What next for Ukraine? Trump's return could redefine the war • FRANCE 24 English

[@markrittman2437]

Lieutenant Colonel Tulsi Gabbard is a decorated Iraq War veteran, a former congresswoman who served on the Committee on Foreign Affairs, a former vice-chair of the Democratic Party, a former presidential candidate, and a political and foreign relations commentator. She is hardly a neophyte. Ms. Shapochkina should be aware of the qualifications of the person she is criticizing.

[@fulltank360]

The channel deliberately bring many woke people who are living in Utopia....

[@MikeMike-cc4jk]

And against the backdrop of the fact that a living cognitive corpse sat in the White House for 4 years and a bunch of his nominations were without qualifications but only with the right skin color or gender orientation, the objections are doubly comical. As a former driver for a few months, but lgbt, became “Secretary of Transportation”, and I'm even afraid to write here about trans Admiral and others.

[@thefirst-yb8sj]

The Russians won't be forced to negotiate, a winning side is never forced to, Russia isn't fighting a media war. The Ukrainians and West are fighting a media war while Russia fights on the battle field.

[@timosullivan5722]

The Ukrainians are on the battlefield also and the russian army can testify to that given the amount of soldiers they are loosing.

[@TheLivingTissue]

Well said

[@zallyzally2698]

Sometimes I just laughed out loud, they always assume one sided

[@dipin2]

The looser is undoubtedly Ukraine. They lost men, land, economy. If they had stayed neutral no war would have happened. The main culprit is Zelenski.

[@Alex-f3m4t]

The loser against EU/US conflict is EU. Ukraine is a puck and Russia is a stick. They can't win or loose.

[@GGF2k6]

NATO is the ultimate loser in this war 😂😂😂😂😂

[@tkrdg7885]

Apparently NATO has done far from enough to support Ukraine defending Russian invasion,

[@jeannettejordan7104]

If you are going to have a serious discussion about what the US might do, you should have some commentators who actually know the people involved rather than people who are just having an emotional breakdown because their favorite candidate didn’t win. Make a serious effort to understand American point of view. Pete has 2 bronze stars from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. He understands the fighting soldiers point of view, also Tulsi Gabbard, not just some desk jockey or liberal commentator.

[@bunyip7343]

Pete Hegseth understands the requirements of a platoon leader at O1-O2 level... it is a big stretch to think that this prepares someone to lead and control the entire US military, procurements and bureaucracy. Tulsi Gabbard has changed her view points so many times over the years it is hard to understand what she really believes. Her latest swing to Trump smells like a grab for fame and power.

[@thankqwerty]

Whenever I see the "you have to understand the people" I read that as an excuse for bad decision.

[@roninoscuro9087]

The American point of view is better understood than you think. The perpetual wars feed the U.S. arms industry. The U.S. arms exports constitute 42% of all arms exports in the world. By comparison, in 2023, Buick sold one car in Spain...one. Boeing continues to lose its market share to Airbus. No U.S. exports are as lucrative as the exports of weapons. Poland is buying a lot of American military hardware. But the Poles are also being from South Korea and that is frowned upon in the U.S. With the apparent supremacy comes the privilege of having the world's primary reserve currency. The Americans have an absolute right to stop leading and walk the path of isolation. However, they will not have their cake and be able to eat it too.

[@Abebe345]

@@bunyip7343 he's a Harvard and Princeton grad, twenty years of service, bronze stars. Ludicrous to think he doesn't understand the military inside out.

[@honoraryamerica5943]

These are the same people who praise the Paris Accord four years ago believing.climate change to be the greatest threat to humanity. Then when the bombs start dropping they tell America to take.on more debt to save them.

[@braxxian]

All Ukraine had to do was stay neutral and not cozy up to NATO.

[@bunyip7343]

All Russia had to do was leave their neighbour alone. Russia have lived with NATO allied countries on their border for years... no issues.

[@Shaft1367]

​@@bunyip7343as if America will agree to Russia forming a military or any sort of alliance with Mexico.

[@asdfghasdfgh5660]

I don’t think the people of Donetsk would agree

[@rosemariebredahl9519]

Their choice as a sovereign nation, not justification for invasion.

[@lisadsouza5061]

​@@rosemariebredahl9519that's nit how world works

[@aghassimkrtchyan6323]

Such a disappointing “debate “ … the way how the lady in pink looks at the guys who is trying to say something balanced is astonishing …

[@Shining237]

Ukraine should have never broken Minsk Agreements with Russia.

[@EthanLomas]

Yeah right 😂

[@michaelalaneme3911]

If there had been grown ups in Ukraine, this unnecessary and devastating war would not have come about. Unfortunate.

[@murrayeldred3563]

Could not listen to the comments of the Ukrainian woman as she was constantly SCREAMING....next time she should shout less so the viewers can listen to her comments.

[@orangebeetle1999]

Eastern European Soviet equipment was replaced with the PROMISE of new equipment! Why do you think Poland is buying from South Korea?! Because the US would ask for the money upfront, and you wait 5 to 10 years for the equipment.

[@guri699]

Alright so Russia is conceding forward and Ukraine is winning backwards. Being at disadvantage of having more power 10/1 Russia is losing more soldiers than Ukraine. Got it.

[@irimiyaibrahim9185]

Your guests, aside the male, are all bitter individuals and I regret viewing this edition of the debate. You and France 24 can do better in getting people with factual views

[@thefirst-yb8sj]

All has been given to Ukraine, yet it has failed woefully, F16, tanks, storm shadows, javelins and the rest. They all did nothing.

[@EthanLomas]

That’s why Muscovite kyvans like you are trolling this page? RuZZia is going down baby! 😆 😂 😆

[@namewithheldforprivacy7107]

ohh they did they resold it to make money according to US Intelligence

[@JoJo-ez3pv]

This will end with Russia keeping 20% of Ukraine and Ukraine not eligible for NATO membership for 20 years. Other than this, I dont see why Russia would consider stopping their advance.

[@jamesmiller2735]

How much longer can Ukraine last? Because the number of those who are condemned to life imprisonment in most Western countries is rapidly dwindling,and we are not sure that ordinary people in most of these countries will be willing to sacrifice themselves for Ukraine.So where does Ukraine go from here.

[@MrGatzby]

Why do all the people who aren’t Americans want to decide who’s going to be in President Trumps administration? Mind your own business and stick to worrying about your own country 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@JimCCorn]

Didn't the French throw down their guns and run away during WWII.

[@sparkyfromel]

The French Army lost 80.000 men and fought a dogged battle in Lille to allows the Brits to evacuate , while the US had to be dragged into the war , by Hitler himself

[@TheLivingTissue]

Every time I hear “full scale invasion” i just lose interest in what biased perspective they are just about to present

[@johnpurcell7525]

Soon as I heard French I signed off

[@she825]

😂😂😂😂

[@MarincaGheorghe]

Poopin is the "man" to listen.

[@milibibi2152]

But you are watching France 24. What did you expect?

[@ivanivanov-qi1el]

The panel lady criticizes Tulsi just of jealously 😂

[@BarunKumar-v6t]

Ukraine is loosing land and West is loosing face. Still West is not able to understand that more delay in peace will lead lead to more loosing of land and face!

[@AbdirashidAbdirahman-f3w]

It's easy let Zelensky sit and talk peace although I am sure that would have been more ideal before Feb 2022 when NATO rebuffed it,but even now peace deals can be made.and let's be honest this fight is between US and Russia,if they are sincere they can make peace,if tomorrow Zelensky is told you are not getting any more weapons he will be willing to come to the negotiation tables and listen, but until then it's just wasting time.

[@falcatafalcata1617]

The real problem is that the US has no money to give to Ukraine again. The annual interest rate of U.S. treasury bonds will be 20% of annual GDP in 2025 😮😮😮

[@sparkyfromel]

The debt repayment has just overtaken the Pentagon budget

[@pravinsarvade7608]

Russian has artillery advantage and Air advantage and still Russia loosing more soldiers and trust me bro 😂😂😂😂

[@JamesShabalala-e6n]

46 thousands Russian army this guy is a liar, impossible what about Ukrainian army?

[@honoraryamerica5943]

America.has $36 Trillion in debt. The incompetence has been Europe who promoted the Paris Accord when military production is most critical to the safety if humanity.

[@nicolasloiseau8971]

And you France ?? Waht are you doing ???

[@EthanLomas]

Omfg … that old man is unreal. Czechoslovakia? What planet is he on? And his condescending attitude

[@sik2765]

Close this channel no longer relevant

[@rolandconnor575]

Oh my, Anastasiya, you are very very misinformed about Tulsi Gabbard and Trump's vision of America First. If this is what you are telling your people over there, I can only hope you open your eyes and see other world views.

[@ahmedabakar5166]

Ukraine will never give up land to Putin or Trump... The EU must support Ukraine whatever the cost.

[@AceChina]

Get rid of Anastasia. She's being way too emotionally invested in this.

[@Abebe345]

The incompetence and ignorance of the lady in the studio about the candidates for office is what you would expect from a island nation broadcast. Haven't watched France 24 in a long time but this is surreal.

[@hemanshuambani9572]

😂😂😂😂lady is getting emotional and desperate

[@letsroll2001]

The French have been all talk. They do little to nothing to reinforce Ukraine. They need to increase their military budget to 4% of GDP and follow the example of Poland in defending Ukraine.

[@EricEs-f6o]

France spends more money than Poland on defence. Those 3.9 % are spread for a 2.5 year defence budget. In real terms Poland will be spending less than 2% every year. If you calculate what actually was delivered from contracts Poland spent very little. Pure creative accountancy.

[@Alex-f3m4t]

They just can't.

[@PatrickBeowolf-jt4nq]

As soon as the old dude said " the British said " I new this was a spoof comedy show. I'm an ish and I wouldn't believe anything the British say about Russia.

[@jimamar]

There are many cries in favour of Ukraine. We dont and cant loose

[@jamesmiller2735]

Russia is not going to move an inch when it comes to their interest,if nothing else is clear enough, by now, it is this simple fact.

[@patrikricci8423]

Jesus that lady is out of touch with reality...Maybe dont bring people to discuss this topic that have clear (and justified) bias towards this war.

[@ondiekibosire6174]

This panel is not professional and you need to bring new panelists when talking about Ukraine next time

[@SK-fi1tf]

New faces bring in better ideas and do a much better job than the usual people. No need for relevant experience. A good mindset is good enough to do a good job.

[@cybourne5910]

Refusing a war is incompetence and an act of weakness? The lady speaker has very few years to learn about life and humanity, please go home and shut up kid!

[@Frankline-v6p]

😂😂😂😂😂 I love you Donald Trump ❤❤❤ Cry baby cry 😂😂😂

[@yp77738yp77739]

I love the way Trump is trolling the establishment. RFK jr in charge of the FDA is hilarious.

[@peterwong4779]

Surrender + Cry,, Goodbye Biden + Zelensky + Macron + Olaf Scholz,, Peace time

[@lizardlizardliz]

Give Trump a chance. Before you judge

[@himiehonor1196]

There you have it, the Ukrainians mowed down 42,000 Russian soldiers in a month and are still losing ground 🤔🤣😅🤣😜 methinks this French officer is 🤥🤥🤥 through his froggies 🫨

[@underconstruction5532]

Whether you stop the war or not , Ukraine is losing 😂😂😂😂😂 This is an emotional breakdown 😅😅😅

[@Laomai24]

This lady Anastasiya Shapochkina , insinuating that the American lady has not studied Geopolitics. Well, you have Anastasiya, let’s assume . BUT, what have you learned, how to sent masses of innocent people to their deaths!? Or how keep fighting a lost war?

[@thefirst-yb8sj]

I understand the emotions of the lady in Ukraine, i won't want my country invaded by a neighbor, but it comes to a time where common sense should come in.

[@gumby2241]

she didn't know her place and just served to reveal how desperate their situation is

[@lizardlizardliz]

To our Ukrainen friends. America Love 💕 you. Don't listen 👂 to propaganda claims about what Trump will do or not do

[@shekusbangura2938]

Ukraine, can not survive without international support, so it's very much easy for Ukraine to accept any decisions.

[@donnyp2024]

Munich Security Council - MSC Come on F24 Im sitting here in California and know of these guys individuals but haven’t any idea who these women are and now realize why, haters both.

[@louaceveu1925]

People seem to forget that the Land that Russia is taken from Ukraine has 80% of the natural resources of the country. Lithium reserves (Value at 70 billions dollars), coal, and Specially rare earth materials. Although the situation for Ukraine at the battlefield it is very difficult, Russia knows that their loses are astronomical and unsustainable and that's why it is trying to take the most land as soon as possible. Russian economists are warning Putin that it the war continues as it is by the Summer of 2025 the Russian economy will completely collapse. By the way, the European Union with its PIB of 17 trillion dollars + the UK 4 trillion dollars PIB have a lot more financial resources than the Russian Federation slightly bigger than Italy's PIB economy. We can't also forget the 260 billion dollars that the European Union has in Russian frozen assets that it could be easily used to finance the war.

[@GodwinGodfather]

Theft

[@elangovan-w3x]

Ukraine has no option but negotiate peace with Russia.

[@Alex-f3m4t]

Ukraine has nothing to offer. West can. To start with returning money of Russian Central bank, which already spent. So West also has not much to offer.... And that's rather tragic.

[@MWENDA-vv5im]

Only Ukraine can be forced into a settlement. Russia will also settle is it is in the best interest of the Russian Federation.

[@anthonykelly4432]

you can tell this general is an idiot 46.000 russia loses in a moth , check real figures not even 6,000.

[@noahbrooksphoto]

Tulsi, and other like her just regurgitate the same basic lines over and over like they are smart, but they clearly have no background in any of this. It’s so cringy

[@smmozza]

… the silence of Nord Stream’s lambs …

[@chimwemwetembo6446]

Blinken is a perpetual lia 😂😂

[@Lana-xd7ey]

Blinken is Ukrainian or his parents is from there

[@smmozza]

… the host … nice haircut … is called “the state of german economy” style …

[@lasseplolsen]

Anastasiya, Nice way to start a new relationship. I am sure you'll do well from here on.

[@esense9602]

French politicians can send their money but I doubt they will do it.

[@danielkarlsson9326]

what i find intresting is that alot of people who have had important parts when it comes to NATO and are generally all critical of how NATO allies including USA has behaved so far regarding Ukraine Including Former Secretary Genral of NATO Stoltenberg and alot of high ranking Officers of G.B And Security Analists who has had correct assesments of the War in general are actually usually somewhat psoitive or atleast not negative regarding the new Administration. This means that there was a high probablity that there was issues with the current Administration of USA and Other Political Leaders in Europa that have had a possibility to put brakes on others regarding aid to Ukraine. Hopefully this new administration of USA will force more Western NATO nations to follow in the footsteps of us in the Northern and Baltic Area of NATO and hopefully a STOP of USA leaderships Blocking of other nations Sending Modern systems to Ukraine.

[@fulltank360]

The pink lady knows only 1% of whats going in , I wonder how these channels select these people ...Yeah the less they know the better I guess

[@8739paulstep7]

I would think russia would know how much personal they have lost over the british knowing 😂

[@alishastark-s9s]

🎉🎉 neutral ,belt initiatives ,NATO designed to improve defence ,time parameters Territories ,Border Camps , Soldiers Safety , Solidarity

[@jasonong3906]

Surrender

[@hemanshuambani9572]

Ukraine😂😂😂😂leeching off money from other countries thinking they can destroy russia

[@BrandyHeng007]

Ukraine developing Nuclear Bomb 😅

[@murrayeldred3563]

Listen to Catherine + the General.

[@renevargas8616]

Russia is an aggresor but 1sra3l is not for ukranians

[@smmozza]

… anastasyia … as clever as she looks …

[@RandolphLogie-ct9ng]

Big up z ❤

[@thefirst-yb8sj]

From the start without listening, I can swear this is a dumb debate with only one view point, no one is going to challenge anything. Where I come from, we call this propaganda, opinion shappening and not broadening the horizon of your viewers to decide the truth for themselves. If this debate turns out to be a for and against with two different viewpoints, I'll tender an unreserved apology.

[@annparkin4910]

😢

[@daikucoffee5316]

I love Ukraine so much.

[@dineshlimbu258]

Ukrine is fucked !!! I just saved your 40 minutes 😅😅

[@waynegore5291]

Ukraine is winning and winning " bigly".

[@henryterranauta9100]

🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺Ukraine has never been an🇷🇺🇷🇺independent country🇷🇺🇷🇺and ever it will be🇷🇺🇷🇺

[@rosemariebredahl9519]

💔🇺🇲😔 ... 💙💛🙏

[@AniKayode]

Suddenly Ukraine is no longer winning 🫠

[@alishastark-s9s]

🎉🎉 neutral ,belt initiatives ,NATO designed to improve defence ,time parameters Territories ,Border Camps , Soldiers Safety , Solidarity