Where Did The Bible Come From and Why Should We Care?: Tim Mackie (The Bible Project)

westsideajc.or...

[@wiseogjc370]

I just want to add something about the bible that wasn't mentioned by Tim Mackie but only because he was concentrated on the subject he was teaching. God inspired the writers of the bible, but He also confirmed His word through His Holy Spirit. Lets remember that in the new testament the Apostle Paul said that the message of the gospel of salvation was not only words but it was also Power, the power of God, the power of His Holy Spirit to transform the lives of those will would believe in Jesus and submit to His authority. The apostles preached but also were used to do signs and wonders through the Holy Spirit to confirm God's word and power to people. Lets remember that the gospel is the power of God, and that the entire bible is the record of all the works, wonders, and power of God which He has manifested throughout history, and until the day of the Lord.

[@2FollowHim777]

Thanks

[@swetztalk5416]

TRUTH

[@mariontjagvad7957]

Most Excellent!!

[@ephramwalton]

The bible reads like a collection of myths, laws, customs etc.

[@eyespy6677]

Where did god come from?

[@robertoandreslunareyes8897]

Man, you are amazing! Thanks for sharing your knowledge with me... I'm from Guatemala, and here is so difficult to learn more about the Bible. There are few people here who are interested in these kinds of questions, and these questions confused me a lot... Sometimes, I felt like I was losing faith. Your passion and your knowledge have to come to the western world... I'm learning to read, listen and speak English, cuz the material to learn more about the Bible is so poor in my mother tongue, or I don't think it is complete. Thank you for being a guide for many people around the world. Get on with your work, because the world needs to hear it. May God bless you, and your family and congregation too.

[@Gotchub]

Zzz l

[@rapturebound197]

That's a fascinating testimonial Roberto. It must be very difficult sometimes being somewhat alone and isolated in your faith. We know that 'Narrow is the way and few be there that find it' but I do want to encourage you my brother in Christ that there are millions and millions of us though miles separate us we are indeed walking along the same divinely lit path you are on. My name is Mike and I extend the hand of fellowship to you we have in Christ our Lord. Psalm 18:28; "You, LORD, keep my lamp burning; my God turns my darkness into light." To God be the Glory! Amen ✝

[@aragoncez]

Amazing! I'm from El Salvador, small world!

[@NinaR478]

I became a believer when I was 20 too :) (it has been a year since I gave my life to Christ and I can’t wait to spend the rest of my life and eternity with our creator!)

[@bryalvarez6863]

If you're truly a believer then you already are spending eternity with Jesus(:

[@fxorigins6624]

Bible is from unknown authors not from God

[@fxorigins6624]

@@bryalvarez6863 Jesus will say depart from him you evildoers. wake up dude..Jesus is not God

[@johnpaulolayvar7037]

@@fxorigins6624 Jesus is a God, he form to a human form to take away our sins, My brethren.

[@memowilliam9889]

@@fxorigins6624 ... “[The] Bible is ... not from God.” From Darwin’s lips to your ears.

[@jflow5601]

Thank God for the Catholic Church, which was the early church established through the Apostles. Keeper of the word until it was written down and canonized by the Church In the book called the Bible, now used by Christians the world over

[@theRealtensigh]

Amazing! The connection between Exodus 24 and the Last Supper blew me away!

[@asaeriksson6007]

27:39 "If you're gonna follow Jesus - you have to follow Jesus! Not your own remake of Jesus."

[@lutkedog1]

But your jesus is a remake, starting with the gospel according to mark written after 30AD and the other gospels accumulating within the next few hundred years. The fact that nothing was written at the time is suspect enough for me, the outlandish and contradicting stories of the gospels are fake. And jesus is mentioned nowhere in the OT along with the word "Resurrection", I have been asking christians where are all those broken tombs of the saints who were raised at the same time as jesus, Matthew 27:53, and coming out of the graves after His resurrection,: they went into the holy city ... And they not recorded by any contemporary sources and that is again suspect enough for me.

[@asaeriksson6007]

@@lutkedog1 This is of course a matter of faith, like almost everything, and faith is a gift. But faith builds on the Word of JEHOVAH and in Psalm 16:10 I'd say that David obviously speaks about the Messiah (for David himself is dead and buried) . "For You will not abandon my soul to Sheol, nor will You let Your Holy One see decay." That's enough reference to the resurrection of the Messiah in my eyes, but also the story of Jonah in the belly of the fish and Joseph delivered from the jail and raised to the ledaing man in Egypt (as a Messianic reference) points to the same fact. May JEHOVAH bless you with faith in His only begotten Son. Prov 30:4 "Who has ascended to heaven and come down? Who has gathered the wind in His hands? Who has bound up the waters in His cloak? Who has established all the ends of the earth? What is His name, and what is the name of His Son- surely you know!"

[@lutkedog1]

@@asaeriksson6007 What the hell are you talking about read what i sent and comment on it.

[@lutkedog1]

@@asaeriksson6007 The word Resurrection is nowhere in the OT.

[@asaeriksson6007]

@@lutkedog1Your comment did'nt follow your own rule to read what I sent and comment on it, so please don't throw stones in your own little glass house! I choose to answer in my way, as likewise you do.

[@godofthebiblespeaks3188]

Your passion for God's word is contagious and uplifting. Thanks for sharing what you learned.

[@kathyclark561]

Your teaching has given me a fresh hunger for the Bible. Thank you!

[@JuanitaLRL]

God's Living Word is alive and Contagious in an Amazing way

[@JuanitaLRL]

House of Isreal House of Judah *Equals All 12 Tribes*

[@tfm_patrick]

God of the Bible Speaks definitely contagious

[@isaiahbattle204]

Definitely contagious 🙏🏾🤍 with everything going on its a good feeling to see so many involved with the word of God

[@grandpahand7410]

“The new covenant people”, in 108 AD Ignatius of Antioch (who is mentioned in the Bible) called the early Christian community catholic, thus the Catholic Church gave us the NT Bible. This is well documented but some people just cannot bring themselves to admit it.

[@Cotswoldblonde]

When it says catholic in the creeds it means unified not Catholic as in Roman Catholic. 🙏🏻

[@kuyawinpascual3815]

Pastor Tim, Praise God for your heart and dedication as a follower of Jesus. We thank GOD for using your life Mightily to tell the Good News as humanly possible as simple as it is complex. A compelling story in a Nutshell. :D

[@johnsteila6049]

I apologize if this has been addressed already, but isn’t it interesting to note that The Catholic Church decided which books would make up The New Testament Canon?

[@jonathannunn2266]

The Orthodox Church

[@johnsteila6049]

@@jonathannunn2266 You may be right but the point is that we owe a great debt to The Catholic or Orthodox Churches for The Bible we have today.

[@christinaandersen2204]

From Denmark, Europe. God bless you, man. Thank you so much for this amazing teaching which I have been searching for. It moved me to watch the original scriptures. I know its real, it just underlines it again and again.. God know what is best for us, as we dont. He is so much wiser than we are. He gives us these chores and team works with Him, cause it makes all the good things from Him to us alive in our daily walk with Him and with each other. Thank you also for being humble although you are very edicated. I also suck at being human many times ;-) But my heart is right and will continue seeking God and His Kingdom first. We need more of this teaching also in Denmark. I will take a look at your church over there. God bless you all, brothers and sisters in Jesus Christ our Saviour and Lord.

[@shydumpling4303]

sadly i have heard that denmark is mostly atheist. God bless you, for being a proud follower of Christ even though you may be alone in your beliefs where you live. i know it is hard to live in a place where there are not many christians. always remember that we are not alone, we have our brothers and sisters in Christ around the world ❤️🙏

[@chie-panda]

Haha! You are the most non-professor professor ever! Most dedicated, passionate follower of Jesus. Thanks Tim!

[@alleadonai]

Lol his conversations where he's like "Please don't call me Doctor."

[@nicolinacappelli3013]

Your off on some things.

[@rebeccagonzalez1843]

Thank you for this and honesty . I’ve been wresting with

[@daleivester6143]

Keep following Jesus and you will not regret that. I know, I'm sure. You will go through ups and downs but if you always remember that Name Jesus of Nazareth you will not be deceived. The new world order is bringing in the false Jesus of the new age hindu god and that is why you must know this . The antichrist comes next Then the true Jesus of Nazareth. However if we are raptured it is not going to come into play. I hope this helps you

[@alexandergallant6444]

“For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man: but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost.” ‭‭2 Peter‬ ‭1:21‬ ‭KJV‬‬

[@billjohnson7706]

That’s exactly what the Bible says. What were you putting that out there for? Oh yeah! Because he lies! He lies about what the Word is. Our opinion is heresy to God.

[@andrewfaniku]

Thank you so much for sharing these. I 💯 agree with you! A while back, I read the biography of Mandela, “Long walk to freedom,” and was inspired by his character and courage. Even though I’ve never met Mandela, I never say it’s the book that inspired me. I say the sacrifice and struggles of Mandela inspired me. However, If I never read the book myself, but my friend read it, and told me about Mandela. I still wouldn’t say it was the book, or my friend, that inspired me. I’d still say I’m inspired by the life and struggles of Mandela. When I read an autobiography, it’s not the book that inspires, it’s the person that inspires. Similarly, the Gospels are the biography of Jesus Christ. The Old Testament is the setting of the story before Jesus stepped on the scene. The Christian faith is based on the inspirational story and sacrifice of Jesus. Unfortunately, I feel even a lot of Christians get this simple fact wrong, placing undue emphasis on our scriptures to prove our case. But when we critically read the gospels, they make no direct claims to divine inspiration. Even Moses didn’t get too attached to the tablets, on which God, with his own hands, wrote the 10 commandments. Moses smashed it down, not wanting the tablets to be worshiped. He knew it wasn’t about the tablets, it was about God’s commandments already written in their hearts. 😪 Judaism is based on the Torah. Islam is based on the Quran. Christianity ISN’T based on Gospels. Christianity is based on Jesus Christ.🙏🏾 Yes I believe the Bible is divinely inspired, but I didn’t know that until I was saved and inspired by Jesus first. It’s not the Book that inspired us, it’s the person.

[@gabrielchavezdesantiago4074]

He broke it in anger due to them worshipping another god.. a golden calf. It was not because of them worshipping the tablet.

[@amsamiam0824]

I've learned a lot from you Tim, and also from John in the Bible Project podcast and KZbin channel. Through old and new videos, I've been able to find the answers to many of the questions I had. Big fan and supporter of your work. May God continue to bless you with good health and wisdom to understand His work so you can continue to teach and win more souls for the Kingdom. God bless brother.

[@rosemcgee1765]

Amen

[@antoniolabrada175]

The catholic church gave us the bible

[@Swavey2k12]

@Christianity Simple are you Familiar with the old Testament? Deuteronomy 4:28 And there you will serve gods, the work of men’s hands, wood and stone, which neither see nor hear nor eat nor smell. Christianity and the "Wood Cross" Islam "Stone/Rock"

[@NewyorkRicanSoulPodcast]

I think it's time for your TED Talk Mr. Tim Mackie. I love the way you teach.

[@joer5627]

To see someone simply on fire for Jesus is not only refreshing but also challenging. I listen to Tim’s Sermons while woodworking in the garage. Frequently I have to stop & write a note. I have church while making sawdust each day. Come out in better spiritual shape than when I start each day! Thank you

[@luisroberto1322]

Deeply short view of the Torah, normal in cristian teachers, the complexity of the hebrew words is not seriuosly taken, (exodus 32,16) .Fortunely Jesus undertood he couldnt resucitate by reading a funny novel.Nevertheless , good initial question, and yes dead sea scrolls are awsome.

[@ShaunusIAM]

I love your pick-up on the context of marriage covenants. In Hebrew circles I've been told they don't see the "10 Commandments" as that at all. That's a Western title for them. They were seen as "the 10 words" as part of a "Ketubah" or marriage covenant. Sheds light on a lot of the language surrounding the covenant including, "treasured possession" and "consider carefully all these words". Interesting too that the final stage of a marriage in Hebrew culture is consummation under a "chuppah" which is the same as the cloud of languages in fire seen in Exodus and again in Acts...

[@rdmariano7334]

WOW I LEARNED SOMETHING FROM THIS COMMENT 😮

[@gracef244]

I love how the entire scriptures illustrates a marriage covenant.

[@mrkleen4039]

Covenant was for the Israelites..........................

[@kymdickman8910]

@@mrkleen4039 We are grafted into the same covenant with God as Abraham had... Peter called us all a Kingdom of priests and a holy nation, the same as Moses called Israel. 1 Peter 2:9-10 (ESV) But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people for his own possession, that you may proclaim the excellencies of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light. Once you were not a people, but now you are God's people; once you had not received mercy, but now you have received mercy.

[@mrkleen4039]

@@kymdickman8910 may I ask what version are you reading from?

[@kahansen2116]

At mid life and being obsessively searching for something or someone who can articulate what I believe is so healing. This is how I see it too but there is no conversation that allows for this. You are truly brave and appreciated beyond words for putting this out.

[@ronhughes1407]

I feel the same way. It is very hard to find supportive content. Have you listened to the Gospel of Thomas? It is super cool. I feel Lucky to have stumbled across this guy.

[@billjohnson7706]

@@ronhughes1407 gospel of Thomas?

[@growingtruedisciples]

This video has been such a blessing to me. I have watched it several times. Thank you for posting it!!!

[@jacobwatson5484]

Tim I wanted to personally thank you for all your work on the Bible Project, Im a new follower and was recommend the Bible Project and cannot overemphasize how much it has helped me on my journey to Christ. Thank you, thank you, thank you

[@janicecovell5297]

You are so blessed to have found this as a new follower of Jesus,! After 40 years of Bible reading, the Bible project is still a wonder and joy to me 😊

[@janice7378]

Your works are amazing. I was asking myself this question today where Bible and it's writings came into existence from and you answered it so beautifully

[@alexrazumov9470]

God is confirming Himself to you, not that any of His messengers are any special))

[@artdanks4846]

Actually, the Old Testament that Jesus and the Disciples would have used, and most all the 1st Century Christians, was the Septuagint, which is the Greek translation of the Old Testament. This is why whenever O.T. passages are quoted in the N.T, the words differ from what we read in OUR Old Testaments. Because the writers of the New Testament were quoting from the Septuagint, whereas our bibles are translations from the original Hebrew.

[@iponderwonder1279]

Thanks for imparting the knowledge that you’ve gain from your studies. I am happy I arrive at your channel. Keep doing the amazing task God has called on you to do.

[@joshmccartney777]

Misleading and deceptive to state Nestle or Leningrad are the source for all translations, and to state that people aren’t changing the Bible; modern translations do add and remove many verses which matter based on worldly wisdom which I would be happy to send through if anyone is interested.

[@gelilaeyasu898]

I am glad I found this guy and the channel. Jesus is cool.

[@elektrotehnik94]

Weird to hear, but yes, Jesus is cool indeed

[@jonathandoe1367]

Jesus is cool! I'm surprised He isn't even more popular! :)

[@soulwaves20000]

Cool? You’re a dork

[@elektrotehnik94]

@@soulwaves20000 yes daddy, hurt me,... more!

[@soulwaves20000]

@@elektrotehnik94 wow that hurt you? 😂😂😂

[@yacquelinnexiscatti9724]

What are the significant differences among the versions? Do they change the meaning of the original texts? How can we check that?

[@James41892]

Yacquelinne Xiscatti Someone is deleting what I'm trying to show you, may I email you ? YAHWEH BLESS Sister ! יהוה ברכה אחות

[@James41892]

Yacquelinne Xiscatti It's answer's to your questions... YAHOSHEA BLESS Sister...יהושע ברכה אחות

[@Lili-jv1zp]

Thank you for bringing me back to my savior, your videos are a blessing to my life. You can clearly see the love you have for the lord shining through, Amen and God bless🤍

[@betocastro8910]

Not just the word of God and his will. The inspiration and authority of the Bible. TOO! 2Ti 3: 16-17 All Scripture is inspired by God, and useful to teach, to convict, to correct, to instruct in righteousness so that the man of God may be perfect, fully prepared for every good work. "Scripture," as used in 2Ti 3:16, refers primarily to the OT writings (3:15). However, there are indications that when Paul wrote 2 Timothy some of the NT writings were already regarded as Scripture inspired and empowered (see 1Ti 5:18, which quotes Lk 10: 7; 2P 3: 15-16). Today, Scripture refers to the authoritative writings of the OT and NT, that is, "the Bible." They are God's original message to humanity and the only infallible testimony of God's saving activity for all people. (1) Paul affirms that all Scripture is "inspired by God" (Gr. Theopneustos, from two Greek words: theos, which means "God", and pneō, "to breathe"). Scripture is the very life and Word of God From the very words of the original manuscripts, the Bible is absolutely truthful, trustworthy, and infallible. That is true not only when it deals with salvation, ethical values, and morality, but also in all the subjects it deals with, including history and the cosmos (cf. 2P 1: 20-21; note also the psalmist's attitude toward Scripture in Ps 119). (2) The OT writers were aware that what they told the people and what they wrote was the word of God to them (see Deut 18:18; 2S 23: 2:, . Time and time again the prophets began their warnings by indicating that they were "the word of the Lord." (3) Jesus Christ also taught that Scripture is the inspired Word of God even in the smallest details (Mt 5:18). He affirmed that everything he said he received from the Father and is true (Jn 5: 19,30-31; 7:16; 8:26). In addition to that he referred to the revelation that would come (ie, the truth revealed in the NT) from the Holy Spirit through the apostles (Jn 16:13; cf. 14: 16-17; 15: 26-27) . (4) Therefore, to deny the total inspiration of the Holy Scriptures is to put aside the fundamental testimony of Jesus Christ (Mt 5:18; 15: 3-6; Lk 16: 7; 24: 25-27, 44- 45; Jn 10:35), the Holy Spirit (Jn 15:26; 16:13; 1Co 2: 12-13; 1Ti 4: 1) and the apostles (2Ti 3:16; 2P 1: 20-21), Furthermore, limiting or ruling out its infallibility is undermining divine authority. (5) In his work of inspiration by his Spirit, God, without changing the personality of the writers, directed them to write without error (2Ti 3:16; 2P 1: 20-21. See 1Co 2: 12-13 , notes). (6) The inspired Word of God is the expression of the wisdom and character of God, and therefore can give wisdom and spiritual life through faith in Christ (Mt 4: 4 Jn 6:63; 2Ti 3:15; 1P 2: 2). (7) The Bible is God's true and infallible testimony of his saving activity for humanity in Jesus Christ. That is why the Scripture is incomparable, concluded forever and of special obligation. There are no human words or statements from religious institutions to match his authority. (8) All commentaries, doctrines, interpretations, explanations, and traditions must be judged and legitimized by the words and message of the Scriptures (see Deut 13: 3, footnote. (9) The Word of God must be received, believed and obeyed as the ultimate authority in all things related to life and godliness (Mt 5: 17-19; Jn 14:21; 15:10; 2Ti 3:15 -16; 2P 1: 3; see Ex 20: 3, note). It should be used in the church as the ultimate authority in all matters to teach, convict, correct, and instruct in righteousness (2Ti 3: 16-17). No one can submit to the lordship of Christ without submitting to God and his Word as the highest authority (Jn 8: 31-32,37). (10) You can understand the Bible only when you are in good relationship with the Holy Spirit. He is the one who opens the understanding to understand its meaning and gives the interior testimony of his authority (see 1Co 2:12, note). (11) The inspired Word of God must be used to overcome the power of sin, Satan and the world in life (Mt 4: 4, Eph 6: 12,17; James 1:21) (12) All members of the church who regard the Scriptures as God's only truth for a lost and dying world should love, treasure, and protect them. Its doctrines must be protected by staying true to its teachings, and proclaiming its saving message, entrusting it to trustworthy people, defending it from all those who disfigure or destroy its eternal truths (see Phil 1:16; 2Ti 1: 13-14, notes; 2: 2; Jud 3). No one has the authority to add anything to Scripture or to take anything away (see Deut 4: 2, fn; Rev 22:19, fn). (13) Lastly, it should be noted that infallible inspiration applies only to the original writing of the biblical books. So when something appears to be wrong in the Scriptures, instead of assuming that the writer made a mistake, it is worth remembering that there are three possibilities in this regard: (a) the existing copies of the original manuscript may not be at all precise; (b) the current translation of the Hebrew or Greek biblical texts may be faulty; or (c) the understanding and interpretation of the biblical text could be deficient or incorrect.

[@craigmoola2120]

John 1:1-4 disagrees with you. The (W)ord of God is a person, not a book. 2 Tim. 3:16 says Scripture is "useful". As in, not essential. Not indispensable. Not infallible. Just "useful". Think about it.

[@yhwhnissi6783]

King James Bible This the covenant that I will make with them after those days, saith the Lord, I will put my laws into their hearts, and in their minds will I write them.

[@debbieculley7532]

Amen!

[@The1stDukeDroklar]

This means the Spirit will guide you from within... not some stone tablets written by a man trying to hear the whisper of the spirit.

[@theway3058]

Amen

[@kamu747]

Please reference the Chapter and verse? Thanks.

[@lutkedog1]

@@kamu747 Jeremiah 31:33 But this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; After those days, saith the LORD, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people. Hebrews 10:16 "This is the covenant I will make with them after that time, says the Lord. I will put my laws in their hearts, and I will write them on their minds." This is only for the Jews Jesus said that salvation was only for the Jews. Mt.15:24; But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel. Mt.10:5,6; These twelve Jesus sent forth, and commanded them, saying, Go not into the way of the Gentiles, and into any city of the Samaritans enter ye not:But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. Jn.4:22 Ye worship ye know not what: we know what we worship: for salvation is of the Jews. I don't believe in the Bible but that is what it says.

[@artdanks4846]

I may have missed it, but I didn't here him explain how, when, where, or who decided which books of the N.T. were actually canonical and which were not. Just like we know that the Bible "didn't drop out of heaven", it's also true that the compilation of the New Testament ALSO "didn't drop out of heaven". It was determined by THE CHURCH, through councils of Bishops that studied these books. The Bible is a book FROM / BY the Church and FOR the Church. In order for it to have the Authority it has, The CHURCH first needed to decide what books were actual Scripture.

[@Tsudkyk]

We had a skate church in our small town and it became a little hub of positivity- due to financials the church had to close its doors. This church did not judge the young rebellious skateboarders. For example; A group of 14 year olds were caught smoking pot behind a car then invited inside. They did not judge- they just let the group of stoned kids vibe with Jesus. This group became regulars at the church because they felt included in the culture- not judged. Skate church ruled.

[@management570]

Maybe I missed it, but I dont remember him answering the question: If God doesnt possess (for lack of a better word) the writers of the bible, and if the bible isnt this golden tablet from heaven, how can we trust flawed humans to accurately transcribe God's words?

[@domenicoabdulmadjid]

I love this guy ...thanks for being so blessing

[@Cus27l]

DO A KICKFLIP

[@johnnylara7032]

The Catholic Church made the Bible before 400 A.D & Martin Luther took 7 books from the Bible in the 16th century. I recommend doing some research about Catholicism. We have 73 📚 while they have 66. God bless! 😇

[@artdanks4846]

The Orthodox Bible has 81 books.

[@monkkeygawd]

“Religions are divisive and quarrelsome. They are a form of one-upmanship because they depend upon separating the “saved” from the “damned,” the true believers from the heretics, the in-group from the out-group… All belief is fervent hope, and thus a cover-up for doubt and uncertainty.” ~ Alan Watts *Alan Watts was protestant minister, but left the religion to pursue the beautiful Eastern philosophy (Truth) of nondualism, such as found in Advaita Vedanta.

[@jancovorster8154]

I enjoyed this very much. In this modern anti-christian world, the media makes you believe the Bible is just another book, that we must question. Thank you for all the valuable information and insight.

[@johnsix.51-69]

Ok so since he didn't answer the question in the title I'll give you the answer. How convenient of this guy to leave out the councils of Rome, Hippo and Carthage. There was no bible canon before 397 AD. Why do you think we don't have the gospels of Peter, Judas, Thomas or Mary Magdalene or the apocalypse of Peter or many other letters? Because the catholic church guided by the Holy Spirit didn't add those to the canon. This man should have stuck to something else and left theology, interpretation and history to the one true church and only bride of Christ. The One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. Why is your protestant bible missing Wisdom? It's as if satan wanted to laugh at protestants and had Martin Luther take it out.

[@tomfrombrunswick7571]

So biblical cannon comes into existence 331. Jesus died around 30-32. Thus Christianity exists for 300 years with no bible. Basis of Christianity the oral tradition. People talked had tradition did rituals. American Christianity based on a rejection of what was the basis of the Church for 300 years.

[@grandmasterlucien]

Well the new testament letters were in circulation during those years too. They didn't just appear in the 3rd/4th century.

[@slomofome14]

That’s basically calling God out on not having a plan for a while... I don’t even need to know the ins and outs, clearly God’s plan worked swimmingly as the whole world knows about/ has access to know about Jesus.. Peter was once told by Jesus in His own way that he was going to die and how. Peter asked, in essence, ‘well what about John,’ Jesus replied, what is it to you if he remains til I return, “YOU FOLLOW ME.” You can speculate all these semantics and what about the people in remote places that never heard.. What is it to you, YOU FOLLOW JESUS. God is faithful and just. Everyone will have an opportunity to either accept or deny the Christ. I believe that by faith. But , it’s not my job to hold God accountable for that. I MUST FOLLOW JESUS

[@tomfrombrunswick7571]

@@slomofome14 It is not callin out anyone on anything. You tell me when the bible was accepted by what was to become the Catholic and Orthodox Church. It was around 320. Prior to that the Bible did not exist as a book. What was to become the Bible was in existence but it did not form the core of what Christianity was about. What Christianity was about was the Christian tradition. All this read the Bible stuff stems from Luther. Prior to that the central practice of Christianity was being a member of the Church participating in the sacraments etc etc. The Bible was only translated into vernacular languages after Luther

[@slomofome14]

@@tomfrombrunswick7571 It’s very obvious you don’t have the Holy Spirit.. God would NEVER downplay His Word.. Come out of the whore church of paganism and dead men’s bones, repent and be born again sir

[@darynas798]

​@@tomfrombrunswick7571 The Bible contains everything we need for salvation. It says how you can have eternal life, how you can have the Holy Spirit, and what the Church is. The Church is people who have the Holy Spirit living in them (1 Peter 2:5, 2 Corinthians 6:16). That's why it's called the body of Christ. If we truly want to follow Jesus Christ and to have His Spirit, we'll look at His words in the Gospels and in the letters of the apostles that He chose. That's where we can find His teachings intact. So be very careful: if traditions and rituals that you follow contradict the Bible, you're on a wrong path!

[@coreyflynn9333]

I am on the same page with heaven and earth becoming one, but I am not sure I agree with the idea that hell is on earth. You also didn’t address death with your theory. The last thing is you didn’t exactly disprove the top part of your drawing. You travel through life trying to do good and get to heaven and not go to hell... the two are not as related as you made them out to be I think. I am a Christian but I actually dislike most of your Bible project videos. They over simplify the Bible, and I see the usefulness in that don’t get me wrong, but it really makes it sound like a fake story that didn’t happen.

[@thomasvansant6246]

I'd love to listen to a series of podcasts with Tim Mackie and Bart Ehrman entering into a discussion about the Bible.

[@lamont6891]

Spotify: The Bible Project

[@thewizzard3150]

It came from the roman emperor constine. Why should you care? Unless you're a very religious jew it's not going to have a lot importance. If you're interested in Jesus you should Start with Thomas who followed Jesus around and coped down what Jesus said.

[@yolibethfigueroa6771]

This is amazing! I’m a leaders in the middle school and high school group and your material is always top 1 to go to. Blessings

[@mrnate19]

Wow. I have never heard hell so glossed over before. Where is the mention of Satan and his influence on the wickedness that comes out of peoples mouths? Everything was great about your video until hell was mentioned. God isn’t trying to “get the hell” out of everyone, the Bible doesn’t say that at all!

[@jaytee2716]

Your very good at giving a good explanation of things. I enjoy the break down it’s difficult for even seasoned vets of Christians to get a handle on a lot of these topics. Your doing good work man GOD BLESS! My question is how much has the Bible been picked apart and things changed within it. I was listening to this show the other day talking about the break down of the Bible from a Historical viewpoint of how Scriptures begin when it’s something that considered authentic all Scriptures begin with a certain word or letter but not genesis it begins with In the beginning and historically speaking that’s not normal for Ancient Hebrew Scriptures they always begin with something certain. It kinda makes me think that the Catholic Church or another sect changed parts of it.

[@36cmbr]

U R ez to listen to but I’m not sure you are quoting or uncovering any abiding truth. Today’s lesson declared the Holy Bible’s authority based on specific passages authorized by Lord Jesus and expressed by the first covenant that created priests for us to follow. That’s what I heard anyway.

[@miltontorres7886]

Wow! Beautiful explanations and passion for teaching the word of God!

[@dekuuchiha9990]

It was just written by people? Can't trust what people wrote yesterday even. God should have left a tablet himself.

[@daveyofyeshua]

Came across this via YT algorithms, but recognised your voice and fashion from your animations. Wonderful Yeshua given passion for the word, for truth. Subscribed 🙌🏾

[@yeshuat1399]

It was no YT algorithm

[@YellowScar2014]

@@yeshuat1399 God using the algorithm is another possibility. You might be right, I might be right. Not like it matters though, in the grand scheme of things.

[@yeshuat1399]

@@YellowScar2014 god is everything so its hard to be wrong 😉

[@dave_ecclectic]

I must have blinked and missed the part where you explained where the Bible comes from. At the very least you seem to have skipped over the part of why these specific books are included and others are not. It seems the Apostles forgot to include a table of contents.

[@kristis4147]

Wonderful, BLESSED, teacher of the scriptures. The visuals really help me understand. I also like the truth he speaks that I feel but am embarrassed or proud to admit

[@sum2automation]

Yes, I wasn't saved by the church or any religion. It happened by calling on the name of Jesus for help and it was truly miraculous! If anything most churches today are just some sick ego trip that destroys the spirit of love. This getting to heaven stuff or burning forever in the after life must be understood correctly. Truly, teachers of the blood and total forgiveness should be talked about more and more often. People still think they're going to hell and are trying to earn their way out of hell and into heaven. Most Churches are truly missing the point and adding requirements that takes away what the blood means. I have enjoyed your work Tim and your views, the teaching are word's to ponder. But I would like to leave you with something to think about. I'm reminded of the seeker St Francis and his findings after a life of study: " What you are looking for is what is looking " Yes, man being made in God's image is truly an incredible 📖 study. I hope God has you teach on the topic some day. Thanks again Tim and may God keep blessing you and yours. It's truly all a miracle in this life and I'm now looking forward to crossing over to the spirit world and shedding this old worn-out body that served me very well in this amazing thing, we call life on planet earth as we are all fly thru space, spinning around our sun.... Yes, it's all truly an amazing 🌎 world that God has created. Be well :)

[@cindyreeves5048]

I must be a Bible geek, because I LOVED all of this!!

[@CorzIlla]

Humans love dogma and to make simple things complex. God is love eternal love everlasting. Nothing we do will ever make us good enough in our own actions.. if it were true that we could earn our way .. Jesus would not have had to give of himself for us. This pastor makes more sense than most I’ve heard

[@jesusislord9447]

Thank You Jesus!!! My Dear Reedemer!!! HaleluYah!!!!

[@michaelcjohnsonmj]

So I never believed in God mainly because of these ancient Holy Books. Well recently I had an encounter with God and he had me write my Testimony and you are right he uses people to write is word. The testimony is mine BUT God was kinda like writing for me even tho I had to do the hard work. he guides you when writing, and what to write. He even had me restart a few times if I was going off track. I would like to share it with you, if you are intersted.

[@joeyhardin5903]

tim mackie is honestly my favourite teacher nowadays, alongside jonathan cahn

[@mancaveedc7596]

Cahn is a FP.

[@joeyhardin5903]

@@mancaveedc7596 nah

[@billjohnson7706]

@@mancaveedc7596 what’s an FP or do I. It want to know?

[@buffalowaterloo101]

Interesting that you claim Moses was given 42 commandments that became 613. There are 42 laws in the Egyptian religion of Ma'at. Moses was given 10 commandments that eventually became over 613 laws, statutes, judgments, ordinances and commandments because the first ten were broken consistently. There are so many other interesting statements but I will sum my response into as few words as possible. Replacement theology and teaching lawlessness is acceptable because of grace. But it's a feel good message that will tickle many ears but bring no conviction or repentance. So it serves the religion but contradicts the very Bible you claim to be proving. Sad that we think HIS laws don't need to be followed but pride ourselves on keeping the laws of the land and being lawful citizens.

[@pappularaviteja5107]

Hi, Mr. Tim I have a question in my mind while I'm reading Genesis chaper about Adam and Eve. Can you solve this for me. If Adam and Eve where the only frist people according to bible. Then after their disobedience to God, they were send out of Eden garden. Then after that they had childres Cain and Abel. Then after Cain killing Abel he was punished and sent out as a wanderer. Then he went west side of Eden. If Adam and Eve had childres then where did the other people came from like the one which Cain married. If they were already born to Adam and Eve then why they aren't mentioned in the bible. Are they sinned people or they are also God's creation. Can you explain it.

[@juriaan13]

Hi, let me help if I can. I'm the Bible he indeed went to Nod and behad his wife, didn't say he found a wife there just had relations with her and ended up gathering Enoch and then the city named after it. Adam and Eve were indeed the first and only people out there and basicly Cain took his sister as a wife, got banned and took her along to Nod. Hope this helps Jay

[@pappularaviteja5107]

@@juriaan13 Thank you Jay 👍

[@pappularaviteja5107]

If he did so then what Adam and Eve are doing, why they have not stopped him from doing so. But why it's not mentioned in the bible, like they had a daughter and Cain took her as wife. Will it make too odd. I didn't remembered the chapter but I do remembered that God made a law that they should not have wife from their siblings. Does this links with the Cain's act.

[@juriaan13]

@@pappularaviteja5107 it doesn't per say needed to be sister ,in genesis 5:4 is says Adam and Eve had multiple sons and daughters ,it's safe to say they had offspring so it might have been his cousin. There is a lot of.. questioning actions in the Bible like Lot's daughters laying with there farther. Adam called Eve mother of all living. They couldn't stop Cain from leaving because it was gods will for what he had done.

[@pappularaviteja5107]

@@juriaan13 Thank you Jay for clearing my doubts 😃👍

[@karendenholm5763]

Tim refers alot about going to his crash course on line... can someone direct me to the link please. Much appreciated.

[@ericrossoni]

Well done! Thank you for all your work

[@MoonHutMusic]

Just throwing it out there for anyone who seeks a deeper connection with God than a church visit because the mystery of God is way beyond what church teaches… the church in fact pushes people away from God and limits the pure connection. If you don’t believe this or if this is in some way triggering, just look around to see the connection most Christians have with God, or rather the lack of connection. … The question is … why does God call himself “I am”… try to go beyond the basic teaching that most churches would give you, indeed most pastors will give you some jibber jabber answer… because they have no idea and have not actually asked God why (because they simply regurgitate most answers as they try to fit into some religious mold). But You can… go straight to God and say “Why do you call yourself “I am”… I bet when you hear the answer, your life will never be the same … and for those who have been baptized, you will realize that the true “Born again” experience is not what most Christians think it is. For when we are born again we are completely United with God and have tasted the living water, and are at rest (which hardly describes most people who put all of their faith in a church (the building): the church is a people, not a building, and a word is Jesus Christ, not a Bible…. Which in fact has been turned into an idol. If you have not experienced the true connection with God, able to hear God, know that God is within you…. Then maybe something doesn’t add up… God is here to embrace you and love you for everything that you are, unfortunately you just won’t find it in most churches today, but you can find it so easily in your own closet while communicating with God.

[@Tascountrygirl]

Thank you. Your work has changed my life as a Christian. I feel I am moving forward in my understanding of the Bible and Jesus' covenant with us. Very grateful.

[@berniesat]

Can I challenge you a little more? Can you show where in the bible christianity became the new recipients of God's covenant that he made with Israel?

[@jrlakin370]

I’m not a Christian or an atheist, maybe a seeker?! and I’ve got to say that was excellent and fascinating 👍

[@danjackson5989]

I was waiting for him to mention the J,E,D and P scribes who actually wrote the bible.

[@IndianaJoe0321]

Malarkey

[@Hadrianus01]

Source THEORY

[@joycebouldin2750]

Ishmael was born of the flesh and Isaac was born of the promise. The laws, statue, and commandments were only given to the Israelites. The old covenant was for the Israelites and the new will be for them as well.

[@cliffdee2]

I'm trying to wrap my head around what Dr Tim said that I'm supposed to accept the authority of the Bible based on the history that's primarily espoused by the Bible or the teachings and life of Jesus described by the Bible. Isn't that circular? The confusing thing to me is that what we believe about Jesus is found in the Bible so you can't assume that history is foundational since you are trying to establish the Bible as authoritative.

[@samuelmorris1035]

Thank you Tim! You're sermons are so helpful! God bless!

[@NicoleDeAngelis]

One source from which all the Bible’s come from. Also one source from which we all come from. 💝

[@markfilippone3845]

My Dear Brother, You have presented a magnificent overview of the Unity of the entire Scripture from The Book of Job at 4,200 years ago until the death of John in as late as 102-104 a.d. keep up your good work ! +brothermark +

[@samuelpage9265]

Without God's intervention and documentation thereof, the forces of evil would probably have destroyed humanity very early in its(human) existence. Clearly, that was not part of the plan.

[@cconroy1677]

Kayla Roszelle evil would have completely consumed man. Surviving evil and being destroyed by it are obviously opposites. I would rather face evil and win than face evil and lose. Cant tell whether you are one of those who thinks evil shouldnt exist or what. But of course it does.

[@TheRichardsonReport]

The best explanation of the covenant with Jesus I’ve ever heard. Bravo!

[@acnowmc7749]

It came from Jesus's Church. The one holy catholic and apostolic church.

[@lexodius]

Gates of hell won't prevail.

[@lexodius]

@@Peekaboo-Kitty let me explain something about the internet. most people who use it don't have English as their first language. most people do the effort of learning it. other people don't write as you would like, but that doesn't mean that in 100 years, because of the internet and a lot of 'official incorrect grammar', it is actually correct. in other words. stop correcting other peoples grammar on the internet anders gaan we gewoon met je communiceren in onze eigen taal.

[@RebecaDli]

Na ha, it came from the Jews listening to God, writting what they experienced from God, and then what they experienced from Jesus, God

[@jamesindran7302]

Wonderful Bible study. Thank you so much. God bless you. From Malaysia

[@alexk1105]

mad appreciation for u

[@djabroni_brochacho4644]

Is this the same dude that says hell and the lake of fire don't exist?

[@khanburger3610]

That’s not true- people sadly take Tim out of context- he never said any of those things

[@gracef244]

I take issue with the statement that Jesus was making a 'new covenant' with a new people - because Isreal's failed to keep it to be a light to the nations - as if it was being passed on to a new people. Jesus came to the house of Judah and the northern house of Isreal that was divorced; the lost sheep of Isreal. (I did not come for the world, but for the lost sheep of Isreal) not to establish a new covenant with a new people. He was making a renewed covenant, yes. He did it in keeping with the Mosaic law - covenants are established with blood, then shared in agreement with a meal. It just sounded like the echos of replacement theology (where Isreal is replaced by the gentiles as the people of God) which I disagree with, but that's another topic. Just want to be sure people understand Isreal was not replaced with the gentiles. We are grafted in to Isreal. I don't want to think people would believe Isreal was replaced.

[@gracef244]

@Shaun Gilmore if you read through from Genesis it has to do with honoring righteousness and then promising to give blessing and then the over-arching plan of salvation. It had nothing to do with favoring a particular people over another, but this people group through which the light of the world would come forth. Israel (because of Abraham *also from the seed of other righteous men- who was a righteous man because he believed and obeyed God) was supposed to be a light to the nations, a people group who would walk righteously showing the character of the One who led them. It wasn't because they were better and others redundant. It's not about that at all. I wish I could sit with you and show you through the entirety of scripture, but it's a long process. Don't look for a single answer to satisfy you, it won't happen. Israel (even the land itself) housed the fertile crescent in which contained Eden. So it's all connected to the garden, those walking righteously (believing and obeying), the redeeming of anyone who would choose Him (Exodus -a mixed multitude that included Egyptians and anyone else wanting to live under Yawheh's protection - mentions several times this isn't simply a blood race of people). He blessed this people because of the root of Jesse, the promise of redemption, the plan of the ultimate savior, but also illustrating sovereignty of a creator who's ways are certainly not like our ways. I urge you to read through every word of your bible, comb through it, pray for understanding, pray for wisdom. If these things are truly in your heart, read your bible under prayer, turn everything else off, and trust that He will reveal to you the thing you seek. Never try to understand Yahweh through your human understanding. He illustrates who He is and what He wants though the entirety of it. It takes time. One pastor's answer or another's is not what you seek; you seek Yawheh's answer. It's all in there. And DO NOT BE DISMAYED when He commands the destruction of an entire people group; it has to do with what He knows that we do not. An easy answer to satisfy your question is not going to happen. But seek Yawheh's Kingdom and His righteousness. Never your own. This is just the beginning. He wants to be known. He wants you to choose Him. He wants you to find that narrow road and walk it and not look to the right or left. He wants you to overcome - not as the world portrays it, but as He prescribes it. Bless you today. I pray you come to know and trust what He says about Himself. And that you are among those who choose.

[@megred7364]

God's word is both a human book and a Divine book just as Jesus, the Living Word, is both a man and Divine.

[@asintonic]

The bible as we have it today was compiled by Catholic Bishops at the synod of Hippo.

[@sheana2005]

I love your clear explanations and how you "go to the source". Thanks for your videos.

[@randomschittz9461]

This guy explained hell like no other person, in another video. I just had to see more and I’m not disappointed.

[@maxonmendel5757]

same

[@roflswamp6]

I disagree his description is quite surface level and not very developed. No wonder jews laugh at christians and muslims lmao

[@randomschittz9461]

roflswamp6 Yeah, just because you’re miserable doesn’t mean you have to take it to the internet and try to act superior, when you’re rotten inside. Now, I’m laughing at you. I hope your life gets better, but with that attitude it’ll just be more of the same.

[@randomschittz9461]

roflswamp6 never mind, I didn’t realize you are a child. Your opinion is negligible.

[@roflswamp6]

@@randomschittz9461 why do you assume this to be true? And if u have no rebuttal then you can just say thatyou still have faith...

[@delamberty]

I just gained a new channel to watch with note taking app! so many things yet simple.

[@franklinayala4879]

Tim has delivered me to Christ, thank you got through clarity

[@unlimitedperseverance1706]

Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life.

[@alfonstabz9741]

The Catholic canon was set at the Council of Rome (382), the same Council commissioned Jerome to compile and translate those canonical texts into the Latin Vulgate Bible.

[@samlatin8933]

thats FACTS!!! KJV uses the Latin Vulgate(RE TWISTS THE HEBREW AND GREEK TEXT)over 600 times in its own book,

[@memowilliam9889]

Yay! Would that be the same church that burned people for: translating it into other languages? encouraging laypersons to read it? Printing bibles and distributing them? 😂

[@alfonstabz9741]

@@memowilliam9889 tyndale's heresy here it comes.!

[@alfonstabz9741]

@@memowilliam9889 you are probabbly one of those John Wycliff loyalist who translate the bible full of heresy and self interest right?

[@caseykay6955]

Its not a trance...When you live & love for God..The Holy spirit LIVES IN YOU & GUIDES YOU & TELLS YOU TO DO THINGS YOU NEVER WOULD WITHOUT HIM UNLESS YOU ARE A OPEN VESSEL💯 JUST LIKE THOSE PEOPLE WOULDVE NEVER WROTE THE BIBLE WITHOUT💯 & The Holy Spirit has Written MORE BOOKS & SONGS & You have the Spirit of DISCERNMENT SO YOU KNOW WHO HAS CREATED WHAT💯😇 The Living Word STILL LIVES & NEVER ENDS💯 Now of course some of the bible wasnt lead by the Holy spirit just like we dont always live in the Spirit & are distracted & snares by the flesh...

[@RandolphTheWhite1]

Love this. What fantastic teacher

[@tammychristian1479]

Greetings Pastor, I see that your link is no longer available. I think the calling you have been obedient too is inspiring amazing and pretty much indescribable in how great he is and how proud I a stranger am of you for this "vital" work you are apart of. It has affected my life in a very positive way. I have been watching your videos for just close to a year and ...To God be every Glory, I am so thankful. I did put a link on another video but in my haste (forgive me) I did not reach out properly to explain and or do not know if you want us to write elsewhere but I never received a reply. I am a elder woman young man of God and a newer Christian (sort of and that's another story) and I after many years of not putting my passion for our Lord Jesus that I have had since I can remember 2 years of age; into his word. This was due to reasons that involve others but in the end it was my unconsciousness or other aspects of myself that allowed myself to be led me astray. The link I sent you however, was the first time since I have given my life (or rededicated) that really stirred up feelings within me that I do not want to spend my energy rebuking etc. The word is an anchor and If I cannot anchor myself in it I will still "know" in Christ Jesus but .... I must also believe in the source of his written word. Everything in this video was amazing but I would like to find out from you (if you do not mind) the following; 1. Could you please look at the link that came to you from me and tell me what you think? Help me so I may bind the spread of incorrect information from a worldy source as big as Newsweek, for the non believers considering. ? 2. I Understand what you mean when you spoke about , yeah, there is some controversies and believe it anyway. But then you said, are those significant differences? Yes. And this is where I need to bring up the question I am almost certain you have received before. Millions of people just went through the media and organised religion corruption misinterpreting "vital" information for such a long time. Translation that makes "all" the difference in the world (I will spare you the Kindergarten examples I am sure you already know) . These significant differences are to me not something to gloss over or some academic error to not be corrected. I pray that this is corrected so that those whom are not scholars but in every walk of life can learn his direct words and inner meanings intellectually , to assist our essential faith and of course in giving thanks ahead of time for his direct voice, touch and supernatural means for letting us know most of all. 3. If you wanted to obtain the closest full english bible with the least amount of "missing" info; which one would it be? If this was not affordable to most , why? that would be something our Lord would not want. Could you please suggest a study bible with as much of the real scripture within it as possible? Thank you God bless you in Jesus's name Amen

[@kaizze8777]

This man is a blessing in my life, unveiling heresies as a bi product of just simply explaining WHAT the bible IS and ISNT. Fundamentalists and KJV only people eat your heart out (and I love the KJV as my default btw so this was a big shock to me)

[@KingdomUploader]

you say you don't particularly like the word 'traditional', i speaking of the bible? why is that? Is it similar to how i don't like the words 'religious or religion'? what word might you replace the word 'traditional' with? I'm hearing that word a lot lately and it's not setting right with my spirit - and i can't determine why. thanks anyone

[@janicecovell5297]

I am a 70 year old lady who has taken the Bible by faith for 40 years this June 22. ✝️His arm is Not too short to save. This is like a reward to me for saying I have to believe by faith that the Bible really is our authority no matter how intellectual any of us are, no matter how hard to believe humans could write down what God wants to say and have it still be His message thousands of years after it happened. Hallelujah Glory 😊✝️

[@josephrohland5604]

Save us from what? Romans 5:13- "where there is no (Old Covenant) Law, sin is not imputed".

[@KingdomUploader]

If God gave the prophets words to speak to the people, isn't it plausable that the inspired writers of the bible have had their words - directly downloaded from God?

[@markhualda7488]

Thank you, Sir Tim. 🙂☝️🧡

[@Bob-hh1sc]

I totally relate to skateboarding and my love for God. Thanks to this gentleman, I was able to finally accept Jesus and my Lord and Savior..

[@freefree526]

Please pray for me I feel that I am at the end of my rope.

[@saramokonnen5567]

Carlos, don't give up. Know that God loves and cares so much about you, He sees you. Praying for strength, may God touch you.

[@Cryin_Lion]

Carlos how are you now? Do you know of any way I can contact you or if there is any way I can help you?

[@bibiandjoshua]

Jesus says cast your cares on him

[@davidcattin7006]

Prayer may comfort you, but it does not solve problems. Depending on your situation, prayer is not going to fix it. If you have serious problems such as physical, mental, or financial -- get REAL help. Best from Indiana.

[@lyn1114]

How are you doing? With quarantine and stuff?

[@leanagonzalez467]

I appreciate this and hope that it gives people confidence in the scriptures. At the same time, it would also be useful to note that there are sectarian translations, like the Book of Mormon and Jehovah Witnesses Proclamation…just a quick crash course of the different between sound and heretical text. Love the closing statements. The questions we struggle with aren’t new to the human experience and there are reliable resources. I pray for each of us to have a hunger and to be committed to search for truth so we can find freedom.