What would you be reborn/reincarnated as?

[@goodearth5584]

The one great master who doesn't mince words and comes to the point straight. Sri Ramana Maharshi has made the path of spirituality quite simple and that has given confidence and hope for the spiritual aspirants

[@mrsrajendranrajendran4712]

No investigation, no arguement. with blindfolded we accept Sri Ramana magarishi is the purest of all pure rishies.

[@shusmitakumari2113]

Body dies but soul never dies .Ramana Maharshi is right. When we realize who we are there are no questions. Our difficulty is we understand the fact touching the surface. When we go deeper, there is none to say I or me. All are energy and vibrations. I experienced this truth once. But again in to the same world and same confusion. It happened accidentally when I was in deep meditation. When the meditation was over it was like a dream. I was searching where I am and where is my body. We are in illusion. That's why we can't understand the fact correctly. It will take time time for us because we are not realized people. Some time it happens to people through meditation as an accident.

[@dasakoota]

You are correct. Without the guidance of a TRUE guru normal people should not meditate. It's quite dangerous. We can do bhakti yoga and karma yoga.

[@geethanair3659]

Very profound wisdom,that calls for deep inquiry.🙏🙏🙏

[@dasakoota]

@@halcyon2864 karma yoga teaches us to do only karma's without expecting the results. Karma means action. Great scientist Newton's third law of motion is nothing but jaisi karni vaisi bharni. i.e. as you sow so you reap. Just think why Lord Krishna had said not to expect the results. To me it seems that we must expect good results if we do good actions and vice versa. But actually what happens is the bad result we get even after doing good action is because of our prarabda. The bad actions of our previous birth bring bad results in this birth. In this process our good action done by us will yield us good results may be in near future. We must keep on doing good karmas only whose good results we expect in near future or far future. This is karma yoga.

[@dasakoota]

@@halcyon2864 In bhakti yoga, we do bhakti. You might have noticed that the younger generation falls in love with the marvel and DC comics heroes, Ash katchem of Pokemon series, etc etc. But why? Our human minds need a support to lean with and evolve. Why not our own Hanuman ji, Krishna or Shiva? Instead of comical heroes? To know about these people, one should cultivate the habit of reading. That too, the originals or the summaries of very great acharyas of the past.

[@dasakoota]

@@halcyon2864 Meditation comes under Ashtanga yoga which was taught by Lord Shiva to goddess Parvati to bring back her memory so that she could slay the asuras. If a person wants to meditate, he or she should follow other seven angas also. To be continued

[@shashanks6240]

There should not be any confusion here. Reincarnation is true as long as the Self identifies with the body or mind or ego or anything other than Brahman. But from the ultimate standpoint, where Ramana Maharshi was, rather is, situated, only Brahman/ Atman/The Real Self of the nature of Existence-Consciousness-Bliss (Sat-Chit-Ananda or Sacchidananda) is The Truth. Everything else, including this world, body, mind etc are appearances in that Brahman. To him (like Maharshi) who has really realised and experienced this ultimate Truth (not merely intellectually or theoretically), reincarnation is meaningless and the world is Mithya- neither real, nor unreal. But from the point of view of one who has not reached that exalted state (like most of us), reincarnation is indeed true. You can watch lectures of Swami Sarvapriyananda of Vedanta New York Centre for more clarity.

[@snakeeye4150]

Beware when you say "reincarnation is indeed true". True has to be absolute otherwise it's not true, it's just a temporary lie. Have you clearly remembered memories of being in different bodies before this one? If yes, then it's temporarily true, but not absolutely true. Best not to say it is true, otherwise the topic of reincarnation winds itself into so much unnecessary imagination. Do sadhana, go deeper, don't conclude, don't identify as a non-realized being.

[@indianmilitary]

SHASHANK S "Everything else, including this world, body, mind etc are appearances in that Brahman" Some followers of Advaitha wrongly interpret Maya as the illusion through which Brahman falsely appears as the universe. Maya is another name for Shakthi. Maya is absolutely real and it is the "creative" shakthi of Brahman (or athman). So, the material realm is also very real In the same way Mithya does NOT mean false either. Mithya means temporary world or contingent world. eg Tasks in your office may be temporary but they do not mean false. So you must finish them. In the same way, the subject (you) and the object (external world) split may be temporary but it does not mean there is no subject or object.

[@cactusray3368]

Well said!

[@vicsp5765]

For all those who are commenting here that rebirth is true, you're missing the point of Ramana. He says the Self is beyond birth and death. It's the ego that feels a sense of control, a sense of drama that's inherent in the idea of rebirth. It's ignorant to think that rebirth can be reward or punishment based on current birth. Whether rebirth is true or not, the wise thing to do is live the current life with full presence.

[@indianmilitary]

Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and create Karma or cause and effect and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that. Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma since it is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen (including reincarnation cycle). This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus and meditation).. Birth/death duality cycle continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate.

[@ashasingh6923]

👍🙏

[@sentientpower]

Thanks for sharing 🙏🏽 It is all the small self which wants to know the answers to these questions, because it fears deeply, the end of its existence. After years of identification with the small self, it is time to correct that error.

[@dasakoota]

FYI, I would like to say that Sri Ramana maharishi had no gurus, he , without any initialization process went into a cave in Tiruvannamalai as a very small kid , there he meditated for about twelve or more years and attained realisation. One should beware of fake and fraudulent gurus of kaliyuga.

[@indianmilitary]

@@dasakoota it also means one does not need a guru to experience SHABTHA BRAHMAN unless one is too lazy to understand and practice different techniques to expand the consciousness. Even of one gets so called "initiation or Diksha" from a guru which can act as a catalyst, one has to put their own efforts and it is neither practical for the disciple nor the guru to be in constant touch with each other. So, stop giving advice that one should not do meditation without a guru. Understand that Karma yoga, Jnana yoga and even mantra based temple tradition are also meditation pathways not just some rigid pose with eyes closed.

[@8956deep]

@@indianmilitary guru is needed he is a avatar purusha his guru is lord arunachala siva if u dont have any guru u can pray to mahadev or any god as ur guru

[@indianmilitary]

@@8956deep You can't call gurus as avatars. Because they all are karmic births or reincarnations. Avatars (Rama, Krishna and others) had non karmic births or incarnations.. Gurus are only for initiation or Diksha for expanding consciousness state or samadhi (for the purpose of removal of past karma) which is not compulsory even though acts as a catalyst. Many people have experienced samadhi without initiation from gurus. eg Ramana Maharishi.

[@8956deep]

@@indianmilitary subramanya swami took three avatars his amsa is ramana final one i learned from real sidhas not from fake gurus

[@Avendesora322]

I understand the method he is using in his teachings. Reincarnation does exist however. Many spiritual awakened people have became aware of their past incarnations, that is just one proof of it.

[@sentientpower]

You’re right, but the Enlightened one is no longer “born“ again after realisation.

[@sathsojourns]

@@sentientpower Even WE arenn't even 'born'. It is our false identification with body and mind that makes us believe so. EG: a birthday isn't the day of your birth, but the day you first inhabited a body and identified with it. All Saints show universal unity for a reason, which is also what Sri Ramana Maharshi taught.

[@true1evanique]

The point is, remembering past lives has to do with memory in the illusion of time and space of a false identity in an illusionary world. It is the dream, but not the dreamer.

[@snakeeye4150]

See, when you say "reincarnation does exist however", how do you define "exist"? That which "exists" means that which you can perceive, and that which you can perceive belongs to the realm of motion, and all motion is temporarily allowed to "exist" by the stillness out of which it springs. So, what "exists" is the motions of the mind perceived by the mind itself, while you remain as the watcher. But the reincarnations that your rational mind wants to prove so badly, are none other than memories of motions, of ideas. And all motion, all ideas, are temporary. They are born out of stillness, are maintained by stillness, and are destroyed back into stillness, by stillness. As long as you are identified with your temporary bodily wave motions and mental wave motions, you will keep believing that you are reincarnating, until you free yourself from the falseness of it.

[@SumiOccult]

Absolutely. Reincarnation is real. Now, I really wonder whether he was really an enlightened soul??!!

[@saththiyambharathiyan8175]

Ramana maharishi did not mean there is no rebirth.... Ramana Maharsishi said as long as ignorance there will be rebirth.....

[@indianmilitary]

YES.,

[@a6hiji7]

He said there is no rebirth. Birth itself is an illusion (a concept in the mind). He also often said that there is no realization, everyone is already realized!

[@valdirbergamobergamo5396]

It was really brilliant. A mental questioner and a soul/heart answerer. The dialogue could have finished at the first question, but the man insisted: there is reincarnation. It is as Arjuna and Krshna: everytime Arjuna spoke about kingdoms, family, richnesses... And Krishna speaking about Brahman everytime. Congratulations, this blessed dialogue could help the World, to put an end to mountains of miseries. May that Brahman bless you with Truth everytime, thanks a lot !

[@dasakoota]

Very well said!

[@indianmilitary]

Vaidir If that was the case why would Krishna "enlightened" Arjuna to kill his relatives, gurus etc? Point is both Jnana yoga and Karma yoga are important. Within the material realm, dharma has to be sustained. Those who violate dharma create Karma or cause and effect and reincarnation. Avatar Krishna was also killed in the end by a stray arrow of a hunter (Vali's reincarnation)? Because Rama was cursed by the pious wife of Vali, Thara for killing her husband by hiding behind a tree in an "adharmic" manner. Point is, even avatars (non karmic births) cannot escape law of karma or cause and effect. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and create Karma or cause and effect and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that. During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate. Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen (including reincarnation cycle). This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus and meditation).. Birth/death duality cycle continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13)

[@dasakoota]

Shri Ramana maharishi showed the path of gyanayoga, the most difficult path for a normal person to follow. People gathered could see a ball of bright light came out of his body when he left his mortal body.

[@sentientpower]

I don’t think it’s necessarily difficult. I feel understanding this path is Grace. All other paths are valid and those too are Grace, albeit a longer route. Different flavours for different body-minds 🙏🏽

[@dasakoota]

Thank you for your information.

[@dasakoota]

@@halcyon2864 there are different paths such as karma yoga, bhakti yoga,gyana yoga, rajayoga, kriya yoga etc. The easiest, but the most reliable path is bhakti yoga. I don't know about rajayoga. Meditation comes under gyanayoga. It needs a TRUE guru for the guidance of the seekers.

[@cosmictruth3600]

So what is ramana rishi saying ?? Does he mean there is no concept of birth , rebirth, soul etc ? All these things are just coincidence and will cease to exist after death ?? Then it would mean there is no karma also cuz we can freely do whatever we want cuz there is no rebirth or soul at all..we all will cease to exist after death ...so why to worry about karmas ??

[@cosmictruth3600]

@@halcyon2864 atman is the soul ...the other layers encapsuling the soul are impermanent that's what all the others so called God men/ self reliazed ppl/ philosophers say .. how come self is different from atman ( the soul ) which is said to be unborn and has no end ...and yeah my name is cosmic truth ...that's why I am questioning this ...it's simple.. so difficult to understand ??

[@ericclaey2243]

*"It is appointed for men to die once, but after this the judgment."* -Hebrews 9:27

[@quinto190]

Very well made video! The music really supports the self inquiry that's necessary to understand what he said.

[@MindfulSoul]

Thank you for engaging! 🙏

[@TheDeepening718]

People used to come to him and say, "sir, what was I in a past life?" as if that question even mattered.

[@ravish05]

Simply superb. It is so difficult to grasp yet it is the closest to us all.

[@indrani8378]

Deeper than the deepest knowledge 🙏🙏🙏

[@geetikasharma968]

Sri Ramana says that Reincarnation exists only so long as there is ignorance. It is clear from this comment that with the physical death, ignorance of the mind does not end and so reincarnation exists so long as ego or the ignorant mind, which is the subtle body and survives the physical death, exists. Once the veil of ignorance is removed, it is known that really there is no reincarnation because the one which reincarnates that is the ego dies and the mind finally becomes or rather it realizes that it is established in Self.

[@indianmilitary]

Yes and attachment with everything, violation of dharma (or the natural law) and those who assume that they are the doer due to false identification with thoughts and body create Karma or cause and effect or vasanas or memories and reincarnation (birth/death duality cycle). There are different types of Vasanas or memories. Elemental Memory atomic Memory evolutionary Memory Karmic Memory and Conscious memory unconscious memory Articulate memory inarticulate memory etc There are different tools and techniques in the form of yoga, tantra and temple tradition to remove the Vasanas to put an end to reincarnation cycle.

[@lyjuslyjus2201]

I’m not concerned about my rebirth . My son passed away recently. He was just 24 , a nice human being . Will he be reincarnated ? I feel so lost ….

[@MindfulSoul]

Dear @Lyjus Lyjus Sorry to hear about your loss. Should be heartbreaking to lose children at such a young age. We do not know about reincarnation, but perhaps you can reflect on how you can celebrate the times he was alive. The feeling of loss comes from the ego, and it is a natural feeling when we find ourselves in a strange, unfamiliar place. What would be good for your soul is to completely process this feeling and express it in whatever ways you find therapeutic. For some people this might be journaling, for others it would be going on a yatra and dissolving the ashes in holy water, or it might be even in a creative pursuit like writing a story or poem or bodily movement. These help to come to terms with the loss and bring about the acceptance which is important for your soul to achieve its purpose. Wishing you the strength and self-love through this dark time.

[@TheSoteriologist]

Excellent.

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

To get success start meditation satsang laughing dancing singing walking fasting and music are best medicine's of the world.

[@serenitysurfersparadise825]

Thought is the physical self. As long as you think, then your body is at work. Only when u go beyond the self can you know. But we limit ourselves to this physical body by constantly questioning and seeking answers. When you go beyond there is no question not answer but only the true pure self untouched by body and thought. These are however are my words from the teaching of his holiness Ramana Maharshi. Who has been a friend in helping me know who I am.

[@siswawidyatmoko6060]

Feels like studying quantum physics after long time study Newtonian physics

[@indianmilitary]

Albert Einstein ``Whenever I read Bhagavad Gita, everything else seems superfluous. I've made Vedas as the guide for the formation of my theories and scientific investigation" Werner Heisenberg _ (One of the pioneers in the field of quantum mechanics) - "Quantum ideas which seemed so crazy made sense only after reading hindu/vedic metaphysics" ERWIN SCHRODINGER (ONE OF THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.

[@anicho3605]

Jai Bhagawan.. I seek refugee in thee .. You are the Truth everything else is illusion

[@shyaaammeneen63]

Nice video but adds to the confusion on reincarnation. What about karma? There are questions like "Why do bad things happen to good people? Why is someone born physically handicapped? Why does a spiritual person die suddenly in an accident? etc. Unanswered questions of life. Just enjoy the present.

[@true1evanique]

I have learned that "karma" simple means, "action". Nothing more, nothing less. It has used as a tool to make one have guilt of their actions, but it is to one's intention if one will experience the action of one's creation. As far as bad things happening to people, I feel that it's spiritual manipulation.

[@shyaaammeneen63]

@@true1evanique True. Relax your mind. Karma is not punishment but it disciplines us and prevents us from comitting mistakes. Daily meditation, asking for forgiveness, divine grace and prayer clears karma but only if we do not repeat the bad actions again and again. Prayers and best wishes. Counsellor.

[@srivanir7434]

Vry true and confusion...all bad things and sad all happening for good ppls only...cheating ppls hurting someone life dey living vry happily as dey wish...but true with good heart ppls not living for long time...

[@shyaaammeneen63]

@@srivanir7434 Very true but sooner or later the bad people will have to pay a heavy price and punishment for their bad karma. Good times will come for good people. I have experienced this but we will have to pass God's test with faith and s urrender.

[@indianmilitary]

@@shyaaammeneen63 It is very simple. Ramana Maharishi's message was lost in translation. If there was no Karma then Ramana Maharishi wouldn't have gone through a deadly disease in the end. HIs Prarabtha karma was to go through whatever he went through. Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen (including reincarnation cycle). Birth/death duality continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and create Karma or cause and effect and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that.

[@gireeshneroth7127]

You don't call it reincarnation of earth when the new day breaks after the previous one after the night passes off.

[@indianmilitary]

gireesh neroth But Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and create Karma or cause and effect and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that. During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate. Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation of humans), wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment of the universe (NOT CREATION OR DESTRUCTION since energy can be neither created nor destroyed). freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious divine + energy or (cosmic allegories Shiva + Shakthi or Vishnu + Lakshmi or Brahma + Saraswathi).. Microcosm = Macrocosm. This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus and meditation).. Birth/death duality cycle continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle.

[@rajeevjayaram4981]

It is the mind that thinks of rebirth..if that identification is gone then what is there to be reborn..this is difficult but is the truth

[@indianmilitary]

Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. Birth/death duality continues due to "vasanas" unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate.

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

All god's are not in temple mosque church or gurudwara of the world but in everybody's 💖💓💓 only.

[@simthiam3712]

For someone who have not wake up from the Dream, reincarnation is very real to him/ her....

[@indianmilitary]

Even if you "wake up" vasanas remain. It is the reason why many gurus who attained samadhi (which can be temporary and permanent) clearly remembers their past (in this life) and discuss about it during satsang with their disciples. Point is, there are tools, techniques (yoga, tantra, temple tradition) in hindu tradition to transcend vasanas or memories. There are different types of memories. Elemental Memory atomic Memory evolutionary Memory Karmic Memory and Conscious memory unconscious memory Articulate memory inarticulate memory Birth/death duality cycle or reincarnation cycle continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that.

[@GenerationAI0]

Shivoham shivoham 🌸

[@iguidemeditation3806]

Rebirth is governed by the law of cause and effect.

[@true1evanique]

The law of, "cause and effect" is a dynamic of a 2 dimensional world that is experienced by our false identity as real. The goal is to become aware of our true essence that is non dimensional.

[@dhanushrajamohan7348]

I have a doubt ..is death and suicide results same or vary?

[@indianmilitary]

@@dhanushrajamohan7348 It doesn't matter. As long as there are Vasanas in the Chitta (the subtle body) in which karma of millions of past lives are stored the subtle body to gross body duality cycle or reincarnation cycle. continues.

[@hariaimar]

Thank you 🙏

[@quake3quake3]

Namaste, I tried to find the song name in the description but you usually don't post them. Could you tell which song? Thank you.

[@MindfulSoul]

Hello, unfortunately I don't have a name at the moment. Will post it in the description once I find it. Grateful for your understanding.

[@indrani8378]

@@MindfulSoul 🤣🤣🤣

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

❤️💖💓💕 touching presentation.

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

Anytime and everytime always respect mother father teacher and guru till death and firstly respect Human beings and next religion's and castes of the world.

[@HemPat56]

Beautiful. Thank You :-)

[@richnaturebaby8759]

he wants to say that self or soul is biproduct of process of life and the feeling of self exists as long as process of life exists between birth and death of body. He clearly says that soul is not eternal or existent beyond process of life i.e. body. nothing remains of a person beyond death of body. It's a common sense.

[@indianmilitary]

Lost in translation?. He did not say that. if he did he wouldn't have asked his famous question who are you? or who am i? Point is there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen (including reincarnation cycle). Birth/death duality continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that. If there was no immanent and conscious athma then who would be the experiencer of 5 senses? Simple logic based on the Vedic metaphysics Sankhya which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge though focus and meditation)

[@theuniques1199]

Infinite and rebirth are the same exact meaning, a flower doesn't grow to get better it grows to replicate and reproduce itself, the Universe is just like zygote to consciousness and when we nuke ourselves and destroy all of our consciousness the Universe rebirths itself as the unconscious self until it's conscious of itself again and I'll be writing this same exact comment again until we nuke and destroy all of our consciousness again. Only one percent of consciousness forever awakens to the logic that you can never first exist because a first is a belief(first belief as conscious existence) because the Universe always first believes it exist as a projection of its own self image but the Universe repeats its projection of itself forever because repeat is infinite as infinite is repeat. To exist is to know you exist as to know you exist is to exist, I am what I always am as I always am what I am.

[@mintusaren895]

If force. Can be changed. But not to destroy. Can not be.

[@Tsun_Wu_Kong-Hanuman]

At my level of enlightenment no one's ever heard of reincarnation... Pssttt... I got the golden ticket... Like as in never again... Why do you think... I let others do whatever they want... Their works will keep them busy... ROFL.. While I can concentrate on where I am going... No suffering forever... Isn't that what it's all about... 😏.. Jealous people drag you down... Atleast they try in my case... But... If you are pure... The enlightenment never leaves you... It keeps building... To a point... Where you are alone even in a crowd.... The crowd wants you... But you don't need them... This was me in my pre teens.. So much struggle... I used to think these people are insane... Now... I know for a fact... I was true... Humanity doesn't not have amnesia... Its just retard... If I were you I would be gone too...

[@indianmilitary]

But Ramana Maharishi simply said if there is no attachment (Attachments can lead to Karma or cause and effect or memories) then there is no reincarnation (birth/death duality cycle). But it does not mean you can do whatever you want and escape karma or cause and effect which works on the principle of delayed causation. So, if you want to validate the pre-programmed karma of "sunil" find a good astrologer who can reveal the pre-programmed role "sunil's" past, present and the future including mode and date of death. Point is, as long as there are vasanas or memories created by false identification with thoughts and body or violation of dharma (natural law) or attachment to everything, there will be reincarnation or birth/death duality cycle.

[@dongee1664]

Sri Ramana can speculate as much as he likes but the fact is that nobody knows.

[@MindfulSoul]

@Don Gee, to put this video in context, Sri Ramana did not speculate as much as directing the questioner to focus on present life. He emphasized that it is important to break the cycle of karma through self-inquiry. When one attains knowledge of the Self, then the question of reincarnation becomes irrelevant.

[@dongee1664]

@@MindfulSoul Yes, focus on present life. It's not as complicated or mystical as some make out.

[@supremeconsciousness1769]

what is born are thoughts collected... they are finally unreal... because the SELF is not a thought but the small self is a bundle of thoughts... discover true self you wont be reborn and whats you and yours...its your thoughts you leave here which a suitable baby attracts..

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

Always live and die in music spiritual meditation and non-corrupt life only till death.

[@menuhamenuha6664]

I am totally confused with the Q&A

[@indianmilitary]

Simple. As long as there are vasanas or memories or Karma or cause and effect created by false identification with thoughts and body or violation of dharma (natural law) or attachment to everything, there will be reincarnation or birth/death duality cycle.

[@menuhamenuha6664]

@@indianmilitary What when I memorize /thoughts process on God's verses or mantras ..isn't that memory that I am recalling?

[@MindfulSoul]

@Menuha Menuha, sure but when you realize that the God is within you, you would not need any verses or mantras. When you are just in a state of Awareness-Consciousness-Bliss, there is no work for any vasanas/impressions or memories. And then, not only do you dissolve your karma, you also break the cycle of rebirths.

[@khandneter463]

Can anyone explain to me, that Sri Maharashi said that reincarnation only exists as long as there is ignorance. It shouldn't exist whether we are ignorant or not if it doesn't exist at all. If I am ignorant, believing reincarnation exists then why do I return if it doesn't exist?

[@indianmilitary]

Ignorance leads to karma or cause and effect. So, as long as there is Karma or Vasanas are there, reincarnation cycle or birth/death duality continues. Yes there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma since it is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. Birth/death duality continues due to "vasanas" unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate.

[@khandneter463]

@@indianmilitary Thank you, I have to read what you wrote a couple of more times. I kind of got what you said. Thank you.

[@MindfulSoul]

Dear @kashsoldier, just to push our collective inquiry further (and to add to the discourse) - how can one experience that "the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body" and "the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates"?

[@indianmilitary]

@@MindfulSoul "how can one experience that "the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body" In samadhi or expanded consciousness state, the experience becomes cosmic for an individual. In terms of an analogy, 10 fingers are athma and the body is paramathma. If you expose your 10 fingers to 10 different experiences (like hot, cold etc), the body experiences all the 10 different experiences even though the individual finger experiences only what it is exposed to. Instead of saying how "one" can experience" we can logically analyze it.. It is well known that conscious, immortal, immutable, immanent and omnipresent athma is always there and everywhere. It also means, without the immanent, omnipresent and conscious athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles of nature can happen including reincarnation cycle. This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition is based on including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus and meditation) It also means, tables, dead bodies and rocks etc also have conscious and immanent athma without which nothing can be perceived in its current form Athma is the experiencer of 5 senses (but neither act nor react or not the doer) not the other way round. So, during transmigration, the subtle body transmigrates (which also should have the conscious athma since it is omnipresent) into the womb of a mother (zygote). So, in the form of cosmic allegories Shiva and Shakthi, Shiva is just the observer and the experiencer and the dance of duality cycle is performed by Shakthi (energy). The moment Shiva loses interest or stops observing, shakthi stops dancing and nothing can exist after that. Thank you for giving me an opportunity to explain.

[@MindfulSoul]

Dear @kashsoldier, the connections between double slit experiment, quantum physics and Vedic metaphysics have largely been discredited. (I studied Quantum Physics myself at a postgraduate level at one of the world's best universities.) Sharing a well-intentioned thought below which you may receive or reject depending on your journey: Thank you for your elaborate response. However, it seems that your response is derived from an intellectual/theoretic/academic understanding instead an experiential understanding at a personal level. This is neither good nor bad, but what worries my perceiving mind is how strong you seem to argue that your knowledge is true by being definitive about it. This knowledge could become a trap, and could limit your own spiritual progress.

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

Live and die in mission vision and actions immediately and permanently to become ZERO TO HERO.

[@ramanavel9559]

Om namo Bhagavate Sri arunachala Ramana ya🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@user-cg9fy1fn6j]

So the discussion about reincarnation in Bhagavat Geeta is wrong?

[@MindfulSoul]

@UDAYA SREE, It would be folly to say anything is right or wrong. Human knowledge is always limited and all interpretation of scriptures is subject to those limits. All we know about Bhagavad Gita are based on human interpretations. Just like one word that can have multiple meanings, different schools of philosophy (dvaita, advaita, sankhya etc.) have their own interpretations. However, the ultimate truth remains the same regardless of the different 'angles' of the view that humans look at it. And, it would be pointless to debate or argue who is right/wrong, especially when it comes to experiential truth. To put it loosely, one school of thought (dvaitist) interprets/believes that reincarnation means being reborn several times until one reaches a state of realisation/enlightenment which is when one merges with God. Another school of thought (advaitist) interprets that reincarnation is not literal rebirth of the same soul, but more like passing of one soul's karmic energy to another. This means that, karma is passed on across human generations (kula vedhana) and is not literally the karma from 'previous births'. Where the 'soul' comes from, we do not know. People have their theories based on their faith, religions, belief systems etc. The beauty of it is that, regardless of what we believe (that there is a God outside, or God within), there is a possibility to make this present life free of suffering and filled with bliss if we understand the basic universal laws of karma. Sri Ramana uses self-enquiry approach to address reincarnation. He says the Real Self has no reincarnation. The Real Self is a state of union with the Universe. In this state, there is no sense of a separate individual. When one is close to that state, one begins to dissolve one's negative karma, and leaves behind positive energy for the future generations. Reincarnation and suffering applies only as long as one dies with unresolved negative karmic baggage.

[@user-cg9fy1fn6j]

@@MindfulSoul thank you for elaborate explanation. If there is no unit of universal energy as soul and no passing of karma with soul, then why should one follow Dharma path? we can do what ever is beneficial and easy to survive irrespective of its outcomes.

[@MindfulSoul]

@UDAYA SREE, Karma is a natural law, and Dharma is the practical path of alignment with Karma. Dharma does not ask humans to follow its path. However, whether humans like it or not, if they lapse from the path, not only do they bring upon bad karma on themselves but also for their community/people around them. And that's what is happening in most places in the world, isn't it. Instances - like large corporates (eg: sterlite) causing environmental and ecological damage just to meet their bottomline - keep happening. 1) If someone asks 'why should I follow the Dharma path if I am anyway not going to reincarnate?', that is selfishness arising out of ignorance because that person is not considering the law of karma in its entirety. Such an intention could itself lead to appropriate karma befalling this person proportionate to the actions arising from that intention. Now, the question is who is going to bear the bad karma. It could be this person's children, family, society and future generations, and everyone he passes on his attitudes, beliefs, values to. This may or may not be good, and it's hard to draw a line and say that this is all good and this is all bad. Universe will give appropriate experiences to this person and the generations until they learn the lesson. 2) If this person follows Dharma only if his own soul is reincarnated, then that's egotism as well (because, it is all about an agenda now. It is like being a 'good student' so that the teacher gives him 'good marks' or incentives). 3) Another approach is - if this person follows Dharma irrespective of his soul being reincarnated. Why? Because, that is needed for collective well-being of humanity. This person would uphold good dharma selflessly, and perhaps even set an example for others to follow it. Here, selflessness does not mean giving up everything to the world and living in poverty (that is another form of ignorance). But it's selflessness of 'not doing good deeds because of an agenda, but doing good deeds because it is good anyway for the world in ways one does not know'. People fall in one of the three types above depending on their spiritual evolution. Yes, there are ignorant, selfish people in the world who do not follow Dharma, who do what is beneficial for them, who believe they can get away from their misdeeds with power or money. While such attitudes cannot change overnight, we can hopefully effect a change through dialogue and discourse.

[@shivargvfilm1989]

I can't understand Ramana Maharishi

[@indianmilitary]

In other words, Ramana Maharishi simply said as long as there are vasanas or memories or Karma or cause and effect created by false identification with thoughts and body or violation of dharma (natural law) or attachment to everything, there will be reincarnation or birth/death duality cycle.

[@dasakoota]

@ Hal cyon .... continuation If a person wishes to meditate, he or she has to follow the other seven angas that is rules also. Then only meditation will be fruitful. I have seen people doing meditation not in an erect posture, the spinal cord,the cervical region and the cerebrum have to be in a linear position. Nowadays people are suffering from so many health issues such as obesity, hypertension, cardiac problems and so on. Apart from this, a TRUE guru is a must for meditation. Is it that easy for anyone to concentrate on any mantra non-stop for half an hour, o.k. at least for ten minutes? It is very dangerous to do meditation by intaking chemical compounds.

[@cosmictruth3600]

Chanting a mantra for 30-45 minutes at one go is possible but I don't think it is easy to keep an undivided concentration on the mantra for that long ..not even for 5 minutes I guess .. even while chanting the mantra..many thoughts do come to the mind, mostly its like mind thinking something and the mouth doing the chanting..and about this guru prampara thing / taking dikhsha from a guru or guidance of a guru doesn't have any significance anymore in todays time..these traditions were valuable in ancient times ...but in today's time..genuine gurus are almost no where ..they don't exist ..all we have is every street having a self proclaimed guru, and now we have 100s of such ppl making KZbin channels and claiming as gurus ...none of them have anything in common, and they claim what they say is right ... none of those so called guru is qualified to give deeksha... so I think we just have to trust our inner voice/ instincts and follow it.. it is said that...there is a guru whihc resides in us and opens up to us when we are deeply seeking for something.

[@indianmilitary]

@@cosmictruth3600 True. Another misunderstanding is that you can only chant mantras (based on ancient times). Good news is you can also hear Sanskrit mantras on your headphones with intense focus. The key is focus. Remember, you need focus when you do any work. Just focus on what you like to do. As far as erect spine is concerned, I also differ from it. Once I heard the Mahamrityun Jaya mantra for 108 times with intense focus (focused on typing a long comment) and my spinal cord was in a horizontal position. The Prathyahara (withdrawal of 5 senses) started within 5 mins. But In the end, the moment I sat down with a vertical posture or spine, I felt the vibrations of the powerful mantra during which my body became like a concrete stone (mentioned as one of the 116 meditation techniques in Vigyan Bhairava Tantra to realize the cosmic self). Later I learned that the superfast but subtle vibrations I experienced was nothing but SHABTHA BRAHMAN. Microcosm = Macrocosm. TAT TVAM ASI. You are (already) that. Mantra vibration experience only confirms it.

[@indianmilitary]

Hema Rao As far as erect spine is concerned, I differ from it. Once I heard the Mahamrityunjaya mantra for 108 times with intense focus and my spinal cord was in a horizontal position. The Prathyahara (withdrawal of 5 senses) started within 5 mins. In the end, the moment I sat down with a vertical posture or spine, I felt the vibrations of the powerful mantra during which my body became like a concrete stone (mentioned as one of the 116 meditation techniques in Vigyan Bhairava Tantra to realize the cosmic self). Later I learned that the superfast but subtle vibrations I experienced was nothing but SHABTHA BRAHMAN. Microcosm = Macrocosm. TAT TVAM ASI. You are (already) that. Mantra vibration experience only confirms it.

[@debashismohapatra2112]

I don't know if it is truly from H.H. Raman Maharhi. But , it is not providing a clear massage on rebirth.

[@indianmilitary]

Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that.

[@Lord.Dakshinamurthy]

@02:57 hAah...look at that..lool ..... just like science does not know what came before the big bang....or even want to talk about it....lol that is an interesting answer :D

[@indianmilitary]

The future script is written based on both the current role and past roles. Human roles are like different movie roles played (or experienced to be precise) by the same actor (athma/shiva). So, the future script is our own making and since millions of past lives (or past move roles) have passed, we do not know what exactly will be the next role. Karma devata or law of nature will decide that. Don't worry about all that. What was supposed to happen would happen,

[@manishpandey1522]

I don't understand why all these Guru gives indirect answer to any question? A simple plain yes or a no would do decent job instead of putting people in dilemma. You can't answer all the question with one answer, SELF.

[@MindfulSoul]

Dear @manish pandey, greetings! Dilemmas and discomfort are part of the spiritual journey, they help us grow. Like radio waves, answers are all around us. Just like we have to tune the radio for a certain station, we all get our answers when we are ready to receive them. Keep up your faith, curiosity and quest for truth. There is no hurry to get anywhere. The Universe will bring to you all that you are prepared (and will prepare) to receive. 🙏🙏🙏 But to put you at ease a little bit, here is a hint: The mind carries 'vasanas' or social-environmental impressions (also known as 'conditioning' in psychology). These cause the mind to falsely identify with the body. As long as this identification is there (which is due to ignorance), there is reincarnation. This reincarnation is not literal but the transfer of the soul's subtle nature that contains the 'vasanas' into other physical bodies. But if the mind is dissolved by realizing the Self, there is no transfer of 'vasanas' or 'karma', which means there is no concept of rebirth and suffering. Sri Ramana says that when arrive at this the state of self-realization, you would not even have these questions. You might ask what is 'realizing the Self'? Please watch other videos, there are answers embedded throughout. 🙏🙏🙏

[@pulkitsharmapremiumvideos9252]

But Gita talks about cycle of birth and death and 84 lakh incarnations of the soul into different bodies according to past life karmas!

[@vicsp5765]

The best one can do is to shed one's karma in this life. Not useful to us thinking abt past life or next life. But would be good for future generations if we don't pass on our baggage.

[@indianmilitary]

Yes but Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that.

[@sriv6842]

Is it really Sri Ramana maharishi's teaching?

[@indianmilitary]

It is but he did not deny reincarnation or self (athma). So, more likely his message was lost in translation.

[@Humanity448]

Where are the soul coming from ? Who is sending these souls to earth? How is earth suspending on space on its own ? How are we getting water, air, breath of life ? How is soul entering into women wombs ? Can a two mortal flesh create an eternal soul ? Any one listening to any teaching, please don't blindly accept anything. We are a spiritual being, God gave us the spirit to understand the spiritual world. We have accountability. We are accountable for our good and bad deeds. We have to attain salvation before we stop breathing? Don't get deceived.

[@randybackgammon890]

So is death the same as sleep then?For that's what his philosophy seems to be sugesting.Is he an atheist?....Personally I don't care if reincarnation is an illusion.I want that illusion.I want to see my loved ones again as sureley as I do when I say goodbye when I let them go to school.To say the question isn't relevant is dodging the question.It IS cirtainly relevant to most humans with a living,loving heart✌️

[@svl-103]

Who ever has written this has not got the correct meaning.I think Marsha wants to say that if you are enlightened, that is, ifyouhave experienced that you are not this mind, body, ego then, then therei is liberation from the cycle of birth and death and henceNO Recarnation. But how many are liberated? So for general public there is recarnation . Because of Such confusing statements as are Aden this video , our youth is confused

[@indianmilitary]

True. True meaning is lost in translation

[@rohanbatty]

I'm shocked at these statements, that these are the actual teachings of the Great Ramana Maharishi!? As per these statements, there is no soul? No reincarnations?? If this were to be true, entire Vedic knowledge will stand falsified, millions of powerful enlightened sages will be falsified! I cannot accept Sri Ramana would have made such statements!!!!

[@madhavauk]

You are right. Ramana Maharshi accepted reincarnation as real. An elderly gentleman, formerly a co-worker with B. V. Narasimha Swami and author of some Vasishtadvaita work, visited the place for the first time. He asked about rebirths, if it is possible for the linga sarira (subtle body) to get dissolved and be reborn in two years after death. Ramana Maharshi responded: “Yes. Surely. Not only can one be reborn, one may be twenty or forty or even seventy years old in the new body though only two years after death.”

[@QuantumCosmos2.0]

Who told Vedas cannot be falsified? There were many Vedic as well as non Vedic sages in India.

[@rohanbatty]

@@QuantumCosmos2.0 vedas cannot be falsified as they are not of any human or material origin. Any sages during the prevalence of Vedic period cannot be referred to as non vedic as the purview of vedas is not just limited to spiritual knowledge, although the deepest teachings of vedas only concerns with ultimate reality. But common teachings of vedas also consist of verses for material gains like Bhagya Sukhtam. And such sages were not considered main stream even if they enjoyed high ranks in the kingdom. You may have Jabaali in mind, but Jabaali was given adequate response to his materialistic claims by Bhagwan Ram.

[@indianmilitary]

@@rohanbatty Kindly understand what Ramana Maharishi said here. I think his message was lost in translation. Yes, there is no individual identity based on the conscious and immanent athma which is also omnipresent but it does not mean there is no conscious and immanent athma or rebirth or reincarnation. It is because without the conscious, immanent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen (including reincarnation cycle). This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu/tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus and meditation) Birth/death duality continues due to "vasanas" (or memories or smells) unless one practices Kriya 40 seconds before the juncture of birth/death duality cycle. Sri Krishna mentions it in Bhagavad gita about both reincarnation and how to come out of the cycle. Ch.2 v.13 (REINCARNATION) dehino ’smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntaraprāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati "As the embodied athma continuously exists, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the athma similarly continues to exist in another body when the body decays and gets another body"(Bg 2.13) During reincarnation, we should not say athma transmigrates. We should say the subtle body (chitta, buddhi, manas, ahamkara, subtle bodies of 5 senses + 5 sense organs) transmigrates. Since the conscious athma and prana are omnipresent, we should not say they transmigrate. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that. If Ramana Maharishi had said no athma then why would he ask his famous question to everyone he met - who are you? or who am i?

[@indianmilitary]

@@QuantumCosmos2.0 Eminent quantum physicists would disagree with you on so called of "falsification of Vedas" Albert Einstein ``Whenever I read Bhagavad Gita, everything else seems superfluous. I've made Vedas as the guide for the formation of my theories and scientific investigation" Werner Heisenberg _ (One of the pioneers in the field of quantum mechanics) - "Quantum ideas which seemed so crazy made sense only after reading hindu/vedic metaphysics" ERWIN SCHRODINGER (ONE OF THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.

[@maria-luisegwerder-pittner8058]

❤❤❤

[@iguidemeditation3806]

Rebirth is true

[@indianmilitary]

Correct. Ramana Maharishi did not say no reincarnation. He just said that it is limited only to people who falsely identify with thoughts and body due to lack of knowledge, violate dharma (or natural law - so the purpose of hindu tradition is to prevent violation) and create Karma or cause and effect and those who are attached to everything and falsely assume that they are the doer. The conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma is NOT the doer (neither act nor react) even though the experiencer of 5 senses. TAT TVAM ASI - you are that.

[@Bajarangbal]

Whom shall I believe , am getting mad !!!

[@indrani8378]

Please don't 🤪🤣

[@Bajarangbal]

@@indrani8378 hey can I get your WhatsApp 🙌

[@shivaprasad9321]

@@Bajarangbal indeed maya is soo powerful 😆

[@Bajarangbal]

@@shivaprasad9321 plz tell what's ur beliefs?

[@shivaprasad9321]

@@Bajarangbal I don't believe anything....I always seek about my true self....just get rid of desires (maya)....all this worldly relationships are temporary illusions....no one unconditionally gonna luv u even ur parents luv u because of attachments.....in this universe only guru could take care of u.....don't get confuse...first of all ask ur heart, what r u really want to know about...then u wouldn't have any doubts....if u watch videos randomly without any intention,so off course u get confuse......I'm 90% sure even after watching this video and my comment...u will not remember about this video nor me by tomorrow...coz maya is that powerful ignorance is so strong....so conquer it my friend....remove false identities such as body and mind...desires will fall by them self.....om Namah shivay....

[@ilonkaleibfried2142]

😊🙏🥰

[@rkraja6603]

A Buddhist disciple kept pasturing his monk what happens after death? I don't know replied the monk! But you are a monk who knows everything, complains the disciple. The monk replied not a dead one!

[@vicsp5765]

Good one! 😆

[@randybackgammon890]

Asks the question then proceeds not to answer it!If 'the question isn't relevant'(is the answer) why ask it?

[@gerarddaly4598]

some of the answers given ,, are in contradiction of each other,,??/?

[@MindfulSoul]

@Gerard Daly, to give more context, Sri Ramana had two answers to the question on reincarnation. One was the 'bitter medicine' for those in advanced stages of self-inquiry, while the other was 'sugar coated' for those who are generally ignorant (no judgments). The former is that reincarnation is not true if one realizes the Self. The latter is that, if one thinks of the self as an individual (which is ignorance), then that ignorance would continue through the cycle of births until the final stage of evolution of consciousness.

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

Koi BHI ishwar Allah Jesus and waheguru se Dil lagao Sab milega silently immediately and permanently.

[@asokchatterjee4044]

Prnam

[@babaiyermanispiritualandpo2062]

Live spiritual and leave political.

[@ultimaterealityrealityinto2525]

🌅👣💖❤️🙏🕉️🕉️🕉️

[@usshreebhargava3675]

Reincarnation is true if bad karma is still in the incarnated god.

[@rkbroger6327]

There is no hell or heaven, these are places where dead and god live according to the Abrahamic religions! Where is heaven ask a Muslim, Jew, or Christian?

[@vicsp5765]

Both Hell and Heaven are on the Earth. The Hell is where the spiritually dead suffer in, while the Heaven is where the spiritually vibrant thrive in. 🙂 Sad that people think of these as after life phenomena.

[@rkbroger6327]

@@vicsp5765 Our Father which art in Heaven Hallowed be thy name.... What are these billions of Christians babbling about every day?

[@indianmilitary]

@@rkbroger6327 Jesus did not exist.Jesus was a figment of imagination of the Jewish mother of Constantine, Helena. If you still like to believe he existed, at least try to validate the nicene creed claims of Christianity like ``Virgin birth ``'' son of god". if you don't validate, then you are just blindly believing that he existed based on fantasy stories propagated as history.. Magdalene existed but so called Jesus did not. She was obviously the wife of a person called Damsa (a sidekick of APOLLONIUS OF TYANA). Apollonius of Tyana (an enlightened pagan sage) was suppressed but his sidekick Damsa was propagated as the enlightened one and he was re-named as so called 'Jesus". This is nothing but identity theft.

[@AdamofEarth317]

Try telling this nonsense to people who astral travel or have had NDE's

[@davidcrane6593]

So whacky.