Pakistani vs ethnic nationalism | Political history of Pakistan Dr. Rasool Bakhsh Raees

[@Sk-cr2bl]

Sumerian , Chinese, Egyptian Arab etc. civilization to suna hai but muslim civilization to sirf pakistanio se suna hai..🧐🧐🧐🧐.......

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا ، پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے ، مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جِسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@sendakan666]

Different places in India have Buddhists, Christians, Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs as majority. Why should only Muslims have special rights and not the others? We all know Aga Khan and Jinnah were playing to British interests. It was deeply painful to see our ancient land divided. But in the end, this was God's plan to protect India. Thank you Jinnah.

[@raghuvirkhanna7636]

Nothing good came out of partition.your last line shows you have been reading too much of what's app nonsense of Indian rightwing

[@subhadippaul4494]

there would have been a complete demographic shift within 30-40 years if partition didn't have happened...the end of INDIAN CIVILIZATION ! so thank you jinnah

[@Ayanokoji-v1u]

I see myself Human first then Punajbi then Pakistani.😊

[@warpeace4469]

🤣💩

[@farzandali5006]

Sir there are Punjabi Saraeki, Sindhi, Pashtun and Baloch nationalities with their own Languages and cultures but they are the citizens of Pakistan. You can not make a nation on the bases of religion only

[@nowie4007]

Agreed 👍

[@junaid_2107]

Jinnah ko bhi bataya logo ne but his ego was too big to understand.

[@shakeeladnanhashmi]

Then what was the " Riasat of Madina" 1:28

[@shakeeladnanhashmi]

Then what was the " Riasat of Madina"

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

@@shakeeladnanhashmi پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@Sk-cr2bl]

Muslim jab india se hai and islam bahar se aaya to pakistanio ka sambandh to indus civilization se hai to pakistani muslim civilization se kyo related karta hai.... professor sahab confuse hai.....🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@atulgupta8522]

Really amazed at the level of incompetence and half baked knowledge of this pakistani professor… bhagwan bhalaa kare Pakistani students kaa 😂😂

[@chitranjankaur6346]

India Mai punjab first language hai hindi second language but English compulsory language Hai. HAM apni mother language ko preference dete hai. I am from Punjab. Proud to be Punjabi and Hindustani first

[@usmankhaki]

Yeah Bhaya hy UP CP DA. ENO ke pata Punjabi Punjab Punjabiyat. Yeah loka nr Punjabia da gaq khada.

[@chitranjankaur6346]

@@usmankhaki 47 di mar khadi punjabian ne. Jinah jagirdara da socha. Oh changa vakil c politician nahi. Pak dub geya nahi ta hindhu muslim ekthey reh sakde c. Jinah ne islami mind set bana dita. Sab angreja tuo ajad ho ke . Ajad bhart bana ke khush c that's all. Gandhi ne keha jinah desh chala layenga? Jagirdaro nu hi preference diti uss ne jo pakistan da eh hall ho geya. Religion jajba eh sab nahi c hona punjab de Muslims just like us changa bhai chara hai koi nindhu muslman nahi sochda 🙏

[@usmankhaki]

@@chitranjankaur6346 Sohnya Punjabia nu mar jinnah de nal nal Tara Singh ty Nehru ne diti

[@tamashbeen6610]

Sahi keha bibi tain.

[@warpeace4469]

@@usmankhaki 🤣 punjab land da naam hai qoom nahi .grunanak say pehlay saray punjab de rahan alay hindu san bat cho sikh aue muslaman huai

[@babarchatha8200]

Precisely explained the creation of Pakistan and its people.

[@Fatima-dy1gi]

I can proudly say that I'm proud Pashtun

[@sikandar-s-podcast]

Proffesor Sahab called 'Balochs', 'Balochis' RIP Proffesor-ship

[@syedmuhammadjamilulhaque7201]

The host should have been very well prepared. Still the effort must be appriciated. This is 2nd podcast of the group. The 1st one was extra ordinary on origion of Pakhtoon and related things. Pakistan is the result of gradual shift تدریجی ارتقا of independence movement of India to a separate homeland .

[@mjiqbal810]

14:30, Professor sahib was amazing and taught a lesson to the host who has no sense of history and even how to lead a discussion. Every tom, dick and harry (in pujabi "eara ghaira") in Pakistan becomes intellectual, starts a youtube channel and becomes expert on history and nation building.

[@TimesGlo]

Im a student of history learning things. At least, what we do is to initiate a dialogue and it takes huge energy and efforts. You are a loser and have no regards for someone who is working hard. GTFO!

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

@@TimesGlo پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@faisalch743]

@mjiqbal810 I think the anchor has Guts and respect, because he is letting the guest speak and not interrupting him often.... Rest ....we all remain in the learning process till the end ..

[@zahidahmedali7083]

Rasool's narrative is contradictory because his view is constructed from the perspective of Pakistan. And he has constraints which he may not go outside. He should ask himself why Muslim identity was not claimed when Mughals ruled India? Why then the idia of Pakistan was not formed? Why then partition of India was not carried out. Was that not easy then? Why Hindus like Nehu and Patel might not have accepted it then?

[@junaid_2107]

He is product of Pak studies, if you cannot come out of pak studies 100%, you will never be 100% logical and get clear picture.

[@dattaprasadjoshi6191]

90% Pakistanis have hindu roots, hindu past and hindu ancestry..

[@shahmoneyshahmoney9250]

lar aka pakistan bar india loya greater pakistan

[@NisarAhmed-mn6ix]

Dear sir if religion is not a unifying factor ,then why we were separate from India.how Muslims in Arab are fighting each other.language and culture may be be a unifying factor.this is a very complicated matter & day by day this differences increasing. If we as a Muslim want to be a united as a nation we should unite on one point agenda what it may be other wise it will be a great desaustrous for every one.

[@AK-gi1ke]

If Islam was not reason creating Pakistan so Muslims can freely practice their religion, what other Cause could be to create another country? True large Muslim population was in rest of India but everyone had an option ti live wherever they chose Some scholars and historians believe that neither cause was justfied nor there was a need for another country They forget the precarious conditions facing Muslims in India

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

Alhamdulillah I am first Punjabi than Pakistan

[@xpsmango4146]

Land cannot be connected to a religion. The people have had different religions in different times. Doctor sahib is discussing events in history and he is aligning himself with the official narrative of the government. Sindhi, Balochi, Pashtun & Punjabi are distinct nationalities, even to this date after Partition. Objective of a homeland for Muslims was successfully achieved in 1947. This alone was no small task and indeed a miracle. To expect that the nationalities would dissolve within Pakistan is not fair, specially when the resources were not distributed equally.

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

Saraiki/Multani is not Ethnicity ,its Punjabi people and Baloch People

[@shakeeladnanhashmi]

دانشمندی میں حتمی رائے جہالت ھے

[@tedtalksdhillon8751]

پنجابیاں دی اَپنی مختلف پہچان ہَے اِس نوں مذھب دے نام تے تقسیم نہیں کیتا جا سکدا زبان اور لہجہ دا تعلق کسے مذھب دے نال نہیں ھَے لیکن افسوس اِس گل دا ھَے کے پنجابیاں نے اَپنی تہذیب اور زبان نوں محفوظ نہیں رکھیا اُلٹا اُردو نوں توجہ دے کے اَپنی ماں بولی دا قتل کروایا پھر دسو کس دھرتی دے پُت ہوئے مان نوں چھڈ کے بیگانے پُت بن گئے ، ہور کسے بھی قوم نے ایح حرکت نہیں کیتی چاہے اوہ سِندی ، بلوچی یا پشتون ہوّن لیکن اوہ پنجابیاں ورگے بے غیرت نہیں بنے میں جسم دے مر جانے نوں موت نہیں سمجھدا ضمیر دے مر جانے نوں اصل موت سمجھدا ہاں پنجابیاں دی ضمیر مر چُکی ھَے

[@Hamadani]

Prof. has unwittingly separated Islam from Muslims. However, Islam is neither superseded by ethnic considerations and identities nor can the Muslim Identity be separated from Islam. Hence, time will prove the reality that political activism of Muslims was the vacuum filled in absence of a Free Muslim Regime at that time, under the preponderance of British Rule. Geographical constraints lay high because of the lack of Muslim Military Power, which could not unite the dispersed Muslim population across the sub-continent. The process of gathering of the Muslims of the sub-continent under the banner of two-nation theory, which is based on Islamic precepts is still going on; Kashmiri resistance against Hindu India and recent events in Bangladesh is a prime example of the same. Separation of Bangladesh was an exclusively foreign-designed and sponsored phenomenon...

[@tamashbeen6610]

The person who does not honor and speak in his mother tongue should never be respected or trusted.

[@NikhileshSurve]

7:56 I'd say Nations are cultural constructs (including linguistic) & States are political constructs. 32:27 Of course Mauryan Empire never existed 😂. This is where I got convinced to take his expertise with a pinch of salt. 38:49 That's no justification for continuing to not teach Punjabi in schools of Punjab even after the British left. You could've introduced compulsory Punjabi teaching in English medium schools, made Punjabi an official language of Punjab Province & do all the Provincial government work in Punjabi. 41:34 Many States have seen opposition to compulsory hindi teaching but most States have kept teaching their own language in their schools. Also if Punjab in India could introduce teaching of Punjabi then Punjab in pakistan not doing it & giving lame excuses for it is just a display of intents of politicians & governments in respective Punjabs on both sides.

[@endeavour1349]

You can be all those things and be nationalistic too. This narrow vision is annihilating cultures that bind you to the land that cradles cultures and languages. Uniformity imposed kills those emotions. And one is left with no roots. Politics that caters to mere power structures is the problem.

[@Vitcini]

پروفیسر صاحب تو بالکل ھی مطالعہ پاکستان پڑھانے لگ گے ھیں وہی مہاجر مڈل کلاس کمپلیکس

[@usmankhaki]

Exactly Muhajir

[@mahboobkhan3710]

There are Punjabis,Saraikis,Potoharis,Pashtoons,Hindkowal,Kohistanis,Citralis,Baluchis,Sindhis,Gilgitis,Baltis,kashmiris and so many.They are Pakistanis by nationality and 94 percent Muslims by religion.Religion comes first,then country,then language/culture and so on.What is strange in it?The so called GB has English, Scott, Welsh and Irish.They are Christians,British and so on.Not to make complications pl for God sake.Digital terrorism.

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

Saraiki/Multani,Pothowari,Hindko all are Punjabi

[@paulomi9351]

​@@PunjabiMuslim510 fact Hindus in the vicinity of Pakistan is their living past, which they are denying vehemently. What Pakistanis say about their pre-islamic ancestry: All those whose title is Sheikh are Arabs: The fact is that all Sheiks are either converted from Kashmiri Pundits or from Khatris like Saigols. All those with title of Mirza are descendants of Mughals: This is only partly true, as most of the Rajput converts and even non converts were given the title of Mirza like Mirza Raja Jai Singh. All those with the titles of Saiyyad are true descendants of Mohammad: This is mostly fake. People took this title to extract respect from common folk. Although there are some true Saiyyads , The first Saiyyad in Sindh married local Sindhi Hindu girls(As per Kitab ul Hind by Al Beruni) thus even the true Saiyyads have local Hindu blood from mother side. All those with the title of Awans are Arabs: While the first census of India was being carried out in 1870, the british officers find it very difficult to distinguish Awans from Hindu Rajputs as their customs were astonishingly similar to Hindu Rajputs. The current effort on the part of Awans to align with Arabs is for the same purpose as elicited at point 3. Dilip Kumar(Yusuf Khan) the film actor is Awan. All Arains are also Arabs: Till Jia ul Haq usurped the throne of Pakistan, Arains were comfortable with their Hindu ancestry. They were and are vegetable growers and gardeners. With Jia’s elevation, Arains suddenly became Arab for obvious reasons. All with the title of Janjua are Arabs: In Suleman mountain, coins of Maldev Janjua has been discovered. This is a matter of Shame for Janjuas rather than pride as they have framed themselves up as Arabs. All with the title of Wattu are Arabs: They are infact Rajputs but prefer to call themselves as descendant of Arabs but shy away at the proposal of DNA test. Khokhars: Khokhars call themselves descendents of Arabs but actually they are related to Jats, Hindu Khokhars created havoc in the Army of Mahmud Ghajnavi when Jaipal attacked Ghajni to take it back in around 980-990 AD. Hindu Khokhars killed Shahabuddin Ghori on the right bank of Indus near Attock in 1203 AD. There are still some Hindu Khokhars in India. All with the title of Khan/ Pathan are actually Pakhtun and all Pakhtuns are Afghans and all Afghans are the lost tribes of Bani Afghana of Israel: The theory was promulgated in the medieval era but is refuted by DNA test. Some Pathan as told in the beginning are recent converts from Rajputs. Afghans have some Tadjik elements also. Pashto is an Indo-Iranic language and is not related to semitic language. According to Farishta, Afghans including Pakhtuns were Hindus and Pagans before their conversion to Islam. Muhammad Ghorí’s great grandfather Shansban was Buddhist. Similarly Tigin Shahis were turks and were Buddhists before converting to Islam. Khan is the title of adopted by any noble Hindu convert to Islam , some times even barbers also used this title after conversion. However every Khan wants to identify with Pakhtuns. All Ansaris are those Madinites who helped Muhammad in Madina: Ansaris in the Indian subcontinent are converts from weaver community of Hindus. They took this title as a semblance of respectability. They are still in the job of stitching, weaving and tailoring. All Quraishis are those Quraishi clan to which Muhammad himself belong to: Qureshis in India are converts from Hindu Butchers or Kasabs. They took this title for the same reason of respectability , It was a clan decision to convert and clan decision to take this title. However there are Jats , Rajputs, Gurjars , Khatris, Kashmiri Pundits and Ahirs in Pakistan who acknowledge their Hindu Past. They proudly keep their titles as Bajwa, Randhawa, Johia, Tomar, Deol, Rathore, Chauhan, Minhas, Salaria, Salathia, Shan, Rana, Raja, Satti, Bhutto, Lohani, Bhatti, Jadoun, Sumra, Samma, Sasan, Ghil, Maan, Gujjar, Katariya, Khatana, Kapur, Kohli, Sethi, Saigol, Bahal, Kakar, Khatri, Bhat, Rao, Rangher. Some Pakhtuns’ title like Sarwani, Shahbani, Shahukhel, Kakar,Khosa, Bamzai, Karzai, Sadozai, Barakzai, Mahmand, Suri, Khattak, Afridi, Shermankhel, Mahsud, Lodi have in themselves definite Hindu and even Greek connotations. Greek historians Plini, Strabo and Sanskrit Grammarian Panini has thrown some light on the people living in what is now Khaibar Pakhtunkhwah. Also with little linguistic retrospection above tribes might be previously known as Suryavanshi, Shahvanshi, Shahkul, Kakar, Khosa, Vam, Kar, Sat, Varak or Virk, Mahamand(Or great Mand: Mand was a Shaka tribe), Sri, Shatak, Aparitai (Greek tribe), Srimankul, Mahashudra(Shudra was not a non Aryan tribe, rather Alexendar fought with Kshudraks a warrior tribe, Sud is still the title of Khatris of Punjab who are upper caste), Lydoi(A Greek tribe). Thus we can infer that these tribes originated from Hindu or Greek ancestors even the Yusufzais call themselves as Isap in their own gatherings, this Isap is the same as Aspesians who under their queen Kripi gave brilliant resistance to Macedonians under Alexendar the great in Massaga(some where near Peshawar) sometime in 327BC. Kripi in Greek sources is mentioned as Kleophis. Kalash kafir people of the Chitral and Hunza still worship Mahadev and Yimraj and follow a primitive Vedic religion. Only 2000 left now as rest are converted by abduction of girls and forcibly conversion of men. They were masters of a province of Kafiristan in north east Afghanistan till 1896. In brief, some 20% of Pakistanis are estimated to be from Turkish/Afghan/Mughal/Arab origins and rest 80% of purely indigenous. Among these 80% , mostly they were Hindus or a mix of Hindus, Buddhists, Animists and Zoroastrians and Jainism at the same time. Even in the remaining 20% there is substantial proportion of Hindu blood from mother side en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lohana All Sikh gurus were Khatri themselves Jinnah was vaishnavite lohana with surname thakkar which comes from takkar province of Afghanistan Alama Iqbal was kashmiri pandit or saraswat Brahmin with surname saproo Liaquat alis wife was converted Brahmin into Christianity and later into islam Malik gafur was hindu converted to Islam Birbal was saraswat Brahmin Mahesh das bhatt And list goes on and on and on

[@paulomi9351]

​@@PunjabiMuslim510 whereas sindhi kutchi are sibling languages Sindhi : tunjo nalo cha aye( what is your name) توهان جو نالو ڇا آهي Kutchi : tunjo nalo koro aye( what’s is your name) Now they got separated from each other after partition Memoni language is a mixture of mainly Kutchi, Sindhi & a little bit of Gujarati. The Memoni language originated from Kathiawar, which I believe is close to the city of Rajkot, Gujarat now. Gujurati language came from sauraseni prakrit and apbrahmsa and uses devanagari script for writing which is used for sanskrit So both Aryan and Dravidian languages have same roots and ancestry Check out spread of brahmi. Kharosti sister script of brahmi written from right to left There is no Aryan invasion and dravadian divide. However human civilization is way ancient and we have continuous history and long list of Chakravarti kings and ramayana and Mahabharata did happened Only during times of Mahabharata and ramayana, bharatvarsha covered large geographical area and it was not confined to today's india So proofs of these events are scattered. Check out kamboj Jatt clan We are descendants of living civilization but have lost touch of our own ancestry and history

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

@@paulomi9351 Bro what about Arain Caste please

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

@@paulomi9351 Bro But Saraiki is recent development in 1960 and 1981 census General Zia ul Haq accepted Saraiki Language. Saraiki Language has no History before 1960 . Multani, Derawali, Riasiti are real name all are dialect of Western Punjabi. pothwari, Hindko, Pahari all are Same dialect only some regional difference. All are dialect of Western Punjabi

[@uz7098]

32:10 Please read about Mauryan empire whose empire not only included the whole of India and Pakistan but it stretched all the way till afghanistan. I seriously take offence when such half-read "intellectuals" Claim to know history and say India kabhi ek entity nahi tha.

[@obaidullahmirwani2923]

Majority speakers says "Balochi" not balochi "BALOCH

[@zardusharyazadraan3608]

ہندوستان ہزاروں سال سے ایک تھا چندرگپت موریا نے نے ایک کیا تھا اگر راجے مہاراجے تھے بھی تو کیا سارے ہندوستان میں ایک سکہ نہیں چلتا تھا ہندوستان ایک تھا یہ تو البیرونی کے کتاب سفرنامہ ہند میں لکھا ہے

[@zardusharyazadraan3608]

پاکستان الگ نہیں ہوتاتو بنگالی بھی الگ نہیں ہوتے کیوں کہ پاکستان کے طرح فیصلے جرنیل نہیں منتخب پارلیمنٹ کرتی جیسا کہ آج تک بھارت میں میں ہوتا آیا ہے

[@obaidullahmirwani2923]

Pakistan is a country but not a nation

[@HimanshuShukla0802]

British were liberal. They spread education and modernity in India. They treated all equally. They encouraged those who were willing to acquire knowledge. Hindus grabbed the opportunity and rose to eminence in British India. At the same time Muslims chose to remain inside the cocoon they wove around them. Mullahs prevented the Muslim mass from going to schools and colleges except to Mosques and madrasas where they studied only Koran. By the time Britishers left this country, Hindus were in dominant positions whereas the Muslim.were cycle repairers, umbrella makers , Barbers , water puller odd mechanics devoid of modern education. It is another glaring example to show how Islam is pulling Muslims backwards in their race of progress and civilization. Not only Indian muslims even now Pakistan , Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq , Lebnon , Iran , Saudi , Qatar muslims couldn't get a single noble prize from thier own muslims lands.

[@faizanhaider4713]

ڈاکٹر صاحب یہ تو آپ نے عجیب بات کردی کہ سندھی میں پڑے ہوئے سندھی سی ایس ایس نہیں کرسکتے آپ کے معلومات کے لیئے عرض کروں جتنے بھی ابھی تک سندھی سی ایس ایس کر چکے ہیں وہ سندھی میڈم اسکولوں سے پڑے ہوئے ہیں ابھی تک انگریزی میڈم اسکولوں سے پڑے لکھے سی ایس ایس میں نہیں بیٹھے آپ کا تجزیہ غیر معیاری ہے اور خدا کا خوف کریں اور بلوچستان میں پارٹیشن سے سندھی میں تعلیم دی جاتی تھی اور انگریزوں کے زمانے میں خطے کا روینیو رکارڈ سندھی زبان تھا کے پی کے تک کی بات کر رہا ہوں۔

[@Agnostic-1]

Sultani & Mughal period ke aage kohi bara empire nehi tha india mey😮😮😮. Sir aap sach main Pakistan ke professor or intellectual hai na? Pakistani student ka bedagark ...😂.

[@mustafahaider8926]

Even till this day you can’t mention Hazara contribution for pakistan But you can say hazar or some other work you gays using It’s better be quiet 🤐 if you cant say 100% facts

[@saidkhan2125]

Muslims are not one nation as Arab a big Muslim majority speaks different language having different cultures different traditions etc don't mislead people with fake information.

[@itzbeleiver]

Professor 😅😮😅😅😅

[@usmankhaki]

L ka professor

[@atifhussain3409]

Just to please the honorable guest We are Seraiki Happy ?

[@usmankhaki]

There is no saraiki in this world. Saraiki created by Zia Ul haq

[@atifhussain3409]

@@usmankhaki alright, thank you

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

Saraiki are created identity Real name Multani are dialect of Punjabi

[@saidkhan2125]

Rasool sahib confusing history just to defend ruling class Punjabi domination.pakistan is not one nation but consist of different nationalities. Majority of Baluch do not live in punjàb or other province.our Punjabi so call intellectuals needs to be out of schvavinist behaviors.

[@PunjabiMuslim510]

In his book Searchlights on Baloches and Balochistan, first published in 1974, Mir Khuda Bakhsh Marri, who served as Chief Justice, Governor and Chief Minister of Balochistan, estimated the Baloch population in Punjab to number around 6 million, constituting around one-fifth of Pakistan's Punjab province which at the time stood at roughly 30 million

[@ala7515]

Professor is failing to understand adhering to culture and language is a sign of power not weakness. In India, I studied in my mother tongue not in Hindi, and then learned English as well. I'm proud of my local identity and doing very well in my professional field. Stick to your culture and language.

[@ala7515]

Urdu is not even a Pakistani language but is being adopted as a de facto language suppressing local languages. This will eliminate the local language and therefore the regional culture.

[@atulsehgal8670]

Ye Ashok aur Chander Gupta’s Maurya they master ji

[@atulsehgal8670]

Jo log Hindustan mein reh gaye un ko saath le jane sey mana kyon kar diya

[@atulsehgal8670]

Angerz jab chala Gaya to Punjabi kar lenı thee . Hindustan ke Punjab mein Punjabi Parai jati hai . Main college ka Hindi Punjabi aur English ka topper hoon . Punjabi kyon mana ki kyon jo ye muzahron ki juban hai . A sad o log met parents ke muzahre they . Is master sey mera interrogation karwa . Mein brain wash karoon bhai ka .

[@atulsehgal8670]

Prof ko Understanding Mohammad by Ali sina padna chahiye . I am 100% sure in ho ney Quran Urdu mein bina chhod chad ke nahi pada . Nahi to in ko moosla hone pey dharam aati . Mujhe thin aati hsi quran pad key . Jo baat karna chahe apna number dey main usey pada doonga . Tahin sona mob number dey