What the Hell is The Mandela Catalogue?

[@MetaSynForYourSoul]

My boy is big enough to get sponsors!? Pagan, I'm truly proud of you! I've legit been here since the beginning and I've gotta say this is totally cool to see you get a sponsorship! You da man! Keep going, dog!

[@vajbujem6698]

So a couple conclusions I've made: - Gabriel is Lucifer (Proof: The Bible quote in CC in Exhibition) - The house in Exhibition and Vol 2 is Cesar's house. - Adam might be the stolen kid from Intruder Alert. When he asks the Intruder what it is, it responds with "You don't remember me" (CC again) and one of the frames flashing is the hanged mother. Here we can theorize that Adam lost his mother. (The 'her' mentioned by Jonah) - Mark plays a bigger role here and we will find out why. - Alex is now 'canon' in this universe and could have something to do with Mark, since they look exactly the same. - "Daddy didn't tuck me in and there's a man in the closet" has a deeper meaning since in both Exhibition and Vol 2, we see an alternate opening the closet door in Cesar's house. - The TV plays Somewhere Over The Rainbow which probably means something too. - The TV Intruder whispers just like 'Gabriel', which implies him to be Satan/Lucifer. - The MAD video is straight bullshit pulled by an alternate. There's a reason why Alex/Mark voiced it. Also "3% prove the possibility to REVERSE THE DELUSION". The same thing the Angel says to Mary. I believe that 'an intruder' in Mark's old home is actually one of those in the 3 percent. This is where cults come in. Alternates forming cults after they've integrated themselves into society. Alex also mentioned that he's surprised how nobody thought of the role of cults in this universe. -Also, seems to me like the Alternate business started with Noah. Here's where the Angel first mentions a mysterious creature that will tell Noah his last message (Noah goes MAD, dies and gets swapped by a fake Noah, starting the chain). - The parts where we witness the thoughts and claims of these ppl in real time are also stunts pulled by Alternates since there's no way we would be able to listen in on them and witness their conversations that happen off-camera. - If Satan truly is to blame for this mess (which would make MUCH more sense than aliens or whatever), we should be aware that everything we see and hear is his choice. He chooses what we know and what clues we get (Just like Habit controlled which uploads we see from the EverymanHybrid crew).

[@aburisnestoris]

Hi, I also have a theory about Cesar's house. When the government issued the Analog Television destruction order, Cesar didn't destroy his, it was simply just put in the basement so that would explain how the alternate in Vol 1 got in Cesar's house. It would also explain how the TV was in the basement in Vol 2 as well. I'm also going to theorise that Mark felt unsafe about going to Cesar's house because of that TV he had in the basement Edit: Thx for the likes

[@iverjosjq8540]

You're awesome

[@aburisnestoris]

Also I think you got it wrong with Alex's mother. I think that he lost his baby sister (the child taken from the crib by the alternate in the TV) So I think he started looking for the same alternate that caused his mother to commit suicide and for his little sister to be taken for him. I am guessing that is why he got so pissed off Jonah, no one not even your own friend should cross that line. That would also mean that maybe alternates raise kids that they kidnap and... Idk what they do to them

[@supergabriel2782]

hey im NOT satan totally not taking that outta cotext

[@Sirnextinline]

Go watch the game theory about it bro I think you’ll find some answers to yr theory

[@Ravuun]

When you skipped through the first parts of Vol. 1, you missed that Type 2: Detectable, is missing from Vol. 1--it goes from Type 1 to Type 3. This shows how the alternates can influence existing videos on the channel.

[@LasagaMan]

Yeah, but that only exists withn the volumes, as the original uploads should be intact if they're accessible.

[@shadowbrain4814]

The "ask not reader" passage is from Dante's Inferno when Dante saw Satan in the lowest circle of Hell

[@Vxldez.]

the police actually choose not to help alternate encounters themselves instead of the government or alternates manipulating the tape because they know they can’t help and will highly likely be harmed themselves if they interfere

[@brazenbob2752]

Hold up, theory moment: What if the angel posing as Gabriel was Gabriel’s alternate, the red text was the alternate talking after he deceived the shepherds, and the white text was the real Gabriel after he had been swindled/offed by the alternate? Just a thought, but that might be consistent with everything.

[@adenperkins9719]

That was my thought process too, after Noah got ganked he was chained up in the desert and left to die (or that’s just narrative but same same)

[@LordAini]

A sponsor? Hell yeah my dude, I am so happy to see this channel grow, and long form content of this kind is so hard to monetise, I am super glad for you!

[@danieltchernov7745]

good meme

[@frostycane5134]

So here is something interesting in the “identifying different alternative “ video. In the Mandela catalog volume version of the video changed. The scene where it shows the type 2 detectable Is removed. So that means we are viewing an alternate version of that video ( or Alex removed it for some reason and it’s not lore significant)

[@kiy9470]

Since alternates can alter videos maybe they don't want us to know what the detectable types are, they are hiding it from us

[@archmagosbelisariuscawl1192]

Love your content mate. I died laughing at the sudden “that detective pussied out”

[@alexbenavidez4500]

This legitimately did not feel over an hour wrong. Maybe I skipped ahead accidentally and didn't notice But I was enjoying the video and it had my attention the whole time, so time just flew by. Great take on the Mandela catalogue as well, and it's nice to see other or more personal interpretations of the series Explained really well and is criminally underrated right now, so hopefully the numbers on this video will really start going up, but it's been only two hours since upload

[@aydinmakesthings]

This, FNaF VHS, and Walten Files are some of the scariest shit I've ever seen. Most modern horror movies can't compare in horror. I know a lot of people find Analog Horror over used, but that's just because it's so good! It can be used to tell absolutely horrific tales. I can't wait to see how the story goes from here!

[@A_Stereotypical_Heretic]

The Walten files are a joke. They don't compare to Gemini or local 58

[@aydinmakesthings]

@@A_Stereotypical_Heretic That's your opinion, I find the Walten Files to be a really great story. But that's what I think.

[@itsJieskies]

@@aydinmakesthings no seriously Martin does a great job in the series, I can't wait for Walten files 4 honestly

[@peachdoesart7175]

8:56 WHY DID I DIE LAUGHING

[@alexbenavidez4500]

That's all folks

[@kirbbaebi]

Love how the comments are excited about the sponsor! Typically every comment complains on other videos, but glad to see the community here is all for it.

[@kittervision]

Right this is my first visit here but the excitement about the sponsors makes me think something special is here and ok just gonna go ahead and subscribe. This is the first I've heard of this Mandela chronicle I'm not finding it very palatable however... Who creates this stuff? Really unnerving to say the least.

[@Glacidon]

Honestly? Its just a crossover fanfiction between Among Us and The Bible.

[@nman551]

No it isn’t

[@aydinmakesthings]

Bruh about to get murder by MC fans lol

[@MrFluffyWolf]

@Kraken Alternates are sussy imposters. Also OP is joking.

[@jj_see_film]

Sossy backee

[@toast6711]

Lol

[@jtotheroc]

Also, if you're going to someones house to do an investigation, why wouldn't you turn on every single light in the house?? In reality, it's probably just Alex walking around his house for twenty minutes with the lights off.

[@nostrangertosterling]

Babe wake up new Pagan Valley video just dropped.

[@ziongamer6905]

Seeing first sponsor is genuinely such a happy moment for the channels I love You genuinely make me think of an up and coming NightMind

[@pipbois1768]

I have to say its been a treat watching your channel grow and improve so quickly, keep up the good work.

[@MMumbles]

I know it's everywhere now, but I've been waiting on *your* take on the Mandela Catalogues for so long!!

[@ourdoghalo5769]

The Mandela catalogue is amazing and I just love it. Truly one of the best analogue horror series out there.

[@LeadMetal82]

I'm surprised a lot of people missed a detail in volume 1. The type 2 in the T.H.I.N.K principle is actually removed from the video.

[@adelynnroces8782]

Yay!! I was hoping you would cover mandela catalogue. love your work dude keep it up

[@bigswag3383]

me and my girlfriend sat and watched your entire gemini home entertainment series and i loved it! keep up the good work!

[@michaellatner975]

1 thing to say, in catalogue 2, you can tell that hes talking to an alternate girl from his comment on coming "tonight". Alternates dont fully understand the language of humans and thought he was saying two nights

[@mariamodesto676]

Hi Pagan, how are you? I just want to say that i love your videos, you're doing amazing and I'm so pround of you! Everyone can see that you're working hard in these videos and this is awesome, keep up the hard work! Kisses from Brazil, we love youuuu! 💚💛💙

[@aiqdelicia]

I'm Brazilian too! :D

[@dissentient1]

It’s a good day when the upload hits.

[@messymaker4554]

a sponsor?!?! great job dude i love to watch this channel grow. keep it up dude!

[@bradleycontreras4736]

This would make for a scary fucking movie! I swear, id gladly pay to watch it! And Pagan should be one of the producers because of how well he breaks down these types of series! 🎥

[@larkefedifero]

Speaking of alternates / replacements, y' know what's also fun aside from "The Mandela Catalogue?" The opening scene from "The Twilight Zone: The Movie!" I love it when Dan Akroyd does that thing with his face, 'cause it's a REAL surprise, and who doesn't love a good surprise every now and then? *Right?!?!* 😲

[@souptime8420]

Mandela Catalogue appeared out of nowhere, yet it's still MILES better than whatever the fuck is hollywood making

[@panqueque445]

40:54 Jesus Christ that knocking sound effect always gets me

[@BigChumby]

Pagan valley continues to put out banger after banger. Analog horror forever!

[@aruce9]

Come to Mandela county we’ve got: Angles Crackheads ??? Distraught at the sight of their missing child Ghost hunters Zzz (tired alternates) Conspiracy theories And I A M I N S I D E Y O U R W A L L S

[@A_Stereotypical_Heretic]

You got any right angles?

[@oh_no....]

@@A_Stereotypical_Heretic Hopefully

[@theemeraldking3251]

Dude my life needs to be in danger with cops who don't help me 24/7 or I'm not going there

[@cathare4909]

That alternate at the door saying "i have a gift for you" etc is literally the scariest thing I've ever seen in my life. Mandela got me into binging tons of analog horror and nothing has ever come close to this day.

[@talusimp7737]

this channel is ridiculously underrated. the quality and quantity delivered is worthy of millions.

[@standardofexcellence]

I reccomend the why files as well, the more entertained while educated and vice versa the better

[@MondoC]

Literally woke up and wished for another video today that’s crazy😂

[@jvv80085]

I really love your videos! I always out them on when studying or drawing!

[@endless_sands]

Alternate scream at 21:29 ? First time im noticing that after like 3 watches edit: during the camera part there are quite a few strange noises which i didn't catch

[@Deth_Kitty]

I believe Ceasar represents Julius Cesar. With the alternate version of his mother representing Brutus. Of course that's just a theory.

[@A_Stereotypical_Heretic]

Well time means nothing in this universe so maybe yeah

[@GentlemanEggy]

Now this is going to be a good watch for today

[@thevonshallow]

just so you know the text after the angels jumpscare is an actual reciting of the divine comedy specifically dantes inferno, its reffering to dante meeting the devil and how he felt

[@felixferguson4331]

This did not feel as if it was an hour, it felt shorter almost. Well, time flies when you’re having fun

[@Left-sh1db]

This crazy you got a sponsor. My baby all grown up

[@FullMoonOctober]

Cesar could be considered a biblical name if you cheat a little bit, because even though he's not a featured character in the New Testament, there is more than one reference to the ruling Cesar and his influence on events. So it all still lines up.

[@pringlesmingles9531]

Can you explain The Macabre Experiment series? Its so underrated

[@archdiangelo7930]

I've been waiting for this day for YEARS >:D

[@idkmanokaylv]

Whenever Gabriel does the smiling thing. He goes bald.

[@gypsydanger0496]

Heartaches will forever be ruined for me

[@jtotheroc]

Pagan can you please keep an eye on the source videos audio levels in the future??? I can barely hear Jonah and Adam talking to one another, but I can hear you just fine.

[@jamesmmcgill]

Man, Alex Kansas just uploaded a finale to the monument mythos titled "ALCATRAZAPOCALYPSE". You should check it out.

[@freddyandfoxy7526]

O was waiting for this.

[@snowqueen_8958]

The Mandela catalogue.....it's creepy and unsettling.....

[@doulest]

turn up da volume! i have my pc, youtube, and browser at full volume and i cant hear you over a whisper!

[@Tacolul]

This channel is going somewhere for sure, it has to

[@lovelydreamingtime9563]

I hate that I can immediately tell that the cartoon clip of the angel telling Mary is from The Beginner's Bible cartoon

[@oh3144]

Awesome video

[@Pokkenjake2021]

Honestly, I've heard about these doppelganger especially ones that's from maledela catalog. And to be honest with you... they're very creepy that it'll be in my nightmares

[@danette8855]

This man needs to be more popular..

[@sunnyquinn3888]

6:41 3-year-old me at the side of my mom's bed at 5:00 am ready for breakfast.

[@jug_inspector]

You say tonight programming like I’m watching this at night. You best believe I’m watching this while orbiting the sun so it’s always day

[@krisi90]

Underrated video ngl

[@SimonPetrikov12]

It's always interesting hearing another's take on this series. You got a few things wrong (the intruder is not an alternate, for example), and I disagreed with a few of your takes but it was still fun to listen to. I hope this series only gets better.

[@ardabaki4597]

oh so thats where the intruder meme came from

[@standardofexcellence]

Wasn't sure at first this was fictional until mandella county which i wouldn't think would be a subtle nod without nefarious intent. Good title, story reminds me of twin peaks the evil doppleganger/other universe idea

[@syrup2489]

Who else is hiding in the comments waiting for Pagan to speak again?…. Just me :(

[@Argyle117]

I was not ready for this to be so eerily unnerving and creepy, and did not like any of the feelings it gave, good video all in all, maybe work on audio balancing cause it’s really difficult to hear some things, then your voice comes booming over everything. Even though it’s a series of videos with just some photo shopped images I was completely on edge the whole time.

[@NuwandaLunaDragon]

36:06 really? I loved they rough image

[@socriabbas454]

I have a theory is to why L4D2 came year later after L4D1. Think L4D1 was supposed to be their demo and see if this FPS shooeter game would actually work and when it did after getting positive reviews from Valves player base, thats when they decided to release the whole game which is L4D2. You can see L4D1 was just a marketing campaign for L4D2

[@junewindsor8764]

Hell yeah man. Get that coin, I'll endure it.

[@quarkmolotov1049]

I think the police are told to ignore alternate encounters to preserve their safety and minimize spread of mad

[@cysipy]

about time u do this one, knew it was coming up heh

[@geblordofchaos2965]

The Mandela catalogue truly is terrifying, man, it's like deepnest but way worse! Someone should make a mod of the Mandela catalogue in HK..... Hmmm.....

[@goldengamer-b2z]

Dang a new record

[@zeakthetinysoviet3702]

22:53 Good lord, it's James Charles

[@gabrielregli1222]

it's not what they see, it's what they hear

[@TeethSkylark]

I don't think they have time powers. I think the story is told non-linearly

[@blatztheruler]

clicks on a scary video hears the youtube answer questions music😏

[@dinosauce9714]

ayy congrats on the sponsor my guy

[@Arcee720]

Can you do an analysis video on Interface by umami, Pagan Valley?

[@OGEdgyUsername]

Very nice

[@redbone9068]

nice video bro

[@yvngtyrant2549]

What's the song in the beginning? I know it's a cover of Don't Fear the Reaper but by who?

[@Uncle-Jay]

Also, I understand the reason why they did it, but having censored evidence from the police is kind of weak. For me the whole fear the unknown isn't a thing. Just having a big ol' black censor bar on the screen does nothing for me. Either figure out a way to show it that doesn't violate KZbin's standards or re-write it to something else that can be seen.

[@fatetheanimator9580]

i wonder if mandela has anything to do with the Mandela Effect.

[@A_Stereotypical_Heretic]

Obviously. It's an alternate universe. Alternate history etc

[@tripz.kobito7216]

When I hear that dude say “ I’m not…Im not” I almost shat myself I thought he was an alternate 😂

[@DummysGirl97]

The one thing that bothers me a Lil is that I've seen clips of Alex's livestreams where he refers to the angel explicitly as "Gabriel" so either Gabriel is the Satan in this universe, or an alternate of Gabriel took his name and place.

[@bigpapi6688]

It’s obviously an alternate of Gabriel. That’s like a day one known fact.

[@iverjosjq8540]

Hell yeah boy, sponsors

[@starxolotl]

Honestly, as much as the alternates are probably caused by the devil himself, I think it would be interesting if Angel, perhaps Gabriel, actually overthrew heaven and took over the position of god or managed to learn the power of creation and is using the alternates to help hone his skills. It would explain why the alternates are deformed and messed up, missing faces and having an emphasis on their eyes (the eye emphasis helps me to think that it could be an angel’s work, due to the fact that “biblically accurate” angels are eyes on wheels with wings. Lots of eyes, and a body that we perceive as odd). Or perhaps Gabriel isn’t perfecting his own creations, but is utilizing other angels to overthrow heaven.

[@KinotheHedgehog]

A good theory, but it's revealed that Satan killed Gabriel and disguised himself to replace him.

[@nuxd9821]

good video :D you can talk about the user nitroxid5 from the sims 4 its a odd and interesting arg

[@Dry983]

what song did he use for the opening its familiar

[@Imsleepeebruh]

Trade proposal. You provide Mandela catalogue I subscribe to you.

[@user-mn7dk2mt8j]

Together.

[@A_Stereotypical_Heretic]

So in their universe they're being overtaken by cartoon characters?

[@blatztheruler]

mandela invasion is now cannon bte it’s just a simulation of how it would be if alternates are a tbing

[@door5443]

the Angel Gabriel is literally Satan in this timeline

[@Uncle-Jay]

How do we know they aren't actually who they claim to be? They are completely different entities than us. Classic Angels look horrifying.

[@isfj8w741]

yeah its definitly the altern8 of marks friend for some reason i just thought that the voice just sounded waaayy too calm when he /it claimed that his mom was rushed to the hospital like i cant help but think if somebody close to you just got attacked i should have at least hear it getting concerned/panick like dud you claimed you were going to the er and your mom got hurt but wow you sounded cold as hell which is a huge red flag (srry for bad eng)

[@fatetheanimator9580]

19:58 :trollge:

[@bruh-oy3bl]

2:39 🤨

[@gaminggranny1541]

Me at 3am: Oh my god it's slenderman! the nth 3rd type alternate that heard this joke when they attempted a break in: 15:29

[@bootleg_24]

and i thought the walten files were scary as good as it is, it aint got nothing on this