Who have been the most UNDERRATED finals players of the last five years? - SEN

[@vigour6786]

Always in for a good show when these 3 are together.

[@Justin-xs2yo]

Yeah, it keeps Kane quiet 🤣🤣

[@nicholaselsholz1958]

Top 2 stat teams out this week just gone. But I think this just shows what an even competition it is, not much between the top 8 sides this yr, or even top 15 on some levels. What I think should be pointed out though is the continued ability of some clubs - Geelong, Sydney, Brisbane now a bit, and Collingwood (on the avg) being regularly up there, and Hawthorn often in contention too. And the longer term absences of North, Saints for a bit now, Essenson, Carlton from real contention. With so many equalisation measures in place, club culture and methodology is more key than ever

[@Lokki_1984]

They played each other though, so hardly as big a thing as it may seem

[@imalwaysright]

Them saying Cam Rayner needs to be called out. We were all shocked when Cam Rayner was included in the All Australian squad. Kane was a selector 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@LITTLEBALLS1]

Crazy right

[@vigour6786]

Kane single handedly put Cam Rayner in the AA?

[@berniesookie]

@@imalwaysright Zach Guthrie completely ignored and he is Geelong's best player in 2024 lol

[@berniesookie]

Zach Guthrie is the most underrated player in the AFL. Has been for years lol..finally he gets recognised

[@jimhaze87]

True That 👍

[@berniesookie]

It's bizarre. He was also crucial to the premiership 2 years ago. I'm a cat supporter and he is our best player all year. He is more important than Tom Stewart this year. He has a very high football IQ, he focuses on doing the essential things right. Unfortunately guys like Stewart, dangerfield get the spotlight, when they aren't our best player, Zach is. LOL. Had to get the stat man to give facts for him to be recognised

[@JamesElias-zx5ev]

Just appreciate the well-kept secret

[@berniesookie]

In previous years, Steww and Danger were undoubtedly Geelong's standout players and were our best players . However, in 2024, Zach Guthrie has emerged as the Cats' current best player. While Miers and Holmes are also having fantastic seasons, it's Guthrie's role as a playmaker off half back that makes him even more vital. His ability to rebound from defense and be playmaker that sets our sling shot play for our wingers, ala holmes/ danger, but also Jezza does this well moves to the wing and drags backman out of position and small half forwards Mannagh/Miers/Close/Stengle and this has been crucial to our success all year. But I still hear oh tag Stewart, oh Dangerfield is back to his best lol.. I need the statman to back me up. I swear Its zach that had the most rebounds off half back for cats and is most efficient at it. Stewart might be 2nd but isn't as efficient, has had a down year and turns the ball over a lot unlike Zach Guthrie. I have watched every Geelong cats game this year.

[@diamondsrubies9423]

What’s the point of having a camera on Gerard if there’s a mic in front of his face ?

[@marcusbinks2678]

Corn must’ve had his eyes closed for the 2 deliberate out of bounds that weren’t called or the 9-2 free kicks in the first quarter.

[@SormonAusPol]

It nice to have someone agree with me that Port/Sydney is a 40-60 game.

[@eugenekrabs8986]

So many writing Port off again. Looks like people haven’t learnt from last week!

[@SormonAusPol]

@@eugenekrabs8986 The loses get blown out of proportion. Port has had multiple win streaks and beaten several of their bogyman teams (Carlton, Melbourne and Adelaide). There's a reason they came 2nd.

[@Dilmahteabags]

The champion data curse.

[@imalwaysright]

No mention of Champion Data’s top 2 teams - Bulldogs and Hawthorn - being knocked out 😂😂

[@ShoeSnatchinWilly]

Stats are just history. No one has ever claimed they will 100% predict the future.

[@imalwaysright]

@@ShoeSnatchinWillythey act as though stats are the golden measure. But their stats are based on subjective opinions and can’t measure emotion, mentality, leadership, confidence

[@andrewkerr5296]

@@imalwaysright No they don't

[@angusdalton9320]

@@imalwaysrightstats are great predictors of what’s likely, not what’s going to happen. Especially in sport, stats are good at explaining why a team is doing well, it doesn’t necessarily say that the team will continue to be that way.

[@imalwaysright]

@@angusdalton9320 so pointless then lol

[@anthonysudarsan20]

Port have a great chance, they play well against Sydney. Great chance. But I will still tip Sydney…… nice each way there Hoiney, if you like!

[@DeeMan17]

Haha - haven’t you been watching? Does this each week. He’s 2 from 6 so far for the finals.

[@BruceB-fo4gj]

COME ON POWER ⚡⚡⚡⚡

[@HeathTaskis]

I think the stats there don't align with the reality. When the swans go long down the line and play conservative footy they turn the ball over and get scored against heavily. When they play agressively, like when they were 28 points down against GWS, they carve teams up and conceed less. Would love to see some meaningful data like, how many times they've gone long down the line to a contest in a qtr correlated with scoring shots for and against.

[@matthewanderson4378]

Are the Giants the best team to go out in straight sets? Only behind for 15mins of footy total but when it mattered most

[@eugenekrabs8986]

Kingsley must be incredibly disappointed. The Giants at their best were unstoppable. Best team in it! Incredibly frustrating to throw the season away like that.

[@matthewanderson4378]

@@eugenekrabs8986 gotta be above the shoulders. Or can they not sustain that game style for a full 4 quarters

[@joeyrobertson9523]

@@matthewanderson4378 Richmond couldn't sustain it for 4 quarters in their 3 flags. They just did it for the last 3 quarters instead of the first 3. GWS go too hard too early.

[@rsamen5091]

SDK was poor in 2023, picked it back up this year - Should play.

[@89joshuadavies]

Cant believe geelong are flag favourites again 😭😭😭

[@LITTLEBALLS1]

Sydney are

[@matthewanderson4378]

They're the best at staying at the pointy end for such a prolonged period of time but Swans are winning this flag

[@RobKieranz]

Giants were just missing something this year.

[@alisterbacon3157]

Goals

[@eugenekrabs8986]

Not much. They had the Coleman medalist, best 1 on 1 defender and a strong midfield. Leading both games for 90% of both. They fumbled a premiership.

[@imalwaysright]

Cogs and Kelly injured throughout the season, but you're right. Something missing this year. Was noticeable all year, especially compared to 2023.

[@UpTheCatters]

I picked them to win it at the start of the year but even with the inclusion of Hogan, they didn’t seem as dangerous as they did last year. Toby Greene and a few others never really got going

[@reecemccullough4829]

Anyone know what the SEN sync is? Sounds awesome.

[@alexerwin3262]

It’s on the SEN app! It lets you sync the SEN commentary with the television feed and you can adjust it if your feed is behind/ahead of the commentary

[@reecemccullough4829]

@@alexerwin3262 thanks Alex. That sounds awesome. Gonna improve the product by a mile.

[@va1974]

Daniher most hot and cold player there is

[@DeeMan17]

That’s his stigma, but he’s the hottest forward in the finals for the last five years.

[@matthewanderson4378]

Stats dont always tell an accurate picture......especially in finals Hoyne leaving out any discussion about his 2 best profile sides Hawks and Dogs being knocked out😂😂😂

[@lsong8461]

Simply proves champion data is rubbish. Both sides it tipped are out. And go have a look at the ratings from the port hawthorn game. Makes absolutely no sense

[@charliemckay2293]

Kane is a shocking analyst if he genuinely thought port had no chance coming in to that game

[@TwoFourFourFour]

Not really. Recent form in finals coupled with his love of the club painted a pretty clear picture. Stats aren’t everything.

[@vigour6786]

@@charliemckay2293 Did you tip port to win?

[@tysondahmes5832]

What makes Kane’s Port bias worse is the way he tries to be clever in his language to hide it. Thinks none of us will notice

[@matthewanderson4378]

Agree completely, everyone writing off Port at home against a young inexperienced Hawks team was crazy. Always was going to be close though

[@vigour6786]

@@matthewanderson4378 Did you tip Port to win? Everyone saying in hindsight "Of course Port were going to win, no one expected them not to" but the people who are saying this are the people who got it wrong. Hawks had a lot more going for them than Port did and Port had so much going against them, that's why it was a surprise win to most.

[@childishslinky324]

I'm sorry, whats all this talk around Daniher??? He had a good 5 minutes which happened to be the match winning goals.

[@nathand4500]

200 goals over the past 4 years. Hardly a dud.

[@childishslinky324]

@@nathand4500 never called him a dud. But it’s pretty obvious all this hype is coming from his performance last week. Which I thought besides those 2 at the end was average at best.

[@nathand4500]

@@childishslinky324 you've just answered your original question then. you didn't really need to ask it.

[@childishslinky324]

@@nathand4500 I understand what it’s come from, but not why. That was my question.

[@lukeowneslol]

It's about when he had his good 5 minutes.

[@Robrulz666icloud]

Champion data the most overrated finals player 🤣🤣🤣 Kane looks confused AF 🤣🤣

[@MusiCatsKing]

Friday night's game was shit. Sat nt was so much better with more goals kicked! It's a shame either Sydney Sooks or Port ferals have to make the GF. Geelong v Brizzy would make the best high-scoring GF and this Sat prelim will prove that. How did Hawks lose? Simple. Port were gifted a healthy lead by the umpires and they failed to target Soft-as-butters' ribs!!

[@matthewanderson4378]

Swans flag incoming. They've been the best team by a gap all season for a reason. Port have a good record against em but not in a prelim Cats v Lions will be geelong's to lose Then Sydney get revenge for 2022

[@haydenfisher7387]

Sydney will get smashed by Geelong Completely smashed

[@matthewanderson4378]

@@haydenfisher7387 not a chance. Geelong will struggle to stay near em this time around. Its not 2022 anymore

[@eugenekrabs8986]

@@haydenfisher7387Brisbane can beat the cats.

[@user-dj2xn]

@@matthewanderson4378sydney got completely outplayed against the giants for 3 quarters at the SCG, and only won because they giants choked and heeney had a once in a lifetime performance. They are definitely not winning the flag 💀