshop of the world wants connectivity and market access to the whole world and in today’s world logistics is the key word. That has been flawlessly explained by Mr Amit Sengupta

[@nishantpaliwal8738]

Thode time me bore ho jaoge

[@barrism7176]

Recently, read about China request the UN to preserve the Silk Road.. Then realised the fact, Eurasia is one continent.. 👽

[@alvaabassndiaye]

the interest of the Chinese in Afghanistan is lithium mines to manufacture batteries. tesla has just opened its patents to the public it's the race for electric cars

[@massinakmin8340]

Hahahaha what a joke. Tesla does not have a patent on lithium batteries.. omg.

[@mitchellnova324]

I think copper also.

[@blackknight4996]

Tesla's battery tech is very backward. They lost the race.

[@AlexCame]

What companies from China want to mine there!???????

[@__Man__]

@@mitchellnova324 yes, copper to support electrical wiring

[@shaik_hasan_ahmed]

"Taliban can't take over Afghanistan as a whole. its practically impossible" it was just a matte of weeks..... :D

[@graydational]

Extremist religionism is the Islamic version of Reign of Terror.

[@shaik_hasan_ahmed]

@@graydational sorry! i don't quite understand

[@cripCrap861]

@@shaik_hasan_ahmed For that you need to be qualified from a good educational institutions and not from madrasa 🤗

[@shaik_hasan_ahmed]

@@cripCrap861 🙁👎

[@bansrajmattai4548]

China's goal is economic, not hegemonic. That is the main relationship between China and Afghanistan and it will bring benefits to both countries.

[@ronaldphoong]

Peace with Afghanistan.. that's all. Trade will grow Afghanistan.

[@ueks69]

Never let them eat cake

[@ronaldphoong]

@Kawaii Time will tell if change will happen. Don't expect overnight change. They need to rebuild their country, bring in education and trade. Normalization may take a decade or two. It is a reset for the people and better now than never. If China can do it, they can succeed too.

[@Zopdoz]

Love the different perspective you bring with your analysis! Very eye opening, definitely subbing!!!

[@razil6749]

@𝓔𝓱𝓲𝓶𝓪𝔂𝓪 𝓚𝓪𝓾𝓻 yes. 1) cpec. China recently said it has got the evidence of raw involvement in dasu dam project 9 Chinese killing. Thing to be noted thwy had said this earlier before the investigation. This would not have been true if China wasn't really eager about CPEC. This just shows how hateful a common Indian is because of CPEC in Pakistan and development being done in Pakistan. This also shows Indians as a nation don't like muslims, Pakistan and Islamic states. They are just hypocrites trying to get into OIC.... 2) India has not been kept in any regional talks regarding Afganisthan till now despite their 4 consulates bring present in Afghanistan near Pakistan border. Despite their huge diplomatic presence in Afghanistan nobody not USA, Not Russia, Not China, Not Pakistan, Not nobody literally cared India for involving them to talks. It is a kind of foreign policy defeat for India one after another. So, it is evident that other superpowers knows India is not a regional factor in Afghan issue. Then the question arises why all these consulates in Afghan, (which is far more than necessary with a country which does not share a common border and is also a small country) It only means India is the terror spreading country in Afghanistan in the means of Tehric-e-Taliban and taking advantage of Refugees crises in between Afghan-Pak border, including teams of Insurgents into Pakistan while a refugee spike....though this Tehric-e-taliban has no relations with the real Taliban....

[@ronnieka3309]

Great video, thanks. And for all those criticisms on that Taliban already took over. What he said about Taliban looking for legitimacy is still true, just that they have to do that while controlling the whole country came a bit as a surprise. Keep up the good work with yr videos, they are very insightful

[@Macorian]

They will have to form agreements, naturally. The US never had any legitimacy. So, yes, it's true but it's also self-evident. Afghanistan, being the tribal country it is, will have to ultimately rely on some kind of balance of power.

[@ToxicMire]

@@Macoriannope, the Europeans did and always will rely on others.

[@ChinDulles]

@@ToxicMire I smell a commie

[@teukurajahitam8225]

Moral of this story : China has a lot of money and Talibans want it 😂

[@petersquier7015]

Previous govt received Money from USA Now TAliban will receve money from China... in the middle of this: the population is screwed

[@hushpuppykl]

China will bring real economic benefit to the Afghans. Simple.

[@bwv1000]

China is a poor country

[@yl128pang3]

Another moral of the story is that Taipei will be the version 3 of Saigon Vietnam ( Kabul is Version 2)

[@noellarodrigues293]

Talibans have a lot of lithium, the new oil, and China wants it. This is why they used their puppet Biden to clear out the Americans.

[@tyn6211]

China does need Pakistan because it's the most economical and safest route for trade between Xinjiang and Africa.

[@pinoyparin4414]

Chinese druglords like this route.

[@veiikgaming]

Not anymore.

[@tancosta1286]

Exacly that , also stratigic point to Europe.... good point

[@wilfoxreal8641]

And Pakistan is a Gemini

[@CosmicSeeker69]

@@wilfoxreal8641 ?

[@guddu791]

This is called an "Explanation..! 💯

[@jujutuladhar7069]

"Trading is better than Bombing" - this is what China wants. Unlike US, China do not send Military troops but Trading troops to other countries.

[@moRaaOTAKU]

Capitalist troops lol

[@NoOneUNo]

CCP enemy of the world. Allowed pandemic to spread. They want power by any means necessary. They sacrifice their own to feed the CCP regime & will regret ever dealing with such an evil regime.

[@ranashome24]

Thanks for a very logical analysis of the complex situation. Please do an update on the unfolding political status.

[@harshabharadwajvn246]

Sir you are a most knowledgeable teacher in Geography and polity

[@andrewdean7917]

As Col Gaddafi said to the U.S. " I thought you were after Al Qaeda not the Taliban" !

[@DS-ll5fn]

Same same. The core is the same

[@btiger9495]

US was embarrassed so US got rid of Col Gaddafi.

[@haiderabbasi145]

China has direct border with Afghanistan while india has none.The real question that needed to be asked: What is india's interest in Afghanistan?

[@cheongwenpa]

India is acting on behalf of America to sabotage Afghanistan relationship with China. If China - Afghan - Iran become strong alliance, the middle oil will flow to China, and China goods will flow to Iran. And Afghanistan will get richer as trader again (just like the silk road era). Then India will find itself surrounded by Chinese alliances. Would India want to see the above happening ?

[@aryanyadav3690]

India has invested 23,000 Crore in Afghanistan India has no interest in Afg, but Afg Govt wants India to free Afg from Terrorism and Debt Trap, in simple peace in Afghanistan✌️ Just see old videos of Indian PM & Afg PM 👍 India has also build road, dam and Parliament Afghanistan wants peace from everyone (terrorism), so it choose INDIA to lead 🙏

[@haiderabbasi145]

@@aryanyadav3690 its great that india has helped Afghanistan. That investment can surely be seen there but this has not come just because of the goodwill india has tried to engage Pakistan in two front war.My problem is that india and Pakistan should stop fighting and progress like the rest of the world.

[@linshengzhuang4049]

@@cheongwenpa Yeah, every country has its position...

[@dallasyap3064]

@@cheongwenpa Good point

[@effexon]

Gotta say this is very very good overview of that region.

[@jharris548]

Dude was literally predicting the future 😳

[@Lrnink]

This is the only place where we have not thanked Neeraj Chopra. So let's put a javelling in the heart of Asia while we chair the UNSC once and for all

[@joselee9605]

😂 India seems extremely proud of Neeraj Chopra, he has broken a 100 year curse. Here’s to many more gold medals for India in the future 🎉

[@billybond4148]

What’s most likely to happen now? Afghanistan, Pakistan, China, Russia, Iran, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan will all work together to provide peace, security and a better life for all its peoples.

[@Minadarling119]

Corona: I spread fast! Taliban: Hold my Turban takes over Afghanistan in a couple of days

[@nobleman_81]

💀🤣💀🤣💀

[@btiger9495]

Done on 16th August !

[@pratiklokhande7735]

Panjshir resistance :- We are in Afghanistan

[@dallasyap3064]

Lol

[@heman6540]

Amit - love your geopolitical and security analysis and the way you describe it - very clear. The graphics are very descriptive and makes every thing very very clear. Very well done and please keep up the great work. Look forward to more from you !

[@beirangiaphiapi452]

"Talibans can't take over Afghanistan" Talibans,"challenge accepted"😂

[@rajpipla1]

Fine tutorial. While the land route is shorter, sea transport is more economical for vast quantities that China exports and imports.

[@tatarchan5212]

Sea maybe cheaper but silk road is a must for China, with south china sea stupidity and India shenanigans the seafaring trade has become too unstable for them, high speed trains will replace camels and things will be ready to get go.

[@tyn6211]

@Khepri There's almost no way to go from China (especially Xinjiang) -> Africa by rail. Need the CPEC.

[@akashbaburaj2349]

@Khepri but comparing rail freight through big terrains I think ocean freight will be more economical. just a thought

[@vidard9863]

Time costs money, the land route is also much faster. Some things will be cheaper overland, some over sea.

[@elpoiken]

@Khepri Also, when the sea routes were established 200 years ago ,we didnt have intercontinal railroads, Shipping by sea is an old philosophy. Today we have fast locomotives,not the slow chugging steam trains.

[@michaellalanae7228]

They are protecting the interests of the oil companys who want to run a pipeline through the land

[@donnieboy123]

Does Afghan have oil ?

[@nobsguykeepitreal]

@@donnieboy123 why else do you think the Americans stayed there for 20 years

[@MrGoatFish10]

@@donnieboy123 how the hell they use vehicles then? If they don’t have oil.

[@tancosta1286]

@@donnieboy123 its about strategic point with no rules, its not about the oil, thats why no one is looking into it

[@tancosta1286]

@@MrGoatFish10 because Iran is their sponsor

[@josefernandez-hz4ep]

Well, Tings, didn't go as you predicted, but, who would hade known this amazing development of history?

[@Americandragonrider333.]

Glad to see someone loves Terrorism.

[@bycottfrenchproducts.mukht1189]

Bcz they (india) always anaylised not on facts but lies and bious attitude and see what happened..!!!

[@CumBrianFries]

"who would have known this amazing development of history?" - uhh, like literally anyone who has taken World History in school could see this coming? You ever heard of the Vietnam War?

[@gardy4390]

@@Americandragonrider333. we just had an idea what terrorists do just remember January 6th.

[@stevehils8618]

Great and very realistic analysis. Well explain. Hope political parties around the world take note of what you just explain.

[@atifrana5470]

You can feel happy by thinking China has stopped CPEC but China is investing in industrial zones in Pakistan it's the 2nd phase now. Many Chinese industrialists are relocating to Pakistan

[@harikrishnabalivada4580]

Pakistan will be chaina colony

[@anushkachauhan9867]

Please make videos on art and culture for UPSC aspirants

[@TrippinCreatives]

Looks like you've also underestimated the Taliban. They've just entered Kabul

[@scoot4081]

"its going to take weeks", "they are unorganized" Taliban: Proceeds to take over entire country in less than 3 months... Literally captured/surrounded the capital city within hours...

[@lovehumankind8087]

China will use Pakistan as " Paper napkin " - Amit Sengupta Sir --- Perfectly said sir

[@thechosenone1533]

I spat out my drink when he said"There's no chance of the Taliban taking Afghanistan". 😂😂😂😂

[@allthatisunsaid9030]

He said "cant take ALL of Afganistan"..which is true, they cant

[@songsabai3794]

@@allthatisunsaid9030 yes exactly, pay attention to details this guys splits hairs!

[@HabtitOklib]

I kept listening this video and admired your analysis. However, Taliban indeed did the other way round🤷‍♂️

[@GuyI9000]

What a biased video.... claims CPEC has failed? CPEC is going full steam ahead..... whereas india chose to worship its colonial masters..... india is finished, india should make friends with its neighbours instead of fighting with them

[@RahulChauhanThakur]

I was eagerly waiting for this, thank you

[@sudiptabasu96]

Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqq0goOnrK6lr9E

[@Bkazi123]

Wow! You've cleared my mind about this issue which has been in a clutter for a long time. Also, why do you think China would rather meet with Taliban and with the Afghan government to make deals about their plans in Afg. Thank you iA.

[@virchandrakumar8186]

Nobody wants to bring looser in their team

[@Bkazi123]

@@virchandrakumar8186 not helpful, but thanks.

[@rs-ku8ls]

It's easy to negotiate with 1 dictator rather than team of dictators

[@razil6749]

@𝓔𝓱𝓲𝓶𝓪𝔂𝓪 𝓚𝓪𝓾𝓻 yes. 1) cpec. China recently said it has got the evidence of raw involvement in dasu dam project 9 Chinese killing. Thing to be noted thwy had said this earlier before the investigation. This would not have been true if China wasn't really eager about CPEC. This just shows how hateful a common Indian is because of CPEC in Pakistan and development being done in Pakistan. This also shows Indians as a nation don't like muslims, Pakistan and Islamic states. They are just hypocrites trying to get into OIC.... 2) India has not been kept in any regional talks regarding Afganisthan till now despite their 4 consulates bring present in Afghanistan near Pakistan border. Despite their huge diplomatic presence in Afghanistan nobody not USA, Not Russia, Not China, Not Pakistan, Not nobody literally cared India for involving them to talks. It is a kind of foreign policy defeat for India one after another. So, it is evident that other superpowers knows India is not a regional factor in Afghan issue. Then the question arises why all these consulates in Afghan, (which is far more than necessary with a country which does not share a common border and is also a small country) It only means India is the terror spreading country in Afghanistan in the means of Tehric-e-Taliban and taking advantage of Refugees crises in between Afghan-Pak border, including teams of Insurgents into Pakistan while a refugee spike....though this Tehric-e-taliban has no relations with the real Taliban....

[@QuentinKLEau]

The motto of China is no intervention in other country's internal affair. They explicitly said the Afghan issue should be resolved by Afghan people and like the Russians, the Chinese are hoping for a political peace agreement between the different factions in Afghanistan. The ethnic and cultural situation of Afghanistan is very complex and similar to India at the beginning of independence, imposing a one state one party solution is not realistic to maintain peace. However, seeing the rapid progress of the Taliban, it is obvious that they will be the biggest political force in Afghanistan when all things will be settled down. The Chinese are just preparing the field.

[@Aryan_Kumar_Sharma7]

Crystal clear video. Thank you so much sir.

[@tarync6539]

"Investment and time" 2 things that are unlimited to China 🇨🇳

[@bangscutter]

This video is suddenly recommended after today's events. I'm sure your video will get millions of views soon.

[@KINGSOMALIA]

I'm a neutral party but I can sense your incredible bias towards Pakistan lol, why are heaps and heaps of Indians like this....

[@uwu.cynostic]

most Indians don't actually have a problem with the people and vise versa obviously some people will be racist but that's just how it is , the real beef is between the Governments and both sides foster hate for the other Government.

[@GuyI9000]

Hindutva hates muslims.... muslims love and adore china, hindutva also hates chinese.... so double hate for muslims

[@atifrana5470]

They are liars 😅😅. China is investing in phase 2 now in Pakistan. Many Chinese industrialists are heavily investing in Pakistan now. Pakistan started made in Pakistan mobile phone exports now. Vivo

[@garychesser5277]

Somalia simply put they are butt hurt about partition and, being hindu, they hate all muslims. The India/Pakistan conflict is not an arguement between two different peoples it is an arguement between two different religious groups.

[@btiger9495]

They do not want to join the Indian army & fight with Pakistan. So they praise Pakistan instead.

[@Nidhi-ll3yq]

For all those saying that the "prediction" in this video didn't age well...His content is NOT about predicting outcomes of geo-political tensions...it is to decode them for better clarity. We all know now, that a lot of the outcome that we are witnessing today- was pre-decided well in advance by the peace negotiating "players".

[@dilipkumarpatel8313]

So what is the future in South Asia according to your analysis.

[@Nidhi-ll3yq]

@@dilipkumarpatel8313 I don't have an answer for that. Even if I did, I'm not an expert in the field of Geopolitics & History. I cannot foresee things either.

[@RPhTom]

"It is not possible for Taliban to take over entire Afghanistan," LOL, this video didn't age well!

[@thechosenone1533]

You know this video is old when he said"There's no chance of the Taliban taking Afghanistan".

[@Hypocrites-507]

Afghanistan needs infrastructure Huawei 5G technology n China can built n do business not war

[@ashutoshsaraswat8350]

Where is India? India lost Iran and will also lost Afghan after Ashraf ghani lost his power from kabul.

[@arminius6506]

India is busy talking sh*t against a country 5-6 time smaller than them. I mean have a look at this video 😅

[@point4537]

on the mars 🤣🤣

[@joselee9605]

@@arminius6506 And they wonder why Pakistan started building relations with China

[@bsobro]

@@arminius6506 i was laughing at it.. yeah even in the "informational or educational" video why does he have to throw around the insults?? What is that gonna achieve besides hate mongering?

[@oceanwave4502]

India barely takes care of themselves, let alone giving money/aids/loans to other countries... Unless Afghan/Iran like to watch Bollywood movies, there is nothing else India can offer.

[@santoshkashmiri4000]

I have watched your both the videos. Very informative, precise and almost correct assessment of the issues involved, more particularly about repositioning by US. Very informative.

[@edgarjohnston7937]

Lots of assumptions

[@razil6749]

@@edgarjohnston7937 yes. 1) cpec. China recently said it has got the evidence of raw involvement in dasu dam project 9 Chinese killing. Thing to be noted thwy had said this earlier before the investigation. This would not have been true if China wasn't really eager about CPEC. This just shows how hateful a common Indian is because of CPEC in Pakistan and development being done in Pakistan. This also shows Indians as a nation don't like muslims, Pakistan and Islamic states. They are just hypocrites trying to get into OIC.... 2) India has not been kept in any regional talks regarding Afganisthan till now despite their 4 consulates bring present in Afghanistan near Pakistan border. Despite their huge diplomatic presence in Afghanistan nobody not USA, Not Russia, Not China, Not Pakistan, Not nobody literally cared India for involving them to talks. It is a kind of foreign policy defeat for India one after another. So, it is evident that other superpowers knows India is not a regional factor in Afghan issue. Then the question arises why all these consulates in Afghan, (which is far more than necessary with a country which does not share a common border and is also a small country) It only means India is the terror spreading country in Afghanistan in the means of Tehric-e-Taliban and taking advantage of Refugees crises in between Afghan-Pak border, including teams of Insurgents into Pakistan while a refugee spike....though this Tehric-e-taliban has no relations with the real Taliban....

[@razil6749]

@𝓔𝓱𝓲𝓶𝓪𝔂𝓪 𝓚𝓪𝓾𝓻 yes. 1) cpec. China recently said it has got the evidence of raw involvement in dasu dam project 9 Chinese killing. Thing to be noted thwy had said this earlier before the investigation. This would not have been true if China wasn't really eager about CPEC. This just shows how hateful a common Indian is because of CPEC in Pakistan and development being done in Pakistan. This also shows Indians as a nation don't like muslims, Pakistan and Islamic states. They are just hypocrites trying to get into OIC.... 2) India has not been kept in any regional talks regarding Afganisthan till now despite their 4 consulates bring present in Afghanistan near Pakistan border. Despite their huge diplomatic presence in Afghanistan nobody not USA, Not Russia, Not China, Not Pakistan, Not nobody literally cared India for involving them to talks. It is a kind of foreign policy defeat for India one after another. So, it is evident that other superpowers knows India is not a regional factor in Afghan issue. Then the question arises why all these consulates in Afghan, (which is far more than necessary with a country which does not share a common border and is also a small country) It only means India is the terror spreading country in Afghanistan in the means of Tehric-e-Taliban and taking advantage of Refugees crises in between Afghan-Pak border, including teams of Insurgents into Pakistan while a refugee spike....though this Tehric-e-taliban has no relations with the real Taliban....

[@sudiptabasu96]

Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqq0goOnrK6lr9E

[@sabaaman]

😀😃🙂🙃

[@michaelweeks9317]

Outstanding analysis, concisely delivered with excellent research and maps. Well done Sir! Bravo! Michael Weeks, an admirer in San Antonio Texas. A+

[@allthatisunsaid9030]

US was better off with Trump, atleast he wasn't interested in creating a war n profit arms industry..his only drawback was he was a straight shooter not a sweet talking politician which actually I appreciated

[@TheBillaro]

This aged well... taliban took over

[@missfatimajinnah8776]

Afghanistan is at war so peaceful Afghanistan is necessary for this also Pak-China Friendship is old & trusted so It's hard to ignore Pakistan

[@btiger9495]

Pakistan and China are friends for long term. Afghanistan will benefit from this relationship

[@jaec5680]

The hasty withdrawal of the United States and NATO troops from Afghanistan actually marked the failure of the U.S. policy towards Afghanistan, and the Afghan people have an important opportunity to stabilize and develop their own country. China interest in Afghanistan could be 'positive', says Blinken - BBC News

[@hfur7758]

Whenever any Country attacked Afghanistan they new that one day their Ars would be Enlightened 😅.

[@chilesauce7248]

The Taliban should be fighting the ccp for their genocide of Muslim peoples in China, the Taliban is a pawn for the ccp, nothing more. Like much of the world they are fooled by Chinas' ccp, while the ccp rapes their oceans, their lands and makes them slaves. #defundtheccp

[@pinoyparin4414]

That means more money for Biden's son.

[@jasons4045]

@@chilesauce7248 brainwashed

[@elixues]

@@chilesauce7248 The good thing is.. More and more Westerners wise up to the fact while there are big scale incarceration of separatists, and even midly radicalised Uyghurs (as admitted by the Chinese themselves), there are no credible evidences of genocide. Even the US law department acknowledged this fact. In fact, many of the so-called evidences were fake and produced by NED funded NGOs to discredit China. Furthermore, the misuse of the term 'genocide' really insult the memories of all past victims. Anyway, nothing you said will change any of the above facts. When faced with evidences to dedunk the lies, the likes of you will just repeat the same lies over and over again. To be honest, it is funny to see the frustration from the same group of liars when they have to make a hasty retreat with their tails between their legs. A timely advice for you.. Time to make more informed research, and don't let your bias and prejudice against the Chinese cloud your thinking. The Chinese is not interested to take over your country, or the World.. They just want to do more trades, and improve the lives of their own people, which indirectly will also improve the lives of those who worked with them, via trades, infrastructure developments etc. Fair trade (or a slightly lopsided one if you still want to insist) will win over wars and killings any day.

[@bluesm4271]

this video needs an update. your content is very informative tough love it

[@btiger9495]

Need to update. Afghanistan had reclaimed her country without a fight.

[@webmaster8925]

''Taliban can't take over Afghanistan'' Laughing in Pachto😂😂😂😂😂

[@pratiklokhande7735]

There is resistance in Afghanistan..... panjshir area is not under Taliban.....maybe you rely on Western media so much .....

[@pennygriffithsattorney1692]

The discussion is very informative. A handful of brilliant politicians rule the world and determine the quality of life for the majority if people.

[@sachingahukar6179]

Cant get more true ...you are absolutely spot on ..but certain correction its not Brilliant politicians its Heartless, Inhuman category of Politician ..and Biden and kamala Harris are crooks sitting at highest order ..Sold the soul to China

[@donchen4906]

Brilliant or motivated by self-interest. It's really hard to tell.

[@graceantonio3573]

😃🤣 I loved listening to u🙂 narrate your video, thank u😀 very entertaining! 🤣😇

[@thepropmachines1042]

YOU CAN CRY AS HARD AS YOU CAN,BUT PAK CHINA FRIENDSHIP IS ABOVE ALL POLITICAL ANALYSIS.

[@behzadahmad8818]

I got my doubts, The taliban has 5000 Uighur fighters which would be very hostile to any Chinese in Afghanistan. Also Afghanistan is very rugged and mountainous, they would have to cross Tienshan mountains and the Hindu Kush to reach Iran through Afghanistan while they can just go through the tienshan and into Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan which both are a lot safer and stable then Afghanistan. But still a good take.

[@resiefan3258]

China has 2 million soldiers all up. 5000 taliban would be slaughtered. hell Chinese forces would kill everyone not just Taliban.

[@Walkercolt1]

China wants Afghanistan's OPIUM! That's all China has wanted for about 8 THOUSAND YEARS! India/England has wanted it too, but even the Seiks couldn't conquer and maintain control of the Afghans. Read Kipling. Raw opium can be processed into modern fentanyl with a kid's chemistry set, and it's value increased about a million times (gram per gram). Afghanistan also is a huge source of white slaves to the Middle East, about 2 million a year. Men for labor, women and children for labor and sex slaves (and a few men for "ladyboys"). Saudi Arabia, Dubai, Oman, Muscat, Yemen and Ankar are the biggest slave buyers in the World, an estimated 8-12 million yearly from different countries, mostly South East Asia, but other places too.

[@shirleylake7738]

Thank you for the important information.

[@ruthretzke8785]

Thank you so very much for this very informative explaination of what is really going down with respect to the Afghanistan, as well as, the Chinese influences in the Middle East.

[@jharris548]

Exactly this is what I valued

[@propergander1162]

Aside from trade routes and vast mineral assets yet untapped , the Chinese interest in Afghanistan is no different from that of America and the UK 🤔 China will control the chip market and therefore control the west's reliance on technology ...

[@gen-zmultibaggers141]

Amit sir, You are a GEM. Thank you for educating all of us

[@bluelines2924]

China's over riding interest here will be the mineral and heavy metal deposits that the region holds, - China: we'll support you guys Afghan: what do you want in return? China: Oh just the mining rights...other than that you can do what you like

[@megaplusultra6428]

9:37 he said they cannot defeat the Afgan forces😂😂😂your credibility just went to shit with that statement and what the situation is at present moment🤭

[@israrfida4048]

You seems to be living in dreams- wake up and start seeing the reality of day 😂

[@lorefox201]

you people be harsh, few análists a few weeks ago would have predicted that the civil government of Afghanistan would simply have folded like paper-mache the second the Americans left.

[@rh2400]

@James Lum plz don't.

[@naurasal9165]

Why Indians are so obsessed with China? When you wake Up, taking bath, having lunch and Dinner and before go to sleep, all you think and say only CHINA CHINA and CHINA. While the Chinese don't even care and think about the Indians. Big LOL

[@Dev-zr8si]

@James Lum "I don't agree with the video so that means the uploader has lost credibility" - You

[@gokulnuthanapati4774]

@@naurasal9165 well good Eve. I don't know from where u belongs. I'm from India. And I don't know why u made this statement. We don't know what u seen through media. We Indians really appreciate the china. To bringing up such social reforms. We also appreciate that ruthless government in implementing such a tough rules to bring china no.1. People's sacrifices really appreciable in China. China is a great country like India.

[@Gohan7]

Can we apply dada's voice for Google Assistance 😅

[@ttrinhity]

That was really informative!

[@tsbelmer7265uuu]

Every street is paved with gold. This is the China Belt and Road initiative. Building a community with shared future for humanity.

[@jwzjwz2003cn]

China: I just want a stabilized region so that I can do business with my neighbours. US & India: Sorry you just can't have that.

[@poushalinag7942]

India also wants stabilisation in the region but with India's strategic influence and sovereignity.

[@CrimsonAlchemist]

You predicted wrong. Taliban already won. End of story. I'm gonna start unsubscribing from now lol

[@shahjadafahim]

Taliban already capture 80% of Afghanistan you are saying they cannot what foolish thought

[@nandagopalmotog6897]

If Taliban can capture 80% so easily, then the Afghan forces can also get it back fast. Afghan forces with the right weapons support from India, Russia,USA can push the Taliban back to their caves and madarsas in Pakistan. Taliban doesn't have an airforce, Afghan airforce is there. This is apart from the numerical advantage (200000 Afghan army vs 70000 Taliban fighters) . Besides that, the civil war has already started.

[@shahjadafahim]

@@nandagopalmotog6897 I think you seem to be never seen current news ☹

[@nandagopalmotog6897]

@@shahjadafahim Today's news say 65 % ,earlier it was claimed to be 80% 😁 www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2021/8/12/10-maps-to-understand-afghanistan-interactive Don't you understand the difference between 70, 000 Vs 200,000 ? 😂

[@shahjadafahim]

@@nandagopalmotog6897 Taliban take it full baby hurrah 😂

[@nandagopalmotog6897]

@@shahjadafahim the Afghan army was supposed to fight. As an Indian who has seen our army in action, we can't understand why the Afghan army wouldn't fight ,because their president ran away. US ,China and Pakistan are cooperating to now rob Afghanistan of its mineral wealth in trillions.Pakistan will now take 25%, China40%, Taliban the rest. Some power play has happened in background for money.

[@superhuman6637]

Astounding!!Everything seems water now. sir apart from ms power point what other Softwares/techniques did you use to animate maps?

[@SuzanneOlsson]

In a tug of war between Taliban and Chinese, the Chinese will make the Taliban look like rank armatures. Amit, this is excellent! Kudos. Well done, sir.

[@musoraic]

04:48 Pakistan has to listen to China 10:12 Pakistan cannot say no to USA

[@RaviKanaujiya]

Therefore India's permanent seat in UNSC is mandatory & need of the hours. 🇮🇳🥇

[@prabhakar5264]

Same comment on world affairs 😀😀

[@manojy2506]

Permanent seat without veto is like a gold medal made of iron..

[@The_verdadero]

@@manojy2506 ya And usa will never share that power ..... We have to be a most closest friends of any of veto powered country except USA and china

[@ASD-ss2lq]

@@The_verdadero but what we have? UK was our past enemy, France? Nope Only Russia is left but Russia too have their self interest. India is like mix of communism and capitalism like USA and Russia mentality. That's why USA nor Russia trust India on Governance. We need to excel ourselves too strong to become permanent member.

[@ASD-ss2lq]

Our country is suffering internally from poverty, corruption , crippling ancient education system, joblessness, brain drain. We must sought these first make India Great first then Geo politics. Do u think farmers , poor people support India in world matter or internal matter ? Remember most of the population is like that. We still moving towards modern day

[@periyasamyp3555]

What a well-clear pictorial explanation. It was a wow experience. Even school kids can make it very clear about the current issue. Thanks a lot, sir.

[@sudiptabasu96]

Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqq0goOnrK6lr9E

[@radcow]

If Afghanistan plays its cards right it could become wealthy country

[@btiger9495]

Very smart

[@frenchenaganus1590]

@Joe Chance True. China is just using the Taliban to over throw them later.

[@atifrana5470]

Pakistan prime minister has already said to USA absolutely not. And Taliban has controlled the whole Afghanistan so you have a wrong analysis.

[@rajagopalachariraghavan8611]

informative

[@alexanderarrakkel3724]

The opening up of land border and thus uninterrupted road connectivity -- major major benefit.

[@Edwardegraham]

I saw that there is wildlife sanctuary, and mountain-pass Issues. What say, Sir?

[@alexanderarrakkel3724]

@@Edwardegraham For China the Afghan territory opens an unhindered south western corridor, strategic in its equation with India.

[@imranyounis1970]

Salute to this youtuber... Nothing happened as he said rather it happened in opposite direction. And after one week this youtuber said........ WHAT..? What the f... 😱 😂🤣😂🤣 In future, I believe he will never jump into conclusions so quickly.

[@trivenibhosale43]

Sir you didn't speak in this video, you just roared like a lion. It's very appreciable and morale boosting 🇮🇳 hats off to you sir

[@aleixodias6076]

China's Interest is business.

[@syedshehram3514]

ITS SIMPLE PAKISTAN CAN CONQUER INDIA NOW

[@TheMrCougarful]

So much for that prediction. But otherwise, yes it was informative. Good analysis.