Who are Pashtuns, Aryans or the lost Israeli tribe? History of Pashtunwali & religion ft Dr Hanif

[@tnkhan8855]

Such a literate conversation. That's the biggest difference between a scholar and a storyteller.

[@Lion677]

I am Pashtun from Mardan. student of history. According to history books. Horse was an important trait of Aryan culture. In Rigveda it is called 'Asva'. In pashto language we call horse 'As'. Which is strong evidence of pashtun being Aryans.

[@M_Sajjad_05]

@@Lion677 and where from Aryan’s learnt that Dara should be named as Khyber?

[@شاد]

@@M_Sajjad_05 The recent name change from NWFT to Khyber Pakhtunkhwa doesn't hold much historical significance.

[@M_Sajjad_05]

@@شاد You did not get my point. I am talking about Khyber Pass or Dara e Khyber.

[@ARIJITMISHRAam]

@@M_Sajjad_05 is Dara derived from Dwar that means door/passage in Sanskrit?

[@M_Sajjad_05]

@@ARIJITMISHRAam LOL then Khyber must have been derived from Uttama (high) ? We are ready to believe these impossible derivations but not ready to accept the fact that Khyber was a Jewish fort conquered during Prophet’s time and people living in this area named this pass after that fort?

[@asfandyar5501]

We are Pashthoons and we never lost. We go somewhere for a reason and we are peaceful people. 🇦🇫

[@AshutoshPandey-kt1rb]

No your ancestors are hindu Rajpoot kzbin.info/www/bejne/g32mZ5l-i5mtrtEsi=Uz5NHWO4Gmq6rgoW

[@zafarhayee]

Babur ruled Kabul, and he was turk he defeated the Pakhtoons. HARI singh Nalwa conquered the area till Qandhara. The narrative that Pakhtoons were never lost in HISTORY were paddled by Americans in the Russo/Afghan war.

[@bilalturk799]

​@@zafarhayeeافغانستان میں پشتون حکومت پہلی دفعہ کب قائم ہوئی ہے تقریبا تین سو سال پہلے اگر میں غلط نا ہوں تو آپ بتاسکتے ہے

[@shahidsaddique6762]

او بھائی ہارنے کا مطلب کیا ہوتا ہے لاکھوں لوگ کا قتل ہونا، بے گھر ہونا، ملک تباہ ہونا، لوگوں کا جان بچانے دوسرے ملکوں ہجرت کر جانا اسے ہارنا نہیں کہتے تو کیا کہتے ہیں 🤨

[@ebad7090]

Allaudin khilji destroyed Punjabis and hindus, so did sher shah suri with mongals, mahmood of Ghaznavi was the man who made punjabis Muslim, also the Lodhi empire 😂😂😂, don't compare urself to pashtuns, you'll never reach us, physically or historically

[@kanwaldhaliwal]

'Pakhta' is one of the Rigvedic tribes found mentioned in the Rig Veda. One of the best proof of Pakhtoons belonging to Aryans.

[@gigilolo4660]

The Rig Veda is a family book of Bharata Puru tribe who won the Battle of 10 kings and subsequently established the Aryavrat. The word Āryā is used as an epithet of self identity by the composers of Rig Veda who are th Bharata Purus. Just because a tribe finds mention in Rig Veda doesn't mean they are refered to as 'Aryan'.

[@yusafraza]

Yeah now the radical Indians are rejecting the Aryan theory.

[@Karlsewak-kempetai]

​@@gigilolo4660 Aryans intermarried, clans were important that lead to gotra system.

[@DilshadBegum-vo9il]

Yes among rajpoots and jatts​@@Karlsewak-kempetai

[@zardusharyazadraan3608]

کساب آویستا میں بھی ذکر ہے اور شاہنامہ فردوسی میں بھی ان دو کتابوں میں آریانا موجودہ افغانستان کے سارے شہروں اور آریائی قبائل کے نام اس میں پشتون بھی ہے

[@Afridee.1]

I am Pashtun and proud to be Pashtun. I demonstrated Pashtun Wali once in my life when A young married lady interned my house asking for asylum. I assured her safety. I did not handover her to culprits instead of pressure. I Called her family and Police, and handed over to her family according to her request. الحمدلله. ❤

[@AbdulRehman-il7wv]

@@Afridee.1 very noise story

[@sureshdewan5350]

You are not a Pashtun, you are Insaan. Pashtun is only your identity. I request everyone to come out of narrow thoughts otherwise forget the search of truth.

[@KhabibUfc-pz9lv]

​@@sureshdewan5350 Cannot believe hindu is telling us what to do 😂😂😂

[@sureshdewan5350]

@@KhabibUfc-pz9lv Mein Hindu nahin Insaan hun. My message was not for you, insanon ke liye tha.

[@ShxhzEditx]

​@@sureshdewan5350 Are you insecure of your culture? Or maybe you don't have one because you are from Ganga basin 😂, stop telling others what to do and focus on your own.

[@medusaachla]

From India, very informative discussion, highly appreciated.

[@AbdullahAli-ne9gp]

I mostly dont write comments on KZbin, but i am so impressed by Dr. hanif....he seem very Educated person. May Allah give you a long life. I am pashtoon also from Attock.

[@Pathan-u7q]

Hope you are not Aryan, who speaks Pashto.

[@bibeksah7985]

I am from Nepal... We use Bikrami saal officially...even now...

[@induchopra3014]

You are great people. British didnot colonise u so u preserved culture

[@saifsamo9750]

Pakistan's connection with Mahabharat :- Rigveda was written near Sindhu river (Indus). Jayadhrata was from Sindh. Gandhari was from Pakhtunkhwa. Sakuni was from Pakhtunkhwa. Pandavas were from Punjab. Kurukshetra war was fought in Old Punjab (Now Haryana) !!

[@cheltooktribefreethinker1028]

Hawa. Rig ved was rewriteed from the Jain avasta. It's a Persian book

[@saifsamo9750]

@@cheltooktribefreethinker1028 Persians are Western Sindhis all of them migrated to Iran from Sindh . Okay !!

[@gpkh-xg8qc]

@@saifsamo9750 Just 10% migration from Iran. Majority of Baluchistani and Sindhi are indigenous people. They are originally Buddhist. Dig everywhere in Sindh, you will find Buddhist Stupas or Viharas and statues. The kings of this region from this region were Nagvasnshi Buddhist who were of darker complexion than Iranis hence Persians called them Hindu, which means black thief and Sindh region was called Hind. After Muslim invasion majority converted to Islam. Jat, Rajput, Baluchi have the same DNA.

[@warpeace4469]

@@gpkh-xg8qc 🤣🤣🤣🤣 99% migrat ti modren day sindhi ...sindh are farsi name🤣

[@gpkh-xg8qc]

@@Alqudswarriors Yadavas were rulers of middle West India before Islamic invasion. They have same roots of Mahars of Maharashtra, jatts, Rajputs Gujarat, Rajasthan, Sindh & Punjab.

[@khuramtorab9243]

A good discussion & the speaker seems literate enough & shows authenticity. ❤

[@gagandeepsingh0988]

I’m greatly impressed the Pashtuns have such a great love and respect for their culture and language on the other hand deeply disappointed at the approach of punjabis towards their cultural and lingual symbols

[@farzandali5006]

I have seen that Sardar Punjabis are proud of their Punjabi culture and Pujabi language on the other hand Muslim Punijabis(Pakistani Punjabis) prefer Urdu and feel uncomfortable with Pujabi language

[@Gappasappa]

​@@farzandali5006true. Sadly, Pakistani punjabis have a real identity crisis. They are neither urdu speaking nor Arabic speaking

[@pranavkumar3782]

Punjabi ha ramkhor hai.... British ke gulam....daal khor puuunjabi ....india me in punnjabi ko media , bollywood se nikal dekhe 💯

[@abhaypatel4292]

​@@farzandali5006pakistan when formed on basis of religion..sadly they tried to press it over the culture that already existed and hence the clash..

[@tahseenn5649]

​​@@farzandali5006 That is not true , punjabi language didn't has any linguistics basics like alphabets or Rasm ul khat . That's why indian punjab used hindi letters to write in punjabi and here in Pakistan we used urdu letters to write punjabi. What is the difference then? These indians always try to divide us on the basis of culture and language. Social media is a dajjali media

[@ksuneetkalyanikar5619]

True to depth, real n consistent to old books of hindi, reference of ancient sanskrit, Iranian farsi is absolutely true n thx. Need more videos from you in coming days, we r deeply interested to know entire history, cultural n people of great Afghanistan. We love pashtun n information you provided is really enlightened to us. Thx, expect more to follow....

[@jaffsx]

Dr. Hanif is real scholar and genius. Fair and full control of Urdu language. Interviewer is also very knowledgeable and intelligent about human history. Need more podcasts like this.

[@ACowboy7]

From India.. highly appreciate this part.. keep it up.. 👍🏽

[@cprtariqsultan3423]

Ma Sha Allah a very valuable information about the Pushtoons has been shared. Many questions regarding Pushtoons and Pathans have been answered. Indeed the honourable guest has a reliable base of research and an in depth knowledge about the history of Pushtoons.

[@Pathan-u7q]

Another Swati found... I hope you are the same Aryan blood as this doctor and not a Pashtoon. Speaking Pashto doesn't make you Pashtoon.

[@muhammadjan7505]

I'm witness to my parents and grandparents who used this calender poh, maah, haar, jait...they were illiterate...but I used to hear names of these months for sowing and harvesting activities

[@user-gs4bu5hz5q]

These twelve months are named Chaitra, Vaishākha, JyeshTha, AashāDha, ShrāvaNa, Bhādrapada, Aashvina, Kārtika, Mārgashīrsha, Pausha, Māgha, & Phālgun

[@Pathan-u7q]

If adopting the Aryan calendar makes us Aryan, then by using the Western calendar, should we consider ourselves European or Christian, or British? It could have been the best calendar in the area when they arrived.

[@m.zareefkhan4171]

ڈاکٹر حنیف خلیل صاحب کو تاریخ خاص کر پشتون تاریخ پر بڑا عبور حاصل ہے ان کی تاریخی گفتگو سن کر بہت مزہ آیا اور معلومات میں بھی اضافہ ہوا ۔

[@bipinchandra7866]

I have not watched this video yet but can say that soon this is going to be the most watched video of this particular account. 😅 Agree or disagree but an open discussion should always be welcomed.

[@tauqeer2514]

That's mind blowing discussion, As pashtun I come to know alot about origin of pashtuns. Thanks for info

[@79alizai]

Mashallah, Wonderful , thanks to impart and revive that knowledge out of grip. MANENA Dr. Sahib and Host.

[@InfoSpireTalk]

Thank you Respected Sir.... Your works and podcasts are very much appreciated. Whenever we see you always bring here something new or very different..

[@NadeemShoukat-nz5ss]

Slam iam punjabi khushi hue aik intlacual admi se sach suna pra likha tabsra jzaak ALLAH

[@sanjaykunwar100]

Pathans are really hospitable and kind people ..my dada was stationed in Peshawar cantt...he used to tell me before 1947

[@mrjaja7303]

He was invader who invaded Pashtun lands under UK army. Your grandfather fought Pashtun tribes.

[@sanjaykunwar100]

@@mrjaja7303 Chowk Yaadgar ....in Peshawar 23 April 1930 ..when British Captain Riket ordered firing against Khudai Khidmatgar (Lal Kurti) it was Gharwal Rifles who refused to fire against their own people and countrymen... My dada was from that rifles and Freedom Fighter left British Indian Army and joined INA of Subash Chandra Bose ...fought for country independence... recipient of Tamra Patra given by Government of India 1991-92

[@AbdulRehman-il7wv]

@@mrjaja7303 these are not the pashtun Lands. Pastuns invaded them in 16th century and with Mughal help occupied them. They massacred almost 98% native Gandhari population who were already Muslims and forcefully pastunised the remaining ones. Since then there is no peace in these lands.

[@AbdulRehman-il7wv]

@@sanjaykunwar100 pastuns were never able to defeat and recover Peshawar valley from sikhs. It was British who defeated mighty sikh empire and pastuns benefited from that thus re-occuping these territories.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@AbdulRehman-il7wv hahahah when Herodotus came he named 4 Pashtun tribes. Afridis are in Khyber for 1000 of years. You can say this for city centers. Pashtuns would not live in cities they preferred downtowns as they would take care of their lands. In city centers they allowed Indics artisans. Those Indics were never comparable to Pashtuns in terms of wars/Violence. If Pashtuns watedthe would have exterminated hindkis , Gujjars , Kohistanis but no the let them live there. Mr Punjabi ghandahara has nothing to do with punjab. You are a gango like Gujrati or bihari

[@HoshTV]

Great Podcast, keep it up!

[@atjamDilMange]

پختون قوم کے آریائی ہونے کا ایک اور ثبوت ان کا ضابطہ اخلاق پختون ولی یا پختو کا ہونا ہے۔ ایسی صورتحال دنیا میں صرف دو زبانوں کے ساتھ ہے جن کے نام پر ضابطہ اخلاق ہوں، پشتو اور سنسکرت اور سنسکرت بولنے والے اپنے ضابطہ اخلاق کو سنسکرتی کہتے تھے، آج بھی یہ لفظ ہندوستان میں استعمال ہوتا ہے کہ فلاں بات ہماری سنسکرتی کے خلاف ہے، اسی سے لفظ سنسکار نے جنم لیا جس کا مطلب اخلاق ہے

[@khkarandoyzazai]

@@atjamDilMange پہلے نام تو سیکھ لے بھائی اور پھر راگ الاپ۔۔۔ یہ پختون نہیں بلکہ پښتون هے۔۔۔پښتون یعنی پښتون... " پخ " همارے ھاں پشتو میں لوھار کو کہتے ھیں اور " تون " پشتو زبان کا عام فہم لاحقہ "suffix" ھے جو لفظ کے آخر میں لگایا جاتا ھے۔۔۔ آپ لوگوں نے تو پشتو زبان کا بیڑا غرق کر دیا اور پشتون قوم کا نام و نشان مٹانے پر تلے ہوئے ہیں

[@Karlsewak-kempetai]

Sanskrit grammar was compiled by great grammarian panini( pakhtun)

[@bilalahmad8010]

Hihihi

[@JawadAli-st5ev]

Wow Wow Wow. Man, what a podcast. Very informative. ❤❤❤

[@waseemarchieve]

Zabardast podcast real research great respect for Dr.Hanif Khalil saab.

[@cheltooktribefreethinker1028]

wrong. Genetic studies shows pastun are the directly decent of Jews

[@Pathan-u7q]

Swati Aryan spotted

[@MsJibran321]

Profound historian , I also was of this thought that pakhtoons were a disappeared tribe of Jews . Doctor sahab interview changed my thought , whole the interview discussed the ancient history and the period of invasions of central Asia and Arabs . It was an elaborative interview I salute you both .

[@kiranmoghe3716]

Very interesting!!!! School history in Pak needs to be so transparent and truthful.

[@dhritimanbanerjee4630]

Thank you Dr. Hanif for such a fantastic perception of the subcontinental history and origins of this great region.

[@humayun1983]

Very informative. It's an excellent effort by Team Times Glo. Thumbs up 👍

[@TimesGlo]

Thank you ♥️

[@al_temuri]

Such a great person with a great analysis. Finally someone speaking facts and not indulging in baseless stories. insha'Allah would love to see more of the unbiased historical and other narratives within our nation. Also to add to the historical timeline is the fact that Indus Valley Civilization was already in a decline when Aryans arrived in the subcontinent. And Aryans then gave rise to Vedic Civilization which came much after the Indus Valley. But yeah Indus Valley influenced alot on Vedic Civilization and as well as Pashtuns and other aryan groups too. Modern day Indo European speaking people of the subcontinent are genetically mixed of these Aryans and those of pre existing people of the subcontinent such as Dravidians and the Adhivasis etc.

[@habibr.afridi830]

Dr Sahab masters the history of Pathans, but one cannot ignore the fact that migration to some extent happened from Europe and from Middle East. However, as migrants they were not powerful enough to sustain their own culture and language so they adopted the dominant local culture. Only in few examples language traces can still be found. A more prominent sign of European and Middle Eastern origin of some people is their complexion and body physic. A pukhtun or pathan can be very well differentiated from the rest of south asians. I am a pukhtun living in middle east and mostly people confuse me as an Egyptian.

[@ahmedmuhammad9877]

I guess just like many others you associate dark complexion with Aryans as well, which is not the case. Do a dna test you are most probably a mixed between Iran/Central Asian. Also most people from north Pakistan have European dna traces, and so does Iran or Aryan races.

[@Pathan-u7q]

The doctor is surely of Swati or any other descent. Look at his face, doesn't look Pashtoon.

[@ahmedmuhammad9877]

@Pathan-u7q what is Pashtun face? Its about time you guys educate yourself a little. Pashtuns do not have any common ancestor they are mix of Iran/Central Asia/South Asia and yes european dna is found in non pashtun people from North Pk as well. Just like any qoum pashtuns are people who follow certain culture/language and live in certain part of world, they can be of any facial feature, there is extensive research done on pashtuns because of their made up history, the research again and again actually showed that they do not have any single dna linking them to any common ancestor and keep that in mind Dna can trace thousands of years back. The tribalism made sure pashtuns stay together and their reluctance to educate themselves earlier on led the pashtuns of today think they are descended from heavens and the obsession of white skin in South Asia given them the opportunity to fuel this fire even further and made them non sensical and arrogant. North Pk is filled with people who look similar to what pashtuns fantasize what pashtun should look like but they are not Pashtun. So just like anyother nation, pashtuns are different tribes combined who share pashtun language/culture/location.

[@habibr.afridi830]

@@ahmedmuhammad9877 point received. Thanks for educating us on gun point😂.

[@Pathan-u7q]

@@ahmedmuhammad9877 blah blah blah. Speaking Pashto doesn't make you Afghan.

[@3.3m41]

Tysm for providing us with such a comprehensive, consice and authentic insight of Pashtuns

[@snehalatamalegaonkar3415]

हम विक्रम राजाको बहुत मानते हैं. उसने विक्रम संवत नामसे नया साल सुरू किया जो हम आज भी मानते हैं.

[@mohammadkashif6024]

Rudra Daman 1 ko Vikram of kannoj ne battle field me haraya tha isliye wo us saal se Vikram samvat era start kiya

[@sigma_wolfpack]

@@mohammadkashif6024 rudra daman defeated by brahmin king Gautamiputra Satkarni and end the Scythian rule in india

[@arsalanqazi88]

Dr Sb is very Good Intellact Person, he is explaining rationally & logicaly.

[@scc57-1]

Dr. Saab used historical, geographical, and linguistic origins. He missed out the biggest one: genetic The modern theories use: - linguistic - archeological, and - genetic By all three, Gandharas are aryans.

[@mrjaja7303]

Ghandara has both iranic and indic influence , both the groups co existed before Hindu influence ghandahara was ruled by Cyrus the great. So don't paint it with a single color. Iranics are different Indics are different.

[@Odyssey1408]

@@scc57-1 Gandhara was Peshawar and the locals of Peshawar still speak Hindko 😆😆😆

[@Pathan-u7q]

As a Yousafzai, it's unfortunate that our history isn't well documented. This is why Pashtoons have to see this day. When the doctor refers to different sources, like the Mughals called them "Aah wa Faghan" and then quoting Greek, he is quoting what others talk about Pashtoons, not what we are told by our ancestors. We were never of Aryan descent. If adopting the Aryan calendar makes us Aryan, then by using the Western calendar, should we consider ourselves European or Christian, or British? It could have been the best calendar in the area when they arrived. Let's mention a fact here; The Old Swatis, now living in Hazara Division, are the real Gandhari, Aryan, whatever this doctor claims Pashtoons are.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@Pathan-u7q So who are Pashtuns? History is there you are not studying it man. From Vedas and Awestan to Herodotus ad strabo and upto modern researchers have written in Afghans. Forget about the fate person/country Ali Jinnah/Pakistan (Whose poet stoled from khushal, flag from old afghan flag and nation anthem is in Persian) and read something , according to french researchers Afghans are the cousins of Ossetians and thy descended into Afghanistan 2000 years ago, the root word of Afghan is almost 2000 year old. Afghans belong to the wave of Scythians which arrived in Bactria after Greeks. Aryan is a useless work.

[@Odyssey1408]

@@mrjaja7303 Agree with the fact that Pashto and Ossetian are very close to eachother.

[@rohitpajni]

Very insightful , kudos to the production team

[@rajkumararora111]

Very scholarly and revealing discussion. Most of Indians connect themselves to the Aryans. Arya putra is a common phrase used in ancient literary refrences. Here few points are necessary to be taken into notice - * Vedas (means knowledge) are soul of Vedic Dharma. Earlier it was only veda. Sage krishna Dwepayana studied Vedas from beginning to end and edited it and devided into four sections i.e. Rig, Yajur, Sama and Atharva. Therefore he was named Ved Vyasa. *Vedic Dharma is a code for civil behaviour. But, it is not a religion. Dharma is much more than religion. It teaches humanity and there is no reference to any religion, history or gegraphy in it. Why? Because Veda was revealed to ancient sages at the very begining stage of civilization or creation on the banks of Sarsvati river in the ancient Sapta Sindh region, presently in Haryana state of India. * As stated above, as civilization advanced, it drew names of people, places and things from Veda that was revealed to bestowed upon sages called "rishies". * Vedas can be studied only with the help of its grammar called Ashtadhyaee authored by maharishi Paninee and vedic vocabulary called Nighantu plus Nirukta (vedic Sanskrit etymology)an another help book. * So no tribe or race can trace its name to veda as a historical book. Might be that their ancestors had taken their names from Vedas the divine knowledge revealed to ancient Rishies at the beginning of this present creation. Vedas refer to the continuty of creation and distraction as a cycle. * Vikaramadity or Bikramadity was not a messanger of God or any Nabi. Rather he was an Emperor whose kingdom is believed to be spread over almost beyond present Iran. His capital was Ujjain city presently in the Madhya Pradesh state of India. * It is said Education was so common under his state that even shepherds used to converse in Sanskrit language which was language of educated people. Great scholar writer of many literary works and dramas Kalidass was a bright jewel in his court where he had eight more such persons experts in their own subjects. * Bikrami year or Vikrami Samvat was established from the year when he was bestowed with the title of "Vikramaditya" which means 'sun of bravery' on giving a great defeat to shakas now believed to be sethians. Please refer to Wikipedia for more information.

[@rajkumararora111]

Dharma has many means like path of righteousness, spirituality and inherent nature etc.

[@rajkumararora111]

Real name of emperor Vikramaditya or Shahanshah Bikramjeet was Chandergupta-II of Gupta dynasty.

[@paulomi9351]

@@rajkumararora111 no Vikramaditya is title adopted Chandragupta maurya 2 of ujjain is later king 👑 There is a former vikramaditya king mentored by Jain monk kaalkacharya and his monk sister Saraswati. Jain monk kaalkacharya had gone to scynthian kings for help to save his abducted monk sister Saraswati by gardhabhil of ujjain. The scynthian kings defeated gardhabhil. Later vikramaditya and son of Saraswati and gardhabhil,both were mentored and they won against the saka kings . And vikramaditya became king of ujjain. Although Mr arora , arora are indeed suryavanshi lineage or ikshvaku lineage people which itself starts from Jain tirthankar rishabhdev or adinath. It's ikshvaku lineage to which 22 out of 24 Jain tirthankaras belong including lord Ram Not only that, when Mahabharata happened, Sindhu naresh jayadrath who was husband of duryodhanas sister , had to fight alongside the Kauravas . 22nd tirthankar neminath or arishthnemi, whose yakshi or guardian attendant diety is goddess amba or ambika, was cousin of Krishna himself. Krishna was chandravanshi or lunar Dynasty king from yaduvanshi lineage in harivansh. So lord Ram was suryavanshi khastriya and Krishna was chandravanshi kshatriya The kuru clan comes under chandravanshi lineage kings However there are suryavanshi lineage Kshatriyas too You can check out the katoch chandravanshi rajput lineage and idol of jina rishabhdev or adinath in kangra himachal pradesh fort with his sign or lanchan of bull and yakshi goddess amba or ambika. It's under ASI Jina rishabhdev or adinath, son of swayambhu Manu or kulkar, nabhi kulkar or ajanabhi. Rishabhdev or adinath attained shiv pad Nirvana or moksha on mount kailash or asthapad His son chakravarti Bharat ruled over entire bharatkshetra karmabhoomi ( 1 Arya khund and 5 malech khund) which is known part of our prithvi and hence the sankalp mantra Jambudweepey bharatkshetrey bharatkhundey or Arya khundey bharatvarshey......... Jambudweep, innermost dweep of madhyalok or middle realm of universe whose centre is mount meru or sumeru or axis mundi or galactic centre around which jyotish devas, nakshatra and navgrahas revolve around in their astral plane with astral bodies. Jainism whose ancient name is shraman dharma or anekantawad also called saman dhamma or shramanism or samanism is way ancient dharma than Buddhism and was parallel to tapas Rishi parampara and later the Vedic haum havan yagya religion So there are many Jain temple in sindh tharparkar Pakistan and multan Punjab Pakistan Sindhu sauvira janpada history is indeed very ancient and interesting All 24 jinas or arihant or arhaat or teerthankar are born in kshatriya household or royal households but they eventually give up samsaar or renunciate samsaar to obtain tri kaal gyaan or kevailya or knowledge of three kaal (past present and future) of all jeevatma in all three lokas of universe ( urdhvalok, madhyalok, adholoka) explained in Jainism cosmology. They are enlightened beings and buddh is title for enlightenment. They eventually obtain Nirvana or moksha or mukti or liberation from karmic bandhan or knot 🪢 of samsaar or rebirth cycles and permanently placed in siddhsheela or siddhlok depicted with crescent 🌙 moon sign with dot or star representing liberated soul. Siddhlok or shivlok or siddhsheela is above the highest devloka or highest realm of universe. Hence they are called siddhatma or ashareeri param Atman or paramatma or supreme spirit and perfected soul free from all vikaar so nirvikaar, nirvikalpa and nirgranth bhav dasha of satt chitt Anand awastha or eternal peace and bliss state as liberated soul is never to be born again in any of realms of universe. They are free from karmic bandhan acquired by one's own thoughts, words and actions which all contribute towards overall karmic phal. As liberation can be achieved only in manushya gati or yoni, one should aim for enlightenment and moksha in this Lifetime or otherwise our soul has to keep taking rebirth in different yoni or gati. That's essence of dharma, karma and moksha, which is basis of Jainism akka real shraman dharma from time immemorial

[@syedmuhammadjamilulhaque7201]

One of the best podcasts. Congratulations to both of them.

[@ARIJITMISHRAam]

Very nice to hear that the whole subcontinent is basically same people sharing languages, foods and cultures before Islam. Islam and politics have changed the scene.

[@Asma_Mushtaq]

That's a devastating oversimplification. 😂

[@kalhumtum]

My heart goes for them who converted to islam out of fear and their survival and now they love them who did the atrocities to their ancestors and hate them with whom they are really connected

[@faheemullah2633]

Yes, we changed for good!

[@tahseenn5649]

​​@@kalhumtum Can't you say such things to converted Christians. You wouldn't do that because they don't have any area separated from india . It Is , you have your eyes on this area nor the people." Clever banye " Have you heard this " banye ka beta kuch dekh ker zameen per girta hai "

[@kalhumtum]

@@tahseenn5649 which Christians are doing atrocities towards other faith ppl??

[@devadattaprabhat2260]

Great analysis.👌

[@dawarmajeed7635]

Very knowledgeable talk. I'm deeply impressed with Dr Hanif way of presentation.

[@dementor2003]

23:07 so he dropped the evidence from the Torah, Zaboor and Injeel for human intervention in those books. And because these are religious hence should not be used for proving the semitic link. However he is using vedic literature as his evidence. So 1. are the vedas preserved? 2. Are they not religious text? 3. Is he a hindu who religiously believes in the vedas?

[@Someone0764]

He is irrelevant and claimed many non sourced Claims 😅

[@Sarahh_28]

He's discussing Theories that people believe. Also, Rig ved is a source of knowledge (the oldest text book) about south Asians

[@wanderingsoul1189]

To certain extent, good analysis Sir. Almost correct on many points, but in few points he is incorrect. 1- Panini was not a Pashtun. Nations change, languages changes, though geography remain the same. 2- 't', 'd' , 'rh' sounds are pure Dravidian sounds. The modern Indo Aryan languages are mixed of Aryan language like Sanskrit and Indigenous Dravidian language. 3- Another point, Indo Aryan is a sub branch of Indo Iranian language family, which is further a branch of Indo European language family.

[@photon2286]

Sure but really no proof just assumptions

[@sigma_wolfpack]

@@photon2286 panini was a brahmin. thats it lived in gandhar

[@patman-bp3qg]

Indo Iranian is just Iranian which is just another word for Aryan. Indian Aryan just mixed with australoids and lost their purity. Iranic languages don't have the retroflex.

[@Newshooter11]

Great scholar and was enlightening to listen to this professor. An asset for our country!

[@Odyssey1408]

With due respect ,The city of Peshawar ,Mardan ,kabul,Swat ,sawabi,Quetta ,Kohat ,Bannu etc never belonged to Pashtuns but the pashtuns started moving into these cities after 11th century.So Claiming Panini was a pashtun is absurd and Pashtuns have nothing to do with the archealogy of buddhist or gandhara civilization .By the way Can you explain the swaddling of babies in Pakhtun households?or the picking up of groom during weddings ?Where did these traditions come from,why no other ethnic group does it the same?The pashtun way of Swaddling of babies is more like egyptian mummies .That's what the ancient egyptions did at brith and death.For those who don't know Please do some research about the local languages of Peshawar,Bannu ,Tirah valley.Those languages are no more .Take for example Tirahi ,Tirahi speakers were displaced when the Pashtuns invaded Tirah and slowly they entered Peshawar valley .How do you explain ushuji language of Swat or the Akra settlement of Bannu ?It's important not to mix up people history with that of places .If you are relating the ruins of Takhtbai or the stupas of swat ,or Bamian buddhist statues with Pashtuns just because Pashtuns are living in these Areas today ,It would be wrong ...Most languages had no grammar until reading and writing began formally or for religious purposes . Languages borrowed and copied it from nearby languages and the ancient languages and so the vocabulary .Even if we go as per your logic ,Why the closest language to Pashto is Ossetian which is spoken 4000 miles away in the Caucases but no closeness to Punjabi ,Ushuji ,Hindko(The local language of Peshawar and hazara division) ,Balochi,Kashmiri or any dardic or dravidian language? I totally disagree with you Professor sb .

[@khanofcaledonia6413]

@@Odyssey1408 I am Yousafzai and my DNA tests tells me that my ancestors have been living in Swat for thousands of years. However they did come from Uzbakistan thousands of years ago but not in the 11th century.

[@khanofcaledonia6413]

@@Odyssey1408 The Pashtun traditions are different because they are on the fringes of India separated by a difficult terrain of high mountains. Even within India the culture and language changes from place to place.

[@paulomi9351]

@@khanofcaledonia6413 Jainism whose ancient name is saman dhamma or shraman dharma way ancient dharma than Buddhism is shamanic tradition High places are holy Universe structure viewed in form of three lokas or realms of existence for soul or jeevatma in universe en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jain_cosmology

[@paulomi9351]

@@khanofcaledonia6413 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jain_cosmology

[@uk3693]

@khanofcaledonia6413. Isapzais are most likely pashtunised locals. I have seen DNA results of some Pashtuns who do not have Swat (especially barikot remains) connection at all, while others do.

[@EisaCh-gh7mv]

ACCORDING TO AFGHANS OF AFGHANISTAN 🇦🇫 THE ARYANS AND IRANIANS ARE SAME SO PASHTUNS BALOCHS PERSIAN LAZ GUJJAR JUTT RAJPUT MAZENDERANI ALL ARE IRANIAN ❤

[@mrjaja7303]

Not Gujjars , jatts , Rajputs , the are Indo Aryans. The speak Indo Aryan languages. Iranics are Persian, Pashtuns, pamiris , yaghnobis , shugnis , wakhis , Ossetian, lurs etc only. You are Indo Aryans who mixed with ancient indians.

[@AbdulQadeerKhan-d1w]

@@mrjaja7303 👍

[@AftabAlam-yi3nz]

@@mrjaja7303 gujjar jatt and Rajput are black brown people while pashtoon is brown white people

[@noumanabbasi9547]

​@@AftabAlam-yi3nzpashtuns are diverse some of them are as white as Russians from Russia I have seen few from Afghanistan and also few farsi speaking people are like that...

[@noumanabbasi9547]

​@@AftabAlam-yi3nzap Waziristan say ho???

[@Pohantoon]

Insightful conversation. The host should prepare and organize his questions before hand. Plus, he should avoid interrupting the conversation.

[@tamashbeen6610]

Couple of things established by learned professor: 1. Pashtuns are a Rig Vedic tribe. 2. To this date traditional Pashtun, who have not yet been fully Talibanized by Pakistan, still follow Hindu Vikrami calendar. 3. Pannini, the greatest Sanskrit grammarian and a revered Hindu figure, was an ethnic Pashtun.

[@kausnishant]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@kausnishant]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@kausnishant]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@kausnishant]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@kausnishant]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊q

[@NaveedIqbal-i8q]

Dr sab provoke my misconception of pukhtoon origin he proof it by logical and scientific way we all need this kind of intellectual to guide us Rather then the story teller without any logic ❤

[@DKY938]

Zabardast…very informative and intellectual information on origins of my ancestors….its so soothing to know about our past, the possibilities and probabilities of where did we come from.👍

[@Pathan-u7q]

A proper Aryan found here. A Pashto speaking man of Sanskrit descent. Apparently, you are not a pure Pashtoon lineage. Speaking Pashto doesn't make you Pashtoon.

[@DKY938]

@@Pathan-u7q my great grand father from paternal side migrated from Qandhar to Mardan 120 years ago… he was and we are from Yousufzai Ajoon khail tribe…from maternal side, I am descendant of Hazrat kaka sahib ….if that doesn’t make me a pashtoon, then you are right.

[@paulomi9351]

@@Pathan-u7q Punjab Pakistan is madra Desh from where the mother of nakul and sehdev, madri belong So it was an important mahajanapada during time of Mahabharata war where kings of distant places participated If you trace the lineage further backward you would start getting the idea of the ten rigvedic tribe mentioned in Vedas Not only that if you further go back , you would understand that Jainism whose ancient name is shraman dharma or anekantawad also called saman dhamma or shraman dharma or shamanism is way ancient and entire Arya khund mentioned in Jainism geographic reference covers such a large area The sankalp mantra Jambudweepey bharatkshetrey bharatkhundey or Arya khundey bharatvarshey...... Jambudweep, innermost dweep of madhyalok or middle realm of universe whose centre is mount meru or sumeru or axis mundi or galactic centre around which jyotish devas , nakshatra and navgrahas ( sun , moon etc) revolve around in their astral plane with astral bodies Well Mr pathan , the sun does not set beyond muddy waters It goes around mount meru or sumeru. That's geographic reference mentioned in Jainism akka real shraman dharma and Turks were shamans originally. So Jain tirthankar idols excavated from turkey and Afghanistan and kept in museum across Europe and America. Brahmi script inscription and kharosti script, sister script of Brahmi Where is your hazrat Adam ?????? Any idea 💡 as to how ancient is human civilization on this bhurlok or prithvi lok You have probably very little knowledge about the evolution of human beings, language and culture Why attan dance of pakhtoons is so strikingly similar to gujurat garba The ancient name of kabul river is kubha mentioned in both avestan and Sanskrit language Probably you are so busy in labelling everything that you forgot that there are multiple layers to one's identification. Well you can be a proud pashtun but the land that is occupied by pakhtoons and Afghans has a very ancient historical significance and link with bharatkhund and bharatvarsh itself Arya is an adjective for someone who is noble . Must have heard the word Arya Putra Unfortunately Vedic haum havan yagya religion people call everyone who follows Vedas as Arya and others as anarya which is not correct interpretation Jains are shamans and don't do Vedic haum havan yagya but both have a very ancient past and origins of tapas Rishi parampara parallelly with shraman monks goes way back in time when no religion called Buddhism nor any abhrahamic religions existed. 22nd tirthankar neminath or arishthnemi whose sign or lanchan is conch shell and yakshi goddess amba or ambika or kushmanandi was cousin of Krishna himself. They were chandravanshi or lunar Dynasty king from yaduvanshi lineage.. While ikshvaku lineage or suryavanshi or solar Dynasty itself starts from Jain tirthankar rishabhdev or adinath, son of swayambhu Manu himself Jina tatva or shiv tatva or sohum or tatva massi concept Besides praying in temples and stupas, jains have concept of timely prayers called samayik prayers and pratikaman or forgiveness prayer sitting on woolen carpet called katashna facing north ⬆️ in direction of mount meru or sumeru It has deep connection with ancient Mesopotamia and Sumerian civilization as well How ancient is pakhtun tribe on this earth ?????? While origins of human civilization on this prithvilok is much before any pakhtun tribe originated

[@mkhurramkhan8465]

Knowledgeable podcast, Dr hanif nice man.....

[@gulmetlo]

The Sindhyat is much similar to Pushtoon Wali in Sindhi society. We also called you are devoid of Sindhyat if someone is not upto mark of our Sindhyat code or values. Or we call someone is fulfilled with Sindhyat if that person strictly follows Sindhyat code. Being Non violent, hospitable, generous, empathetic, peaceful, coexistence, cultured, honourable, globalised, etc. these are ever evolving Sindhyat Values which have been continuously evolving since time immemorial.

[@kayk9204]

Very informative. Thank you for this ❤

[@roohisaleh2139]

Very interesting topic. Nice to hear about the pushton history

[@Hk18424]

Great information❤

[@aftabex]

بہت معلوماتی پروگرام ہے ڈاکٹر صاحب نے احسن طریقے سے ہر بات نہایت آسان الفاظ میں بیان کی جو علم میں اضافے کا باعث بنی بہت شکریہ ❤

[@M_Sajjad_05]

Origin of Pashtoons is such a great topic of research that it is impossible for anyone to arrive at a conclusion after listening to one scholar or one video. I have read hundreds of books on the topic and watched hundreds of videos and can confidently say that NO THEORY has satisfactorily answered ALL the questions or have solved ALL the mysteries of pashtoon’s origin, period.

[@saliksayyar9793]

Pushtuns are not one people. Many different groups who speak related languages. These are all Indo-European language. The primary language was Pakrit

[@Zangalwaal]

Pashtuns are one people- they all have the same language and customs with regional differences.

[@Divyanshusingh-gc2hn]

​@@ZangalwaalVery sorry , But there are numerous tribes among Pashtuns

[@Sarahh_28]

​@@Divyanshusingh-gc2hn we all have same DNA and speak the same language and have same culture so different tribes doesn't mean different people.

[@user-uz5cq4xo5h]

Very rational and scientific approach.

[@xphaisalx]

I’m a Pashtun from swat. I’m proud of my Afghan heritage

[@HimanshuShukla0802]

Raj Mata Gandhari was Pashtoons in Mahabharata. She was the princess of the Gandhara Kingdom and wife of Dhritrashtra, the king of Kuru. Puskalavati (I think Charsada) , Takshasila (Taxila) , Purushapura (Peshawar) , Kabul (Kapisa) and Zabul (Jabal) were cities in this Gandhara kingdom.

[@RoamingDoctors]

Don't just resist because of no reason... It has been clearly mentioned in Mahabharat about afganistan n gandhari. Religions can ​be different now but all peopleof this area are connected to each other by same ancient lineage. Even if u visit bali in Indonesia, u find same religion . Unfortunately, towardspakistan n afganistan, ancient things have been destroyed. Uncless u read other books, u can't come to know...@@fatimakhan-qf4ev

[@paulomi9351]

​@@fatimakhan-qf4evmay be you are telling about hindkowans speaking hindko and pashto language Well even Jews once were not following Judaism religion Before Afghanistan got islamized, it was ruled by hindu Shahi Dynasty and turk Shahi kingdoms Even Persians were not muslim originally When Alexander burnt persepolis ( abode of Paras kul or parsa or parsu clan people) and attacked today's Punjab Pakistan area,magadh was ruled by Nanda Dynasty rulers. There was no Mauryan Dynasty empire existing

[@paulomi9351]

​@@fatimakhan-qf4evhuman civilization is way ancient on this prithvilok

[@cheltooktribefreethinker1028]

Dnt give hawa guff here. Mahabharata is a new version of TROJAN which is a greek mythology story.

[@mickyjain7977]

@@paulomi9351 sahi not shahi bro it was later changed as shahi thx

[@sureshdewan5350]

Excellant research.

[@skmisra6187]

I there is need find out other cultural and social traditions which are still continuing in Pashtun society like names of the month

[@HassanKhan-ji4xv]

What an insightful video. Thank you!

[@bistrajendra1]

The word ARYA is Sanskrit means NOBLE. Arya people/ ARYAN= People of Noble descent ARYA PUTRA= Son of Noble family

[@mrjaja7303]

Indo Aryans are different while Indo Iranians are different. Pashtuns belong to the latter.

[@bistrajendra1]

@mrjaja7303 agree, but going by linguistics, both are branches of the same trunk. So much so that in the 20th century, it was sanskrit grammar rules(drafted by PANINI) that were used to decipher old Avestan texts.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@bistrajendra1 bakshali town is still there in mardan district from which panini belong. You are going very far. In those times Pashtun didn't descended to Iranian plateau. Panini was an Indo Aryan , a pure Indian like north indian. Pashtuns never claimed panini. Pashtuns migration to Pakhtunkhwa is not very old.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@bistrajendra1 if you want to read more about us afghans search 'Origin of the Afghan name on Google, academia has an article on it. Closest group to Pashtuns are Ossetians linguistically culturally and geographically. Indians are 180 opposite to Pashtuns in language, culture, behavior , cuisine etc. I have dug my history deeply. We belong to the iranic wave that defeated Greeks in Bactria,later another iranic wave displaced us to Kandahar region and that new wave spread to India as well. Which is the source of steepe related ancestry bin Indians

[@bistrajendra1]

@@mrjaja7303 Agree, Maybe i did go bit too far in linking the two branches based on linguistics. Please do take note of the following, basis which i will rest my case. 1)It is Dr Hanif, in the interview who ends up calling Acharya PANINI as a Pashtun from Swat. I can corroborate in my readings that Pashtuns are named in the Vedas as Patakas, who are highlighted as a tribe in around the Gandharan region. 2) The clincher to me is the nomenclature of the months. Which is easily intelligible to any one in India. These month Names are clearly from VIKRAM SAMVANT, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vikram_Samvat The only difference being that VIKRAM, whom the professor calls a prophet/ sage, is known as an accomplished King VIKRAMADITYA, who established the lunar calendar. This calendar is distinct from the 360 day Old Persian calendar. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_calendars 3) Pashai/ Pashto- while having a lot of Persian words is from the Indo-Aryan Language family. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Aryan_languages

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

Fascinating discussion very informative ❤

[@bogusrevealer9890]

Dr. Hanif seems to be a great scholar. But he fails to mention that Hinduism was the main religion of Pakhtoons.

[@mrjaja7303]

Hinduism has nothing to do with Afghanistan or Pashtuns. Pashtuns were iranic Pagan, then Zoroastrians then Bhudists them islam. We were never Hindu. Th d!rty religion where one is on top another on bottom.

[@deepes567]

They will never going to accept this they think we drink cow urine and we are dirty

[@prabhahyades1233]

Wow… this is how guys think and talk ? No wonder you guys are a situation you are in as md you deserve every bit of what you are getting. Civility and manners have no meaning.

[@osamaafridi5]

@bogusrevealer9890 No it was not...In Pashtun society, there is no concept of a caste system everyone is equal and by tradition and culture there are no Hindu pagan practices that can be seen in other Muslim ethnicities within the region. And I do not understand why you people are obsessed with deliberately labeling other communities without any solid proof and references

[@AjmalKhan-sq5qm]

Hinduism is not a religion. But a group of people living near to indus Valley.

[@politics5707]

That's why we are always proud to be Quaiden. We have such seniors and professors. Thank you dear senior for bringing such an intellectual session.

[@FAISALKHAN-sg3tv]

Dr,Hanif you Did Wonderful Job To Did That Much Study To Get very valuable Information Allah App Ko Kushkuram Rakay Ameen 🙏 I am Leaving in USA From Last 40 Years I am watching your Nice video about Pushtoon Nation 🌹👍🍀👍👍

[@HarjinderSingh-ww4cy]

Very informative conversation.

[@tahseenn5649]

ڈاکٹر حنیف خلیل کتنی لاجکل باتیں کر رہے ہیں۔ کم پڑھے لکھے لوگ ہسٹری کو بہت نقصان پہنچاتے ہیں۔ آپکی کوشش کو سلام ہے to keep the record straight

[@AsifMehmoodWaince]

Good analysis ,

[@scc57-1]

Gandhari, wife of Dhritarashtra, is the mother queen of Kauravas. Gandharas are as Aryan as they get.

[@dinozaurpickupline4221]

where are they now, what are their names

[@mrjaja7303]

Mr Pashtuns have nothing t do with Ganadhara, the are recent immigrants to that region. Hindis and Dardics are old Gandaharans and the are still counted indians. Pashtuns and Persians are cousins , they are not indians at all

[@khkarandoyzazai]

​@@mrjaja7303Avesta was written in Bukhdi present day Balkh a province in Afghanistan when vedas were not even imagined to be written...Avesta was originally written in Ancient pushto but king Cyrus1 invaded Bactria (Bakhtar) in (540-545 BCE) and hijacked Avesta and its language as well as its author zoroaster(gharghakht)... Avesta is much more older than vedas...Gandhari was merely a woman in ancient India but we still have an entire Province by the name of Qandahar its dialect, its ancient monuments and so many things to prove that pushtuns are nor Iranians neither Indians but separate Nation since many many millennia...

[@mrjaja7303]

@@khkarandoyzazai Iranian is the citizen of Iran, I accept that with time we have beacame independent. But iranic is a race. As you know the word Iran is a misnomer as there are less than 30 percent Aryans in Iran so Aryans infact are east iranics whose DNA is a proof. Both Iran and India are stealing history and rewriting it to fit their narrative. In Iran we have very few aryans that also with natufian admixture and in India there are fake Aryans whose assi reach upto 70 Percent.

[@harshnaik6989]

@@khkarandoyzazai btw every tribe and state of India has their own history and language, you cannot pin point India, India is a union of state. iam Banjara and it is speculated that we were native to gor province of Afghanistan in ancient times , and we are the largest tribal people in the planet right now but hardly anyone knows about us.

[@NikhileshSurve]

55:54 I don't think Vikram is considered as "nabi" in India by anyone. I think he was a King & the calendar starts from the day of his reign.

[@sahilsingh6048]

Pashtuns are one of the closest group to the aryans , bcz they have 40% - 45% Sintashta(indo iranian) blood.

[@mrjaja7303]

What do you mean ? With 10 percent steppe , 50 percent Indus , 20 percenr far east ancestry you consider yourself Aryan as well

[@sahilsingh6048]

​@@mrjaja730340 percent isnt a small amount. Even you have R1a paternal lineage, you can still be considered aryan.

[@ahmadbilal1626]

Hahaha bro we are westerners iranin group do you know about Aryan invasion of India before 1200bc

[@mrjaja7303]

@@sahilsingh6048 Why don't you call yourself Indus ppl , in some indians IVC ancestry reaches upto 80 percent. Whatever Aryan is they are not similar people. Even Iranians and Afghans don't match let alone indians who can be identified from 1 mile.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@ahmadbilal1626 these idiots have coined another theory they say they bareyhe original Aryans and ppl spreadout from India upto Europe , middle east and america.

[@Humayoun-f3p]

This gentleman is very knowledgeable and his analysis is excellent, I've listened to marry great historians and archaeologists and they all agree that Aryans migrated from central Asia to the Indus , where as the Indians are trying to claim without any evidence that the Indian Aryans from the Indus invaded central Asia and Europe..

[@ArnavSharma-bj4ct]

I am an indian brahmin and I know that oit is a dumbass puranik theory.

[@msg4vickky]

Talking abt pasthun, taxila, afghanistan and no mention of mahabharat.. It shows how this gentleman is limited or distorted knowledge of history in bharat varsha..

[@mrjaja7303]

Mahabharata was written by Tulsi das in 16th century, Tulsi das even failded to inform you about any temple in Ayoddhya let alone Pashtuns

[@msg4vickky]

@@mrjaja7303 The more u write.. it shows ur limited knowledge of ur own ancestors. FYI --> Mahabharat was written by Ved Vyas AND Tulsi dasji wrote --> Ramcharit Manas. It was his version of Ramayan.. So plz don't try to teach Hinduism to hindus..

[@mrjaja7303]

@@msg4vickky I have nothing to do with these books , these are all man made and man written books full of lies. These are your scriptures read it and remind happy. My history is Awestan, Zarathustraism and Gathas. Gathas and Behistun inscription is enough for us. In Behistun inscription India is declared one of the province of Cyrus's empire.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@msg4vickky You current religion is founded in lies if Tulsi das failed to inform you about any temple why you broke mosque and created temple over it? Remember supreme court never said there was any temple there. You current religion is a bunch of lies and confusion. And my ancestors ? Who are my ancestors? I have awestan and gathas. My ancestors were iranic

[@msg4vickky]

@@mrjaja7303 no comments please live in ur fantasies..

[@anilmalhani6904]

Great analysis.kudos..salute to pakhtoon brother s from India

[@Hamadani]

It was the Messianic Jewish Priest Joseph Wolff who popularized the false idea of the Jewish roots of many Muslim and non Muslim people including Pakhtoons and Kashmiris to spread Jewism in them

[@piyushsonone7]

10:22 Ahmed Shah abdali never became Ruler of Whole Hindustan

[@AbdulQadeerKhan-d1w]

The Mughal king of the time & his indian empire was his vassal state & regularly paid him tributes after defeating & subjugating him successively. Hope it's clear now!

[@user-Rayyan123]

@@AbdulQadeerKhan-d1w Still that doesn’t include whole of Hindustan 😂

[@aqeelkhan1271]

Tumhari kyu jalney lagti haa, Pathano se wasta parha hai kabhi ya bakar bakar karogey, stupid

[@aryanwarrior6233]

Eather biharis of magadha ruled whole.of afghanistan​@@AbdulQadeerKhan-d1w

[@Gangoodeshi]

@@aryanwarrior6233 Biharid ruled over Aghanistan 🤣🤣🤣 AryanDasa, the history is far more than the myths that Hindutva extremists create online every day.

[@sabahafghanistan6211]

مننه ستاسونه محترم حنيف صاحب ډير ښه تحرير اوتاقيق مو ده پښتنو ده تاريخ اوسجره په هکله واعضي کړه 👍👍👍🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫🕊️

[@baloch8961]

Word Afghan comes from aspwan (horse rider)

[@mrjaja7303]

No such thing.

[@sigma_wolfpack]

GH pronounciation is turkic

[@mrjaja7303]

@@sigma_wolfpack it was not gh , it was g only and amid Afghans specific name of the dominant ethnic group is Pashtun which is derived from parswana. Afghans are 2000+ years old in this region and turks appeared in this region after 1000 ad

[@rajeevbhatt6842]

Very knowledgeable and reasonable main.❤

[@bogusrevealer9890]

Dr. Hanif also mentions that the peace is very basis of Pakhtoonwali. Peaceful person never kills animal for consumption. Budhhism definately doesnt not allow killing animal. One question was missed by the interviewer that when the tribe started eating Non-veg food.

[@randommemories9471]

How do you explain the Aramaic writing by Ashoka only in Pashtun populated areas? Why do Pashtuns put blood of the sacrificed animals on their doors ? Why do Pashtuns light candles on Thursday nights? Why they say " Yawah " when they are in pain or in troubled situations? The dress , the footwear etc that's so common to Bani-Israeli tribes? Why our ancestors kept telling generations that they are Bani-Israel? Even the Jews researchers keep insisting that Pashtuns are Bani-Israel? There must be something so important about Pashtuns that the so " proud " Israeli keep relating Pashtuns as their own people?

[@Life_Cycles]

I am also a Pashtun, but I don't give a sh*t about who were my ancestors. We humans are all the decedents of single human couple, born somewhere in Africa and then migrated to different regions of the world. I don't have an identity crisis because I know I am just a human, and 'Pakistani' is my nationality.

[@azeemkhan327]

Do you give a shit about what your linguistic origin is?

[@il313li]

Zindabaad

[@tahseenn5649]

Oye hoye oye, global sh*t

[@MrChughad]

Being Muslim is universal solution not hindustani Or Pakistani

[@moshak4804]

Adam and Eve were not born in Africa!

[@jaffsx]

Zaburdast.

[@samarnaseer6293]

Plz read the book Panni Pathan written by mr sharif Panni which also shed light on pashtun origin

[@handle_it798]

Any reference for the word 'Afghan' derived from Greek word 'Apgaan'? I searched for this word but couldn't find in both modern and ancient Greek.

[@Indisword]

Afghan was considered Indian civilization only. Rigveda oldest book 5000 yrs old mentions king of Pakhtia, pakhtika as one of the 10 Aryan kings .

[@mrjaja7303]

Hahahah Pashtuns had awestan and gathas which are older than your vedas. We are not Indians dude. Do you really think indians look like afghan? Do you understand anything when they speak?

[@paulomi9351]

@@mrjaja7303 do you know about real saman dharma or Jainism whose ancient name is shraman dharma or anekantawad way ancient dharma than Buddhism Jains have concept of timely prayers called samayik prayers and pratikaman or forgiveness prayer sitting on woolen carpet called katashna facing north Ghenghis khan was tengrism follower from Mongolia and babar from Uzbekistan was related to him Aum , swastik and crescent 🌙 moon sign with dot or star representing liberated soul has deep associated meaning in Jainism whose ancient name is shraman dharma or shamans The Jain monks wear white coloured cholpatta or lion cloth and muslims haj dress is strikingly similar to it Khamemi Savve Jiva* (I forgive all living being) *Savve Jiva Khamantu me* (May all souls forgive me) *Mitti me Savva Bhooesu* (I am on friendly terms with all) *Veram Majjham Na Kenai* (I have no animosity towards any soul) *Micchami Dukkadam* (May my faults be dissolved) We truly ask you for forgiveness, incase I have hurt you by my thoughts (Maan), words(vachan )or actions(Kaya) 🙏🙏 Khamma stems from the word 'kshama' meaning forgiveness and ghani means 'a lot of'. This is a greeting which is deeply rooted in humility The core teachings of Zoroastrianism include: Following the threefold path of Asha: Humata, Hūxta, Huvarshta ( lit. 'good thoughts, good words, good deeds').

[@noumanabbasi9547]

​@@mrjaja7303I think you haven't been to India right??? India is much more diverse the are jaats,khatris and some elite class brahmins who look like indo European they have indo European dna among them specially up jaats from western part of up also from haryana they look similar to Persians not all Indians are dark skinned as it was portrayed by international western media...

[@mrjaja7303]

@@noumanabbasi9547 don't lie even your film Industry queens need dermatological procedures and Plastic surgeries let alone common Indian. Persians and Pashtuns are iranic ppl not indic. When bin kasem arrived to India he found jats low caste Hindus(Read anybook on Arab conquests) all the ppl in India have mixed with old Indian stock. First Zargos farmers arrived to India and mixed then came Aryan waves which also mixed there and lost their genetics , religion and culture. All India is amalgamation of a fu*ked off cultural/genetic and religious mixing. And dont show me ppl like Khans, Zoroastrians, central Asian origin ppl who migrated there and settled there. Your leading political figure Rahul Gandhi is half Italian. What can be said further?

[@Watanyar_khan]

​@@noumanabbasi9547in our university, I see very few Fair skin indian who are from north India like Nagaland etc and 90% are dark skin... Even Pakistani punjabis look fair then most of indians... And we are very different from pakistani punjabis even.... Our tradition and culture and mindset everything is too different.... We are very similar to Iranian, tajik, kurd,Turks etc

[@mrjaja7303]

I am in my third decade as a Pashtun i knew about bani Israel theory and nematullah harawai 15 years ago. This story is very old and Pashtuns themselves rejected bani Israel theory years ago and Afghan now believe in saka origin theory (Signed by French researchers) but to confuse this old man I will ask him a question. On nature journal there is a article Pashtun DNA. Where the researchers says there are some tribes in Pashtuns whose DNA have Ashkenazi fragments. Now how will he solve that ?

[@fareeda67]

They might have married some Jew women.

[@mrjaja7303]

@@fareeda67 they might have ? Who told you ? Trust me? What were Jews doing in Afghanistan? If there were where are they now ?

[@Masood-w7h]

Ashkenazi jews r not bani Israeli jews. They r converted jews from Georgia near russia

[@Karlsewak-kempetai]

Askenazis have high frequency of r1a1 haplogroup, many so called European Jews are not ethnically semetic. Indo-European were ancient coloniser of known world.Persian, north Indian, pakhtun, saka , tocharian belongs to indo- Iranian family.

[@noumanabbasi9547]

​@@Karlsewak-kempetaiwhich part of north India???

[@sahilsingh6048]

Pashtuns are my favourite ethnic group after jats

[@EisaCh-gh7mv]

WHAT ABOUT GUJJARS ❤ COUSINS OF PASHTUNS AND JATS❤

[@sahilsingh6048]

​@@EisaCh-gh7mvim not well aware of gujjars , except They are related to Hans

[@Aratiii06]

Even after they drive away Hindus 😮😮😮😮😮

[@mirzahussain4427]

Enlightened. I pray the upcoming generation takes heed🙏

[@promilajoshi7815]

Pashtuns are most civilized and kind people . My dad studied n lived in Peshawar before Partition

[@hotfun07]

Ask this from Hindu and Sikh families who were thrown out of Mirpur, Kotli, Poonch and other areas in Pok and Indian Kashmir where PASHTUN RAIDERS UNLEASHED MASSACRE, LOOT, RAPE AND GENOCIDE.

[@promilajoshi7815]

@hotfun07 sad indeed! but it was from both sides . My grandparents and parent have told me enough . I would love to visit Peshawar sone time , where my dad did his schooling and graduation too. They were so happy in Peshawar . There were no conflicts among people . Political leaders were the main culprits. One Muslim friend saved my grandparents by hiding them in his house. Hate has no end . I keep watching many videos of partition . It was from both sides. One of my grand maa was Sikh muhal. She only encouraged my dad to shift to Peshawar from khanpur as she wanted him to study . No one can understand the pains of others you are cursing pashtuns. I always thank the muslim brothers who saved my family members so no issue.. May peace and love prevail in both the countries.

[@hotfun07]

@@promilajoshi7815 OF course it was from BOTH SIDES BECAUSE MUSLIMS AND PASHTUNS NEED TO BE GIVEN BACK AS GOOD AS THEY HAD DONE. HOWEVER, THE PASHTUNS WERE NOT AFFECTED BY THE PARTITION RIOTING POGROMS LOOT AND RAPE. UNDER ABDALI, THE 18TH CENTURY PASHTUN RULE OVER THE PAKISTANI PUNJAB AND KASHMIR IS CONSIDERED THE MOST BRUTAL AND EXACTING. PAKISTANI PUNJAB AND KASHMIR VALLEY WERE BOTH MAJORITY MUSLIM. I HOPE YOUR ELDERS DIDNT TELL YOU ABOUT THIS 🤣

[@hotfun07]

@@promilajoshi7815 I hope your GRANDPARENTS had told you about the MASSACRE, LOOT AND RAPE OF MUSLIM KASHMIRI WOMEN BY THE SAME PASHTUN LASHKARS WHO HAD COMMITTED THE GENOCIDE OF HINDU AND SIKHS in what is present days Pok or AJK. It is NOT A HINDU OR SIKH versus Muslim argument. It is HISTORY and you need to come down from your high 'Secular' Horse. Learn to call a spade a spade instead of acting Pigeon spotting a Cat.

[@Divyanshusingh-gc2hn]

Times have changed , Don't try and live the past in present times And don't let that influence your mindset on status quo ​@@promilajoshi7815

[@mohammadnaeem1378]

Few corrections: Zhnad is not a language. Zhand refers to the holy scripture of Zorostrian religion. More technically, it means, "interpretation" (i.e., interpretation of the scripture of Zorostrian religion). Second Indo-Iranian doesn't mean just Persian, Pashto, and Baluchi. It Within it are included further two branches; Indo-Aryan(Urdu-Hindi, Punjabi, Sindhi, etc.) and Iranian (Persian, Paahto, etc.). Iranian represents a large language family and has further two sub-families; West Iranian, which includes Persian, Baluchi, Zaza, Kurdish, Talish, etc.; East Iranian, which includes Pashtun, Mungji, Yidgha, Wakhi, Singa;chi, etc.

[@Jeet-2023]

Very true. Pashtuns were actually true Aryans. And also the connection between indo-aryans and iranic-aryans. They are most aryans of the aryans.

[@sigma_wolfpack]

Brahmins are true aryan and milk drinkers. pathan dont drink milk.

[@girijashanker5959]

Dr: shahab ko dhanyavad hai.❤

[@baloch8961]

The Romani began to leave India about 1,000 years ago. They probably left to escape the invasion of Afghan general Mahmud of Ghazni early in the 11th century.

[@Aamir-ak47]

Ghaznawi not a afgaan he was a turk