Who can Draft a lineup with the most RBI's? (AL West Edition)

[@adrianmendiola5498]

Alternate video title: Me screaming Edgar Martinez at my screen for 18 minutes

[@jacobalbus1137]

The entire time

[@scottthompson3954]

I'm starting to think they purposefully leave out some guys just to keep us all hooked in to see if they're going to remember them or not. Pretty shrewd

[@michaelgliddenforteski6576]

I was so angered by this I got out a pen and paper and started to write them a very angry-worded letter. I'll be mailing it tomorrow.

[@sealeo5772]

These guys are why it took him so long to get into the hall of fame.

[@RockyMtnRebecca]

😅😅😅😅

[@Sicknilva4]

2023 Jonah Heim with 95 RBIs is absolutely hilarious, a true Polar Bear in Arlington moment

[@iangish8336]

His stats with RISP last season are absurd

[@generallukeproductions]

The whole 2023 Rangers offense was magic

[@heartlady724]

everyone talking about lucas's facial expressions makes me need a lucas cam in the corner of these

[@YungCatch]

Please

[@kicking222]

I would love this.

[@jollyredjoker7682]

Jolly & Ryan fumbling Cal Raleigh & Pudge at catcher is just insane to me. Even crazier is taking Cal's unfinished 2024 season would be the fourth highest RBI total since 2000

[@mattinm]

Teix, Edgar, and Garret Anderson going undrafted is nuts.

[@hanj31]

If I was doing it GA would have been drafted by me

[@johncrone5465]

00' DH Edgar Martinez (145), 05' 1B Richie Sexson (121), 06' LF Raul Ibanez (123) Cuz I am a Mariner faithful!

[@mikeb7644]

For what it’s worth you could toss in ‘01 Mike Cameron (110)

[@ima1den765]

A batting average draft would be fun

[@namne11]

nice spin on the hits draft.

[@Theorpo]

2004 Ichiro was my first guess for the AL west

[@TonyGarciaxProdigy1994]

would be sick!!!

[@brycebogan2853]

Would be an awesome twist as you would probably benefit from fewer games! They would have to change the rules a little to accommodate imo.

[@princechickenwings2746]

Would have to have an at bat minimum for that or in the NL draft one could say 2021 Tommy Hunter who went 1-1

[@benblair582]

Getting the moneyball years wrong AGAIN to waste giambi years should’ve been an auto DQ. Crazy stuff from Jolly there

[@KyleSprabary]

A Rod at short gotta be a first pick

[@dgrblue4162]

Griffey,Jr entered the chat

[@JBBGeek]

@@dgrblue4162Not in the 2000s.

[@brettadiah10]

Boone at 2nd in 2001 should be up there.

[@kicking222]

​@@dgrblue4162He didn't play in the AL West in the 2000s until he was 39 years old.

[@zackaryhaselius2226]

Ryan Seemed to forget Cruz was a Mariner too.

[@ILoveMisty1985]

Edgar Martinez and his 145 RBIs in 2000 could have been the difference for Jake.

[@eenu]

Problem is the default year guess would have been 2001

[@aaronwitt03]

Surprised no one snagged 2023 Marcus Semien for 2B

[@drew.bassett]

This is by far my favorite draft video cast!

[@dmay327]

The fact that the best at every position besides catcher was before 2010 is insane.

[@mcclintocksamuel05]

I love how it’s actually two contests at once. There’s the RBI’s contest, and always an undercurrent of who can name drop a silly name.

[@danielrafael7624]

Ohtani was on the angels where no one gets on base. Of course his career high rbi was only 100

[@JohnBtons]

Love the series!!! and also like the best possible lineups at the end. GG's

[@lelandbailey8657]

Also some fun names: both Kyle Seager and Mitch Haniger hit 100 RBIs in 2021

[@reed5369]

im not thinking when i watch so i never remember any players. So great job guys. Im being serious. I bet y'all dont get this often, praise

[@zachmiller1175]

No Tex or Garrett Anderson is insane lol

[@kurtzmann22]

Rafael Palmeiro or Juan Gonzalez would've been good picks.

[@nickshulevitz2572]

garret anderson disrespect is out of control here

[@TheTEN24]

Glad Jake remembers early 2000s studs like pudge and Tejada

[@Beeswithgunz]

biggest misses were Edgar Martinez 2001 with 145 and Mark Teixeira 2005 with 144

[@williamfischer3990]

Best part of Mondays are JM Drafts Baby!

[@FNJL]

Seeing jonah heim on here is so cool considering how far he regressed this year after the wrist injury late last year

[@queenautumnween2796]

Shout out Jake showing eric chavez some love by putting him on the list! My all time favorite player! Was hoping someone would've put him on their list

[@RockyMtnRebecca]

JOLLY!!!!!!!

[@kenlytle4331]

Doing this myself, my 1.01 without hesitation was Bret Boone 2001. Surprised he wasn't the first 2B off the board.

[@taanorth]

Something fun to see would be what total each person would have had if they had the best year from each person they drafted

[@harrisonbaylor1432]

The “best possible lineup” at the end of the video doesn’t have an Astro on it. Therefore not making it the best possible according to the rules.

[@bigbenuwrf]

ACTUAL best possible lineup would have 2019 Bregman at 3rd (112 RBI) and 2000 Giambi at 1st (137 RBI) for a total of 1151 RBI.

[@Emmathelady]

15:14 Niiiiiiiccccccce! Bravo! Should have picked 2001 though! 😊

[@Treikyl]

It would be fun to have a team of 3 vs lucas in one of these

[@andrewoppedisano7949]

Everyone forgets The Big Hurt had one amazing season in Oakland... Which one, who knows, but there is one.

[@bricecarter4d4]

Finally with the Brett Boone. Bout damn time you recognize lol

[@zackaryhaselius2226]

Jolly not saying Richie Sexaon is weird. Thats his dude.

[@MM_3131]

The amount of times they mess up the moneyball year is crazy

[@Sliceofswiss]

Me simple man, me see Jake, me click

[@c0ltsfreak18]

Yo Jolly what the heck is going on with that A's knowledge? 2003 moneyball? A's last playoff in 2018? They went in 2019 and 2020 too man! Dont do this to me!!!

[@DRQ1101]

I’m very surprised it took someone that long to grab Albert Pujols.

[@chuckseals9013]

Jolly with almost a flawless performance

[@biged263835]

Could have lived with the 2001-2008 Rangers by throwing darts at years and sprinkled in some other teams players and easily won.

[@KyleSprabary]

Fax I was really hoping for a big Tex or Soriano shot

[@harrisonalexander6203]

Yeah going with as many Rangers due to their old ballpark would've been the smart play. So many good ones left on the board. (Texeira, Soriano, Young, Blalock, Palmeiro)

[@cowsaymoomoo]

2017 Altuve was a blunder. Marwin Gonzalez led the team in RBIs that season with like 90 and you could put him at any position (including 2B).

[@kylen6430]

I mean, taking altuve over Boone was really the blunder

[@cowsaymoomoo]

@@kylen6430 well yeah definitely. I was thinking just in general if any 2017 Astro gets taken it’s gotta be Marwin

[@caelanmulligan3696]

Yordan Alvarez career OPS is roughly 17th all time, around the same as Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle and Stan Musial. I know he gets injured but like come onnnnnnnn, we gotta give him a go.

[@chrisjett6232]

Me waiting for ARod to come off the board: Eighth pick, "This guy had a 1 or 2 really good years for a team he signed a big contract with..." Me: Ryan's getting a steal here "...Robinson Cano"

[@thomasclements5433]

these three the best lineup

[@JD62627]

Mark Teixeira had a bajillion seasons in a row of 30 & 100 and got overlooked. I'm sick

[@Emmathelady]

16:12 Fuck yeah! That guy was a fucking stud!

[@pacificdrumma]

Should add up the RBIs from all the drafts to crown a total winner

[@BenjaminYoung-ri8cy]

Draft an all time lineup with players with the most strikeouts

[@joshshanley9656]

I'm not sure if anyone else realized that they missed a division. They missed the NL East!!

[@slimjimmypage]

I got 938! This is the first time I've ever even been competitive, haha!

[@kevinhinkle7632]

Rafael Palmeiro had two 120+ and four 100+ seasons left on the table

[@noahaxinn7880]

LETS GO JOLLY RAAAAAHHHHHH

[@ericolson1932]

Y'all should do all-time homer draft against a team i.e. drafting players that crushed one particular team. e.x. Jimmie Foxx against the Yankees.

[@BennyintheBoothPodcast]

C: 2011 Mike Napoli: 75 1B: 2006 Frank Thomas: 114 2B: 2001 Brett Boone: 141 SS: 2002 Miguel Tejada: 131 3B: 2019 Alex Bregman: 112 OF: 2004 Vlad Sr: 126 OF: 2010 Josh Hamilton: 100 OF: 2017 George Springer: 85 DH: 2014 Kyle Seager: 96 Total: 980

[@randallwong7196]

Thomas was DH'ing in 2006.

[@InkIsPink]

astros fan waiting for someone to say 2015 evan gattis (catcher)

[@kylen6430]

3:00 booooo! How could you forget about ‘01 Boone!!

[@dizzykincade7831]

Haven’t watched yet, but as an As fan, I gotta imagine Tejada at SS and Chavez at 3rd have to be picked.

[@TrocarSlushWeasel]

Jake really should have walked out of the room when he picked Altuve over a Boone.

[@RoryBlanst]

14:57 Ryan forgetting Pudge played for Texas is embarrassing. A-Rod is a little more understandable. Dude has to learn about Texas baseball lol.

[@dizzykincade7831]

Haven’t watched yet, but as an As fan, I gotta imagine Tejada at SS and Chavez at 3rd have to be picked. Early 2000s Tim Salmon too

[@queenautumnween2796]

I was thinking Eric chavez as well. Favorite player of all time. Had 114 in 01. A lot of people forget about eric Chavez

[@kyleetasker1701]

Do Gold gloves next!

[@dmoneyyy1863]

Jolly took the first shortstop and it wasn’t A-Rod… yikes. Also love the Olerud pull from Jake

[@bentaylor4705]

Aww man, the glglgast division for the RBI draft! 😂

[@texasjoeames4362]

#JMBaseball your best possible lineup wouldn't be allowed based on the rules you have added to the game. that requires one player from every team. Yall forgot a Astro player

[@bigbenuwrf]

ACTUAL best possible lineup would have 2019 Bregman at 3rd (112 RBI) and 2000 Giambi at 1st (137 RBI) for a total of 1151 RBI.

[@nathankrenz8840]

I'm good at years so Jollys 2002 As Giambi f up hurt my brain lol has he really seen the movie?

[@lofo3232]

My Lineup C 2005 Jason Kendall - 55 1B 2001 Rafel Palmeiro - 123 2B 2023 Marcus Semien - 100 3B 2021 Kyle Seager - 101 SS 2006 Michael Young -103* OF 2021 Yordan Alvarez - 104 OF 2006 Raul Ibanez - 123 OF 2001 Mike Cameron - 110 DH 2005 Richie Sexson - 121 TOTAL 940 1st Place *2011 Michael Young had 106 but wanted SS eligibility

[@tonycomer1415]

It's Ivan Rodriguez boys, NOT pudge. That was is and always will be Carlton Fisk

[@bryanfoss6736]

No big dumper?

[@LjQuinn-rp2wb]

You should do strike outs but make it like golf it’s whoever has the lowest career strikeouts for hitters

[@aidanmccoy9872]

Jolly where did you get that shirt?

[@hkgcgsdhjgd]

*SPOILERS AHEAD* The lineup I came up with before watching the video C: Ivan Rodriguez, 2000 - 83 RBI 1B: Jason Giambi, 2001 - 120 RBI 2B: Jose Altuve, 2019 - 74 RBI 3B: Troy Glaus, 2001 - 108 RBI SS: Alex Rodriguez, 2001 - 135 RBI OF: Yordan Alvarez, 2022 - 97 RBI OF: Tim Salmon, 2000 - 97 RBI OF: George Springer, 2017 - 85 RBI DH: Edgar Martinez, 2001 - 116 RBI 915 Total RBI. This was a tough loss, knowing that I left a bunch of RBI on the table by getting the years wrong.

[@ThatRedHusky]

Here's food for thought. As putrid as their offense is, Cal Raleigh is on pace to hit 100 RBIs as the Mariner's catcher.

[@Stafnee]

Ohtani sat on the board for a long ass time

[@UrBeat06]

How do you get the money ball year wrong every time?

[@Stutz_77]

Didn’t Jake meet Guerrero Sr in Pittsburgh Airport

[@ab88698]

Bret Boone 2001, go M's!

[@p.johnson1]

Y'ever danced with 2000 Edgar Martinez in the pale moonlight?

[@DaBaltimoron]

I thought Jolly was taking Teixeira when he took Giambi

[@robertochapa9735]

No Juan Gone or Ruben Sierra?

[@Dodgers564]

This is only since the year 2000

[@sgstoner]

How did A-Rod at SS last until when he did and was NOT the first or second SS taken??

[@vallo105]

Shohei should've won MVP in 2022

[@TonyGarciaxProdigy1994]

im surprised they didn't pick up raleigh for their catcher

[@righteous_factz5875]

Before i watch: im pretty sure this follows the right timeline of the jahmai jones vid jimmy posted Edit: 3:30 THERE IT IS

[@peterharris6409]

The answer when saying the name Altuve is ALWAYS 2016

[@ab88698]

The Tejada miss cost Jake this one

[@RoboticTechnician]

Idea: Assemble a lineup with the LEAST number of RBIs. Might get a little mean spirited highlighting bad years. Injured years count, trade years cutting their rbis down count, being part time in the minors counts. They just have to be an active player to some degree that year.

[@wilberalonzo9645]

‘98 Juan Gonzalez

[@jacksonroberts2205]

Could one take 2024 Big Dumper if they so chose? He’s already up to 78 with over a month to play…

[@ravensface]

The disrespect for the mariners was unreal. Edgar. Jr. Ichrio.

[@hkgcgsdhjgd]

Ichiro would not be a good pick for an RBI draft.

[@brennanvoss5657]

Do a gold glove draft

[@biggybiggs47]

WE NEED THE HITTER STRIKEOUT DRAFT. CHRIS CARTER 1:1 PICK

[@alexlayton2735]

i had 1026 before i saw the video

[@sigouinfb]

Love this series!! Just an idea... if you want to go "old school" (before 2000) maybe you could choose a year and when you hear the number, you can choose another year or stick with your first choice... Keep up the good work fellas!

[@benwright794]

Juan gonzalez, edgar and ken griffey!?

[@austinnistico3845]

Raul Ibanez

[@ryanwalsh7762]

its always a good video when big baby lib isn’t in it

[@PaulSmith-fz3qc]

15 minutes in and no one has chosen Griffey Jr or Juan Gonzalez???? Unless I missed it and it’s only after 2000.

[@hkgcgsdhjgd]

2000 is the earliest year you can pick. That's how it works with pretty much all of their draft videos, with a few notable exceptions like the All-Time Stolen Bases Draft or the All-Time WAR Draft.

[@henrik_klubert300]

how did no one take ken griffey jr

[@anniesymons8474]

the disrespect towards the mariners here is out of hand. the teams haven't been great, but they've had a ton of great hitters over the years