Who Are These Supposed Religious Jews Who March With Hamas?

The Horrific Behavior of Neturei Karta
Thumbnail Photo: Representatives of the fringe group, Niturei Karta presenting gift of a model of the al aksa mosque on the Temple Mount to Hamas leader, Ismail Haniyeh (ימ"ש)
An excerpt of "Talkline With Zev Brenner" - Are Neturei Karta Jews? Rabbi YY Jacobson & Jake Turx Senior White House correspondent of Ami Magazine discuss and debate how we should relate to the small number of members of our community that belong to the anti-Israel group that supports Hamas and other enemies of the Jewish people.
To sponsor or dedicate an upcoming class click here: www.theyeshiva.net/donate
To watch more classes & to read Rabbi YY's articles visit: www.theyeshiva.net
Follow Rabbi YY Jacobson:
KZbin: / rabbiyyjacobson
Facebook: / theyeshiva
Instagram: / yyjacobson
Twitter: / yyjacobson
Linkedin: / yyjacobson
Telegram: t.me/RabbiYY

[@shlamushaaretz5357]

Rabbi YY, for years I have been troubled that no rabbinic authority has publicly stood up against Nutri Karta, so I thank you for taking this most important stance.

[@knowledgeisstrength2554]

Actually over the years many Rabbis openly spoke out against them. Even the Satmar Rebbe who is known not to be fond of the state of Israel openly spoke out against Neturei Karta a few times recently.

[@jamesrowland9982]

Because they want no appearance of conflict in klal Israel and unity, they are willing to overlook things like the NK's

[@saraleigh5336]

@@hot2handlethe Satmar are Ashkenazim.

[@zvell636]

Jacobson is not a rabbi. יהודי לא ציוני 🇵🇸

[@musicman1770]

Your statement is categorically false @@zvell636

[@sharmundt6188]

That's how I have viewed this issue for years as well. For someone who is Jewish by lineage who does not do any act of being a Jew, I do not see them as Jewish because their outward also has to be their inward too and the two need to marry up and be a union otherwise is is dysfunctional at best. It does not mean their lineage isn't Jewish to say they are not Jews. It is that their actions to not align with being a Jew and they act like the other Heathen instead of the children of HaShem.

[@charliebrownie4158]

I know I've been saying that. I was being instructed by more than a few rabbis when I was first coming to knowledge of my Jewish ancestry. Of which I didn't know anything about until 1998 when my grandma's only sister was dying and the death bed explanation came forth and of which shoulder sister was quite a shame to be thought of as being Jewish. My grandma wasn't my mom wasn't and I wasn't but I decided back then in 1998 that I wanted to learn as much as I could. And I enjoyed the learning but I also understood a lot based on how I perceived the way that people related to each other as Jews. Although I don't really like that term cuz it it makes it seem like the only real people are the people of the tribe of Judah. Whereas I know that there are many of the other tribes that are not lost they're in the areas where they're at but slowly and surely they're coming forward to return to Israel. One day I will too. But until that golden day comes I can persevere and try to live my life as best I can. And to be the kind of a person that I can be who Hashem would want to be proud of that the spirit that he put in US would resonate with us like Ezekiel in the valley of Bones. And yes I've had other people even some Christians who have told me that they think that the value of the bones is that the people killed in Holocaust will be risen to fight if need be in a war to save us from the enemy.

[@Leosandoval-pd6di]

David was betrayed by doeg and achitophel, yosef was sold by his own brothers, during inquisition and holocaust, people betrayed each other. I don't know why it's so difficult to accept that our worst enemies can sometimes be those close to us.

[@kakaroto7578]

you're right, but still hard to accept

[@charliebrownie4158]

It's horrendous it really is. As a matter of fact wasn't not one of the greatest Jewish Minds who supported barkova in the revolt against Rome and by the Roman Caesar at the time had put together a situation where they wrapped together a bunch of things so that when he was going to be killed they wanted it read to him all the sins that he was going to be killed for and one of those was for what happened with the selling of Joseph into slavery. And it was said after them that that they put an injunction saying anybody who taught Torah or scriptures to people who are not Jewish should be killed. Now the reason why a brother can defend again or go against her brother is because it's easy to do when you know you're the person for example Norman Finkelstein. I would never harm the person but I have no respect for him. I've got even less respect for him than I do for the people who are standing with terrorists of whom I have absolutely nothing in common with if they're going to do that. Any more so than I like the religious ones who have also said that they felt that the Holocaust occurred because of greedy Jews in Germany. As I've read from different people who claim to have heard these people saying such that was broadcast in Germany before the war even began so it was before 1939 obviously. It's it's horrendous but it happens. My dad who was not Jewish was my mother who was Jewish. But my dad told me of a time when he looked up and saw that his brother his oldest brother was with bunch of kids from school and they were all beating on him. He talked about how he felt so much like he'd been betrayed by that brother of his. Yet when I talked to the counselor about those kind of things they were explaining to me about what happened with their brothers and how that he said the greatest thing ever happened to my brothers was we moved away from we all moved to different states. Because we always fought always he said we were all alphas and we all had fists and we were going to use them. Sometimes Brothers will fight sometimes they will not team up to overcome an adversary and that is sad.

[@ruthyk7083]

Jewish historians and talmudic tractates have flatly stated that it is always us who can destroy us the most. Particularly interesting that it's discussed by the Kli Yakar re the burning bush in this parasha. The Chofetz Chaim discussed it as well.

[@joshgarbemusic]

Meaning the Zionists?

[@Leosandoval-pd6di]

@@joshgarbemusic are you that stupid? Do you not realize betrayal exists in all cultures, even among family members? You should search for biggest betrayals in history and get informed.

[@savtamarlene]

Most of the Jews in the kibbutzim in the south that are close to the border of Aza who were massacred by hamas and the fakestinians, who helped, aided and abetted hamas, were GOOD FRIENDS and workers of these PEACENIK secular Jews. In fact, one of the older women who was taken hostage and later released looked sinwar in his eyes and asked him..”How could you?! We were friends!!! “. He looked away from her without responding! Our daughter, jewinthecity, walked up to nuteura karta at an Israeli Day parade in NYC several years ago and asked them why they do what they do? The response was to HOPEFULLY save their own lives!!! DISGUSTING!

[@naomilevell9990]

Yeah, they need to read what Mordecai said in the book of Esther if they think that's a workable survival strategy...

[@rickymanne9266]

“So in times of distress their first instinct is to save themselves, turn against their people, and side with a movement/religion that has a “New” Book, From… Him ? Oookaaaay… Let’s see how well that works out for them, in the near future. They’re about to get a really, REALLY big surprise ;)”

[@TimothyDeSomerville]

Worked for the Christians​@@rickymanne9266

[@TimothyDeSomerville]

Modern Zionism is a Sodom and Gomorha. It is only Kosher to not accept the laws and customs of the false idol regime called Israel.

[@bellira3979]

Like the men that God sent to watch the promised land that refused to enter the land because they had fear.

[@menajembenchimol8109]

Thank you Rabbi YY for putting a firm line of what we cannot tolerate. Why is it so hard to do that?

[@InkaPley]

❤

[@abuzolfiqar2122]

Because Zionism is apikoros according to SHAS and every single Posek in the world before the heretic Kook so its pretty hard to denounce people for actually practicing Judaism.

[@chriskessell4579]

BDS israel FREE PALESTINE from the UK, the West knows about mass migration of non Christians into Christian counties done by Zoinist israel research who's funding NGOs like IsraAID, Barbara Learner Spectre, watch Europa the last battle , the USS Liberty , sick of Zionists and their lies.

[@baileysmith2434]

You can not side with EVIL if you side with EVIL. YOU ARE EVIL!!!!

[@Mikey-jb3nd]

I'm a Catholic who has always been interested in biblical history, including Jewish history, and I am shocked about the subject of this video. I was unaware that such a group of non-traditional, Jewish people existed. It makes no sense to me. It's so horrific.

[@shaulwiesen7876]

Catholics and other Christian/fascists from Ukraine,Latvia,Lithuania,Hungary ,Romania ,Slovaks and of course Germany/ Austria mass murdered the most tradional Jews,some 80 years ago,so we are left with a much less traditional Jewish public,than we had in 1924..

[@jittmet7766]

They're fringe lunatics but the Jewhaters love them.

[@weakglovehand82]

Virtually all religions have their own version of Neturei Karta. It's just that with the peculiarity of antisemitism, how it has existed across history and how it rears its ugly head yet again, the consequences of their tokenism, their self-hating testimony is so much greater than, say, if a Catholic-appearing individual were to call for the destruction of the Vatican or of an entire Catholic state. They would be laughed out of the city walls, whereas NK serve to confirm the bias of every antisemite...."If these ultra-Orthodox Jews agree with my anti-Zionist world view, then I must be right!" Conversely, there is no world hatred of Catholics--or any group for that matter--as there is toward the Jewish people. So, the power dynamics at play here wouldn't be easily replicated among other groups.

[@unitjeter9451]

They are the traditional ones and represented the absolute majority of Jews till the temptation of a state became too much for them.

[@shahzadrafiq4534]

If you were unaware what is your level of knowledge. God exiled them, and spread them, this is a rebellion

[@user-vx3wm4hn5i]

I have seen them backup Anti israel demonstrations After October 7. I have seen them join a panel against israel after October 7. I have yet to hear them condemn Hammas . Maybe it’s not completly evil what they are doing ??? Why would the host say that ??? Sorry that was a horrible thing for him to say .

[@mrcomenttoe2009]

Everybody pray and hope for goodness to overcome evil all over the globe

[@aharonfaiman8834]

I have never heard Nuterei Karta offer any solutions. What do they propose should be done? I am totally in line with Rabbi Jacobson. May all us Jews be blessed with the ability to truly love each other and support each other and inspire each other to become closer to Torah and mitzvos.

[@kakaroto7578]

they're completely insane, the "solution" they offer is giving the land to the so called palestinians and wait until "god" give the land back to them, and i say them because they consider themselves as the only jews. They even refuse to talk to other jews, but they met Iranian leaders, hezbollah, Arafat, the ultra lefties and i'm not sure but maybe hamas too.

[@bellira3979]

Amem!

[@goldencalf5144]

They propose that Jews should obey God and wait for the Messiah before returning to the promised land.

[@kakaroto7578]

@@goldencalf5144 they're completely delusional, they support Hitler, Hezbollah and hamas.

[@paulnia8404]

People think andcsay they are they are part if Erev Rav

[@Josh-kd7uo]

Circumstances have that I live with moderate Muslim. I heard the saying. We don’t want peace we want justice. In the end I sent my friend one of the nutrei karta videos. It worked. Since the lies from Islam against Jews are so huge. It made a starting point of dialogue. And then I could show what happened even to the Bedouin Muslims in Israel. Who were also brutally attacked. It’s all a extremely complex situation. Interesting book I saw below. "Palestina ex Monumentis Veteribus Illustrata" by Adriaan Reland. Published in 1714, in Utrecht, Netherlands. The book is written in Latin in 1695, Reland described what was then called Palestine. He visited almost 2,500 settlements mentioned in the Bible. The research was conducted as follows: *He first created the map of Palestine. He then designated every settlement mentioned in the Bible or the Talmud with its original name. * If the original was Jewish, it meant "pasuk" (a suggestion in the Holy Scriptures that mentioned the name). * If the original was Roman or Greek, the connection was in Latin or Greek. In the end, he made a population census by settlements. Main conclusions and facts: * The country is mainly empty, abandoned, sparsely populated, the main population is Jerusalem, Akko, Tsfat, Jaffa, Tveria and Gaza. * Most of the population are Jews, almost everyone else is Christians, very few Muslims, mostly Bedouins. * The only exception is Nablus (now Shchem), where approximately 120 people from the Muslim family Natsha and approximately 70 "shomronims" (Samaritans). * In Nazareth, the capital of Galilee, lived approximately 700 people - all Christians. * In Jerusalem there are about 5,000 people, almost all Jews and a few Christians. * In 1695, everyone knew that the origin of the country was Jewish. * There is not a single settlement in Palestine that has Arabic roots in its name. * Most settlements have Jewish originals, and in some cases Greek or Roman Latin. * Apart from the city of Ramla, there is no Arab settlement that has an original Arabic name. Jewish, Greek or Latin names that have been changed to Arabic that don't make any sense in Arabic. In Arabic, there is no meaning in names like: Akko, Haifa, Jaffa, Nablus, Gaza or Jenin, and names like Ramallah, al-Khalil (Hebron), al-Quds (Jerusalem) - they do not have philological or historical Arabic roots. So, for example, in 1696, Ramallah was called Bethel (Beit El, the House of God), Hebron was called Hebron and the Cave of Mahpel was called El-Khalil (the nickname of Abraham) by the Arabs. * Relandi mentions Muslims only as nomadic Bedouins who came to the cities as seasonal workers in agriculture or construction. * About 550 people lived in Gaza, half of them Jews and half Christians. Jews were successful in agriculture, especially in vineyards, olives and wheat, Christians were engaged in trade and transportation. * Jews lived in Tveria and Tsfat, but their occupation is not mentioned, except for the traditional fishing in Kineret. * In the village of Um El Fahm, for example, lived 10 families, all Christians (about 50 people). There stood a small Maronite church. The book completely refutes theories about "Palestinian traditions", "Palestinian people" and leaves almost no link between the land and the Arabs who even stole the land's Latin name (Palestine) and took it for themselves. Adriaan Reland (Adriaen Reeland/Reelant, Hadrianus Relandus) (17 July 1676 - 5 February 1718 was a noted Dutch Orientalist scholar, cartographer and philologist.

[@Eio7]

Thank you.

[@InkaPley]

Thank you for sharing! Will definitely read this if I can find a translation.

[@juleswhy5920]

It is very complicated, so much so that the average person in the US cannot even understand, and have no connection to historical facts. This is by Design. Our educational system really really sucks! And our liberal colleges are toxic to the human soul. God help us all

[@shahzadrafiq4534]

I'm a Muslim, anti zyo, we are not anti Jewish. It doesn't matter if they have Greek, Arab or Japanese traditions. It's their land because they lived there. The most you can say is you want to live there too (alongside them). You cant have Jewish only state, nor apartheid.

[@Love-19]

So much lie

[@bellira3979]

I'm praying for you and for the world. May God protect all good people.

[@janiceridsdale2904]

BLESSED IS HE WHO COMES IN THE NAME OF THE LORD .

[@leilamiller8201]

Yes, seeing jews standing with those hateful protestors proudly causes such deep sorrow and despair immediately my mind goes to my grandparents and I say that I am glad they're not here to witness such hate

[@mrcomenttoe2009]

Thank you for your video and everything that is support of the hostages and Israel and for peace

[@annenicholsonmbtp]

This is a great conversation between two really good minds within Judaism. It is very hard to live with conflict. You are demonstrating that we can live with internal conflicts, which enable us to live with external conflicts.

[@joycegifford8826]

“Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.” Martin Luther King Jr

[@phillipgrey]

Exactly!

[@cathys465]

I love you too. I'm not Jewish, but I lived in a Jewish home when I was young. All this hatred hurts me to my soul. I pray that this will all work out well.

[@aussiebushhomestead3223]

Shof'tim (Judges) 19 and 20 tells us what HaShem did to Benjamin when they committed horrific sin against a Levite. All Israel came out and they attacked and killed their brothers and it was done under HaShem's direction. I believe this absolutely answers this issue. Rabbi Jacobsen is absolutely right.

[@charliebrownie4158]

What about Norman Finkelstein? I remember Herschel Shanks in one of his biblical archeology review magazines, he had just recently found the Fortress that was the area where they found the pottery that had the name of David on it and that the based on the things that was from that area it was around the time that the dating of when King David was in power. Now he was speaking with Finkelstein because finkelstein's point on the issue of David being a king of Israel was in saying that David was actually a king like how a Shepherd would be a soldier. Saying that there was no Kingdom of David that the kingdom of David was nothing more than maybe 50 or 100 men or something but there was no real Kingdom of Israel. Or Judea for that matter. And Shanks beginning of the issue tried to smooth feathers over by saying please do not call this man up and threaten him and do this and that I don't know who he was talking to. But after I when I when I connected up who this Finkelstein was with the person who had been one of the people working with the National Geographic group in trying to pull down the idea that there ever was a kingdom like Solomon or David in Israel. Now when I've seen that there have been videos that have this Norman on them I have no interest in hearing anything he has to say. The same thing with Roger Waters from the rock band Pink Floyd. I have absolutely nothing and no interest to hear a goddamn thing he has to say. As a matter of fact the wife of David Gilmour the guitarist for Pink Floyd has said that Rodger Waters has always been hateful of Jews even long before he even knew that Jews were over in the Middle East. And how that when he was going to high school he loved nothing more than attacking Jews at school and then when he dropped out of college to be in this band there was nothing he hated more on that college campus than making fun of and doing things like s******* in or outside of the lockers of Jewish students. And likewise I don't give a damn of what I put Finkelstein in the same boat as Roger Waters I was quite found it quite funny that they had them together in something on KZbin and I was like there's no way I want to hear what either of them have to say anymore than I want to hear a cow farting or or anything else of that nature.

[@daisyduke6573]

It is possible to share a meal with an enemy…it changed my life🦋

[@klmnclement]

We need @RabbiYYJacobson to explain the 770 tunnel situation!

[@savtamarlene]

WHY?

[@adamherskine8594]

@@savtamarlene It is aa very serious issue, a massive chilul Hashem has been made, im not sure why, but it seems some non-jews are starting a blood libel type thing, based on stupid assumptions. We need to unite and rely only on Hashem, then we dont have to worry about anything. (Oh and also be careful about 3 meals on shabbos gemoro shabbos 119)

[@chatisawasteoftime]

@@adamherskine8594 The Zionist state of Israel is the massive chilul Hashem. Just because anti-semites exploit it, doesn't make the tunnels a "massive" chilul Hashem?

[@geraldogregory1070]

Lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂.

[@phillipgrey]

That was a bunch of putzes that are out of control and need to be reigned in.

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

Israel needs new leader fast.

[@agoodpitch9]

they don't march with hamas, what they do is send a message that zionism isn't judaism

[@Vvvvvvvvvv848]

No they March with hammas I’ve seen videos of them doing it

[@raychingcar7881]

This group reminds me of Korah who rebelled against Moses. Korah and his followers were dealt with in the end.

[@geraldogregory1070]

Rebelling is much different than pointing out the wrong!! Rabbi YY sounds kind of??? Never mind. I must show respect.

[@barrys.9040]

Wow, it's unbelievable to listen to this guy. Making excuses for evil boggles the mind. I knew a Rov who was Satmar Royalty who wouldn't let Neturei Karta in his Shul

[@Rovtful]

Finally clarity

[@janiceridsdale2904]

IF THEY ARE JEWISH - HOW DO THEY JUST IGNOR GODS WORD ?

[@briarpatchson3039]

Romans 11:26 “And so all Israel shall be saved: as it is written, There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob: Romans 11:32 “For God hath concluded them all in unbelief, that he might have mercy upon all.”

[@joeluna7729]

THANK YOU RABBI! 👏👏 If any of us were confused about these wicked bastabbing reshaim; post Oct 7, they clearly demonstrated what and who they truly are. I'm not a Navi either, but the Vila Gaon stated we would have problems with the Erez Rav / Amalek born among us. Here they are. Amalek Erev Rav joins Amalek Chamas, to attack us.

[@gideonbasson8040]

They are not Jews

[@FA-ms9jc]

How about getting one of those guys your talking about on your program.Ask them why? Don’t be afraid to hear what they have to say.

[@ddd7099]

These are not Jews at all Shame on them

[@janiceridsdale2904]

STAND WITH GOD / HASHEM .

[@MariaMartinez-hg4nv]

Rabbi you should invite these so-called Jewish Group to your show-🙏🏽❤️🇮🇱✝️🇺🇸

[@shanky.y]

There is some sick minded people out there . . .

[@mrcomenttoe2009]

Thank you for this video and this interview (knowledge can end War)

[@Thomas-fx3om]

I totally agree with you Rabbi YY. ‭‭D'varim (Deu)‬ ‭10:16‬ ‭ [16] Therefore, circumcise the foreskin of your heart; and don’t be stiffnecked any longer! To side with the haters means that you're heart is completely corrupted.

[@angerycamel2]

I loved Jake Turx commentary, I thought he provided alot of great insight to the conversation. Firstly its important to remember these people are representing a hashkafa (what the chasidim call shita), a worldview in english, that is from their avos, or atleast they perceive it to be, its something that they think their fathers and rebbes and teachers believed in...weather its still an accurate representation of their ancestors belief is itself a controversial subject, but it simply doesnt mean hating them and not tollerating them will bring them bach to achdus with klal yisrael. As usual Zev I love that you had a representation of different points of view on the show and I will definately watch your other interview with the renegade neturei karta.

[@solotron7390]

I could not agree more with Rabbi YY Jacobson! The State of Israel--like it or not--is a foregone conclusion. Why stand with those who would destroy Am Yisrael? It's madness.

[@dvorahchesed]

Moshiach is not going to fall from the sky, that's the Beit HaMikdash.

[@janiceridsdale2904]

IF THEIR VIEWS DO NOT LINE UP WITH GODS WORD - THEY'VE GONE ASTRAY = PRAY FOR THEM . & YES BE CAREFUL - THEIR VIEWS ARE DANGEROUS .

[@moshefund1]

Can we or should we love predators in our midst? Is that comparable to loving a typical tinok shenishba?

[@larryjackson6075]

Please invite them on your show.

[@praagvandaniel1188]

Why don't we say Naturei Karta has a din of a rodef or moser?

[@koopon3900]

With the amount of hatred they are stirring up against the majority of yids, they are laying the groundwork and providing justification for violence against Jews around the world. The rodef label is not hyperbolic

[@SaraGold]

That was intense

[@ironbutterfly12]

So what will those Jews do if their Messiah appears someday? Will they dismantle the Al Aqsa to build the third temple?

[@beth3535]

With brothers in faith like these who needs enemies?

[@mrcomenttoe2009]

The answer is no matter no matter what your color religion ethnicity whatever it is no matter what wherever you're from you should be, against terrorism and anyone that condones it😮

[@fuadalsaify7888]

I am Jewish but I don’t believe in occupation

[@yeard7507]

I wouldn't mind if you would have a more in depth conversation with Jack

[@user-nf4sd4ss3o]

Paranoia is a curse of God to those who hates humanity.

[@exitthematrix1487]

What about Satmar? Are they same?

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

No. Satmar food went to U.S. religious Jewish soldiers.

[@saard2411]

The Satmar condemned the NK years ago. There is a difference between disagreeing and working with the enemies of the Jewish people.

[@Vvvvvvvvvv848]

Satmar are kosher yidden

[@janiceridsdale2904]

CHRISTIAN HERE 😊 ❤

[@jacksaranta7574]

Baruch Hashem rabbi YY Jacobson ❤ Thank G-d for this show ❤ Am Yisrael Chaim!

[@Jared_Albert]

Thank you for covering this. In 67 years, I had never said the word 'Kapo' outloud until I saw these 'jews' on TV at one of these marches.

[@JeffKohn]

Rabbi YY is great and it's amazing that he has so much patience for so much stupidity expressed.

[@edithslama1702]

The old "Rebbetzin" was once an exotic dancer and a spy, the circumstances of her conversion were not clear. Many people think she pursued her activities after she changed her name for Ruth. She was involved in the kidnapping of a young boy from his parents because they turned secular. She spent time in prison for this crime. I met her in Paris once when she was hosted by a very naive friend. She came for fundraising but didn't have a lot of success. Few days after her arrival in the house she behaved like if she was the balabusta and was giving orders to my friend in her own house. Ahavat Israel is a mitsvah that brings to Ahavat Enoshut, they forgot it. They are hateful and arrogant.

[@ruthbentley2090]

Humanitarian secularism has always existed. Personal opinion that governs one’s conscience completely misses the spiritual dimension.

[@benzismuzic]

Rav Amnon Yitzchak released a psak 10 yrs ago that they have a din Rodef....

[@zetaepsilondelta545]

Maybe there is some type of division between followers of Moses and followers of Joshua. Moses is still up the mountain and cannot enter the Promised Land because Hashem says He was too aggressive... and yet Joshua is a soldier. Is Joshua also disallowed from entering the Promised Land for being too aggressive? Presumably the Orthodox Yehudim, or anyone else for that matter, who are still up the mountain with Moses, wouldn't know if Hashem had forgiven Moses since that time, oh so long ago, and permitted him entry to the Promised Land (that forgiveness has not been written on any paper for the human eyes of others to witness).

[@iceking956]

Rabbi, with all due respect, isn't the Jews exiled? And only allowed to go back to the promise land when the Moshiach comes?

[@lynetterowberry2]

Would I be correct in my understanding that ... Religion is not an identity and Religion is not G_d.💫🙏💜

[@tubegersh]

This guy is talking insanity. He thinks Netirei Karta is trying to bring Moshiach?! Unbelievable

[@YonieZukowsky51]

For my father him and 100 Nuterei Karta didn't make a minyan. He needed 9 other people.

[@lynetterowberry2]

I watched an interview on AlJazeera with the Jews in question. Then I scrolled through the comments 😅 and was suprised to see so many Muslims with an outpouring of Love towards Jews. I was reminded that Hashem can use bad for good, and practiced gratitude for the outpouring of Love from the enemy. Love for One Jew is Love for All Jews. I wonder if the love they bestowed was conditional or unconditional? I guess time will tell.

[@user-vx3wm4hn5i]

So you think Muslims loving Jews that want to see the destruction of Israel is genuine love ?? Dang

[@charliebrownie4158]

I guess you don't know the stricture that their profit gave to them saying you will lie to Jews you'll light a Christians you'll lie to atheists. Whoever the enemy is those are who you will kill. As a friend of mine who was from Pakistan he kept trying to get me to convert to Islam. Now what he told me in the end was you have to understand he said you have to understand there's no such thing as a moderate Muslim. He said I'm only a moderate Muslim because I'm standing with you he thought I was he didn't know I was Jewish. He said I'm standing with you me being a Muslim you being a Christian and I can tell you I don't want to kill you. Because I don't want to kill you. But if I'm around one or more extremist Muslims and they say we're going to kill him pointing at me. Then he said I'm an extremist Muslim and I'll be one of the ones killing you. And that's the way we are even the ones who have no feeling of hatred and we would not want to kill anybody if we're around one saying we're going to kill everyone we find then we have to do that. Now when I said to him what would happen if I went to Pakistan with becoming if I did convert to Islam and I go to Pakistan what would happen when I get there? He said you wouldn't be be alive within 5 minutes of arriving there. So I said to him Muhammad, how many years did you live in America? And start shaking his head, as he said that's not fair that's not fair you're using my own experience against me. I said no you gave yourself away when you said the first bit about the fact that nobody can be as barbaric as a Muslim and I said to you that you don't know anything about American history if you think that Americans can't be Barbara especially if you know the self and what happened with the things that went on between the whites and the blacks. And I know that there's plenty of black people likewise who are not going to bend their need to Allah no matter how much pressure is put on them and that's just one of those kind of things that's going to happen and people are not going to stand by and allow it to happen they will stand up and they will fight

[@ruthyk7083]

Ich. I don't need such love. Islamists don't speak honestly in public (taquiya) and if someone betrays their own people, they are not seen as trustworthy in middle eastern culture. Sweet words covering deathly poison.

[@kenandbarbie-b6c]

Collaborators are always loved by any enemy.

[@shahzadrafiq4534]

We don't see Jews as the enemy. We are only now becoming to know what is zionism, and I have differentiated zionists from jews. It's not the same

[@musicman1770]

Thank you for this. I hope the source I provided you regarding the Ta'amei HaMinhagim shed some light on who these caricatures really are. טעמי המנהגים ומקורי הדינים ליקוטים - אל תטוש תורת אמך תקנג-תקנד הערת שוליים ***

[@shabirahmadshah8163]

How I wish people around the world live with justice and peace and love and empathy and compassion and happiness. Am afraid some big calamity will engulf the world as a punishment from God for murdering 10000 children and many under rubble. 😥

[@SharkSandwich451]

You must mean those who were murdered in Syria? Darfur hostages that were murdered or those who were taken and never seen again? That’s the world: everyone turns a blind eye until Israel needs to defend themselves. Oh, and one off the 136 hostages who weren’t murdered right away is a 1-year-old.

[@shahzadrafiq4534]

@@SharkSandwich451 no he means what you have done. The live streamed genocide, and ethnic cleansing we have only now come to know the reality of

[@robertsansone1680]

A Jewish friend of mine calls Jews like that, "Self Haters". Very interesting program. Thank You

[@AKSTUDIOUSA]

Well said Rabbi YY Jacobson. May HaShem bless you.

[@user-vx3wm4hn5i]

“ neturi karta are using Ham’Ass “ using Hammas hate and violence and that’s not evil ????? What is wrong with the host here who kept on trying to vindicate Neturi karta ??

[@yehuditflax204]

total insanity hashem has never ever been forgiving to people who went against his children

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

You don't have to back to 1648. It happened in holocaust and a century and a half ago by cossacks etc.

[@slim12997]

Rabbi you don't have feeling for all these gazaoui children

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

Arab foe doesn't have such traitors in its ranks likened to neturei karta.

[@AliyaDabkes2465]

We also do not have so many of the heroes either. Because the rule about backbiting is that even if it is telling the truth we are not to speak against anyone of our own. Therefore even if they do the most unspeakable horror it is silenced to save face. And so only recently, through the events of October 7th and it's resulting war any real Muslim heroism of the past century. I'm referring to speaking out and the Muslim IDF heroes.

[@ejeanroh377]

I have a question. The God of Abraham, Isaac & Jacob - i.e. sons of Abraham... did Abraham have a different god with his son Ishmael? Or with his other 4 sons with Keturah? I myself think not... so, aren’t all Abraham’s sons half-brothers? And all Abrahams’ sons blessed by God of Abraham... this is a quandry for me...

[@earthman808]

I anxiously await the further internal strife such pride of Nationalism grants you, and the HOW that is going to play out. Arthur Ruppin's planned society with the Ashkenazi's at the top of the hill must be working quite well. I must say.

[@torbjornlindholm4098]

I’m an atheist Jew but it’s interesting to see the perspective of a Rabbi about those traitors. Even anti Zionist Jews won’t sell their fellow brothers for the enemy, but those Neturei Karta are crazy.

[@zetaepsilondelta545]

An atheist Jew? Perhaps you are Theo Himself then! Only a true Theo would be unaware of its own divinity.

[@torbjornlindholm4098]

@@zetaepsilondelta545😅 I’m ethnically a Jew, I have Jewish blood but I just don’t believe in god. The religious Jews are still my brothers tho, we share the same Jewish blood. So of course I will support my country Israel, for being the “safe” haven for my people (won’t call it safe after Oct 7th).

[@zetaepsilondelta545]

@@torbjornlindholm4098 Some animals recognise themselves when they look in a mirror, elephants and chimpanzees often do, but not all animals... cats and gods usually don't.

[@prezervezefunk]

@@zetaepsilondelta545and some people believe a Egyptian magician can transform a wooden cane into a snake and some don’t. Some people also don’t want a religion in which their messiah ( moshe ) order to kill an entire population ( except the young virgin girls ) just because they had intercourse with the Hebrews, sounds too much like Isis

[@kharris9359]

​@@zetaepsilondelta545'Jewish' is a culture/sub-culture group AND/OR a religion. 24-40% of Jews in Israel and the U.S. are ATHEIST.

[@chmoueltaieb6454]

thank you Rabbi YY

[@traceygoodman6203]

From my lips to HaShem’s ears I had this question about Jews marching and despising Israel 🇮🇱 the worst kind of traitor. God bless you for talking about this. Am Y’ISRAEL chai. Baruch HaShem. I’m a UK Jew and so so proud. My mom spent a lot of time in Israel. Her whole life was devoted to being of service including to Israel. ✡️🇮🇱☮️💟😢🇬🇧

[@ghostboy3994]

you’re not native to the land of israel

[@dieterhaase2842]

ich liebe Israel☘️🌹🌈🕎🇩🇪🇮🇱 Gott bringe alle geiseln wieder gesund zurückעם ישראל חי

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

Korach also had relatives. So?

[@UnownLeaf]

I also subscribe to the idea that Judaism is a peoplehood first and foremost. You can't be a real Jew if you wish harm on most Jews. It makes no sense.

[@Jacob_28]

I will start with this i love all of you and that love is why i have put so much effort into trying to understand this conflict. I have many flaws and was not created perfect and have no more right than you to say anything, But after listening to and talking to many i have this to say. If the killing of children on mass and war upsets them and they want it to stop and that makes them not part of your religion by your own decision maybe you have different Gods... yes it is a dramatic thing to say. Some are willing to be persecuted and called everything under the sun by all including who is supposed to be their brother for what they believe will bring peace and bring love... at the same time i see a lot of rationalization and an effort to save face in others like the Israeli government (not all of its people).... A move done for ego and appearance. Why so much explanation and defense if there is no wrong decisions being made. Rabbi said he is not a prophet, and some things are not his decision to make . The leaders of the idf seem to think they are and have so much authority. The right to defense is absolute but what is the definition of this. We are at over 23,000 dead in gaza at the moment. How many were hamas and how many were not even old enought to speak yet. Where are the open fights soldier to soldier. I only see bombing of city blocks. why is the death toll not even half hamas fighters? Sloppy work to say the very least. The very thought that you can throw an entirety of a people in a single group for condemnation is exactly how evil has done it in the past.... can't you see. Does this conflict as it is actually fix a problem. Ask yourself why would hamas even commit such evil and it absolutely was evil they need to be gone. But why attack like they did? Clearly they are getting outmatched in all ways so why? There was only very limited outcomes and none of them end well for hamas. Have you thought that such evil doesn't actually care for Palestinians and in fact wants them to die as well. There is an effort to harm both Israeli and Palestinian in body and soul. It is time to stop looking to warlords and politicians there is only one way to true peace.

[@user-pd9kl5lm2w]

That's troubling.

[@iceking956]

Why can't you address the elephant in the room? Why are you focusing on some political perspective of the situation??? They're supposed to be scattered around the world, exiled for breaking the covenant as the Prophet Moshe predicted.

[@sarite1652]

There are crazy people in every nation, in every religion. sometimes a leader's mental problems effects the whole communit

[@dieterhaase2842]

Was heißt hier verrückt? es gibt gut und böse! Und diese sekte ist Vom bösen

[@balurmoshiyakgova2261]

Oh come on. Bringing Moshiach is learning Torah learning to respect and love one another not hugging the enemy. They killing sooooooo 😢many of us.thiis is betrayal. Hashem doesn't like it!!!

[@PunkiBrooster]

Since when does Hamas hold marches? Seems kinda bad faith to me idk

[@leeli2690]

Land agreement, open new university 🎓 of all. Agree 😊

[@mosheh9453]

Dearest gentlemen Thank you for all. Please can you have a similar meeting and actually bring a Neturei Karta representative? That would be so much more fiery! And we could get a full perspective of the views?

[@yitzchakmordechai]

They absolutely shouldn't be given a platform.

[@kenandbarbie-b6c]

I have one question- are these “Jews” leftest? If so, do they take their Socialism/Communism as primary & Judaism as something of less importance?

[@RhonaDavis-lz3qp]

I was a victim of verbal abuse

[@e.r7228]

Rabbi YY! Be strong! BE strong! BE STrong! BE STRONG!!!!!

[@janiceridsdale2904]

ONLY GOD / HASHEM KNOWS FOR SURE - SPEAK TRUTH - LOVEING THEM IS NOT ONLY PRAYING FOR THEM ITS SLSO TELLING THEM THE TRUTH .

[@deanwilson2689]

Ones that don’t know commandments , they need to study Torah

[@rightclick7266]

22:00 They say stuff about Zionists it usually includes a reference to Amalek with a touch of Yimach Shemam vZichram.

[@kharris9359]

But Jews aren't suppose to have their own state until the recoming of the Messiah?

[@dieterhaase2842]

עם ישראל חי

[@Vvvvvvvvvv848]

Source?

[@lapimano2]

Satan is a conjurer, he will also try to pose as something positive and noble, meanwhile he is hideous, but how will you discern him from the real good guys?

[@jackdepalma]

The ANC has consistently criticized Israel as an “apartheid state,” even before the current war. International rights groups have also accused Israel of the crime of apartheid against Palestinians and that “resonates strongly with South Africa,” said Thamsanqa Malusi, a South African human rights lawyer. Israel adamantly rejects that characterization, saying its Arab minority enjoys full civil rights. It views Gaza, from which it withdrew soldiers and settlers in 2005, as a hostile entity ruled by the Islamic militant group Hamas, and it considers the West Bank to be disputed territory subject to peace negotiations - which collapsed more than a decade ago. Malusi said many in the South African government experienced the oppression of apartheid and that could help explain its decision to lodge the case against Israel at the U.N.'s top court. While Mandela, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning statesman, also reached out to Israel in an attempt to foster a peaceful solution, anti-Israeli rhetoric in South Africa has strengthened over the years, sometimes seeping into everyday life. For example, the ANC’s youth wing pressured South African grocery store chains to drop Israeli products and threatened to forcibly shut them down if they didn’t.

[@4clempt]

The authors of the two Universal-Global Religions, baked “the Jew” into a permanent position of “the GUILTY ACCUSED” who has pain and suffering coming to him. This RESULTED in a diverse ideological, functional,and psychological adaptations. The Ayatollah huggers is an adaptation that has gone rogue. We can never look at a moment in time as our story; our story is constantly being written. I’m proud of us for not hating them,

[@lindadavidson1389]

No one and nothing can stop Messiah from coming. He will come in due time. But, what will he find you doing when He gets here. Anyone who sides with Hamas is not human, that person is a devil full of deceit.

[@PC-lu3zf]

They are deluded supporting Hamas. Its really upsetting.

[@briarpatchson3039]

Romans 2:28 “For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:”